Working dads were twice as likely as mums to win promotion in the UK
A UK study found the gender pay gap quadruples once women reach their 40s, and the Office for National Statistics traced it to motherhood. For tech companies working hard to recruit women, maternity is the moment many of them are lost. Emma Waltham, a chemistry PhD and former executive director who now coaches maternity returners, asks what women need to see in a workplace before they believe they can stay.
Learn the culture signals and practical steps that keep mothers progressing in tech careers
Emma Waltham, a maternity returner specialist working with STEM organisations, argues that maternity is a major pinch point in women's tech careers, driven by bias, unequal unpaid work and inflexible cultures. She shares UK and global evidence on pay and promotion gaps, describes the signs of a family-friendly workplace, and sets out practical strategies for managers, HR, colleagues and returning mothers.
“You know, it's fantastic that we're encouraging women to come into tech careers, but maternity is a real pinch point for women in their careers, not just in the tech sector, but across the board.”
“So when men become dads, they're assumed to be more committed at work because they're the breadwinner and they're more likely to be promoted.”
What you will learn
Recognise how maternity bias affects the opportunities, pay rises and promotions offered to mothers.
Explain the link between unequal unpaid work at home, flexible working requests and the gender pay gap.
Spot the culture signals that show an organisation is genuinely family friendly.
Plan support for returners, from involving women in their maternity cover to buddies, mentors and coaching.
Apply transparent promotion criteria and checked assumptions so stereotypes do not shape decisions about mothers.
Key takeaways from the speaker
The impact of the maternity transition on women at work.
How managers/HR/colleagues can improve the experience of maternity returners.
How to help women have a positive experience when they go through the maternity transition, so that they stay and continue their career progression.
Details
Level
Intermediate
Format
Talk
Technical depth
Non-technical
For
People manager, Returner, Mid-career
Length
19:19
Published
July 2022
Questions this talk answers
Why is maternity such a pinch point for women in tech?
Pregnancy sends a strong signal that triggers stereotypes about commitment, while women also face identity change, time away and extra home duties. In male-dominated environments there are few templates of women blending careers with family life.
What does the evidence show about mothers' pay and promotion?
As the speaker cited, the UK gender pay gap quadrupled for women in their 40s because of motherhood, and in 2018 working dads in the UK were about twice as likely to be promoted as working mums.
Why should flexible working be offered to everyone and not only to mothers?
When only mothers work flexibly they feel different and under pressure to work extra hard to keep a privileged arrangement. Senior people and fathers working flexibly make it normal and safe.
What signs show that a workplace is family friendly?
Inclusive behaviour modelled by others, embedded flexible working, visible role models of any gender who talk about family, a family-friendly reputation and support such as networks and enhanced parental benefits.
What can managers and HR do to ease the return to work?
Map the employee journey with clear policies, train managers and HR, check assumptions, involve women in their maternity cover, offer buddies, mentors or coaching, and make pay and promotion processes transparent.
About this talk
An interactive and informative look at how the maternity transition impacts on women at work. It covers:
The lived experience of women in the workplace when they go through the maternity transition, including the biases that impact on their re-engagement, confidence and progression.
Evidence that shows what is happening to women today, so that managers and
colleagues understand the importance of supporting returners on retention and how barriers to participation impact on the gender pay gap.
Ideas for how participants can successfully blend their own working lives with
parenthood, so that they feel understood and that this is an organisation that values returning mums.
How to ease the transition back into work, from the perspective of women returners, colleagues and managers/HR, so everyone goes away with something they can do to improve the experience of maternity returners.
The walk of shame: flexibility for everyone (70 s)
Okay, welcome to this session on the impact of maternity on careers in tech. My name is Dr. Emma Waltham and I'm a maternity returner specialist and I work predominantly in the STEM sector, so with tech women and organisations. So I'm really delighted to be here to talk to you today about this really important subject. You know, it's fantastic that we're encouraging women to come into tech careers, but maternity is a real pinch point for women in their careers, not just in the tech sector, but across the board. But it's particularly difficult for women when they're in male dominated environments and they can't see women having children and have been able to blend their careers with family life successfully that there aren't templates for that. So I think it's just great that we're talking about this subject. And it's something
that I'm really passionate about. So I'm going to start by telling you a bit about how I came to specialise in this area. And so I started out my career in STEM, I've got a chemistry PhD. And over time, I moved into different areas. So I've worked in different sectors like media, and recruitment, and my career went pretty well. And I rose up to executive director level. And when I was in my mid 30s, so it was it was going pretty well my career and and then I hit a bit of a roadblock because because I had children, and it was really difficult at that time for me to carry on with my career. And so I took a career break. And when I went back to work, when my children were small, I thought I'd be able to just pick up where I left off. But it wasn't really that straightforward for various reasons. Obviously, I changed. And also, it's a bit more difficult to get into it when you've got a career
gap. And so I decided to set up my own business. And over the last six or seven years, I come to specialise in working with organisations to help them support maternity returners. So that they have a better experience than I had. So I was working in a in a male dominated environment, where there weren't people with children at senior levels working flexibly, I was doing a lot of travel in Europe, I'm based just near London, London, but also in Asia. And so it was really difficult for me to see how I could marry up being a mum with having that kind of role. So it's something that's really important to me, and something that you know, clearly is important to you if you're if you're watching today. So what I'm going to do is I'm going to take some time to look at kind of what the lived experiences for women going through the maternity transition. And then we're going to look at how we can help. So whether you know, we're on that pathway ourselves,
or whether we're working with women as managers or whether we're working with women as managers or HR or colleagues, or if we're partners of women going through this major life change. So I'm going to start by talking a little bit about what it's like for women as they become mothers in the workplace. So we're really looking at this through a sort of professional workplace lens.
And obviously having a baby is a wonderful experience, it brings so much to our lives, it's really enriching. And but it's true to say it's really disruptive. So right from, you know, pregnancy and birth, there's a really strong physical signal that women have chosen motherhood, and that can really trigger people to make assumptions and stereotypes about women, when they've chosen to become a mother. And so this sort of maternity bias that can happen, it can affect women at work in terms of kind of opportunities that are offered.
Promotion, pay rises, and set one. And, and obviously for women themselves, it's a big change, it's a change physically and emotionally and sort of practically as well. And so going through this, this change can affect people's feelings about their identity, priorities and goals, you know, they've got someone really important, more important themselves now that can change kind of their priorities and goals.
And also taking a break from work. So here in the UK, it's very common for women to take six to 12 months off when they have a baby, away from paid work, obviously, potentially with a busy time, and that does vary, you know, in different parts of the world, but certainly any sort of extended time away from work can make us feel more detached from work and our kind of personal self, we can lose touch with that.
And that can affect confidence on the return to work. And there's other emotions as well, like guilt, you know, grief, really, going back to work and leaving your baby with someone else. And there's also sort of practical things around, you know, dropping a child off at nursery and, you know, and all the extra work that kids create and having to deal with that while working as well.
So there's lots going on there at a personal level. But there's also, you know, things that happen in the organisation as well, and in society at large, which impact on women, I'm going to look at those now. And so I'm afraid I can't see the chat. So I'm going to ask you some questions and feel free to put the answer in the chat. But, you know, at least have a think about the answer before before I tell you what it is.
And so the first question I've got is how much work in the homes, chores, admin, shopping, cleaning, childcare, do women do compared to men? So women do more work in the home than men. It depends what research you look at, but typically the answer comes out about twice as much. And there's a particular study that I'm going to share with you, a 2018 global diversity study, which looked at countries across the world, and it found that generally women did, you know, twice as much work in the home as men.
And this is important because what it means is that women are doing kind of full time job often in the home before they even go out to pay, do paid work. So that's often why they ask the flexible working because they need to work around these other commitments. And it also says something about how women aren't able to participate as fully in the workplace because they're doing this, this unpaid work disproportionately to men.
And I think it speaks to the fact as well that equality needs to begin at home. And if women aren't equal at home, then they're not going to be able to be equal in the workplace, you know, they're going to be held back from participating. So it's really important. Another question here, what percentage of women assumed primary responsibility for childcare or homeschooling in the pandemic?
Well, it probably won't surprise you that again, about 70% of women took that on so much more than likely than men. This was a study that was done in the UK by BBC and Kantar Public. But other studies around the world carried out in the US by the UN have found similarly that women, when there was a crisis, were the ones that kind of stepped up and took on these extra responsibilities.
So again, you know, that's something that women have to bear in mind when they're going back to work, that they're probably the ones that are going to have to deal with it if there's an issue. How much bigger does the gender pay gap become when women hit their 40s? The gender pay gap is a representation of how much women are paid compared to men.
It's average hourly pay. And in the UK, there was a study published in December last year, 2021, which showed that the gender pay gap quadrupled when women got to their 40s. This was released, this study by the Office of National Statistics. And what they found was that it was the impact of motherhood. Women weren't getting into those managerial positions because of motherhood.
And this meant that they were earning less than men in their 40s and beyond. And again, those types of trends we do see globally as well. It's not just in the UK. How much more likely are working dads to be promoted than working mums? Well, here in the UK in 2018, they were about twice as likely to be promoted as working mums.
And the reasons for that are because of biases, really. So when men become dads, they're assumed to be more committed at work because they're the breadwinner and they're more likely to be promoted. Whereas the women have become mothers. They're perceived as being less capable and less ambitious, and they're less likely to be given pay rises or promotions.
And so all this has a big impact, has a big impact on working women. This is some of the quotes that women have told me in my work with them. I work one to one with women and also working organizations. So I hear a lot about what women have to say, particularly in the STEM sector. And so impacts on them financially massively because they earn less at work and in their working lives.
In the UK, it's about the amount of money that they earn less than men is equivalent to an average sized home over their lifetime. And this doesn't affect them only when they're at work. It affects them in their pension, in their retirement, because the pension is usually about half the amount of money that men have. Yeah. So it's a lot less.
And as well as affecting women individually also affects businesses as well. And it affects their profitability. We know that more diverse workforces are more profitable. There's research by McKinsey and Co, which is great to look at and shows that, that when you've got gender diversity at senior levels, businesses do better because of that diversity of thought. And also because, you know, women are able to participate at work and come back and be productive and be promoted and carry on their career pathways.
And then companies are retaining that talent. And that is really important. Yeah. So I've talked a lot about some of the negative, I suppose, impacts on professional lives for women when they have babies. And it is a major pinch point in women's careers, but there's lots we can do to improve the situation. And if you're a woman looking at working in a company and you want to see, you know, other family friendly, I thought it'd be good to look at some of the indicators that you might look for.
And also if we're in organisations, you know, whether we're managing people, we've got colleagues who are having children or, you know, we're in HR, what kind of things, you know, can we look for what signs are there to show that our culture is inclusive for women? Because it's great, you know, we're bringing women into tech careers, you know, with varying degrees of success.
But if the culture isn't good and they're not able to feel that it's a good place to become parents and to stay after they've had their babies, then we'll lose them. Yeah, it has to be a good culture for them. Otherwise, you know, anybody that comes in is just going to think this isn't for me and they're going to go into another section.
We're going to lose these women. So what kind of things do we see? Well, we see women want to stay in an inclusive place. So they want to, they see people modelling behaviour and attitudes that make them feel safe and able to have kids and be able to carry on their career. And we'll see, you know, more diverse range of people working there in an inclusive environment.
Often we'll see flexible working. So I talked about this before, how important it is for women to have flexible working, because they're doing a lot outside the workplace in the home. And they need to be able to work around that. And they're often the people that need to step up if there's an issue. So, you know, they need to prioritise that and be able to work around around those responsibilities.
And it's really important as well, that it's not just working mums that are given flexible options, working patterns and being able to work from home. So some or all of the time it's good. It's good for them if this is across the board, because when it's just working mums that are working flexibly and it makes them feel, you know, kind of special.
And maybe different, that can be more challenging for them. It's awful, you know, if you're the only one doing that walk of shame, sort of late in the afternoon, you're the one that's got to go and pick a child up, you know, from childcare and everyone else is sat at their desk and you're the only one walking out.
And, you know, that makes people feel, you know, that they're not, well, that they're different. And also they, they might be worried about losing that. See, it's a privilege that only they've got that working pattern and they need to work extra hard to be able to keep it. So it puts them under a lot of pressure. So even if there aren't lots, lots of women in the organisation or there aren't, you know, working women, women with, with children, anybody can, can do flexible working.
So if you've got people at senior levels doing that as well, that's really powerful. And, you know, and men working around their kids or, you know, maybe taking chair parental leave, those kinds of things are really important and make women feel that, okay, I can, I can do what I need to do. And I'm not going to stand out and be different and I'm not going to have to work, you know, twice as hard to keep that special working arrangement.
And I guess that feeds into role models. You know, it's great if we've got women, you know, further up in the organisation or in the sector that have got kids and are showing that they can blend working life with family life. But, you know, maybe that's just not possible with, with the numbers. So anybody can be a role model, you know, showing that they're talking about their family or spending time with their family, you know, taking time off holiday or parental leave, taking time to go to sports day and things like that.
You know, working those flexible hours can mean, you know, that they're a role model, even if they're not, you know, female going back to work after having had a baby. All these things then feed into having a family friendly reputation, one in which, you know, colleagues and employees will want to talk about the organisation as being family friendly and encourage, you know, their friends and family to come and work there because it's a great place to work when you have children.
And, you know, the company will be able to help support families and parents, you know, whether it's networks or flexible working, it can be, you know, benefits, enhanced maternity benefit and paternity benefits and so on. Yeah. And what we see there is that women are able to come and participate and be productive. So because they're able to, you know, do everything that they want to do at work, you know, whether that's get a promotion or go to a conference or, you know, carry on on their career pathway or take on, you know, that juicy interesting project, develop their skills.
You know, they're being productive and that obviously benefits the organisation massively because they've got that talented, experienced person that they've recruited and that they want to keep and that will continue to be productive, you know, for years to come. And also what that means is that women have better wellbeing. So when they feel that they can blend working life with, with, with being a parent, then they're going to be happier and have a stronger wellbeing.
So just to wrap up real, here are some strategies for us all to use, to be able to help with that. Yeah. So it's about organisations having family friendly policies and clearly mapped out processes with an employee journey. So everybody knows kind of, you know, what, what support people need as they go through this maternity transition and that managers are trained and HR are trained to be able to support women at those pinch points. Yeah.
Flexible working is embedded. I think as well, it's important that people check their assumptions. So we talked about earlier how when people are pregnant and that, you know, they're having a baby or they're coming back to work, working flexibly, it can make people maybe have stereotypes about their commitment to work. So we just need to be really careful that that that's not happening with us, that we don't have those assumptions and that we've got good communication with a returning mum and we kind of know what she needs and what she wants, and we can work with her.
And it's important. It's really great if women are involved in their maternity cover, it helps them feel more safe when they go on leave, that they've got somebody there that they trust and that they'll be able to pick that back up easily when they come back. It's great to reorientate women when they come back and offer them support.
And offer them support. So family networks, maybe a buddy or a mentor or a coach. That's something that I do for organisations. I offer one to one maternity coaching and support women through that transition to ease them in so that they come back feeling able to blend the, you know, their family life and work. And then they'll, they stay in their careers sort of longer term and they can carry on.
They don't go through that pinch point. And some organisations offer childcare support. And I think it's also really great if they can, if there's transparency around paying promotion, that's something I see in my work that when, when women put themselves forward for promotion, that they're really clear about what the criteria are and that the process is really transparent.
So that people, again, who are doing, you know, these hiring, making these hiring decisions are not, are not using or making assumptions or feeling, you know, that there's a stereotype here and that's affecting their decisions. So there's lots of transparency around that. And so that, that's pretty much it in a nutshell. We're, we're back onto this start slide because I'm getting to the end now.
And I just wanted to say thank you for coming and listening. And I hope that, you know, what we've shared here has, has helped you, whether, whether you're a parent or you're working with, with, with, with, with returning moms to have, you know, an idea of what they're going through and what's impacting on them. And also some strategies, you know, for helping so that we can all be allies.
And if, if we're women going through this transition, that we kind of have some ideas about what to ask for that might help us. And if you've got any questions, please do get in touch. You can find me on LinkedIn. Thank you. Bye bye.
Transcribed automatically; names checked against the speaker record. Select a time to jump there.
Article based on this talk
Why tech loses women at maternity, and how organisations can keep them
Maternity returner specialist Emma Waltham explains the bias, evidence and culture signals that decide whether new mothers stay and progress.
In short
Maternity is one of the sharpest pinch points in a woman's tech career, argues maternity returner specialist Emma Waltham, and the problem lies less with having a baby than with the bias, unequal unpaid work and inflexible cultures surrounding it. Organisations that make flexibility normal for everyone, check their assumptions and support women before, during and after leave keep the talent they worked hard to recruit.
Key takeaways
The impact of the maternity transition on women at work.
How managers, HR and colleagues can improve the experience of maternity returners.
How to help women have a positive experience when they go through the maternity transition, so that they stay and continue their career progression.
A personal route into the subject
Waltham opens by framing the problem plainly. Recruiting women into tech is welcome, she says, but the gains are fragile if mothers cannot see a way to stay. In male-dominated environments there are few women at senior levels who have visibly blended careers with family life, so there is no template to follow.
"You know, it's fantastic that we're encouraging women to come into tech careers, but maternity is a real pinch point for women in their careers, not just in the tech sector, but across the board." (0:00)
Her own path explains her focus. She began in STEM with a chemistry PhD, moved through sectors including media and recruitment, and reached executive director level in her mid thirties, with travel across Europe and Asia. Having children brought that career to a halt, and returning proved harder than she expected.
"And when I went back to work, when my children were small, I thought I'd be able to just pick up where I left off. But it wasn't really that straightforward for various reasons." (1:07)
She set up her own business and has spent the past six or seven years helping organisations support maternity returners so they have a better experience than she did.
What changes when a woman becomes a mother at work
Waltham describes the maternity transition through a workplace lens. Pregnancy is a strong physical signal that a woman has chosen motherhood, and it can trigger assumptions that shape the opportunities, pay rises and promotions she is offered. At the same time, women themselves change physically, emotionally and practically, and their identity, priorities and goals can shift.
Time away matters too. In the UK, she notes, it is common to take six to 12 months off, and any extended break can leave women feeling detached from work and less confident on return. Add guilt, a sense of grief at leaving a baby, nursery drop-offs and the extra domestic load, and the personal side of the transition is substantial before organisational factors are even considered.
The evidence: home, pay and promotion
Waltham poses a series of questions to the audience and then shares the numbers, as she cited them. A 2018 global diversity study found women generally do about twice as much work in the home as men. A UK study by the BBC and Kantar Public found around 70% of women took primary responsibility for childcare or homeschooling during the pandemic. The Office for National Statistics reported in December 2021 that the UK gender pay gap quadrupled when women reached their 40s, linked to motherhood keeping women out of managerial roles. And in the UK in 2018, working dads were about twice as likely to be promoted as working mums.
"And if women aren't equal at home, then they're not going to be able to be equal in the workplace, you know, they're going to be held back from participating." (6:37)
She attributes the promotion gap to bias that cuts in opposite directions for each parent:
"So when men become dads, they're assumed to be more committed at work because they're the breadwinner and they're more likely to be promoted." (8:37)
The costs compound. In the UK, she says, the lifetime earnings gap is equivalent to an average-sized home, and women's pensions are usually about half of men's. Businesses lose too: she points to McKinsey research showing that gender diversity at senior levels helps companies perform better.
What a family-friendly culture looks like
The second half of the talk turns to solutions, starting with the indicators women look for when judging whether a workplace is safe to become a parent in. Without them, Waltham warns, recruitment efforts are wasted.
"But if the culture isn't good and they're not able to feel that it's a good place to become parents and to stay after they've had their babies, then we'll lose them." (11:19)
Flexible working is central, but she stresses it must be available across the board. When only mothers work flexibly, they feel singled out and under pressure to work twice as hard to keep a privileged arrangement.
"It's awful, you know, if you're the only one doing that walk of shame, sort of late in the afternoon, you're the one that's got to go and pick a child up, you know, from childcare and everyone else is sat at their desk and you're the only one walking out." (12:46)
Role models need not be mothers. Senior leaders working flexibly, men taking parental leave and anyone who talks openly about family or goes to sports day all signal that it is acceptable. Together these build a family-friendly reputation, support productivity and improve wellbeing.
Strategies for organisations and returners
Waltham closes with practical strategies: family-friendly policies backed by a clearly mapped employee journey, managers and HR trained for the pinch points, embedded flexible working, and colleagues who check their assumptions and communicate well with returning mothers about what they need. She also recommends involving women in planning their own maternity cover.
"It's really great if women are involved in their maternity cover, it helps them feel more safe when they go on leave, that they've got somebody there that they trust and that they'll be able to pick that back up easily when they come back." (17:07)
On return, family networks, buddies, mentors or coaches help women reorientate, and some organisations offer childcare support. Finally, transparent pay and promotion criteria reduce the room for stereotypes to influence hiring and promotion decisions. Her closing message is that everyone, whether a returner, manager, HR professional or colleague, can act as an ally.
Watch the talk
The Impact of Maternity on Careers in Tech, Emma Waltham, 19 minutes: https://www.womentech.net/video/impact-maternity-careers-in-tech-emma-waltham
About the speaker
Emma Waltham is a Maternity Returners consultant and maternity coach based in London who supports STEM organisations to re-engage their women returners through maternity coaching, training and return-to-work consultancy. She holds a chemistry PhD, worked as a director in a variety of sectors before a maternity break, and has worked as a consultant, trainer and executive coach since 2015 after gaining a Certificate in Coaching with the University of Cambridge.
Questions this talk answers
Why is maternity such a pinch point for women in tech?
What does the evidence show about mothers' pay and promotion?
Why should flexible working be offered to everyone and not only to mothers?
What signs show that a workplace is family friendly?
What can managers and HR do to ease the return to work?
Drafted with AI from the talk transcript. Editor review pending.
Resources mentioned
McKinsey & Company research on gender diversity and business performance
Cite this talk
Emma Waltham. "The Impact of Maternity on Careers in Tech." WomenTech Network, 2022. https://www.womentech.net/video/impact-maternity-careers-in-tech-emma-waltham