Stepping into the Unknows we can trust! by Zara Zamani
19:522022
Blockchain's biggest promise is not crypto but scaling trust
People no longer trust banks, governments or Facebook, and the cause, this talk argues, is structural: industrial-era hierarchies put decision-makers far from both the information and the people their choices affect. As Web3 and the metaverse arrive wrapped in anxiety, Zara Zamani, who has worked with blockchain since 2015 and researches its adoption in small and medium enterprises, asks what trust even means. Can a network governed by consensus be trusted by default?
Learn why decentralized networks could scale trust, and where on-chain trust stops
Zara Zamani argues that blockchain's biggest contribution is not cryptocurrency or decentralized finance but the ability to scale trust and decision-making beyond what industrial-era hierarchies can manage. She traces how layered, centralized institutions separated decision-makers from information and impact, leading to corruption and lost trust, and explains how consensus-based networks and Web3 could close that gap, with limits during the transition.
“The biggest advantage is actually scaling trust and decision making.”
“And the more we close this gap, the less corruption we will have.”
What you will learn
Explain why hierarchical, bureaucratic structures stop scaling trust and decision-making past a certain size.
Trace how distance between information, decisions and their impact leads to corruption and lost trust.
Describe how a blockchain consensus mechanism replaces trust in a person or entity with trust in a construct.
Distinguish trustworthy on-chain applications from off-chain Web2 elements such as many crypto wallets.
Assess why small and medium enterprises may drive blockchain adoption faster than large centralized institutions.
Details
Level
Beginner
Format
Talk
Technical depth
Introductory technical
For
All career stages
Length
19:52
Published
June 2022
Questions this talk answers
Why have centralized institutions lost people's trust?
Layered hierarchies put decision-makers far from the source of information and from the impact of their decisions, so their choices become influenced by other interests. That distance leads to corruption, which erodes trust.
What is blockchain's biggest advantage for society?
According to Zamani, it is not cryptocurrency or democratized finance but scaling trust and decision-making. Data ownership and a fairer share of the economy follow from that.
How does blockchain change who we have to trust?
It moves trust from a person or organization to a mathematical or logical construct, the consensus mechanism, that governs a peer-to-peer network whose members do not need to know each other.
Will decentralization threaten banks and other centralized institutions?
Yes, any entity empowered by centralized control over users' data is threatened, which slowed adoption for a time. Awareness is now higher, and flatter small and medium enterprises may force larger entities to follow.
Can everything in Web3 be trusted by default?
No. Only what is on the chain can be trusted; many integrated applications, such as off-chain crypto wallets, still carry Web2 risks, so users need to educate themselves.
Why distance from decisions breeds corruption (67 s)
Blockchain's biggest advantage is scaling trust (81 s)
What you can and cannot trust in Web3 (67 s)
I'm a chief solutions officer at ChromaWay. ChromaWay is the Nordic leading blockchain company. I'm a blockchain solution architect in my expertise. And I'm also a researcher and university lecturer in adoption of blockchain in small and medium enterprises. So I've basically been working with blockchain since 2015. So I have the practical side of the coin, but I also have the academy side of the coin since I'm doing my PhD in blockchain adoption as well. And I'm teaching that at the university scientifically.
Speaker: But today we are here to talk about the unknown future that everyone is talking about these days. We keep hearing about all these, you know, attractive terminologies, metaverse, NFT, virtual life, and all these unknowns that for a lot of us is new. Speaker: And it might come with a lot of anxiety and stress. Like what is this unknown future? How can I trust? Do I even trust this unknown future? What is trust at all here? So today I want to go into the context of in which blockchain as a technology impacts our society.
Speaker: And so I'm not talking about much of the blockchain architecture today, but I'm talking a lot about trust architecture today and looking at how this, how, how the trust works and how the trust scales in a society and how is that related to blockchain and how is that related to this unknown future that we are, we are, we are stepping into.
Speaker: But before I actually talk about future, I want to go a little bit back into the history and talk about past and talk about where, what has caused us to be where we are today. Speaker: So if you look at, um, if you look at the history, uh, society, the way society operates today is based on structures that are initially built.
Speaker: Uh, and are born in industrial revolution era and industrial revolution era is a lot about hierarchies. Speaker: It's a lot about bureaucracies and scaling, scaling in through, you know, applications and technologies that were built in that era meant it meant eventually having more layers of bureaucracy and more layers of hierarchy. Speaker: And this was nothing. Speaker: It's nothing wrong with it.
Speaker: This was working great. Speaker: This has actually scaled trust a scaled human being to a big extent, but it has also reached to a point that. Speaker: Our lives became extremely hierarchical that eventually is started to fail us. Speaker: Eventually it started all these hierarchical institutions that started to fail human being in many ways. Speaker: Uh, it failed to scale.
Speaker: Uh, it, and when we say scale, it failed to scale in terms of trust, in terms of decision-making. Speaker: Um, we kept, uh, not trusting banks. Speaker: We, uh, we reached a point. Speaker: We don't trust banks. Speaker: We don't trust governments. Speaker: We don't trust Facebook. Speaker: We don't trust all the big entities. Speaker: Uh, we keep hearing fake news.
Speaker: We don't trust the information that we receive. Speaker: So it has done a great job up to a certain level, but from a certain level onwards, Speaker: it has actually started to fail human being. Speaker: And then when we look at what is happening there and how, how scaling trust has failed Speaker: In hierarchical and bureaucratic, um, life or societies.
Speaker: And then we look at what we want for our society, which is the globalized, uh, society. Speaker: We're talking about global globalization of information and there is a conflict here. Speaker: How do, how are we going to handle this globalization of information if we can't really scale trust? Speaker: If we can't scale decision making? Speaker: And how are these local institutions who have failed us are going to handle this globalization of information?
Speaker: And, you know, a lot of other other challenges like illegal, legal challenges come into the picture, et cetera. Speaker: So this whole hierarchical, but, but why has it failed? Speaker: Why, why has this hierarchical and bureaucratic structure has failed, uh, societies, um, so far? Speaker: The more hierarchical, the more pyramid looking structures, uh, exist in societies means Speaker: that the source of information is further away from, uh, decision-maker, from the decision-maker itself.
Speaker: So decision-maker is quite far from the source of information. Speaker: But the decision-maker is also quite far from the impact of the decision. Speaker: So I, as a decision-maker in a hierarchical organization, hierarchical structure of society, I'm far from the source of information because there are different layers that this information is coming up to me. Speaker: I'm also far from the impact of the decision that I make.
Speaker: And information and decision is built from down to top, but also this means eventually power is built from down to top. Speaker: Right. Speaker: Power is coming from down to top. Speaker: So we have information, decision and power that are, uh, very distant from each other. Speaker: And this means throughout the time decision-makers are getting further and further and further away from, uh, from the society or the community that they are making decision, uh, based on and for.
Speaker: And this eventually means corruption. Speaker: This, this ends in corruption. Speaker: The further I get away from the community that I am supposed to make decision for, or that I am supposed to make decision based on the data that I received from the community. Speaker: Then my decisions are influenced by other data. Speaker: And that means corruption.
Speaker: And the more corrupted the societies have become, uh, the more the trust has been tarnished. Speaker: And that is pretty much where we're standing today. Speaker: Centralized, hierarchical, bureaucratic structures of societies have, have caused this distant corruption and tarnishing trust. Speaker: So it has not done done good for us, but why, why are we even talking about this?
Speaker: We're talking about this because we want to relate this to how is that different from the, the, the, the structure of the world that we're stepping into. Speaker: So if we go back again to the history 30 years ago and the unknown that we were stepping into, you know, giant tech companies coming to the picture, social media, and a lot of FinTech.
Speaker: And I know applications in finances, et cetera, technology was really booming and it was great, but we were stepping into a very centralized world that we had to place our trust on an entity. Speaker: We had to place our trust on an individual, but we no longer want to do so. Speaker: We no longer will to do so.
Speaker: And that's exactly where we need a flat, a peer to peer, a non hierarchical platform or network that I do not need to know the, the rest of the community. Speaker: I do not need to trust the rest of the community. Speaker: And this is pretty much what blockchain technology is offering, right? Speaker: If a flat, a peer to peer network, non hierarchical network that, that you don't need to, you don't know all the people who are, or the entities or individuals who are in the network.
Speaker: But also you, you, you move your trust, remove a person to a construct, whether it be a mathematical or logical construct, construct that actually governs the network, which means you, you replace the trust that you have on a person or an, on an entity with a construct, which is, which is what we call. Speaker: Consensus mechanism in blockchain technology.
Speaker: So what does this mean? Speaker: This means eventually you are now stepping with Vectry and metaverse and all these applications that are being introduced to you, to us, to all of us. Speaker: We are now stepping into a world that it is no longer centralized. Speaker: We no longer need to place our trust in an organization, but now we are, we are replacing that trusting an entity with a construct, a consensus mechanism, a technology that actually governs, governs the network.
Speaker: We use a network as a model for governance that actually can now scale. Speaker: So the biggest advantage that the blockchain technology will provide to us in this coming unknown future is, is not about democratizing finance industry. Speaker: It's not about crypto currencies applications. Speaker: And, and it's, it's not about, you know, giving your power of ownership of your data back to you.
Speaker: The biggest advantage is actually scaling trust and decision making. Speaker: And as a result of the scaling trust and decision making, that is exactly what, what we receive. Speaker: We will receive back the ownership of our own data. Speaker: We will receive, we will, we will receive the share of the economy that we're not part of today.
Speaker: So, so by placing that, by replacing that trust on an individual or an entity with, with the construct or consensus that is governing the network. Speaker: Now we can scale trust and decision making tremendously now in this unknown future that we are stepping into. Speaker: And, and that means we will be able to replace centralized organizations today with decentralized organizations without the centralized autonomous organizations that are coming up or that are already existent.
Speaker: However, and that means there is no more a director or a group of, or a board of directors who, who are making decision. Speaker: They come a company and organization can have millions of directors and millions of shareholders and billions of shareholders that are actually building an organization together and are making decisions together. Speaker: And that means the source of information is getting closer and closer to the decision maker.
Speaker: And the decision maker is also getting closer and closer to, to the, to the people who this decision is impacting their life. Speaker: And majority of the times is the people themselves. Speaker: So we are making decisions for our lives. Speaker: We are making decisions that are impacting our life directly. Speaker: And the more we close this gap, the less corruption we will have.
Speaker: And plus the fact that blockchain technology is architecture in a way that you cannot manipulate with data. Speaker: You can, it's irreversible. Speaker: It's immutable. Speaker: That adds on top of that. Speaker: And therefore the, we minimize the corruption technology that the future, the corruption by the technology that the future is the unknown future that we're talking about today is built on.
Speaker: And that means eventually more trust, the less the corruption. Speaker: Eventually you can trust that network more and more and more. Speaker: And so the major advantage here is, or the major takeaway here is that we are stepping now with the world of metaverse decentralized world or a web tree world, which is the internet based on blockchain technology.
Speaker: We are stepping into a world that trust and decision making is a scale. Speaker: And eventually we make a big change in how our data is treated today. Speaker: So our data is treated today as a store of value or a medium of exchange or unit of analysis, but also a lot of decentralized entities have added system of control over that.
Speaker: And now we're eliminating that and giving that control back to the whole network. Speaker: So you are making decisions for your own data. Speaker: You're controlling your own data and there is no centralized system of control. Speaker: So having said all of that, by using blockchain technology, by taking advantage of blockchain technology, building the metaverse and virtual worlds on blockchain technology, Speaker: we're stepping into a future that we don't even need no longer to think whether we can trust it or not.
Speaker: And it's by default a network that is governing governing that. Speaker: And that is basically by default trust that you're because it's a trustless operation because the trust element is eliminated and is distributed among the network. Speaker: And this network, they don't know each other. Speaker: They don't, they don't need to know even each other. Speaker: And as long as they're all agreeing on what, what decision needs to be made, then they go ahead with it and they make the decisions.
Speaker: You make the decisions basically that are impacting your life immediately yourself. Speaker: So having to wrap up and probably even we can look at the questions, I would say the major difference between stepping into Web2 and Web3 is when you, when we were stepping into Web2, Speaker: we were risking our life with giving too much of control of it to centralized entities while, and have you had to trust banks?
Speaker: We had to place trust in, in centralized organizations. Speaker: Whereas by stepping into Web3, we no longer need to place that trust. Speaker: And we are stepping into an unknown role that we can by default trust because it's built on, on a technology that is by default trusted. Speaker: So we can, we can have a look at the questions as we have five minutes.
Speaker: Do you think that this centralized world might threaten deeply rooted banks and borders? Speaker: For sure. Speaker: Not only banks and borders, you know, it threatens any entity that is empowered by centralization. Speaker: And centralization means control. Speaker: Any entity that would, would want to keep control over end users data and end users life would be threatened.
Speaker: And banks, financial institutions, governments, legal institutions, European Union, universities, any central, a majority, as I said, to our today's societies is structured around hierarchical, bureaucratic centralization organizations as it's coming from industrial revolution time. Speaker: So yes, could that risk stalling this progress? Speaker: Both yes and no. Speaker: It did slow the adoption for, for, for some time.
Speaker: However, I would say now the awareness among a lot of organizations is much higher than it was before. Speaker: If you look at the, if you look at the economy of Europe, specifically because my scientific research is on the smaller and medium sized companies, 99% of the economy of EU comes from a smaller medium sized companies.
Speaker: And these are much more flat and less centralized. Speaker: And that means it can actually, while they buy the idea, once they buy the idea, then the speed of adoption forces the centralized and bigger entities to, to join the pack as well, I would say. Speaker: So is there any other question? Speaker: Yeah. Speaker: Thank you, Maria, for, for your questions.
Speaker: If there's any other question, I would be happy. Speaker: Let me go to Q and a actually. Speaker: Okay. Speaker: No, I can see that the questions are only in the chat. Speaker: Um, so, um, we have two more minutes, so I would probably wrap up this session by saying that, uh, uh, while I have mentioned that we are stepping into.
Speaker: With that tree and metaverse are stepping into an unknown future that you can trust. Speaker: Uh, you have to keep in mind the trust that the trust element that I talk about is about the on chain, you know, on the, the applications that are on blockchain. Speaker: However, when we are taking the lead from web two to web through this transition will take some time.
Speaker: And there is a lot of, you know, integrated applications that is web two elements suite and web three elements suite. Speaker: Like when it comes to cryptocurrencies, you have a lot of wallets that are off the chain. Speaker: So that doesn't mean that you can by default trust anywhere, anything around it, but you can trust anything that is on the chain.
Speaker: So that, that is what you can more or less trust, uh, mostly, but you have to be very, very smart and, um, also, you know, do a lot of, uh, self-learning and education around it. Speaker: There's also risks around it when you are taking the lead from web two to web three. Speaker: But, but, um, I would say we need to, to worry less in this transition compared to when we did the transition 30 years ago from web one to web two.
Speaker: With that, thank you very much. Speaker: And, um, I wish all of you who are taking the lead to web three success, and you can always reach out to me on LinkedIn and find me on LinkedIn. Speaker: And if you have any further questions about this, thank you, everyone. Speaker: Yeah.
Transcribed automatically; names checked against the speaker record. Select a time to jump there.
Article based on this talk
Why blockchain's real promise is scaling trust, not cryptocurrency
Zara Zamani traces how hierarchies eroded trust and argues that consensus-based networks can rebuild it at global scale.
In short
Zara Zamani argues that the most important thing blockchain offers is not cryptocurrency, decentralized finance or even data ownership, but the ability to scale trust and decision-making. Industrial-era hierarchies, she explains, pushed decision-makers away from information and from the people their choices affect, which bred corruption and lost trust. Consensus-based networks could close that gap, although during the move from Web2 to Web3 only what is on the chain deserves default trust.
Key takeaways
Explain why hierarchical, bureaucratic structures stop scaling trust and decision-making past a certain size.
Trace how distance between information, decisions and their impact leads to corruption and lost trust.
Describe how a blockchain consensus mechanism replaces trust in a person or entity with trust in a construct.
Distinguish trustworthy on-chain applications from off-chain Web2 elements such as many crypto wallets.
Assess why small and medium enterprises may drive blockchain adoption faster than large centralized institutions.
An unknown future, and the anxiety around it
Zamani opens with a familiar feeling. Terms such as metaverse, NFTs and virtual life are everywhere, and for many people they bring stress rather than excitement. The question underneath, she says, is about trust: can we trust this future at all, and what does trust even mean here? She deliberately sets blockchain architecture aside and focuses instead on what she calls trust architecture, meaning how trust works and how it scales across a society.
She brings two perspectives to that question. In the talk she describes working with blockchain since 2015 on the practical side, while also researching and teaching blockchain adoption in small and medium enterprises as part of her PhD.
How hierarchies scaled trust, then failed it
To explain where we are heading, Zamani first looks back. Today's institutions, she argues, were born in the industrial revolution, an era of hierarchies and bureaucracy. She is clear that this model worked for a long time and scaled human cooperation a great deal. But as layers multiplied, it started to fail people, both in trust and in decision-making. Banks, governments, Facebook and other large entities lost public confidence, and fake news made people doubt the information they received.
Her diagnosis centers on distance. In a pyramid-shaped structure, information has to travel up through many layers. "So decision-maker is quite far from the source of information." (5:33) The decision-maker is equally far from the consequences of the decision, while power also flows from the bottom up. Over time, leaders drift further from the community they are supposed to serve, and their decisions come to be shaped by other interests. "And this eventually means corruption." (6:40) The more corrupted societies become, she says, the more trust is tarnished, and globalized information only sharpens the problem because local institutions cannot scale trust to match it.
From centralized Web2 to a peer-to-peer network
Zamani then compares this with the last major leap into the unknown, roughly 30 years ago, when tech giants, social media and fintech arrived. Technology boomed, but the world it created was highly centralized. "We had to place our trust on an individual, but we no longer want to do so." (7:55)
Blockchain, in her account, answers that by offering a flat, peer-to-peer, non-hierarchical network where participants do not need to know or trust each other. Trust moves from a person or organization to a mathematical or logical construct that governs the network: the consensus mechanism. Because the network becomes the model for governance, it can scale in a way hierarchies cannot.
Scaling trust is the real advantage
This is the core of her argument. Many people associate blockchain with democratized finance, cryptocurrency applications or returning data ownership to individuals. Zamani reorders those priorities. "The biggest advantage is actually scaling trust and decision making." (10:37) Data ownership and a fairer share of the economy, she says, are results of that, not the main event.
She points to decentralized autonomous organizations as an example. Instead of a director or a board deciding, an organization could have millions of participants building and deciding together. That brings information closer to decision-makers and decision-makers closer to the people affected, who are often the same people. "And the more we close this gap, the less corruption we will have." (12:02) Blockchain's immutability adds a further safeguard, since data cannot be manipulated after the fact. In her framing, data today is treated as a store of value, a medium of exchange and a unit of analysis, with centralized entities layering control on top; Web3 hands that control back to the network.
What you can and cannot trust in the transition
In the closing Q&A, Zamani agrees that decentralization threatens banks, borders and any entity whose power depends on centralized control of users' data, and says that resistance did slow adoption for a while. She is optimistic, though: as the speaker cited, 99% of the EU economy comes from small and medium enterprises, which are flatter and quicker to adopt, and could pull larger entities along.
She ends with an honest caveat. The default trust she describes applies to applications that are on the blockchain. The move from Web2 to Web3 will take time, and many tools mix both worlds, such as crypto wallets that sit off the chain. "So that doesn't mean that you can by default trust anywhere, anything around it, but you can trust anything that is on the chain." (18:44) Her advice is to keep learning and educating yourself, while worrying less than we did during the move from Web1 to Web2.
Watch the talk
Stepping into the Unknows we can trust! by Zara Zamani, about 20 minutes: https://www.womentech.net/video/stepping-unknows-we-can-trust-zara-zamani-0
About the speaker
Zara Zamani spoke at a WomenTech Network event on blockchain, trust and Web3. The session record does not include her role, company or bio; in the talk she describes working with blockchain since 2015 and researching blockchain adoption in small and medium enterprises.
Questions this talk answers
Why have centralized institutions lost people's trust?
What is blockchain's biggest advantage for society?
How does blockchain change who we have to trust?
Will decentralization threaten banks and other centralized institutions?
Can everything in Web3 be trusted by default?
Drafted with AI from the talk transcript. Editor review pending.
Frameworks and ideas mentioned
Consensus mechanism
Decentralized autonomous organizations (DAOs)
Web1, Web2 and Web3
Cite this talk
WomenTech Network. "Stepping into the Unknows we can trust! by Zara Zamani." WomenTech Network, 2022. https://www.womentech.net/video/stepping-unknows-we-can-trust-zara-zamani-0