Working harder lost her a promotion to the man who kept saying he wanted it
Raised on the immigrant formula of hard work, good grades and keeping her head down, she watched a colleague who put in fewer hours get the promotion she was working toward. A study she cites found women earn higher ratings yet are 14% less likely to be promoted. Jenny Zhao, Head of Product for Digital Services at Asurion, unpacks what that colleague did that she did not.
Get a four-part promotion plan, plus what leaders and allies can do, that you can start right away
Jenny Zhao, Head of Product for Digital Services at Asurion, argues that hard work alone rarely gets women promoted and that promotions have to be actively built. Drawing on a promotion she lost and the ones she later won, she teaches a four-part approach: build credibility, make it easy for your boss to advocate for you, build relationships including sponsors, and find your leverage. She ends with concrete actions for leaders and allies.
“Ultimately, it's not good enough to be good. You must also be known by others for being really, really good at your job.”
“People can't help you if they don't know what you want.”
What you will learn
Align personal goals with what the company cares about so your impact is obvious to decision makers.
Tell your boss, your boss's boss and your team clearly what role you want next and why.
Document the gaps between your current role and the next level with your leader to make promotion actionable.
Free yourself for higher-level work through templates, self-service tools, shared ownership and delegation.
Distinguish mentors from sponsors and build a peer cohort that grows alongside you.
Key takeaways from the speaker
Things you should start doing now
How to create your promotion plan
Leaders and allies – here’s how you can help
Details
Level
All levels
Format
Talk
Technical depth
Non-technical
For
Early career, Mid-career, Senior individual contributor
Length
20:09
Published
July 2022
Questions this talk answers
Why can strong performers still get passed over for promotion?
Zhao lost her first promotion because she never said she wanted it, while the colleague who got it had made his ambition clear from the start. She also cites a study finding women get higher ratings but are 14% less likely to be promoted, largely because of a biased 'potential' category.
What is the difference between a mentor and a sponsor?
Mentors answer questions and give advice, pushing you up or forward. Sponsors actively pull you up, for example by steering you toward a career-defining opportunity.
How do you make room to grow into a bigger role?
Make yourself less necessary to day-to-day work through repeatable systems, templates, self-service dashboards, rotating meeting ownership and delegation. Her litmus test is whether you could take two weeks of vacation and progress would still be made.
What should you do when someone takes credit for your wins?
Start by giving them the benefit of the doubt and raising it with them one-on-one. If it is egregious, proactively share your work before they do.
How can leaders and allies help women get promoted?
Recognize where promotion processes may be biased, build women's confidence by asking what they want, find them opportunities to shine, and promote women.
About this talk
It’s no surprise that the higher up the ladder you look, the percentage of women and people of color in leadership roles dwindles. So, what can you do about it? Get yourself promoted and be a part of the next generation of leaders.
Promotions don’t happen magically, especially not for women. While there are many things we can’t control, from glass ceilings to unconscious biases, we will focus on what you can do to best position yourself for the next step in your career. You go, girl!
Jenny Zhao: Hi, everyone. My name is Jenny Zhao and I am currently the head of product of digital services at Asurion, which is a global tech care services company that's based out of Nashville. I'm here today to talk to you about the art of getting promoted. So first, I'd like to start by sharing a little bit about myself. This is a picture of me with my parents. I immigrated to the US from China when I was two years old. Growing up to Chinese immigrant parents, I was always told that if I worked hard, got good grades and kept my head down and stayed out of trouble, I would become a doctor.
That was the formula for success. What a stereotype, right? Well, obviously I didn't become a doctor, but I did work hard. I got good grades and I got into a good university. And so far the formula seemed to work pretty well for me. The first time I got passed up for a promotion, I was frustrated, angry and baffled. You see, I did my job and I did it really, really well.
I worked hard, long hours and never complained, just as my parents had taught me. This was the formula for success, right? Yet someone who hadn't worked as hard and had put in less hours than me ended up getting the promotion. Why? How had the formula for success failed me? The guy that got promoted was a white male. And while there's nothing I could do about that, I now realized there was something he did, whether consciously or not, that I didn't do. And it made all the difference.
We'll get to what that was in a little bit. So why am I here today? I realized my experience was not unique. In a recent study, it was found that while women on average received higher performance ratings, they were 14% less likely to be promoted than their male colleagues. The study found this was largely due to the emphasis placed on an arbitrary category called potential that is ripe for bias.
I'm here today because I'm frustrated by the lack of women in leadership positions, and I imagine you are too, which is why you are here with me today. While we can't control the unconscious biases of others, I'll cover some things we can do to improve our chances of having more women in leadership roles, other than starting our own companies.
I only have less than 20 minutes, so this is by no means exhaustive or a one-size-fits-all approach, and I recognize everyone's circumstance is unique. But I do hope if you are seeking a promotion, you will take away at least one or two things you can start doing right away. So I've broken these down into four main categories.
First one is building credibility. This is the most obvious one. If you want to get promoted, you need to be really good at your current job. If you're not or you're not in an opportunity to shine, focus on getting better at your current role or move to a job or situation that lets you be really, really good.
When I was promoted to a director of product management here at Asurion, there were three things that helped me build my case. The first one was I was deeply involved in my personal as well as team goal setting, just like the previous speaker was talking about. So for us, this is part of our performance reviews, and by partnering closely with my leader, we made sure my goals were clearly aligned with important things that the company cared about.
When the goals were set appropriately, it made my broader impact obvious, and it also gave me a chance to set goals that I could actually achieve. This set me up nicely so that people knew I was accomplishing things that mattered. You should do the same if you're not already. Take a look at what are the most important things your company or organization care about and connect the dots between your personal goals and those broader goals.
Then make sure you actually achieve them. Second, help your team succeed and make them look good. As the saying goes, a rising tide raises all ships. Where possible, I try to remove obstacles from my teammates or help them grow professionally, even when I was an individual contributor. I also made sure our team wins were widely broadcasted. This created opportunities for leaders to associate me with those wins as well.
Not only did I get promoted, but so did other members on my team, including several engineers and UX designers. This helped me build credibility, not only with the senior leaders, but also with my team and my peers. And third, be known for being the go-to for something. For example, in addition to being the subject matter expert of our team's products, I also became a go-to for championing product best practices for building high-performing teams, diverse and inclusive.
Teams and for developing people. I call this out because being a go-to can be technical or it can also be something else that's important to the company. And in my case, Asurion has really put a lot of emphasis on improving diversity, equity and inclusion in the last few years. So I was actually able to channel one of the areas I'm most passionate about into an asset.
Ultimately, it's not good enough to be good. You must also be known by others for being really, really good at your job. All right, second, serve yourself on a silver platter. So basically what this means is figure out how you can package yourself up for your leader to make their job to promote you as easy as possible.
In many companies, especially larger ones, a promotion is rarely determined by one person. It usually needs to be agreed upon by a cross set of leaders, which means your boss not only has to believe you deserve it, but they also have to convince others that you deserve it. So here are four things you can do to help your boss help you.
So this scene is from the movie The Notebook. And this is that moment where Ron Gosling's character, Noah, is yelling at Rachel McAdams' character, Ali, saying, what do you want? What do you want? And if you've never vocalized to your leader what you want next in your career, go do that ASAD. This seems obvious, yet so many people don't do it, especially women.
Going back to that first story I shared about getting passed up for a promotion, the biggest mistake I made was not making it loud and clear that I wanted a promotion. I had assumed by doing the work, the leaders would see that I was gunning for that next role. It turns out I never even had a chance because the guy who got it had been making it clear ever since I remember meeting him that that was a role he wanted next.
It was something I never did. And whether or not it would have resulted in my promotion earlier, no one will know, but it would have at least given me a shot versus no shot at all. Figure out what you want and why you want it. This is always time well spent. If you're not sure, that's okay, too.
But I found it's always better to choose a direction in the meantime until you do figure it out. It's kind of like a product roadmap. Having something out there is often better than nothing because it invites feedback and participation. And like a product roadmap, things can change based off of new information. Some things you can ask yourself include what roles interest me and why.
What makes me a good fit for those roles? Do I want to be an individual contributor or a people leader? Do I want to stay on the team or do I want to try something different? And once you know what you want, make sure your boss knows, make sure your boss's boss knows, make sure your team knows anybody.
People can't help you if they don't know what you want. Next, bridge the gaps between your role now and the next role you want. So while some lucky people have amazing leaders that help them do this, many don't. And if you want to get promoted, you have to be willing to do the research. Seek to understand what the major differences are between your role and the next and have candid conversations with your leader on what gaps are keeping you from getting promoted.
Getting alignment on this is super important to make the process actionable. And by bringing your boss along for the ride, they will be more invested in seeing you succeed. If you have good alignment and documentation on the gaps between your current role and the next level, it makes it much easier to take action, get help and know where you stand with your leader.
Be known for good things. You do this by marketing yourself. The easiest way for people to know how amazing you are is if you tell them. Put on your marketing hat and learn how to sell yourself and your work. After all, the men aren't men aren't trying about how good they are. In fact, in a Harvard Business Review study from 2019, men rated their performance 33% higher than equally performing women.
That's right, they performed the same, yet men rated their own performances 33% higher. So obviously, don't lie, but next time you write up your end of your performance review, think about this. It's impossible for your leaders to know all the details of your day-to-day work and accomplishments. So it's really up to you to tell them. And to the earlier point that promotion processes usually involve other leaders that are even more removed from your work than your leader, what are some quick hits your leader can repeat to help sell you?
Help them help you. And better yet, if you are good about frequently marketing your team's work, progress, and successes out to other decision makers, those decision makers will already know how talented you are without your leader having to say anything. To effectively do this, you should understand what do your leaders care about? What does your culture prioritize?
So, for example, Assurance Product Org cares about outcomes and learning over effort. So our team makes it a point to share out results of tests and what we learn with broader stakeholders. Even if they're not on our immediate team. A couple of ways we do this include sending an email to relevant stakeholders and decision makers for notable wins, kind of like a press release.
We also meet monthly with senior leaders to share out results and seek feedback. This gives our team an opportunity to showcase their progress regularly, as well as it gets senior leaders invested in our work and success. This allows other decision makers to get familiar with our work and our people, which then makes it easier for me to talk about how amazing they are when it comes to promotion time versus selling someone cool.
And the last part on how you can serve yourself up on a silver platter to your boss is create opportunities for yourself. Prepare the runway. So if you think about airplanes, they can only take off if the runway is clear. Getting yourself promoted is pretty similar. Here's an example. For me, moving from a senior product manager to a director role meant I needed to spend more time with overarching vision and strategy and ensuring that evolved with where the company was headed.
I realized I was having a hard time doing that because I was getting bogged down by so many small things where I was the only person who could address these things. I realized I needed to make myself less necessary to the day-to-day operations of the product team if I wanted to expand my scope. I did this through creating repeatable systems, templates, and self-service processes.
So instead of wasting time and energy reinventing the wheel, I have go-to templates for sharing out experiments or my go-to processes for prioritization meetings. By just reusing things that worked in the past, I saved myself so much time. I was also very transparent about things and always tried finding ways for people to help themselves. So, for example, I kept getting asked about certain questions about data and how we're performing.
So we prioritized building out a self-service data dashboard that updated the numbers in real time so that stakeholders could monitor what was going on without bothering us. Democratize ownership. So, for example, our team would regularly rotate who ran stand-ups and retros. It didn't always have to be the product lead. The unintended consequence was it actually improved participation and engagement in our meetings.
And it meant I wasn't always the one having to prepare for every meeting. And then lastly, get really good at delegating. As you grow in your career, it becomes less about what you do and more about the broader impact you can make, which oftentimes it's done through others. Learning early how to delegate is a crucial life skill in your career progression.
It may seem counterintuitive, but you can think about it as how can you work yourself out of your job so you can work yourself into another one. A good litmus test is asking yourself, can I go on vacation for two weeks without someone bugging me and progress is still being made? When you have redundancy, you free yourself up to do higher level work for the higher level role you want.
And it makes a transition an easier decision and easier logistically to execute. Last, another thought here is you can write your own job description. So in some cases, you might need to actually just create your own role to get promoted. At one company, I actually created two of my roles there. I did this by identifying gaps in the company that were holding it back from achieving its goals.
And then I recognized what my strengths were and what I wanted. And working with some mentors and my leaders, I connect the dots between those two worlds and was able to kind of craft two new roles that I ended up taking on. All right, third, build relationships. Relationships are super important to getting promoted. Everyone knows this. In addition to having mentors, also make sure you get a sponsor.
What's the difference? Mentors are people who you may go to with specific questions about an area of expertise or for advice. These are people who may push you up or forward. Sponsors are people who actively pull you up. So, for example, I had one previous leader at Asurion who identified an amazing opportunity that he felt could be career-defining for me.
I loved the current product I was working on, but he paved the way and assisted that this new opportunity was worth pursuing. It was a lateral move at the time, but it was that move that eventually resulted in me getting promoted to a director. I never would have made that move if that leader hadn't believed in me before I believed in myself.
Second, find your cohort and grow together. So, look around and identify peers who are also high performers, are respected, and that you respect, and seek to form alliances with them. It's often said that it gets lonely on top, but it doesn't have to be that way. We need to get ourselves out of this mindset that it's always a competition.
While it might be, you benefit so much more when you have a community of smart, talented people who you can grow together with. To this day, I have close relationships with people I've worked with earlier on in my career, and it's been really, really cool seeing our careers grow in parallel. What's more, it's been so valuable having these people to turn to when I have questions or problems, and they kind of get me.
They've been through the same thing that I've been through, and we have that in common. Lastly, make sure you are talking frequently with your leader about your career goals and progress. This can't be overstated. This needs to happen more than once a year during your end of your review. This should be happening all the time. All right, homestretch.
Last section. Find your leverage. Okay, so figure out what your strengths are and find opportunities to use them and market the heck out of it. There are a lot of talented people out there, so what is unique about you that sets you apart and makes you memorable in a good way? For example, in a previous role working for a staffing company, I worked in an industry that was primarily white men.
At first, I thought this would be a disadvantage, and while it was at the time, while it was at times, I quickly learned that there were benefits to being different. In a sea of Johns and Matts and Steves, being a Jenny just inherently made me stand out and made me more memorable so that when there was an opportunity to provide our service, they called me because they remembered who I was.
Lastly, if you have done literally all of the things we've covered and you keep getting passed up for promotions, it might be time to find a new place. In the previously mentioned MIT study, men who were passed over for a promotion were 35% to 40% more likely to leave than female employees. Sometimes even that unconscious bias of men results in a man getting promoted over a woman.
And if that's the case, sometimes we have to be brave enough to know our worth and stand up for ourselves and find us a place that values us. In summary, these are the four sections we covered on things you can do. Be really, really, really good at your current role. Make it easy for your boss to advocate for you.
Build relationships up, down, around, and know your worth. As a bonus for allies and leaders out there, learn to recognize where you or your company's promotions processes might be biased. What you can do is to support the amazing women on your team is build their confidence, asking the right questions if they aren't proactively offering things up. I will never forget being sat down by a VP once early in my career at Asurion, and he asked me just what I wanted to do out of the blue.
And it was that meeting that I mentioned I was interested in product, and I would love an opportunity at some point to try it. Two months later, I got the opportunity to be a product manager. These things are important. Third, find her opportunities to shine, whether that's setting up a monthly leadership cadence like our team does, or bringing up a shiny opportunity to her that you think she will do well.
Good leaders find opportunities to help their people grow. And lastly, the most obvious one, promote women. Thanks so much for joining me today. I would love to know what you thought about today's talk, so feel free to share your thoughts with me on LinkedIn. That's my LinkedIn right there. And I'm grateful for the career growth Asurion has provided me, and the good news is we're also hiring.
So we're looking for great people to join our team. We'd love to work with you. We're hiring software engineers, product managers, UX designers, and more. So you can scan the QR code to apply, or you can visit our booth and talk to some of my amazing co-workers. So thanks again, and enjoy the rest of the conference. Do both scan and go visit the booth and maximize your chances, you know?
I just feel so energized with your presentation. I think that it was super useful. There were so many comments in the chat, and people were looking forward to this presentation. Because yes, women do want to get promoted. Someone shared, I just started my role, but I already want to get promoted. I was actually blown away with the stat that you shared, that men actually rated their performance like 32% highest, and women with the same result.
This was like, oh my God, seriously? We should, you know, like, do better. And yeah, absolutely. Something interesting that you mentioned, creating a job description, maybe that doesn't, the job, and a job description for the job you want to do, which doesn't exist as a big company. And that was super interesting, I think. And maybe something interesting for our people.
If there is a question, let's take it. How do you deal with the situation where someone else takes away your wins and credits? Yeah, that's a really great question. So I generally like to start with giving people the benefit of the doubt. So first, I might start pulling them aside one-on-one. Maybe after the meeting happened or that situation occurred and address it directly with the person that's doing that to make them self-aware that that's happening.
In most cases, it's innocent. But if it's done egregiously, then be the one to share it before they do. So if you're doing a good job of proactively marketing your team's work or your work, you can share it out before they get to it. Yeah. Thank you. Thank you for your answer. And I think we're just on time.
And we took one minute for the question. So thank you so much, Jenny. I think people were asking about your slides. They wanted to go back to different parts. But I think the best would be if they just follow up with you on LinkedIn or drop by assurance booth. Yep, sounds good. And I'll find a way to share the slides somewhere.
So I'll get the feedback. Thank you, Jenny. It was really awesome to have you with us. And thank you for a useful presentation today. Thanks for the time.
Transcribed automatically; names checked against the speaker record. Select a time to jump there.
Article based on this talk
Why hard work alone won't get you promoted, and what will
Asurion product leader Jenny Zhao turns a missed promotion into a four-part plan for building a case leaders cannot overlook.
In short
Jenny Zhao, Senior Director and Head of Product, Digital Services at Asurion, argues that doing excellent work quietly is not enough to get promoted, especially for women. After losing a promotion to a colleague who had made his ambitions clear, she developed a practical approach in four parts: build credibility, make it easy for your boss to advocate for you, build relationships, and find your leverage. She closes with specific actions leaders and allies can take.
Key takeaways
Things you should start doing now
How to create your promotion plan
Leaders and allies: here's how you can help
When the formula for success stops working
Zhao immigrated to the US from China at two years old and grew up with a clear formula: work hard, get good grades, keep your head down and stay out of trouble. It carried her through school and into a good university. Then she was passed over for a promotion she felt she had earned, by someone who had worked fewer hours.
"The guy that got promoted was a white male. And while there's nothing I could do about that, I now realized there was something he did, whether consciously or not, that I didn't do." (1:10)
She stresses that her experience is not unique. As the speaker cited, a recent study found that women on average received higher performance ratings yet were 14% less likely to be promoted than male colleagues, largely because of an arbitrary and bias-prone category called potential. Her focus is on what individuals can control while those biases persist.
Build credibility in your current role
The first step is the most obvious: be really good at your current job, or move to a situation where you can be. When Zhao was promoted to director of product management, three things built her case. She partnered with her leader so her goals were clearly tied to what the company cared about, then achieved them. She helped her team succeed and broadcast team wins, so leaders associated her with them; several engineers and UX designers on her team were promoted too. And she became the go-to person for something, in her case product best practices, building diverse high-performing teams and developing people, which matched Asurion's emphasis on diversity, equity and inclusion.
"Ultimately, it's not good enough to be good. You must also be known by others for being really, really good at your job." (5:16)
Serve yourself on a silver platter
Promotions in larger companies are usually agreed by a group of leaders, so your boss must believe you deserve it and convince others too. Zhao's advice is to package yourself so that job is easy. Start by saying what you want. Her biggest mistake in that first story was assuming leaders would see she wanted the role.
"People can't help you if they don't know what you want." (7:32)
She compares a career direction to a product roadmap: having one invites feedback and can change with new information. Next, research the gaps between your current role and the next one, and agree on them with your leader in writing. Then market yourself. As the speaker cited, a 2019 Harvard Business Review study found men rated their performance 33% higher than equally performing women. Her team shares test results and learnings through press-release style emails and monthly sessions with senior leaders, so decision makers already know the people she later advocates for.
Finally, prepare the runway. Moving to director meant spending more time on vision and strategy, so she made herself less necessary to daily operations with reusable templates, a self-service data dashboard, rotating who runs stand-ups and retros, and delegation.
"A good litmus test is asking yourself, can I go on vacation for two weeks without someone bugging me and progress is still being made?" (12:06)
Sometimes you can even write your own job description: at one company she created two of her own roles by matching gaps holding the business back with her strengths.
Build relationships: mentors, sponsors and your cohort
Zhao separates mentors, who advise and push you forward, from sponsors.
"Sponsors are people who actively pull you up." (13:18)
A previous leader at Asurion steered her toward a lateral move she would not have chosen, and it eventually led to her director promotion. "I never would have made that move if that leader hadn't believed in me before I believed in myself." (13:38) She also urges building a cohort of respected peers who grow together rather than treating everything as a competition, and talking with your leader about career goals far more than once a year.
Find your leverage and know your worth
Identify what makes you different and use it. Working at a staffing company in an industry made up mostly of white men, she first saw being different as a disadvantage, then found it made her memorable.
"In a sea of Johns and Matts and Steves, being a Jenny just inherently made me stand out and made me more memorable so that when there was an opportunity to provide our service, they called me because they remembered who I was." (15:20)
If you have done all of this and still keep getting passed over, she says it may be time to find a place that values you. For leaders and allies, her advice is to recognize bias in promotion processes, ask women what they want, find them opportunities to shine and, most obviously, promote women. A VP once asked her out of the blue what she wanted to do; two months after she mentioned product, she became a product manager. In the Q&A she addresses colleagues who take credit for your wins: raise it one-on-one first, and if it is egregious, share your work before they do.
Watch the talk
Girl, Get Promoted! Demystifying Promotions, by Jenny Zhao (about 20 minutes): https://www.womentech.net/video/girl-get-promoted-demystifying-promotions-jenny-zhao
About the speaker
Jenny Zhao is Sr. Director, Head of Product, Digital Services at Asurion, where she leads the teams behind Asurion's cloud storage and digital security products. Before product management she worked in operations and sales leadership, and she is passionate about building diverse, empowered teams and improving representation of women in tech leadership.
Questions this talk answers
Why can strong performers still get passed over for promotion?
What is the difference between a mentor and a sponsor?
How do you make room to grow into a bigger role?
What should you do when someone takes credit for your wins?
How can leaders and allies help women get promoted?
Drafted with AI from the talk transcript. Editor review pending.