New hires plateau around day 60 when they cannot see their next role
Strong hires often start dynamic, then level off somewhere between day 40 and day 60, the number one complaint Natalie Dawson hears from the business owners she consults. As EVP of Operations and Partner at Cardone Ventures, which grew from zero to 121 employees since 2019, she has hired at speed in a tight tech talent market. So what has to be clear before day one, and what should happen to people who never fit?
Get a three-step cycle to align, develop and transition people so your top performers stay
Natalie Dawson, EVP of Operations and Partner at Cardone Ventures, presents a cyclical align, develop and transition model for building high performance teams. She argues that leaders must make mission, direction and culture explicit before hiring, show every new hire their next role within 60 days, and use clear, stats-based standards to move people up or out.
“Here's the deal. Nobody is going to give their all every single day if they do not understand what's in it for them.”
“People want to be a part of something where they see an opportunity to grow.”
What you will learn
Articulate your mission, destination and core values so candidates can judge fit before they join.
Define each new hire's next role, and what it takes to reach it, within 60 days of onboarding.
Set stats-based performance standards that high performers want to be measured against.
Transition poor fits out quickly to signal that the team expects A-level performance.
Choose and communicate one clear stance on in-office, hybrid or remote work.
Key takeaways from the speaker
Build a high performance team.
Understand the three essential components of growth: alignment, development, and transition.
Create clarity for your team as they pursue their personal, professional, and financial goals, as well as the goals of the business.
Craft your mission, vision, and core values.
Details
Level
Intermediate
Format
Talk
Technical depth
Non-technical
For
People manager, Executive, Founder
Length
22:52
Published
July 2022
Questions this talk answers
What does a new hire need to know to align with an organization?
Dawson names three things: the mission (why the business and product exist), where the organization is going, and the core values that describe how the team operates.
Why do strong new hires plateau after 40 to 60 days?
According to Dawson, they cannot see themselves in the organization's future because they do not know their next role or what it takes to get there.
Why should leaders let people who are not a fit leave quickly?
Keeping underperformers signals to high performers that B-plus work is acceptable, which makes it harder to attract and keep top talent.
How should leaders approach return to office and hybrid work?
Dawson argues there is no single right answer, but leaders must take a decisive, consistent stance, because mixed arrangements create confusion. Her company keeps leadership in person and made technology development roles virtual.
What team rituals help build connection?
Monthly celebrations where people answer personal questions such as their most impactful age, holiday games like guessing baby photos, and events led by team members rather than leadership.
About this talk
High-performance teams are built intentionally by leaders who understand the three essential components of growth: alignment, development, and transition. Natalie Dawson will detail her three-step framework to creating clarity for your team as they pursue their personal, professional, and financial goals, as well as the goals of the business. Audiences will be equipped to build a high performance team and craft their own mission, vision, and core values.
Welcome. My name is Natalie Dawson. I'm the executive vice president and partner at a company called Cardone Ventures, and I'm an expert in hiring teams and finding team members, and especially in technology. We've built out a robust technology team over the last year and a half. In 2019, we had zero employees, and today we have 121 employees.
And my specialty really is mastering how do you find the right talent in a marketplace like 2022 where it's unprecedented. You have situations like last year with the great resignation taking place. Now you also see a resurgence of people coming back into the workforce who maybe thought it was a great idea to leave their job in August and September of 2021 and have now since decided, wait a second, I don't know how to run a business.
And I'm not exactly sure that my side hustle is going to make it to allow me to grow and scale without the structure of traditional employment. And so again, my specialty lies in really being able to create clarity for what the hiring plan is, how to retain great team members, and ultimately how to transition those two members. I wrote a book called Teamwork, and it's all about how you build a high performance team. And so what about to discuss how to discuss with you guys during our time today and then leave it open for questions, I can see it in the chat as well, is how do you align? How do you develop and how do you condition a remarkable team? And when you're starting in the alignment place, most people start with this idea of, okay, I'm going to interview somebody and I'm going to onboard them. And that's the extent of their hiring strategy. That's the extent of the planning that they put into place. I need to find a warm body
to help me to help me solve these problems. I need to find a warm body to do the product rollout. I need to find a warm body to be a junior developer. But what they miss is what do you do to engage and inspire a junior developer to stay with you and not leave you for your competition because they see what the availability is for growth within the organization. And so career pathing is incredibly important in that transition phase. And so as I talk about alignment, alignment, development, and transition, I think of this in this real and it's a cyclical model, you first align somebody, you give them clarity around three key things that every single person needs to know in order to properly align with an organization, a department, and a new leader. Those three things are the mission statement. Why does this business exist? Why does this product exist? Help them understand the why. If you cannot clearly and consistently
state in a very short amount of state in a very short amount of time, why you do what you do, why the product is what it is, why the organization does what it does, you are going to have a very difficult time attracting top talent because businesses who are competing for top talent today, they have clarity on those things and they can clearly articulate it because it grabs the attention of the potential workforce. And the second piece of that is where are you going? It's not just about why you exist, but what is the opportunity? Where is where is the destination? If you do not have a destination? If you do not have a destination and that isn't clear to somebody, especially with the technology workforce, again, as I've been interviewing hundreds of applicants over the course of just the last six months as we've
endeavored on building our team, everybody wants to be a part of something big. You have to remember that. There is not a person that wants to think back and when they're 85 years old and think, oh man, I'm really glad that I just played a small my whole life, that I took small mediocre roles and that, you know, they're just like, this wasn't anything interesting or exciting about what I did. Nobody will say that. Nobody has ever said that. People want to be a part of something where they see an opportunity to grow.
So this idea of where you're going has to be so lush out. Maybe it's not every little minute detail because that can be difficult as a leader to figure out all of those things, but the where you're going is critical. And the last piece in this alignment phase, before we get to development and condition, the last piece on alignment is what are the core values? How does the team operate? Inside our organization, we have every single team member before joining our team, give us a presentation.
on how they align with our core values. It's a five-minute presentation and it's given to anybody inside our leadership team. And what this does is it creates that buy-in. It creates that commitment for a brand new team member to understand, oh, I'm stepping into this culture and this culture is clearly defined. This culture isn't, oh, I'm going to come and be a part of it and it's just loose and there's no structure. No, there should be a structure. If you're creating a team, you're a leader, you're creating a business and you're an owner.
You should have clarity as to what you want your environment to look like. Are you friendly and approachable? Are you strict and to the point? Is it results-oriented or is it impact-oriented? All of those things have to be clear to a candidate, to a high performer on the front end. Because here's the deal. By the time they enter your environment, by the time they are a full-time employee of yours, you expecting that they're going to change and become like your environment just because they're in your environment now does not work in 2022.
That tactic, that methodology no longer works. What works is, hey, I was this person before, this was my contribution, this is what my belief system is, and I am joining a place that is congruent with that. It's not, oh, I was this before, and now I'm going to turn into or elevate into this. That's not what candidates are looking for. And the more that you surprise people and shock people about what your environment is, because you aren't transparent on the front end, you're going to have a result of high turnover.
And an ideal scene, you keep your turnover as low as possible, because you're really clearly stating on the front end, hey, this is what I'm doing, or this is what you're putting yourself into. I equate this to dating. When you are madly in love with somebody, and you just skip the whole dating process, you meet them, you go on your first couple dates, you're excited about them, and then you just decide, let's get married.
And then on the honeymoon, maybe a couple days in, after some rest and relaxation, you're sitting there and you're talking to your significant other, and your significant other is saying, wow, I'm so excited for us to begin our lives together. I know we've just been hanging and knowing each other for a short while, but man, when we get back to town, I can hardly wait to be able to move out to the countryside and to have our farm and to raise our family and to start a family.
Like, I'm so excited and looking forward to that. Where the other significant other is like, wait a second, I love living in the city. I have no interest in having children. I want to work 70 hours a week. I love going out to eat and my friends and social life there. That is what you do to your team members when you are not clear about what the department looks like and what the organization looks like.
You are just surprising them on day one. At that point, you're already married. You're not technically married. The parent can leave and go to somewhere else to work, but why not suss that out on the front end? Once you've done these things, and I keep making this kind of movement because I have a graphic that shows in my book, the first step is alignment. Then you move into development.
Here's the deal. Nobody is going to give their all every single day if they do not understand what's in it for them. Now, this might be common knowledge to you, but as it relates to your team members, when you think about across the board, does every single one of your team members know what they need to do today on June 7th on a Tuesday afternoon in order for them to go to the next level inside the organization?
Do you have clarity on that? If they're a senior developer or if they're a junior developer, do they know what it would take to become a developer? And then from there, do they know from a developer what it would take for them to become a senior? This isn't just for sales roles. This is especially important in technology roles because if I don't have a picture of where I'm going, if I don't have the picture of what the opportunity looks like, if I don't know what I'm putting all this work and energy and effort in for, why am I going to show up every day, motivated and excited?
I consult thousands and thousands of business owners each and every day. That's what our business does. And the number one complaint that I hear from employers is I can't find any great people. And even once I find them after 60 days, they just go into this lull. They start off great. They interview so well. They're amazing and they're dynamic.
And then about at that 40 to 60 day mark, they just kind of plateau and level off. Well, it's because they don't see themselves in the future of the organization. They don't see what they need to do in order to become the next role. They don't understand what their trajectory looks like. And so a really clear target for every leader should be within 60 days of somebody being on board with your team or your organization.
They should know what the next role looks like. They'll have a clear understanding of what it's going to take for them to develop, to get from where they're at to where they want to go. And if you don't have that in place and yet you're questioning why your team members are disengaged, that's going to be your answer right there.
It's because they're stuck in what I like to call development predatory. Instead of growing and evolving, I think of this view as like this ever evolving, growing view that's very cyclical. Instead of that, it's like the gear has been jammed and they're just stuck. And when somebody is stuck, why are they going to get their all every single day?
They don't know what the next step is. So, of course, I'm going to be maybe a little bit negative. I might have an attitude. I might withdraw from the problem. I really don't understand why that extra effort is going to get me to the next level. My last piece, and again, I believe this transition is the most important piece because there's two types of transition.
There's, okay, I align, I develop, and then ideally I transition up so that I am able to be in that next role. But there's also the type of transition where, hey, I tried to align with the organization and I started to develop my skill sets, but ultimately I'm not a fit. So then that person transitions out. You see right there at the wheel, and then in some cases somebody just goes out because they're no longer inside that organization any longer.
And those forms of transition are still beneficial for the organization because your team needs to know, hey, what does it take for somebody not to be a fit here? And if you don't allow people inside your department or inside your organization to leave because they aren't a fit, you're sending a signal to high performers that you need that you're just going to be okay with B-plus players, even though you're telling the high performers, I want A-plus stars.
It's a lack of alignment, and when that lack of alignment takes place, you're really never going to be able to have two great, ingratiating conversations with your potential top performer because as soon as they come into the environment, the first thing that they're going to notice is, oh, there's only B-plus team members here. I want to be on the A-team.
That's why so many big tech firms get better talent than smaller firms because they know that the expectations are likely so much higher there, and they want to be on an A-plus team. So how does somebody who's smaller, who doesn't have the names of the more recognized organizations, still compete in this talent war that's going on? Well, you don't allow team members inside your environment who are just stuck in the environment.
If somebody is below A-minus, and you know, you're just like, man, this person is always late. This person is always coming up with excuses. That person is going to be one of the reasons why you're not able to get good talent, even though your natural inclination is going to be, oh, I'm going to keep this person because I'll need them.
It's the exact opposite. You have to get rid of that person as quickly as possible. Fine, you know, they're not hitting their objectives, right? I think it's because of personality or a different opinion. Really, hey, they're not meeting their performance standards because the one thing that high performers love is performance standards. Think of it like somebody who makes music or somebody who plays sports professionally.
High performers want to know how many records they sell or what number they're at on the chart. Or for a basketball player, they want to know their free throw percentage. There's not a single person in the NBA that doesn't want to know their free throw percentage. But now, conversely, when you aren't holding yourself accountable to something, it's probably those things that you're going to want a lot of freedom in and you're not really going to want to look at for the target.
Maybe for some people, that could look like the example of stepping on a scale. When you're, like, really into your diet and you're really into your exercising, you're going to feel great about stepping on a scale because you want to be measured on this scale. If you're not feeling so great about that, how you're contributing to, you know, what choices you're making, you're probably not going to want to actually look at that number because you know it's not going to be a number that you want.
Equate this to this performance. When you are in a state of performing and when somebody, when talent is in a state of performing, they want to be measured on their stats. They want to have clarity on their stats. Their transition inside your organization has to be very stats-based. Without the statistics, they're going to be confused as to what the actual measurement is.
And when confusion happens, we have a saying around here at Cardinal Ventures, we say, confusion creates failure. If I don't know what my target is, I don't have clarity on my metric, I don't know what my contribution posts look like, that thing is going to fail because there's no clarity. But when there is clarity, all of a sudden, you have the test because once a target is known, you can put all of the resources and all the energy behind that.
As you're thinking about your talent, how can you figure out the alignment piece? Have you clearly articulated why you exist, where you are going, and defined your culture? As it relates to developing team members, are you really honest about, hey, this is where you're at and this is what it would take for you to get to the next level?
And then having very direct conversations with people about doing the things in order to get to the next level. And lastly, in the transition, how are you sharing with people what the next level actually looks like, how they benefit from the next level, how they benefit from putting extra hours and they're developing their skill set or learning something new.
So if you don't have the transition picture painted when somebody is onboarding, then of course you're going to run into just a different issue with your team members, because they're not really going to know how to contribute more, and they're not going to have an understanding of what the bigger picture can look like for them to be able to contribute something much greater than just what they're doing in front of them today.
So with that, I haven't been able to help you on the chat here, but I would love to take any questions if we have just a couple of minutes. I would love to connect on anything regarding team building, hiring, firing, rewarding team members. This is really my zone of genius. But for those questions that we can't get to, please, I would love to connect with you.
Please feel free to download a copy of my book. It's free and made it free to you guys if you go to cardinventures.com forward slash teamwork. I will dive into much deeper detail as to what interview opportunities you should be asking in and what structure the interview should go in in order to stress out the right candidates all the way through how you fire somebody, how you develop them, et cetera.
So my book, cardinventures.com forward slash teamwork, you can get a free copy, trip to your house today, we'd love to be able to provide that for you. Can you type in the book, please? Oh, yeah, the book is called Teamwork. Cardinventures.com forward slash teamwork. Favorite team building exercise. My favorite team building exercise would be, I take on a monthly basis, you do a cool celebration inside our office where we care for things.
However, we like can do all the normal birthday stuff. But then we also ask the person a handful of questions. One of them has been, that's been really helpful, is what is the most impactful age that you've had? And as soon as you're in a team environment, we're totally sharing something that is more personal, that really creates a level playing field.
Like, man, 31 was my favorite age. Or 15 was my favorite age. And this is why it takes just the professional stuff outside of the work and reminds you, oh my gosh, I'm talking to somebody who also had these weird experiences at 16 years old and they were able to grow and develop for them. We also do things like holiday celebrations where, for Mother's Day, we did baby photos and we had to play the game where everybody guessed which baby was which number, which was hilarious.
I'm a big proponent of cool moments and cultures and environments where you just don't feel like you're working with colleagues, you feel like they're connecting with other people and that human side of the business is incredibly important to navigate. As you're also doing everything you can each and every day to drive a result, I'm a very serious person, I talk about numbers and metrics and I'm very intense all the time, but then there are these moments that, as a leader, it's my responsibility to create inside our environment.
But this allows people to be people and to connect in different ways. So with that, I believe I am over my time. I've appreciated connecting with you guys. I would love to connect with you more. I guess I can keep going until they're shutting them off, so we're just going to do this. As people begin to return to office after COVID, what are some ways to attract staff back, thinking they will always work in a hybrid manner?
You know, Elon Musk just came out just last week and said, if you come and continue to work with Tesla, you need to be expected to be in the office. I think that it takes a strong leader with a strong vision to set that challenge. Why are we working in office versus why are we not working in office?
And what is the value if we choose it to do hybrid? For us, our in-office component is incredibly important. We consult businesses every single day and our trenches are grown like crazy, which makes us have visibility challenges in a hybrid or remote work environment. With our tech roles, though, it's fairly difficult for us to be competitive in tech with virtual or with in-person work.
So our leader is in-person, but we have made all of our technology development roles virtual. And I think it takes a strong leader to say, I have an opinion, I have a stance, this is what we're doing, and then to follow it across the board. If the leader is like, oh, some people can work hybrid, others can be fully remote, and others need to be in the office, I think that it causes confusion in the environment.
I really appreciate Elon Musk's stance where he's saying, if you expect to have a job here, you better show up in the office. And I also respect other organizations who have very clearly said, you will never have to work in an office ever again if you continue to choose to work here because we have gone fully remote for the future.
I don't think that there is a right or a wrong answer because businesses demand different things of their team members and of the type of work they're doing. But I do expect that somebody who is going to put financial risk at stake in order to go to business and to lead a business, that person needs to have clarity as to what the structure is to look like and really be decisive around the topic.
We did Welcome Back Wednesdays. It was a dedicated day of the office with particular socialization activities, food, slash beverage, especially that day. I love that, Tiffany. The more you can get your team involved with stuff like this, the better, right? The more you can have it be, like it doesn't come from Natalie, it doesn't come from this level of leadership.
The baby photos was an idea from one of our team members. I know this Thursday we have a dad joke, a karaoke event taking place that is very much team-led. And again, when it's led by the team, your team is likely going to be more predictive in it versus when it's just coming from top-down. And then, you know, we're going to be more competitive in it versus when it's going to be more competitive in it versus when it's going to be more competitive in it versus when it's going to be more competitive in it versus when it's going to be more competitive in it versus when it's going to be more competitive in it versus when it's going to be more competitive in it versus when it's going to be more competitive in it.
It's going to be more competitive in it versus when it's going to be more competitive in it versus when it's going to be more competitive in it versus when it's going to be more competitive in it versus when it's going to be more competitive in it versus when it's going to be more competitive in it versus when it's going to be more competitive in it versus when it's going to be more competitive in it.
I'm happy to be more competitive in it versus when it's going to be more competitive in it versus when it's going to be more competitive in it versus when it's going to be more competitive in it. I'm happy to be more competitive in it versus when it's going to be more competitive in it versus when it's going to be more competitive in it versus when it's going to be more competitive in it versus when it's going to be more competitive in it versus when it's going to be more competitive in it.
I'm happy to connect on any social platforms. I'm very active on social at Natalie. I'm not really working. I recently got married, so some places it's tossing, but I appreciate your time. Enjoy the rest of the conference. In order to check out the book, go to currentledgers.com/teamwork. We'll see you next time.
Transcribed automatically; names checked against the speaker record. Select a time to jump there.
Article based on this talk
Why do great hires stall after 60 days, and how can leaders keep them growing?
Natalie Dawson's align, develop and transition cycle gives leaders a practical way to attract, grow and keep high performers.
In short
High performance teams are built on purpose, not by filling seats with "a warm body". Natalie Dawson, Executive Vice President of Operations and Partner at Cardone Ventures, argues that leaders need a repeating cycle of alignment, development and transition: make the mission, direction and culture explicit before someone joins, show them their next role within 60 days, and use clear performance standards to move people up or out.
Key takeaways
Build a high performance team.
Understand the three essential components of growth: alignment, development and transition.
Create clarity for your team as they pursue their personal, professional and financial goals, as well as the goals of the business.
Craft your mission, vision and core values.
Alignment: why, where and how
Dawson opens with the hiring climate she was working in: the Great Resignation, followed by people returning to traditional jobs after trying side businesses. Her company went from zero employees in 2019 to 121, including a technology team built over about a year and a half, so she has seen what attracts candidates and what drives them away.
Most hiring strategies, she says, stop at interviewing and onboarding. Alignment goes further. Every new team member needs clarity on three things: the mission (why the business and its product exist), the destination (where the organization is going), and the core values (how the team operates). Candidates competing for top roles listen for these, and organizations that cannot state them quickly and consistently will struggle to attract strong people.
The destination matters especially for technical talent. After interviewing hundreds of applicants, Dawson concluded that ambition is nearly universal: "People want to be a part of something where they see an opportunity to grow." (3:41)
To make values concrete, every candidate at her company gives a five-minute presentation to a member of the leadership team on how they align with the core values before joining. The exercise creates buy-in and makes the culture explicit rather than loose.
Hiring is like dating, not eloping
Dawson is direct about a common mistake: expecting people to change just because they are now inside your environment. Candidates today want to join a place that matches who they already are. When the environment comes as a surprise, people leave. "And the more that you surprise people and shock people about what your environment is, because you aren't transparent on the front end, you're going to have a result of high turnover." (5:42)
She compares this to skipping the dating stage and marrying after a few dates, only to find out on the honeymoon that one partner dreams of a farm and children while the other loves city life and 70-hour weeks. Being clear about the department and the organization upfront is how leaders avoid that day-one shock.
Development: show the next role within 60 days
The second stage rests on a simple premise: "Here's the deal. Nobody is going to give their all every single day if they do not understand what's in it for them." (7:52)
Dawson says the most common complaint she hears from business owners is that they cannot find great people, and that even good hires start strong and then level off around the 40 to 60 day mark. Her explanation is that those hires cannot see themselves in the organization's future. A junior developer should know what it takes to become a developer, and a developer should know what it takes to become a senior. This, she stresses, is not only for sales roles.
Her benchmark for leaders is concrete: "And so a really clear target for every leader should be within 60 days of somebody being on board with your team or your organization." (9:07) By then, each person should understand their next role and how to develop toward it. Without that, people get stuck, and stuck people withdraw.
Transition: up, or out
Dawson calls transition the most important stage, and it has two directions. Ideally people move up into the next role. But some people try to align and develop and still are not a fit, and letting them go is also good for the organization. Keeping weak performers tells high performers that B-plus work is acceptable, even while leaders say they want A-plus stars. That, she says, is why smaller firms struggle to compete with big tech for talent. "That person is going to be one of the reasons why you're not able to get good talent, even though your natural inclination is going to be, oh, I'm going to keep this person because I'll need them." (12:05)
The answer is performance standards, because high performers want to be measured. She uses sports and music as examples: "There's not a single person in the NBA that doesn't want to know their free throw percentage." (12:50) Transitions should be based on clear statistics, because, as her company's saying goes, confusion creates failure. Once a target is known, people can put all their energy behind it.
She closes the main talk with a checklist. Have you said clearly why you exist, where you are going and what your culture is? Are you honest with people about where they are and what the next level requires? And are you showing them how they benefit from reaching it?
Clear stances, from rituals to return to office
In the Q&A, Dawson describes the human side of her operation. Monthly celebrations include personal questions such as "what is your most impactful age", and a Mother's Day baby photo guessing game, which came from a team member. She notes that team-led events tend to get more involvement than top-down ones.
On return to office, she cites Elon Musk's statement that Tesla employees are expected in the office. She also respects companies that have gone fully remote. Her company keeps leadership in person but made its technology development roles virtual to stay competitive for tech talent. What matters most is decisiveness: "If the leader is like, oh, some people can work hybrid, others can be fully remote, and others need to be in the office, I think that it causes confusion in the environment." (19:35)
Watch the talk
"How to Build a High Performance Team" by Natalie Dawson, 23 minutes: https://www.womentech.net/video/how-build-high-performance-team-natalie-dawson
About the speaker
Natalie Dawson is Executive Vice President of Operations and Partner at Cardone Ventures, a management consulting, joint ventures and private equity firm that helps business owners reach their personal, professional and financial goals by growing their business. She has interviewed, hired, trained and led thousands of employees over her career, and specialises in aligning employees with business objectives for measurable returns on investment.
Questions this talk answers
What does a new hire need to know to align with an organization?
Why do strong new hires plateau after 40 to 60 days?
Why should leaders let people who are not a fit leave quickly?
How should leaders approach return to office and hybrid work?
What team rituals help build connection?
Drafted with AI from the talk transcript. Editor review pending.
Frameworks and ideas mentioned
Align, develop, transition cycle
Mission, vision and core values
Resources mentioned
Teamwork (book by Natalie Dawson, offered free via the Cardone Ventures website)
Cite this talk
Natalie Dawson. "How to Build a High Performance Team." WomenTech Network, 2022. https://www.womentech.net/video/how-build-high-performance-team-natalie-dawson