From TechWoman to TechEnbie - the impact of being non-binary in a binary world
Cal Brown19:312023
Women in tech communities have to decide who they are really for
Thirty-five years ago, a young engineer is told the gender ratio in tech will be 50/50 within 10 to 20 years; today the ratios look much the same. Cal Brown, Lead Security Storyteller at BT, who came out as non-binary in 2021, says the people these communities reach increasingly fit neither box. How can allies and women-in-tech groups welcome them without diluting their core message?
Learn three practical steps allies can take and one small change any community can make today
Cal Brown, Lead Security Storyteller at BT, who came out as non-binary in 2021, explains what being non-binary means and why it is not a passing trend. They set out three escalating steps individual allies can take and pose open questions to the tech women community about inclusive language, intersectionality and who the community is for, aiming to start a debate rather than close it.
“I don't think anybody wants to be defined by being not something.”
“You're taking a stand on the other side at that point, and the listeners will hear and recognise that.”
What you will learn
Explain what being non-binary means and why it is distinct from biology and from transitioning.
Counter the claim that non-binary identity is a trend, using historical and cultural examples.
Apply three escalating ally steps: using pronouns, speaking out in public forums and checking where your money goes.
Assess your own bandwidth before deciding how much advocacy to take on.
Question how intersectional your community wants to be and avoid gatekeeping who counts as a woman.
Key takeaways from the speaker
There are more than two genders - take time to think about the implications of this.
How does the tech women community want to work with trans and non binary people?
What small changes make a big difference? Some things allies can do to show support.
Details
Level
Beginner
Format
Talk
Technical depth
Non-technical
For
All career stages
Length
19:31
Published
May 2023
Questions this talk answers
What does it mean to be non-binary?
It means having a gender identity that does not conform to the belief that you are either male or female. For many non-binary people it is not a step towards transitioning but where they are.
Is non-binary identity just a recent trend?
No. Cal points to the pharaoh Hatshepsut, the Polynesian mahu and the Hijra of South Asia, and says the internet has simply helped people find words and community.
What can an individual ally do to support non-binary colleagues?
First consider your bandwidth, then use the gender-neutral pronouns people ask for, speak out against transphobic views when you feel safe, and research whether the companies you buy from fund transphobia.
What can the tech women community do to include non-binary people?
Think about inclusive language, decide how intersectional it wants to be, avoid gatekeeping who is a woman, and even add a note in the small print recognising non-binary people.
Do we really have to use they for one person?
Cal tells the story of an anonymous stranger who returned their lost wallet, showing that singular they already sounds natural when a person's gender is unknown.
About this talk
Because being a woman in tech isn't hard enough, I came out as non-binary a year ago. How are we, as a society and a community, going to recognise and welcome the hidden people who know they don't fit in a single box, without diluting the critical messages about the larger minorities? My talk brings some possibilities to the table, but my main goal is to stimulate the debate I passionately believe we need to have.
I'll start by introducing myself. So my name is Cal. I live and work in the UK. I work in cybersecurity at the moment. I've done a lot of different roles in technology over the years. I've been a networks director. I've been a software developer. I've done a PhD in fiber optics, which involved working down in a lab.
I'm unquestionably a techie person. I've got two children, and I am non-binary, which is partly the point of this talk that I don't identify as either male or female. This is something that I had recognized at some level for a long time, but because certainly the culture that I grew up in was very polarised. It wasn't something that I ever felt comfortable voicing. So my route through tech has been very similar to that of many tech women. I was heartily encouraged to take STEM subjects at school.
I was encouraged to go into engineering. This was 35 years ago. And I was told, you know, within 10 to 20 years, the ratios would be 50/50 male/female. It'll be amazing. But go now and strike a blow for women. I'm not seeing that there's any particular difference in the ratios of men to women technology to what they were 35 years ago, but perhaps I made a difference.
We're starting to see a bit more diversity. But one of the things that I think we need to talk about as a community, or as the tech women community, which I still to some extent feel part of, and certainly my local tech women have been super supportive of me saying, actually, I'm not a woman, I'm non-binary. is that we need to think how we want to include people who are not part of the obvious big visible minority, the oppressed majority.
So I don't have any answers on this. I've just got more questions, which is why I want the debate to begin. I don't think it's an easy thing to answer, but by starting the debate, we can hopefully move it forwards. It's one of the things I get asked quite often. What is being non-binary? There's a formal definition of having a gender identity that does not conform to traditional binary beliefs about gender, i.e. that you're either male or you're female, you cannot be one or the other.
Your gender identity is different to any biology that you have. When my doctor needs to know what plumbing I have for the necessary, appropriate plumbing, I can't help you to discuss the biology that I possess with my doctor, but for practical day-to-day working, there is no reason why I cannot have the gender identity that I see. I am very confident that I am neither male nor female, but I have assumptions that it's a step on the way to transitioning, but it's not for the people I know who identify as non-binary.
For some people, for sure, it's a step towards transitioning between genders completely and assuming an entire different binary gender identity, but for a lot of the enemies that I know, to be non-binary is where you are. It's where you are, it's your thing in and of itself, I don't feel particularly male, I don't feel particularly female, I may dress as either, I may dress as neither, although our culture is very much either you are dressed female or by default you're male, which is a bit exhausting sometimes, but there we go.
Another thing that I get asked fairly often is why suddenly do we have so many non-binary people kicking around, you know, is this just a trend, it's just fashion, it's all woke nonsense, I hear a lot, and there have been, throughout recorded history, there have been people who have presented one way, acted another. So, and there are cultures that have a tradition of a third gender, which balances masculinity and femininity, so to refute the, is this suddenly just a thing, is it just a fashion, is it a trend, I would offer the pharaoh Hatsheput, from 1479 BC, when their reign began, they were, The recorded views of the recorded views of them, are that they are female in shape, they possess some of the female biological characteristics, all of their pronouncements or written text about them, describes them as male, or as genderless.
They balanced masculinity and femininity. There are in, for example, the Polynesian cultures, the concept of mahu, a third gender. There's a still I've shown from the film about Hina Le Mawana, Wankalu, known as Hina for short, who is a mahu. Their story is very powerful, but very modern, but that is a culture which has extended for thousands of years.
There is also the Hijrah of South Asia, again, a third gender, which balances masculinity and femininity. It's nothing new. Why are so many Western cultures suddenly feeling able to say this? Partly it's the rise of the Internet. The Internet is responsible for a great many things, both good and bad, but for not feeling isolated, for being able to talk to people outside of your own local area.
It's been tremendously powerful for those of us who are not conforming in some way to standard. I've been able to find words for how I feel, and I've had the confidence that how I feel is as valid as how other people feel, and that I can start talking about it. And I think it's really important that we talk about it more, because with each generation, it's becoming more common for people to say, I'm not comfortable with gender binary.
One of the reasons that the tech women communities need to start engaging with this is that increasingly the people who we are reaching out to and working with are going to have their genders as well as male or female. And we need to be thinking how we are going to deal with that. So, if we're looking at what individuals can do, there's different things if you feel that you want to engage to help support.
I'm going to talk about what individuals can do and then what the tech women community can do. So, there are different levels of engagement, because the first thing you have to do is consider how much bandwidth you have. Well, we cannot fight all the battles simultaneously. I can be indignant and recognise the injustice of things that are happening to people in other spaces without having enough bandwidth to support them vigorously, as well as supporting my own agenda, which is clearly the non-binding one.
So, first of all, consider how much bandwidth you have for helping and being an ally. There are very simple things you can do. The most basic one is to recognise that if somebody is saying, I am not male or female, I am gender neutral, then please use gender neutral pronouns. They will have pronouns that they prefer. Yes, it's difficult because it doesn't flow naturally or it's not as hard as it feels, but yes, it does take a change of thinking.
And that's something that's a courtesy that any human who asks you to talk to them in a particular way, I think that's the basic human courtesy. If you want to go that little step further, then if you're in any sort of public forum, any sort of meeting place, anywhere where there are people talking and someone expresses transphobic views or views which are opposed to non-binary people, then if you feel brave and if you feel safe and confident enough, speak out.
Say, look, at the basics, you know, this is not cool, this is not how we respect other people, it's not up to you to change the mind of the person speaking. And what you're actually doing is making it clear to everybody else who's listening, because there'll be one speaker but lots of listeners. You're taking a stand on the other side at that point, and the listeners will hear and recognise that.
And in any reasonable size public forum, at least one of those listeners will be so grateful that you have stood up here when they didn't feel safe to themselves. And several others will know people who are trans and one binary, and they too will be grateful that you've spoken up, you may find that that other people speak up alongside you.
But what's most important is that people who are saying things which are transphobic, who are opposed to other people expressing their own gender identity, people who are behaving like that need to recognise that this is wrong, that this is not acceptable. And so a good next step beyond recognising an individual's pronouns and personal choice is to stand up for them, whether they are present or not present, whether they feel confident to stand up themselves or not.
The next thing you can do, and this gets increasingly more challenging, do your research on who you buy from, where you buy, what products, what films, what stories you endorse. Don't give transphobic money. This is harder for a lot of people. It means investigating a little behind the companies you invest in, the books you buy, the films you watch, the music you listen to, just to check, you know, are these people, although you know, they may make great products, but are they using that money to fund transphobia?
And if they are, do you want to be giving them the validity that they get? There are known transphobes who say, well, I'm clearly right because people keep giving me money. And the fact that people are giving them money for the product that they're creating, rather than their views, they see as irrelevant. But as I say, these are increasing steps and there are things beyond this, beyond this that people can do as individuals to help and support people who are non-binary, who are exploring their gender identity.
And I'd be happy to talk about that in the questions. But these are the first three steps that any ally can consider taking. But my talk was really about what can we as a community do? And the first is to think about inclusive language. I am going to be the first to say that calling this not cis, white, men tech rather than women tech is the most lousy title I can think of.
I don't think anybody wants to be defined by being not something. I also think it's a hell of a mouthful, and it doesn't summarise what we're for. But women tech is a very good title. All of the tech women, women in tech, whatever it is, they're all good, clear things that stand up and say, this is primarily what we're about.
What the community needs to think about is how intersectional they want to be. And by intersectional, I mean a lot of the challenges that women face in technology are shared by other low power groups in our culture. So people of colour, people of different races, ethnicities, people of different religions, people with physical or mental handicaps, people of different class even.
I'm not sure, Adriana, where you're from, but in the UK there is still quite a prevalent class structure. That means that I, with my reasonably middle class accent, get on much better than people with working class accents. So there are all sorts of ways in which the communities which are not part of the ruling, I'm trying to find words which apply to it because I love, I mean, my husband's a white man.
But there are a lot of people who are not part of the obvious hegemony, but need the same sort of support as women. And really, and this is why I have a picture of the universe, the question is to the tech women community, why are we here? What are we trying to achieve here? Are we simply focused on people who identify as women?
And then can we double check that we are recognising people who identify women as women, we're not starting to gatekeep, are you a woman or not? That's the first step. And then is there a way to, oh, I'm sorry about the microphone. I've just seen the messages pop up. It's the best I can do with this microphone, I'm afraid.
The, where are they? So the final question is why are we here? Why are we here as a community? How do we want to support people? And then just as a note, you know, it's something that even if there's just like a little note in the small print to say that tech women recognise people who are non-binary and who may experience a lot of the same challenges as tech women as part of their community, just stick it in the small print.
It's a start. And it might be all that's needed. So I deliberately timed this to be 15 minutes so we had a bit of time for questions at the end. There's a question which I always get asked, which I'm happy to roll with because I prepared a slide. But are there any other, I can see questions coming in the chat or comments coming in the chat.
And thank you for that. I'd be happy to talk about more, more inclusivity. But are there any specific questions? Shall I roll with the thing I always get asked? So I always get asked, do we really have to use them? Them isn't part of the thing. Them means plural in English. And actually, before I tackle that, I want to talk about something that happened to me.
We had a bank holiday a couple of weekends back in the UK. And I went all the way across the country on the train to Port Maddox. I got to Port Maddox and I realised that I'd left my wallet on the train, which was like almost a bigger disaster as if I'd left my phone on the train.
And I called the station and they told me there that someone had found it and they dropped it off for me. And they'd not left a name or anything, so I couldn't thank them. I couldn't leave them a note or say thank you. But I was so grateful to them. And I told all of that story and it sounded perfectly natural about somebody, a singular person whose gender I didn't know.
And if you think about that for a moment, it's really, it can be really powerful. Yeah, being one of the boys can be beneficial, but that means that I have to pretend to be a man all the time. And it feels like lying. How do we manage a situation of coming from a non-binary community and how can we face it?
We try when we can. I can see a raised hand as well. I will answer Kavita's question first and then... Oh, yes. Sorry, I can see it. There we go. So a lot of the time I'm educating people, which is hard work. I am in a company which is super supportive of my gender identity. I cannot be appreciative enough for how much support I get from the majority of my company on this.
I think, yeah, two minutes left. I think for each of us who comes from a non-binary community, it's a question again of how much bandwidth we have to both carve out the space that we need in the world and to carve a bit of extra space so that we have siblings who would like to say yes, me too, feel that they've got safe spaces.
And I think managing that bandwidth every day is something that you have to do. But for those of us who are to some extent first in this race at the moment, I think where possible, we should be doing things like I'm doing. And the reason why I'm giving this talk now is to try and forward the debate.
I think a lot of people in the world are very open, very relaxed about the idea of somebody being non-binary. Once they've got over the pronouns, they're pretty good about it. And it makes life a lot easier and a lot more comfortable for us. So being brave, I think, is how we manage and brave as often as we can.
But being gentle with ourselves when we can't be and finding ourselves a non-binary community that we can go back into when we need that support. And we need to be with people who understand us properly. Around to the end of my time. Thank you all for listening. If you want to get in touch privately, that's absolutely fine.
I'm on LinkedIn. I'm Cal Brown on LinkedIn. Thank you. Goodbye.
Transcribed automatically; names checked against the speaker record. Select a time to jump there.
Article based on this talk
What do women-in-tech communities owe non-binary people?
Cal Brown explains non-binary identity, offers three steps for allies and asks the tech women community to decide who it is for.
In short
Cal Brown, a lifelong technologist who came out as non-binary in 2021, argues that the tech women community needs to decide how it will include people who do not fit a single gender box. They offer three escalating steps for individual allies and a set of open questions for communities, from inclusive language to how intersectional a women-in-tech group wants to be. Their main aim is to start a debate rather than settle it.
Key takeaways
There are more than two genders: take time to think about the implications of this.
How does the tech women community want to work with trans and non-binary people?
What small changes make a big difference? Some things allies can do to show support.
A tech career that began with a battle cry
Brown describes themselves as "unquestionably a techie person". They have been a networks director and a software developer, completed a PhD in fibre optics and now work in cybersecurity. Their route into tech mirrors that of many women: encouraged into STEM at school and into engineering 35 years ago, with the promise that within 10 to 20 years the ratio would be 50/50 and an instruction to go and strike a blow for women.
Looking back, Brown is candid about the result: "I'm not seeing that there's any particular difference in the ratios of men to women technology to what they were 35 years ago, but perhaps I made a difference." (1:19)
Brown still feels part of the tech women community, and says their local group has been very supportive. That is exactly why they want the community to think about people outside the most visible minority. They frame the talk as an invitation: "So I don't have any answers on this. I've just got more questions, which is why I want the debate to begin." (2:19)
What non-binary means, and why it is not new
Brown defines being non-binary as having a gender identity that does not conform to the traditional belief that you are either male or female. Gender identity is separate from biology, which matters to a doctor but not to day-to-day work. For some people non-binary is a step towards transitioning, but for many it is simply where they are.
To the frequent objection that non-binary identity is a fashion or a trend, Brown offers history. They cite the pharaoh Hatshepsut, whose reign began in 1479 BC and whose records describe them as male or genderless despite female characteristics. They point to the Polynesian concept of mahu, a third gender, and to the Hijra of South Asia. "It's nothing new." (6:06)
What has changed, Brown argues, is the internet, which lets people who do not conform find others beyond their local area. "I've been able to find words for how I feel, and I've had the confidence that how I feel is as valid as how other people feel, and that I can start talking about it." (6:31) With each generation, more people say they are not comfortable with the gender binary, so the people tech women communities reach will increasingly include them.
Three steps any ally can take
Before any action, Brown asks allies to be honest about their capacity: "Well, we cannot fight all the battles simultaneously." (7:35)
The first step is the most basic: when someone says they are not male or female, use the gender-neutral pronouns they prefer. It takes a change of thinking, but Brown calls it a basic human courtesy.
The second step is to speak out when someone expresses transphobic or anti-non-binary views in a meeting or public forum, if you feel safe and confident enough. The goal is not to change the speaker's mind but to signal to everyone else. "You're taking a stand on the other side at that point, and the listeners will hear and recognise that." (9:15) In any sizeable forum, Brown says, at least one listener will be grateful you spoke up when they did not feel safe to.
The third step is harder: research the companies, books, films and music you pay for, and avoid giving money to people who use it to fund transphobia.
Questions for the tech women community
For communities, Brown starts with language. They reject the idea of renaming women-in-tech groups around who they exclude: "I don't think anybody wants to be defined by being not something." (12:13) Names like women in tech are clear about what a community is primarily for.
The harder question is how intersectional a community wants to be. Many challenges women face are shared by other low-power groups, including people of colour, people of different religions, disabled people and, in the UK, people with working-class accents. Brown asks the community directly why it exists and what it is trying to achieve. If it focuses on people who identify as women, it should check that it recognises them all and does not start to gatekeep.
Their suggested first move is modest: a note, even in the small print, recognising non-binary people who face many of the same challenges as part of the community. "It's a start. And it might be all that's needed." (15:00)
Singular they, bandwidth and bravery
In the Q&A, Brown takes the question they are always asked: do we really have to use they? They answer with a story about leaving their wallet on a train and an anonymous stranger handing it in. Told naturally, the story already uses singular they for a person whose gender is unknown.
Asked how non-binary people can cope with constantly educating others, Brown returns to bandwidth. Those who are early in this space should help carve out room for others where they can. "So being brave, I think, is how we manage and brave as often as we can." (18:37) That comes with a balance: "But being gentle with ourselves when we can't be and finding ourselves a non-binary community that we can go back into when we need that support." (18:55)
Watch the talk
From TechWoman to TechEnbie - the impact of being non-binary in a binary world, by Cal Brown, about 20 minutes: https://www.womentech.net/video/techwoman-techenbie-impact-being-non-binary-in-binary-world
About the speaker
Cal Brown is Lead Security Storyteller at BT, based in Ipswich, United Kingdom, and was drawn into tech in the 1980s by the call for more women in engineering. They came out as non-binary in 2021 and are increasingly active in raising awareness of trans and non-binary issues in tech.
Questions this talk answers
What does it mean to be non-binary?
Is non-binary identity just a recent trend?
What can an individual ally do to support non-binary colleagues?
What can the tech women community do to include non-binary people?
Do we really have to use they for one person?
Drafted with AI from the talk transcript. Editor review pending.
Cite this talk
Cal Brown. "From TechWoman to TechEnbie - the impact of being non-binary in a binary world." WomenTech Network, 2023. https://www.womentech.net/video/techwoman-techenbie-impact-being-non-binary-in-binary-world