Unlocking business impact through digital transformation
Grace Andrews20:302023
An app that unlocks the gym door is not digital transformation
As the speaker cites, about 70% of digital transformation initiatives fail, even as spending reaches $3.25 trillion in 2023. Grace Andrews, Principal Product Evangelist at Equinix, scrapped her whole talk after a Sunday in her brother's smart gym, where an app opened the doors and the treadmill ran its own programs. Drawing on Philips and Netflix, she asks what separates the few that succeed from companies that only digitize.
Get four guiding questions and four people pillars for transformation that actually lasts
Grace Andrews argues that digital transformation is the intersection of technology, necessity and timing, and that most initiatives fail because companies merely digitize instead of changing how they work. Using Philips, Netflix and her brother's smart gym, she shares a question-led framework (what, who, why, how) and four people-centered pillars for transformation that builds long-term competitive advantage.
“And I believe that digital transformation is actually the intersection of technology necessity and timing.”
“But there is no tool on planet earth and there is no flexible framework ever created that's going to take the place of deep transformation.”
What you will learn
Distinguish digitizing (adding digital tools) from digital transformation (changing how the business works) using concrete examples.
Apply the what, who, why and how questions to map your current state, your target state and the roadmap that fills the gaps.
Spot when necessity and timing signal a pivot, as Philips and Netflix did years before the payoff.
Plan measurable action items and benchmark against competitors and peers in your industry.
Build the people conditions for change: clarity, transparency, trust, incentives for learning and active listening.
Key takeaways from the speaker
What digital transformation means, the tools needed to start the digital transformation journey, and the applicable models
How technical transformation can become a framework for creating approachable, inclusive technologies throughout a company to enhance employee experience, productivity and business operations
Best practices and technical solutions that support digital transformation
Details
Level
Intermediate
Format
Talk
Technical depth
Non-technical
For
People manager, Executive
Length
20:30
Published
June 2023
Questions this talk answers
What is the difference between digitizing and digital transformation?
Digitizing means taking on digital applications without changing the framework of the business. Transformation merges those tools with market opportunity, timeliness and necessity to build long-term competitive advantage.
Why do so many digital transformation initiatives fail?
As the speaker cited, about 70% fail, and she argues the reason is that companies digitize to stay in the game rather than truly transform.
What questions should an organization ask before transforming?
The what, who, why and how: who the company is and who it is trying to become. Pick the questions that make sense for you and that create more questions, including ones you cannot yet answer.
Which tools should a company use for digital transformation?
Andrews says tools should be whatever works for your company and team, but no tool or framework replaces deep transformation, which takes people, patience and fearlessness.
What makes transformation work beyond technology?
Four pillars: being crystal clear and transparent to build trust, betting on the house by incentivizing learning and curiosity, listening more than talking, and using improv's yes-and to improve.
About this talk
Digital transformation is more than just the technology that powers a company; it’s a holistic approach that impacts the technological stack, team practices and overall culture of an organization. Given that digital transformation requires a companywide commitment, organizations must assess all work streams and operations to prioritize the digital initiatives that will create the strongest business impact.
In this session, Grace will discuss the definition of digital transformation, the tools needed to start the digital transformation journey, and the applicable models used by various companies worldwide. Attendees will learn how technical transformation can become a framework for creating approachable, inclusive technologies throughout a company to enhance employee experience, productivity and business operations. Grace will bring this framework to life by highlighting what works for her teams, best practices in the market and technical solutions that support digital transformation. She will also share use cases demonstrating common challenges Equinix has seen across its customers and partners and discuss how they were able to approach these challenges across products, technical teams and overall strategy.
Awesome. Well, everyone, welcome to Unlocking Business Impact Through Digital Transformation. My name is Grace Oressi Andrews, and I am a senior manager for solution marketing here at Equinix. And I'm really excited today to talk to you about digital transformation. Why don't we go ahead and get started? So, to get started, we're, of course, going to start with our definition. So, let's talk about precisely how we define digital transformation.
Well, sorry about that. It's seeming to not let me be able to progress to the next slide. Just one moment. Sorry about that. What is a technical talk without a little technical difficulties? Awesome. So, let's go ahead and talk about the definition of digital transformation. Digital transformation is the process of exploiting digital technologies and supporting capabilities to create a robust new digital business model. Now, this definition is quite, one could say, dictionary. And it comes from the Gartner Glossary. And it's one that can apply to many verticals and have many ways in which it's interpreted. So, I thought, instead of standing by this definition, which I do agree with, that we could actually maybe talk about transformation in the wild and talk about it in story. So, let's actually talk about two use cases of digital transformation that I think
went well, or at least defines what I believe to be business and digital transformation. So, I want to tell you the two stories. One is about Philips. So, Philips, a lot of us might know Philips for their work with light bulbs, right? It's a company that was started in 1891 in the Netherlands, family owned and run for over 130 years. And fast forward to 2014. In 2014, Philips decided that they were going to do something that was quite new.
So, quite experimental and quite groundbreaking. And that's, they were going to divide up their company. They were going to create Philips Lighting, which is now Signify. And they were going to have Philips, as we know it today. And Philips began to embark on a journey towards healthcare, applications, healthcare, smart tech, and healthcare components. Well, fast forward to 2020. And it's the beginning of the global pandemic. And Philips is standing at a really interesting interesting intersection of timing, necessity and ability. And so Philips is actually able to help create a new ventilator that they're able to mass produce at scale quite rapidly that have biosensors embedded within them that allow for medical professionals to offer safe care to the most highly contagious COVID-19 individuals.
individuals. Now, this is only possible because six years earlier, Philip decided to make that split. And even though it was a very, you know, for some people shocking, maybe unpopular decision, they made it because they understood that where they were was not where they wanted to end up. Let me give you another example. And that's with Netflix. I think we all know about the streaming service provider Netflix at this point. But for those of you who may not be as familiar, Netflix started off as a DVD rental website in 1998, right as DVDs were entering the market in Asia. And what they understood the problem to be was that you couldn't get the kinds of videos that you wanted when you wanted them as soon as you wanted them. And you were inconvenienced by having to go to, you know, a VHS or movie facility. And so they decided that they were going to bring it to the consumer in their
home. Now let's move to the present. And Netflix currently has award-winning shows scripted and non-scripted documentaries. They've even been nominated for Oscars. And they're a content conglomerate with a digital infrastructure and a cloud capacity to rival Amazon Web Services and Google Cloud compute. I think it goes to show you that digital transformation, especially when we're talking about it inside of business can mean so many things.
And especially when we're talking about it inside of business, especially when we're talking about it inside of business, especially when you understand that a big piece of the puzzle is knowing when it's time, when it's time to pivot, when it's time to move on, and when it's time to try something new. So I want to show you a more personal story. And that's about me and my brother. So my brother and I are like most siblings. He's five years older than I am. And we all slate between being arch nemeses, being best friends. He's my biggest cheerleader and sometimes my greatest bully. And I love him dearly.
And this past weekend, he's my brother. And this past weekend, he dragged me out of the house and insisted I come and see his gym. And he has a private sports facility training building here in Tennessee called TLT Sports Performance. And he wanted me to try out a new treadmill and look at his new recumbent bikes and also give the thumbs up or thumbs down of the new layout of his gym.
And so I begrudgingly went, mostly because I was reworking this talk at the 11th hour and decided to scrap everything I had in order to start and build something new. And so my brother was like, let's go anyway. So we go and we're talking. I, of course, am obliged to walk on the treadmill, which is a smart treadmill with a flat screen, touch screen panel, pre-programmed workouts.
It's actually quite impressive. And then, of course, I look at the bike and I look at the layout and we start talking about digital weights, such as tonal, which is a digital weight system, as well as things like the mirror, which allows for you to train with a reflexive surface that shows you a trainer and lets you see yourself at the same time.
Now, I know you're probably thinking, well, what's this got to do with digital transformation? And honestly, that's a great question. And I'm going to answer it. So by spending time with my brother in his gym, when we first got there, he actually didn't have the keys to get into his building. He needed to unlock the keys or unlock the doors by using an application, an application that lets you open your doors from wherever in the world you might be in case you or someone else gets locked out.
So when we got in the gym, when we got in the gym, another application on the treadmill that allowed for you to pick a variety of programs, more so than what's normally on a traditional treadmill. And it really got me thinking about what digital transformation is. And I reworked my definition of digital transformation based on the interaction inside that gym on Sunday.
And I believe that digital transformation is actually the intersection of technology necessity and timing. I think you've actually got to have all of the above in order to be able to begin to ask yourself the questions and create the frameworks needed in order to transform technology. So let's talk about what that actually means in application, right? So the way that Netflix and Philips were both able to take technical know-how and merge it with an opportunity in the market as well as long-term vision.
And I think that that's a big component of it. It's being able to understand that to get from point A to point B, you have to be able to push the needle a little further than your peers. So let's talk about what the current state of things actually are. So the current state of things as we know it are actually quite varied, right?
The state of digital transformation has a lot of data around it. And I'm not going to spend too much time discussing every one of these data points. But the data point that I actually do want to look at or the two data points that I want to look at are the last two on the right. So $3.25 trillion, that's the number in monetary currency of spending on digital transformation in 2023.
And 70%. Now, this number really means a lot. And it got me thinking about why things don't always work out the way we believe. And this number is the percentage of digital infrastructure and digital transformation initiatives that fail. And this is quite a high percentage. It means that only 30% of those who undergo a process of transformation are actually going to be successful.
And so the question actually then becomes, well, why? Why are people not more successful? And I actually think that the answer to that lies in this quote. And so we see here that Linwad and Mani wrote an article for the Harvard Business Review where they say the former is mostly about enabling business as usual and staying in the game, while the latter is about building real long-term competitive advantage to succeed.
And what they're talking about is digitizing versus digital transformation. Now, what is digitizing and what actually is the difference? Digitizing is when you take on digital applications without necessarily changing the entire framework of your company, your business, or your organization. And so a way to look at it is with my brother's gym. Yes, he has an application that opens the door.
Sure, he has smart technology, smart equipment, and is at the cutting edge of reform inside of wellness. But what does that mean for the way in which he sets up the gym, the way in which he creates his programming, the way that he utilizes new modalities for wellness? And that's what digital transformation is. It's the merging together of these worlds.
It's saying, yes, we have the tools and we have frameworks that we're applying, but we also understand that we've got to actually leverage market opportunity and timeliness. And, you know, the cousin of timeliness, which is necessity in order to create long-term competitive advantage. So that actually takes me to my next point, which is, well, then what are effective tools and frameworks that can be used inside of your transformation process?
So let's talk about that. And before we talk about the tools, I actually want to talk about the framework. So this is a framework that I created, and it was inspired by Harvard Business Review's The Five Fronts of Digital Transformation in the Middle Market, which is by Doug Farrin and Anil K. Makhaja. And, you know, Doug and Anil, which I'm saying that like they're old friends, they're not, but, you know, I feel quite familiar with this article now that I've spent some time with it.
You know, they say that what you actually want to know what you're selling, how you're producing it, how you're selling it, how you're supporting it to your IT backbone, and who is supporting it for you. And as much as I agree with those tenets that they have built, I actually think that what you really have to do is you have to ask the right questions.
So I took a bit of their framework, and I built this one, and I'm calling this, you know, the four guiding principles. And the four guiding principles are the what, who, why, and how. And these are the questions that I believe you've got to ask yourself in order to understand what is actually happening in your company in the present, and identify what it is that you want to build in the future, and then create a roadmap that fills the gaps.
Now, here's the catch. When you go to ask these questions, and not all these questions are going to be applicable to your organization or your business endeavors, but you pick the questions that make the sense for you, the most sense for you. And you also pick the questions that create more questions. You know, that's something that sometimes we're afraid of in the business world is, well, what happens when we ask a question that we don't know the answer to, right?
If we were lawyers, we would say, no, you never ask the question you don't know the answer to. But since most of us, some of us are not, you know, legal counsel, I would say ask the questions you don't know the answers to. And inside of the unknown, inside of those gaps are actually where you are going to start to build the solutions that leverage the tools and the frameworks of the future.
And so what you really want to know when you go to ask the what's, the who's, the why's, and the how's is who you are as a company and who you're trying to become. And that's so important. A lot of companies, we don't have the luxury of digging deep into these kinds of questions every day. But if you're serious about your digital transformation and you don't want to just digitize, you want to actually push yourself into transformation, you're going to have to not only ask these questions, but listen for the answers.
And sometimes the answers are not going to be ones we like. And sometimes the answers are not going to even exist. And sometimes you're going to have to create the precursor to what it is you wish to build. And that leads me to another point that's really, I think, beautifully illustrated with Philips. And that is these workflows are sometimes, and by sometimes I mean most likely, going to be outside the wheelhouse of the current revenue model and product cycle that you're in.
So we saw that with Philips, right? Most likely, when Philips announced in 2014 that they were splitting up into two bodies, Philips Lighting and Philips, I'll call it Philips Traditional, we probably, it was the first we'd heard of it. But most likely, they had already been having these conversations, asking these kinds of questions, and the answers that they had come up with led them to the idea that they had to separate in order to grow a new branch of the business that they knew would eventually become the full branch of the business, right?
And it's been 25 years since, you know, they've really kind of moved away from lighting. And as we kind of get to that point, they're now beginning to wind down on some of those processes, right? Signify is all on its own. Same thing for Netflix. Netflix started off doing DVDs, but now, and they still do DVDs, by the way.
You can still get a DVD sent to your house from Netflix, but they're also winding down on the DVD rental portion of their business because even though that's the model that had best served them, it's not the model that's going to continue to serve them well. And so these questions are really about asking ourselves what it is that we wish to build, who are our consumers and customers, and what is it that they need.
Necessity, once again, and timeliness are going to be two of your best facilitators in digital transformation. So now that we've kind of gotten a handle on the what, the who, the why, and the how, let's actually talk about measurement and tools. So what I want to say about measurements and metrics is you got to collect them, you got to measure it, and you got to check back in with those measurements.
As you're trying to build this ladder to climb from your point A to your point B, you've got to have measurable action items that you can look back and say, when we tried that, this happened, when we tried that, that happened. And if it's not for your own business, looking at your collaborators, your competitors in your verticals and in your industries to see how they're performing, how they're doing, data is everywhere.
There is so much data being collected. There's really no reason why you shouldn't be able to find data that can really help shape the work you do. So now that we're talking about shaping the work we do, why don't we go ahead and get to the tools portion. So here's my tool slide. I know some of you are probably thinking, oh, okay, well, where are the names or the logos of the tools and frameworks we should be using?
Where can we sign up for them, et cetera? And this is what I want to say. It honestly, I don't want to say it doesn't matter because it does, but tools and frameworks are all about finding what works for your company. What works for your team. What works for your organization. But there is no tool on planet earth and there is no flexible framework ever created that's going to take the place of deep transformation.
And that work begins inside of the organization. You know, that work actually takes people. It takes patience and it takes fearlessness. The thing about Netflix, the thing about Phillips, even my brother is these are institutions, organizations, and people who are not afraid to take a chance. They're not afraid to do something that might be unusual, unpopular in their pursuit of transformation.
And so that's what transformation is really about. Once you realize that it's the people who build transformation, you can decide if you're able to be flexible enough to undergo this, you know, transformation within. So let's talk about what this means beyond technology to wrap up. And that's these four points right here. So I think that, you know, we've got our four guiding principles, but these are really the four pillars of those principles that make it work.
And that's got to be crystal clear. You got to know who you are as a company. You have to know who your employees are. You have to be transparent about the process. You have to make sure that they understand what's going on and you've got to build trust. And once you've done that, you've got to bet on the house.
So what that means is you've got to incentivize learning. You've got to foster empathy. But most of all, you've got to really encourage your employees to be curious, to not be afraid to fail. And then that leads us to listening. They've got to know that no matter what happens during the process, we're there for them and vice versa.
That we're listening to them, talking less, listening more, and using the data to really back it up. And then last but not least, improv to improve. This is my favorite one because if anyone's seen improvisational theater, you know that it's always a wild ride and quite the show. And even if the cast of characters have never met before and the props are completely foreign to them, they're able to leverage the power of yes and and to come up with fascinating ideas that really help everyone shine.
And that's what you want to do. Some of the greatest transformations that exist, that will ever occur, and that will occur next, are direct results of companies being unafraid to take a risk and recognizing the value of necessity. No one can undergo transformation by going small or playing small. Thank you so much for your time today. You know, if anyone has any questions, please feel free to reach out to me at grandrews at equinex.com and on Twitter at Grace Oressi.
I'd love to hear from you. Please shoot me any of your questions that you might have. Love to engage in a conversation. Thank you.
Transcribed automatically; names checked against the speaker record. Select a time to jump there.
Article based on this talk
Why most digital transformations fail, and what the successful ones do differently
Grace Andrews of Equinix argues that real transformation sits at the intersection of technology, necessity and timing, and that people, not tools, make it happen.
In short
Grace Andrews argues that most digital transformation efforts fall short because organizations digitize, adding apps and smart equipment, without changing how the business actually works. In her definition, real transformation sits at the intersection of technology, necessity and timing, and it is built by people rather than bought as a tool. She offers four guiding questions (what, who, why and how) and four people-centered pillars to help leaders close that gap.
Key takeaways
What digital transformation means, the tools needed to start the digital transformation journey, and the applicable models
How technical transformation can become a framework for creating approachable, inclusive technologies throughout a company to enhance employee experience, productivity and business operations
Best practices and technical solutions that support digital transformation
From the dictionary to transformation in the wild
Andrews opens with the Gartner Glossary definition of digital transformation, the process of exploiting digital technologies and supporting capabilities to create a robust new digital business model. She agrees with it, but finds it too much like a dictionary entry, so she turns to stories instead.
The first is Philips. Founded in 1891 in the Netherlands, the company decided in 2014 to divide itself, spinning off Philips Lighting (now Signify) and steering the remaining business toward healthcare technology. When the pandemic arrived in 2020, Philips was able to mass produce ventilators with embedded biosensors that helped medical professionals care safely for highly contagious COVID-19 patients. Andrews credits that outcome to a decision made six years earlier: "And even though it was a very, you know, for some people shocking, maybe unpopular decision, they made it because they understood that where they were was not where they wanted to end up." (3:07)
The second is Netflix, which started in 1998 as a DVD rental website and grew into a content company with award-winning shows and, as she describes it, cloud capacity to rival Amazon Web Services and Google Cloud. Even its founding model is not sacred: "You can still get a DVD sent to your house from Netflix, but they're also winding down on the DVD rental portion of their business because even though that's the model that had best served them, it's not the model that's going to continue to serve them well." (15:22)
A smart gym and a sharper definition
The most personal story comes from a weekend visit to her brother's private training facility, TLT Sports Performance in Tennessee. Andrews had just scrapped her talk at the eleventh hour when he insisted she try his new smart treadmill. They also talked about digital weight systems such as Tonal and the Mirror. Even getting through the door required an app that unlocks the building from anywhere in the world.
That visit reshaped how she defines the subject: "And I believe that digital transformation is actually the intersection of technology necessity and timing." (7:04) Philips and Netflix, she says, combined technical know-how with a market opportunity and a long-term vision, pushing the needle further than their peers.
Why so many initiatives fail: digitizing is not transforming
Andrews points to two figures from her slides, as the speaker cited: $3.25 trillion in digital transformation spending in 2023, and a 70% failure rate for digital transformation initiatives. Only 30%, in other words, succeed.
Her explanation draws on a Harvard Business Review article by Leinwand and Mani that contrasts digitizing with digital transformation. Digitizing keeps a business in the game, while transformation builds long-term competitive advantage. She puts it plainly: "Digitizing is when you take on digital applications without necessarily changing the entire framework of your company, your business, or your organization." (9:25)
Back at the gym, the smart equipment and the door app are digitizing. Transformation is about what those tools mean for how her brother lays out the space, designs programming and uses new approaches to wellness. "And that's what digital transformation is. It's the merging together of these worlds." (9:56)
Four questions that create more questions
Inspired by the Harvard Business Review piece The Five Fronts of Digital Transformation in the Middle Market by Doug Farren and Anil K. Makhija, Andrews built her own model: four guiding principles framed as questions, the what, who, why and how. They help an organization understand what is happening now, identify what it wants to build and create a roadmap that fills the gaps.
Not every question will apply, she notes. Choose the ones that make the most sense, and especially the ones that open up more questions, even if lawyers would never ask a question they cannot answer. "And inside of the unknown, inside of those gaps are actually where you are going to start to build the solutions that leverage the tools and the frameworks of the future." (12:52) Leaders must also be ready for uncomfortable results: "And sometimes the answers are not going to be ones we like. And sometimes the answers are not going to even exist." (13:51)
She adds that the resulting work will usually fall outside the current revenue model and product cycle, as it did for Philips. Measurement keeps it honest: collect metrics, check back on them and look at competitors and collaborators in your industry, because data is everywhere.
People, not tools, do the transforming
Andrews deliberately leaves product names and logos off her tools slide. Tools should be whatever works for your company and team, but they are not the point: "But there is no tool on planet earth and there is no flexible framework ever created that's going to take the place of deep transformation." (17:14) That work starts inside the organization, and "You know, that work actually takes people. It takes patience and it takes fearlessness." (17:46)
She closes with four pillars that make the guiding principles work. Be crystal clear about who you are and who your employees are, and be transparent so you build trust. Bet on the house by incentivizing learning, fostering empathy and encouraging curiosity without fear of failure. Listen more than you talk, and back it up with data. And improv to improve, using the yes-and spirit of improvisational theater to let everyone shine. Her final word: "No one can undergo transformation by going small or playing small." (19:48)
Watch the talk
Watch "Unlocking business impact through digital transformation" by Grace Andrews (21 minutes): https://www.womentech.net/video/unlocking-business-impact-through-digital-transformation
About the speaker
Grace Andrews is Principal Product Evangelist at Equinix, an avid storyteller and entrepreneur who has worked in anthropology and technology for over 15 years and brings a cross-cultural focus to how we interact, teach and develop technology. She holds a Bachelor's in Sociology & Anthropology and International Politics and a Master's in Public Administration, and uses narrative and storytelling as a data collection method that leads to more impactful systems and policies.
Questions this talk answers
What is the difference between digitizing and digital transformation?
Why do so many digital transformation initiatives fail?
What questions should an organization ask before transforming?
Which tools should a company use for digital transformation?
What makes transformation work beyond technology?
Drafted with AI from the talk transcript. Editor review pending.
Frameworks and ideas mentioned
Four guiding principles (what, who, why, how)
Four pillars (crystal clear, bet on the house, listening, improv to improve)
Digitizing vs digital transformation
The Five Fronts of Digital Transformation in the Middle Market
Yes, and (improv)
Resources mentioned
Gartner Glossary
Harvard Business Review article by Leinwand and Mani on digitizing versus digital transformation
Harvard Business Review, The Five Fronts of Digital Transformation in the Middle Market (Doug Farren and Anil K. Makhija)
Cite this talk
Grace Andrews. "Unlocking business impact through digital transformation." WomenTech Network, 2023. https://www.womentech.net/video/unlocking-business-impact-through-digital-transformation