The Impact of Digital Content: Mitigating Your Carbon Emissions
Alisa Bonsignore19:262023
Halving one homepage saved the emissions of a Lisbon to Moscow round trip
A client's homepage weighed 5.9 megabytes, mostly generic stock photos, and halving it avoided about 4,000 kilowatt hours of energy a year. Sustainable content strategist Alisa Bonsignore, founder of Clarifying Complex Ideas, argues that every byte has an emissions cost, paid mostly when data moves rather than when it sits in storage. So how can a communications team put a number on a website, an email or a podcast before it ships?
Learn a simple way to estimate emissions for web pages, apps, emails, videos and podcasts
Alisa Bonsignore argues that digital content is not the clean alternative to paper it seems, because every byte transferred uses energy that still largely produces carbon emissions. She shows communications teams how to estimate the emissions of web pages, apps, emails, videos and podcasts using an energy-per-gigabyte figure, and makes the case that lighter content also improves user experience and conversions.
“Data equals energy, energy equals emissions, and therefore data has an emissions cost. There's just no getting around it.”
“Just because it can be a video doesn't mean it should be.”
What you will learn
Calculate the energy use and emissions of a web page, email, video or podcast from its file size and number of transfers.
Explain why moving data, not storing it, drives most of the energy cost of digital content.
Challenge generic stock imagery and vanity videos by asking whether each asset adds value for the audience.
Use sustainable content metrics alongside page speed and conversion arguments to justify design choices to management.
Distinguish net zero from absolute zero when discussing digital emissions.
Key takeaways from the speaker
All content has a measurable emissions impact
How to incorporate sustainable content metrics into your best practices
How to assess the equivalent greenhouse gas emissions for everything from websites to emails to video meetings
Details
Level
Beginner
Format
Talk
Technical depth
Introductory technical
For
All career stages
Length
19:26
Published
June 2023
Questions this talk answers
Why does digital content have a carbon footprint?
Every byte of data is energy, and most of the world's energy is still at least partly generated by fossil fuels. The biggest cost comes from transferring data, not from storing it.
How much energy does it take to transfer a gigabyte of data?
Estimates range from 0.06 to more than 100 kilowatt hours per gigabyte. Bonsignore builds on sustainablewebdesign.org's 0.81 kWh per gigabyte, which covers networks, data centers, equipment and end devices.
How do you estimate the emissions of a web page or email campaign?
Multiply the file size by the number of downloads or recipients to get gigabytes transferred, then apply the energy-per-gigabyte figure and convert energy to emissions.
Does streaming have the same impact as downloading?
Yes. In both cases the data is transferred, so the same energy cost per gigabyte applies.
Is there a business case for lighter digital content?
Yes. Citing a 2019 Akamai white paper, she explains that faster pages improve user experience, conversions and profitability while also cutting emissions.
About this talk
The accelerating wave of digital content is increasing the energy demands on an already overextended planet. There is a perception that digital is less environmentally costly than cutting down trees for paper. Yet the energy costs for our digital lives can be steep.
Every byte is energy, and energy has a carbon cost. And our digital footprints are ever-increasing. In 2018, Forbes reported that the world is generating more than 2.5 quintillion bytes of data created annually, no doubt a significant contributor to the fact that the world has almost doubled its energy consumption since 1980.
I have developed formulas to calculate the carbon impact of your digital initiatives. These formulas can be applied proactively to new projects to understand the carbon cost of content. All communications teams should keep these numbers in mind when deciding what needs to be communicated, and how.
Halving a homepage cut 2.9 tons of emissions (78 s)
Lighter pages are better for business (61 s)
Welcome and thanks for coming. I'm going to start promptly because recording cuts off at exactly 20 minutes and I don't want to lose time for questions at the end. If you do have any questions, put them in the Q&A, but I will not answer those until the end because I don't do a terribly good job of reading and speaking simultaneously.
So as someone who came of professional age alongside the internet, digital was kind of the ultimate in innovation and progress. It was going to be a shiny paperless sci-fi utopia, right? After all, digital was free and clean and harmless. Well, not exactly. Our digital content has a carbon footprint. Every bite of data that we create is nothing more than energy, and energy, at least for the foreseeable future, generates carbon emissions.
It's hard to get this message across in the community of content and communications professionals. Surely it can't be that bad. If it was, I would have heard about it already. And so the project briefs are generated for another app or a landing page with a huge stock art image that doesn't actually show what the organization does. Think of all of those websites that you see with, you know, a person looking at their mobile phone or the banks on the bank's homepage or the person pointing at a whiteboard for a software company, right?
So, several years ago, I tried to step outside of the content community into the world of sustainability, because surely someone was talking about it there, right? But what I found were an increasing number of data-intensive digital solutions to sustainability problems. We're going to create an app, a podcast, a YouTube channel, an Instagram feed, or, God forbid, an NFT to build engagement.
Machine learning and blockchain are all the tools that we need to solve this crisis. Whether the problem is poverty or education, cycling or climate, didn't really matter. The solution is always digital. We're just going to take our way out of this mess. But by throwing more tech at the problem, we're creating an even bigger problem. We need to be cautious when we consider the media that drives home our message.
As my mother always said, it's not what we say, but how we say it that truly matters. So, when we're talking about this, we need to really think of this not in terms of storage, but of transfer. People think of data always in terms of storage, in terms of the data center. What is the cost for that website, that video, or that app to sit in the data center?
Given the fact that the economic cost of storage is rapidly decreasing over time, we expect it to be low. After all, the cost to store a 4-megabyte homepage is minimal, right? But it's not the energy required just for storing that 4-megabyte webpage. Just like the junk stashed away in your attic, there's limited energy needed for it to just sit there.
The real energy comes when you have to move it. So, let's say that you download that information to your phone, to your tablet, and your laptop. You need to move 12 megabytes of data, 4 megabytes, three times. Three times the energy, three times the emissions. What about 200,000 hits? With most websites, we're looking at tens of thousands, possibly even millions of hits each year.
Gigabytes upon gigabytes of data transferred. Hundreds of thousands of kilowatt hours of energy used to move them. Suddenly, we're looking at some serious numbers in terms of energy use and emissions. And with the IPCC reports forecasting dramatic and widespread impacts of climate change, you know, impacts that we're already starting to feel, there's really no time to lose in terms of reducing energy and emissions.
The impacts of climate change are going to be unevenly felt, with more dramatic consequences experienced by women, those experiencing poverty and homelessness, and in minority communities, Black, Indigenous, populations of color. So, we have an ethical obligation to mitigate our climate impacts where we can. So, how do we measure the energy of data? Well, complicated. I've spent countless hours researching this one seemingly basic question, because you figure it'd be easy, right?
How many kilowatt hours of energy is required to transfer one gigabyte of data? And answers vary from "a lot" to "not much" to "it depends on how you measure it." But all sources agree on one thing: it's complicated. One study from 2012 estimates that we use 5.12 kilowatt hours of energy per gigabyte of data. I've used that energy in my calculations until about mid-2022.
Others suggest it's more than 100 kilowatt hours, while others estimate as being just, you know, basically nothing at 0.06 kilowatt hours per gigabyte. So, sustainablewebdesign.org does a really good job of explaining their rationale and research behind their website carbon.com calculator. And I recommend that you take a look at that if you haven't already. They've settled on a fairly comprehensive number that includes IP core networks and the access networks, which are included in most calculations, but also the cables, the data centers, the networking equipment, and even the devices in your home or office.
So basically anything from large-scale infrastructure right down to the endpoint, and that gives them a final number of 0.81 kilowatt hours per gigabyte that they use for their calculations. So that's what I'm going to build on, 1.81 kilowatt hours per gigabyte from sustainablewebdesign.org, because the logic there makes sense to me. But what we do know is that most of the world is using energy that is at least partially generated by fossil fuels.
Fossil fuels generate carbon emissions, and so we need to make some estimates and come up with an average. Different devices and applications are going to draw energy differently, so again, we need to establish an average. And emissions vary based on the intensity of the draw of the energy grid at any given time of the day. And again, you guessed it, we need to come up with an average.
But we should all be aware that there are studies and data that can reinforce almost any agenda, higher or lower. You may be confronted with different and conflicting mathematical assumptions to reinforce a political agenda, but note the underlying principles are sound. Data equals energy, energy equals emissions, and therefore data has an emissions cost. There's just no getting around it.
So it's important to note that while we're increasing our ability to generate renewable energy, humanity is also using more energy than we have ever before. Our world has more than doubled its energy consumption in the past four decades. According to Our World and Data, we consumed 87,000 terawatt hours, give or take, in 1980, which jumped to 173,000 terawatt hours in 2019.
One terawatt hour is a billion kilowatt hours. So I've deliberately chosen 2019 as the last pre-pandemic year because everything's been weird since, and it's hard to make accurate direct comparisons. So as we're increasing our percentage of renewable energy in that little line you see there, we're also increasing our total consumption, so it's limiting the amount of headway that we're making on a true green energy transition.
Digital content is driving a lot of that. For approximately 90% of the energy generated in the US, that energy creates greenhouse gas emissions. We can use less energy during the transitional period to reduce the greenhouse gas emissions that are generated by fossil fuels. So let's put this in some context and run numbers. One of my clients had a very image-intensive homepage.
It was heavier than average, 5.9 megabytes, and stock art images of healthcare providers doing generic things. You've seen those pictures, right? Like someone in a surgical mask talking to someone else in a surgical mask in a hallway, or a picture of these people meeting in a conference room, but nothing that actually showed any of the products or the services in action.
But what value do these generic images add for the customer when we're selling a product or service? So we cut the page weight in half, eliminating lots of the unnecessary images, and converting others to new photos that actually showed products in action. They conveyed actual meeting and added context for the user experience, and the UX improvements, you know, made a difference, right?
Even with major changes, it was still very image-intensive, and it looked like what you'd expect from a modern website design. So we reduced the web page weight by half, about 2.95 megabytes. Multiplied by the 1.7 million hits a year means we avoided the transfer of 5,000, give or take, gigabytes of data. Using the 0.81 kilowatt hour per gigabyte of data that we've talked about already, we avoided 4,000 kilowatt hours of energy or 2.9 metric tons of greenhouse gas emissions.
It's roughly the same emissions as driving from Lisbon to Moscow on back in a passenger car. Reducing the page weight improved the download times, presented users with more information, more relevant information, and significantly minimized energy use and emissions. And that's just for the home pages. I mean, think about what that impact could be when you extrapolate that across a site that has dozens or hundreds of pages.
In many cases, less is more. My phone is loaded with apps. There are two factors to consider when you're weighing an app, the size of the app itself and the amount of data that it uses. There are more worldwide users of Android than iPhone, but iOS apps are approximately five times the size of Android apps. So when you start doing the math on them, it's been reported that, and using Instagram as an example, it's been reported that there are 2 billion active Instagram users each month.
It doesn't account for inactive app holders or those who downloaded the app and deleted it later. So we're just going to use that 2 billion numbers around happy number. And estimates say that the Android app is about 30 megabytes. So that would be about 1.4 billion downloads. The iPhone app size is 220 megabytes downloaded approximately 600 million times.
It gives totals of 34 million kilowatt hours and 170 million kilowatt hours, respectively. Together, that's more than 61,000 metric tons of emissions in app downloads. Obviously, there are additional emissions that come from the use of these apps. Reports say that 15 minutes a day spent scrolling Instagram uses approximately 10 megabytes of data per minute. That's 105,000 metric tons of emissions generated each day.
My personal email address, which I've had for more than 25 years, is an absolute disaster. Do I need another email from anyone, especially a retailer? My inbox says no. But what about that email from a streaming provider telling me what's coming soon? Estimates say that emails are only 75 kilobytes on average. However, average is a little misleading in the same way that averaging the net worth of someone in poverty with the average worth of Jeff Bezos, which was reported at 136 billion in September, would mistakenly suggest that everyone is, in fact, a multi-billionaire.
We send tons of plain text emails every day, but marketing emails, of course, are heavier with imagery and tracking data, increasing their weight. But for the sake of argument, we're going to use the lowball estimate for corporate emails and say that 75 kilobytes is our standard. And at that size, each email seems trivial enough, right? But when you extrapolate that over 200 million subscribers from a streaming provider, each email blast adds up quickly.
That's 15,000 gigabytes of data transferred in each email blast at 0.81 kilowatt hours per megabyte, 12,000 kilowatt hours of energy used each week, generating 5.3 metric tons of emissions. But these are weekly emails. Over the span of a year, that's the equivalent of adding nearly 59 passenger cars to the road, just to tell us about a new season of a show or suggesting that I watch something that I've already seen.
There are, of course, times when video is an indispensable tool for walking customers through setup or use or maintenance of a product or service. There are also times when video is used for video sake, as we saw on the pivot to video trend that was driven by Facebook half a decade ago. Just because it can be a video doesn't mean it should be.
A two minute YouTube HD quality video has a file size of about 115 megabytes. And a client who was hoping for 100,000 views for a vanity video, the smiling employee faces in conference rooms and on factory floors across their social media and email marketing campaign and their website. If they had met their click targets, that would amount to 11,000 gigabytes of data transferred at the 0.81 calculation that would use about 9,000 kilowatt hours of energy or four metric tons of emissions.
About the same as driving a passenger car for a year. But what's the value for the user, right? If we're not showing something that's of use, why are we doing it? It's value for marketing and value for management, but it's not value for the user. So if we're putting our attention into video, let's put it into something that's more useful, like a product setup or a troubleshooting video.
I'm not suggesting that we never create or watch streaming videos. I mean, video plays a large role in our lives. But I am hoping that this spurs us to action to consider a very important question before we do. Does this add value for our audience? Podcasts also have an emissions impact. I'll use the calculator from podcast hosting company, Blueberry, to estimate the file sizes and relative impacts.
It's incredibly difficult to get an accurate independent read on the number of listeners, but some approximate data is available. I'm going to use the Office Ladies podcast because they published data, which made it really easy to solve. The Office Ladies podcast is where Jenna Fisher, who played Pam Beasley, and Angela Kinsey, who played Angela Martin, recap episodes of the TV show The Office.
And in December 2021, they reported that they'd had 200 million total downloads of episodes of at least an hour in length, so 45 megabytes each. We can estimate that as of this date, the podcast had transferred 9 million gigabytes of data and used 7 million kilowatt hours of energy. And contributed to about 3000 metric tons of emissions since they launched in 2019.
So if we average that out to assume an even number of downloads per episode, 102 episodes in December 2021, that works out to be about 30, 31 metric tons of emissions per episode, or driving nearly seven passenger cars for a year per episode of podcast. As with all communications tools, I'm not advocating eliminating any from your repertoire of options, but the important thing is to remember to use them efficiently and effectively.
Leaner webpages, smaller app sizes, shorter or less frequently published podcasts, all reduce your organization's carbon footprint. So congratulations, you now have a new set of metrics for justifying content design choices with management. But this isn't all tree hugging and granola. Lighter pages download faster. In a 2019 white paper on retail best practices, Akamai talked about the speed of web page downloads and the corresponding speed with which impatient customers will abandon your site.
Faster pages mean a better user experience, the paper notes. This translates into better conversion rates and better profitability. Akamai reported that a one second increase in download speed decreased conversions by 26%. If your web page is four, five, six megabytes or more, your organization is leaving money on the table. So reducing page weight not only reduces carbon emissions, it also improves your customer experience, increases conversions and boost profitability.
And also, it's good for the planet. So think before you create. Use these metrics to help you identify new ways to justify accessible, usable design choices to management. Consider the impact of what you create and how you communicate to minimize your environmental impact. So thank you for attending. I'm going to go to the Q&A now. But if you'd like to follow up afterwards, my virtual door is always open at clarifyingcomplexideas.com, and I do look forward to speaking with you.
Let me take a look. Is it possible to apply blockchain to track the digital emissions? Yes, but by tracking the additional emissions with blockchain, you're also using more digital stuff. So it's causing more emissions. So it depends where your priorities are on that. But yes, it is definitely an option. But you can calculate manually and it will get you the same results.
Can we assume that using Android phones is more sustainable than iPhone? Yes, in that the app size is smaller. However, you know, when you're when you're looking at this in the bigger picture, too, you've got to look at the cost and impact of devices and production and recycling. So that's a bigger picture that I don't know all the details on because, I mean, the production to end of life discussion is is is complicated and large as well.
So but if you're looking for more information about lifecycle of devices, I recommend looking into the work of Jerry McGovern. He wrote a book called Worldwide, Worldwide Waste, and it's a very good book. And he he gets into these, you know, these these types of conversations. We will have emissions always in the digital world. True. There is not such a thing like reaching net zero CO2 in this industry.
Well, I mean, net zero is one thing. Absolute zero is is something else. Right. We're never going to completely eliminate it. But net zero is an accounting measure. So it's about offsets and, you know, and compromises. So we could potentially reach net zero by reducing, you know, other things in, you know, to balance it out. But that doesn't mean that we're going to reach absolute zero.
No, no, that's not going to happen. Is streaming causing the same impact as download? Yes. In the same sense, because you're you're you're you're transferring that data. It's the cost to transfer the data, you know, per gigabyte. You know, so the kilowatt hours per gigabyte of data and you are using the energy to transfer. So you are still transferring that that data regardless.
If you have any other questions, let me know. I have less than a minute to go. But if there's anything you can squeak in, let me know and I'll answer that. And otherwise, thank you so much for attending. And I look forward to hearing from you offline.
Transcribed automatically; names checked against the speaker record. Select a time to jump there.
Article based on this talk
Every byte you publish has a carbon cost, and you can measure it
Alisa Bonsignore shows communications teams how to calculate the emissions of websites, apps, emails, videos and podcasts, and why lighter content wins on every count.
In short
Alisa Bonsignore argues that digital content is not the clean, free alternative to paper it is often assumed to be. Every byte that moves across a network uses energy, and that energy still largely comes from fossil fuels, so websites, apps, emails, videos and podcasts all carry a measurable emissions cost. Her answer is to calculate that cost before creating content, and to ask whether each asset genuinely adds value for the audience.
Key takeaways
All content has a measurable emissions impact.
How to incorporate sustainable content metrics into your best practices.
How to assess the equivalent greenhouse gas emissions for everything from websites to emails to video meetings.
The myth of clean digital
Bonsignore came of professional age alongside the internet, when digital promised a shiny, paperless future that was free, clean and harmless. The reality is different: "Our digital content has a carbon footprint." (0:21)
She found this message hard to land among content and communications professionals, where project briefs still call for another app or a landing page built around a large stock image that does not show what the organization actually does. When she stepped into sustainability circles, she expected a more critical view. Instead she found a stream of data-intensive digital solutions: apps, podcasts, YouTube channels, Instagram feeds and even NFTs, with machine learning and blockchain presented as the tools to solve the crisis. Her warning is blunt: "But by throwing more tech at the problem, we're creating an even bigger problem." (1:45)
The cost is in the move, not the storage
Most people think about data in terms of storage in the data center, where economic costs keep falling. Bonsignore compares stored data to junk in the attic: it takes little energy to simply sit there. "The real energy comes when you have to move it." (2:48) A 4 megabyte homepage downloaded to a phone, a tablet and a laptop means 12 megabytes moved, with three times the energy and emissions. Multiply that by the tens of thousands or millions of hits most websites receive in a year, and the figures become serious.
Measuring the energy of data is complicated. As the speaker cited, one 2012 study estimated 5.12 kilowatt hours per gigabyte, other estimates exceed 100, and some put it as low as 0.06. She builds on the 0.81 kilowatt hours per gigabyte used by sustainablewebdesign.org, because it covers core and access networks, cables, data centers, networking equipment and the devices in homes and offices. She cautions that conflicting numbers can be used to support almost any agenda, but the principle holds: "Data equals energy, energy equals emissions, and therefore data has an emissions cost. There's just no getting around it." (5:54)
The context matters too. Citing Our World in Data, she notes that global energy consumption rose from about 87,000 terawatt hours in 1980 to 173,000 in 2019, so growing demand limits the headway renewables can make. She also stresses that climate impacts fall hardest on women, people experiencing poverty and homelessness, and minority communities, which creates an ethical obligation to reduce emissions where possible.
Running the numbers on everyday content
The heart of the talk is a series of worked examples. One client had a 5.9 megabyte homepage full of generic healthcare stock photos. By cutting the page weight in half and replacing generic images with photos of products in action, the team avoided transferring about 5,000 gigabytes a year across 1.7 million hits, which she calculates as roughly 4,000 kilowatt hours of energy or 2.9 metric tons of greenhouse gas emissions. The page also loaded faster and gave users more relevant information. "In many cases, less is more." (9:21)
She applies the same method to Instagram app downloads, to a weekly marketing email sent to 200 million streaming subscribers (about 5.3 metric tons per blast, or nearly 59 passenger cars over a year), and to a two-minute HD vanity video aiming for 100,000 views, about the same emissions as driving a car for a year. "Just because it can be a video doesn't mean it should be." (12:12)
Podcasts are not exempt. Using published download data from the Office Ladies podcast, she estimates about 3,000 metric tons of emissions since 2019, or roughly 31 metric tons per episode. She is not asking anyone to stop using video or podcasts, only to pause before creating and ask one question: "Does this add value for our audience?" (13:25)
Better for the planet and for the business
Bonsignore is clear that this is not only an environmental argument. Lighter pages download faster, and as the speaker cited from a 2019 Akamai white paper on retail best practices, slower pages drive impatient customers away and reduce conversions. Reducing page weight therefore cuts emissions while improving customer experience and profitability. For content designers, that is a practical lever: "So congratulations, you now have a new set of metrics for justifying content design choices with management." (15:03)
In the Q&A she addressed whether blockchain could track digital emissions. "Yes, but by tracking the additional emissions with blockchain, you're also using more digital stuff. So it's causing more emissions." (16:35) She added that Android apps are smaller than iOS apps, though device production and recycling complicate the comparison, and pointed viewers to Gerry McGovern's book World Wide Waste on device lifecycles. Streaming, she confirmed, carries the same per-gigabyte cost as downloading, and while the digital world may reach net zero through offsets, it will never reach absolute zero.
Watch the talk
Watch "The Impact of Digital Content: Mitigating Your Carbon Emissions" by Alisa Bonsignore (about 19 minutes): https://www.womentech.net/video/impact-digital-content-mitigating-your-carbon-emissions
About the speaker
Alisa Bonsignore is Founder of Clarifying Complex Ideas, LLC, where she clarifies complex ideas and develops sustainable content strategies for a global clientele, with a focus on sustainability communications aligned with the U.N. Sustainable Development Goals. She is an Associate Fellow of the Society for Technical Communication, Executive Editor of STC's Intercom magazine and a Certified Master Gardener.
Questions this talk answers
Why does digital content have a carbon footprint?
How much energy does it take to transfer a gigabyte of data?
How do you estimate the emissions of a web page or email campaign?
Does streaming have the same impact as downloading?
Is there a business case for lighter digital content?
Drafted with AI from the talk transcript. Editor review pending.
Frameworks and ideas mentioned
Sustainable Web Design model (0.81 kWh per gigabyte)
Resources mentioned
sustainablewebdesign.org
Website Carbon Calculator (websitecarbon.com)
Blubrry podcast file size calculator
World Wide Waste by Gerry McGovern
Cite this talk
Alisa Bonsignore. "The Impact of Digital Content: Mitigating Your Carbon Emissions." WomenTech Network, 2023. https://www.womentech.net/video/impact-digital-content-mitigating-your-carbon-emissions