0:0024:13

Modeling an Ethical Data Culture

Cindy Lin 24:13 2023

Crime statistics measure enforcement, not crime: what else does your data hide?

Chicago police kept showing up at Robert McDaniel's home after an algorithm flagged him as likely to be involved in a shooting, and he later became the victim in two separate shootings. Data strategy consultant Cindy Lin argues that ordinary business data can repeat this kind of harm without anyone intending it. So how does a team build a data culture that drives better decisions and protects people at the margins?

Get a three-layer data culture framework and concrete checks for equity and ethics

Watch on YouTube

In short

Cindy Lin presents her three-layer data culture framework (organization, department and individual) and argues that a strong data culture must also be an ethical one. Using examples from protecting trans students' data, aggregated income figures, crime statistics and a predictive policing algorithm, she shows how data can compound bias and offers practical ways to build equity and ethics into everyday data practice.

“If you think about it, crime statistics are a measure of enforcement, not of crime.”
“And so all organizations use data in some way and have some kind of practices around it, but there's a big difference between having a data culture and having a strong data culture.”

What you will learn

  • Map your organization's data culture across the organization, department and individual layers of Lin's framework.
  • Spot how aggregation and limited categories, such as binary gender fields, hide the experiences of marginalized groups.
  • Question whether a dataset measures a behavior or the process that captured it before using it for decisions or algorithms.
  • Protect sensitive personal data such as preferred names and pronouns from being shared with people who could cause harm.
  • Plan a data culture rollout by starting with an assessment of where trust, alignment and skills stand today.

Key takeaways from the speaker

  • Data Culture is the infrastructure, processes, and practice surrounding how your employees and teams use data to make everyday decisions that run your business.
  • An Ethical Data Culture is one that ensures that the gathering, protecting, and using of data is done morally and inclusively.
  • Implementing an Ethical Data Culture helps improve business outcomes.

Details

Level
Intermediate
Format
Talk
Technical depth
Introductory technical
For
Mid-career, People manager, Executive
Length
24:13
Published
June 2023

Questions this talk answers

What is a data culture, and what makes it strong?

A data culture is the infrastructure, processes and practices around how data is used to make decisions. A strong one supports decisions that are made faster and achieve the intended outcomes.

What are the layers of the data culture framework?

The organization layer needs trusted data, alignment, storytelling and governance; the department layer needs relevant tools and a data community; the individual layer needs strong data talent and curiosity.

What makes a data culture ethical?

Lin defines an ethical data culture as one that recognizes and offsets harm experienced by marginalized individuals and organizations in how data is used to make decisions.

How can aggregated data mislead decision makers?

Lin shows that Asian American median income looks higher than the national median, yet some subgroups such as Burmese Americans earn far less, which would change how resources are allocated.

Where should an organization start when implementing a data culture?

Lin starts with an assessment of how the organization compares to each part of the data culture framework, then builds a plan from the gaps found.

About this talk

We rely on data to run all parts of our business: forecast growth, determine resourcing, improving product offerings, measure performance, and so much more. But do our coworkers and / or employees have the skills and tools to use that data, and as important, do they know how to use that data ethically? As women, we have likely experienced the impact of inequitable data systems and so we have a responsibility to model ethical data practices. This talk will cover what an ethical data culture consists of, how we model ethical data practices, and how being an ethical data user can also improve business outcomes.

Topics

Related talks

Browse the library

Auditing AI Ethics

Arpna Aggarwal Senior IT Auditor, Labcorp

Biased healthcare AI can be caught before launch, if auditors know where to look

Intermediate AI and data 2025