Maximizing Trust and Efficiency: Verifiable Credentials and Decentralized Identity
Char Howland19:372022
Proving your age should not mean handing over your height and eye color
Showing a driver's license to buy an age-restricted item hands over your license number, height, weight and eye color, when the seller only needs a yes or no. Online, the trade-off is worse: privacy and security get sacrificed for convenience. Indicio software engineer Char Howland, who co-moderates a Hyperledger open-source working group, asks whether trust and efficiency really have to sit at opposite ends of the spectrum.
Learn how verifiable credentials verify, protect and secure identity without passwords or data hoarding
Char Howland, a software engineer at Indicio, explains how decentralized identity and verifiable credentials solve the internet's trust problem across four dimensions: verification, privacy, security and resilience. She walks through the issuer, holder and verifier model, selective disclosure, zero-knowledge proofs and frictionless zero trust, then shows a real deployment for COVID travel credentials in Aruba.
“We are forced to sacrifice privacy and security for convenience.”
“So the holder can prove exactly what they want to prove without revealing any more information than necessary.”
What you will learn
Explain the four dimensions of digital trust: verification, privacy, security and resilience.
Map the trust triangle of issuer, holder and verifier and what each puts on a public ledger.
Distinguish selective disclosure from zero-knowledge proofs using everyday examples like age checks.
Recognize how verifiable credentials make zero trust security frictionless by removing accounts, passwords and logins.
Find open-source entry points, such as the Hyperledger Identity Implementers Working Group, to learn and contribute.
Key takeaways from the speaker
Verifiable credentials maximize trust and efficiency.
Blockchain is an ideal platform for both security and transparency.
There are serious consequences for our lack of data privacy and transparency.
Details
Level
Beginner
Format
Talk
Technical depth
Introductory technical
For
All career stages
Length
19:37
Published
July 2022
Questions this talk answers
What is the difference between centralized and decentralized identity?
In centralized systems, organizations such as social media or email providers hold your identity data and decide what to do with it. With decentralized identity you hold your own credentials, like cards in a physical wallet, and choose when to present them.
How does a verifier know a verifiable credential is genuine and unaltered?
The issuer places cryptographic information, never personal data, on a public ledger. The verifier uses the keys found on the blockchain to confirm that only that issuer could have signed the credential and that it has not been changed.
What are selective disclosure and zero-knowledge proofs?
Selective disclosure lets you present only the relevant attributes of a credential instead of the whole document. Zero-knowledge proofs go further, letting a verifier confirm you meet a requirement, such as an age limit, with a simple yes or no and no actual values revealed.
How do verifiable credentials support zero trust security?
Zero trust requires continuous authentication and validation, which only works if it is frictionless. Verifiable credentials remove the need for personal accounts, passwords and logins, making continuous verification convenient.
Where has this technology been used in practice?
In the Cardea project, Indicio worked with SITA and the government of Aruba so travelers could prove COVID vaccination or test status from their phones without revealing health information.
About this talk
Verifiable credentials (VCs) use blockchain-based distributed ledger technology to create digital credentials that can verify information. Instead of centralizing identity in the hands of institutions and centralized third-parties, decentralized identity empowers individuals to take control of their digital identity and online data. Rather than sacrificing trust for efficiency or vice versa, VCs optimize both trust and efficiency. This talk will introduce decentralized identity, the technology used to create systems to exchange verifiable credentials, and explore their use cases.
How Aruba verified travelers without storing health data (62 s)
Hello and welcome everyone. Thank you for joining me here today. I'm very excited to be here. My name is Char Howland and I am a software engineer at Indicio. We are a global leader in building technology for verifying digital information in a privacy-preserving way. To give a bit of background about myself, I studied physics before moving into software engineering. I co-moderate a Hyperledger open-source working group and I live in Denver, Colorado. I'm going to talk to you for about 15 minutes and at the end I would love to hear any questions or comments that you might have.
Today I'm going to talk about trust. In particular, trust on the internet. Trust is fundamental to human community and survival. But by 2022, we live out a lot of our lives in a place with a serious lack of trust, which is the internet. So much of our communication happens online. We do conferences online. We bank and make purchases online. We might do our jobs, school, social media, telehealth all online. It is stressful to spend so much time in spaces where we are vulnerable to theft of our information and tracking of our every move. We are forced to sacrifice privacy and security for convenience. This New Yorker cartoon drawn by Peter Steiner was published in 1993 and almost 30 years later, this is still the key problem of the internet that you have no way to verify the person or dog that you are
talking to on the other end. When the internet was created, the small number of original users were all known to each other and there was not a need for verification in the same way. Billions of users later, the trust, the need for trust is still very present and the jury rigged solutions have, have serious problems. So there must be a better way to have trust and security in our digital lives. You should have control control over your data and your digital identity. This should not come at the cost of convenience or efficiency or requiring you to spend so much time doing multi-factor authentication or memorizing 40 passwords. You should feel a sense of safety, security, reassurance being in control on the internet.
So we see this digital trust problem in four dimensions. The first is verification. How can you verify who you are talking to? How can you verify that the information you receive actually comes from the source it claims to and that it arrives to you unaltered? The next is privacy. How can you make sure that nobody is listening in on your online interactions? How can you make sure that your data isn't being stored and sold behind your back? Security. How can you continuously verify digital information as authentic and unaltered in a frictionless way? And resilience. How can you make sure that there's no single point of failure and that we are not locked into technologies that aren't future-proof?
So we will talk about how decentralized identity can solve each of these problems. To dive into decentralized identity, we first need to examine our current centralized identity systems. So centralized in this context means that you and many other people's identity information is held by an organization. So you create a digital identity when you sign up on your website, you are not locked into technologies that aren't future-proof.
Also, meta holds your information. Your information is in their control and they choose what to do with it. If you are not on social media, you probably have an email. This is the same setup since this is a centralized identity system. Your email provider holds all of that personal information. And it's not even just that one organization holds your digital identity. You probably have had to sign up for more online accounts than you could ever remember. This means that there are copies of you and your digital information all over the internet, all centralized in the control of third parties.
So with decentralized identity, you control your own identity information. This is in the same way that you hold your driver's license and your library card and your rewards card to your favorite coffee shop in your physical wallet. They are yours, they're in your control, and you choose when to present them. In the previous slide, there were copies of you everywhere. Here you are at the center of all of your interactions.
Blockchain technology creates digital uniqueness that allows for the secure private digital equivalent to physical identity documents. This means that you can reveal certain information when you want to, but these organizations are not able to store information about you. So I'm going to talk about how decentralized identity solves each aspect of this four dimensional problem of verification, privacy, security, and resilience.
So we will start with verification. Verification means that information must be able to show definitively that it came from the source it claims to have come from and has not been altered. With decentralized identity, information is transferred through verifiable credentials. So we'll start with a credential. A credential is a passport, driver's license, vaccine card, health test, diploma, anything that proves information about you.
These we typically think of as physical documents that we can reasonably trust are unique because of security features like the material or the watermark, and we have a certain degree of trust based on that. So when you present a credential, when you present a verifiable credential using your mobile device, the cryptographic keys are found on the blockchain and it is verified that this credential was issued from the source it claims because only this issuer could have used those cryptographic keys to sign the credential and that this credential is unaltered.
Otherwise, this would break the blockchain. So there are three roles when we are discussing verifiable credentials, the people or organizations who issue credentials like the DMV with the driver's license example. This is called an issuer. The holder is the one who holds the credential. So I am the holder when I have my driver's license and then verifiers who verify this information.
This could be the airport or a concert venue anywhere where you need to prove your identity, your age, any information about yourself. And so when issuers issue credentials to a holder, they put certain cryptographic information on the public ledger. Very importantly, they never put any personal private information on the public ledger. That would obviously be a very serious privacy problem.
The information that they do put on the ledger is what allows the verifier to cryptographically verify that the credential, again, came from the issuer claims to unaltered, as we mentioned. So the only way in which the issuer and verifier interact is through the distributed ledger. The issuer and verifier have no way of storing, selling, sharing information on the holder behind their back.
So the holder can prove exactly what they want to prove without revealing any more information than necessary. This brings us to privacy. We will talk about the privacy enhancing features of verifiable credentials. So selective disclosure allows for only disclosing certain pieces of information on an identity credential. For example, when you have to present your driver's license to buy an age restricted item, they don't need to be able to see your driver's license number, your eye color, your height, your weight.
It is not at all relevant to that interaction. So this is a limitation of a physical identity document. It is all or nothing. With verifiable credentials, you can select which attributes in a credential you want to present. And so you don't have to show any irrelevant information. Zero knowledge proof adds another layer of privacy. It takes this a step further.
So in this same example of presenting your driver's license to buy an age restricted item, not only does the verifier not need to be able to see your height or your eye color. They also don't even need to know your age. They only need to know if you meet the age requirement. It's a true, false, yes, no, not a specific value necessary.
So verifiable credentials allow for a verifier to cryptographically verify if you meet a requirement without revealing the actual values in your credential. All they get is the bare minimum, yes, no, that they need to make a decision and they receive zero knowledge about you. There is an argument that people don't care about privacy or that we are willing to sacrifice privacy and convenience or for convenience and security.
But perhaps this is because we haven't really had much of a choice. It is also true that enough people do care about privacy, that there are laws to make it very costly to violate privacy rights. These laws are not going away, and so future proof technology really needs to have privacy at the forefront. The third dimension of the problem is security.
The new dominant paradigm for security is called zero trust. This means that you don't trust anything without verification. It is a security framework that requires everyone to be authenticated, authorized and continuously validated. Zero trust is a good framework, but it can't work well unless it's not, unless it is frictionless and convenient. Nobody has time to spend all day doing multi-factor authentication.
Verifiable credentials make the continuous verification necessary for zero trust security frictionless because it removes the need for personal accounts, passwords and logins. So currently we must sacrifice efficiency and jump through complicated hoops in order to increase trust and minimize risk. Or we can choose to skip the hassle, accept the risk and be vulnerable to theft and tracking.
Decentralized identity gives an option where trust and efficiency are not on opposite ends of the spectrum. You don't have to choose between them. You can have control over your identity information and you can have trust because of the distributed ledger while having the convenience of storing and presenting them digitally on your mobile device. The fourth dimension of the problem is resilience.
So the centralized paradigm has a single point of failure. If centralized identity systems go down, it's as if somebody shuts off access to the power grid. Bad actors only need to target one point to bring the whole system down. Decentralized identifiers and distributed ledgers mean resilient systems because they are built on decentralized technology. This does not have a single point of failure.
In addition, the foundation of this technology is open source. This means people from all over the world and all sorts of companies are collaborating on this technology and giving it constant reliability testing and constant sustainable innovation. This also means it's interoperable and easy to integrate with existing systems. It allows for the virtuous cycle in which open source technology innovation helps business innovation and vice versa.
And in addition, this means that you are not tied into a proprietary technology that may not evolve to meet the needs of tomorrow or commit you to expensive upgrades. So we've identified how decentralized identity and verifiable credentials solve the problems of verification, privacy, security and resilience. And we will now take this a step further and describe the comprehensive solution they create as a trusted digital ecosystem.
This refers to an ecosystem for verifying and sharing high value information. So this means that trust extends not only within the system, but also outside of the trust triangle. This is what creates the ecosystem. There can be trusted interactions between holders, issuers and verifiers anywhere in the ecosystem. It can scale to involve everyone and covers all parties in the exchange and verification of data.
This allows for reusing identity between contexts. You can take identity information from one institution to another because they are, again, in your control and do not need a centralized database. So we will now talk about how this technology is actually being used today. The example we will discuss is the Kardia project. I just want to call it that Kila Shatzkin and Heather Dahl gave a great presentation on this project earlier today.
So I hope you were able to join that session. I'll discuss it very briefly here. This award winning technology allows travelers to prove their COVID vaccination or test status while protecting their health information and privacy. This, again, relates to the previous slide connecting different roles across contact contexts because health information does not exist in the vacuum. You don't just need to be able to securely send and receive information to and from one doctor.
You probably have multiple providers and you may need to reveal certain information in different contexts, such as travel in this case. So on this project, Indicio worked with Cida Aero, which is the leading technology provider to the airline industry and the government of the Caribbean island of Aruba to deploy this technology with travelers. So Aruba's economy is very dependent on tourism.
And as the COVID-19 pandemic started, they had to figure out how to keep residents safe and comply with health mandates while keeping the local industries alive. They didn't want the costly and risky path of dealing with data privacy and storing health information, and so they turned to verifiable credentials. The Cardia project just won the European identity or an award at the European Identity Conference last month, which is a great validation of the success of this technology.
And Cida donated this project to the Linux Foundation Public Health, where it has an active open source developer working group. So just to give a brief overview of this technology, I won't go into too much detail, but you'll recognize this trust triangle again where the lab technician is the issuer and is issuing a COVID credential. So again, they put public cryptographic information, no private information on the ledger in order to do this.
They give the credential data to the holder, who is the traveler in this interaction, who is presenting their credential to the government health representative, who is the verifier in this case, and verifies that it came unaltered from this trusted lab technician. So this allows travelers to use their mobile devices to cryptographically prove vaccine or health status. A simple yes, no if they're able to enter the island or certain venue without revealing any healthcare information along with it.
They have complete control over their information throughout this interaction. And in this way, health mandates can be enforced without compromising anyone's privacy rights to broaden this out from a health care from a health information management solution. This technology can be applied to any information where businesses and people want trusted, actionable data. So right now, this technology is useful in the financial travel and health care industries, but it will also help prepare for the coming technology.
This technology is useful in the future. Digital trust only becomes more imperative as more of our lives are lived online, which will accelerate with the rise of the spatial web. This term describes how through the proliferative proliferation of cameras and sensors, digital objects will interact with non digital objects. In other words, when there are tiny computers in everything and everything is interconnected, the need for trusted communication will explode.
Everything will require an identity and privacy and security. I'd imagine if you have a Roomba vacuum robot cleaner, I'd imagine that you don't want to any random person to be able to control it. And the risks are far greater when we think about health care devices in our bodies, national security, to name a few. So we are at the start of a revolution in how we interact online.
And we are solving that key problem that the original creators of the internet could not have imagined. So because so much of this technology is open source, this means that if you're interested, you can learn as much as you want about the technology and even get involved in building it. I have linked the information of many working groups here.
I moderate the hyper ledger identity implementers working group, which is a great starting place because it is a high level group that keeps track of progress from the majority of the world. The majority of the working groups in this space, and we would love it if you join us. There are also meetup events hosted by in DCO and hyper ledger as well as custom trainings available.
And with that, I will conclude my talk. Thank you so much for listening. Here is my contact information. If you'd like to reach out and looks like I have gone a bit over the time that I said that I would love to answer any questions that you might have. So feel free to drop any questions in the chat.
All right, I'm not seeing any questions. So thank you all for listening. And it looks like I'm at time. Thank you for listening. And thank you to the event organizers and tech support for making this conference possible. And again, please reach out if you would like to chat about this anymore. Thank you.
Transcribed automatically; names checked against the speaker record. Select a time to jump there.
Article based on this talk
Can you prove who you are online without giving away your data?
Char Howland explains how verifiable credentials and decentralized identity let people prove only what is needed, so trust no longer costs privacy or convenience.
In short
Char Howland, a software engineer at Indicio, argues that the internet still has no reliable way to verify who or what is on the other end, and that people are forced to give up privacy and security for convenience. Decentralized identity and verifiable credentials, she explains, let individuals hold their own credentials and prove only what is needed, so trust and efficiency no longer have to be traded against each other.
Key takeaways
Verifiable credentials maximize trust and efficiency.
Blockchain is an ideal platform for both security and transparency.
There are serious consequences for our lack of data privacy and transparency.
The internet's unsolved trust problem
Howland opens with a familiar image: the 1993 New Yorker cartoon by Peter Steiner, which she says still captures the key problem of the internet almost 30 years later. You have no way to verify the person, or dog, you are talking to. When the internet began, its few original users all knew each other. Billions of users later, she says, the need for trust is still present and the improvised fixes have serious problems.
Meanwhile, more of life has moved online: conferences, banking, shopping, work, school and telehealth. Spending so much time in spaces where information can be stolen and every move tracked is stressful, and the cost lands on the individual.
"We are forced to sacrifice privacy and security for convenience." (0:44)
Howland breaks the problem into four dimensions. Verification asks whether information really comes from its claimed source, unaltered. Privacy asks whether anyone is listening in or selling your data. Security asks how to keep verifying information in a frictionless way. Resilience asks how to avoid a single point of failure and technology that is not future-proof.
From copies of you everywhere to a wallet you control
Today's identity is centralized. A social media company or email provider holds your information and decides what to do with it, and the many accounts most people create leave copies of them scattered across the internet. Decentralized identity flips this model. Howland compares it to a physical wallet holding a driver's license, a library card and a coffee shop rewards card: they are yours, and you choose when to present them.
Verification works through a trust triangle. An issuer, such as the motor vehicle authority, issues a credential. A holder keeps it on a mobile device. A verifier, such as an airport or concert venue, checks it. The issuer puts only cryptographic information on a public ledger, never personal data, and the verifier uses the keys on the blockchain to confirm the credential is authentic and unaltered. Because issuer and verifier interact only through the ledger, neither can store, sell or share information about the holder behind their back.
"So the holder can prove exactly what they want to prove without revealing any more information than necessary." (7:56)
Proving only what is needed
Howland's clearest example is buying an age-restricted item. A physical license is all or nothing: the seller sees your license number, eye color, height and weight. Selective disclosure lets you present only the relevant attributes. Zero-knowledge proofs go a step further, because the seller does not even need your age.
"They only need to know if you meet the age requirement." (8:54)
She also challenges the claim that people do not care about privacy. Enough people care, she notes, that laws make violating privacy rights very costly, and those laws are not going away, so future-proof technology needs privacy at the forefront.
"But perhaps this is because we haven't really had much of a choice." (9:38)
Zero trust without the friction, and no single point of failure
Zero trust, which Howland describes as the new dominant security paradigm, requires everyone to be authenticated, authorized and continuously validated. It only works if it is convenient, and nobody wants to spend the day on multi-factor authentication. Verifiable credentials make continuous verification frictionless by removing the need for personal accounts, passwords and logins.
"Decentralized identity gives an option where trust and efficiency are not on opposite ends of the spectrum. You don't have to choose between them." (11:02)
On resilience, she compares a failure of centralized identity systems to someone shutting off the power grid: attackers only need to hit one point. Distributed ledgers and decentralized identifiers remove that single point of failure. Because the foundation is open source, people and companies worldwide test and improve it, it integrates with existing systems, and adopters avoid lock-in to proprietary technology. Together these pieces form a trusted digital ecosystem in which identity information can be reused across institutions without a central database.
A real deployment: COVID travel credentials in Aruba
Howland grounds the ideas in the Cardea project. Indicio worked with SITA, which she describes as the leading technology provider to the airline industry, and the government of Aruba, an island whose economy depends heavily on tourism. Aruba needed to keep residents safe and meet health mandates without taking on the cost and risk of storing health data. In the deployed system, a lab technician issues a COVID credential, the traveler holds it, and a government health representative verifies it, receiving only a yes or no. As the speaker cited, the project won an award at the European Identity Conference, and SITA donated it to Linux Foundation Public Health, where it has an active open-source working group.
She closes by looking ahead to the spatial web, where cameras, sensors and tiny computers connect physical and digital objects and the need for trusted communication will explode, from a home robot vacuum to medical devices and national security. She invites viewers to join open-source efforts such as the Hyperledger Identity Implementers Working Group, which she moderates.
"So we are at the start of a revolution in how we interact online." (17:41)
Watch the talk
Maximizing Trust and Efficiency: Verifiable Credentials and Decentralized Identity, by Char Howland (20 minutes): https://www.womentech.net/video/maximizing-trust-and-efficiency-verifiable-credentials-and-decentralized-identity-char
About the speaker
Char Howland is a Software Engineer at Indicio, a company that provides software and infrastructure for Trusted Data Ecosystems so organizations can authenticate and exchange high-value information. She has contributed to customer products and systems including the Hyperledger Aries Cloud Agent Python ecosystem, and holds a degree in physics from Willamette University.
Questions this talk answers
What is the difference between centralized and decentralized identity?
How does a verifier know a verifiable credential is genuine and unaltered?
What are selective disclosure and zero-knowledge proofs?
How do verifiable credentials support zero trust security?
Where has this technology been used in practice?
Drafted with AI from the talk transcript. Editor review pending.
Frameworks and ideas mentioned
Zero trust
Verifiable credentials
Decentralized identifiers
Selective disclosure
Zero-knowledge proofs
Trust triangle (issuer, holder, verifier)
Four dimensions of digital trust (verification, privacy, security, resilience)
Resources mentioned
Hyperledger Identity Implementers Working Group
Indicio and Hyperledger meetup events
Linux Foundation Public Health Cardea working group
Cite this talk
Char Howland. "Maximizing Trust and Efficiency: Verifiable Credentials and Decentralized Identity." WomenTech Network, 2022. https://www.womentech.net/video/maximizing-trust-and-efficiency-verifiable-credentials-and-decentralized-identity-char