In short
Sarah Chapman, Technical Manager and North Europe STEM Champion at 3M, argues that stereotypes and a failure to connect science to everyday life keep many people, especially girls, out of STEM. Famous role models help, but they are far away. What also matters are the "streetlights": the teachers, mentors, colleagues and volunteers close to home who may be a bit less brilliant than the stars, but are just as important and inspiring.
Key takeaways
- Good ideas can come from anyone, whatever their gender identity, race, age, sexuality, abilities or background.
- People still struggle to relate STEM subjects (science, technology, engineering and maths) to their everyday lives.
- We can all help to address the STEM skills gap through stories, stars and streetlights.
- Research shows that having STEM role models significantly increases girls' interest in these subjects.
Stereotypes are powerful, but they can be broken
Chapman opens with a personal confession: for years she labelled herself "not a runner". She is asthmatic, was teased for running like a robot, and avoided running until she discovered parkrun, a free weekly five kilometre run that genuinely welcomes everybody while records are still broken every weekend. For her, it shows that inclusion and excellence are not in conflict.
The same lesson applies to tech. "Stereotypes are powerful, but they're not irrefutable." (1:04) Her background is in chemistry, yet she does not wear a white coat and does not consider herself a genius. Recalling the IT colleague she worked with as an intern, she wonders whether a woman in that role, a more relatable role model, might have led her down that path. She frames occupational stereotypes as a real business barrier, citing the growing STEM skills gap in the UK and its cost to businesses, and reminds leaders that diverse teams are more productive, more innovative and make better decisions.
The public agrees, but cannot see the relevance
Chapman draws on 3M's State of Science Index, a global independent survey her employer has run for five years. As the speaker cited, over 8 in 10 people believe women are a source of untapped potential in STEM, and 9 in 10 think the world needs more people pursuing STEM careers. Yet more than a third of people globally did not feel their lives would be impacted if science didn't exist.
"So, even after the pandemic, where tech connected doctors to patients, workers to workplaces, grandparents to grandchildren, many people still find it quite hard to relate STEM subjects to everyday life." (3:17) Combined with outdated stereotypes, she says, it is no surprise that many people do not see these careers as being for them.
Stories: STEM needs good PR
The first of her three ways to help is storytelling. Chapman did not enjoy STEM at school until a teacher explained how she had used chemistry at a fruit cordial company to keep the drink's taste consistent even when the harvest varied. That simple story showed her that science could help people.
She believes long familiarity can make experts forget how wondrous technology is. "As technologists, we sometimes focus on the how and the what and we forget the why." (4:17) A would-be doctor, she notes, does not say they want to prescribe treatment; they say they want to save lives. Her advice is to tell interesting, relatable stories in plain words and always communicate the why.
Stars and streetlights
Citing research by Microsoft, Chapman notes that the number of girls interested in STEM almost doubles when they have a role model. Because underrepresented groups are unlikely to find one role model exactly like them, they need "a sky full of stars": visible people breaking glass ceilings in books, on screens and at conferences. When a TEDx reviewer looked at her list of inspiring women, which included the first African-American woman in space, and asked who they were, she saw the problem. "We need more diverse role models and we need to share their stories more widely so that they become household names too." (6:16)
But stars are far away. Closer to home are the streetlights: friends, family, managers, teachers, co-workers and volunteers who are authentic and accessible. "They may be a bit less brilliant than the stars, but they're just as important and inspiring." (7:22) Looking only at the stars, she warns, keeps alive the myth that you must be a genius to work in science.
From ballet to chemistry
Chapman's own route illustrates the point. At 13 she wanted to be a ballet dancer, and everyone called her a natural dancer, but no one ever told her she was a natural scientist. After injury ended that path, she chose science and maths to prove she could do something different. At university she met the "brilliant boffin" myth again and believed she needed a PhD, until she saw a poster of someone who looked like her, in a polar suit beside a penguin, with the line "not all chemists wear white coats". "That poster was enough for me, but not everyone gets to see a poster like that." (8:10)
You have to see it to be it
She closes with a call to leaders. Tech is transforming almost every industry, and passions for sport, fashion or music can lead to roles such as performance analyst, shoe designer or sound engineer. "But you have to see it to be it." (9:04) Her request: share stories, including the less brilliant bits, showcase diverse and relatable role models, and celebrate difference because it drives innovation.
Watch the talk
"Why We Need More STEM Role Models Who Are A Bit Less Brilliant" by Sarah Chapman (10 minutes): https://www.womentech.net/video/why-we-need-more-stem-role-models-who-are-bit-less-brilliant
About the speaker
Sarah Chapman is Technical Manager and North Europe STEM Champion at 3M and a board member at Farnborough College of Technology, who moved from ballet into STEM after an injury and an inspirational chemistry teacher changed her direction. She has won multiple awards as a STEM volunteer, chairs the 3M EMEA Technical Women's Leadership Forum, and advocates for diversity in public talks including at TEDx and on the BBC.
Questions this talk answers
- Why do so many people not see STEM careers as for them?
- What are stories, stars and streetlights?
- Why are famous role models not enough on their own?
- How can tech leaders help close the STEM skills gap?
Drafted with AI from the talk transcript. Editor review pending.