Giving women a Voice. How to build a Grassroot Women@ Employee Resource Group (ERG)
Ronit Bohrer Hillel20:562023
She gave 30 to 40% of her time to DEI work and her managers rarely noticed
A new employee at a US tech company, she is flattered to join a VP diversity offsite, then finds herself spending 30 to 40% of her time on DEI work her managers rarely recognize. Ronit Bohrer Hillel, a VP of Engineering and career coach formerly at Smartsheet and Amazon, later co-builds a women in tech community that becomes a formal ERG. How does a grassroots group take on governance without losing its spirit?
Get the step-by-step path from grassroots community to company-backed ERG, and how to pace it
Ronit Bohrer Hillel argues that women's employee resource groups are strongest when they grow from the bottom up as grassroots communities rather than being imposed top down. Drawing on building a women in tech community at Smartsheet, she explains what ERGs give employees and employers, the steps from informal community to company-backed ERG, and how to add governance gradually without killing the community's momentum.
“So don't let that stop your momentum. Don't let that need for governance and order kill the beautiful community you already created.”
“When ERGs are born from communities, employees feel a sense of ownership and a unity that makes them stronger within their company. It's their space.”
What you will learn
Weigh whether DEI volunteering is an expectation you accept or a contribution you choose, and separate ERG work from team-level inclusion work.
Explain the value of an ERG to both employees and employers, from belonging and talent spotting to engagement and feedback.
Build a grassroots women's community step by step: open invitation, a communication channel, consistent events, volunteers, allies and leadership collaboration.
Formalize a community into an ERG with a clear purpose, executive sponsors, chairs and directors, budget and programming.
Phase the move to governance so the community keeps its momentum and new leaders from all levels can step in.
Key takeaways from the speaker
The value of creating a Women@ ERG and the challenges you may encounter
How to bring an ERG to be acknowledged and supported by the organization
What is the role of such ERG? What content, values, opportunities and Support should it provide to the members
What is the place for Allies in the success of the ERG
How to mature an ERG without slowing down.
Details
Level
All levels
Format
Talk
Technical depth
Non-technical
For
All career stages
Length
20:56
Published
June 2023
Questions this talk answers
What is an employee resource group?
An organized community within an organization, typically led by employees who share a common characteristic such as gender, ethnicity, religion or interests. It provides support and a safe place for that community and a platform for allies.
Why should a women's ERG start bottom up rather than top down?
Ronit believes grassroots communities are much more powerful because members feel ownership and unity. When an ERG is born from a community, it is their space.
What changes when a community becomes a formal ERG?
The community adds formality and governance and the company becomes an invested partner. At Smartsheet that meant a clarified purpose, executive sponsors, appointed chairs and directors, a budget and more mature programming.
How do you formalize an ERG without burning out the community?
Do not do everything at once: appoint a chair and clarify the purpose first, then a program director with a handful of activities, and add further roles only as things settle.
How can recent graduates find entry-level data roles when most openings are senior?
Ronit advises connecting with communities, including nonprofits that connect women in tech and people one step ahead in their careers, because connections and recommendations are extremely helpful.
About this talk
Promoting Women in Tech is on top of our mind. Companies have learned to acknowledge the value that diverse workforce brings and therefore invest in DEI, however this only creates a top down paradigm of enablement and awareness. What is still missing is allowing women to connect and build their own community within the organization and shape it the way best supports, empower and serve them as a community. In this session you will get inspired as well as receive practical tools on how to create a Women@ grassroot group within your organization. An affinity led by the community, open to allies and able to be self-sustainable. You would learn how to empower women in all levels in your organization to go and do.
*music* Let me know when I should start, I don't see the participants. Okay, welcome. My name is Ronit Borilel and I'm a product engineering leader and a career coach. I'm really excited to be with you today and I wanted to take you today through my nine years voyage and journey to support women in technology and BI. Hopefully inspire you a bit and give you some tools to see how you can build powerful grassroots communities.
When I first started working in a tech company in the US, I was invited to attend the Diversity Offsite with all the VPs in the organization. I was extremely flattered. As a new employee, that was an opportunity to be with leadership on kind of a very intense couple of days. However, I soon realized that it wasn't actually the that I got a lot of value. It was actually the other way around.
The leadership was getting a lot of value. The leadership was spending time with the most senior underrepresented minorities in the organization. And it was helping them steer the organization. And they also saw it as our job to contribute to the effort to increase diversity. During my first four years in the company, I found myself initiating, participating, leading, contributing in so many ways to the EIs.
And so at peak, I spent about 30 to 40% of my time as an engineering manager in the EI activity. Unfortunately, my managers rarely recognized or accepted or even rewarded me for that time. They believed it was my obligation as a woman in tech to improve the EI for the organization and I should just do it. So ask yourself, what is your sense of duty? As an employee from a minority group, what is our role in improving the EI within the organization?
Is it fair for the organization to expect us to contribute in this way? And how do employee resource groups, ERGs, factor into this effort? It's all great questions to ask ourselves in the great daylands. So let's start with defining what is an employee resource group. ERGs are an organized community within an organization that are typically led and comprised by employees who share a common characteristic.
It can be about gender, ethnicity, religion, lifestyle, interests. It could be many different things as long as it connects a group together. These groups are established to provide support and create a safe place for employees from that community. ERGs also serve as a platform for allies who wish to support their colleagues and be actively involved in creating an inclusive work environment.
So that's kind of what is an ERG. Now let's think about it from an employee perspective first. Let's put our employee head. What's the value it gives us? We touched a little bit into that. So ERG provide us a space that we can connect with others like us, right? We can identify. We'll have maybe mutual interest. Interest.
We can share experiences. We can lean on folks like us. And create a feeling of support that we have a support system and a sense of belongingness. ERG can also help identify maybe emerging talent that by other means were too junior or maybe some unconscious bias would have pushed them aside. But in that safe place, they have that place to shine out.
It can provide opportunities for employees to become leaders regardless of who they are in their job. And because the community usually comprise of multiple people in different levels in their organization, it can actually give them a real opportunity. And then it can become this source of information. A lot of our biases come from ignorance and having a source of information that can provide data and real reliable information about that group can actually be very powerful and help support that group within the organization.
So we understand what it is for us as employees, but why would employers, companies, what's their interest in ERGs? So we know that diversity is good. And I'll share my hint of data about that. Companies with strong women representation are 25% more likely to be outperforming. As if you make sure that you have a diverse force in the organization, you probably have better success in your in-business outcome.
But the other interesting part that ERG also bring, it's not just that they create that group that improve diversity. I mean, it creates that inclusion feeling because companies with higher engagement in the workforce have 21% higher profitability. And those ERGs create that engagement. They make the employees feel better, feel more included, feel supported, feel belong, feel they have a voice.
And that empowers them to outperform at work and support the company's business goal. They also create this valuable place where the company can learn and get feedback about what it's doing good or not good in terms of the AI. And that is a very powerful tool for the company to be connected to minority groups. So where do we start?
When I left my first company here in the US, I moved to Smartsheet, my next one. I was determined to start doing things only when the company would be ready. And the reason for that was not my lack of sense of duty or my desire not to support my community was actually because I found that there is a huge amount of power when the organization and leader in the organization are fully committed.
And when the right time came, it took about a year. For the last year, I and amazing colleagues of mine decided to build a community, women in tech community within Smartsheet. And there are two ways to start. When you think about a community, it's a community. What's the relation to an ERG? How it become an ERG? So when you think about an ERG, you can start exactly like that.
Those grassroots bottom up from a community that will later grow to what we will learn is an ERG. Or it could come from top down. A company can decide, hey, we want to encourage our underrepresented minorities, our affinity groups. We want to allow them to connect. We're going to give them support and budget and everything they need from start.
We're going to ask for volunteers in those groups to actually build that up. I want to talk about those bottom up, those grassroots created communities, because I think they are much more powerful. So let's see how you do that. When we started, our goal was to build a community. In our case, a community for women in tech within the company.
It would be that place, that support, that nurture, create this safe place for women in the company. We started by declaring that we are building that and that we are inviting anyone to join. We were very inclusive. Anyone could actually join. We build two critical elements. One is that communication channel. So people could hear, could talk, can start forming a community offline as well, not just an event.
And then this consistent activity, actual meetups and events that occur. We extended that to tailor to the community need and involve more people to volunteer. We actually, our dream was, I was a senior director at the time and my peers were directors as well. And our dream was that anyone in any level, regardless who they are in that women in tech community can go.
And so we encourage people to volunteer. We supported them where they needed. We took one step further and invited allies, people that really cared about this to join us. And they were coming. And we started to have this huge events with many people from a variety of groups coming. Our third step was to invite the organization, lead our leadership to do collaboration.
So we collaborated, for example, on the Women History Month at this time. And then the last step before we became an ERG was actually to take part in formalizing what should be those employee resource groups within the company. And after that, we made that jump and became an ERG. So what makes an ERG different from just the community, right?
The answer is that this is a time when the community creates formality and governance. And the company become an invested partner in that community. So there is a very strong part between, a very strong relation between the community and the company. So now we grew up becoming from a community and ERG. And I want to share with you what does it mean, that maturity, that level of governance that we added.
First, we clarified our purpose and mission. At that time, we were women in tech and gender minority and allies. We had this very long name comprised of all of that together. We clarified and said, hey, there are several ERGs. We are going to focus on women and that's our goal for that ERG. And we knew that the other parts are supported in the right way.
So we clarified that. We established that company relation. We got the executive sponsors. We got leadership supporting, DEI leadership as well supporting. So both the company leadership in general and DEI leadership supporting. We created formal leadership. If any one of you have been in PTSA, very similar. We appointed chairs and co-chairs, director for different parts. And so we have communities around the world.
So they were directors leading different parts of those communities. And then we defined budget that the company was willing to provide for that activity. If in your community time you have not yet established how people become members or what is your kind of schedule for the year or how do you communicate? That was the time that we actually clarified it and mature it, especially the element of programming, by the way, which became more mature.
So this, this is a good recipe. Now you know how to build a formal ERG. However, migrating from a grassroot community to a formal ERG can be overwhelming. Everything at once happened and it can chip in and, and kind of fracture the structure of the community. This can lead the group to feel pressure and can burn it down.
So don't let that stop your momentum. Don't let that need for governance and order kill the beautiful community you already created. To prevent this, save the transition. Not everything needs to happen in the first time. So define what needs to be done first. Yes, you do need to appoint a chair. This is the time where I, when I actually stepped down and I allowed, and I allowed the community to set up who is the chair for, for that ERG.
That's an important step. It's important to clarify your purpose, but then stop there and figure out what do I need next. I need activities. Okay. Otherwise I wouldn't be able to engage with my community. So maybe point the program director and, and come up with that five, six activities along the year or the next quarter activities. Don't get crazily carried away.
And then as things start settling down and you're keeping that momentum as a community and everybody engaged, then add the next and next step. There are more type of directors and more type of roles. And this is an amazing opportunity for people from the community to volunteer, but take that time that you need. Remember not to rush the process so it would not jeopardize the community that you have worked all of you so hard to create.
There is a power in number and a power in unity is a saying I heard from great leaders. ERG can offer significant benefits for both employees and employers, and they provide the power in number and the power in unity. Those can, ERGs can increase diversity, inclusion, engagement, and they can improve the company business outcome. So it's a win-win.
When ERGs are born from communities, employees feel a sense of ownership and a unity that makes them stronger within their company. It's their space. We all have that opportunity to make a positive impact within our organization. We can give community the voice by supporting them, by helping create them, by volunteering them. And if you think about your sense of duty for that might be that thing, you are not obligated.
But if you want to contribute, this is the way you can feel comfortable to do so. And the community would benefit immensely. So thank you for so much for being and listening to me and I would love to answer any questions that anyone had. You're more than welcome to put them in the chat and just open in the chat.
We have about kind of five minutes. So thank you so much for the first question. I'll read it out. Would you mind giving some advice to recent graduates seeking an entry level data related position in today's job market? Because most of jobs are open to senior position now. Thank you. Not very much related to an ERG, but definitely, you know, I think the secret today is knowing people and community again.
So even within graduate, you can reach out to communities that exist for you. Also community that are usually one step forward in your career. So, and those exists as well. They are not, they're not officially within organization. It is the other way around. They're actually, there's tons of nonprofit organization that connect women in tech. And when you start getting to know people, that, that might be a good way for them to give you a chance.
There are very, very few positions open, but they are there. And having connection and people recommendation is very extremely helpful. The other way around is doing those connections through some of those social networks. Any, any other questions anybody had? Anybody had an experience of building and taking part of a employee resource group through their time? And have a positive or negative or concern or question?
I can tell you that I've, in the last nine years, I've seen so many evolutions of creating some type and form of community. And I don't know how many of you feel or part of such, but when you have the opportunity to be part of, it is really critical in that place to actually contribute and volunteer. And I'm putting that aside from your contribution to diversity and inclusion within the team that you're working in or the organization that you're working in.
Those are two different things. And you can separate them in your mind and decide what is right for you in each one of them. Okay. Any other questions? I can tell you one more thing that I, the one, the moment, the most happy moment for me, I call it. Was the moment where I saw the community became completely independent.
And when I started the community, the women in tech, it's not cheap. I was a senior director and I was, you know, they're not men. I was the most senior person from in tech later on that. Another person joined that was more senior than me, but I didn't feel that I was the good representation of the voices around.
I felt that I had the power to go and do, but I, but not necessarily representing the voices all around. And the happiest moment for me was the moment where I could say, Hey, I can happily step down. Okay. And we had two more early career, mid career women actually taking that lead and becoming the chair of that community.
And for me, that was the peak moment. It was also very challenging because that was the moment where we became formally RG. And that was the moment where they needed to mostly step into a very complicated role of governance. So they needed the support. They needed executive support from around, but they, but the community became huge. It actually wider itself to contain all women at the company.
And it had a very strong voice, but it was even able to make a difference in high level company decision. So I was extremely proud that that happened. I think we are out of time for today. And I wanted to thank you for being with me. Enjoy the rest of the conference.
Transcribed automatically; names checked against the speaker record. Select a time to jump there.
Article based on this talk
Why the strongest women's ERGs start as grassroots communities
Ronit Bohrer Hillel shares how a women in tech community at Smartsheet grew into a formal ERG, and how to add governance without breaking it.
In short
Ronit Bohrer Hillel argues that women's employee resource groups (ERGs) are most powerful when they grow from the bottom up, as communities employees build for themselves, before the company formalizes them. Drawing on her experience co-building a women in tech community at Smartsheet, she lays out the steps from an open invitation to a company-backed ERG, and warns that rushing governance can burn out the very community it is meant to support.
Key takeaways
The value of creating a Women@ ERG and the challenges you may encounter
How to get an ERG acknowledged and supported by the organization
The role of such an ERG: what content, values, opportunities and support it should provide to members
The place of allies in the success of the ERG
How to mature an ERG without slowing down
The hidden cost of being asked to do DEI
Ronit opens with her own experience. As a new employee at a US tech company, she was invited to a diversity offsite with all the VPs and felt flattered. She soon realized the value flowed mostly the other way: leadership was learning from the most senior underrepresented people in the organization, and expected them to help increase diversity. Over her first four years, she says, at peak she spent about 30 to 40% of her time as an engineering manager on DEI activity.
"Unfortunately, my managers rarely recognized or accepted or even rewarded me for that time." (2:29)
That experience frames the question she asks the audience to consider: what is your sense of duty as an employee from a minority group, and is it fair for an organization to expect that contribution? ERGs, she suggests, are part of the answer, because they give that effort a structure and a home.
What an ERG gives employees and employers
Ronit defines an ERG as an organized community within an organization, typically led by employees who share a common characteristic such as gender, ethnicity, religion, lifestyle or interests. It is also a platform for allies who want to be actively involved in creating an inclusive workplace.
"These groups are established to provide support and create a safe place for employees from that community." (3:32)
For employees, she lists connection and a sense of belonging, a place where emerging talent can shine when unconscious bias might otherwise push people aside, leadership opportunities regardless of job level, and a reliable source of information that counters the ignorance behind many biases. For employers, she points to diversity and engagement. As the speaker cited, companies with strong women representation are 25% more likely to be outperforming, and companies with higher workforce engagement have 21% higher profitability. ERGs also give the company a direct line of feedback on what it is doing well or badly on inclusion.
Building from the grassroots
When Ronit moved to Smartsheet, she deliberately waited until the organization was ready, because she had seen how much power comes from leaders who are fully committed. That took about a year. Then she and colleagues began building a women in tech community.
"I want to talk about those bottom up, those grassroots created communities, because I think they are much more powerful." (8:07)
Her sequence is practical. First, declare that you are building a community and invite anyone to join. Second, create two critical elements: a communication channel so people can talk and form connections beyond events, and consistent activity such as meetups. Third, encourage people at every level to volunteer, and invite allies who care about the cause. Fourth, collaborate with leadership, for example on Women's History Month. Finally, take part in defining what ERGs should look like in the company, then make the jump.
From community to formal ERG
What separates an ERG from a community, in Ronit's framing, is governance and a real partnership with the company.
"The answer is that this is a time when the community creates formality and governance. And the company become an invested partner in that community." (10:15)
At Smartsheet, maturing meant clarifying the purpose (narrowing a long name to a focus on women, knowing other groups were supported elsewhere), securing executive sponsors and DEI leadership support, appointing chairs, co-chairs and directors for communities around the world, agreeing a budget, and defining membership, an annual schedule, communications and a more mature program of activities.
Pace the transition so the community survives
Ronit is candid that moving from a grassroots group to a formal ERG can be overwhelming. Everything happens at once, the structure can fracture, and the pressure can burn the group out.
"So don't let that stop your momentum. Don't let that need for governance and order kill the beautiful community you already created." (12:48)
Her advice is to stage the work. Appoint a chair and clarify the purpose first. Then appoint a program director and plan five or six activities for the year or the next quarter, without getting carried away. Add further roles as things settle, treating each as an opportunity for community members to volunteer.
"Remember not to rush the process so it would not jeopardize the community that you have worked all of you so hard to create." (13:48)
She closes the talk by returning to duty: no one is obligated, but those who want to contribute can do so in a way that feels comfortable. In the Q&A she adds that ERG work and contributing to inclusion within your own team are two different things, and each person can decide what is right for them in each.
Knowing when to step down
The moment Ronit calls her happiest came when the community became independent. As a senior director, she felt she had the power to act but did not necessarily represent the voices around her.
"And the happiest moment for me was the moment where I could say, Hey, I can happily step down." (19:28)
Two early and mid-career women took over as chairs just as the group became a formal ERG, a challenging moment that required executive support. The community grew to include all women at the company and, she says, became able to make a difference in high-level company decisions.
Watch the talk
"Giving women a Voice. How to build a Grassroot Women@ Employee Resource Group (ERG)" by Ronit Bohrer Hillel, 21 minutes: https://www.womentech.net/video/giving-women-voice-how-build-grassroot-women-employee-resource-group-erg
About the speaker
Ronit Bohrer Hillel is a VP of Engineering and career coach (ex Smartsheet, ex Amazon) and a seasoned product-engineering leader who has led SaaS, AI, no-code, telecom and big data initiatives over more than 20 years. A trained career coach who advises engineering executives, she is an advocate for accelerating women in engineering and an active DEI leader.
Questions this talk answers
What is an employee resource group?
Why should a women's ERG start bottom up rather than top down?
What changes when a community becomes a formal ERG?
How do you formalize an ERG without burning out the community?
How can recent graduates find entry-level data roles when most openings are senior?
Drafted with AI from the talk transcript. Editor review pending.
Cite this talk
Ronit Bohrer Hillel. "Giving women a Voice. How to build a Grassroot Women@ Employee Resource Group (ERG)." WomenTech Network, 2023. https://www.womentech.net/video/giving-women-voice-how-build-grassroot-women-employee-resource-group-erg