In short
Sheri Kurdakul, CEO of VictimsVoice, argues that technology built to help vulnerable people can harm them if founders do not think through its ripple effects before they build. Using a documentation app for domestic violence victims in the United States as her example, she walks through eight areas to vet before writing code: technology, legal, security and privacy, compliance, evidence, access, community and business funding. Her message applies to any founder whose users are at risk.
Key takeaways
- Explore the four key areas of documentation-based tech tools: evidence, legal, security and technology.
- Know the federal regulations and legal standards that must be followed and how they may apply to the technology.
- Examine the liabilities that come with owning or recommending the technology.
- Discuss the legal and moral responsibilities to users.
Every splash makes ripples
Kurdakul opens with an image of entrepreneurs looking at calm water, the status quo, and throwing in an idea to disrupt it. The splash is the point, but the ripples follow. "And if you're not careful to consider the peripheral effects, you could end up harming the very environment you intended to improve." (0:32)
To set the stage, she shares figures as she cited them: across their lifetime, one in five women and one in seven men report severe physical violence from an intimate partner, and according to the National Domestic Violence Prosecution Best Practices Guide of 2017, 80% of reported cases were dismissed largely due to a lack of evidence. Abuse usually begins with emotional abuse and coercive control, behaviors that are nearly impossible to prove. As a survivor herself, Kurdakul understands the instinct to build a tool that lets victims document what is happening. Her question is what comes before that: "But what are all the things you should consider before you write your first line of code?" (2:25)
Technology choices and the law
The first decision, native app or web app, is already a safety question. Native apps distribute well, but when users are being tracked and monitored, an icon on the phone can give them away, and an abuser may simply smash the device. She also notes that Apple's App Store takes 30% of revenue in the first year and 15% on renewals. Web apps need a network connection, but they are device agnostic, harder to discover by accident and cheaper to build and update with one set of code.
The content a tool encourages users to collect matters just as much. The natural advice is to record what is going on, yet recording a conversation without consent is not legal in every state, and in some it is a felony. "If you don't understand the laws, you can actually put a user in harm's way." (4:06)
Security, privacy and compliance
Kurdakul asks founders to secure their internal processes as well as their systems. "Human errors cost companies more than technical ones in most cases." (5:05) Even standard features need rethinking: if a user's devices are monitored, a two-factor text or email could alert the abuser that they are documenting. She raises privacy questions about what data is collected, where it is stored, how it flows into tools such as a CRM, and what happens if a user contacts support and knows the representative.
Compliance cannot wait. She points to California's CCPA, Virginia's new law, 14 other states with privacy legislation in the pipeline, and GDPR for any data on European citizens. "Don't assume that because you're a small early stage startup that they don't matter. They do." (6:47) In the Q&A she sums up the general rule: store only what you need, be transparent, allow opt-outs, be specific about opt-ins, and let people review, edit or delete their data.
Evidence, access and hidden needs
If the purpose of a documentation tool is to prove a crime, its records must be legally admissible, or the user may be re-victimized when they learn it cannot be used in court. That depends on chain of custody. "It says that you can prove and certify to a court that the data from the time it goes into the system until the time it goes out and everywhere in between has not been tampered with, altered, or deleted in any way, shape, or form." (7:47)
Access is a moral question too. "Make sure if you're going to market this to anyone, you make it available to everyone." (8:10) She asks founders to consider age, gender identity, legal status and culture, and to invest in persona discovery. Her example: most pet owners will not leave an abusive relationship if they fear leaving their pet behind, and all 50 states have animal cruelty laws, so a tool can help users document when a pet is part of the abuse.
Funding the mission
Finally, she turns to the business model. "You cannot do anyone any good if you go out of business, so you'll need to figure this piece out sooner than later." (9:22) Nonprofits fundraise constantly but can access grants; a public benefit corporation may strengthen a social impact brand; investor-backed companies answer to shareholders and boards; bootstrapping is slow but preserves control over mission and culture. In the Q&A, she adds that VictimsVoice allows images rather than audio or video, and uses Facebook's resurfaced memories to show how a feature can be triggering for survivors. Her close: "And make sure your decisions, all of them, are done with your moral compass pointing towards your north star so you don't lose your way." (10:24)
Watch the talk
The Moral Considerations of Technology: Looking at the Whole Picture, by Sheri Kurdakul (15 minutes): https://www.womentech.net/video/moral-considerations-technology-looking-whole-picture
About the speaker
Sheri Kurdakul is the Founder and CEO of VictimsVoice (EBinRA, Inc.) and was formerly Managing Partner of Holistic Business Solutions, a small business and nonprofit consulting firm. A survivor of child abuse and domestic violence, she has devoted herself to ensuring victims of discrimination, harassment and abuse are heard, believed and able to seek legal justice.
Questions this talk answers
- Should a tool for domestic violence victims be a native app or a web app?
- Can victims legally record their abuser as evidence?
- What is chain of custody and why does it matter for evidence apps?
- What do privacy laws generally require of a startup?
- How should a social impact founder choose a funding model?
Drafted with AI from the talk transcript. Editor review pending.