How to Intentionally Engineer Inclusion™ and Belonging
Meagan Pollock43:132023
Welcoming diversity without changing anything is just forced belonging
Engineering teams often say they want more women and more people of color, then expect newcomers to adapt, shaving off parts of themselves to fit. Former Texas Instruments engineer and engineering education PhD Meagan Pollock argues that this forced belonging fails, and that fixing people instead of systems only reinforces the problem. So what does a leader actually change to build structural belonging?
Learn a four-part inclusive leadership model with prompts, warning signs and strategies to apply
Meagan Pollock, founder of Engineer Inclusion, argues that inclusion requires structural belonging, not forcing people to assimilate, and that change must target root causes in systems rather than individuals. She walks through culture as an iceberg, force field analysis, the interlocking four I's of oppression and a four-part inclusive leadership model (individual, lens, practices, outcomes) with prompts and strategies.
“We're literally shaving off parts of ourself trying to fit into this sort of forced belonging.”
“So privilege is characteristically invisible to people who have it.”
What you will learn
Distinguish forced belonging, where people assimilate to survive, from structural belonging built on their strengths.
Apply force field analysis and root cause analysis before investing in inclusion initiatives, instead of trying solutions at random.
Map how ideological, interpersonal, institutional and internalized oppression interlock in your own organization.
Assess your leadership against four parts: individual, lens, practices and outcomes, using planning prompts and warning signs.
Commit to one immediate action, because awareness alone does not create change.
Key takeaways from the speaker
Inclusive leadership enhances performance, collaboration, attendance, and reduces turnover, and facilitates environments where people feel valued, affirmed, and that they belong.
Inclusive leaders are imperative for creating cultures, schools, teams, and organizations that drive equitable outcomes for historically marginalized and minoritized people.
We can assess and adapt our leadership practices to become more inclusive leaders
Details
Level
All levels
Format
Workshop
Technical depth
Non-technical
For
People manager, Executive, Mid-career
Length
43:13
Published
June 2023
Questions this talk answers
What is the difference between forced belonging and structural belonging?
Forced belonging means adapting and assimilating to fit a space, shaving off parts of yourself. Structural belonging is an asset-driven environment where people can show up as their authentic selves and fit as they are.
Why do well-intentioned inclusion efforts often fail?
Pollock says organizations throw solutions at the wall without first understanding the root causes. She recommends root cause analysis followed by targeted, verifiable interventions.
What are the interlocking four I's of oppression?
Ideological, interpersonal, institutional and internalized oppression, which overlap and reinforce one another. Systemic change requires addressing all four levels, not only fixing individuals.
Is imposter syndrome a personal problem to fix?
Pollock frames imposter syndrome as internalized oppression resulting from systemic external forces, so telling women they have it problematizes the person rather than the system.
What does an inclusive leader do in practice?
She examines her own identity and positionality, thinks systemically about bias, leads with a human-centered and accountable mindset, and practices culturally intelligent communication and inclusive collaboration.
About this talk
Belonging and being valued are fundamental human needs. Each of us can facilitate structural belonging for those around us, which is imperative to create cultures, schools, teams, and organizations that drive equitable outcomes for historically marginalized and minoritized people. To Intentionally Engineer Inclusion™ and belonging, we can learn and employ practical strategies that enhance performance, collaboration, attendance, reduce turnover and cultivate every employee’s well-being and success. This talk examines a four-part, iterative, reflective, and reflexive framework for developing into an inclusive leader.
Forced belonging: the triangle peg in a round hole (62 s)
Stop throwing spaghetti: find root causes first (76 s)
Imposter syndrome as internalized oppression (45 s)
Speaker: All right. Good morning. Good afternoon. Wherever that you are dialing in from today, I see that we've got a few people here. Hopefully we're going to increase our numbers a little bit. If you are here to talk about how to intentionally engineer inclusion and belonging, you're in the right place. And so I'm really grateful that you joined us today for this conversation.
Speaker: My name, allow me to introduce myself. My name is Megan Pollock. I am based in a really small town in Texas. And I actually just recently moved back to the town that I grew up in to be closer to family. And my company is called Engineer Inclusion, and I get to help organizations, institutions, all over the globe intentionally and systematically engineer equity and inclusion into the workforce, into education, while we're really Speaker: We're really being thoughtful of how we're serving our constituents and our students and our clients, and really serving the community as well. And so if you're dialing in with us today, I want to make sure that you have access to this handout. I'm going to have Speaker: This resource shared multiple times throughout the session. And so you'll be able to access this link throughout. So if you can go to engineer inclusion dot com engineer inclusion dot com slash
Speaker: Download, or you can access that QR code there on the screen. And that will give you a chance to download the handouts for today's workshop. And so those handouts, what they look like, I've got a five page PDF that really summarizes the resources that we're going to be talking about today and some of the models. But you'll also find on there some key action items that you'll be able to take away. And then on the right side of the page, there are lots of QR codes that give you an Speaker: And then you'll be able to take away the opportunity to link out to some of the other resources that I've created on my website that you might find useful as you're approaching how you do this work. And so again, I hope that you will download this tool and use it in your practice. And so again, engineer inclusion dot com slash download.
Speaker 1: So because we don't have the chat feature, I want to know who's here with us. So we're going to be using slide out for the next 40 minutes of this session for a couple of different conversation points. Speaker 1: And so if you want to say hello, you can open up your phone, your smartphone, use the QR code reader that's usually in your camera and say hello. You can share your name, your role and your location.
Speaker 1: I know that there's just a few of us here today, but I really love to have your participation in this workshop. Speaker 1: And so if you'll tune in, we'll give you just a second to see if anybody is interested in chatting with me here. All right. We got two people who are, who are up there, who are chiming in. So I'm looking forward to seeing who's here.
Speaker 1: And then we'll dive into it into today's content. Speaker 1: Hi, Ashton. Welcome calling in from Denver. It's good to see you. Hi, Darby. Welcome to you from Raleigh. Speaker 1: Who else is with us today? Thanks so much to Darby and Ashton for being the first to say hello here. Speaker 1: Hopefully Slido is not too new for you, but it is a good tool, especially in this webinar setting.
It allows us to, to still feel present with one another and engage the best way that we can. I'm going to wait till this last person contributes and then we'll, we'll go ahead and move on to the first topics. Maybe not. Oh, Colleen. All right. Hi, Colleen, engineering manager from Indianapolis. So three engineers plus one. We are in good company.
So I am also an engineer by training. I am formally, I guess I'm always an electrical engineer. I used to work for Texas Instruments on their MEMS technology for DLP before going on to get my doctorate in engineering education. So now I get to engineer engineers and engineer environments that help us create places where everyone feels valued, include included and affirmed that they can have the most likelihood of being successful in those environments.
And so I'm really grateful for you all for joining me. And even if you aren't an engineer, we welcome all kinds here. It's just, we do have a critical mass here. So we're going to talk first about belonging. And the first sort of language I want us to think about is that of forced belonging. And I see that my logo is covering the bottom slide there. And I apologize for that.
But forced belonging is really different than the kind of belonging that we're going to be talking about. So forced belonging is this environment where you feel like a square peg or a triangle peg trying to fit into a round hole. Like you are determined to fit in. You're going to do everything it takes for you to be able to fit in.
But in the process of you doing that, you have to adapt, adjust, shift, and really you're assimilating, trying to fit into a space. And sometimes we do this as a survival tactic and we're not even aware that we're doing it. But what happens when we do this is imagine this little triangle peg here as we're jamming into this hole.
We're literally shaving off parts of ourself trying to fit into this sort of forced belonging. This is not the kind of belonging that we're talking about today. We're talking about how do we create structural belonging. So structural belonging is a sense where we get to show up into an environment as our authentic self. It's an environment that is asset driven, which means it's really based on strengths.
It's recognizing what is it that people bring to a space and trying to create environments where they fit, literally where they fit. And so what happens so often within the fields of engineering is that we say, sure, we want more women. We want more people of color. We welcome diversity, but don't expect us to change anything. So come in and do what you can to fit in.
But that's not structural belonging. That's not creating environments that help people succeed. And so we can do that. We can be really intentional about creating environments that allow us to belong. And that's what we're really going to be focusing our energy on. And so why are we even talking about belonging? Well, we talk about belonging because belonging are fun.
We're going to be talking about belonging. Efficacy, which is a self-actualization, the belief that we can accomplish some tasks. And so I want you to think about for a minute what influences belonging. When you think about your experience, as many of you are in engineering, what are some of the things that influence belonging? Whether we're talking about in the workplace or whether we're talking about in your community organizations or otherwise.
One of the things that I've found is that I, I like to, I, I'm a sort of naturalist. I am a naturalist. Like I'm taking like Texas master naturalist program because I love to look at birds. I love to talk about plants. And I love going to those meetings because I get to talk about these things with great emphasis and people's eyes don't gloss over.
Right. But when I started talking about plants and birds with my non plant and birds friends, their eyes just like gloss over. And they're just like, oh, you Megan, like, please not the birds again. But it's that sense of belonging when you're around people who have that same passion that you do and you can get so silly about something.
And so we have these sort of places where we go, where we have that sort of feeling of fitting in, where we have that feeling of being able to not have to hide ourself or like tamper down our love of whatever it is. So I thought somebody was going to contribute on the poll, but we don't have any contributions yet.
Looks like one person still thinking I want to give you a chance to submit. Oh, great. So common interest, a shared experience, your comfort. Like, how do you feel in that space? You have some kind of a shared goal. Right. The whole of these things are things that influence how we feel, how we experience belonging, whether you can bring your whole self.
So you can bring your whole self and you're not having to like jam into those little smaller boxes to try to fit in where you're not adapting. One of the stories I tell and my my TED talk that came out a couple of years ago is as my experience as a woman in engineering. And I talk about how how relieved I was and I didn't realize how much I had adapted and changed just to sort of survive and fit in within within engineering.
But it wasn't until I left that I realized how much I had done to sort of adapt in that space. And it was just that a survival tactic. So now thank you all for sharing and contributing your ideas here. So we're going to connect these dots here and talk about culture. Right. So culture, these are the beliefs, the systems and values that influence our customs, our norms, the practices, those social institutions, as well as the psychological processes in our organizations.
So culture, this shapes our worldview. It shapes how we look at the world. It shapes how we move through the world. It also shapes how we experience and celebrate life. Right. So it's all of those sort of shared ways of knowing and doing and being. And culture and diversity are not always visible. They're not always visible. And so this is a really popularized way of thinking about how we can consider culture.
And so when we look at someone, we can say, hey, they're just like us. Well, maybe they're just like us because we haven't given them a chance to show us what's below the surface with them. Or maybe we just look at them from a surface and just make some assumptions that they're just like us. And we don't see all of those beautiful parts of them that are wonderful and different.
So there are so many different dimensions of diversity. And this list here is absolutely not comprehensive, but some of the different dimensions of diversity are our race, our gender, our socioeconomic status, and maybe our experiences of how we have changed socioeconomic statuses. Our ability or disability, our ethnicity, our citizenship, our sexual orientation, our religion, faith, or lack thereof, our physical attributes, the trauma that we've experienced, our age, our language.
And so when we look at these many dimensions of diversity, again, not a comprehensive list, one of the things, the language that we'll be talking about is using the language of being a marginalized individual. And so a marginalized individual, these people who are, these are people who are consistently confined to like the lower peripheral edges of society or groups because they are different from the perceived norms and dominant cultures.
And so they often experience disadvantages and discrimination that stem from systemic social inequalities and justices. And so some marginalized identities in engineering and tech are women, trans and non-binary individuals, people of color, people who are not heterosexual, people who are disabled, and people who are not Christian. So those are just some, not all, but some of the marginalized identities within engineering and technology.
And so when we think about this iceberg, right, this iceberg of culture, I want us to look and understand how that drives the organization. Because if you take away anything from the session, I want you to take away the systems view. And I think particularly those of us who are trained in engineering and technology, we have, we're taught to think about systems.
And so we can take that same lens to understand the powers and forces on our organization that create those outcomes. So when we look at the culture, there's often this visible culture that we experience. And then there's this invisible culture, this both seen and unseen, right? So even though it's at the waterline, we can still kind of see it sometimes.
But then down very, very deep is this deeply hidden part of the culture of our organizations. And a lot of times this is a really unconscious thing. I think about some of my experience in the industry. I have a friend and she always talks about like how much she's tackling email. Now she's my friend, but like if I only listen to what her job is based on how she talks about her job, I think her entire job is just answering emails, right?
But that's not what her job is, right? She actually manages systemic change for a large chemical chemical plant. And so what's so interesting, though, is that can become a cultural norm of like how many emails did you answer this weekend, right? And it becomes like a competition. I remember when I was working at Texas Instruments, it was within my group.
I can't speak for all groups with the TI. But it was a competition for people to see how much time bank that you had added up, which was like a point of pride to see who hadn't taken the most vacation, who had taken the least vacation, right? So those become cultural forces, right? And then they create those organizational forces, which then produce the outcomes that we see.
So those organizational forces can then become the structures, the rules and the policies. They can then become these patterns of behavior and practice, and then they create the events and symptoms that we see. Now, if we want to talk about change, we have to think about this thoughtfully and understand what are the forces that are with us and those that are against us.
And so a force field analysis, as you may have learned in school, this was created back by Kurt Lewin in the 40s, and it was originally used in his work as a social psychologist. However, today we use it a lot in business for making and communicating like go or no go decisions. The idea behind this sort of force field analysis is that situations are maintained by an equilibrium between forces that drive change and others that resist change.
And so for change to happen, the driving forces must be strengthened and the resisting forces weakened. So when the language I'm using here are the tailwinds, those are the forces for change. So if you were here in this workshop, I bet that you're a force for change, whereas we have lots of headwinds often coming at us forces resisting change.
Now, as I mentioned, I live in Texas, and there is lots of legislation here in my state that is like literally legislating against the work that I do to help, you know, create equitable and inclusive environments. And so there are lots of like big, big forces that are resisting change. And so we have to think about this strategically.
And in order to drive change, we have to understand our data. We have to begin to create some root cause analyses and address those with targeted strategic interventions that are designed to address the root causes. So many of my clients that I've worked with over the last 12, 13 years, you know, everybody has the best intentions, right?
We have the best intentions. We want to create change. But what happens is like we just start, it's like throwing spaghetti noodles at a wall. Like, let's see what sticks and see what happens. And so what I see and what I've learned is that people are investing so much time, resources, money, energy to create solutions, but they've not stopped to actually understand what are the root causes that we're trying to address.
And so this is really an important stop, and one of the key things I do with my clients is doing a root cause analyses, and then we create those targeted strategic interventions that we can then verify. Are we meeting the goal of addressing that root cause, and then evaluating that progress. And so with these change models in mind, I want to give you a minute to think about the very popular Stephen Covey popularized this, but it actually is like ancient Greek stoic philosophy.
But when we think about what we can accomplish, we make progress when we focus on what we can control, and where we can influence, rather than on those things that we cannot. So I want you and you as you're doing this work to always be thinking about what can I control, what can I influence, and how do I really make change from there.
I thought I had a slide here that was going to get your input. I'm sorry it must have not updated here, but I want you to take a minute and reflect before we go forward. I do want you to take a minute to reflect and just not write a jot down on your notebook like what can you control, what can you influence when it comes to intentionally engineering inclusion and belonging.
What are those things that are within your realm of control that you can influence, because what often happens when I think about this work. is that if I get so stuck on thinking about, you know, state legislation that says that my job is problematic. I can't control that right. And at this point in my life, I can't directly influence it.
And so if I get stuck there, I'm never going to make progress. So what I want to do is to be really intentional about investing my energy on those things that I can control. And so I encourage you to take some time to do that. And I do have a resource on my website that is an exercise for this as well.
And so when we think about how all of this plays together is that the input that we have drives the output. The input of our organizations drives the output, our culture of our organization. It predicts the outcome and the forces yield a system and the forces yield a system. So if you're just joining us, I want to encourage you to download the handout, the QR code and the link is there on the bottom of the page engineer inclusion dot com slash download, and you can access that.
And so when we think about these kinds of things, this is going to help us begin to think about the systems that we can begin to change. So I'm going to talk about some big old gnarly words that that sometimes can get misconstrued. But we're going to first talk about systems of disadvantage, and then we'll talk about systems of advantage and how all of these work together.
And then I'll give you a model for how we can begin to address this within our spheres of influence. So first to think about is I want us to think about oppression and oppression. This is a combination of prejudice and power, and these create systems that discriminate against some groups and benefit others. So these systems include racism, sexism, heterosexism, ableism, classism, ageism, anti-Semitism, all the isms, right?
It's all the isms. These are systems of disadvantage that benefit some groups and disadvantage others. And so these systems of oppression, they enable dominant groups. Those are the ones that have traditionally had the most power to exert control over non-dominant groups by limiting their rights, their freedom and their access to basic resources such as health care, education, employment and housing.
And there are four types of oppression, ideological, interpersonal, institutional and internalized. And these four systems, they overlap and interact. They are designed by people and upheld by people. Now, just as we have systems of advantage, we also have systems disadvantage. We also have systems of advantage. So systems of advantage are what we call privilege. So privilege, these are those special rights advantages or immunity that's granted or available only to a particular person or group.
So privilege is characteristically invisible to people who have it. One of the things that has been such a focal point for me at this point in my career over the last many years is that having grown up as a white woman, I really had no concept of privilege. I had zero concept of privilege because I had zero concept of the social structures that create systems of advantage and disadvantage.
And that's because the systems in which I was raised in, for the most part, worked for me. It wasn't until I became, you know, an engineer as a woman working in engineering that I began to recognize I did not have privilege and as much privilege in those spaces. It wasn't until I became one of them. It was an extraordinary moment to me.
And so I offer and share that story not to say like, wow, gosh, I just didn't know very much. It's to say, hey, we've all got to keep learning and growing and doing. But then once we learn about systems of advantage, once we learn about the privileges that we haven't earned, right, what do we do with it?
Right. And so we can begin to create some change. And this privilege that exists, it also operates on the personal, ideological, interpersonal, cultural and institutional levels, thus creating the system of advantage. And so one of the models that I want to introduce you today is the interlocking for eyes of oppression model. And this is in your handout.
And so I encourage you to access it. Let's see. If you look at the PDF, it's on the second page. And then on the third page are all of the resources that that are kind of linked to this and then some specific actions for us to address that. And so in order for us to understand. So this is one way for us to understand how systems of oppression work together.
But to facilitate systemic change, which is our goal, we have to address oppression at all four levels. So the first level is ideal ideological ideological. These are the underlying ideologies that are really foundational to all of the systems that are created, all the isms, right? So there could be ideologies about people's ability, people's expectations about the kinds of future they have.
There are all kinds of ideologies. And then these ideologies become manifested in our interpersonal interactions. So much of the training that has gone over the last decade or so around, around like unconscious bias. This is about interpersonal, the conversations around microaggressions and micro messages. These are interpersonal kinds of messages. It's how those ideologies manifest in our conversations.
And so these, these interactions, then they become institutionalized within our organization. And so once we institutionalize these ideologies. So institutionalized sexism is, for example, is like the pay gap, right? Like that's institutionalized sexism. And so we can institutionalize policies that exclude some people. So if we institutionalize policies that don't honor some people's holidays, but privilege others, right?
That's institutionalized some, you know, around religion, right? If we institutionalize, you know, things that are around socioeconomics, right? So we can institutionalize these, institutionalize these different ideologies. But what happens is we have these three external forces and these three external forces then create an internalized oppression. That once that oppression has already been enacted, it's done, right? If, if someone has become internalized ideologies from their lived experiences, if they have internalized messages, that say, for example, people who experience internalized homophobia, that usually means that they've experienced during their life ideologies that say being a homosexual is bad, right?
Or they've had family members that sort of shame them for them things. So people who are non-heterosexual, they can create internalized homophobia to themselves, even though that's who they are, right? But that means that the oppression has done its job. And what happens so often in our work is that we start, particularly within an education setting, is we start to problematize and say, hey, let's fix the students.
We've got to help build their self-efficacy and help them reduce the sort of ways in which they've internalized these ideologies. But if we do that and we don't change the system, it's just going to keep reinforcing itself, right? So again, to facilitate systemic change, we must address oppression at all four levels. And so how we do that is we have to understand root causes.
And so to understand root causes, and again, most of you are in the tech space, so you fully get this. Root causes, those are those core issues. It's the highest level cause that sets in motion the entire cause and effect reaction that leads to the problem. And so when we think about this from a graphical standpoint, so often we think about and we see the symptoms, right?
We see the chart where I had the iceberg that drives organizational change, right, that had the big arrow. The things that we see, the events and the symptoms, those are things that are a result of not only problems, but those root causes. So oftentimes I hear people say, well, women just aren't interested in that, or they're just not aware of it.
Well, those are problems, but they are not root causes. They are not root causes because we can continue to dig in and understand other ways that operate and drive those problems. So I've got a question to engage you here. I want you to think about for a minute. How do you see the interlocking four eyes at play in your organization?
So you can either participate in the poll or just take a minute to reflect. I want you to think about in what ways do you see ideologies playing out? And in the interpersonal interactions and what ways have some ideologies become institutionalized in your policies, practices and norms? Or in what ways have some of these ideologies and the interpersonal and the institutionalized policies affected people internalized?
You know, maybe you've heard of like queen bee syndrome. If you've heard of imposter syndrome. All that is both of those are internalized oppression that are then enacted back on each other. Right? So imposter syndrome. There's a great Harvard business review article that says, stop telling women they have imposter syndrome, because all you're actually saying is like you're problematizing the person.
But what they're experiencing is simply a result of systemic external oppression. And so that is just internalized ideologies about where they fit into a space. So you've got one person thinking here. And so I'm going to give you another minute. And then we're going to dive into the inclusive leadership model that kind of brings all this back together.
So how do you see the inner locking for eyes at play at your organization? Okay, so we've got a contribution here about Christian holidays or days off work while other religious holidays aren't. Yeah, like that's institutionalized. I don't know the ism for like religion. Like there's an anti-Semitism, but like I don't know the ism that's against religion.
But yeah, so you get the idea just because we don't have just because I don't know the word for it doesn't mean it doesn't exist. So that is a great example. All right. So I want you to take a note to continue thinking about that. You can access your handout so that you can continue to learn about this.
And this has more explanations about each of the four things there. So now let's step forward and talk about inclusive leadership and how all of this connects together. So inclusive leadership. It is so important because it facilitates belongingness. It helps people feel valued. It enhances performance and improves collaboration. It boost attempts. It reduces turnover like it's all great things.
And so to practice inclusive leadership is a model in which we can use to intentionally engineer inclusion and belonging. And so on my website, you can find a free download of this. We have our article is open source, and it's called inclusive leadership development for engineers. And so this is particularly written for educators. But if you're interested in reading it, you can access it again from my website.
And I'm sure there's a QR code on one of the handouts as well. And so now we're going to talk about this model, and that'll wrap us up for the last 10 minutes or so. So the model is for port four parts individual that's looking in lens is understanding the ways in which you look out practices are the things that we do and outcomes are also things that we do.
And in reality, they're all practices, but outcomes are the things that we're striving for. But when we're trying to incorporate this model into our practice, we're really doing all the things all the time, right? And so I want us to learn a little bit about this. And even though we're we've got a tight session today, I hope that you'll take some of the resources and dig a little deeper on my website.
Specifically, you can go to my website and go to engineerinclusion.com/ild, and that's inclusive leadership development. It's just short there. And so it will reroute and allow you to see all of the resources that I have on inclusive leadership. And so I've got my Ted talk is linked there. There is a download. You can download a reflection and discussion guide if you want to facilitate a conversation with your colleagues.
I also have linked to the the resources here for understanding the model. But then this is something we'll talk a little bit about today in the last few minutes is that you can download our inclusive leadership reflection tool with the strength space growth continuum. If you if you like, you can actually just take a little quiz because we all love a quiz, right?
And that will give you a chance to sort of process the data to see if what what level and what opportunities you have for growth. So let's dive in here. So there are four parts of inclusive leadership. And so I'll tell you as fast as I can what each is what it does not look like some planning prompts that you can think about, and then some specific strategies.
And again, all of these resources that we're going to talk about are on my website so individual first is looking at who we are so an inclusive leader understands that social and political context that create their identity and how it biases their perception of an outlook on the world. And so this is a constant journey of self awareness. It's a constant journey of reflection.
It's a constant journey of looking back at your lived experiences and understanding your own ways of knowing, doing and being. And so what this doesn't look like, or when we hear people say things like I'm just here to do a job, I'm tired of being politically correct, or I don't have culture, or I'm not biased. So what does that look like? Right? And so what we can begin to think about and plan is to ask ourselves questions like, and what ways are we collectively encouraging one another to reflect on how our social and political context create and inform our identities?
And what ways are we inviting dialogue that collectively expand social consciousness and explains how our identities bias our perceptions and outlooks on the world? And so some specific strategies that you can employ here is to examine your positionality. I've got a great resource on my website. If you download it now, I will be finishing up a book, a full workbook on it in the next week or so.
Whoever's downloaded it before then is going to get the full book for free. And so I encourage you to access that incorporate some reflection activities into your day and really build that culture of feedback. Now, the next part is the lens. This is understanding how we're looking out. And so the first part of this is, which is what we spent the first half of our workshop talking about today, is that of systemic thinking.
So an inclusive leader considers how systems of oppression and advantage influence their decisions and impact their teams. And so in order to be a systemic thinker, in order to have that, we have to understand and build in a growing understanding of systems of advantage and disadvantage. And in addition to that, we have to find that there is an ethical dilemma of bias.
So this means that we are investigating how our interpersonal and institutionalized biases produce an ethical dilemma that we have to address like it's not acceptable to not right. We have to get that done. So what this does not look like, or when people say things like, hey, women just are interested in careers, tech careers, or they just don't succeed in that they just don't succeed in that type of role, or they didn't ask for more.
That's about the pay gap. So some planning props that we can employ here, or how can we use root cause analysis to reveal inequities our marginalized people face? How are we considering institutional barriers that marginalized and minoritized people face in the workplace? And how are we actively working to remove those obstacles and supplant them with support? And then finally, in what ways are we establishing guardrails that attempt to protect us from biased decisions, policies, and practices?
Some strategies here. Again, these are linked from your resources. We've got to keep learning, folks. We've got to expand our knowledge and awareness. We have to push ourselves to think about things systemically. This often happens when we sort of get stuck in the, well, I'm not biased or I'm not this. We've got to think about the system, and then we've got to keep doing root cause analysis to understand issues of inequity.
So next are the practices, and there are two. So first is human-centered approach. So a human-centered approach means that this leader is working from an asset or strengths-based mindset, recognizing the value and celebrating the beauty of diversity. They intentionally lead with empathy, curiosity, open-mindedness to strengthen the dignity of all humans around us. You can learn more about asset mindset on my website.
And then the second part of this is being an accountable, lifelong learner. Now, I like to sort of split this into two pieces about being a lifelong learner and being accountable. And so here it's so important that we are always accountable for our mistakes, our failures and mishaps rather than deflecting, avoiding responsibility or claiming good intent. That does not respect the dignity of others when we sort of gaslight them and don't say, well, you know what I meant, or that's not really what happened.
We have to acknowledge that and take accountability for our actions, and we have to model that for others. And then we have to continue to reflect on the personal and institutionalized actions and be super committed to learning more about what we don't know, including other ways of knowing, doing and being. So what this does not look like is saying things like, that's not how we do it, or that's not what we meant, or don't be so sensitive.
So some planning prompts to help us incorporate this into our practice are asking things like, how are we shifting mindsets to value and elevate different ways of knowing and doing? How are we celebrating differences? How are we celebrating differences rather than suggesting people hide and avoid them? How are we practicing visible accountability for mistakes, failures and mishaps?
So again, a few strategies, and then we're going to jump to the very last one. We must incorporate activities that encourage curiosity and respect of other ways of knowing and doing. We have to emphasize empathy and accountability as a crucial skill for your team culture. And so finally, the last part of the model to intentionally engineer inclusion and belonging and to build those inclusive leadership practices are that of our outcomes.
And so the outcomes are two culturally intelligent communication and inclusive collaboration. So first, an inclusive leader is attentive to which voices, values, and ways of knowing and doing are present, missing, or silenced. They actively and empathically listen and search for cues to bridge gaps among diverse people. And then inclusive collaboration. That is when a leader actively and equitably engages diverse perspectives and experiences and backgrounds to enrich the collectively shared environment and balances the assumed norms to allow for more authentic engagement.
What this doesn't look like is when someone repeats or rephrases what was said by someone else and gets credit for it. When someone says they didn't see anything, so they must be fine. Or they always go along with what we usually do, so it's not a big deal to operate as always done. So what we can do about it.
And we'll ask questions like in what ways are we actively listening to marginalized voices and striving to incorporate their ideas? How are we evaluating and refreshing our key norms so that more people can authentically engage? And then again, incorporate these strategies into your practice. And so wrapping up the model here, you can learn more about this model.
I've got lots of more extended, longer workshops that you can listen to on my work on my website. And I encourage you to look at the growth continuum and reflection tool to kind of give yourself a benchmark for how you're doing in this process. Now, my final question for you is to think about before you go, I want you to think about what are three things that you learned?
What's two things that you will do differently? And then what's one immediate action item? And I want to give you a chance to share that. And so before you go, we've got a handful of people. I hope that you'll contribute here. I want you to think about what is your one action item? What's the one takeaway before you close your books and move on to another session?
What's one specific thing that you want to take away from this? Maybe it's to just read the handout a little deeper. Maybe it's to click through some of those resources to find something, a specific tool that you'll be able to employ. But I hope that, and I hope that you're doing this with all of your sessions that you attend this week, is making sure that you're taking a moment to really create an action plan because awareness folks is not enough.
We got to take action. And so I'm going to go ahead and, whoops. Alright, so somebody's going to add a recurring reminder to brainstorm what areas of focus are within your control, determine what's in your realm of control, bookmark your website. Oh, yes, thanks so much. I'd love for you to join my mailing list. I am not as good at sending emails as I would like to be.
But I send out like maybe once, once a month. But I always send things that add value. And, and, and so I hope you'll access those. And if you're interested in the, the resource on control, you can search on my website, an activity on sphere of influence. It's possible that it is on linked from this handout as well.
Let me see if it's linked from your handout. Okay. It's not linked from this handout. But again, from my website, you can go to here and just search influence influence. Let's spell it correctly. Influence. Let's try again. And then that should pull that up for you. And so I encourage you to access that resource. Yeah. So where, where does your will intersect with your influence?
So I encourage you to access that there. I also want to invite you to provide your feedback. I'm sure that the organization has a way for you to do this, but I also value your feedback. And so if you go to engineerinclusion.com/thanks, you can evaluate the session. If you're interested in a certificate, I am really slow at getting those done, but I do do them.
Maybe once a quarter or so. And I welcome your feedback. And, and if you have any questions on how I can help you, I really hope that you'll reach out and let me be a resource for you. Thank you so much for your time. If you have questions, do we have any time for that? What time do you have to close the room?
All right. No word from them. I wish I could see and hear you all. There is a Q and a feature. So if you have, ah, so no time up and no questions. All right. Well, thank you all again so much for your time and your energy. And I really hope that you'll reach out and that we can stay in touch.
Thank you all so much. Goodbye.
Transcribed automatically; names checked against the speaker record. Select a time to jump there.
Article based on this talk
Why inclusion fails when organizations ask people to fit in
Meagan Pollock shows how leaders can replace forced belonging with structural belonging by fixing systems, not people.
In short
Meagan Pollock, founder of Engineer Inclusion, argues that real belonging is structural: environments built around what people bring, not spaces they must squeeze themselves into. Lasting change, she says, comes from understanding root causes across the whole system of oppression and privilege, then growing as an inclusive leader through a four-part model of individual awareness, systemic lens, practices and outcomes.
Key takeaways
Inclusive leadership enhances performance, collaboration and attendance, reduces turnover, and creates environments where people feel valued, affirmed and that they belong.
Inclusive leaders are essential for creating cultures, schools, teams and organizations that drive equitable outcomes for historically marginalized and minoritized people.
We can assess and adapt our leadership practices to become more inclusive leaders.
Forced belonging versus structural belonging
Pollock, an electrical engineer who worked on MEMS technology for DLP at Texas Instruments before earning a doctorate in engineering education, opens with an image many women in engineering will recognize: the triangle peg jammed into a round hole. Forced belonging, she explains, is the work of adapting, shifting and assimilating to survive in a space, often without noticing it.
"We're literally shaving off parts of ourself trying to fit into this sort of forced belonging." (5:31)
Structural belonging is the opposite. It is asset driven, based on strengths, and lets people show up as their authentic selves. Pollock names the pattern she sees too often in engineering, where organizations ask for diversity but resist any change themselves:
"We want more people of color. We welcome diversity, but don't expect us to change anything." (5:54)
She shares that she only realized how much she had adapted as a woman in engineering after she left the field, a survival tactic she had not seen while living it.
Culture as an iceberg, and the forces around change
Pollock describes culture as the beliefs, systems and values that shape norms, practices and psychological processes. Much of it sits below the waterline. She recalls a competition in her group at Texas Instruments over who had banked the most unused vacation, a hidden cultural norm that became an organizational force. Those forces turn into structures, rules and policies, then patterns of behavior, then the events and symptoms people actually notice.
To drive change, she uses force field analysis, which she attributes to Kurt Lewin in the 1940s: situations are held in balance between forces driving change and forces resisting it. She urges leaders to study their data and run root cause analyses rather than trying solutions at random.
"But what happens is like we just start, it's like throwing spaghetti noodles at a wall. Like, let's see what sticks and see what happens." (16:50)
She also invites viewers to focus energy on what they can control and influence, an idea popularized by Stephen Covey and rooted in stoic philosophy, noting that dwelling on things like state legislation outside her reach would stall her progress.
The interlocking four I's of oppression
Pollock defines oppression as prejudice combined with power, creating systems that disadvantage some groups and benefit others, and privilege as the matching system of advantage. Speaking about growing up as a white woman, she reflects that she had no concept of privilege until she became a woman in engineering.
"So privilege is characteristically invisible to people who have it." (21:31)
Her model of the interlocking four I's shows how ideological beliefs show up in interpersonal interactions such as microaggressions, become institutionalized in policies such as the pay gap or holiday schedules that favor one religion, and finally become internalized by the people they harm. The common mistake, especially in education, is to try to fix the individual.
"But if we do that and we don't change the system, it's just going to keep reinforcing itself, right?" (26:05)
She applies the same lens to imposter syndrome, citing a Harvard Business Review article that argues against telling women they have it, since what they experience results from systemic external oppression. Statements like "women just aren't interested" are, in her words, problems rather than root causes.
A four-part model for inclusive leadership
The final section of the workshop presents Pollock's inclusive leadership development model. For each part she offers what it does not look like, planning prompts and strategies.
Individual: understanding how social and political context shape your identity and bias your outlook. Warning signs include "I don't have culture" or "I'm not biased." Strategy: examine your positionality.
Lens: systemic thinking about advantage and disadvantage, and treating bias as an ethical dilemma that must be addressed, supported by root cause analysis and guardrails against biased decisions.
Practices: a human-centered, strengths-based approach led with empathy and curiosity, and being an accountable lifelong learner who owns mistakes instead of claiming good intent.
Outcomes: culturally intelligent communication that notices which voices are present, missing or silenced, and inclusive collaboration that refreshes team norms so more people can engage authentically.
She flags familiar failures, such as someone rephrasing a colleague's idea and getting credit for it, or assuming people are fine because nobody complained.
From awareness to action
Pollock closes with a 3-2-1 reflection: three things learned, two things to do differently and one immediate action. She points attendees to her reflection tool and growth continuum to benchmark their progress.
How to Intentionally Engineer Inclusion™ and Belonging, Meagan Pollock, 43 minutes: https://www.womentech.net/video/meagan-pollock-how-intentionally-engineer-inclusion
About the speaker
Dr. Meagan Pollock is the Founder of Engineer Inclusion, which she began after starting her career as an engineer at Texas Instruments working with light projection on microscopic mirrors. A TEDx speaker and author with a PhD in engineering education from Purdue University, she helps others intentionally engineer inclusion in education and the workforce.
Questions this talk answers
What is the difference between forced belonging and structural belonging?
Why do well-intentioned inclusion efforts often fail?
What are the interlocking four I's of oppression?
Is imposter syndrome a personal problem to fix?
What does an inclusive leader do in practice?
Drafted with AI from the talk transcript. Editor review pending.
Frameworks and ideas mentioned
Forced belonging vs structural belonging
Iceberg model of culture
Force field analysis
Root cause analysis
Circle of control and influence
Interlocking four I's of oppression
Inclusive leadership development model (individual, lens, practices, outcomes)
Strength-space-growth continuum
Asset-based mindset
3-2-1 reflection
Resources mentioned
Workshop handout at engineerinclusion.com/download
Inclusive leadership resources at engineerinclusion.com/ild
Article: Inclusive Leadership Development for Engineers
Inclusive leadership reflection tool and growth continuum quiz
Positionality workbook
Sphere of influence activity on the Engineer Inclusion website
Meagan Pollock's TEDx talk
Harvard Business Review article: Stop Telling Women They Have Imposter Syndrome
Engineer Inclusion mailing list
Session feedback at engineerinclusion.com/thanks
Cite this talk
Meagan Pollock. "How to Intentionally Engineer Inclusion™ and Belonging." WomenTech Network, 2023. https://www.womentech.net/video/meagan-pollock-how-intentionally-engineer-inclusion