0:0019:47

Consuming, Contributing, Collaborating: Open Source from all sides by Ron Minsky

19:47 2022

A trading firm's build tool now has more outside contributors than inside

A trading firm with nearly 2,000 employees and no open source business model rewrote parts of Mercurial in Rust, runs its own OCaml fork and publishes around 240 packages to the outside world. Ron Minsky draws on Jane Street's experience to show why that investment pays off for a tech-heavy business. The open question is which way of engaging fits your goals, and what the tooling has to look like to make it work.

Learn four ways companies engage with open source and how to choose the right one

Watch on YouTube

In short

Ron Minsky draws on Jane Street's experience with Mercurial, OCaml, Dune and its exported libraries to show how a company whose business is not open source can still benefit from engaging deeply with open source communities. He argues that this work must align with business goals, that companies should choose their mode of engagement deliberately, and that tooling and developer experience shape whether it succeeds.

“Because I think an important thing to remember is contributing in open source is a repeated game, right?”
“Today, there are more people contributing to Dune outside of Jane Street than there are people inside of Jane Street.”

What you will learn

  • Align open source investment with your organization's goals so it can be sustained over time.
  • Choose deliberately between funding maintainers, filing issues, contributing patches, running a fork and launching your own projects.
  • Plan the tooling for hosting, exporting and importing contributions so friction stays low for internal and external developers.
  • Decide whether a project is internal-first with a public export or community-first hosted in the open.
  • Build trust with maintainers by proposing high-quality, well-engineered changes.

Details

Level
Intermediate
Format
Talk
Technical depth
Introductory technical
For
Mid-career, Senior individual contributor, People manager
Length
19:47
Published
June 2022

Questions this talk answers

Why would a company whose business is not open source invest in it?

Open source grows the ecosystem the company depends on, helps recruiting, and gives outside developers something to integrate with, which aligns external tools with internal needs.

When should a company stop relying on consultants for an open source dependency?

When it needs to move faster than consultants can, since they are not inside and cannot see the company's problems, repo or workflows. Jane Street then made changes itself while keeping consultants to generalize and upstream them.

How can a company keep an internal fork without breaking from the wider community?

Land changes internally first, iterate with internal users, then submit stabilized features upstream and argue for them as general additions to the language.

What makes an open source project attractive to outside contributors?

Using the community's tools rather than your own, as Jane Street did by hosting Dune on GitHub, so outside contributors have the same experience as anyone else.

What mindset helps when contributing to open source projects?

Treat contribution as a repeated game, think about what is best for the community, and take care over the engineering quality of every change so maintainers come to trust your contributions.

Topics

Related talks

Browse the library

Crafting Frontend Strategy

Maria Korneeva Frontend Tech Lead, Aleri Solutions GmbH

Every frontend trend list said the same thing, so she started from the why

Intermediate Leadership and management 2021

Canonical Meet & Greet

Miona Aleksic +3 Product Manager

Open source needs contributors who never write a line of code

All levels Software engineering and cloud 2023