0:0019:39

Consuming, Contributing, Collaborating: Open Source from all sides by Ron Minsky

19:39 2022

More people outside Jane Street now contribute to Dune than inside it

A trading firm with nearly 2,000 employees and no open source business model now contributes a large fraction of the improvements in each OCaml release and has published around 240 packages. Ron Minsky, speaking from his experience at Jane Street, shows why that effort pays off. For any company that only consumes open source, the open question is which way of engaging fits, and what it really costs.

See four real open source strategies and the three principles that keep them sustainable

Watch on YouTube

In short

Ron Minsky explains, through Jane Street's experience with Mercurial, OCaml, exported libraries and the Dune build system, how a company whose business is not open source can still benefit from contributing to it. He argues that sustainable open source work must align with business goals, that companies should choose their mode of engagement deliberately, and that tooling decisions shape the experience of internal and external contributors.

“Because I think an important thing to remember is contributing in open source is a repeated game, right?”
“Today, there are more people contributing to Dune outside of Jane Street than there are people inside of Jane Street. So I think of that as a pretty big success.”

What you will learn

  • Map the different ways a company can engage with open source, from funding consultants to launching community-first projects.
  • Justify sustained open source investment by tying it to concrete business goals such as ecosystem health, hiring and integration.
  • Decide when to keep an internal fork and when to upstream changes so you do not drift away from the wider community.
  • Design hosting and contribution tooling with the friction for both internal and external developers in mind.
  • Build trust with maintainers by treating contribution as a repeated game and proposing well-engineered, high-quality changes.

Details

Level
Intermediate
Format
Talk
Technical depth
Practitioner
For
Mid-career, Senior individual contributor, People manager
Length
19:39
Published
July 2022

Questions this talk answers

Why would a trading firm invest in open source when its business model is not open source?

Minsky says a healthy ecosystem gives the firm outside software to use, makes its main language attractive to recruits, and encourages external tools to integrate with its code.

When is hiring open source consultants not enough?

At Jane Street the consultants could not move fast enough because they were not inside and could not see the firm's problems, repo or workflows, so the firm started contributing directly while keeping the consultants to generalize and upstream the work.

How can a company publish code from a private monorepo?

Jane Street exports a chosen subset of its internal code to individual GitHub repos once or twice a week and imports issues and pull requests back into internal systems so developers can respond.

What made Dune succeed as a community project?

Jane Street hosted Dune on GitHub first and brought it internally periodically, giving outside contributors the same experience as anyone else; today more people outside the firm contribute than inside.

What are good practices for contributing to open source projects?

Minsky advises thinking about what is best for the community and treating contribution as a repeated game, investing in the engineering quality of changes so maintainers come to trust and accept them.

Topics

Related talks

Browse the library