Leading Transformation with a Human Centered Mindset
Erin Buonomo20:062023
Most transformations fail on fear, not on technology
Fear of change is a debt that has to be paid up front, and with 70% of transformations falling short, leaders who treat change as a technology project risk becoming the statistic. Erin Buonomo, Director of Design at IBM Sustainability Software, has spent four and a half years leading her organization through one. What did it take to win over the people inside it?
Get the people-first playbook her team used: balanced lenses, tiger teams and quick-win pilots
Erin Buonomo, Director of Design at IBM Sustainability Software, argues that most transformations fail because leaders focus on technology and neglect the human fear and resistance that change creates. Drawing on her organization's four-and-a-half-year journey, she shows how balanced problem framing, empowered tiger teams, design thinking and quick-win pilots can make people the agents of transformation rather than its casualties.
“Humans need to be the agents of transformation, not just the casualties of it.”
“And we need to think about fear of change as like a debt that we need to pay. It's going to have to be paid up front before you can make genuine progress on these initiatives.”
What you will learn
Recognize fear of the unknown, of failure and of being replaced as the main obstacle to transformation, and plan to address it up front.
Evaluate problems through four lenses (human desirability, business viability, technical feasibility and positive impact) to find the sweet spot for innovation.
Set up small, diverse, empowered tiger teams that prototype constantly and deliver in six-to-eight-week time-boxed projects.
Build momentum with a shared North Star narrative, jointly defined business and human outcomes, and high-impact pilots.
Sustain change by sharing quick wins and lessons learned repeatedly and recognizing the behaviors you want to see.
Key takeaways from the speaker
To develop the right “change muscle” and create a sustainable culture of innovation, you need to start with People.
Think BIG, but start small. Focus on small pilots that promote these new ways of working and addresses specific business problems through innovation.
Incorporate a human centered mindset into your companies DNA. To have sustained success, you need to lead and empower your teams to incubate, innovate and propagate change.
Details
Level
All levels
Format
Talk
Technical depth
Non-technical
For
People manager, Executive, Senior individual contributor
Length
20:06
Published
May 2023
Questions this talk answers
Why do so many digital transformations fail?
Erin Buonomo argues that organizations focus too heavily on technology and neglect the human side, failing to manage the fear and resistance that change triggers. Without managing resistance, buy-in and sustained support are hard to achieve.
What are the ingredients of a successful transformation?
Citing a McKinsey study, she lists committed digital-savvy leaders with skin in the game, investment in workforce capabilities, sustained behavioral and cultural shifts, and clear, frequent communication of the change story.
Where is the sweet spot for innovation?
It sits at the intersection of four lenses: what people desire and need, what is viable for the business, what is technically feasible, and whether the product makes a positive impact on the world.
How should teams be organized to drive transformation?
Her organization created small, nimble, diverse tiger teams empowered to decide and act with less bureaucracy, used design thinking, treated everything as a prototype and ran six-to-eight-week time-boxed projects.
How do you build momentum and win people over during change?
Visualize a North Star narrative, define business and human outcomes with stakeholders, focus on high-impact pilots, and share quick wins, lessons and recognition over and over again.
About this talk
Today's clients expect more. These expectations are rapidly changing and calling for companies to pursue new business models and digital transformation initiatives that improve the client experience and drive future innovation and growth. That being said, 70% of transformations fall short of their objectives, many due to a lack of focus on the human element of the equation.
This session will highlight why human centered design is a critical ingredient to ensuring a more balanced approach to solving complex challenges and implementing successful processes, solutions, and services - enabling you to find that sweet spot of innovation. Learn about a human, design led approach that Erin is taking to drive a transformation journey to better enable clients to adopt new business models while enabling her teams to be more agile, adaptive and resilient.
Hi, everyone. Good morning. Good afternoon. Good evening to you all across the globe. I'm Erin Buonomo, and I'm here hosting this session with you today. It's an honor to be here and to be kicking, helping kick off the events this week. So just before we get started, if you have any questions throughout, we got 20 minutes, but if you have any questions throughout, please feel free to put them in the chat and I'll try to hit them at some point during the presentation. So I'm sure all of us have had to embrace uncertainty and change at some point in our careers, personal lives, and in business as well. And I know that embracing this and being open to opportunities has helped me evolve in new and better ways, although it may have been scary at times. So when we think about it, transformation is like a metamorphosis of this crumpled paper into this origami butterfly, right? It helps us emerge stronger and more capable
than before. And businesses are undergoing significant changes to embrace digital transformation. This is a big focus across multiple different industries. But what's really driving this need to evolve and change? First is a few things, right? Consumer behaviors and expectations are changing. Engagement has become more dynamic and technologically enabled, and we expect a wider range of services to be provided quickly and seamlessly and integrated across a variety of different channels. User experience matters. User experience matters more to us than ever before. When you have companies succeeding in creating amazing user experiences, you have the same expectation that you're going to have similar impressive interactions from other companies across all different industries. Second, the impact from market forces is really adding pressure around talent and skills. And there's a work for talent more than ever before, and pressure to upskill and train the next generation of the workforce. And this is all happening,
we're working against a backdrop of continuous technological disruption. We have deployment of technologies like hybrid cloud, automation, AI, and connected devices that are ushering in new opportunities, but they're also adding new risks to businesses, as well as regulatory changes that are transforming industries and reshaping business models. Lastly, there's a growing demand for a greater focus on sustainability and social impact of today's business operations. And it's really forcing companies to be more introspective and transparent about their impact on their products and services. In the technology sector, this changes omnipresent. Companies are investing in technology to help automate their business processes, introduce new ways of working that are faster and more cost-effective. They're looking to improve the client and employee experience, and all focusing on maintaining their competitive advantage and driving profitability. The same companies that are working with these companies to transform are driving their own internal transformations. So at this point, really, transformation is not an option. It's a necessity to future-proof business.
So why am I? So during this time, so during this time, I've worked under three different CEOs, held roles in four different business units and across multiple different areas related to software, from engineering to product management and now design. So you can say that I basically grew up here and I saw a lot of things. I've experienced organizational restructuring. I've been involved with transformation initiatives at large scale, and involved with acquisitions and also sell off of some acquisitions within our company. I've been a I've been a team member and an organizational leader. I've been a team member and an organizational leader. I've been a team member and an organizational leader through some of these experiences. I've also been on the battlefield trying to drive some transformation, but also watching from the sidelines.
And I wanted to come here. And I wanted to come here. And I wanted to come here to share with you some lessons that I've learned. And one of the key success factors that I think is often missing, but it's critical to driving innovative change and transformation successfully. As a current or future technical leader, you may find yourself involved or leading transformation yourself. So my hope is that you walk away with ideas of how you can be a positive agent of change, because it's really clear that you, you know, every single one of you play a crucial role in ensuring that your organizations and the companies that you work for, and the broader community that you interact with are able to keep up with the rapid pace of innovation and change, but do so in a way that is very
human-centric. So we've established that transformation is critical. It's a business necessity. If that's the case, then why do 70% of transformations fail? When you think about that, that's a really sobering statistic. Transformation is more than just adopting new technology or change in the way that you do things. It requires you to rethink old structures, old processes. It also requires a change in mindset. And this is the key point that I want to make here.
One of the biggest obstacles to success is really helping humans overcome their fear and resistance to change. When you think about humans, we're amazing creatures, right? But we're dominated by emotion. And that means that emotions drive our decisions in our behaviors. So we need to change in our behaviors. So we need to be mindful that change is really going to be judged emotionally and everyone reacts to it slightly differently. There's going to be fear of the unknown, fear of failure, fear of rejection, failure, fear of being replaced. And we need to think about fear of change as like a debt that we need to pay. It's going to have to be paid up front before you can make genuine progress on these initiatives.
If the organization that you're involved in. If the organization that you're involved in doesn't manage resistance effectively, it's going to be difficult to achieve buy-in and have sustained support for any initiative or transformation that you're trying to drive forward with. In organizations that focus too heavily on just looking at it from the technology side and neglect some of these aspects of change are going to struggle to achieve their goals. McKinsey actually did a study that said that there's a few ingredients for successful transformation.
One is leadership. You have to have committed digital savvy leaders in place to champion the initiative. And I, when I say committed, I mean, they need to have some skin in the game. The second area is really around investment in building the capabilities for the workforce of the future, really investing in training and education and helping build the skills in your organization to be successful.
The third is around sustained behavioral behavioral and cultural shifts, really fostering a culture that's going to empower people to work in new ways. You need to think about giving your employees a voice in how these changes could and should be adopted, or encouraging and recognizing the right behaviors. And then lastly, and this may seem a simple thing, but clear and frequent communication of the change story to help those impacted understand where the organization's headed, why it's changing, why the change is important.
They need to, humans need to understand how this is going to impact them on a day-to-day basis. So what's the common pattern here? There's a critical human factor at play that is really resonating, and it's important that your employees and your leaders are recognized as having a critical impact on the success of whether a transformation is going to be successful or not.
But it's often underemphasized. Humans need to be the agents of transformation, not just the casualties of it. So I'm here to say that it's time to lead transformation with a more human-centered approach. When you have empathy as a key guiding principle, you're better able to drive both innovation and change forward in uncertain environments by listening, understanding, and appealing to the hearts, minds, and souls of the people, rather than simply ordering a quick jump from the way of the old to the ways of the new.
For the past four and a half years, in the organization that I've been involved in, we've been undergoing a significant transformation ourselves. We have very mature software products that are market-leading products, but we needed to really take a step back and think about how we needed to modernize our technical architecture, as well as our user experience, to maintain that competitive advantage.
We also needed to look to accelerate our output and productivity and eradicate some of the inertia that has been plaguing our teams and hindering our progress. It required a more solid and balanced approach to looking at problems, a set of principles and practices that drive our team's everyday actions, and then results needed to result in tangible outcomes to build momentum so we can scale this new way of working and this new modernized software forward for both our clients and our business partners.
So I'm going to kind of walk you through the approach that we took that was our journey of becoming more human-centered. So first, we started with a more balanced approach when tackling business problems and opportunities. Transformation really should advance the human experience. It's about reimagining how we interact with technology and the world around us. When we tackle a problem, there's a few key elements that many times come into play.
One, you've got to think about it from the people perspective. Are you creating a solution or a service that humans desire and need? You need to look at it from the business perspective. Is it going to be a viable, profitable solution that's going to be aligned to your business goals? You also need to look at it through the technological lens in terms of feasibility.
Are you able to technically implement what you're trying to develop as a solution or bring to market? And then lastly, and this is going to have a growing area, is your impact element. And then essentially, this is your integrity question. Are you making a positive impact to the world you live in through your product or service that you're going to bring to market?
And where you focus is really important. The sweet spot for innovation is the intersection of all four of these. Many times, we were leaning too far on solving problems with just technology and a financial lens without fully understanding the human desire and need that we were trying to address. So we needed to reconsider questions like how our employees were going to react to this change, how is it going to impact our customers, our business partners, our ecosystem, as well as how some emerging technology was going to help us keep up with the evolving expectations of our clients and the industry.
When we took a step back and we were replacing the end user at the center of solving the problem or looking at the opportunity, we were able to have a much more balanced approach, and it enabled us not to over-index on any one element. So the second thing we did was we adopted a set of human-centered principles and practices, and this really shaped the way that we solved problems as a team in our everyday actions.
So our main focus was really putting people first and focusing on the human problems rather than just the technical solution. And this was incredibly important, but we also knew that we needed to invest in the talent of our teams to adopt more human-centered practices and understand what that meant. So we rapidly increased our investment in design and development talent and up-skilled them on practices like design thinking.
We also brought in new leadership that understood the importance of a more human-design-led approach to innovation that really made a significant impact on the focus and investment in the initiative itself. The second area was around creating more diverse and empowered teams, and that was the fuel that was going to help kind of make the magic happen on a day-to-day basis.
So we took a step back and said, you know, we need to create more small, nimble tiger teams, that's what we call them, to accelerate our progress. And these teams needed to move quickly. They needed to be able to share insights or ideas, but also quickly reject or commit to them. And they needed to be empowered to make decisions and act, which was somewhat of a different approach to how teams were operating within our own organization.
And removing sort of bureaucracy and levels of approval to get to make decisions. The other thing we focused on is making sure that our teams were really made up of diverse perspectives, because it enabled us to have a better understanding of any given situation, generate more ideas, look at problems from different angles, and just be more effective problem solvers.
And then the third element was really creating an environment that encouraged restless reinvention. So we leveraged IBM's design thinking framework to help us reframe problems from the end user's perspective. But also, it's a more experimental iterative approach that enabled us to move beyond the way we've always done things. And we had this mentality within our teams that everything was a prototype.
So we were continuously, rapidly prototyping our new ideas, getting them in front of SMEs and stakeholders, getting feedback, getting them in front of clients as well, in order for us to ensure whether we were moving in the right direction. And the last thing we did is we ran time box projects for about six to eight weeks, and this really enabled us to shift towards a more flexible and collaborative fast changing environment and delivering progress in smaller increments.
So we had a set of principles and a framework that we used, but the principles alone aren't the drivers of change and innovation doesn't just happen with just great ideas. So for any transformation to win legitimacy, it needed to quickly prove its ability to deliver tangible outcomes. And you can't do that without really focusing on flawless execution.
And part of flawless execution is building momentum. We needed to get some quick wins to inspire and motivate the organization. So going back to the human element of transformation, we wanted to win over the hearts and minds of our organization to improve our success and be able to scale. And that went beyond just the people that were in the midst of the work day to day.
So the key was making sure everyone understood and collectively owned the change agenda from the leaders down to the individual contributors. So we wanted to take our employees and our clients along on the journey because it brought more importance and tangibility to the work. So we did a few things. We visualized our North Star. Our North Star was the vision of a future from the standpoint of the humans impacted by the transformation, both the employees and the clients.
So we had a series of working sessions, and we crafted a narrative and a video, and we shared that across the organization to be a rallying force for the teams. We also wanted to make sure that it was clear why we were embarking on this journey, how, and how we should be measuring success. And that measuring stick was really important because it enabled us to course correct over time.
So we worked with our stakeholders to really define both our business and our human outcomes that we were driving towards. And we did this collectively together to ensure alignment from the onset. And then lastly, we needed to motivate through progress. Change movements need to prove concrete value quickly. So we focused our efforts on high-impact pilots that addressed specific problems and enabled us to focus on a few critical areas without boiling the ocean.
The big element here, though, is that we made sure that as we were making progress, we shared our quick wins and our lessons learned repeatedly to the organization. We recognized the right behaviors, called out folks that were taking risks or bringing up new ideas, adopting new ways of working. And we also welcomed feedback from the broader organization throughout the process.
So it was really focused on motivating and inspiring with storytelling. I would say the one thing that I would want to emphasize is that we did this over and over and over again. Over-communication is critical in order to making sure people are really fully grasping what is going on and how we're making progress. So just to wrap it up, transformation is never done.
It's an ongoing experience. It's exhausting, yes, but it's exhilarating. I had to keep reminding my team that it's a marathon that we're running. It's not a sprint. We're four and a half years in, and we still have a lot of work to do, but we're moving in the right direction. But we needed to do a few things to really develop that change muscle and create a sustainable culture within our team.
So just to leave you with three kind of key takeaways. One, you need to start with people. We often start with the technology first, but we need to make tech-driven experiences more aligned between our business objectives and the human outcomes we're trying to drive and really optimize what makes those experiences meaningful and relevant to the humans and how we're advancing our human experience, and then use technology where and when it makes sense to amplify and deepen that experience.
Second, you've got to think big, but start small. Know what your North Star is, but focus on small pilots that's going to promote these new ways of working and address specific business problems and get some quick wins in scale. And then lastly, incorporate a human-centered mindset into your company's DNA. You have to have some skin in the game.
You need to lead and empower your teams to incubate, innovate, and propagate change. But you need to expect resistance to be able to normalize the experience. Your goal needs to be to dance with this resistance, right? Find out what's underneath it. Discuss it so that you can work with that energy to move forward, but also continue to learn and adjust as needed.
I will say that success in this new age really requires a new level of resilience and agility that's rooted in responsible, purpose-driven, human-led business practices that are going to drive innovation and competitive differentiation and really help us move forward. Claiming to be human-centric as a person or an organization is easy, but you have to really be able to turn those ambitions into actions, and that's the harder part.
So I challenge you to ask some tough questions. How human-centric is your business, really? Does your company's cultural DNA empower you to drive successful transformation efforts? What is the one thing that you can do today to become a future agent of transformation, and how can you make sure that humans are always put first to drive success? Thank you for your time today, and if anyone has any questions, I'd be happy to take them.
Thank you. You're welcome, Janet.
Transcribed automatically; names checked against the speaker record. Select a time to jump there.
Article based on this talk
Why transformation succeeds only when people come first
IBM design leader Erin Buonomo explains how a human-centered approach turns employees from casualties of change into its agents.
In short
Most transformations fail not because the technology is wrong but because organizations ignore the fear and resistance that change creates in people. Erin Buonomo, Director of Design at IBM Sustainability Software, argues that leaders must put empathy at the center of change, and she shares the concrete practices her organization used during a four-and-a-half-year transformation: balanced problem framing, empowered tiger teams, constant prototyping and momentum built on quick wins.
Key takeaways
To develop the right "change muscle" and create a sustainable culture of innovation, you need to start with people.
Think big, but start small. Focus on small pilots that promote these new ways of working and address specific business problems through innovation.
Incorporate a human-centered mindset into your company's DNA. To have sustained success, you need to lead and empower your teams to incubate, innovate and propagate change.
Transformation is no longer optional
Buonomo opens by comparing transformation to a crumpled sheet of paper becoming an origami butterfly: a process that helps people and businesses emerge stronger than before. She identifies the forces pushing companies to change. Customers now expect fast, seamless, integrated experiences, and once one company delivers an impressive user experience, people expect the same everywhere. Market forces are adding pressure on talent and skills, technologies such as hybrid cloud, automation, AI and connected devices bring both opportunity and risk, regulation is reshaping business models, and there is growing demand for sustainability and social impact.
Her conclusion is blunt: "So at this point, really, transformation is not an option. It's a necessity to future-proof business." (1:59)
Fear of change is the real obstacle
If transformation is essential, why do so many efforts fall short? Buonomo cites the figure that 70% of transformations fail and calls it a sobering statistic. Transformation, she explains, is more than adopting new technology. It requires rethinking old structures and processes and, above all, a change in mindset.
People are driven by emotion, so change is judged emotionally: fear of the unknown, of failure, of rejection and of being replaced. Her framing is memorable: "And we need to think about fear of change as like a debt that we need to pay. It's going to have to be paid up front before you can make genuine progress on these initiatives." (5:30)
She points to a McKinsey study, as the speaker cited, that names four ingredients of successful transformation: committed, digital-savvy leaders with skin in the game; investment in the capabilities of the future workforce; sustained behavioral and cultural shifts that give employees a voice; and clear, frequent communication of the change story. The common thread is human. "Humans need to be the agents of transformation, not just the casualties of it." (8:07)
A balanced lens and the sweet spot for innovation
Buonomo's organization had mature, market-leading software products but needed to modernize its technical architecture and user experience, accelerate output and remove the inertia slowing its teams. The first step was a more balanced way of framing problems through four lenses: whether people desire and need the solution, whether it is viable for the business, whether it is technically feasible, and whether it makes a positive impact on the world, which she calls the integrity question.
"The sweet spot for innovation is the intersection of all four of these." (10:37) She admits her teams had been leaning too heavily on technology and financial lenses without fully understanding the human need. Placing the end user back at the center kept them from over-indexing on any one element.
Principles, people and empowered tiger teams
The second step was adopting human-centered principles and practices. The organization increased its investment in design and development talent, upskilled people on design thinking and brought in leaders who understood a design-led approach. It then formed small, nimble tiger teams built from diverse perspectives, which helped them generate more ideas and look at problems from different angles. These teams were expected to move quickly, share or reject ideas fast and act without layers of approval. "And they needed to be empowered to make decisions and act, which was somewhat of a different approach to how teams were operating within our own organization." (12:26)
Using IBM's design thinking framework, the teams reframed problems from the end user's perspective and worked iteratively. "And we had this mentality within our teams that everything was a prototype." (13:17) Ideas went quickly in front of subject matter experts, stakeholders and clients, and work ran in time-boxed projects of six to eight weeks.
Building momentum through quick wins and storytelling
Principles alone do not drive change, Buonomo says. A transformation wins legitimacy only by delivering tangible outcomes quickly. Her organization crafted a North Star narrative and video describing the future from the point of view of employees and clients, defined business and human outcomes together with stakeholders so they could course correct, and focused on high-impact pilots rather than trying to boil the ocean.
Crucially, they shared quick wins and lessons learned repeatedly, recognized people who took risks or adopted new ways of working, and invited feedback. "Over-communication is critical in order to making sure people are really fully grasping what is going on and how we're making progress." (16:37)
She closes by reminding the audience that transformation is a marathon, not a sprint, and that resistance should be expected and explored rather than suppressed. Her final challenge is about action: "Claiming to be human-centric as a person or an organization is easy, but you have to really be able to turn those ambitions into actions, and that's the harder part." (18:35)
Watch the talk
"Leading Transformation with a Human Centered Mindset" by Erin Buonomo, 20 minutes: https://www.womentech.net/video/leading-transformation-human-centered-mindset
About the speaker
Erin Buonomo is Director of Design, IBM Sustainability Software, at IBM, where she focuses on the design of AI-powered enterprise solutions in the asset management, supply chain and ESG domains and leads a global, multidisciplinary design team using Design Thinking. She has been with IBM for 19 years in roles spanning strategic product planning, organizational leadership and agile product design and development, and holds an MBA from Bentley University and a B.S. in Computer Science from Worcester Polytechnic Institute.
Questions this talk answers
Why do so many digital transformations fail?
What are the ingredients of a successful transformation?
Where is the sweet spot for innovation?
How should teams be organized to drive transformation?
How do you build momentum and win people over during change?
Drafted with AI from the talk transcript. Editor review pending.
Frameworks and ideas mentioned
IBM Design Thinking framework
Design thinking
North Star vision
Desirability, viability, feasibility and impact lenses
Cite this talk
Erin Buonomo. "Leading Transformation with a Human Centered Mindset." WomenTech Network, 2023. https://www.womentech.net/video/leading-transformation-human-centered-mindset