A leader told her she smiles too much to be promoted
Every successful launch felt like a fluke, every skip-level meeting made her wonder why she had been invited, and one leader told her she smiled too much to be taken seriously. PayPal Senior Product Manager Ronke Majekodunmi talks candidly with her mentor Beth Hayden about where that self-doubt came from and how exhausting it became. What actually quiets the voice that says you are a fraud?
Learn the four habits Ronke uses to turn imposter feelings into confident, authentic leadership
In this fireside chat with SpotHero Chief People Officer Beth Hayden, PayPal Senior Product Manager Ronke Majekodunmi describes how imposter syndrome showed up in her product career and personal life, and traces it to an upbringing that did not foster confidence and to two toxic workplaces. She shares the habits that help her manage it: drawing on her grandmother's example, journaling accomplishments, reframing anxiety as excitement, and refusing to compare herself with others so she can run her own race.
“It feels like no matter what I have accomplished, it's just never enough.”
“When you work harder, it's never enough, because you always feel like you're not working hard enough, and it's just exhausting after a while.”
What you will learn
Recognize the signs of imposter syndrome, from feeling like a fraud in meetings to working twice as hard without ever feeling it is enough.
Trace your own self-doubt back to its sources, such as an early environment that withheld confidence or a toxic workplace.
Write emails that invite colleagues' perspectives without over-apologizing or sounding bossy.
Keep an accomplishments journal so you can tell the story of your product's impact to leadership.
Reframe presentation anxiety as excitement by naming the worst that can realistically happen and accepting you will get through it.
Key takeaways from the speaker
Feelings of self-doubt, insecurity, and anxiety can be used as tools to be traversed into success.
How to deal with imposter syndrome and feelings of insufficiency as a product manager.
Details
Level
All levels
Format
Fireside chat
Technical depth
Non-technical
For
All career stages
Length
20:13
Published
July 2022
Questions this talk answers
What does imposter syndrome feel like?
For Ronke it feels like never being good enough no matter what she has accomplished, believing she is a fraud who will be found out, and triple checking everything.
What causes imposter syndrome?
In her experience it started in an environment where self-confidence was not fostered, where a B prompted 'why not an A', and was reinforced by two toxic work environments where nothing was ever good enough.
How can you write emails without over-apologizing or sounding bossy?
Share your perspective, then open the door by asking what others think and offering further discussion, since as a product manager you have blind spots and biases and benefit from diverse thought.
What practical habits help manage imposter syndrome?
Ronke draws on her grandmother's example, writes down her accomplishments to review before presentations, turns anxiety into excitement by naming the worst that could happen, and stops comparing herself to others.
How should you respond to feedback like 'you smile too much'?
Ronke recognizes it as a double bind where women can't win, gives herself time to process it, and chooses to stay authentic and find an organization that values her.
About this talk
Imposter syndrome is something that we’ve all dealt with, especially as women in the workplace. It can make us doubt our worth within our organization, and illicit feelings of inadequacy, even when we are successful.
In this fireside chat I will talk about some of my own experiences with imposter syndrome and how to deal with those feelings of insufficiency as a Product Manager.
Journal your wins, turn anxiety into excitement (80 s)
Speaker 1: Welcome, everyone. We are so excited to have you all here for this important topic. My name is Beth Hayden. I'm the Chief People Officer for Spot Hero, and it is my sincere pleasure to introduce you to one of my favorite people in the entire world, Ronke Majekodunmi. Ronke, for many years, has been, by the way, her pronouns are she/her. She's been a noteworthy leader in powerhouse and product management. She has dedicated her career to creating outstanding world-class products and investing her time to educate the next generation of product leaders.
Her mission is to make the world of product management more accessible for diverse product makers entering the field, providing insights and authentic experiences for the next generation to draw from. And that's really why we're here, is we're thinking of no matter where you are in your career trajectory, this really important topic of imposter syndrome, and feeling like you don't measure up for whatever reason. From time to time, we've all felt that way. And we're here to hopefully convince you, you are enough. And we have some amazing stories through Ronke's lens, personally and professionally. And with that said, Ronke, you ready? I thought we'd just start with, what is imposter syndrome? What does it feel like?
Yeah. Thank you so much, Beth. By the way, just to let everybody know, Beth is also one of my favorite people in the world. And she's my mentor. And she's also the one of the reasons why I'm able to do this conference today. So thank you so much for always supporting me. And also thank you women in Women in Tech Global for having me today. So what does that feel like? It feels like I'm not good enough. That's what it feels like. It feels like no matter what I have accomplished, it's just never enough. I feel like I don't work harder. Like I have to work even harder. And it's just that feeling like when I'm in a room with people, I feel like I'm a fraud and people are going to find out that
I don't belong there. I'm not smart enough to be there. It's just, it's that specific, it's always, it's always there for me, right? And that mindset, no matter what it is, it's always like, okay, well, do I really belong here? Do I know what I'm doing? I have to triple check things, right? And as a product manager, it's even more pronounced, right? Because when I started out as a product manager, there was in product school that was in all these other resources that there were. So how do you really know you were doing well, right? And it was just, it's just always that feeling like, oh my god, I don't know if I can make it. And just to dive a little deeper on that,
maybe describe a scenario where you felt this show up. Oh, my god has joined us. This is better in the back. I knew this. Yeah. Well, welcome. Welcome. Oh, man. In my professional life, whenever we would successfully release a feature, a product, you name it, and I would celebrate with the team. But deep down, I'm always thinking, what if it's not, you know, this is just a fluke, right? People will figure out eventually, I'm not a good product manager, I don't know what I'm doing, right? When I have skip level meetings with leadership, I'm always that those thoughts are there, like, what comes to my mind is, why did they invite me to this meeting? They must know I'm not smart enough to be here, right?
I cannot tell you how many times I've been in conference rooms, right, with my colleagues, and I'm always, there's always that thought, like, someone's gonna come in and tap me on the shoulder and say, yeah, you don't belong here, you're a fraud, we figured you out. Those are the way it manifested in my personal life, the constant feeling like I have to work twice as hard, I have to work harder, and of course, that's the thing, right? When you work harder, it's never enough, because you always feel like you're not working hard enough, and it's just exhausting after a while.
So when did you come to the conclusion that this was imposter syndrome for you? So I started to do, well, first, I started to do a lot of reading, that's one, and two, there were just a couple of things that were happening personally that I had to deal with. One was, I met this incredible man, right, and I was used to not have a functional relationship, you know, with boyfriends, so he kind of came along, and I kind of thought, well, that's just weird, this is not real, right? And so no matter how, it started with that, really, where I kind of had to go, okay, I have to stop this, where I literally would question our relationship, right? The first time we ever met, it was, we met online, but the first time we actually ever talked was via video chat,
and I remember five minutes into the conversation, I looked at him, and I said, you do understand, I'm not skinny, right? And he looks into the camera, and he looks at me, and he goes, I saw your pictures, I'm good, but it's, but I, but even after that, right, it was there, it was always there in the back of my mind, we would go out to dinner or whatever, I'm always like, why, you know, why is this man, incredibly good-looking man with me, right? And eventually, as our relationship kind of progressed, I realized I needed to deal with that, because I didn't want to, honestly, it was just this thought one day that came to me that 30 years from now, when I'm married to this man, and we're old,
I don't want to think back to the early stages, and keep, and remember that I spent most of my time doubting him, and doubting our relationship, and doubting myself, that was one, the other thing that happened was, in my professional life, I had gotten out of a toxic work relationship, a toxic, yeah, it was a toxic work relationship, and same thing there, I was sort of dealing with some after effects of that, some people call it post-stress disorder, but same thing there was, as I was about to embark on this new journey, working for a new employer, I wanted to, again, walk in with confidence as a product leader, and not feel like I needed to cower somewhere, like I didn't belong there, so it was just a series of things, but also, I started to do a lot of reading about what it is,
I googled it, actually, and then I'm like, oh, that's what it is, imposter syndrome, okay, let's go, let's go work on that, so that's sort of how it started out for me. Well, I'm seeing some notes in chat where you're resonating, and this is relatable, and people are feeling this self-doubt, and I like the comment about being weird, there's a book called Weird that I love, relevant, so you talked a little bit about professional and personal, which I find really interesting, this isn't limited to feeling like this, or doubting yourself only in the professional environment, what causes imposter syndrome?
Oh, great question, so for me, for me anyway, I don't know, I mean, everybody's experience is different, obviously, so for me, there were multiple things, one was my environment, right, so I think I kind of came from an environment where self-confidence wasn't exactly fostered, right, where if I got a B, then it's like, why didn't you get an A, right, that was always there since high school, right, where, you know, so those were there, right, so if I, so my environment kind of made me feel like I didn't, I wasn't good enough, right, so then that kind of carried on to further into my 20s, right, so it started there, and then I've had, like I said, not one, but two toxic work environment where I've had to honestly just, you know, I've really tried to figure out, okay, do I
really want to keep working in this kind of environment where nothing I do is ever good enough, and that's, for me, I think those are the causes of it, and also the other thing I wanted to mention is because the environment, you know, didn't foster self-confidence and, you know, being good enough to be able to be, so imagine that person in their 20s now going to work, to, you know, going into corporate America, right, so then when you're in a toxic relationship, when you're in corporate America, your instinct is not to leave, right, your instinct is to stay and try to fix it and try to be better and work twice as hard, basically literally killing yourself, right, and it doesn't really matter because you're never going to be good enough, right, to that person as well, so it's doing that
analysis and trying to figure out, you know, eventually that got me to kind of go, okay, you know what, even now I'm very picky about the kind of environment I go into work-wise, but those to me were the causes, right, it's, it starts there, right, being a teenager or, you know, or, you know, or about to graduate high school, not getting a B, but it's not an A, not being good enough, it kind of starts in that environment and then it just stays with you, so. Yeah, thank you, thank you for that and, and for sharing so openly your, your journey. I want to go for a second to chat on a couple things that I find really interesting around how this shows up, so one of them is speaking up in meetings and another one is how do you audit
your emails so you don't come across across as bitchy or bossy, so what do you, what do you think of our chat here? Yeah, no, I love it, um, well, actually the other thing too is there's also the reverse that of apologizing for everything even in emails, right, which is something that I stopped doing when I first started out, I used to do that, I go, I'm so sorry, it's just like, I used to go, can I take a day off, almost like, almost that feeling like I'm lucky to be here, right, so there's also the reverse of that too. The other part of that is yes, you're right, you don't want to sound like you're being bitchy either, I write emails where I say hello, hope you're having a lovely day, listen,
these are my thoughts, my perspective, what do you think, right, you know, opening that door, like, what are your thoughts, what do you think, let me know if you want to have coffee to have further discussions about this, but I find that usually helps, you know, opening that door, but not saying this is the final answer, this is how I feel, but more like, listen, I'm not perfect at this, right, especially with product management, you kind of have to check your ego at the door, because you have blind spots and biases as a product manager, and so you want, the more diverse thought you have, you know, on the table when you're building a product, the better, so that's sort of how I approach that, is I'm not perfect, I have biases, I have blind spots, let's have this conversation,
tell me what I'm missing, rather than, you know, so it doesn't come across like being bitchy. Yeah, I, and I want to explore that more, kind of making the, the product, right, or the customer and user, the, the hero of the story instead, I, I love how you talk about that, what, what are some, speaking of, of that, what are some solutions that you've employed when you're encountering these moments of imposter syndrome? So again, so these are the things that have worked for me, everybody's different, but I sort of wanted to list them, so the first one is, um, my grandmother, my grandmother, um, helped raise me, and my grandmother, um, didn't, she was raised by her often, I mean, sorry, she wasn't often, she was raised by her grandparents, um, I often think about
her a lot, and the fact that she worked so hard to give me the life that I have, right, and how it's important that I give back to the next generation of product leaders, and by the way, that's another reason why I write blogs, I do a lot of what I do, because I sort of got to a point in my career when I thought, okay, well, how do I pass this on, right, you know, at the end of this, when Rocky stops being a product manager, what are people going to say, what have I done, what lives have I helped to change, um, even if I only help the trajectory into product a little bit, it's something, so that's one, I always think about her a lot, and I gotta tell you, every time I think
about her a lot, especially when I'm about to walk into a situation where I'm presenting, those fears go away for me very quickly, then it becomes about that moment, and the fact that I need to meet that moment, and I need to meet it with the gravitas that he, that are, that he needs, right, so that's one, the second thing is, I write down my accomplishments now, once I realized that I had imposter syndrome, I try to figure out, okay, how do I, when I get, when I get into those moments, and I need to do a presentation for my leadership, and really talk about who I am, and tell my story, and the story of my product, I go back, and I look at my journal, and I kind of go, okay, we did this, we did that, we did this,
here's the impact that I had in our customers' lives, and I tell those stories, and by the way, again, we're all human, so easy to forget, once you release something, and that's why I write it down, to remind myself, the impact, you know, how our product is the hero for our customer, you know, is the hero internally, but for our customers, they are the hero using it for their organization, and telling that story, the third is, anxiety is due to stress, right, for me, so I've learned to turn that anxiety into excitement, and the way I do that is this, the worst thing to happen, I always tell myself, in a meeting is, either the laptop, my laptop drops, stops working, slack shuts down, or we don't stop the meeting for five minutes,
due to technical difficulties, it doesn't matter, but those are the worst things to happen, but I will get through it, I will survive, the worst things, there are spelling errors in my presentation, it's okay, I'm human, right, but what's important to me is learning from those mistakes, because then it makes me a better human being a better person, a better leader, and I'd rather have that, because nobody's perfect, once again, right, I want to learn that, fourth is, I stop comparing myself to other people, I had this colleague, who, till today, is such an awesome person, I still talk to her all the time, and she's just perfect in my eyes, perfect, I would go to customer visits with her, and she would just walk in like she owned the room, and she would ask questions, she would chat with them, she would laugh,
she always had a list with her, ready to go, she was never surprised, and one day, we visited a customer in Connecticut, we were heading back to New York on a train, and I looked at her, and I said to her, I said, you're perfect, I'm like, I don't understand, how do you do it, and she looks at me, she goes, oh, Ronky, I'm not, she's like, I'm faking it until I can make it, and I'm like, wait, what, she's like, oh, I have no idea what I'm doing, she's like, I'm just going by the moment, and that day, that conversation, and same thing, by the way, the more I talked to her on the train that day, the more I realized that she also came from a similar environment that I came,
where self-confidence was now fostered, but she, along the way, figured out that when she's in those moments, she makes it look like she has it together, by faking it until you can make it, and that conversation changed my life, because I realized, oh my god, I've been comparing myself to this woman for months and years, thinking she was perfect, and I needed to be perfect, I mean, I'm telling you, that we would need to, she would say to me, okay, Ronky, we're going to Connecticut, so I'll meet you at Grand Central Station at 7:45, right, and I would be there at 7:30, because I didn't want to disappoint her, and I wanted to be there on time, and by the way, she strolls in at 7:50, right, and I just, that conversation changed my life, and I just realized,
okay, I've got to stop comparing myself to other people, and I need to run my own race instead, it's imperfect, my story is messy in its brilliance, but man, I love it that way, that is how it's meant to be. Amazing, amazing, I'm looking at the chat, and I want to, either from your grandmother's story, or your own, there are expectations placed on women, right, from the media, from our environments, whatever that might mean, I'm seeing things like, why don't you smile more, or expectations of apologies, or asking for permission, oh yeah, talk a little bit more to our audience about how you overcome these expectations, or find ways to meet them in your own unique, authentic way.
So, here's the thing everybody, I've sort of decided to run my own race now. One of the reviews I recently had was a leader telling me that I smile too much, right, so, I just thought I was too happy, and that nobody would take me seriously. We got a scary, a scary emoji people right there, right, I literally had a product, my own, I had a leader tell me, you smile too much, you're too happy, no one's going to take you seriously, and you're not going to be promoted.
It's this double bind, right, for women, you have to be likable and credible, and pick one, right? Right, pick one, right, so it's either you're not smiling, or you smile too much, right, oh, and else I can't take it seriously, because you smile too much, but here's the thing, as a product leader, right, if I didn't come in every day, and I didn't cheer, I wasn't a cheerleader for my developers, then the feedback I would get is, you're not a people person, right, you're not a leader, so you can't win, so I've decided to run my own race, and I'm going to be my authentic self, and if that organization doesn't see it, well, that's fine, eventually I'll move on, and I'll find the right fit, that's sort of where I am right now, and also I'm a little older now, I think in my 20s,
I mean, I'm sure in my 20s, I've been calling you and going, oh my god, Beth, they said I smile too much, what should I do? And listen, when I got that feedback, at first I thought, oh my god, is this person saying I'm fluff, like I'm not smart, like why wouldn't anybody see that I'm smart, look at all the features and products, look at how I lead my team, that was, those were the literally the first thoughts that came into my mind, were, oh my god, like what, yeah, but after, and again, listen, I still deal with it, 24 hours later, I'm like, okay, what, thank you for the feedback, I gotta run my own race. I love run your own race, and I think that's, as we, as we draw to our, our time and the
bottom of the hour, I think it's, it's such good advice, because the perception or the rating of all of us is as much or more about the Raider, right, than it is about you, and I'm so proud of you for coming into your own and, and seeing, um, seeing through that, so for, for everyone that's listening, run your own race, Rocky, you're incredible, great time, I, I listened to you, I learned something new, you're, you're an inspiration, so thank you so much. Oh, thank you so much, and thank you everybody for attending, thank you Women in Tech, Women in Tech Global for having me, this was awesome, I'm profoundly grateful for this opportunity to talk about imposter syndrome and, and, and self-doubt, so thank you all so much, thank you Beth. Hi everyone. Bye.
Transcribed automatically; names checked against the speaker record. Select a time to jump there.
Article based on this talk
How a product leader learned to quiet imposter syndrome and run her own race
PayPal Senior Product Manager Ronke Majekodunmi traces her self-doubt to its roots and shares four habits that help her lead with confidence.
In short
Imposter syndrome can follow even successful product leaders into every launch and leadership meeting, but it can be managed. In a fireside chat with Beth Hayden, Chief People Officer at SpotHero, PayPal Senior Product Manager Ronke Majekodunmi traces her self-doubt to an upbringing where confidence was not fostered and to two toxic workplaces. She then shares four habits that help: remembering who she does the work for, journaling her accomplishments, reframing anxiety as excitement and refusing to compare herself with others.
Key takeaways
Feelings of self-doubt, insecurity and anxiety can be used as tools to move toward success.
How to deal with imposter syndrome and feelings of insufficiency as a product manager.
What imposter syndrome feels like
Hayden opens with a simple question, and Majekodunmi answers without hesitation: it feels like not being good enough. She describes walking into rooms convinced she is a fraud who is about to be found out, triple checking her work and wondering whether she truly belongs.
"It feels like no matter what I have accomplished, it's just never enough." (1:21)
At work, this showed up in moments that should have felt like wins. When her team shipped a feature, she celebrated outwardly while privately suspecting it was a fluke. Invitations to skip-level meetings triggered the thought that leadership must already know she was not smart enough to be there. The response was always to work harder, which never resolved anything.
"When you work harder, it's never enough, because you always feel like you're not working hard enough, and it's just exhausting after a while." (3:36)
Where the doubt comes from
Majekodunmi recognised the pattern through two life events. She met a partner and found herself questioning the relationship, and she left a toxic work relationship and wanted to start her next role with confidence rather than cowering. Reading about the topic, she finally had a name for what she was feeling.
When Hayden asks what causes it, Majekodunmi points first to her early environment.
"I think I kind of came from an environment where self-confidence wasn't exactly fostered, right, where if I got a B, then it's like, why didn't you get an A, right" (7:13)
She explains how that background carried into her twenties and into corporate America, where the instinct in a toxic situation was not to leave but to stay, try to fix it and work twice as hard. Two toxic work environments reinforced the belief that nothing she did would ever be enough. Today she is deliberately selective about the workplaces she joins.
Emails that open the door
Prompted by audience comments about speaking up and auditing emails so they do not come across as bossy, Majekodunmi notes the opposite trap too: apologising for everything, as if lucky just to be in the room. Her approach is to share her perspective and then explicitly invite others in, asking what they think and offering to continue over coffee. She ties this to the realities of product work.
"especially with product management, you kind of have to check your ego at the door, because you have blind spots and biases as a product manager" (10:11)
Framing her view as one input among many, and asking colleagues to tell her what she is missing, lets her be direct without sounding defensive or harsh.
Four habits that quiet the doubt
Majekodunmi is careful to say these are the things that work for her. The first is thinking of her grandmother, who helped raise her and worked hard to give her the life she has. That memory makes her fears fade before presentations and reminds her to give back to the next generation of product leaders.
The second is an accomplishments journal.
"the second thing is, I write down my accomplishments now" (12:22)
Before presenting to leadership, she reviews what her team shipped and the impact on customers, so she can tell her story and her product's story with evidence rather than memory. The third habit is turning anxiety into excitement by naming the worst that could realistically happen, such as a laptop failing or a spelling error, and accepting that she will survive and learn from it.
The fourth habit came from a train ride back from a customer visit in Connecticut. She told a colleague she admired that she seemed perfect, and the colleague admitted she was faking it until she could make it, and came from a similar background.
"that conversation changed my life, because I realized, oh my god, I've been comparing myself to this woman for months and years, thinking she was perfect, and I needed to be perfect" (15:30)
Running her own race
The chat closes on expectations placed on women. Majekodunmi recounts a recent review in which a leader said she smiled too much and would not be taken seriously or promoted. Hayden names it as a double bind in which women are expected to be both likable and credible. Majekodunmi points out that if she did not cheer on her developers, she would instead be told she was not a people person.
"I literally had a product, my own, I had a leader tell me, you smile too much, you're too happy, no one's going to take you seriously, and you're not going to be promoted." (17:06)
She admits the feedback still stung, but after a day she chose to stay authentic and, if needed, find an organisation that sees her value. Her summary of the lesson is the line the session is built around.
"my story is messy in its brilliance, but man, I love it that way, that is how it's meant to be." (16:14)
Watch the talk
Managing Impostor Syndrome and Self-Doubt, Ronke Majekodunmi with host Beth Hayden, about 20 minutes: https://www.womentech.net/video/managing-impostor-syndrome-and-self-doubt-ronke-majekodunmi-beth-hayden
About the speaker
Ronke Majekodunmi is a Senior Product Manager at PayPal, where she collaborates with global stakeholders, leads the strategy and development of new products and supports the career development of product management teams. Through Product School she hosts webinars on soft skills and coalition building and guides new product managers in a Product Management Certification course.
Questions this talk answers
What does imposter syndrome feel like?
What causes imposter syndrome?
How can you write emails without over-apologizing or sounding bossy?
What practical habits help manage imposter syndrome?
How should you respond to feedback like "you smile too much"?
Drafted with AI from the talk transcript. Editor review pending.