0:0018:31

Dr. Carmen Martínez - "Your Chatbot is too sexy"": Stolen Female Capital in the Era of AI

18:31 2021

Why a helpful, kind AI assistant keeps ending up with a woman's voice

A woman VP explains that her company picked a female voice for its assistant because testers called it helpful, kind and compassionate, qualities she says the women on her team share. Anyone building conversational AI risks scaling that stereotype. Dr. Carmen Martínez, an applied linguist automating a call center with conversational AI, traces where such choices come from and asks what designers should do before giving AI a body.

Learn how capital theory exposes gender bias in AI personas and three steps to counter it

Watch on YouTube

In short

Dr. Carmen Martínez, a conversational AI expert and applied linguist, argues that gender biases learned in society are transferred into tech products, especially voice assistants given female personas. Drawing on Bourdieu's forms of capital and Catherine Hakim's theory of erotic capital, she shows how female capital, including emotional labor, is commodified, and urges teams to reflect and use inclusive design before giving AI a body.

“They are innate, but in humans, they are mainly learned. They are learned through our social interactions and from our exposition to media and social media and culture in general.”
“but i ask you now what is natural and instinctive about uh humans”

What you will learn

  • Explain what biases are and how people learn them through social interaction, media and culture.
  • Distinguish Bourdieu's economic, cultural, human and social capital from Catherine Hakim's erotic capital and its seven components.
  • Spot how emotional labor stereotypes lead teams to give service-oriented AI a female voice.
  • Question research that presents a preference for feminine service providers as natural or instinctive.
  • Apply three checks before giving an AI product a persona: reflect, examine the gendered meaning of the service, and design inclusively.

Details

Level
Beginner
Format
Talk
Technical depth
Non-technical
For
All career stages
Length
18:31
Published
June 2021

Questions this talk answers

Why do so many intelligent personal assistants have female voices?

Teams link service and emotional labor with women; one VP justified her choice by saying testers described the voice as helpful, resourceful, kind and compassionate, qualities she attributed to the women on her team.

What is erotic capital?

A concept from British sociologist Catherine Hakim (2010) describing a mix of visual, aesthetic, social, sexual and physical assets, with seven components ranging from beauty and social skills to fertility and motherhood.

What happens if you give an AI product a persona without reflection?

According to the speaker, it replicates and amplifies existing social biases and the dynamics of gender and power.

How can designers counter gender bias in AI personas?

Think historically from a gender perspective about what a service means when paired with a gender, then use inclusive design to break the canon and offer a variety of interaction styles.

Are biases innate or learned?

The speaker says biases are innate, but in humans they are mainly learned through social interactions, media, social media and culture.

Topics

Related talks

Browse the library

Impact of AI on Society

Jyotika Singh Director of Data Science, Placemakr

Round-trip 'she's a doctor' through Hungarian and AI makes her the nurse

Beginner AI and data 2022