0:0021:06

The Spoof of Imposter Syndrome, And How This Pathology Has Been Gaslighting Women In The Workplace For Decades

Leslie Smith 21:06 2022

Imposter syndrome is a systems problem women were told to fix alone

Three in four women executives, as the speaker cited, admit to feeling like frauds, yet the label born in 1970s research on high-achieving women ignores racism, classism and workplace microaggressions. Leslie Smith, National Director of GET Cities, argues the diagnosis itself gaslights women in tech. If the problem is not in women's heads, what should workplaces and leaders change first?

Learn why fixing systems beats fixing women, and the concrete changes GET Cities pushes for

Watch on YouTube

In short

Leslie Smith, National Director of GET Cities, argues that imposter syndrome is a misleading label that turns a systemic problem into a personal flaw women are expected to fix themselves. She traces the concept to 1970s research, shows how biased norms around confidence and language shape hiring and funding, and calls for inclusive workplaces, active allies and policy change instead of fixing individuals.

“And that is you can't be what you can't see.”
“And because we feel like we have to be twice as good to get half as much, the additional sort of burden of feeling as if we don't belong slows us down.”

What you will learn

  • Trace imposter syndrome back to its 1970s origins and see what the original theory left out.
  • Recognize how gendered norms about confident language shape resumes, interviews, job offers and venture funding.
  • Spot the pet-to-threat pattern, where confident women are first celebrated and later treated as a threat.
  • Make the economic case for diverse teams instead of relying on short-lived civic motivation.
  • Apply individual practices such as truth-telling, setting boundaries and remembering you are not alone, alongside pushing for system change.

Key takeaways from the speaker

  • The current conversations and proposed solutions to overcoming imposter syndrome are often outdated and misguided.
  • The answer to overcoming imposter syndrome is not to fix individuals, but to create inclusive working environments with diverse leadership styles.
  • Racial, ethnic, and gender identities are not and should not be deemed as other; rather, they need to be honored and celebrated as a crucial piece on the path to innovation, growth, and progress.

Details

Level
All levels
Format
Talk
Technical depth
Non-technical
For
All career stages
Length
21:06
Published
July 2022

Questions this talk answers

Where did the idea of imposter syndrome come from?

It was derived in the 1970s by two psychologists researching high-achieving women and was originally called the imposter phenomenon. It described women who believe they are not intelligent and have fooled anyone who thinks otherwise.

Why does Leslie Smith call imposter syndrome a spoof?

Because it treats a feeling of lacking worth as an individual problem instead of looking at systemic racism, classism, xenophobia, workplace microaggressions and other bias. It places the burden of proving their value on women, trans and non-binary people.

How do confidence norms affect women differently than men?

Men tend to use affirming, confident language and are rewarded for it, while women use more limiting language, which shapes resumes, interviews, job offers and venture pitches. When women do act confidently, they can shift from being celebrated to being seen as a threat.

What should organizations change instead of fixing individual women?

They should put more women in leadership, engage willing leaders as allies, accomplices and sponsors, drop outdated professionalism standards and support policies such as universal child care and pre-K.

What can individuals do in the meantime?

Remind themselves of their inherent value, set boundaries to protect their mental health, practice truth-telling about harmful behaviors and remember they are not alone in feeling this way.

About this talk

Imposter Syndrome, the act of doubting your abilities and feeling like a fraud at work, is a diagnosis often given to women. However, the fact that this is considered a legitimate diagnosis is in itself the problem. The concept of imposter syndrome was derived in the 1970s, and the development of this theory wholly excluded the effects of systemic racism, classism, xenophobia, workplace micro-aggressions, and other biases. This theme of imposter syndrome has taken a fairly universal feeling of discomfort, second-guessing, and mild anxiety in the workplace and pathologized it, especially for women. The time has come to recognize these glaring caveats in regards to this widely popularized idea of imposter syndrome that seems to be hurled at women to internalize well into their careers.

My objective is to disrupt this theme of Imposter Syndrome that seems to monopolize the conversation of women in tech, and look beyond some of the most popular interventions intended to “empower women.” I believe the answer to overcoming imposter syndrome is not to fix individuals, but to create working environments that are more inclusive of diverse leadership and working styles. We need to create workplaces where racial, ethnic, and gender identities are not deemed as other and instead are honored and celebrated as crucial pieces on the path to innovation, growth, and progress.

Topics

Related talks

Browse the library