The Spoof of Imposter Syndrome, And How This Pathology Has Been Gaslighting Women In The Workplace For Decades by Leslie Smith
20:592022
Imposter syndrome is a system problem misdiagnosed as a personal flaw
Three in four women executives, as the speaker cites, admit to feeling like frauds at work, and that doubt shapes how they negotiate pay, pursue projects and ask for promotion. Leslie Smith, national director of GET Cities, argues the label itself has been gaslighting women for decades. If the problem is not in women's heads, what has to change, and who has to change it?
See why the imposter label misleads and what leaders, allies and policy can do instead
Leslie Smith argues that imposter syndrome is a misdiagnosis that blames women, trans and non-binary people for the effects of systemic bias. She traces the concept's origins, shows how gendered expectations about confidence shape hiring and venture funding, and calls for representation, active allies, new professional norms and policy change alongside individual self-belief.
“Also, just to acknowledge that we have been gaslit by this language for a long, long, long, long time.”
“And that is you can't be what you can't see.”
What you will learn
Recognize how the imposter syndrome label shifts responsibility for systemic bias onto individual women.
Spot how expectations about confident versus cautious language affect hiring, promotion and venture funding outcomes.
Explain the pet to threat pattern and why confidence can be penalized for women, especially Black women.
Make the business case for diverse teams and for allies in leadership to act as sponsors and accomplices.
Apply individual practices such as truth-telling, boundary setting and remembering you are not alone.
Details
Level
All levels
Format
Talk
Technical depth
Non-technical
For
All career stages
Length
20:59
Published
June 2022
Questions this talk answers
Where does the idea of imposter syndrome come from?
It was derived in the 1970s by two psychologists researching high-achieving women and was originally called the imposter phenomenon.
Why is imposter syndrome a problematic label?
It focuses on an individual's feeling of a lack of worth instead of on systemic racism, classism, xenophobia, microaggressions and other workplace bias.
How do gendered expectations about confidence show up in venture capital?
Smith says men pitch with affirming, confident language while women point out every risk, and as she cites, women globally still receive less than 3% of venture capital.
Why can't women simply act more confident?
Smith explains that confident women may be rewarded at first but then come to be seen as a threat, a pattern described in Kecia Thomas's pet to threat research.
What can organizations and individuals do instead?
Increase women in leadership, engage willing men in power as allies and sponsors, drop outdated professionalism standards and push for policies like universal childcare, while individuals practice truth-telling and set boundaries.
Why imposter syndrome is the wrong diagnosis (73 s)
Confident language and the venture capital gap (73 s)
Move first to the willing: engaging allies (61 s)
Good morning chats from all over the country. It's nice to see you today. I'm excited to be with you this morning during this amazing conference. This is the week for conferences. We have Women in Tech global conference. We also have Lesbians Who Tech. And so we've been toggling back and forth between both with some online conferences. And some in-person events. So excited to be with you all this morning or this afternoon as the case may be in Lisbon. Hello, Raquel. My name is Leslie Smith and I'm the national director of GET Cities. GET Cities stands for gender equality in tech. And we're really focused on shifting power to women, trans and non-binary people in tech with a specific focus at the intersection of race.
And ethnicity ensuring that our initiative is a comprehensive and inclusive initiative. And we're really working to ensure that the tech industry is an engine for and not against equity and economic justice. So I know in that way, we all share a similar goal. We use an adaptive and iterative process. That takes different forms in each of our cities. We are currently activated In three US cities, Chicago, DC and Miami. We really take our efforts to the local level because we know that's where economies are built. That's where behaviors can be shifted and innovation can occur. It allows us to be really agile and unique. And ultimately, hopefully weaving the networks across each of those cities together, but also the networks in each of our three cities.
together. We focus on education, workforce and innovation as levers for that power and influence opportunity for women, trans and non-binary people. And work really closely with local ecosystem actors in all of our US cities. And center the technologists we seek to lift up into this work. And so, you know, having spent my entire career really focused on lifting underestimated populations into their power and influence. I've learned a couple of things and one of those things is really centering for our work. And that is you can't be what you can't see. So a lot of our efforts are designed to ensure that we're lifting up the stories of the technologists that are moving through the tech economy, what's working for them, what's not working for them, how our research
resources can prepare them, how our resources can prepare them for success or how some of the environments and or policies can impair them or prevent them from achieving success. And so knowing that we can't be what we can't see and often the stories and successes and really learnings of other technologists who look like us aren't sort of sort of prevalent in social media or other forms of media channels. I think we tend to assume that we don't belong. And so because we don't see other people that look like us in positions of power influence, and that can be as early as in our K through 12 educations, as we're moving into our considerations for university, and then ultimately as we're moving into industry, we start to assume that we start to assume that we don't belong. And it is out of I think that assumption that we don't belong comes as sort of pervasive challenge, which is it which is sort of bewilderingly entitled the imposter syndrome. And so what I wanted to talk about today with all of you is really the spoof of the imposter syndrome, and how I think the imposter
syndrome is really gaslighting us and preventing us from being great. So I have some prepared comments here, I'll run through those, I see all of your welcome notes in the chat to the extent you have a comment or a question, as I'm talking, please feel free to pop those in, I can see them sort of running as I'm moving through my notes, and I'll happily try to incorporate any thoughts that y'all have. But I'll start by I'll start by talking about what imposter syndrome is, or how it's defined, which is really the act of doubting your abilities and feeling like a fraud at work. We know that this is most often a diagnosis, unofficial diagnosis, by the way, given to women. The concept of the imposter syndrome was derived in the 70s by two psychologists who were doing some research
research on high achieving women, it was originally called the imposter phenomenon. And, and what they said is, it's data that women who suffer from it maintain a strong belief that they are not intelligent. In fact, they are convinced, they have fooled anyone who thinks otherwise. So it's this notion that in spite of our expertise, in spite of our position, in spite of our education, in spite of our experiences, we're not good enough. And any anyone who thinks we are, anyone who thinks we are, anyone who thinks we are, is sort of being fooled by us. What's also interesting is that this phenomenon occurs far less frequently in men, and when it does, it is much less intense. So in other words, men don't sort of worry about this, or think that they're in places they don't belong, or less smart than it, than it appears to people around them. What's also really interesting, 75%
75% of women executives have admitted to experiencing this. 75% of us think we're not as smart or not worthy of the places that we find ourselves. And that is really overwhelming, in the ways we negotiate our salaries, pursue projects, ask for promotion, elevate our voices in rooms where they are most necessary. for innovation, for innovation to occur, for a diverse, complex set of insights to show up in any room. So imagine that, like, in any room you find yourself, up to 75% of the women can be feeling this sort of sense of being an imposter.
The problem with this is, you know, even the fact that it's considered a legitimate diagnosis is really a problem, because we know it's, it's, it is a huge and shocking number, mostly. Yeah, Marina, I got you. But when the room gets more full, hopefully, we'll, we'll, we'll know that we're in good company, right, relative to this imposter syndrome.
The, the syndrome itself, I think is, is really mostly problematic because it focuses more on the individual, a feeling or a sort of sense of a lack of worth. Instead of really focusing on systemic racism, classism, xenophobia, workplace, microaggressions, and, and other bias that exists in the workplace, it's, it's, again, sort of the unique and complete burden of women, trans and non-binary people to sort of carry their value in a room.
And the concept of this imposter syndrome is unfairly sort of individualized instead of looking at the systems that perpetuate the advancement of predominantly cis white men who don't suffer from, from this. And the theme of this imposter syndrome takes on this like universal feeling of discomfort or second guessing or anxiety, and it's so typically pathologized, especially for women.
And, Catherine, Catherine, we're going to get to that. What's also interesting, and we see this in venture capital outcomes is that men tend to be overconfident in their accomplishments and abilities. I recently gave a keynote about AI and some of the ways that artificial intelligence is really negatively impacting marginalized groups across society in particular, relative to the use of language.
And men tend to use far more affirming, confident, and positive language, whereas women use far more limiting language. There's been a huge amount of research done on this. And even in that sort of expression of strength in language, we're seeing resumes get sort of handled differently, interviews being handed out differently, and job offers being made differently. So just as sort of one example of the way that shows up in venture capital outcomes, where women sort of globally are still getting less than 3% of the total allotted capital available in the venture capital streams.
It is, obviously, it's related to a variety of things, sort of homophony and the behavior that ensures that we grant access and/or capital to people who look like us. But also is in the way language is used in pitching of ideas to venture capitalists, where men are always very promoting and positive and act as if all of the things they say have or will happen.
Whereas women are far more limiting and ensuring that every risk that exists is sort of pointed out as a potential failure. So that's just one way that this sort of, I think, urging to not oversell or appear overly confident is showing up in this imposter syndrome. There's also this really interesting phenomenon where men are rewarded, not only in getting the job or getting the capital, but getting the project, getting the promotion, getting the raise.
There's always ways. The opposite is true when women are sort of advanced using an overly confident posture or language, who are often at the beginning rewarded, but as they sort of lean forward through their work with this sort of confidence or in the absence of an imposter syndrome, they can switch from being really idolized. Or appreciated to appearing as a threat.
And that was studied really well in Keisha Thomas's pet to threat where black women are often brought into spaces and initially well received and paraded around as this sort of diverse icon in the space. But they're seen as competition or a threat as soon as folks start to support them as soon as folks start to support them.
And we're continuing to do this now. So I think paying attention to how we feel individually is important, but it's also like, how do we unpack and organize our systems differently? Clearly, at GATT, one of the things we think is important is that we have more women represented in leadership. Earlier in the chat, I saw someone comment about being the only woman in the room.
It's hard to bring this sort of empathy and confidence and collegiality when there just aren't as many women in the room. So one of our goals is just to increase the percentage of women across the C-suite. So I think there's a couple of things that we think is important. I hit on this earlier, but sort of telling a new story, right?
The time has come for us to recognize that we're doing this, that it's being thrown at us, that we're adopting it and internalizing it. And unfortunately, often believing it and start to just sort of shed that as a trope that we're willing to advance or a belief that we're willing to accept as a community of women. So, yeah, these comments are occasionally really just throwing me for a loop.
Also, just to acknowledge that we have been gaslit by this language for a long, long, long, long time. And because we feel like we have to be twice as good to get half as much, the additional sort of burden of feeling as if we don't belong slows us down. I think what I would love to see us do is sort of shift the mindset from we don't belong and sort of begin really adopting the sort of business case for why we do belong.
I think the civic activities of hiring more diverse and complex teams falls away as soon as the moment that called us into it fades away. And, you know, the data, science and math on this are real clear. Diverse teams perform better. And as such, we should continue making the economic case for that. But it's also the only way we're going to bring innovation that serves the entirety of society.
So long as tech solutions are being built almost singularly by cis white men, they the innovations that are created there are going to sit in unique service to cis white men who make up a smaller percentage of the population than they do the percentage of the overall tech workforce. So bringing that sort of balance will ensure that the innovation is not only sort of truly disruptive and bleeding edge, but also is empathetic and inclusive the needs of our entire society.
So, I think that's really important. I think that that's really important. I think that's really important. And I think that's really important. But by creating workplaces that are racial, ethnic, and genderly are balanced from a gender perspective is really important. And it's important that in those systems, we're not sort of othered or diminished or marginalized. We're running a program at Get Cities called Get Champions, which is really designed to educate and empower cis white men in positions of leadership across the tech economy to become better accomplices, allies, and sponsors.
Because what's also true is that sort of the plight of the oppressed is not singularly solved by those of us who are oppressed by the system. The people in positions of power across the system also have to change. And our strategy relative to that is really to move first to the willing. Which means if you're willing to be a better ally, accomplice, or sponsor of women, trans, and non-binary people in your workplace, we are going to engage you and help show you a path to creating a more belonging, welcoming, and inclusive environment.
I also think we have to let go of these outdated standards of professionalism, like never showing emotion at work, right? Wearing certain hairstyles, assuming that only women, trans, and non-binary people have family obligations and have to take care of the children. This whole notion of parental taxing that's occurring. I mean, we've just seen on blast through COVID what happens when the weight of the care for family and home is disproportionately placed on women.
So, you know, I believe really strongly there are some policy solutions, you know, universal childcare and pre-K being one of them. I think there are some universal healthcare standards that exist across the globe that don't necessarily exist in the U.S. that I think will better create balance across the cis white male and women, trans, and non-binary responsibilities.
I also think we have to continue to, again, tell the stories of these women, trans, and non-binary leaders so that we can see ourselves in other, and we can know that we belong. And we can know that we're smart enough. And then we have to be able to recognize these behaviors and call them out. At GATT, we call it truth-telling.
We just have to be able to sort of speak our truths. Solutions for individuals, I think, is really like reminding ourselves that we have inherent value. setting boundaries to protect our sort of mental health and space, but often that we're not alone in feeling this way. I'm seeing sort of strung through the chat fear of calling out the truth is that we get blackballed, which is a very real fear and has to be sort of managed carefully.
Claudia, I agree. We have to believe that we belong there, but I also think that sort of oversimplifies the pressure that the systems are putting on us to adopt that behavior in the first place. So I think it's sort of a both-and situation there. And then I said it earlier, and I'll say it again. I think a broad-based set of policy solutions is really important for us to continue to balance the weight of this inequity.
As you can see, it's 10:50. I could talk to you and/or chat with you in this chat box for hours and hours and hours and hours, but I think we're only granted 20 minutes of time to spend together. And so thank you, Claudia. With that, I want to thank you so much. It was amazing to spend time with you.
Your comments in the chat confirm for me that this is a real challenge for all of us and that the world will be a better, more productive, and just place as each of you continue your path toward your power and influence of the tech economy. And so I thank you ever so much for joining me. People are asking for my LinkedIn handle, which I am trying to masterfully handle getting to you as we exit.
There it is. Thank you for asking. It's also in my profile. Feel free to link up with me. And I look forward to working with each of you to advance the plight of women, trans, and non-binary people across the tech economy in the future. Have a great day. Thank you.
Transcribed automatically; names checked against the speaker record. Select a time to jump there.
Article based on this talk
Is imposter syndrome really a personal flaw, or a symptom of biased systems?
Leslie Smith argues that the imposter label has gaslit women for decades and that the fix lies in systems, allies and policy as much as in self-belief.
In short
Leslie Smith argues that imposter syndrome is less a condition women suffer from than a label that hides systemic bias. The concept, she explains, puts the burden of proving worth on women, trans and non-binary people, while the systems that reward confident men go unexamined. Her answer is a "both-and": believe you belong, and also change representation, allyship, professional norms and policy.
Key takeaways
Recognize how the imposter syndrome label shifts responsibility for systemic bias onto individual women.
Spot how expectations about confident versus cautious language affect hiring, promotion and venture funding outcomes.
Explain the pet to threat pattern and why confidence can be penalized for women, especially Black women.
Make the business case for diverse teams and for allies in leadership to act as sponsors and accomplices.
Apply individual practices such as truth-telling, boundary setting and remembering you are not alone.
You can't be what you can't see
Smith opens with the work of GET Cities (gender equality in tech), which she describes as shifting power to women, trans and non-binary people in tech, with a specific focus on the intersection of race and ethnicity. The initiative works locally in Chicago, Washington DC and Miami, using education, workforce and innovation as levers.
A principle runs through that work: "And that is you can't be what you can't see." (1:59) When people do not see others who look like them in positions of power, from school through university and into industry, Smith says they start to assume they do not belong. Out of that assumption, she argues, comes the pervasive challenge that has been "bewilderingly" named imposter syndrome.
What imposter syndrome is, and why the label is the problem
Smith defines imposter syndrome as doubting your abilities and feeling like a fraud at work, an unofficial diagnosis most often given to women. She explains that the concept was derived in the 1970s by two psychologists researching high-achieving women, originally under the name imposter phenomenon, and that it occurs less frequently and less intensely in men.
The scale matters. As the speaker cited, 75% of women executives have admitted to experiencing it, and she connects that doubt to how women negotiate salaries, pursue projects, ask for promotion and raise their voices in rooms where diverse insight is most needed.
Yet her central point is that treating this as an individual condition misses the cause. "And the concept of this imposter syndrome is unfairly sort of individualized instead of looking at the systems that perpetuate the advancement of predominantly cis white men who don't suffer from, from this." (8:23) Instead of addressing systemic racism, classism, xenophobia, microaggressions and other workplace bias, the label leaves women, trans and non-binary people to carry the burden of proving their value.
Confidence, language and the pet to threat trap
Smith shows how expectations about confidence play out in practice. Drawing on her work on AI and language, she says men tend to use more affirming, confident language while women use more limiting language, with consequences for how resumes, interviews and job offers are handled. In venture capital, she notes, men pitch as if everything they say has happened or will happen. "Whereas women are far more limiting and ensuring that every risk that exists is sort of pointed out as a potential failure." (10:36) As the speaker cited, women globally still receive less than 3% of available venture capital.
The obvious advice, to simply be more confident, does not hold up either. Smith points to Kecia Thomas's pet to threat research: Black women are often welcomed into spaces and showcased at first, then seen as competition or a threat once they gain support. Confidence that is rewarded in men can turn women from appreciated to threatening.
Telling a new story about belonging
Smith asks the audience to name what has been happening. "Also, just to acknowledge that we have been gaslit by this language for a long, long, long, long time." (13:42) Because women feel they must be twice as good to get half as much, she says, the added burden of feeling they do not belong slows them down.
Her proposed shift is from "we don't belong" to the business case for why they do. She argues that diversity efforts driven by a passing moment fade, while the evidence that diverse teams perform better endures. She also makes an innovation argument: technology built almost singularly by cis white men will serve them first, so balanced teams are needed for innovation that is both disruptive and inclusive of the whole of society. GET Cities, she adds, aims to increase the share of women across the C-suite.
Allies, outdated norms and policy
Smith is clear that the people affected cannot solve this alone. "The people in positions of power across the system also have to change." (16:25) Through the GET Champions program, GET Cities educates cis white men in tech leadership to become better accomplices, allies and sponsors, with a strategy to "move first to the willing".
She also calls for dropping outdated professional standards. "I also think we have to let go of these outdated standards of professionalism, like never showing emotion at work, right?" (16:55) That includes assumptions about hairstyles and about who carries family obligations, a burden she says COVID exposed. She points to policy solutions such as universal childcare and pre-K, and healthcare standards that exist elsewhere but not in the US.
Truth-telling and what individuals can do
Finally, Smith returns to stories and to naming behavior. At GET Cities, she says, this is called truth-telling. "We just have to be able to sort of speak our truths." (18:22) For individuals, she recommends remembering your inherent value, setting boundaries to protect mental health, and knowing you are not alone. She acknowledges audience fears of being blackballed for speaking up as real, and responds to a comment that women must believe they belong by calling it a "both-and situation": self-belief matters, but it cannot replace changing the systems that create the pressure.
Watch the talk
The Spoof of Imposter Syndrome, And How This Pathology Has Been Gaslighting Women In The Workplace For Decades, by Leslie Smith (21 minutes): https://www.womentech.net/video/spoof-imposter-syndrome-and-how-pathology-has-been-gaslighting-women-in-workplace-decades-0
About the speaker
In the talk, Leslie Smith introduces herself as national director of GET Cities, an initiative focused on shifting power to women, trans and non-binary people in tech, with attention to the intersection of race and ethnicity. She describes having spent her career lifting underestimated populations into power and influence.
Questions this talk answers
Where does the idea of imposter syndrome come from?
Why is imposter syndrome a problematic label?
How do gendered expectations about confidence show up in venture capital?
Why can't women simply act more confident?
What can organizations and individuals do instead?
Drafted with AI from the talk transcript. Editor review pending.
Frameworks and ideas mentioned
Imposter phenomenon
Pet to threat
Resources mentioned
Kecia Thomas's pet to threat research
GET Champions program (GET Cities)
Cite this talk
WomenTech Network. "The Spoof of Imposter Syndrome, And How This Pathology Has Been Gaslighting Women In The Workplace For Decades by Leslie Smith." WomenTech Network, 2022. https://www.womentech.net/video/spoof-imposter-syndrome-and-how-pathology-has-been-gaslighting-women-in-workplace-decades-0