0:0019:57

Meaningful Impact: Making the Case for DEI Programs

Sabrina Macpherson 19:57 2022

Why a well-run DEI program is capitalism, not a political agenda

Outside the DEI echo chamber, friends tell her the work is just "very on trend", and critics on both the far left and far right have reasons to reject it. Sabrina Macpherson, who has led DEI for Morningstar Canada for six years, takes those objections head on. For leaders weighing whether diversity work deserves a place in strategy, the question is what separates a program with real impact from buzzword bingo.

Get the case for DEI and the principles that keep programs from becoming performative

Watch on YouTube

In short

Sabrina Macpherson, Senior Product Manager at Morningstar and longtime DEI leader, argues that diversity, equity and inclusion work belongs in every organization's strategy for two reasons: ethics and stakeholder capitalism. She answers critiques from both the far left and the far right, contrasts effective programs with performative ones, and offers principles for running DEI as a data-driven, people-centered part of the business.

“Employees are no longer faceless resources you can throw at the wall of your projects until they burn out. They are stakeholders and you have to consider what they want.”
“Ineffective DEI programs is frankly where all of the critiques come from. It is performative and it is where you see it being run like a game of buzzword bingo, right?”

What you will learn

  • Articulate the ethical and stakeholder-capitalism case for DEI to skeptical leaders.
  • Respond to the most common critiques of DEI from both the political left and right.
  • Distinguish effective DEI programs from performative ones using goals, metrics and transparency.
  • Plan short-term wins and long-term goals such as pay equity and leadership parity.
  • Set up a data-driven DEI program with baselines, transparent KPIs and a dedicated paid team.

Key takeaways from the speaker

  • There is a case for DEI work, from both an ethical and business perspective, that should be lined out for leaders engaged in the work
  • DEI programs do not automatically have meaningful impact; they require a specific kind of activity and structure
  • DEI programs do not belong to either end of the political ideology spectrum. They are another realization of stakeholder capitalism.
  • Key guiding principles that will help guide your DEI program to success and meaningful impact.

Details

Level
Intermediate
Format
Talk
Technical depth
Non-technical
For
People manager, Executive
Length
19:57
Published
July 2022

Questions this talk answers

Why should businesses do DEI work at all?

Macpherson gives two reasons: ethics, because everyone deserves fair treatment and equal access to opportunity, and capitalism, because employees, clients, millennials and Gen Z now judge how a business operates.

Is DEI a political agenda?

She argues it can be politicized but is politically neutral, describing it as sustainable business decisions and stakeholder capitalism rather than politics.

How do you answer critics who say DEI cannot work inside capitalism?

She says not to let the perfect be the enemy of the good: helping people now through pay equity and flexible schedules matters, and incremental change is how progress has always been made.

What makes a DEI program performative rather than effective?

Performative programs throw jargon around with no goals, metrics or transparency, ignore the disengaged, avoid the hard parts of equity and inclusion, and offer no training.

How do you set up a DEI program for long-term success?

Treat it like any other business area with data baselines and transparent KPIs, fund a dedicated paid team, balance short-term wins with long-term goals, pay external experts, make room for dissent and keep the focus on people.

About this talk

I spend a lot of time and energy promoting psychological safety and diversity to business audiences, and I work to execute programs that achieve equity and inclusion in meaningful ways. For those people who don’t have the perspective that I do, or who only ever see the performative programs run in some organizations, I think it’s fair to lay out the case for why a well-run DEI program should be a key part of every organization’s strategic objectives. I want to answer the question: “Why do we take it for granted that this work should be done in a professional environment?”

I’ll start by talking about the first principles: why should this work be done? Then I’ll speak about effective diversity work in a professional context, both what it is and what it is not. From that I will take time to address the most pointed criticisms leveled at the work from both the leftmost and rightmost arms of the political spectrum - to establish that the value in this work is outside of any political ideology or affiliation. I’ll conclude by talking about what you need to do if you want to avoid the pitfalls that lead to performative programs, and set your organization up for sustainable success.

Topics

Related talks

Browse the library