Top companies like Google, Microsoft, IBM, and others use structured interviews with clear rubrics, standardized questions, and technology support to reduce bias, ensure fairness, focus on job-relevant skills, and align hiring with company values—leading to more reliable, objective selection.
Which Companies Are Leading the Way in Structured Interviews and What Can We Learn from Their Successes?
AdminTop companies like Google, Microsoft, IBM, and others use structured interviews with clear rubrics, standardized questions, and technology support to reduce bias, ensure fairness, focus on job-relevant skills, and align hiring with company values—leading to more reliable, objective selection.
Empowered by Artificial Intelligence and the women in tech community.
Like this article?
Structured Interviews & Evaluation Rubrics
Interested in sharing your knowledge ?
Learn more about how to contribute.
Sponsor this category.
Google Standardizing for Consistency
Google is renowned for its rigorous, data-driven interview process. Structured interviews at Google follow carefully crafted rubrics and consistent questions for each role. Their success stems from a commitment to removing bias and focusing on job-related competencies. The takeaway is that standardization and preparation can greatly reduce interviewer subjectivity, resulting in fairer and more predictive hiring outcomes.
Microsoft Aligning Interviews with Core Competencies
Microsoft has implemented structured interviews that directly assess their core competencies, such as problem-solving and teamwork. They use behavioral and situational questions with predefined scoring guidelines. Microsoft’s approach shows the importance of aligning interview structure with the values and needs of the company, ensuring hires are both skilled and culturally fit.
IBM Leveraging Training and Technology
IBM focuses on interviewer training and utilizes digital tools to support structured interviews. They have platforms that help interviewers stay on script and score candidates objectively. The company’s experience demonstrates how technology and ongoing training can enhance the reliability of structured interviews, making the process scalable for global organizations.
Unilever Skills-Based Assessment Integration
Unilever integrates structured interviews with skills-based assessments and AI tools. Their interviews are part of a multi-step process designed to reduce unconscious bias and predict job performance effectively. Their success highlights the value of combining structured interviews with other objective assessment methods to create a comprehensive recruitment process.
Procter Gamble Behavioral Interview Expertise
Procter & Gamble pioneered the use of behavioral-based structured interviews decades ago. Their method, known as "The P&G Way," evaluates candidates’ past behaviors against a set of core company principles. The lesson here is that focusing interviews on past job-related experiences, with clear rubrics, enhances the predictive power of hiring decisions.
Deloitte Structured Scoring and Panel Interviews
Deloitte employs panel interviews where each interviewer is assigned specific criteria to assess using structured questions and scoring systems. This multi-rater approach ensures objectivity and a well-rounded evaluation. Their process teaches that distributing assessment responsibilities and using standardized scores can minimize individual bias.
Southwest Airlines Culture-Focused Structured Interviews
Southwest Airlines designs structured interviews around cultural fit and customer service skills, which are core to their brand. They use a set of behavioral questions for all candidates applying for similar roles. Their approach shows that structured interviews can be tailored to prioritize the attributes most vital to a company's unique identity.
Amazon Data-Driven and Bar Raiser Program
Amazon uses structured interviews supported by their "Bar Raiser" program, where independently trained interviewers ensure consistency and uphold hiring standards. All candidates are evaluated against leadership principles using standardized frameworks. Amazon’s experience highlights the effectiveness of a dedicated oversight program to reinforce structured interview practices.
Accenture Global Consistency through Centralized Templates
Accenture applies structured interviews worldwide through standardized templates and centralized training. This global consistency allows for reliable comparisons and fair evaluations across diverse locations. Their method illustrates the benefit of centralizing resources to maintain interview quality at scale.
McKinsey Company Case-Based Structured Interviews
McKinsey uses highly structured case interviews, where candidates tackle predefined business scenarios with clear scoring guides. This approach ensures every candidate addresses the same challenges, resulting in fair and objective evaluation. McKinsey’s method shows the power of combining structured interviews with job simulation for roles requiring analytical thinking.
What else to take into account
This section is for sharing any additional examples, stories, or insights that do not fit into previous sections. Is there anything else you'd like to add?