A manager's baseball idiom sent her to the window looking for a park
Told by her first director to hit the ball outside the park, a new immigrant walked to the corner window to search for the park. Idioms, gestures and unwritten rules about hierarchy and deadlines quietly decide who feels included on global teams. Neelam Mohanty, Principal Enterprise Architect at Northwestern Mutual, and co-speaker Anu Pakala ask what it takes to read the cultural lens in the room and adapt to it.
Learn the idioms, gestures and behaviors to watch for, plus tips for building inclusive teams
Neelam Mohanty and co-speaker Anu Pakala of Northwestern Mutual draw on their experiences as immigrants to the United States to show how idioms, gestures and culturally shaped behaviors such as self-promotion, hierarchy, feedback and views of time can be misread at work. They then share tips for integrating into a new culture and for building teams where everyone feels included.
“So while you might be thinking that this colleague has a poor work ethic, they might actually be trying to get consensus on their side of the fence with other colleagues before they send you a consolidated response.”
“When you let your coworkers know that you didn't understand something or you don't know about a certain topic, they're more than willing to help you.”
What you will learn
Recognize idioms and sports metaphors that may not cross cultural lines, and ask for clarification when a colleague's phrase is unclear.
Check the origins of common phrases such as "grandfather in" before adopting them into your vocabulary.
Attribute coworker behavior through a cultural lens, from silence in meetings to slow email replies.
Draw out quieter teammates by asking for their view, inviting them to lead a discussion or holding one-to-ones.
Plan informal team-building that bridges cultures, such as pairing a cricket viewing party with a baseball outing.
Key takeaways from the speaker
Attendees will leave with increased awareness and strategies for adapting communication, gestures and behavior with a cross-cultural lens
Managers will be able to accurately attribute behavior with a cultural lens
Organizational leaders will leave with strategies for developing training and learning programs that not only build awareness, but also bring about change in behavior
Details
Level
All levels
Format
Talk
Technical depth
Non-technical
For
All career stages
Length
24:48
Published
June 2023
Questions this talk answers
What is cross-cultural intelligence?
It is the ability to recognize, understand and adapt your verbal and nonverbal communication and behavior based on the cultural lens you find yourself in, here focused on business settings.
Why might a colleague abroad take days to answer an email?
In cultures where time is seen as cyclical, the colleague may be building consensus among stakeholders before sending a consolidated response, rather than showing a poor work ethic.
Which workplace behaviors vary most across cultures?
The speakers highlight self-promotion and personal branding, notions of hierarchy, personal space, direct versus indirect feedback, and linear versus cyclical views of time.
How can someone new to a culture integrate at work?
Be vulnerable about what you do not understand, stay curious, observant and adaptable with a growth mindset, and connect with colleagues through shared human experiences.
What can team members do to include colleagues from other cultures?
Notice who speaks less and draw them out, explain in-group topics so others have a way in, create informal team-building opportunities and share learnings with each other.
About this talk
A diverse workforce brings different skills, perspectives, and backgrounds. It is statistically proven that such companies exceed the median financial return in their industry. The benefits of diversity are only truly realized when they are partnered with inclusion and belonging. Diverse teams that cross national borders are becoming the norm with increasing globalization and expanding remote work in technology. An inability to understand and adapt communication and behaviors to cultural context can lead to certain employee groups feeling marginalized or excluded from work related networking events. We are women leaders in technology and were immigrants to America a couple of decades ago. Using personal examples from our experiences such as when managers asked us to "knock the ball out of the park" or "to do Monday morning quarterbacking", we will provide tips and help attendees with strategies to build "cultural intelligence" to allow them to relate and work effectively in diverse teams. These strategies will contribute to engagement and collaboration at an individual, team, organization and societal level.
Searching for the park in "hit it out of the park" (62 s)
The troubling history of "grandfather in" (88 s)
Slow email reply or consensus building? (79 s)
Welcome to our session on mastering the art of cross-cultural intelligence. I'd like to introduce my co-speaker and myself. I'm Neelam Mohanty and my co-speaker is Anu Pakala. We are both women leaders who work at Northwestern Mutual and we work in their engineering solutions delivery within the technology function. Today, we're here to talk to you about the art of mastering the art of cross-cultural intelligence.
As my co-worker, Anu, is presenting her slide, we'll move on to the first one after this slide. And the first thing I'd like to talk about is what is cross-cultural intelligence and why is it important to you? To us, cross-cultural intelligence means the ability to recognize, understand, and adapt your communication, both verbal and nonverbal, and behavior based on the cultural lens that you find yourself in.
And specifically for this presentation, we are going to focus on that cultural lens from a business setting. Why is this important to you? In today's day and age of increasing globalization and remote work, it's inevitable that you're going to find yourself interacting with members of your work team who come from a different cultural upbringing and heritage than yours.
And this is going to be universal, irrespective of whether you're an individual contributor, a leader, or a leader of leaders. It's important to develop language and behaviors that cross those cultural boundaries because this will help you succeed in a problem-solving context over and across your regular problem-solving, and it is definitely correlated to business success. Now, we'll also move on to the next slide. Before we go into specific verbal and nonverbal behavior and communication, let's talk about again why it's important.
We spoke about globalization and we spoke about also increasing remote work, but it's also important to understand and attribute the behaviors of your coworkers appropriately. Have you ever seen a co-worker who appeared standoffish, but really they were struggling to speak in meetings, or they might have been struggling to build relationships with senior colleagues in the organization because they came from a culture where that was taboo.
It's very important to be able to give those individual co-workers or those individuals the right tools or learnings to be able to succeed in their day-to-day work. And it's also important as a manager to be able to attribute that behavior and communication appropriately. Now, I would ask the attendees, if you have any questions, please feel free to use the Q&A tab that you see over here, and towards the end of our presentation, I and Anu will address your questions.
But what we're going to do next is, I'm going to actually tell you experiences that I encountered as an immigrant into the United States a couple of decades ago. And hopefully you'll learn about my experiences and then my colleague Anu is going to work you through some strategies on how to really adapt cultural intelligence. So let me give you some examples of verbal communication, when I was new to this country, my first director called me and asked me to hit the ball outside the park.
And I quickly went to the corner window and started looking out searching for this elusive park that everybody but me understood and knew what where that park was I had no clue what ball they were talking about. And of course, it was much later that I realized it was a baseball idiom. And that wasn't the only one that I got exposed to as a new immigrant right sometimes I was asked to touch base I was asked to be a pinch hitter on a project that was running late I was asked to provide.
An estimate a ballpark estimate. An estimate. And it didn't even end with baseball, it went on to football and boxing right sometimes in football metaphors I would hear of people being Monday morning quarterbacks are doing Friday night football, or sometimes I'd be asked to run interference when a project was fumbling. Or make sure that it hit its end goal post and the list goes on so you can imagine a confused and worried me when I was a new immigrant just trying to navigate my way through all these metaphors.
And in terms of verbal communication it's not just American metaphors that you worry about if you had a colleague who comes from the other side of the Atlantic where cricket is a popular sport. They might tell you that they're on a sticky wicket, which the equivalent metaphor in baseball would be, hey life has thrown me a curveball if they're just encountering a difficult situation.
In baseball we might say you've hit a home run and in cricket they might tell you that you've hit a six. But the interesting thing in the cricket metaphor is that that phrase hit the ball for a six, which is the highest score you can get by a single touch of the bat is actually used in the opposite context.
So it might be used as an you know hey when I heard the news of their breakup I really felt like I'd been hit for a six. And so, even though the metaphors are similar in different sports across the Atlantic their usage and the context and how they're used can be very different. And it's important to not just be aware of when you're using these phrases and be aware that the intent might not be crossing through to your intended audience.
That's important, but it's also equally important to be aware that when they are using phrases that might be local to their specific culture, that you understand their intent and interpretation and if not ask them for clarification. Let me give you another example that will really bring home the importance of knowing the cultural context. Again, in one of my earlier jobs, very early on, my director asked me to grandfather him in for a project when a new rule was passed.
And I went to a co worker and asked him, well, how do I contact this director's grandfather and why is he bringing his family member into our work. My co worker just burst out laughing and he told me, no, no, no, no, this has nothing to do with his actual grandfather. It's just a phrase and it just means that he's asking you to give him an exception for the new rule that was just passed.
And that was that or so I thought I started incorporating this phrase into my vocabulary because I was trying to fit into this country. But later on, as I started researching the origins of this phrase, I learned that it had its origins in American slavery. And after the Civil War, seven states in the southern part of US had enacted statutes that allowed specific voters to get an exemption to poll taxes or literacy tests if their grandfathers had voted prior to the Civil War.
Well, because African Americans had not been eligible to vote before the Civil War, they obviously were not able to get these exemptions, so it was another way of just giving, you know, allowing American slavery to continue and disenfranchising for black voters. When I learned the origins of this phrase, I made a conscious choice to stop using it, but I had I didn't know I might have been offending somebody not knowing what I was saying, thinking it was just a cool phrase to use.
And so hopefully this example really strikes home the importance of understanding the cultural context of your verbal communication. Now we're going to take some examples of nonverbal communication, the first one that you see on the screen here is when you bring your index finger close to your thumb, and this usually is a symbol of okay in America.
But in Brazil, but in Brazil, it's actually a very vulgar symbol. In fact, President Nixon got booed while using it in Brazil, and in France and Belgium, it means to be worthless. The other example we have here is a common thumbs up or a thumbs down, which commonly signifies approval or disapproval in America or Rome. But in the Middle Eastern countries, it's a crass insult.
So depending on the cultural context, nonverbal communication and gestures can also have a very different meaning. Let's now talk about behaviors, and you can see on the right side of the screen you've got specific behaviors that again vary based on your cultural upbringing and how you've been raised. The first one I'd like to talk about, which is very personal to me, is self promotion and branding.
I grew up in a culture where I was taught to be modest, and my values of humility told me that I really shouldn't be touting my personal accomplishments. However, when I came to US, it was expected personal branding self promotion is an expected part of your career. And in my initial performance reviews when I was more junior, the feedback I would always get is you're doing great work, but you really need to make people aware of it.
It took me a long time and a lot of coaching to learn that self promotion or personal branding was really a way of making others recognize my unique contributions that I brought to the table, and also a way of controlling the perception they had of me. And so I learned to incorporate self promotion or personal branding into my behavior, but I still print internally whenever I do it.
The second one and really important one is the notions of hierarchy. The second one is the one. Certain cultures have a very well defined notion of hierarchy that is difficult to break. And that you'll find that more common in the Eastern cultures as compared to the Western cultures. And in the Eastern cultures, if you've been taught as a child to just not speak up and there are authority figures like your parents or teachers in your presence or even bosses, just do as you're told and put your head down and do work.
It can be very difficult to change that ingrained behavior when you move to a culture where the notion of hierarchy is less is less ingrained right and then you're actually expected to not just build relationships with senior colleagues or senior leaders, but also to voice your opinion and talk to them freely when they're at the table. And so how do you give individuals who have been raised in a more hierarchical culture, the tools and learning to be able to appropriately make the change and affect the change in their behavior so they can go on to have a successful career in a less hierarchical culture.
The third behavioral aspect I'd like to talk about is this construct of personal space. Have you ever noticed that how far you stand from someone is a direct notion of their cultural upbringing. I come from India, and it's a highly populated country, right, we just surpassed China to be the most populated nation in the world. And so there's not that notion of personal space and social situations, you know, it's perfectly okay to brush by other people to touch other people as you're walking by.
But there's a but there is a notion of a personal space when you're interacting with individuals of the opposite gender, and then there is an invisible personal space that comes into play. So the interesting anecdote I have here is when I came to America in the initial days and you know colleagues or acquaintances would go and give me a hug in the hallway.
If they hadn't seen me for many days, if they hadn't seen me for many days, that felt so foreign to me. It felt like my personal space was being violated. Of course, now I give person I give hugs to people all the time. So that just shows you my journey of maturing and being culturally acclimatized to this country.
The other thing that I, you know, had to learn in America was just leaving that personal space and walking by people. And sometimes people would tell me, excuse me, even though I wasn't touching them. And it took me some time to recognize that there's an invisible personal space that I need to keep track of and not invade in.
Let's talk about the fourth behavior, which is direct feedback or indirect feedback. Have you ever noticed that there's people who will give you to the point, succinct feedback? Exactly. You'll get to hear exactly what they mean to say. But then there's other people who will talk in really flowery language. They will hint at what they mean, but they'll be very passive about it.
And you'll never get to hear directly what they really want to say. You'll have to guess or interpret it. And again, I found that's a function of cultural upbringing. You know, some cultures, they're just taught to be nice, right? Even if you didn't like something or you want to give someone direct feedback, which might actually help them in their coaching.
In some cultures, that's a complete no, no. You just hint at it and you hope the other person can interpret what you're trying to say. Let's talk about time and how time is viewed as linear or cyclical across different cultures. Especially in Eastern cultures, time is more cyclical. But in Western cultures, time is very linear. There's deadlines.
There's milestones. And so imagine the situation. You're working for a global company and you send an email to a colleague who's half across the world, expecting to get a response in a day. And when you don't get a response for a day, even two days, you might start questioning the work ethic of this colleague, thinking that they're just not paying attention to their work.
On the other hand, this colleague lives in a culture where time is cyclical and they need to manage time with other competing priorities. And in this colleague's mind, it might be more important to maintain harmony and get consensus amongst a group of stakeholders before they respond to your email. So while you might be thinking that this colleague has a poor work ethic, they might actually be trying to get consensus on their side of the fence with other colleagues before they send you a consolidated response.
And this can lead to, you know, as you can imagine, misinterpretations and poor problem solving across the different cultures, unless you had a very good understanding of how the cultural lens plays in here. So hopefully these examples, both for verbal communication and nonverbal communication and behaviors that you've now learned are different based on different cultures, have opened your eyes on how important it is to master the art of cultural intelligence.
And now I'm going to turn this over to my colleague, Anu Pakala, who will walk you through some strategies to grow and adapt your cultural intelligence based on situations. And again, I'd say if you have any questions, please feel free to post them in the Q and A tab. Also, we'd love to hear your comments as you're going through this presentation.
If there are questions, we'll try to address them in the last few minutes of our presentation. Now back, now to you, Anu. Thank you, Neelam. I hope, you know, many of you got a chuckle out of some of the examples Neelam shared. You know, that's what happens when we're going through it. It's very confusing. But when you look back, some of these are definitely a cause for some laughter here.
So now that Neelam has shared some of those situations which made us feel like we couldn't connect as closely with our coworkers as we would like, where I want to now take this topic is what did we do with that situation? How did we adapt and what are some tips that, you know, we want to share? And also, as Neelam mentioned, hear from you through chat or later on as to whether any of these resonated with you or if you have additional tips.
So with anything, you know, it starts with an awareness of we were feeling a certain way, like we couldn't integrate. So having that awareness, then the next thing is, what do we want to do about it? Do we care enough, you know, to do something about it? For Neelam and I, we felt like we needed those deeper connections with the people we're working, because it leads us to better engagement, better motivation, and more important than anything, just makes us feel better.
So here are some tips that we tried. So the first one is being vulnerable. When you let your coworkers know that you didn't understand something or you don't know about a certain topic, they're more than willing to help you. Many years ago, there was a project that we completed successfully, and the team was planning a celebration. So they were thinking about going to a place which has really good beer.
So I shared that I don't drink beer. And then they said, well, we'll take you to a place which has really good beer, as well as really good root beer. So I was a little puzzled, but I went along with it. And then later, during the course of that evening, I realized that root beer is actually not a beer, and a root beer float is ice cream floating on top of that root beer.
I had a great time. I learned something new. If I had not shared my, you know, the fact that I didn't like beer, I may just have decided not to go that evening, and I would have missed that whole experience. So many such examples where, you know, we can share when we feel like it's something that, you know, we're not familiar with or that we don't understand.
The second tip is being curious, being observant, and adaptable. When we talk about the concept of growth mindset, it's all about that learning versus knowing. And I think that's the same concept we can bring to cultural intelligence. And I think that's the same concept that we can do. And I think that's the same concept that we have.
So I think that's the same concept that we have. And that's the same concept that we can do. That's the same concept that we can do. We can do some of those human experiences of ups and downs. And when we lean into those and connect to other people through those commonalities, some of these differences that seem so challenging are not challenging anymore.
So now where we want to take this topic to is that, you know, the first half we really discussed about situations where maybe we were feeling a little left out. And what are some things that we did to integrate better? Now where we want to take the topic to is that we also have a role to play in creating that inclusive environment.
So just like we have situations where we may have felt left out, we may also be in situations where we are the people who know the topic or we are the people who have others and we have something in common. And there may be a few others who don't. So it's also on us to now make sure that we are not contributing to making others excluded.
So some of the same things that we talked about in terms of integration are also the things that we also need to watch out for when we are trying to create that inclusive environment. So as an example, being observant. So if you have, you know, teams where certain people are, you know, talk more, and then there are certain people who talk less, being observant of that, and then maybe drawing out some of those less communicative folks.
So by just asking them, hey, what do you think, or asking them to lead a discussion or maybe having a one on one of them so that you can draw them out a little more and make sure that they are not feeling excluded. The second is kind of complementary to the growth mindset where there we were talking about how we can look for opportunities to learn.
Similarly, we can also look for opportunities to educate. So I have many teams where a pattern that I see is that, you know, there are a lot of young men and they're talking about video games as an example, just as well, you know, team, team bonding. And then there may be, there may be a few female engineers who, you know, they're not into video games or it's one of the topics that they do not know much about.
So typically what happens is some of these people are not involved in those, in those bantering or, you know, before the meeting start chats. So in those situations, what I advise my team members to do is that you can still bring some of those other people along by a simple thing like explaining what the video game is about.
How do you win it, you know, saying, okay, you know, I'm doing, I did really well today. So that the next time, those other team members at least have a lead in or an avenue to ask a question. How did the game go? Or, you know, just having some way of inclusion, making them inclusive. The next step is something which is so simple, but yet so powerful, which is the team building opportunities.
Many years ago, this is almost a year ago, India was in the World Cup cricket final. And it was a Monday and we were all really distracted. So one of the managers noticed that and he actually created a viewing party for us. We had a great time. And then a week later, we went and watched a baseball game and then discussed the differences.
And it was one of the best team experiences we ever had. So looking for ways to create those opportunities to interact informally outside of work is a great way to create that inclusive environment. Lastly, which is what we're doing here, is sharing our learnings with each other so that we can piggyback on that and then not really know what we do.
So now we come to the key takeaways. So if you're feeling, and we're just going to wrap up because we are over time. So Anu will just wrap up with the key takeaways. So if we are, if you are feeling alone or lost, then, you know, our takeaway is that you're not alone, but at the same time, you do have to make an effort.
It is also upon each of us to create that inclusive environment. And lastly, and most importantly, there's only one thing to take away. It is connecting as humans, because that makes it all so much simpler. So with that, here are some of, if you're interested, here are some of the references that also talk about this topic and our LinkedIn profiles.
And then I see we have some. All right, I think we are done then. Thank you all.
Transcribed automatically; names checked against the speaker record. Select a time to jump there.
Article based on this talk
Why cultural intelligence decides who feels included on global teams
Two technology leaders who arrived in the US as immigrants show how idioms, gestures and unwritten norms get misread, and what colleagues can do about it.
In short
Neelam Mohanty and her co-speaker Anu Pakala, both technology leaders at Northwestern Mutual, argue that cross-cultural intelligence is a working skill every professional needs as globalization and remote work grow. Drawing on their own early years as immigrants to the United States, they show how idioms, gestures and culturally shaped behaviors are easily misread, then share practical ways to integrate into a new culture and to make sure others are not left out.
Key takeaways
Attendees will leave with increased awareness and strategies for adapting communication, gestures and behavior with a cross-cultural lens.
Managers will be able to accurately attribute behavior with a cultural lens.
Organizational leaders will leave with strategies for developing training and learning programs that not only build awareness, but also bring about change in behavior.
What cross-cultural intelligence is, and why managers need it
Mohanty defines cross-cultural intelligence as the ability to recognize, understand and adapt both verbal and nonverbal communication, and behavior, based on the cultural lens you find yourself in. In a world of distributed teams, she says, everyone will work with colleagues from a different cultural upbringing, whether they are an individual contributor, a leader or a leader of leaders.
The practical stake is attribution. Behavior that looks like a personality trait may be a cultural norm: "Have you ever seen a co-worker who appeared standoffish, but really they were struggling to speak in meetings, or they might have been struggling to build relationships with senior colleagues in the organization because they came from a culture where that was taboo." (2:07) Managers who read that correctly can give people the tools they need to succeed.
Idioms that do not travel
Mohanty's own first months in the US were full of sports metaphors. Asked by her first director to hit the ball outside the park, she went to the corner window looking for the park. Touching base, pinch hitting, ballpark estimates, Monday morning quarterbacking and running interference followed. She notes that cricket cultures have their own versions, and that the same image can carry the opposite meaning: in cricket, being hit for a six can describe receiving bad news.
Her most pointed example is the phrase "grandfather in." When a director used it, she asked a coworker how to contact the director's grandfather. "My co worker just burst out laughing and he told me, no, no, no, no, this has nothing to do with his actual grandfather." (6:21) She adopted the phrase until she researched it and learned, as she explained, that it traces back to post-Civil War statutes in southern states that exempted voters from poll taxes or literacy tests if their grandfathers had voted before the war, which excluded Black voters. She stopped using it. The lesson works both ways: check what your phrases carry, and ask for clarification when a colleague's phrase is unclear.
Gestures and behaviors shaped by upbringing
Nonverbal signals vary too. As Mohanty cited, the OK sign is vulgar in Brazil and means worthless in France and Belgium, and a thumbs up can be an insult in Middle Eastern countries.
She then walks through five behaviors. On self-promotion, she says: "I grew up in a culture where I was taught to be modest, and my values of humility told me that I really shouldn't be touting my personal accomplishments." (9:00) Early performance reviews told her to make her work visible, and coaching helped her see personal branding as a way to shape perception. She also covers hierarchy, where people raised to stay quiet before authority must learn to speak freely with senior leaders; personal space, from unexpected hallway hugs to invisible boundaries; and direct versus indirect feedback.
The fifth, time, may matter most for global teams. Where time is linear, a two-day silence can look like poor work ethic. Mohanty offers another reading: "So while you might be thinking that this colleague has a poor work ethic, they might actually be trying to get consensus on their side of the fence with other colleagues before they send you a consolidated response." (14:01)
Integrating: vulnerability, curiosity and common ground
Pakala picks up with what the two of them did about feeling disconnected. It starts with awareness and deciding that deeper connections are worth the effort. Her first tip is vulnerability: "When you let your coworkers know that you didn't understand something or you don't know about a certain topic, they're more than willing to help you." (16:48) Admitting she did not drink beer before a team celebration led her colleagues to choose a place that also served root beer, and she discovered the root beer float.
Her second tip is to be curious, observant and adaptable, bringing a growth mindset of learning rather than knowing. (Part of this section is lost to a recording error.) She returns to the idea that shared human experiences of ups and downs make differences feel less challenging.
Building inclusion for others
Pakala then turns the lens around: anyone can be the insider. "So it's also on us to now make sure that we are not contributing to making others excluded." (20:32) She suggests noticing who speaks less and drawing them out by asking their view, inviting them to lead or meeting one-to-one. On her teams, when conversation centers on video games, she encourages people to explain the game so others have a way into the chat. Her favorite example is a manager who organized a viewing party when India reached the cricket World Cup final, followed by a team trip to a baseball game. "So looking for ways to create those opportunities to interact informally outside of work is a great way to create that inclusive environment." (23:23)
The closing message is simple: if you feel lost, you are not alone, but you have to make an effort, and everyone shares responsibility for inclusion. "It is connecting as humans, because that makes it all so much simpler." (24:10)
Watch the talk
The Art of Mastering Cross-Cultural Intelligence, Neelam Mohanty (with Anu Pakala), 25 minutes: https://www.womentech.net/video/art-mastering-cross-cultural-intelligence
About the speaker
Neelam Mohanty is a Principal Enterprise Architect at Northwestern Mutual with more than 20 years in technology across delivery leadership, architecture and operations, and she has written a blog and a Kindle book on cultural intelligence. Her co-speaker Anu Pakala, Senior Director, Engineering at Northwestern Mutual, leads a team of over 100 engineers and mentors in the company's Asian and Women's Employee Resource Groups.
Questions this talk answers
What is cross-cultural intelligence?
Why might a colleague abroad take days to answer an email?
Which workplace behaviors vary most across cultures?
How can someone new to a culture integrate at work?
What can team members do to include colleagues from other cultures?
Drafted with AI from the talk transcript. Editor review pending.
Frameworks and ideas mentioned
Growth mindset
Linear versus cyclical time
Cite this talk
Neelam Mohanty. "The Art of Mastering Cross-Cultural Intelligence." WomenTech Network, 2023. https://www.womentech.net/video/art-mastering-cross-cultural-intelligence