You have not because you ask not - A recruiter's guide to salary negotiations
Jenny Cones19:362023
A recruiter held an extra $5K for a candidate who never asked for it
A recruiter sits on an approved extra $5,000, hoping the candidate will ask whether that is the best offer, but she never does. Jenny Cones, a Senior Talent Attraction Advisor at SonicWall with 20-plus years in recruiting, argues that these small silences compound into a lifetime pay gap. So what does a confident, well-built ask actually sound like, and why do so many capable women skip it?
Learn the bridge-building script, the levers beyond salary and the exact phrases to ask with
Recruiter Jenny Cones argues that women leave real money on the table by not negotiating, and that the gap compounds over a career. Drawing on offers she has extended, she explains how "good girl syndrome" holds women back and teaches practical tools: treating the offer as a business deal, building bridges, using multiple levers and asking simple questions.
“That loan that you took out early in career because you didn't negotiate becomes literally hundreds of thousands of dollars by the end of your career.”
“They're going to laugh at your stories, but they're not your friends.”
What you will learn
Calculate how an unnegotiated starting salary compounds through raises and job changes over a career.
Recognise the habits of good girl syndrome that make you accept an offer without asking.
Build a business case during interviews with stories, data and results you can bring to the offer stage.
Structure an ask as a bridge: a positive, the gap you want closed, then another positive.
Put multiple levers on the table, from bonus and title to flexibility and tuition reimbursement, without issuing ultimatums.
Key takeaways from the speaker
• Get what you want by building "bridges" at the negotiation table
• Don't let your "Good Girl Syndrome" take control
• Build a negotiation strategy based on the value and results
• Be prepared for the "who dos" and imposter syndrome
Details
Level
All levels
Format
Talk
Technical depth
Non-technical
For
All career stages
Length
19:36
Published
June 2023
Questions this talk answers
Why does not negotiating a first salary matter so much?
The money lost is like a loan that grows with every percentage raise and every job change, becoming hundreds of thousands of dollars by the end of a career.
What is good girl syndrome and how does it affect negotiation?
It is the conditioning to stay quiet, not rock the boat and please others, which leads women to accept offers and even explain their own skill gaps instead of asking for more.
How should I treat the recruiter during an offer?
Recruiters are not your friends, so be strategic about what you reveal, but maximise likability and share praise so the recruiter becomes your advocate.
What is building bridges in a salary negotiation?
You start with a good thing such as wanting to work there, state the gap you want covered, and end with how you can add to the team.
What can I say if negotiating feels uncomfortable?
Use simple phrases such as 'Is there any flexibility?', 'Is that the best offer that you can make?', 'Could you consider?' or 'Could we adjust?'.
About this talk
It is time to give yourself a raise, and I can help you do just that! A 2007 Carnegie Mellon study found that only 7 percent of female MBA graduates had attempted to negotiate their starting salary, compared to 57 percent of their male counterparts. Even today, women leave thousands of salary dollars on the negotiation table annually. I will share proven techniques to give women in tech the power to get the raises and offers they deserve.
My role has given me a really unique viewpoint on the way that women approach interviewing on salary negotiations and how women in particular manage their careers. What I love about recruiting is it really allows me to be a student of human behavior and people never ever cease to amaze me. Let's talk a little bit more about salary negotiations and how this became a passion of mine. One morning I was getting ready for work and I heard a statistic that absolutely stopped me in my tracks. An anchor woman said that only 7% of female MBA graduate negotiate their starting salary. Well, over 57% of male MBA graduates negotiate. Think about that the other way. 93% of women don't negotiate their salary at that point. So, you know, that morning
I really started thinking about the impact that that has over the lifetime of a woman's earnings. On average, we know that women earn 83 cents to every dollar that a man earns. And we know that that data is really normalized for the role. So, female program managers make less than male program managers. Female software engineers make 83 cents compared to their male software engineer colleagues. So, you know, if you think that they make less in salary, then you also think about those 3% to 5% raises and then that 15% increase when you change jobs, it has a huge lifetime impact. Let's think of it this way. If you're early in your career and you start your first job and you take out a loan for $5,000, $10,000, $15,000, and think of it, that's the money that's represented by the amount of money you lost because you didn't negotiate.
And then if you take that money and you add another 3% in every year and then you add in that additional money every time you don't negotiate when you change jobs, it has a huge impact. That loan that you took out early in career because you didn't negotiate becomes literally hundreds of thousands of dollars by the end of your career.
So, I cannot emphasize enough that this is super important. The other part that makes this even more impactful is we know, at least in the United States, that women are regularly the heads of household or they're going to be single mothers. So, we're also much less likely to invest. You know, we're spending our money on school uniforms and diapers and tennis shoes rather than buying or investing in the stock market. So, every dollar that we make is super important.
So, let's talk a little bit more about this. You know, I had all this brainstorm and I was thinking, and so that particular day I went to work and it just happened that I had three offers to negotiate. The first offer was to a man who'd been working as a contractor for a different company. And so, he'd been being paid on an hourly rate. In his new role, it would be full-time salary job. So, he would have vacation and benefits and things like that. He'd have to take a cut in pay.
In our initial conversation, I was very clear with him. I said, okay, this role pays $120,000, not a penny more. If you're not happy with that, don't interview. So, he said, oh, yeah, Jenny, no problem. So, he goes through the interview process. We get to the offer stage. I say, hey, guess what? We're ready to extend you an offer at $120,000.
He said, okay. He said, well, can't we do $125,000? I was furious, but I also had a duty. So, I went back to the hiring manager and I said, look, you know, I told the candidate, I doubt we'll get a change, but let me talk to the hiring manager. When I talked to the hiring manager, he said, well, let's give him a small win. And so, we did extend an offer at $122,000. So, data point in the back of my mind, right?
So, you know, my next offer was to a woman who was leaving a managerial role in a different industry and coming into an individual contributor role. And when we initially talked, her compensation expectations were really at the top of our range, but it was doable. And, you know, she went through the interview process. And when the hiring manager came back to me to extend an offer, it was below what we were expecting it to come out, both the candidate and I.
And, you know, I was disappointed. But I went to the candidate and I gave her the offer. And not only was I disappointed in the offer, but when I extended the offer to her, she began talking about, oh, well, these are the financial cuts that I can make in my life. She also began explaining to me the gaps in her skill set. And then she accepted the offer. And not only that, but she sent me a really nice thank you note. Now, my heart was broken because I would have been more than happy to go back to that hiring manager And fight for a better offer for her if I'd had a business case or if that's what the candidate had asked me to do, you know, so then I had my last offer to the day.
And, you know, this was to a woman who'd been working in a state institution. So she was moving to a software company. I knew I was going to be able to give her a nice big increase. And in prepping for it, I talked to the hiring manager, and we agreed to a number. But we also agreed that if she negotiated, I could give her an extra 5k. We wanted her to be happy. We really wanted her to join.
And we also were giving her a big raise in order to get her in line with what the market was for her skill set. So I extended the offer. And as we were talking through it, she asked me about, you know, was there flexibility to take her kids to school in the morning and she asked me about benefits.
And I'm sitting there hoping with every fiber of my being that she would ask, Hey, is that the best that you can do? Is there any room to negotiate? And she didn't. Now, some of you might be going, okay, well, why didn't you just give her the money? You have to understand, I was working for a publicly traded company, we wanted our employees to have a fair compensation. But also, I was an employee, I was a shareholder in the company, I ethically could not give away 5k unless she asked, you know, so that night, I was really troubled.
And I did what most Southern women do. I called my mama. And the first words out of my mama's mouth were, Hey, Jenny, have you been being a good girl? You know, my mom begins every call with be a good girl. Have you been being a good girl? You know, and that brings me to good girl syndrome. So I don't know if you'll recognize this, but I think a lot of us were raised to be good girl.
So what good girl syndrome says is that you want to appear sensible and in control, you keep silent, or quiet, you try really hard not to rock the boat, you really have an intense self pressure to do things right the first time to focus on keeping everything tidy to not make a mess, to focus on living up to people's expectations, maybe you have fear of disappointing others, you know, good girls often smile too much, and we don't even mean to.
So, you know, we're taught that good girls are compassionate and warm and cheerful and soft, soft spoken and loyal and we're given a lifetime of subtle subconscious cues that really give us a double edged dilemma right good girls are seen as push overs people take advantage of us good girls work so hard to please everyone that we can hurt ourselves.
You know, we don't always, you know, we don't always, you know, we don't always, we don't always, we don't always transparent with our colleagues, we self audit, you know, good girls are reluctant to say no and quite frankly as a recovering good girl, you can be exhausted. So, you know, the good news or the bad news is my mom and I aren't just making up, you know, good girl syndrome and the way that people perceive us, you know, Stanford University reported that desirable adjectives for women are often, you know, you're warm, you're cheerful, you're soft spoken, you're loyal.
Well, those are all qualities of good girls, you know, those are all qualities of good girls on the other hand when they talked about what men are desirable it's all this independent assertive dominant decisive. You know, so it's unfortunate that sometimes we feel like we have to be soft. So, you know, I'm still really reeling with this whole concept of good girls of how does it work of women negotiating salary.
So, I called one of my recruiter friends and I said, you know, I appreciate you, I've seen you be fierce, I know that you're smart, you're strategic, you're strong. And I'm seeing this pattern where women are not negotiating, I heard this statistic, you know, I'm in awe of you and your communication skills and your ability to go toe to toe with executives, what are you seeing with women negotiating salary.
And she said, Jenny, she said, it happened to me. Um, and I couldn't believe it because this woman is so fierce. And she said, yeah, she said the last time I was extended an offer, I know that I'm paid about $30,000 below what the market rate for my skills are. And I said, Oh, my gosh, I can't believe that you did that.
I said, what happened? She said, you know, I was scared. I really wanted this job, my kids are about to go to college. Um, so it broke my heart to think of this woman that I see as a lioness that I have seen absolutely advocate for others. But she was a scared to advocate for herself. She's a good girl.
So what do we do about this? What do we do about this? Let's talk about some real life tools and techniques that you can use to then take fear out of the equation and have tools so that you can negotiate salary. Um, you know, the, the first thing is to realize that it's a business deal. It's not personal.
Um, and the second thing is to realize that, you know, recruiters are fun. They're interesting. They're going to laugh at your stories, but they're not your friends. Um, so be very thoughtful and careful and strategic about the information that you recruit, you reveal to them. However, do you remember that recruiters can turn into an advocate for you.
So the way that you're going to do this is you're going to maximize your likability during the interview and offer process. You're going to look for opportunities to highlight things that you love about the company, ways that you can impact the organization. You're going to send thank you notes and emails. You're going to stockpile compliments. Hey, here's something I noticed that I love.
You're going to share all those subtle niceties that the recruiter has done with senior leadership so that the recruiter goes. They value me. I look good. It makes you look good. And it gives you leverage when you get to the negotiation table. When you're in the interview process, you're going to spend every minute building a business case so that you can review that at awkward time.
You're going to talk about the skills that you bring to the table, how you can drive revenue, how your superpowers fit into that open role. You're going to stockpile stories about your best accomplishments. You're going to have your references or your refers be prepared to talk and tell those stories that you want. And you're going to try to gather as much data as you can so that you can say things like, I ran $10 million projects at my last company, and I saved 20% on each of those.
I can do that here as well. So once you've established the value when you're at the offer stage, then you can do what I call building bridges. That means you start with a good thing. It sounds like this. It sounds like I really want to work here. But, and then you move to the gap that you have to cover.
I would like to see X, Y, or Z. And then you end with, you know, but I really feel like I can add to the team. This is how I can make a difference. So that's the way that you're going. A good, an ask, and then a good. And remember when you're negotiating, there's a lot of things that you can talk about rather than just salary.
So a lot of levers. The more levers that you have in play, the more likely you are to get a win. And that's the way it is with any negotiation. So, you know, you can talk about salary, bonus, title, vacation, sign on bonus, an MBO, six month review, stock, workplace flexibility, tuition reimbursement. There are so many things that you can talk about.
And putting multiple items on the table means that you're more likely to get a win. You know, if you have a very complex compensation situation, I've had a number of men that will give me a spreadsheet that helps me understand how their compensation works. I can share that with my executive team. Not once have I ever had a woman do that.
So do put together a spreadsheet if your compensation is complex, and do share it with the recruiter. Help them understand how they can help you. One word of caution here is don't ever give an ultimatum or leave no room for compromise. On a few rare occasions, I've had candidates push so hard that the hiring manager and I decided that, you know, this is really more of a mercenary rather than a teammate.
And we've stopped the negotiation process. So, you know, the market out there is not as hot as it used to be. So just be thoughtful as you're going into the negotiation process. You know, here's the hard part is this is a business deal, but it feels really personal. So be prepared for that imposter syndrome or what I call the hoodoos.
You know, my mama would say, well, who do you think you are or don't go beyond your raising. You know, this is the part that's emotional and it's really challenging. One of my dear friends would was offered a promotion at her college, but the offer she received was about a 12% raise. That sounds good, except for the job paid 30 K more in the past.
She was crushed. She called me and said, oh, my gosh, I can't believe this. And I said, you know what? And no, this feels personal, but it's a business deal. And so let's put together a plan. So she went and worked with her hiring manager with her manager. And they put together a plan to say, you know, HR thinks that you can't get too big of a raise.
But let's focus on the job, the value of the job, what the market looks like, and also the difference, how your skills have grown and faster than your compensation has. Now, it was a hard negotiation and it took months. And she called me several times upset. But at the end of the day, she was able to get a 20K raise over what she'd been in because she focused on a data driven business case and took the personal feeling out of it.
Now, for many of us, we only get a few chances to negotiate compensation, maybe once a year when you're getting review every few years when you change jobs. And so that can be a muscle that will really atrophy. I want you to think about being good girls, being a steward of their resources and use every opportunity that you can to practice your negotiation skills.
Maybe at a car dealership, maybe at a tag or a yard sale, maybe getting the best rate on a rental car and upgrade every time you check in to a hotel. You know, anytime that you have an opportunity to negotiate something, ask, because if you don't ask, you'll never get it. Let me end with one quick story.
I had a mentee that was negotiating with the new company and she sent me a message saying, hey, there's a 30% gap in the retirement plan. I said, well, you know, go and remind them, tell them about the gap, tell them you really like the role and see what you could do. Well, she told me later that she'd called them and asked about the retirement plan with a huge lump in her throat because at the end of the day, the offer that she accepted was a full 70K higher than what she was previously making.
Now, that's not going to happen in every situation, right? But, you know, remember that those 5K and those 10K and that 30% difference, all of that adds up and you're never going to ask if you don't know. And good girls do ask for salary increases. Good girls do negotiate because we want to take care of our fiduciary responsibility.
So, in ending, let me give you just a few parting phrases that I want you to take away. You know, things like, is there any flexibility? Is that the best offer that you can make? Could you consider? Could we adjust? So, it doesn't even have to be hard, but I promise you, if you will just ask, those little things do make a difference.
You know, my niece, the market is a little tough. She'd just gotten her PhD. And so, she was looking for, you know, starting the interview process. She was at the offer. She had one company that was interested in her. They'd made an offer that was at the top of the salary range that they'd initially given her. And I said, well, you know, do you feel comfortable just asking?
Just asking if there's any flexibility. And she said, okay, I will. Well, she got an extra 5K. You know, over the course of her career, every single dollar adds up. So, I encourage you, you know, to be sure every time that you're at a situation to lean into the negotiation. Also, if you found this topic interesting, there are a lot of really great resources out there that are available.
And the other thing is, is each and every one of you, please feel free to reach out to me on LinkedIn, Jenny Combs. I'll be more than happy to help you if you have a situation where you want some coaching or guidance. I don't charge anything for it. Helping women advocate for themselves and grow their careers really my personal passion.
So, please feel free to reach out with any questions.
Transcribed automatically; names checked against the speaker record. Select a time to jump there.
Article based on this talk
Why women leave money on the table, and how to ask for it
Recruiter Jenny Cones explains how good girl syndrome costs women pay and shares the scripts and levers that change the outcome.
In short
Women lose significant lifetime earnings simply by not asking, and Jenny Cones has watched it happen from the recruiter's side of the table. In her talk she shows how a small unnegotiated gap compounds over a career, names the "good girl syndrome" that keeps capable women quiet, and gives concrete tools: treat the offer as a business deal, build bridges, use many levers and practise asking.
Key takeaways
Get what you want by building "bridges" at the negotiation table.
Don't let your "good girl syndrome" take control.
Build a negotiation strategy based on value and results.
Be prepared for the "who dos" and imposter syndrome.
The statistic and its lifetime cost
Cones traces her passion to a morning news report: as she cited it, only 7% of female MBA graduates negotiate their starting salary, compared with over 57% of their male peers. Put the other way, 93% of women do not negotiate at that point. She adds that, on average and normalised for role, women earn 83 cents for every dollar a man earns.
To make the stakes tangible, she asks viewers to imagine the money they failed to negotiate as a loan taken out at the start of their career. Every 3% to 5% annual raise and every roughly 15% jump when changing jobs is calculated on top of that lower base. "That loan that you took out early in career because you didn't negotiate becomes literally hundreds of thousands of dollars by the end of your career." (2:08) She notes that, at least in the United States, women are often heads of household or single mothers and less likely to invest, so every dollar matters.
Three offers in one day
On the same day she heard that statistic, Cones had three offers to extend. The first went to a man she had told plainly that the role paid $120,000 and not a penny more. At the offer stage he still asked for $125,000, and the hiring manager agreed to give him a small win at $122,000.
The second went to a woman whose offer came in below what both she and Cones expected. Instead of pushing back, the candidate talked about the cuts she could make in her life, explained the gaps in her own skill set, accepted, and sent a thank you note. Cones would gladly have fought for more if she had been asked or given a business case.
The third candidate had an extra $5,000 already approved if she negotiated. She asked about flexibility and benefits, but not about pay. "And I'm sitting there hoping with every fiber of my being that she would ask, Hey, is that the best that you can do? Is there any room to negotiate?" (6:29) As an employee and shareholder of a publicly traded company, Cones could not ethically hand the money over unprompted.
Good girl syndrome
That night she called her mother, who opens every call by asking whether she has been a good girl. "You know, my mom begins every call with be a good girl." (7:04) Cones describes good girl syndrome as wanting to appear sensible and in control, staying quiet, not rocking the boat, fearing disappointing others and smiling too much. She cites Stanford University findings that desirable adjectives for women are warm, cheerful, soft spoken and loyal, while for men they are independent, assertive, dominant and decisive.
Even strong women are not immune. A recruiter friend she admires for going toe to toe with executives admitted she had accepted an offer about $30,000 below market because she was scared and needed the job. "Um, so it broke my heart to think of this woman that I see as a lioness that I have seen absolutely advocate for others." (10:12)
Treat it as a business deal and build bridges
Cones's first rule is that negotiation is a business deal, not a personal matter. Her second is a candid warning about her own profession. "They're going to laugh at your stories, but they're not your friends." (10:53) Be strategic about what you reveal, yet remember recruiters can become advocates: maximise likability, send thank you notes, and share their help with senior leaders.
Throughout the interview, candidates should build a business case: skills, revenue impact, stockpiled accomplishment stories, prepared references and hard data such as running $10 million projects and saving 20% on each. At the offer stage, she recommends "building bridges": a good, an ask, then a good. It opens with something like wanting to work there, names the gap, and closes with how you will add to the team.
She also urges candidates to widen the conversation beyond base pay, to salary, bonus, title, vacation, sign-on bonus, stock, a six month review, flexibility and tuition reimbursement. "The more levers that you have in play, the more likely you are to get a win." (13:12) Men regularly send her spreadsheets explaining complex compensation; no woman ever has. Her caution: never give an ultimatum, because pushing too hard can make a candidate look like a mercenary rather than a teammate.
Imposter syndrome, the who dos and practice
"You know, here's the hard part is this is a business deal, but it feels really personal." (14:20) Cones calls the inner voice asking "who do you think you are" the who dos. A friend offered a promotion with a 12% raise, for a job that had paid much more, built a data-driven case with her manager over several months and secured a $20,000 raise.
Because most people negotiate pay only rarely, the skill atrophies. Cones suggests practising at car dealerships, yard sales, rental car counters and hotel check-ins. "You know, anytime that you have an opportunity to negotiate something, ask, because if you don't ask, you'll never get it." (16:21) A mentee who raised a retirement plan gap ended up $70,000 above her previous pay, and her niece gained $5,000 simply by asking whether there was any flexibility. Her parting phrases are simple: "Is there any flexibility?", "Is that the best offer that you can make?", "Could you consider?" and "Could we adjust?"
Watch the talk
"You have not because you ask not - A recruiter's guide to salary negotiations" by Jenny Cones, about 20 minutes: https://www.womentech.net/video/you-have-not-because-you-ask-not-recruiters-guide-salary-negotiations
About the speaker
Jenny Cones is a Senior Talent Attraction Advisor at SonicWall with more than 20 years of recruiting experience across software, consulting and financial services, during which she has negotiated hundreds of millions of dollars in salaries. Her passion is helping women build strong resumes, interview skills, personal brands and self-advocacy abilities in the employment process.
Questions this talk answers
Why does not negotiating a first salary matter so much?
What is good girl syndrome and how does it affect negotiation?
How should I treat the recruiter during an offer?
What is building bridges in a salary negotiation?
What can I say if negotiating feels uncomfortable?
Drafted with AI from the talk transcript. Editor review pending.
Frameworks and ideas mentioned
Building bridges (good, ask, good)
Good girl syndrome
Resources mentioned
Jenny Cones on LinkedIn (free coaching offer)
Cite this talk
Jenny Cones. "You have not because you ask not - A recruiter's guide to salary negotiations." WomenTech Network, 2023. https://www.womentech.net/video/you-have-not-because-you-ask-not-recruiters-guide-salary-negotiations