The Business Case for Driving Representation in the Leadership Circle
Carrie Rasmussen18:242023
Nearly half of workers won't seek leadership where leaders lack diversity
She started college as a pre-med student set on becoming a veterinarian and never pictured herself as a CIO until her boss said she would make a great one. Carrie Rasmussen, now CIO at Ceridian, sees the same self-selection at scale: diverse candidates opt out of leadership when no one at the top looks like them. So what breaks that cycle, and what keeps diverse talent once a company has it?
Get three concrete moves for finding, building and keeping diverse leadership teams
Carrie Rasmussen, CIO at Ceridian, argues that diverse representation in the leadership circle is a competitive advantage and that companies must break the cycle in which diverse candidates opt out of leadership because nobody at the top looks like them. She draws on McKinsey research, Ceridian's 2023 Pulse of Talent report and her own career, then gives three calls to action: find your place, lead by example, and hold on to diverse talent.
“It's not just about opening the door. It's about building the leaders who are willing to walk through the door.”
“And why did it take somebody else to tell me that I could sit in that chair?”
What you will learn
Recognize how a lack of visible diversity at the top leads capable candidates to self-select out of leadership.
Evaluate whether an employer's DEI commitment is action or ambition by checking public scores, values and dated targets.
Build representative teams by asking talent partners for varied candidates and talking openly about diversity.
Make the business case for inclusion using McKinsey's four areas: talent, productivity, innovation, and loyalty and engagement.
Retain diverse talent through manager flexibility, personal one-to-ones, development plans and opportunities open to all.
Key takeaways from the speaker
When working from home became the norm during the pandemic, it could have been a boon for women eyeing top tech jobs. Instead, women disproportionately left the workplace because care of children was still left primarily to women. Combatting this requires
To be able to create an inclusive workplace environment, and an engaged and diverse workforce, requires a willingness to be flexible to meet the needs of how people best balance work and home. This means one-on-one conversations, whether virtual or in per
Ensure that opportunities are open to all. This means mentorship, sponsorship, networking and education. I didn’t think about being a CIO until a male colleague suggested it. That’s the value of mentorship.
Recognize that tech jobs are not just about technology to increase diversity in talent ranks. My job as CIO is not just about IT. It is much more about driving business value. Many “tech” jobs are likewise mis-characterized, and so unnecessarily weed out
Details
Level
All levels
Format
Talk
Technical depth
Non-technical
For
People manager, Executive, Mid-career
Length
18:24
Published
June 2023
Questions this talk answers
Why does a lack of diversity in leadership hurt a company's leadership pipeline?
Diverse candidates self-select out when they see no one like them in the leadership circle; Ceridian's 2023 Pulse of Talent report found 45% of workers would not pursue a leadership role in such an organization.
How can you tell whether a company genuinely supports DEI?
Look for companies that publicly measure and share DEI scores, hold transparency and equity as core values, and set bold targets with action behind them, as Rasmussen puts it, action rather than ambition.
What does a company gain from diverse and inclusive leadership?
Citing McKinsey, Rasmussen names four areas: better talent, faster and higher-quality decisions, more innovation, and higher loyalty and engagement.
How do managers hold on to diverse talent once they have built it?
Companies and managers must offer flexibility, get to know people through personal one-to-ones, meet needs such as development plans, and open mentorship, sponsorship and training to everyone.
How can an early-career graduate promote diversity, equity and inclusion?
Show up and know you deserve to be there, then collect public examples of companies doing DEI well and share them from the heart.
About this talk
Has a lack of diversity in a company’s C-suite ranks stopped you from considering a leadership role in that organization? Well, you are not alone.
A vicious cycle of getting diverse candidates to apply to such roles is brewing and companies need to be intentional about changing that.
Data from Ceridian’s 2023 Pulse of Talent Report found almost half of workers (45%) say that a lack of diversity in leadership at an organization would stop them from pursuing a leadership role at that organization. This goes up to 60% for those who identify as racial minorities, and 59% for LGBTQ+ respondents.
Workplaces – in and outside of technology – need to adjust grooming women and minorities for leadership roles and help advance them to the C-suite. The pandemic has proven that people can work and lead from anywhere, and when workplaces embrace that, they make it possible for many more diverse candidates to pursue executive roles.
Carrie Rasmussen, Chief Information Officer at Ceridian, will talk about how workplaces need to adjust to keep the best people – and that includes women – in leadership roles and on track to reach leadership positions.
Three calls to action for diverse leadership (59 s)
Video calls are personal: know your people (48 s)
Speaker 1: For allowing this opportunity to speak with you all today. I've written a great speech to share with you, but I'm hoping this is a bit more of a conversation. I was scrolling through the list of speakers that were on the Women in Technology Global Conference website and I couldn't stop smiling. I looked at all these amazing women, leaders, mothers, mentors.
They all have taken a seat at the table, some of whom which I know personally and have personally helped me in my career. I'm delighted to be here today to talk to you about the importance of driving representation in the leadership circle and how it can create a competitive advantage for organizations. I'm going to start by sharing this question with you. Is today better than yesterday? Will tomorrow be better than today?
Speaker 1: My name is Carrie Rasmussen and I am the Chief Information Officer at Ceridian. Ceridian is a global human capital management software company who is best known for their flagship product called Dayforce. We provide solutions for human resources, payroll benefit, talent management, all on a single platform. Our company's brand promise is make work life better. Think about that makes work life better.
How lucky am I to come to work every day and be able to live that message, creating diverse and inclusive teams. I've been in the industry, the technology industry for 25 years. I was once asked to share my career and story with a group of women leaders as many years ago. And it kind of caught me off guard because they said, Carrie, I want you to share your story because your career was so perfect.
And I thought about that. It was anything but perfect. And many of you are probably thinking the same thing. Speaker 1: It was filled with steps forward, steps backwards, steps sideways. It was filled with tears, hard work, triumph, failure, and a whole lot of grit. So I felt compelled to talk to these young women and tell them more about my true story.
I don't have a fancy college degree in technology. I was a pre-med major when I started college. I wanted to fulfill my dream of becoming a veterinarian. I was always like an accidental tours, kind of wandering around, hoping that they wouldn't figure out that I didn't have a clue what I was doing. Yes, I had a case of the imposter syndrome.
Some of you know it. As a working mother and wife, I was always challenged with the battle to be present with my family versus flying out to another meeting where I would obviously spend more time on the plane traveling than in the actual meeting. That age-old comment people would say, you can have it both, career and family.
We all know that that's not true. Something always gives. Something always sacrifices. I recall talking with my CIO I was reporting to one day, and he said, Carrie, you're going to make a great CIO one day. That kind of caught me off guard again. I thought I'd never cross my mind to be that I would be a CIO one day.
And why did it take somebody else to tell me that I could sit in that chair? I quickly found myself a statistic. 26% of women in technology, that statistic, and I really didn't like it. In 2010, Sheryl Sandberg gave a moving TED talk on why we have too few many women leaders. She went on to write a bestselling book encouraging others to lean in.
She shared her own personal challenges with gender inequality. In her 2010 speech, Sheryl Sandberg referenced that out of 190 heads of state, only nine were women. Today, in 2023, we have 193 heads of state. Only 13 of them are women. In 13 years since Sheryl Sandberg stood on the stage and told us, we've only added four women to the list.
While the topic of women in workforce and leadership roles has not gone away, the conversation has evolved into taking into account looking at the whole individual, not just gender diversity. In 2020, the DEI and you consulting published that 72 of the S&P 500 companies were including diversity, equity and inclusion, DEI, in their annual reports. Two years later, in 2022, we now see 402 of those companies, including DEI, in their annual reports.
That is an increase of 550% in that short two-year time period. I'm not standing here today telling you that our work is over, despite the football to move on. The issues still exist in every organization today. The lack of diversity in the C ranks stops diverse candidates from thinking they belong. At the same time, we know that diversity is not only good for the individual, it is good for the company.
Research from McKinsey found the greater the representation, the higher likelihood of outperformance. Listen to these two statistics. Companies with more than 30% women executives were 48% more likely to outperform companies with less gender diversity. McKinsey also tells us that companies in the top quartile for being ethnically and culturally diverse are 36% more profitable than those in the bottom quartile.
Of course, there are forces stacked against these diverse candidates from outside racism, sexism, ageism, but we also see those candidates continue to self-select out. Because they don't see other people who look like them in the leadership circle. It's a vicious cycle, and the onus falls on companies to be intentional about changing it. Data from my own company, Ceridian, our 2023 Pulse of Talent report, found that almost half of workers, 45%, say the lack of diversity in the leadership in an organization would stop them from pursuing a leadership role in that organization.
Let's look at that again. Half of the workers said that they wouldn't pursue a leadership role because of how the leadership circle looked. So I found myself asking that same question we started with. Is today better than yesterday? And is tomorrow going to be better than today? So I did what I do. I did my research. I did what every mom would do.
I called upon my kids to ask that question. I texted my son. His name is Tom. Tom is an 18 year old high school graduating senior with a terrible case of senioritis. So I asked him the following question. Why do you think diversity is important in the leadership circle? Now he's sitting in class. His phone should be off.
But of course, he responded with the most haste. And at the moment, I got a dean back saying this. This came from my 18 year old son. It allows for different perspectives and different character traits in order to achieve ideas and goals that are beneficial to everyone in a broad societal context. So I asked him, I said, did you just Google that?
And his response was, no, mom, no Google. I meant it. Of course, that was followed by, do you want anything from Chick-fil-A on my way home? So the point being is that today is better than yesterday. Our call to action is to ensure that tomorrow continues to be better. To get diverse leadership representation in the leadership circle starts with building the catalyst that will propel change.
It's not just about opening the door. It's about building the leaders who are willing to walk through the door. Your call to action today are these three things. Find your place. Get to a company that is actively supports diversity, equity and inclusion. Number two. Lead by example. Don't wait for others to tell you the value of creating a diverse, inclusive team.
And last one, probably the most important and my favorite. Hold on to it. Once you have created it, don't let it go. Create the environment that continues to build the strength and the foundation. So let's take a look at a couple of these. All right. Find your place. Think about where you're at today. Are you in a company that is actively supporting DEI?
Are you in a company who looks for, who is actively publicly measuring and sharing their DEI scores? Companies who have transparency and equity as part of their core values. Companies who are making bold and aggressive statements and targets to foster change and putting action around them. Look for action, not just ambition. And an example from Serenian. We just recently published our ESG report in 23.
And in here are two bold statements I want to highlight. Listen to this. As a company, our goal is to achieve gender parity 50/50 in senior management roles globally by 2025. The second bold statement that we make is to increase underrepresented minorities representation in management roles in the United States by 50% by 2025. I need to call out that both of those were moved up to 25 from 2028.
That is action, not ambition. That is an aggressive, bold statement that is being fulfilled. All right. We talked about number two, lead by example. Don't wait for others to tell you the value of creating a diverse and inclusive team. When you're looking at your own team, make sure you're working with a talent team to bring you a variety of candidates when you're interviewing.
Design your team to have representation. Make it a point to talk openly about diversity and its importance. Educate your management team that is coming up behind you. I think McKinsey does it really well. They tell us that companies devoted to diversity and inclusion at a high level of belonging excel in these key four areas. I think they summarize these well, so let me walk you through them.
Talent. They attract, develop, and retain better talent because they draw from a larger pool of resources. In turn, they are more likely and more prepared to compete within an ever-changing world. The second one McKinsey calls out is productivity. Thanks to a range of backgrounds and perspective, diverse teams have been proven to make faster, quality decisions with improved productivity.
With improved productivity, we're all striving to build high-performance teams. Innovation. With an eye on a wide range of customer markets and shifting trends, diverse and inclusive teams are more creative, innovative, and better equipped to meet customer needs. And the fourth one McKinsey talks about is the one I know I lean into. It's around loyalty and engagement. Inclusive environments with high level of belonging increase employee satisfaction, loyalty, and engagement.
All of which then attract more high performers. And it's a tough competitive world out there to build that talent pool. All right, we've talked about once you build it. You need to hold on to it. Don't let it go. You are building today's talent for tomorrow's leadership circle. And you need to look at what you need to put in place to hold on to those resources, to hold on to that diverse talented team.
So, first flexibility. Not on the part of the workers, but on the part of the companies and the managers. To be able to create an inclusive workplace, environment, and engage in diverse workforce requires the willingness to be flexible to meet the needs of how people best balance work and home. It's the number one thing that candidates are looking for right behind compensation.
Remote work options, which are much more widespread than before due to the pandemic. They're now supporting women's return to the workforce. Knowing your people. We live in a very different world today, and you've got to embrace that. And when you're having conversations with team members, you need to have the one-on-one conversations and get to know other people.
The world has changed. I can't just walk down the hallway and say, "Hey, come to my office. Let's have a conversation. How are things going?" We're usually meeting on video conference. And you don't know how the person on the other side is feeling. It's personal. They invited you into their home. You know, if someone has their background down and you can see their personal life, you may ask them a question to get to know them.
If they have something up, they may not be comfortable around their surroundings. They might be working out of a location that embarrasses them because they can't afford to live in a fancy home. So remember, it's personal when people are inviting you into the workforce to get to know them. Ask the questions. And meeting their needs. Our Pulse of Talent Survey research also found a desire for development plans.
50% of our talent, when asked, that workers want from employers to help them achieve their career aspirations. Make work a safe environment for people to tell the truth about what they need to be successful. And inclusion. Ensure that opportunities are open to all. This means job postings, mentorships, sponsorships, networking, education, training. I hope you've recognized that leadership roles and technology have shifted to focus on building high-performance teams and driving business value.
Everyone's annual goals should have an objective to deliver diverse, inclusive teams. If you are a global company, you are responsible for ensuring your global workforce is included in the conversation. As a technology manager of teams worldwide, as a mom, a woman, wife, I have experienced firsthand the positive impact of gender equity and creation of a fair and inclusive workplace.
Our world would be a better place when the talents and efforts of everyone are embraced to the fullest extent possible. But for that to happen, the way we do things need to change. And it starts by getting more diverse peoples into the higher-up roles. And then showing, not just telling, others that they belong there too. Remember what we started with today.
Today is better than yesterday. Together, we need to continue to ensure that tomorrow is better than today. I want to thank you for allowing me the time to speak with all of you today. Again, my name is Carrie Rasmussen, and I hope you have a wonderful rest of your conference. I'm going to go ahead and answer the one question I have here.
It says, hi, Carrie. Thank you for this session. As an early career graduate, how can I identify and leverage avenues for promoting diversity, equity, and inclusion in the professional pursuits? Oh, first of all, show up. Know that you deserve to be there, right? When you're promoting diversity and equity, it's getting easier in companies. There's a lot of ways you can reference and showcase other companies that are doing this well publicly and open.
So hold on to these examples. Share them. Speak with them from the heart. All right. I'm going to go ahead and wrap up today. Again, thank you for your time today. And again, thank you for everyone for having a wonderful conference in the Women in Technology. There's some great events out there, so please go out and sign up for them.
Transcribed automatically; names checked against the speaker record. Select a time to jump there.
Article based on this talk
Why diverse talent skips leadership roles, and how companies can break the cycle
Ceridian CIO Carrie Rasmussen makes the business case for representation at the top and offers three practical calls to action.
In short
Carrie Rasmussen, Chief Information Officer at Ceridian, argues that diverse representation in the leadership circle is a competitive advantage, and that companies, not candidates, carry the responsibility for breaking the cycle in which diverse talent opts out of leadership. Her answer comes as three calls to action: find a company that acts on diversity, equity and inclusion, lead by example in building diverse teams, and hold on to that talent through flexibility, personal connection and open opportunity.
Key takeaways
When working from home became the norm during the pandemic, it could have been a boon for women eyeing top tech jobs. Instead, women disproportionately left the workplace because the care of children was still left primarily to women.
Creating an inclusive workplace environment and an engaged, diverse workforce requires a willingness to be flexible to meet the needs of how people best balance work and home. This means one-on-one conversations, whether virtual or in person.
Ensure that opportunities are open to all. This means mentorship, sponsorship, networking and education. Rasmussen did not think about becoming a CIO until a male colleague suggested it, and that is the value of mentorship.
Recognize that tech jobs are not just about technology in order to increase diversity in talent ranks. Rasmussen's job as CIO is not just about IT; it is much more about driving business value, and many tech jobs are likewise mischaracterized.
An imperfect path to the CIO chair
Rasmussen opens with a question she returns to throughout: is today better than yesterday, and will tomorrow be better than today? She then dismantles the idea that her own career was perfect. She started college as a pre-med major hoping to become a veterinarian, has no technology degree, and admits to imposter syndrome. As a working mother, she often had to choose between being present with her family and flying to another meeting.
"It was filled with tears, hard work, triumph, failure, and a whole lot of grit." (1:50)
The turning point came when the CIO she reported to told her she would make a great CIO one day. The thought had never crossed her mind, and that still bothers her: "And why did it take somebody else to tell me that I could sit in that chair?" (3:23)
Progress is real, but slow
Rasmussen sets out where things stand. As the speaker cited, Sheryl Sandberg noted in her 2010 TED talk that only nine of 190 heads of state were women; in 2023, she says, 13 of 193 are, meaning only four women have been added in 13 years. She points to growth in companies including DEI in their annual reports between 2020 and 2022, and to McKinsey research, as she cited it, showing that companies with more than 30% women executives were 48% more likely to outperform less gender-diverse companies.
The obstacle she highlights is self-selection. Ceridian's 2023 Pulse of Talent report found that 45% of workers say a lack of diversity in leadership would stop them pursuing a leadership role at that organization. "It's a vicious cycle, and the onus falls on companies to be intentional about changing it." (6:21)
To answer her opening question, she texted her 18-year-old son, who replied that diversity brings different perspectives and traits that benefit everyone. For Rasmussen, that answer shows today is better than yesterday. The job now is to make sure tomorrow keeps improving.
Find your place
Her first call to action is aimed at the individual. "It's not just about opening the door. It's about building the leaders who are willing to walk through the door." (9:02) She urges viewers to ask whether their company publicly measures and shares DEI scores, treats transparency and equity as core values, and backs bold targets with action. "Look for action, not just ambition." (10:01)
As an example, she cites Ceridian's ESG report goals: gender parity in senior management globally and a 50% increase in underrepresented minority representation in US management roles, both brought forward to 2025 from 2028. "That is action, not ambition. That is an aggressive, bold statement that is being fulfilled." (11:15)
Lead by example
The second call to action is not to wait for permission. Rasmussen asks leaders to work with their talent teams to see a variety of candidates and to educate the managers coming up behind them. "Design your team to have representation. Make it a point to talk openly about diversity and its importance." (11:40)
She summarizes McKinsey's view of the four areas where diverse, inclusive companies excel: talent, because they draw from a larger pool; productivity, through faster, better decisions; innovation, because diverse teams are better equipped to meet customer needs; and loyalty and engagement, the one she personally leans into.
Hold on to it
The third call to action, and her favorite, is retention. Building diverse talent today creates tomorrow's leadership circle, so companies must work to keep it. She starts with flexibility, which she says candidates rank right behind compensation. "So, first flexibility. Not on the part of the workers, but on the part of the companies and the managers." (13:44)
She also asks managers to know their people. On video calls, someone's background may reveal their personal life, or hide a home they feel embarrassed about. "So remember, it's personal when people are inviting you into the workforce to get to know them." (15:05) Meeting needs, such as the development plans workers asked for in the Pulse of Talent research, and making job postings, mentorship, sponsorship, networking and training open to all complete her retention approach. In the closing Q&A, she tells an early-career graduate to show up, know she deserves to be there, and share public examples of companies doing DEI well.
Watch the talk
The Business Case for Driving Representation in the Leadership Circle, Carrie Rasmussen, 18 minutes: https://www.womentech.net/video/business-case-driving-representation-in-leadership-circle
About the speaker
Carrie Rasmussen is CIO at Ceridian, where she leads all aspects of global information technology with the objective of creating an optimized infrastructure and data strategy across all operations. An industry veteran with more than 20 years leading enterprise organizations, she was previously Chief Information Officer at The Save Mart Companies and held senior leadership roles at Safeway Inc.
Questions this talk answers
Why does a lack of diversity in leadership hurt a company's leadership pipeline?
How can you tell whether a company genuinely supports DEI?
What does a company gain from diverse and inclusive leadership?
How do managers hold on to diverse talent once they have built it?
How can an early-career graduate promote diversity, equity and inclusion?
Drafted with AI from the talk transcript. Editor review pending.
Frameworks and ideas mentioned
Three calls to action: find your place, lead by example, hold on to it
McKinsey's four areas of diverse and inclusive companies: talent, productivity, innovation, loyalty and engagement
Resources mentioned
Sheryl Sandberg's 2010 TED talk on why we have too few women leaders
Lean In (Sheryl Sandberg)
Ceridian 2023 Pulse of Talent Report
Ceridian ESG report
Cite this talk
Carrie Rasmussen. "The Business Case for Driving Representation in the Leadership Circle." WomenTech Network, 2023. https://www.womentech.net/video/business-case-driving-representation-in-leadership-circle