Meaningful Impact: Making the Case for DEI Programs
Sabrina Macpherson19:572022
Why a well-run DEI program is capitalism, not a political agenda
Outside the DEI echo chamber, friends tell her the work is just "very on trend", and critics on both the far left and far right have reasons to reject it. Sabrina Macpherson, who has led DEI for Morningstar Canada for six years, takes those objections head on. For leaders weighing whether diversity work deserves a place in strategy, the question is what separates a program with real impact from buzzword bingo.
Get the case for DEI and the principles that keep programs from becoming performative
Sabrina Macpherson, Senior Product Manager at Morningstar and longtime DEI leader, argues that diversity, equity and inclusion work belongs in every organization's strategy for two reasons: ethics and stakeholder capitalism. She answers critiques from both the far left and the far right, contrasts effective programs with performative ones, and offers principles for running DEI as a data-driven, people-centered part of the business.
“Employees are no longer faceless resources you can throw at the wall of your projects until they burn out. They are stakeholders and you have to consider what they want.”
“Ineffective DEI programs is frankly where all of the critiques come from. It is performative and it is where you see it being run like a game of buzzword bingo, right?”
What you will learn
Articulate the ethical and stakeholder-capitalism case for DEI to skeptical leaders.
Respond to the most common critiques of DEI from both the political left and right.
Distinguish effective DEI programs from performative ones using goals, metrics and transparency.
Plan short-term wins and long-term goals such as pay equity and leadership parity.
Set up a data-driven DEI program with baselines, transparent KPIs and a dedicated paid team.
Key takeaways from the speaker
There is a case for DEI work, from both an ethical and business perspective, that should be lined out for leaders engaged in the work
DEI programs do not automatically have meaningful impact; they require a specific kind of activity and structure
DEI programs do not belong to either end of the political ideology spectrum. They are another realization of stakeholder capitalism.
Key guiding principles that will help guide your DEI program to success and meaningful impact.
Details
Level
Intermediate
Format
Talk
Technical depth
Non-technical
For
People manager, Executive
Length
19:57
Published
July 2022
Questions this talk answers
Why should businesses do DEI work at all?
Macpherson gives two reasons: ethics, because everyone deserves fair treatment and equal access to opportunity, and capitalism, because employees, clients, millennials and Gen Z now judge how a business operates.
Is DEI a political agenda?
She argues it can be politicized but is politically neutral, describing it as sustainable business decisions and stakeholder capitalism rather than politics.
How do you answer critics who say DEI cannot work inside capitalism?
She says not to let the perfect be the enemy of the good: helping people now through pay equity and flexible schedules matters, and incremental change is how progress has always been made.
What makes a DEI program performative rather than effective?
Performative programs throw jargon around with no goals, metrics or transparency, ignore the disengaged, avoid the hard parts of equity and inclusion, and offer no training.
How do you set up a DEI program for long-term success?
Treat it like any other business area with data baselines and transparent KPIs, fund a dedicated paid team, balance short-term wins with long-term goals, pay external experts, make room for dissent and keep the focus on people.
About this talk
I spend a lot of time and energy promoting psychological safety and diversity to business audiences, and I work to execute programs that achieve equity and inclusion in meaningful ways. For those people who don’t have the perspective that I do, or who only ever see the performative programs run in some organizations, I think it’s fair to lay out the case for why a well-run DEI program should be a key part of every organization’s strategic objectives. I want to answer the question: “Why do we take it for granted that this work should be done in a professional environment?”
I’ll start by talking about the first principles: why should this work be done? Then I’ll speak about effective diversity work in a professional context, both what it is and what it is not. From that I will take time to address the most pointed criticisms leveled at the work from both the leftmost and rightmost arms of the political spectrum - to establish that the value in this work is outside of any political ideology or affiliation. I’ll conclude by talking about what you need to do if you want to avoid the pitfalls that lead to performative programs, and set your organization up for sustainable success.
Free speech versus the workplace social contract (62 s)
Effective DEI versus buzzword bingo (69 s)
All right. So thanks, everyone. Sorry for the delay. Just had to get help from the excellent tech team in getting these slides to share. Really appreciate your patience. So hi, my name is Sabrina Macpherson. I am here to talk about meaningful impact, which is about making the case for an effective diversity, equity and inclusion program. So let's get started.
So I'm going to start by talking about who I am. Why should you even listen to me on this topic? I'm going to talk about why I think we need to make the case for DEI and why it's not clear that everybody knows why we should be doing this work. Then I'll talk about why should we be doing this work in a professional context? There's two main reasons. Then I'm going to, as part of that making the case, address the critiques that come about this work from both the leftmost and the rightmost arms, the political spectrum. I'm hoping by doing that, that I can and prove that this work itself is not political. And then I'll wrap with some tips, some ideas, some strategies for how to set your organization up for success when it comes to diversity, equity and inclusion work.
So quick intro. Who am I? I am a senior product manager. I work for Morningstar. If you're not familiar with us, we are a fintech company. We gather data and research. We put it into products to help people make better investing decisions. So I myself work in data and technology and in strategy. I'm also a DEI leader. I have been the president of the Americas chapter of out at Morningstar, which is our LGBTQ employee resource group for the last two years.
I've been a DEI leader in the Canada region for six years and been a partner in building internal and external DEI work streams in our technology org, both with internal partners and external partners like Amazon works, web services with William Blair and West Monroe partners, among others. I've also led leadership training for managers, not explicitly about DEI, but when you're talking about inclusive and successful teams, DEI does come up. And I'm also, I'm not usually in the habit of sharing my political views with a bunch of strangers, but I am also what my friends love to call a raging centrist.
And because I'm about to talk about political perspectives and left and right, I think it's only fair that I point out, I don't have a dog in either fight. I really, I lean left on some issues and right on others. And if you were to measure me, I probably map right in the middle. I hope that gives me a relatively neutral perspective to make the points that I'm going to make later today.
So enough about me, let's talk about why we need to make the case. So when you work in DEI and you talk about people, with people about this work, you tend to get into echo chambers, right? Everybody thinks, yeah, yeah, they're nodding along affirmatively. I agree with everything you're saying. But if I talk to people who don't work in this space, or if I talk to friends who aren't involved in businesses that do this work, I hear, you know, oh, DEI, yeah, it's very on trend.
It's very on trend. And unfortunately, it is a trend right now, you have a wide variety of companies that are realizing this is popular, it's important, and so they're picking up on it. And I wanted to be able to make the case outside of the echo chamber for why we should be doing this work, I wanted to make, you know, a convincing case, and particularly to those people who think that DEI work is driven by a particular political agenda.
I wanted to prove that it's valuable to business, and that it isn't necessarily assigned to one political tribe. So I think especially now, when we have so many companies hopping on this bandwagon and using these very trendy terms, we need to establish what's really impactful to people's lives and what's simply performative. So why, why should we be doing this work in business? Well, I argue that business success is all about satisfying your market and your stakeholders. The difference is that your market and your stakeholders has changed. And whether you're an industry, you're an educational institution, or you're a nonprofit, the list of people that your organization has to care about your stakeholders, and fundamentally, what they care about has changed.
So I'm going to talk in detail about who those stakeholders are. But what it comes down to is this, your business needs diversity, equity and inclusion work as part of your business strategy. And the two reasons come down to ethics and capitalism. So let's dive into that first one. At heart, at its core, professional diversity and equity and inclusion work believes that everyone has an inherent right to be treated fairly and justly, and that everyone should have an equal access to opportunity, regardless of their identity, so they're free to pursue it to the best of their abilities.
Now, if you believe these things are true, and you are an organization that has responsibility and power over individuals, whether those are clients or stakeholders or prospects or employees, then you have two responsibilities, you have to acknowledge that historically, these statements haven't always been true universally. Not everybody has always been treated fairly and just justly in a business environment, even though they have the right to be. And not everybody has always had equal access to opportunity, regardless of their identity. We know historically, that slices of identity have had significantly more access to power and opportunity than others.
So if you acknowledge that these things have not been universally true in the past, then you have to commit to doing the work in your sphere of influence to bring these statements to life. That is the ethics behind DEI work. And I can already hear and have heard some objections in my professional DEI work. Hang on, hang on. I didn't get into this business for philosophy class. Why are you talking to me about ethics?
Well, if you are an organization, business or nonprofit or educational, and you want to thrive over the next 40 years, you have to care about millennials and Gen Z. Millennials and Gen Z are getting older. The oldest of the millennials, myself included, is turning 41 this year. Millennials and Gen Z are getting older, gaining political capital, gaining financial capital, they are looking for ways to spend their money and their influence to donate to invest.
And they don't just care about the fact that you do business. They care about how you do business. When we talk about socially responsible, it's critical to this cohort. And if you want to thrive as a business, whether these are clients, donors, employees, shareholders, attracting this cohort is going to need evidence of your ethics in practice. Now, there's lots of different ways you can do that. They're going to look at your mission statement and your values statement and then look at how you do business and see how they match up.
But diversity, equity and inclusion work is a key way that you're going to be able to provide that evidence to this group. And I hope this rolls quite nicely into my second part, which is that stakeholder capitalism isn't new. Capitalism and business has always been about satisfying your stakeholders. It's just that it used to be limited to the market of people who might buy your product and the people who are buying your shares.
That list has significantly changed. As I said, it includes employees now. Employees are no longer faceless resources you can throw at the wall of your projects until they burn out. They are stakeholders and you have to consider what they want. This includes potential employees. It includes your clients and your prospects who are all fully aware of your brand, whether they're contributing to your success right now or not.
It's important to know that right now, if you can't show how you're investing in DEI work and you can't show importantly how that work goes beyond the surface layer, you're going to lose market share and you're going to lose brand capital. And on this topic, I don't necessarily want you to just take my word for it. Larry Fink is the CEO of BlackRock International.
Every year he writes a letter to CEOs and this year he included quite a section on stakeholder capitalism and socially responsible business. And he makes the point this is not about politics. It's not about an ideological agenda. It is capitalism. It's mutual beneficial relationships. And he points out your employees, your customers, your suppliers, the community all around you and your company that you need to prosper.
So I argue that this work is truly capitalism at its finest. So now I'm going to talk a little bit about how DEI work itself is not political in nature. It can certainly be politicized, but it itself is politically neutral and I think has its most value when it doesn't ascribe to a particular political tribe. So I'm going to try and make this case by reviewing the criticisms that come of this work from the different arms of the political spectrum.
And then hopefully establish it doesn't really belong to either and talk about the next steps. So first let's talk about the criticism that comes from the left most arm of the political spectrum. This group of political thinkers believes that regardless of the intentions of people inside a corporation or a capitalist organization, that you can't meaningfully address inequity and injustice within that framework.
That capitalism itself is inequitable. And so their argument is that you shouldn't be doing this work in a corporate setting, that capitalism has to be torn down before you can even approach equity and justice. And then related to that, sometimes it's separate. Sometimes there's a deferral of, okay, yes, you could do it in a corporate setting, but incremental settings are incomplete.
And in corporate settings, you can only ever get these settling for less solutions. So those are the key points that come from that arm. My response here is, you know, to pull out that old Voltaire quote. Don't let the perfect be the enemy of the good. Now, where I talk about the difference between helping people now and helping people in a potential future.
So if I have the option of making a difference for people's lives now, making strides toward pay equity in my company, so that makes a difference to people's lives or making it easier to have flexible schedules, because I know that different people have different caregiving responsibilities, whether that's for children or elders. I can make these meaningful differences right now versus helping in a potential future where something large and systematic has changed.
I would rather make the choice to help people now. And in terms of incremental advancements, I would argue that is the only way we make progress. If you think about the slow but steady changes we've seen over the last 40 to 60 years, it's been because of people making slow but steady changes within the existing system. So, you know, think about explaining DEI practice to your parents or your grandparents.
My dad was a progressive guy for his era, worked in corporate offices in the 80s and 90s, and, you know, probably would have thought it's a pipe dream if I explained this kind of work to him. My grandfather, on the other hand, it wouldn't have mattered to him. It wouldn't have made sense to him that we do this work.
He wouldn't have understand the reasons for it, let alone me sitting here as a woman who's a leader in business, explaining it to a group of people who's eager to listen to me. So we have made significant process. It's slow, but it's steady. Now I'm going to talk about the criticism that comes from the rightmost wing of the political spectrum.
So here it breaks into three categories. One, you'll often hear DEI requires policing of speech, which is a, you know, attack on a fundamental force. Of freedom. Or that DEI is an attack on straight white men and it actually makes their lives worse. Finally, you'll hear people argue that DEI work being done business is forcing leftist politics onto an organization.
And that's not fair to people who signed up for an organization, not for leftist politics or a political agenda. So I'll respond to that. You know, first, in terms of freedom of speech, having a social contract doesn't equal restricting your free speech. When you join an organization, particularly those of us who work in a corporate office type environment, you often walk in and you have a social contract and an agreement of how you're going to behave and how others are going to behave towards you.
My favorite example of this is asking, do you swear when you're at work, right? When I'm around my friends or my husband, it's, you know, occasionally I swear, but when it comes to a business meeting, I am using polite and professional language. I'm holding myself in a professional way and I expect others to do the same. The only difference with DEI workers that we're now explicitly saying, along with polite professional language, that you can't be using racist, sexist, ableist, homophobic, transphobic language as part of that social contract.
The agreement you make to be part of this work community. The argument about it not being fair to straight white men. Well, I argue back that DEI represents the arrival of a true meritocracy. We are effectively saying that we want to change the historical division of power and resources. We know it's always been heavily weighted to one particular group.
We want to open up access to multiple groups and provide paths of opportunity to multiple groups. Now, can that seem more difficult to some people? Yes. Yes, it can. Because if you've always had access to all the power and resources, it will seem unfair that you have to now share it across multiple groups. But is it more fair to everyone?
Does it represent a more just meritocracy where everyone who has the ability can go and achieve? Yes. Yes, it is more fair. Finally, I hope that I've established by now that DEI is about sustainable business decisions. Not about politics. This is true both inside and outside your organization. Employees who feel safe and included are shown in study after study to be more innovative and more productive.
And stakeholders who feel that you're making responsible choices for the success of your business are willing to invest more in your business. So this is about business decisions. It's really not about politics. So, now that we've talked about that, I'm going to talk about what we can do. How do you have guidelines for sustainable success in DEI, a program that lasts over the long term?
So, first we need to think about when is it being done right? How do you know when it's effective and having meaningful impact in people's lives or when it's ineffective? So, when you see an effective DEI program, you're going to see them setting goals. There's going to be clear tracking and sharing of progress. You'll see incremental and consistent improvements.
Consistency is key. Constantly seeking and encouraging candid feedback. And being willing to have necessary difficult conversations when you have people who are challenging the work. Ineffective DEI programs is frankly where all of the critiques come from. It is performative and it is where you see it being run like a game of buzzword bingo, right? You see executives throwing jargon at the wall and hoping that something sticks.
But there are no goals. There's no metrics. There's no transparency. And so, there's no progress. You can't prove or disprove that you've done anything. It's also ineffective to ignore the disengaged. Oh, you don't like DEI or you don't want to talk about it. So, we're just not going to talk to you. Well, that's not helpful fundamentally. It also, you can tell when people are avoiding the difficult parts of equity and inclusion.
Equity is hard. Equity is about changing things in your company so that people do have equal access. That's hard work. And inclusion is even harder. That's about making people feel like they genuinely belong and they have a place. That's emotional and mental work on top of the daily work of doing your job and delivering to the bottom line.
And where it's also ineffective is where you have no training or guidance. Because how can you expect anyone from your entry level to your C-suite to do this work effectively if you don't teach them how? So, here are the ways that I think you can set up a program for success. Number one, treat it like any other area of your business.
It has to be data driven. You have to know your baselines. What are your population demographics right now? What is your employee base saying about their satisfaction rates and how do they feel? Are your psychological safety level okay? And find out about what your industry and market is doing. How good are they at it? Can you be better than them?
Because that's a competitive advantage for you. You want to have transparent KPIs and communications. I've said that before. It's got to be crystal clear. And it requires a dedicated paid team. You are going to need an army of volunteers to help bolster and support that team. But you need someone who is being paid to direct it and lead it.
And you have to ask yourselves, how diverse is your DEI team? You know, do they all look the same? Can you bring in more people from the community you're trying to serve to diversify your DEI team and make it more effective? Now, you need to think about the short game and the long game. Helping people in a meaningful way can take time.
So, you've got to think about long-term plans that you'll show progress with over time and then short-term wins that build trust and credibility. So, short-term can include developing employee resource groups, providing flexible work for people, providing education and development events. Long-term, you're going to be thinking about things like pay equity and talent development and making sure that you have leadership parity.
So, developing your team that makes sure that your C-suite eventually looks like the community you're trying to serve. That's a long game. And so, you have to think about all of those different plans. You're also going to need to listen to and learn from experts who are already doing the work. You have lots of great organizations right now who will be able to put your job postings in front of communities that you want to invite into your workplace and will give you all kinds of great information on strategy.
But please pay them for their expertise and their services. I shouldn't have to say this, but it is amazing how many professional organizations will go to organizations and services who are doing work in diversity and equity and inclusion and expect to get the work for free. Don't do that. Number three is really important. Really, really important. You can't shy away from the hard stuff.
You can't stifle dissent and discomfort. You have to make the space for hard conversations where people are saying, I don't want to do this work or I don't think this work has any business in a business place. That's an important conversation to have and you have to be open to it. And really importantly, you have to make the work about people, not about politics or policies.
There's an old saying, soldiers don't fight for king and country. They fight for the men and women in the trenches beside them. And it's true. You want to make this about the people in your company and how you're helping them and the stories about their lives. That's what people relate to and connect to. And not just about policies either.
Your guiding question can't be, what policy am I going to build now? It's how is this really going to help people? How am I making people's lives better? These are hard questions. And to do it right, these are the questions you have to answer. And finally, I'll say this is a journey. This work is never done. There's not a finish line that you can cross and say, yeah, we did it.
We solved diversity. It doesn't work that way. You have to continue asking. You're accountable to your stakeholders. That's your employees, your clients, your prospects, your potential candidates, your shareholders, your community, everybody. What's next? How can we be better? I promise you the results will show up and they will show up in improved employee satisfaction, improved retention of talent that you've taken time to develop, increased engagement in your employees, and what we've seen in study after study, more innovation and creativity.
And really, that's what we want. Any organization should be doing this work so that we have a group of happier people who are more committed to producing great stuff and putting it out there in the world. I want to thank you so much for your time. We'll see you next time.
Transcribed automatically; names checked against the speaker record. Select a time to jump there.
Article based on this talk
Why DEI belongs in business strategy, and how to keep it from becoming performative
Sabrina Macpherson makes the ethical and capitalist case for diversity, equity and inclusion, answers critics on both political flanks, and lays out what effective programs do.
In short
Sabrina Macpherson argues that diversity, equity and inclusion work belongs in every organization's strategy for two reasons: ethics and capitalism. She contends that DEI is not owned by either end of the political spectrum, that most criticism targets performative programs, and that effective programs are data driven, transparent, properly funded and centered on people rather than policies.
Key takeaways
There is a case for DEI work, from both an ethical and a business perspective, that should be laid out for leaders engaged in the work.
DEI programs do not automatically have meaningful impact; they require a specific kind of activity and structure.
DEI programs do not belong to either end of the political ideology spectrum. They are another realization of stakeholder capitalism.
Key guiding principles will help steer your DEI program to success and meaningful impact.
Making the case outside the echo chamber
Macpherson, a senior product manager at Morningstar who has led DEI work in the company's Canada region for six years, starts from a problem she sees often. Inside DEI circles, everyone nods along. Outside them, she hears that DEI is simply "very on trend", and some people assume it is driven by a political agenda. With many companies adopting the language without the substance, she believes it is time to separate what changes people's lives from what is merely performative.
She is open about her own position, describing herself as a "raging centrist" who leans left on some issues and right on others, which she hopes gives her a relatively neutral vantage point. Her goal is explicit:
"I wanted to prove that it's valuable to business, and that it isn't necessarily assigned to one political tribe." (3:17)
Ethics and stakeholder capitalism
The first reason is ethical. Professional DEI work rests on the belief that everyone has a right to fair and just treatment and equal access to opportunity regardless of identity. Macpherson argues that any organization with power over clients, employees or other stakeholders must acknowledge that this has not always been true historically, and then commit to making it true within its own sphere of influence.
The second reason is capitalism. She points to millennials and Gen Z, who are gaining financial and political capital and care not just that a company does business but how it does business. Business has always been about satisfying stakeholders, she says; what has changed is who counts as one.
"Employees are no longer faceless resources you can throw at the wall of your projects until they burn out. They are stakeholders and you have to consider what they want." (6:53)
She cites Larry Fink's annual letter to CEOs, which, as the speaker described it, framed stakeholder capitalism as mutually beneficial relationships rather than an ideological agenda. Her conclusion: "So I argue that this work is truly capitalism at its finest." (8:02)
Answering critics on the left and the right
From the far left, Macpherson hears that inequity cannot be meaningfully addressed inside capitalism and that incremental corporate solutions mean settling for less. Her answer is to help people now, through steps such as pay equity and flexible schedules for caregivers, rather than wait for a future systemic change. She points to the slow but steady progress of recent decades, noting that her grandfather would not have understood this work at all.
"Don't let the perfect be the enemy of the good." (9:13)
From the far right, she addresses three objections. On free speech, she compares DEI norms to not swearing in a business meeting: a social contract about professional conduct, not a restriction on speech. On the claim that DEI harms straight white men, she reframes the work as opening access to power and resources that were historically concentrated in one group.
"Well, I argue back that DEI represents the arrival of a true meritocracy." (12:32)
On the charge of leftist politics, she returns to business outcomes, saying that employees who feel safe and included are shown "in study after study", as she put it, to be more innovative and productive.
Effective versus performative programs
Macpherson draws a sharp line between programs that work and those that do not. Effective programs set goals, track and share progress, improve consistently, seek candid feedback and are willing to have difficult conversations with people who challenge the work. Ineffective ones lack goals, metrics and transparency, ignore disengaged employees, avoid the hard parts of equity and inclusion, and offer no training.
"Ineffective DEI programs is frankly where all of the critiques come from. It is performative and it is where you see it being run like a game of buzzword bingo, right?" (14:22)
She stresses that equity, which means changing systems so people have equal access, is hard, and that inclusion, making people feel they genuinely belong, is even harder.
Principles for sustainable success
Her guidance for leaders starts with treating DEI like any other area of the business. That means knowing baselines such as population demographics, employee satisfaction and psychological safety, benchmarking against the industry, and publishing transparent KPIs. It also requires a dedicated, paid team supported by volunteers, and a team that is itself diverse.
She recommends balancing a short game and a long game. Short-term wins such as employee resource groups, flexible work and education events build trust, while long-term goals include pay equity, talent development and leadership parity. Leaders should learn from expert organizations already doing the work and pay them:
"But please pay them for their expertise and their services." (17:43)
Finally, she urges leaders not to stifle dissent, to make the work about people rather than politics or policies, and to treat it as ongoing accountability to every stakeholder.
"This work is never done. There's not a finish line that you can cross and say, yeah, we did it." (18:44)
The results she promises are improved employee satisfaction, better retention of talent, higher engagement and more innovation and creativity.
Watch the talk
"Meaningful Impact: Making the Case for DEI Programs" by Sabrina Macpherson, 20 minutes: https://www.womentech.net/video/meaningful-impact-making-case-dei-programs-sabrina-macpherson
About the speaker
Sabrina Macpherson is a Senior Product Manager, Enterprise Data Platform at Morningstar, where she focuses on delivering data through innovative technology solutions and has led leadership training for managers on psychological safety and innovation. She is President of the Americas chapter of Morningstar's LGBTQ+ employee resource group and served as the Lead of DEI for Morningstar Canada for six years.
Questions this talk answers
Why should businesses do DEI work at all?
Is DEI a political agenda?
How do you answer critics who say DEI cannot work inside capitalism?
What makes a DEI program performative rather than effective?
How do you set up a DEI program for long-term success?
Drafted with AI from the talk transcript. Editor review pending.
Frameworks and ideas mentioned
Stakeholder capitalism
Psychological safety
Resources mentioned
Larry Fink's annual letter to CEOs
Cite this talk
Sabrina Macpherson. "Meaningful Impact: Making the Case for DEI Programs." WomenTech Network, 2022. https://www.womentech.net/video/meaningful-impact-making-case-dei-programs-sabrina-macpherson