Feeling out of place in the boardroom is inherited, not personal
As a child, she found a Picasso print hung outside the family bathroom ugly and frightening, until her mother asked her to study it for a couple of minutes every day. Space engineer Bianca Cefalo, who helped deliver missions for NASA and ESA, now sees the same reaction whenever women, or their ideas, enter rooms that have never seen them. So what should an innovator do when speaking up feels most uncomfortable?
Learn three ways to turn being the unfamiliar one in the room into an innovation edge
Space engineer Bianca Cefalo argues that the skepticism women and their ideas meet in boardrooms is a reaction to the unfamiliar, inherited from centuries of stereotypes, and not a judgment of the individual. Drawing on a childhood lesson from a Picasso print and her work innovating spacecraft, she urges women to own their difference and speak up exactly when an idea feels too strange to share.
“It was beautiful and it was new because it was different.”
“That's against an entire system that has been built in a wrong way.”
What you will learn
Reframe the feeling of not belonging in a boardroom as other people's reaction to the unfamiliar, not a verdict on your ability.
Recognize how decades of stereotyped imagery, such as adverts portraying women as housewives, shape how new people and ideas are received.
Practice looking at the unfamiliar repeatedly until its value becomes visible, as Cefalo did with a Picasso print.
Apply a different angle to established designs, for example innovating a standard spacecraft from the inside with new materials.
Share ideas precisely when they feel weird or different, since that is when they can break stereotypes.
Details
Level
All levels
Format
Talk
Technical depth
Non-technical
For
All career stages
Length
18:15
Published
December 2020
Questions this talk answers
Why do women innovators often feel they do not belong in boardrooms?
Cefalo argues people react with skepticism to what they have never seen before. The feeling is a constructed heritage of stereotypes, not a personal failing, so women should not take it personally.
What did a Picasso poster teach her about innovation?
By looking at a print she found ugly for a couple of minutes every day, she came to see it was beautiful because it was different. From then on she learned to see beauty in weirdness.
What separates a good engineer from an outstanding innovator?
First, accepting your own personality and way of thinking differently from everybody else. Second, looking at a problem from a different angle instead of repeating what has always been done.
When should you share an idea that feels too strange?
Exactly when it feels weird and different. If women do not speak up at those moments, she says, the stereotypes will not be broken.
How can something as standard as a telecom spacecraft be innovated?
Instead of changing how it looks from the outside, change the inside by using advanced materials that have never been used on a spacecraft.
The ugly Picasso print that taught her innovation (78 s)
Imposter feelings are a system problem, not yours (63 s)
Three takeaways for the only woman in the room (66 s)
After a childhood spent playing with spare parts in her dad's garage and dreaming of tuning Michael Schumacher's Formula One Ferrari. For the past 10 years, Bianca has been playing rocket science across Berlin and London and contributing to the delivery of multiple science and commercial telecoms missions sponsored by NASA, ESA, DLR, UKSA, and EU, including the landing on NASA GPL inside Mars mission. She's STEM consultant, space communicator, youth mentor, public speaker.
She's actively pursuing her mission to inspire and empower the next generation of fierce female leaders on Earth and beyond. She was also one of our keynote speakers at WomenTech Global Conference. Speaker 2: Hi, Bianca. Welcome. Bianca Cefalo: Thank you very much. Speaker 2: Thank you. Speaker 2: And good morning, good evening, good afternoon, everyone. It's an honor for me to be here in this very, very special day, especially when something happens, especially when we are talking about WomenTech Awards. So, what I want to share with you today, as Anna shared part of my biography. So, I work in the space industry and I've been working in the space industry for the past 10 years in different ways. So, coming from Italy, moving to Germany, moving to London, now working in the
States. And my main work in the industry has been about innovation. However, as we are all women here, and we are talking about women in tech, we know that when we talk about innovation, especially when we talk about innovation made by women and possibly for women and for the humanity as a whole, Speaker 2: we are talking about a territory which is really interesting and also difficult because Speaker 2: innovation these days is, especially when we talk about disruptive innovation, is not just Speaker 2: technological innovation. We are not just talking about designing something which is going to change Speaker 2: an instrument or a system, per se. We are talking about innovation that is going to change and is going to drive humanity evolution on Earth and especially in space, because this is what I do.
Speaker 2: And when we are talking about the subject so seemingly complex as this one, we have to understand that, Speaker 2: as women especially, and also as women who are innovators and don't really fit into a category of a Speaker 2: women in tech. What's really important is to understand how we have to stand our own ground from a social and cultural perspective.
Speaker 2: And I will give you some, let's say a couple of anecdotes from my own experience and my own life since I was a child. Speaker 2: So what basically brought me into into the space industry and especially rocket science wasn't Speaker 2: something that I had really envisioned before. So coming from the south of Italy, coming from a culture where Speaker 2: we are exposed to a way of seeing beauty, seeing women, seeing the contribution to technology in a very Speaker 2: standardised way, especially when I started studying aerospace engineering, Speaker 2: my idea of becoming a rocket scientist was very far fetched.
Speaker 2: And this is still applies to many of us and how it can be broken down. Speaker 2: So I remember that when I, when I was a child, my mom always loved art. Speaker 2: And she was hanging new posters, springs around the house. Speaker 2: So I remember that she had just hanged a poster of a prince of a Picasso painting just in front of our bathroom.
Speaker 2: So when I was, when I was very small and I would used to go to the bathroom, Speaker 2: then I get out of the bathroom and I will look at these springs in disbelief. Speaker 2: So one day I asked my mom, mom, why, why did you decide to, to attach this, this, Speaker 2: to hang this thing to our wall, which is so ugly.
Speaker 2: And my mom sat down with me and she asked me, why do you think it's ugly? Speaker 2: And I said, because first of all, I don't understand it. Speaker 2: And second, it's scary because I've never seen it before. Speaker 2: So as you can imagine, when we talk about women in innovation, what do you most hear about?
Speaker 2: We've never seen it before and it's kind of threatening because we don't understand it. Speaker 2: This applies to us as new figures and in the industry and it applies to our ideas. Speaker 2: So what basically we have to do has an entirety, as a community of women first, and then as humanity, we have to break down these walls of unknown, which makes things scary.
Speaker 2: And also seeing things from a different perspective. Speaker 2: So when I told my mom that it was ugly because I'd never seen it before Speaker 2: And it was scary because I couldn't understand it, she said, okay, so every day that you go to the bathroom, try just to spend a couple of minutes looking at it and tell me what you see.
Speaker 2: So this is what I did every day. Speaker 2: I was spending a couple of minutes looking more at what that weird, for me it was weird, Speaker 2: painting was trying to say. And the more I was looking at it, the more I was understanding Speaker 2: that it was extremely beautiful and it was extremely beautiful because it wasn't scary because it was different. It was beautiful and it was new because it was different.
Speaker 2: And the more I would look at it, the more I could understand the emotions Speaker 2: and what Picasso was trying to portray, the boundaries and the stereotypes that for that kind of art he was trying to break down. Putting eyes and hands and colors in ways that I never seen Speaker 2: before because I was again exposed to a culture and aesthetics that goes more for Michelangelo, more classical way of seeing beauty and art. For me, that kind of piece of poster became emblematic Speaker 2: of an entire way of living and breathing innovation. So I, since a very young age, I started seeing beauty in weirdness. If you think about beauty in what is provocative and what it doesn't seem Speaker 2: like it fits anywhere. And this is what I've done my entire career. So anytime I was the youngest
Speaker 2: only woman in a boardroom, people will look at me like I was an alien or the elephant in the room, but that's because they weren't usually exposed to somebody like me breaking into rocket science and Speaker 2: being at the boardroom where generally not a woman like me will be there. Anytime I've done something or I've expressed or I've been pitching ideas, business ideas, or innovative ideas to internal Speaker 1: or stakeholders or space agencies, and even now in my new role where we are basically working Speaker 2: with a very advanced nano material, which has never been done before in the space industry, Anytime I speak about that, I have to make it's it's people look at it with a skepticism because it's new.
Speaker 2: It's different. So what is scaring people? It's not our presence, our personality per se, Speaker 2: but it's what they have always been used to see and do their entire life. Speaker 2: For instance, there are multiple marketing adverts. I shared this one this morning on my LinkedIn, where in the 68 and even in 2017, the woman is still portrayed like she's meant to clean the Speaker 2: house. She's meant to be the housewife or she's meant to be the gold digger, the young woman Speaker 2: who is basically marrying the older wealthy guy. She's just this pretty object.
Speaker 2: So if you think about this exposure that has been happening for the past centuries into our own humanity, Speaker 2: this is what people have been used to see. So when each one of us is working Speaker 2: on an innovation, is getting into a boardroom, is getting that promotion, that new job, Speaker 2: that new is becoming the new entrepreneur of the year, is getting on the press as 40 under 40 Speaker 2: fortune or 30 under 30 forms or all of these. It is traveling because it's something that I've never seen before.
Speaker 2: But this doesn't mean that it's an attack to our own personality. It's not to ourselves. Speaker 2: So when we are scared to enter into a boardroom, when we feel anxious or we feel like imposter to be in a place, Speaker 2: because we are looked at like we don't belong there. That's not against us individual.
Speaker 2: That's against an entire system that has been built in a wrong way. Speaker 2: So my message here today is especially this one. Anytime we are standing our ground and we are talking Speaker 2: about innovation in engineering, in tech, in whatever things we are doing, anytime we don't feel Speaker 2: like we want to speak up or we want to share that innovative idea because it feels weird and it Speaker 2: feels different, that's exactly the moment when we have to do it. Because if we don't do that, Speaker 2: if each and every one of us doesn't do that, we are not going to break these stereotypes.
Speaker 2: We are not going to break this generational heritage of image and visuals that people are used to see. Speaker 2: And we will just perpetrate for more centuries what has been done to us. So anytime we feel Speaker 2: that we don't belong to a place, it's not really our own personal feeling. We are carrying a baggage of Speaker 2: heritage that doesn't really belong to us. It wasn't ours. It was never ours. It was there because Speaker 2: it was prefabricated. It was pre-constructed. So the first thing that I would say is that Speaker 2: we have to definitely enter into any boardroom as a provocation and not as a provocation, Speaker 2: because we are not capable of. I've been told many times, oh, she's just a pretty face.
Speaker 2: she's just here because it's different. No, we have to get there. Because then once we put our Speaker 2: foot in the door and we are actually Speaker 2: creating something, solving the problem from an angle that was never considered before, Speaker 2: this is where we are actually changing the entire course of the technology and at the same time Speaker 2: of an entire social and cultural construct. And this is exactly what then helped me Speaker 2: going through my different roles and my different ways of advancing technology in this space.
Speaker 2: And because whilst I was reading the book called Psychology of Creativity and Innovation, Speaker 2: this is what exactly I was seeing. And the more we embrace our own weirdness, diversity, Speaker 2: and whatever other unique quality we have, the more we have a chance to create something Speaker 2: and to build something that has never been done before and that will change humanity entirely.
Speaker 2: And this is what I've done. This is what I still do. And this is what I enjoy doing every day. Speaker 2: When we talk about space technology again, it seems a lot far away or something that is not really understood. Speaker 2: But we play, all of us, space scientists on a daily basis using Wi-Fi, posting pictures on Instagram, Speaker 2: using the broadcast, using TV, using Netflix, using the GPS. This is what we do on a daily basis.
Speaker 2: And if we can't see this from a different perspective, we will never be able to apply our own different perspective to things that we can change. Speaker 2: And when we look at space engineering or spacecraft or interplanetary missions and we think about innovations. Speaker 2: So there is a way of being a good painter, a good engineer, a good analyst, and there is a way of being an outstanding innovator and inventor.
Speaker 2: And that is when going back to the psychology of creativity and innovation, this book that is amazing is the same approach that everybody can take a good picture, Speaker 2: but not everybody can be an amazing photographer. Speaker 2: At the same way, everybody can do the daily routine job in any kind of industry. Speaker 2: Not everybody is able to be that absolute amazing entrepreneur, innovator or anything.
Speaker 2: And this is because that requires, first of all, to accept our own personality, our own difference, Speaker 2: our own way of thinking, of behaving, of speaking, of acting differently from everybody else. Speaker 2: That's the first step, and the second one is exactly to look at things from a different perspective. Speaker 2: Just don't think about what has always been done so far, but how can I look at this problem from a different angle?
Speaker 2: For example, when I was working in innovation on telecommunications spacecraft on the platform, Speaker 2: Generally, you would think, okay, a spacecraft is always being built like that. Speaker 2: It's a massive cube with different systems on, they're always the same. Speaker 2: There are cameras, there are optical heads, there is the antenna, what else do you want to innovate?
Speaker 2: But if you look at that saying, well, the innovation doesn't necessarily come from how I see this from the outside, Speaker 2: but I can change the inside looking at the tiniest material that has been advanced and has been never used on a spacecraft. Speaker 2: This is something, for example, that is absolutely innovative, it's scary, it's never been done before, Speaker 2: but it's totally the one thing that will make any project and any kind of innovator stand out because it's a way of looking at problems from a different perspective.
Speaker 2: So I'm conscious that I'm quite close to my speech. Speaker 2: So my takeaways from today are that first, when we are entering into a boardroom and we don't feel like we belong there, Speaker 2: that's not our own problem. It's a heritage of humanity that has been put there, has been constructed. Speaker 2: So don't take it personally. Second, you can look at this from a different perspective and say, Speaker 2: these people have never seen this before, which means if I want to change this, I have to be here.
Speaker 2: I have to be here for myself, for my daughters, for my friends, for my mother, for my grandmother, for a whole generation of ancestors that could Speaker 2: couldn't or didn't have the chance to break those boundaries. Speaker 2: And third, once you own your own difference, your own unique points, your own Speaker 2: amazingness, however you want to portray it, in a way you speak, in a way you express yourself.
Speaker 2: This is when the major creativity kicks in because you won't be afraid of sharing your opinions or your ideas because you won't think they Speaker 2: are crazy. And even if you think they are crazy, this is when you have to share them. Speaker 2: Because all we need nowadays as women and all we do best is the surprise effect.
Speaker 2: When you surprise people, you surprise an entire plethora of generations which have been afraid and scared and threatened of the novelty. Speaker 2: But that's how novelty comes. And that's how you will then be able to say, Speaker 2: I've done this not only for myself, but for the evolution of an entire generation of women and men that tomorrow will look at what I've done and say, I can do that too.
Speaker 2: Thank you. Speaker 2:
Transcribed automatically; names checked against the speaker record. Select a time to jump there.
Article based on this talk
Why feeling out of place in the boardroom is not your fault
Space engineer Bianca Cefalo explains how the fear of the unfamiliar holds women back, and how owning your difference turns it into innovation.
In short
When women walk into boardrooms or pitch new ideas, the skepticism they meet is usually a reaction to the unfamiliar, inherited from centuries of stereotypes, and not a judgment of them as individuals. That is the argument Bianca Cefalo makes in her talk at the WomenTech Global Awards 2020. Her answer is to own that difference, because the moment an idea feels too strange to share is exactly the moment to share it.
Key takeaways
Reframe the feeling of not belonging in a boardroom as other people's reaction to the unfamiliar, not a verdict on your ability.
Recognize how decades of stereotyped imagery, such as adverts portraying women as housewives, shape how new people and ideas are received.
Practice looking at the unfamiliar repeatedly until its value becomes visible, as Cefalo did with a Picasso print.
Apply a different angle to established designs, for example innovating a standard spacecraft from the inside with new materials.
Share ideas precisely when they feel weird or different, since that is when they can break stereotypes.
Innovation is bigger than technology
Cefalo has spent about ten years in the space industry, moving from Italy to Germany, then to London and now working with the United States, and her work has centred on innovation. She opens by widening the definition. Disruptive innovation today, she says, is not only about redesigning an instrument or a system. It is about changing how humanity evolves, on Earth and in space.
For women who are innovators and who do not fit neatly into a category, she argues, the real task is learning to stand their ground socially and culturally. She traces this back to her own childhood in the south of Italy, where she was exposed to a very standardised idea of beauty, of women and of who contributes to technology. Becoming a rocket scientist, she says, seemed far-fetched.
A Picasso print and the fear of the unfamiliar
The heart of the talk is a story about her mother, who loved art and hung a print of a Picasso painting just outside the family bathroom. The young Cefalo found it ugly. When her mother asked why, she answered that she did not understand it and that it was scary because she had never seen anything like it. Cefalo then turns the story toward the audience: this, she says, is what women in innovation hear most often.
"We've never seen it before and it's kind of threatening because we don't understand it." (5:10)
Her mother's response was simple: spend a couple of minutes each day looking at the painting and report back. Day by day, Cefalo began to understand the emotions Picasso was portraying and the stereotypes he was breaking.
"It was beautiful and it was new because it was different." (6:05)
The poster, she says, became emblematic of a whole way of living and breathing innovation: "So I, since a very young age, I started seeing beauty in weirdness." (6:34)
The only woman in the boardroom
Cefalo describes being the youngest person and the only woman in boardrooms, looked at "like an alien" because people were not used to seeing someone like her in rocket science. The same skepticism greets her ideas, including her current work with an advanced nanomaterial that has never been used in the space industry before. She also points to advertising, citing adverts from the 1960s and even 2017 that still showed women as housewives or decorative objects, as an example of the imagery people have absorbed for generations.
Her key reframe is that the anxiety and imposter feelings women experience in those rooms are not about them personally.
"That's against an entire system that has been built in a wrong way." (9:58)
She describes that sense of not belonging as a baggage of heritage that was prefabricated and pre-constructed: "It wasn't ours. It was never ours." (10:40) Staying silent, she warns, simply perpetuates the same images for more centuries.
Owning your difference is how innovation happens
Citing the book Psychology of Creativity and Innovation, Cefalo argues that the more people embrace their own weirdness and diversity, the more chance they have to build something that has never been done before. She compares it to photography: everybody can take a good picture, but not everybody is an amazing photographer. Becoming an outstanding innovator takes two steps. First, accept your own personality and your different way of thinking and acting. Second, look at problems from a new angle.
"Just don't think about what has always been done so far, but how can I look at this problem from a different angle?" (14:25)
She illustrates this with her work on telecommunications spacecraft. A spacecraft can look like a fixed design: a large cube carrying cameras, optical heads and an antenna. Yet the innovation does not have to come from the outside. Changing the inside, with a material that has never been used on a spacecraft, is scary and unprecedented, and it is exactly what makes a project and an innovator stand out. She also reminds the audience that space technology is not distant: Wi-Fi, Instagram, Netflix, television and GPS all depend on it every day.
Three takeaways for the next boardroom
Cefalo closes with three points. First, if you do not feel you belong in a boardroom, that is not your problem but a constructed heritage: "So don't take it personally." (15:58) Second, if people have never seen someone like you there, that is the very reason to be present, for yourself and for the generations of women who did not get the chance. Third, once you own your difference, creativity kicks in, because you stop fearing that your ideas are too unusual.
"And even if you think they are crazy, this is when you have to share them." (17:04)
"Because all we need nowadays as women and all we do best is the surprise effect." (17:04) That surprise, she concludes, is how novelty arrives, and how the next generation of women and men will look at what was done and decide they can do it too.
Watch the talk
New Age Leadership & Innovation, Bianca Cefalo, 18 minutes: https://www.womentech.net/video/bianca-cefalo-womentech-global-awards-2020
About the speaker
Bianca Cefalo is Director, International Business Development at Carbice Corporation, and a former Space Systems Thermal Product Manager at Airbus Defence and Space UK, where she led thermal innovation roadmaps for next-generation telecommunication spacecraft. She has spent nearly a decade between Berlin and London contributing to missions sponsored by NASA, ESA, DLR, UKSA and the EU, including the HP3 instrument on the NASA/JPL InSight Mars mission, and founded Cosmica Space Consulting to inspire the next generation of female leaders in engineering.
Questions this talk answers
Why do women innovators often feel they do not belong in boardrooms?
What did a Picasso poster teach her about innovation?
What separates a good engineer from an outstanding innovator?
When should you share an idea that feels too strange?
How can something as standard as a telecom spacecraft be innovated?
Drafted with AI from the talk transcript. Editor review pending.
Resources mentioned
Psychology of Creativity and Innovation (book)
Cite this talk
Bianca Cefalo. "New Age Leadership & Innovation." WomenTech Network, 2020. https://www.womentech.net/video/bianca-cefalo-womentech-global-awards-2020