How to unlock the value of data for all with data-driven innovation?
Lorrayne Porciuncula20:322023
Data is not oil, and the gold-rush mindset keeps its value locked away
Mexico City was short of space for telecom antennas until the regulator listed public-building rooftops in a system that worked almost like a rooftop Airbnb for private operators. Companies that hoard data like gold miss value like this, while global data debates stay concentrated in the global north. Economist Lorrayne Porciuncula, who leads the Datasphere Initiative, asks how data can be shared responsibly when open and closed are not the only options.
Learn how sandboxes, privacy-enhancing tech and shared governance unlock data value responsibly
Lorrayne Porciuncula, Executive Director of the Datasphere Initiative, argues that data is not oil and needs new narratives, responsible sharing models between fully open and fully closed, and agile governance tools. She calls for a collaboratively governed "datasphere" that includes the global south and bridges the public and private sectors, then grounds the ideas in Q&A examples from Mexico City rooftops and encrypted CO2 emissions sharing.
“Completely open data should not be the only alternative to closed data. There's a spectrum in between.”
“We cannot keep using the same tools and the same old tools to solve new problems.”
What you will learn
Explain why analogies like "data is oil" mislead, given that data is non-rivalrous and can be reused without being depleted.
Map data-sharing options on the spectrum between fully open and fully closed, with traceability and compliance controls.
Consider regulatory sandboxes, protocol-based data commons and privacy-enhancing technologies as agile governance tools.
Recognise how encrypted data pooling lets competitors share sensitive data, such as CO2 emissions, while each benefits from the aggregate.
Frame data work around the goal and the question first, before choosing tools, datasets or visualizations.
Key takeaways from the speaker
Share examples of innovative approaches to responsibly unlock the value of data for all, giving the participants the opportunity to share their own experiences during a Q&A.
Present real case studies from the Datasphere Initiative concerning data-driven development.
Besides sharing knowledge, the session also aims to identify new partnerships to join discussions organized by the Datasphere Initiative to advance the session learnings.
Details
Level
Intermediate
Format
Talk
Technical depth
Introductory technical
For
All career stages
Length
20:32
Published
May 2023
Questions this talk answers
Why is data not like oil?
Data is multi-dimensional and non-rivalrous: it can be replicated and combined in many value chains without being depleted, so analogies taken too literally lead to misguided choices.
How can companies be persuaded to share data they see as valuable?
By showing that partners can create more value from shared data, and by using mechanisms such as privacy-enhancing technologies that pool encrypted data so no single company's data point can be identified while everyone benefits from the aggregate.
What is the datasphere?
It is the speaker's term for the increasingly complex relationship between data, human groups or actors, and norms, which she argues should be governed collaboratively and dynamically.
Should only IT and data engineers create data reports?
No. Engineers know data techniques, but customers and subject-matter experts know which questions matter, so they have something to add to reporting.
How do you get stakeholders to care about data?
Start by asking what the policy, corporate or individual goal is and which questions you want answered, rather than starting with the tool or dataset.
About this talk
Countries around the world are facing increasing pressure to deal with the exponential growth of data production and use and the resulting complex challenges this creates for data governance, data sovereignty, data protection, and inclusion. The role of data to address global challenges has been seen across sectors such as health, climate and education. At the same time, debate on data requires a different approach from traditional policy debates. Different from physical goods and services, data is multi-dimensional with an ever-changing value that is hard to measure. In fact, measuring data’s intrinsic value, or positive and negative externalities, is particularly challenging, given data’s unique properties (non-rivalry, replicability, etc). These trends are forcing actors from government, academia and the private sector to think differently about data and develop new and innovative approaches to support a data society we want to see.
The presentation will present how we can move beyond a polarised and unequal data society and take steps towards a new ambition to responsibly unlock the value of data for all. The presentation will introduce participants to the concept of the “Datasphere” - a new way of thinking about our connected data-driven societies and digital world.
This talk will share examples of collaborations led by the Datasphere Initiative concerning data-driven innovation and development focusing especially on case studies from the global south.
Sandboxes and moonshots for data governance (65 s)
A rooftop Airbnb for telecom antennas (73 s)
Sharing CO2 data without revealing secrets (83 s)
Hello, everyone. My name is Lorraine Persiuncula. I'm the Executive Director of the Data Street Initiative, a nonprofit foundation with a mission to responsibly unlock the value of data for all. I'm honored to be speaking at the Women in Tech Conference today, and I'd like to share some thoughts on what this mission really means and why it matters for our future. I would love if you could introduce yourselves in the chat for those who are watching and also asking questions.
Okay, so today I have five points I'd like to make. The first one is that narratives around data matter. Data is not really oil, nor it is air, water, labor, or legal. Analogies are useful to approach unfamiliar situations, but taking them to literally can lead to new guided choices. Data is multi-dimensional and pretty unique in its characteristics. For one, differently from traditional goods and services, data is non-rivalrous. Some would say data is an asset, also would say that it's critical infrastructure for our 21st century. But the bottom line here is that the world of data is growing and is diverse. It's prone to overlapping modes of classification: personal data, non-personal data, anonymized data. Data can be replicated and combined in numerous value chains without being depleted. Data that can be churned also using new techniques such as private enhancing
technology. And the relation between data, human groups, and norms is increasingly complex. This is what we call the data sphere. Data that is what we call the data sphere. And because it's so complex, we need new words and new narratives often to capture that complexity. And that's what gets me to the second point, which takes us from what data is for what it can do for us. The second point is that it's crucial that we consider how to unlock the value of data for all.
We need to think hard about the missed opportunities from data that is hoarded and not shared. We need more data, access to data, and reusability for use cases such as addressing climate changes or global pandemic. But we also need to strive for maximizing value that is not only economic but also social value, which includes the public interest. And for doing so, we should set a clear goal to establish a more equitable data society that distributes the value created to all. And this gets me to my third point on responsibility or responsibilities. While we need to unlock the value of data for all, we also need to take responsibilities for the use and the reuse of data. Completely open data should not be the only alternative to closed data. There's a spectrum in between. And when I say responsibility, I also mean
that we have to have a responsibility to make more data available for the public interest and to do it responsibly. Within the spectrum of open versus closed and compliance, which is very difficult, there must be a way that we can actually look into opening data, unlocking the value of data in a way that is responsible. So traceability and compliance mechanisms are essential to ensure that data access is appropriately controlled. And this gets me to my fourth point. And here I want to talk about agile frameworks.
We cannot keep using the same tools and the same old tools to solve new problems. We need innovation through agile frameworks that can recognize the international dimensions and the constant updating from complex adaptive systems. There are a number of possible approaches to test. Sandboxes and operational sandboxes or regulatory sandboxes, for example, can be experimental frameworks to test these dynamics of a system and conduct also different impact assessments in a way that is more interactive. A protocols approach, for example, can enable the formation of data commons or data sharing communities with appropriate governance charters to leverage new techniques such as privacy enhancing technologies. But the point is that we need to think with big, bold ideas. We need to think about what are moonshot ideas that can get us closer to creating a
more collaboratively governed data sphere. And this takes me to my last point about coming together to build a collaboratively governed data sphere. This conversation that we have today at the international level is still too siloed and too much concentrated within the global north. We need new voices. We need the global south to be present. And we need this conversation to make a bridge between the private and the public sector. We needed to make a bridge between different stakeholders and have a really multi-stakeholder conversation between different economic sectors and social sectors and society. Because this is one of the key questions of our century. How are we going to come together to design the digital future that we want? And how are we going to manage a system that can responsibly
unlock the value of data for all? For me, this will take building trust and transparency between public and private sectors and creating new governance structures that are bottom up, that are more dynamic, and also recognizing the importance of digital self-determination of individuals and communities, and not only of states. And this will also take testing new tools for collaboration, using mechanisms that are iterative and that are flexible, rather than being linear and static, of really shifting the focus from only the technology solutions to the people, and recognizing that the narratives that we have matter, that they have the power to either alienate people or bring them closer. Within narratives that are able to take in all of this complex hypergraph of vectors, of potential trade-offs, or also the benefits and the costs of unlocking the value of
data for all responsibly, it's not an easy road ahead. And it's not certainly one that we can make it ourselves by ourselves. So most importantly, what we need is narratives that bring us together to build a collaboratively governed data sphere that benefits everyone. And so this is our mission at the Data Sphere Initiative. To make sure that first, that we are talking about these narratives on why data matters, to having conversation about data. But also to making sure that we are pinpointing how to unlock the value of data for all. And that we're looking into the dimensions that are not only economic, but also social. We're also looking into how to do that responsibly, to make sure that we are attuned to the guardrails that are
necessary to prevent any abuses. And also to mitigate the different digital risks that exist. But we're looking at from a perspective that is new, and it's also fresh, in terms of how we can actually do that by building agile frameworks that respond to challenges in a way that is innovative, in a way that can bring different actors together. Because the last point is that we need to manage the data sphere, this complex complex relationship between data, actors, and norms in a way that is more dynamic, and that brings everyone together. And that's what I wanted to share with you today. I would love to get questions from you as well, so that we can have a conversation on why you think that matters, why we should be unlocking the
value of data, what are the different dimensions, and how to think about that in a way that is responsible, and how what this represents in your reality as well. I'd love to use these moments to identify allies, why it matters for your work, for you as an individual, and I'd love to get that conversation started. Thank you so much.
So if you'd like to open the mic and introduce yourself, or speak in a chat, I'm told that we have 10 minutes for an exchange, if that's of interest to you. You can also introduce yourself in the chat, so just ask a question, and I can be more specific about the different projects that I work in. In different countries. We have some exciting things happening where we're working with different policy makers in Africa, but also Latin America, and I have one question in the Q&A.
So I have a question from Elaine Moveney. Thank you so much, Elaine. And she asked me, what do you see is the most useful thing that can be unlocked from data that you have worked with? I think data has the power to really shift our perspective on things, and particularly to shed light on issues that we didn't even know that we were looking for in terms of questions.
I have a very good example when I worked in the telecommunications sector where the regulator, one of the key issues that existed in the city of Mexico was on the lack of spaces for antennas in Mexico City for telecommunications. And what they did is that they brought together information on the available rooftops from public buildings. They put it in a system, almost like a rooftop Airbnb for public buildings, so that private companies could actually rent those rooftops and use to actually close the gap on the number of antennas they needed. And this is a matter of making the data available and public interest kind of solution that was able to bridge this information asymmetry that existed between different actors and also create a sort of revenue for the public sector.
I have a really interesting question from Emma Conley. Thank you. How do you think we can get past how that is seen as a new gold rush? What's the best way to get companies to share something with a large financial value? And I think the problem, as I started saying, is the narratives that we have, it seemed that because it's seen as a scarce resource. Everyone's rushing to get this and they hoard data and they think they're going to make up more money just by keeping data for themselves. But often what happens is that you may have partners who are in the public and the private sector that can not only draw value themselves from this data sets that you're hoarding but also create more value for you. And it's interesting
because here one plus one does not equal two when we're talking about data. There's a very interesting example about data sharing from the private sector also that I'd like to share. And that's the case on the case that we're actually working on and that's on the sharing of data on CO2 emissions. There's new European regulation on scope three that actually requires companies to share the CO2 emissions alongside their value chain. And what happens is that most actors are not willing to share data with their potentially competitors, potential competitors, potential competitors, because this can be industrial secrets around, you know, details on how you are actually emitting CO2. And we're working with a foundation in Germany that came up with a system using privacy enhancing technology where you can actually pull your data
and get the results and get the aggregated using encryption and a specific type of encryption where you put your data in but no one really can pinpoint on that specific data point from a company. But everyone benefits from the aggregate data and intelligence coming out of this which then meets the requirements from the European regulator. And for me that's a brilliant example of how we can actually get past the notion of a gold brush and everyone keeping data for themselves and using new mechanisms which, as I said, they sit in the spectrum between open and closed. And you can actually have mechanisms that can get you to what you want data for and what you want data to do to you and how to share it to unlock that value for everyone. And I think
that's a really good example on how private actors coming together to share data that typically they would not like to share not only contribute to creating more intelligence for themselves exponentially, but also to the society as a whole when you actually have more transparency around CO2 emissions, for example, which is extremely relevant for ESG reporting, for impact assessment, but also for climate change in general.
So thank you so much, Emma, for the question, which is something that we are very passionate about, and that relates to one of the projects that we're doing around making sure that not only leveraging technology, but also creating the governance mechanisms, because often it's not the technology that it's it's the point of tension. It's actually the fact that you can't get lawyers to sit around the room and agree on what can be shared and cannot be shared. And that's what we're working on, on governance mechanisms and templates to help data sharing communities or to be communities to share that data and get out of that loop of narratives, of a gold rush.
And I get another question in the chat. Would you recommend the visualization of data only to be done by IT and data engineers, or would you advise customers to have direct access to data to make their own reporting? I think that customers and subjects always have something to add when we're thinking about reporting, because IT or data engineers, they may be experts on the data techniques in itself, but subject matter expertise is something else entirely, which you need to know for you to understand what you're reporting to, and what are the questions you're asking.
Hello, Lorraine. I'm an IT project manager from Nigeria. How can improve data storytelling really make our stakeholders across different levels to understand why data matters. You mentioned something about social dimension of data in the introduction, how that can be leveraged in the workplace. I think, ultimately, what we're trying to bring with the concept of the data sphere is to make sure that we understand that we are in an ecosystem where we are part of the relationship of data, that we have an impact on it.
And that it's not only data disaggregated to ourselves, but also what data means for us and what we want to do with data. So I would say it's really getting people involved in trying to understand what are the questions that you want to be asking, what is your goal. And, ultimately, it's very easy for us to think, first of all, the tool, rather than thinking of what is our objective.
And I think once you start asking what is your policy goal, your corporate goal, your individual goal, you can try to start asking the questions on the data to see why you should care about it. I think we need to be very intentional about what we're doing with data, rather than just thinking about opening, closing, reporting or not, visualization or not, or what are we actually trying to achieve out of it.
And I think that's the key aspect of it. And I have to say that, for me, as an economist who's been working with ADA for a while, the questions that I asked for the data set and the models that I did only made sense when it was a subject that I cared about. So I think it's not about the data in itself, but the question that you're trying to answer, be it in the perspective of a company or the perspective of a public organization, for example.
So really getting people to care about the why while we're doing that. I read that we have only one minute to go, thank you so much for the questions there's a lot more that we could be talking about this and I love that you you connected and engaged in the chat that's what I wanted from this talk.
I would love to connect on LinkedIn if that's something that you want to continue chatting about wonderful to be part of other women in tech conference and I thank you so much for for joining my short session today. And please be in touch if you're also as passionate about data as I am. So thank you so much.
Transcribed automatically; names checked against the speaker record. Select a time to jump there.
Article based on this talk
Why data is not oil, and how to share it responsibly for everyone
Lorrayne Porciuncula argues that new narratives, agile governance and privacy-enhancing tools can unlock data's value beyond the gold-rush mindset.
In short
Lorrayne Porciuncula, Executive Director of the Datasphere Initiative, argues that the value of data stays locked when organizations treat it like a scarce resource to hoard. She makes the case for new narratives about data, sharing models that sit between fully open and fully closed, and agile, multi-stakeholder governance. In the Q&A she grounds these ideas in two concrete examples: public rooftop data in Mexico City and encrypted pooling of CO2 emissions data.
Key takeaways
Share examples of innovative approaches to responsibly unlock the value of data for all, giving participants the opportunity to share their own experiences during a Q&A.
Present real case studies from the Datasphere Initiative concerning data-driven development.
Beyond sharing knowledge, identify new partnerships to join discussions organized by the Datasphere Initiative to advance the session learnings.
Narratives about data shape the choices we make
Porciuncula opens with the first of five points: the words we use for data matter. Data is often compared to oil, air, water or labor, and she accepts that analogies help people approach unfamiliar things. Taken too literally, though, they lead to poor decisions. Unlike traditional goods and services, data is non-rivalrous. It can be replicated and combined across many value chains without being used up, and it falls into overlapping categories such as personal, non-personal and anonymized data.
"Data is multi-dimensional and pretty unique in its characteristics." (0:32)
She calls this web of relationships between data, human groups and norms the datasphere. "And because it's so complex, we need new words and new narratives often to capture that complexity." (1:32)
Unlocking value for all, and doing it responsibly
Her second point moves from what data is to what it can do. She urges people to think hard about the opportunities lost when data is hoarded rather than shared, for example in tackling climate change or a global pandemic. The aim, she says, should be value that is social as well as economic, and a more equitable data society that spreads that value to everyone.
The third point balances this with responsibility. Organizations have a duty to make more data available in the public interest, and a duty to do so with care. Traceability and compliance mechanisms help ensure access is properly controlled. Above all, she rejects the idea that the only choices are fully open or fully closed: "Completely open data should not be the only alternative to closed data. There's a spectrum in between." (2:02)
Agile frameworks and bold ideas
For her fourth point, Porciuncula argues that legacy policy tools cannot keep up with a system that is international and constantly changing. "We cannot keep using the same tools and the same old tools to solve new problems." (3:47)
She points to several approaches worth testing. Regulatory or operational sandboxes can act as experimental spaces to study how a system behaves and to run impact assessments more interactively. A protocols approach can support data commons or data sharing communities with clear governance charters, drawing on privacy-enhancing technologies. Beyond specific tools, she asks for moonshot thinking about how to get closer to a collaboratively governed datasphere.
Bringing everyone to the table
Her final point is about who is part of the conversation. "This conversation that we have today at the international level is still too siloed and too much concentrated within the global north." (4:52) She calls for voices from the global south and for real bridges between the public and private sectors and across economic and social sectors.
Getting there, she says, will take trust and transparency between sectors, bottom-up and more dynamic governance structures, and recognition of the digital self-determination of individuals and communities, not only states. It also means using iterative, flexible collaboration mechanisms and shifting focus from technology alone to people.
Lessons from the Q&A: rooftops, emissions and the why
The audience questions bring the framework down to earth. Asked what valuable thing data had unlocked in her experience, Porciuncula describes Mexico City's shortage of space for telecom antennas. The regulator gathered information on available rooftops of public buildings into a system that worked almost like a rooftop Airbnb, so private companies could rent them. Making that data available closed an information gap between actors and created revenue for the public sector.
A second question asked how to get past the view of data as a new gold rush. Here she describes work on CO2 emissions data. European regulation on scope 3 emissions requires companies to share emissions along their value chain, yet competitors are reluctant to reveal details they treat as industrial secrets. A foundation in Germany built a system using privacy-enhancing technology and encryption, so companies can pool their data without anyone identifying a single company's figures, while everyone benefits from the aggregate. She notes that the hardest part is often not the technology: "It's actually the fact that you can't get lawyers to sit around the room and agree on what can be shared and cannot be shared." (16:05) That is why her organization works on governance mechanisms and templates for data sharing communities.
On reporting, she argues that customers and subject-matter experts should have a role alongside IT and data engineers, because they know which questions matter. And to a project manager from Nigeria asking how data storytelling can win over stakeholders, she advises starting from the goal: "And, ultimately, it's very easy for us to think, first of all, the tool, rather than thinking of what is our objective." (18:14)
Watch the talk
"How to unlock the value of data for all with data-driven innovation?" by Lorrayne Porciuncula, 21 minutes: https://www.womentech.net/video/how-unlock-value-data-all-data-driven-innovation
About the speaker
Lorrayne Porciuncula is the Founder and Executive Director of the Datasphere Initiative, based in Paris, and an internationalist and economist with over 10 years of experience in digital and telecommunications policy. She previously directed the Data & Jurisdiction program at the Internet & Jurisdiction Policy Network and has worked in international organizations including the OECD.
Questions this talk answers
Why is data not like oil?
How can companies be persuaded to share data they see as valuable?
What is the datasphere?
Should only IT and data engineers create data reports?
How do you get stakeholders to care about data?
Drafted with AI from the talk transcript. Editor review pending.
Frameworks and ideas mentioned
Datasphere
Regulatory sandboxes
Privacy-enhancing technologies
Data commons
Scope 3 emissions reporting
Cite this talk
Lorrayne Porciuncula. "How to unlock the value of data for all with data-driven innovation?." WomenTech Network, 2023. https://www.womentech.net/video/how-unlock-value-data-all-data-driven-innovation