Digital Protectors of the New Era: Cyber Insurance
Onur Korucu20:012022
Cyber insurance won't make you more secure, and that is the point
A hacked sprinkler system can flood a warehouse, and a GDPR regulator, not the insurer, may decide whether a breach fine can be insured at all. As business and home life move onto connected devices, cyber losses spill well beyond data. Onur Korucu, a senior GRC, data protection and cyber security manager at Avanade, asks what cyber insurance is really for, and who actually needs it.
Learn where cyber insurance fits in risk management and what it does and does not cover
Onur Korucu, a senior GRC, data protection and cyber security manager at Avanade, explains what cyber insurance is, why cyber risk now reaches physical assets and personal lives, and who needs cover. She argues that cyber insurance is not a cybersecurity tool but a risk transfer mechanism for residual risk, complicated by questions such as whether GDPR fines are insurable.
“And it is very important to remember that the primary purpose of cyber insurance is not to improve cyber security, but to transfer your residual risk.”
“But cyber loss is not just the whole digital risk, it splits over the physical world, tangible assets as well.”
What you will learn
Explain cyber insurance as a mechanism for transferring residual risk, not a substitute for security controls.
Map cyber risk beyond data to physical damage, business interruption, reputational damage and privacy claims.
Recognise that a GDPR regulator decides whether breach fines are insurable, and plan finances accordingly.
Identify personal cyber risks such as identity theft, mobile banking fraud and attacks on connected home devices.
Anticipate emerging forms of cover for cloud, IoT, AI and blockchain risks.
Key takeaways from the speaker
A cyber liability policy protects businesses from claims and expenses (including loss of income, related expenses, and damage to your company's reputation) resulting from a data breach, hacking or cyber attack.
A cyber liability policy protects you beyond the basics of general liability insurance, which does not protect against cyber attacks and data breaches.
Details
Level
Intermediate
Format
Talk
Technical depth
Introductory technical
For
Mid-career, People manager, Executive
Length
20:01
Published
July 2022
Questions this talk answers
What is cyber insurance?
Also called cyber risk or cyber liability insurance, it is cover designed to protect a business from digital-age threats such as data breaches and malicious hacks on its computer systems.
Does cyber insurance improve cybersecurity?
Its primary purpose is to transfer residual risk, not to improve security. However, the risk assessments insurers make can raise awareness, expose poor cyber hygiene and push organisations to add controls.
Who needs cyber insurance?
Any business with an online component, that stores or sends electronic data, or that relies on technology for its operations, which is nearly every business. Individuals can also buy cover for personal cyber risks.
Can cyber insurance pay GDPR fines?
Many policies offer coverage for breach-related fines, but a GDPR regulator determines whether fines are insurable, so business owners may have to pay them out of pocket.
Why does cyber loss go beyond digital assets?
Attacks can hit physical systems such as sprinklers, alarms, warehouse controls and connected cars, while cyber cover has historically focused on digital assets and left tangible assets largely uninsured.
About this talk
Cyber insurance (also referred to as cyber risk or cyber liability insurance) is a form of cover designed to protect your business from threats in the digital age, such as data breaches or malicious cyber hacks on work computer systems.
Cyber insurance helps to protect your business against a variety of digital risks by supporting financially if you experience a damaging network event such as a cyber-attack. Also known as cyber liability insurance, this commercial cover is designed to react quickly to malware attacks, hacking events and electronic data breaches by funding investigation and reimbursing losses.
The future: AI, IoT and blockchain insurance (73 s)
Hello, everybody. Before I start, I want to say very sincere hi to everyone and thank you all for taking time and attending the session today. I'm very proud to show the Women Power together once again and with participation from many different locations in the world. And it's great to be part of Women Power. I would like to express my gratitude once again to giving me a chance to meet you. I hope you don't mind my voice because my voice is a little bit scratchy due to cold I have. Anyway, I hope the content we are prepared for you will be useful.
First of all, I want to introduce myself to you. My name is Onur Korucu, and I'm working as a senior data protection GRC and cybersecurity manager at Avonad UK and Ireland. Previously, I worked in multinational professional services companies such as KPMG, PwC and Grant Orton, and I help organizations create robust tailor-made and well-established information and cybersecurity governance structures and data protection practices that mitigate the risks they face in their business, in their sectors, and help them to comply with regulatory requirements like GDPR or implementation issues.
And my current role is in a technology company and we are empowering companies in areas such as GRC cybersecurity data protection by using different technology solutions. It can be Microsoft and it can be other useful technology solutions. Now, along my side, I continue to be a woman in technology representative in large-scale international communities like ISACA Europe, ISACA Asia, IAPP by having a presence in conference and seminars.
And I published my first book last year. It was about correlation risk management and GDPR and cybersecurity. And so today I'm going to talk about the very trending topics of recent years. This is cyber insurance. And in the session, we will focus on the definition of cyber insurance and the benefits of cyber insurance. And I think the importance because I think people cannot understand more. This is very important thing for our future. So maybe I can start like that. My first encounter with the concept of cyber insurance dates back to seven, eight years ago.
And I am very happy to witness the studies and investments made in this field because we were working on this cyber insurance issues together with Microsoft right now. And I'm really happy because we can use, we can understand the importance of cyber insurance. If we can continue with cyber insurance. If we can continue with our slides, let's start with cyber risk because cyber risk, which are the root cause of cyber insurance have increased drastically during the pandemic.
And so any risk emerging for use of information and communication technology that compromises, you know, we've got a trilogy, this confidentiality, availability and integrity of the data or services. And the empowerment of operational technology eventually leads to business disruption, infrastructure breakdown and physical damage to humans and properties. Cyber risk either caused naturally or it can be manmade where the ladder can emerge for human failure or cyber criminality, cyber war and cyber terrorism.
And it is very, very, very, very, you know, familiar right now. Everybody used to it because this cyber bullying, you are using very clever phone, machine, cars, everything's can cause cyber risks right now. So it is characterized by interdependencies, professional extreme events, high uncertainty with respect to data and modeling approach and resources. And risk of change. And another unique of cyber risk is risk of change because, you know, time is changing after pandemic new technologies and regulations continuously affect the nature of cyber risk.
For example, future technological innovations such as Internet of Things, IoT, artificial intelligence, health tech, robotics. Think about 5G blockchain will further increase cyber risks and lead to emerging both new and unforeseen risks. And the changing risk comes the need for better insurance and the development of connected technologies or cyberspace is leading to business opportunities as well as increasing risks.
This provides space to develop, new and improve existing insurance, leading to premium products. And to size, these opportunities today are full potential, non-conventional approach is needed. While in insurance markets needs require to build a providing stability by being stable when it comes to cyber risk market, it needs to require development change in risks as well as markets will happen ever more quickly.
So in the not too distant future, only the insurance who know how to service their customer with these changes will remain. And understanding cyber risk, this is a fundamental role for the future of the insurance is it's a good start for them. And if you look at the slide afterwards, we understand what is cyber risk, we can talk about what is cyber loss because we generally always think about if you will lose something by cyberspace, it can be very digital.
But cyber loss is not just the whole digital risk, it splits over the physical world, tangible assets as well. For example, hacking into fire protection, sprinkler system cloud leads to flooding and the match the physical property. An integrated wave of cyber is critical to fully intangible assets, which leaves organization exposed to a much wider scale of damage.
Because cyber insurance has historically been focused on digital assets such as clients' personal data, the transactional data, tangible assets are generally not being insured. The increase in cyber attacks, along with its wider impact, has lead clients and insurers to retake. And these rethinking issues and knock-on effect on the insurance lines like personal reputation, physical damage and intellectual properties.
In general, cyber risk can be categorized according to several dimensions. If you look at it in here, you can understand it's not just about physical damage or just business interruption. It's, of course, related to reputational damage and privacy claims and phishing because in pandemic you experience a lot of ransomwares. And, for example, the float, earthquake or fire can cause this physical damage too.
So, you can think about there are a lot of different examples. Also, with digital assets like database, it extends far deeper across other lines of risk. The bulk of damaged cyber events may actually be physical assets, especially if cyber security is being used to gain access and physical assets. For example, your home. You've got a hacking and you can be hacked because you, a lot of house and you got an alarm system to gain entry and steal possessions.
And, for example, your property like hacking control systems for malicious purposes, including sabotage, changing temperatures in computational warehouse to destroy stock, setting of fire sprinkler systems to evacuate buildings. So, for example, for example, you're not driving Tesla or very electronic cars. And so, your vehicle tapped by controlling onboard computers, immobiles, cars, and aviation shipping, stealing customers' personal information to onboard internet access.
And it's very typical personal data breach scenario in this era. And, for this reason, cyber risk is being recognized as operational risk and monitored separately from general operational risks. So, we have to understand it's not just about our physical issues or just business interruptions. It's really about your personal life, daily routine, and it's really impacted everywhere. And then, the question is, then what is this cyber insurance?
This cyber insurance, we can refer that cyber risk insurance or cyber loyalty insurance too, is a form of coverage design to protect your business from threats in digital age, such as data breaches, malicious cyber hacks on your computer systems. And it is very important to remember that the primary purpose of cyber insurance is not to improve cyber security, but to transfer your residual risk.
It's not a silver bullet for cyber security challenge, but this is very important. It's not just a product to just focus on post-incident. The cyber insurance included forensic analysis, incident response, legal services, and peer advice. So, with these ways by which cyber insurance has some positive effects, cyber security and risk management can be identified. I mean that it's like assessing your risk profile and security practices, or if you have a company, you can understand your posture, your maturity of cyber security.
And then linking these risk profiles with best practices and the financial incentives. And then raising awareness of risk and providing access for these services. To access your client's profile, they can identify potential risks, poor cyber hygiene and bad practices via intentional risk management, implement new controls, and remediate previously identified vulnerabilities. I think it's like a complex work because in professional services, we always started with risk management and understand our clients' needs and the maturities for the cyber security, information security, and data protection area.
And with cyber insurance. And with cyber insurance, you can grow up business, became dependent on computer networks and the internet because you can profile your clients, you can profile your companies, or you can profile your own internet, your own digital era. So, I mean that cyber insurance. And cyber insurance has two primary purposes. This is depending on the needs per child purchase.
Cyber insurance provides a risk transfer mechanism. This enables an organization to spread and defer financial risk to another party to cover at least cost steaming from a cyber incident. If used properly, this financial backstop serves as the last step in the risk management process. It emphasizes that cyber insurance is intended to transfer residual risk to risk that's in other cyber risk management practices not mitigate.
And who needs this cyber insurance? This is a very important area because any business which has an online component or one that sends or stores electronic data might benefit from cyber insurance as may an organization that relies on technology to conduct its operations, which is pretty much every business in this world. And if we can continue in here, you can understand that cyber insurance is very, very familiar with GDPR because while many insurance policies provide comprehensive coverage for fines penalties associated with the data breach, a GDPR regulator will determine whether fines are insurable or not.
Based on GDPR insurance requirements, this could means business owners may have to pay these fines out of the pocket. And these regulatory fines and penalties that follow companies actions, whether they are negligent or intentional for non-compliance as the GDPRs can be extensive. You know, business owners must plan accordingly with their finance should they face these fines. And this is very typical again, because in your daily routine, you are using all your, you know, digital devices and you are using e-commerce and you always share your personal data with these companies, organizations.
So the cyber insurance is one of protectors for GDPR penalties and data breach issues too. And if you can continue in here, you can see it's not just for organizations. It's also cover the personal in cyber insurance issues too. I mean that technology has become very extensive and so it's hard to live without it, you know, it comes with huge advantages, but also risks.
And there is an increasing role for insurance to play in protecting customers in the face of cyber threats. Besides being able to stop whenever or wherever, as well as stream movies and music, the digitalization of the personal space has many, many other more tangible benefits too. For millions of people in emerging markets managing money via mobile phone has become a lifeline, rapid advance in technology or in inevitable new services all the time.
And smart doorbells let you see who is at the doorstep via your app on your phone. And smart heating lighting controls let you change the temperature and the switch lights automatically. All such as all such these devices are part of Internet of things. I mean that IOT, the meaning they are connected and send information via Internet and enabling them to be controlled by phone, tablet or PC, whatever.
Thing about sky is the limit right now. There are many cyber attacks types that are targets in the videos more specifically and which can have profound and distress. And distressing the consequences. And so you can face with this area, this identity protection, data loss recovery, cyber bullying, connected on device attack protection, network extortion protection, mobile banking protection, because it can cause financial fraud.
Most probably a lot of people face this kind of issues because every day we receive some messages, some emails from different organizations, from different financial area. And we have to face, we have to understand these risks and we have to control these areas and the online transaction and cyber liability. And there are also cyber insurance solutions for people needs as the same as companies.
That is why that we can protect themselves from these cyber risks. And then finally, sorry, yeah, we have some challenges in the sector, this negative dynamics in cyber insurance markets. But I believe that with all these negative issues came to solve and several long standing barriers and uptake. We can understand after that the potential for cyber insurance to, you know, incentivize negative behaviors like the moral hazard and ransomware.
And all in all, cyber insurance can still be considered very new and important. So cyber insurance, I think this insurance area can be understood yet very well. And technology is touching every aspect of our lives. And therefore it's very innovative, cyber insurance will become more and more critical. And my perspective, it is highly likely what we will start seeing the cyber insurance concepts in the form of cloud computing insurance, IoT insurance, AI insurance or blockchain insurance in the future.
And although a well-functioning cyber insurance industry could improve cyber security practices on a societal scale and it's very, very related with our cyber risks to control everything in our daily life. And I am very sure that the wonderful ladies like you will start taking place in the field of cyber insurance, which is one of the emerging concepts and brings together, you know, cyber security, risk management and financial sector approaches.
And wishing you good health and happiness. And thank you for everyone, your time and listening to me and hope you will enjoy the conference. It's very nice to meet you all. Bye bye.
Transcribed automatically; names checked against the speaker record. Select a time to jump there.
Article based on this talk
Cyber insurance does not fix security: it transfers the risk that remains
Onur Korucu explains what cyber insurance covers, who needs it, and why GDPR fines and physical losses complicate the picture.
In short
Onur Korucu argues that cyber insurance is not a cybersecurity tool but a financial one: it transfers the residual risk that remains after other controls have done their work. Because cyber losses now reach physical assets, reputations and personal lives, she sees cyber insurance becoming more critical for nearly every business and for many individuals.
Key takeaways
A cyber liability policy protects businesses from claims and expenses (including loss of income, related expenses and damage to the company's reputation) resulting from a data breach, hacking or a cyber attack.
A cyber liability policy offers protection beyond the basics of general liability insurance, which does not protect against cyber attacks and data breaches.
Cyber risk keeps changing, and insurers must keep up
Korucu begins with cyber risk, which she calls the root cause of cyber insurance, and notes, as the speaker cited, that it increased drastically during the pandemic. She frames it through the familiar trilogy of confidentiality, integrity and availability of data and services, and describes it as either natural or man-made, ranging from human failure to cyber criminality, cyber war and cyber terrorism.
What makes cyber risk distinctive, in her view, is the "risk of change". Technologies such as the Internet of Things, artificial intelligence, health tech, robotics, 5G and blockchain keep creating new and unforeseen exposures, and regulation keeps moving too. For insurers this is both a threat and a business opportunity, and she argues it calls for non-conventional approaches rather than the stability insurance markets usually prize.
"So in the not too distant future, only the insurance who know how to service their customer with these changes will remain." (6:02)
Cyber loss reaches the physical world
Korucu's second point challenges the assumption that a cyber incident only costs data. Her examples are concrete: a hacked fire sprinkler system that floods a property, a home alarm system compromised to let burglars in, warehouse temperature controls changed to destroy stock, and connected cars immobilised through their onboard computers, with passengers' personal data stolen through onboard internet access.
She explains that cyber insurance has historically focused on digital assets such as clients' personal data and transactional data, while tangible assets have generally not been insured. The rise in attacks has pushed clients and insurers to rethink, with knock-on effects for lines such as reputation, physical damage and intellectual property. Cyber risk, she notes, is now recognised as an operational risk and monitored separately from general operational risks.
"But cyber loss is not just the whole digital risk, it splits over the physical world, tangible assets as well." (6:40)
What cyber insurance is, and what it is not
Korucu defines cyber insurance, also called cyber risk or cyber liability insurance, as cover designed to protect a business from threats of the digital age, such as data breaches and malicious hacks on computer systems. Her central message is about purpose.
"And it is very important to remember that the primary purpose of cyber insurance is not to improve cyber security, but to transfer your residual risk." (10:16)
She adds that it is not a silver bullet, and that it is not only a post-incident product. Policies can include forensic analysis, incident response and legal services. The underwriting process itself has side benefits: insurers assess a client's risk profile and security practices, link that profile to best practices and financial incentives, and can surface poor cyber hygiene, prompting new controls and remediation of known vulnerabilities. She positions this risk transfer as the final stage of risk management, not the first.
"If used properly, this financial backstop serves as the last step in the risk management process." (12:39)
Who needs it, and the GDPR catch
Korucu's answer to who needs cover is broad: any business that has an online component, sends or stores electronic data, or relies on technology to operate.
"And who needs this cyber insurance? This is a very important area because any business which has an online component or one that sends or stores electronic data might benefit from cyber insurance as may an organization that relies on technology to conduct its operations, which is pretty much every business in this world." (13:16)
She then flags an important limit. While many policies offer coverage for fines and penalties linked to a data breach, a GDPR regulator determines whether those fines are insurable. Business owners may therefore have to pay GDPR fines out of pocket and should plan their finances accordingly.
Cyber insurance is not only for organisations. Korucu points to the connected home, from smart doorbells to smart heating and lighting, and to mobile money, which she describes as a lifeline for millions of people in emerging markets. Personal cover can address identity protection, data loss recovery, cyber bullying, attacks on connected devices, network extortion and mobile banking fraud.
Challenges and the road ahead
Korucu acknowledges negative dynamics in the market, including concerns that insurance could incentivise bad behaviour through moral hazard and ransomware payments. Still, she considers the field new, important and not yet well understood, and expects it to grow as technology touches every part of life.
"And my perspective, it is highly likely what we will start seeing the cyber insurance concepts in the form of cloud computing insurance, IoT insurance, AI insurance or blockchain insurance in the future." (18:26)
She closes by encouraging women to step into cyber insurance, a field that brings together cybersecurity, risk management and financial sector approaches.
Watch the talk
"Digital Protectors of the New Era: Cyber Insurance" by Onur Korucu (20 minutes): https://www.womentech.net/video/digital-protectors-new-era-cyber-insurance-onur-korucu
About the speaker
Onur Korucu is Sr. GRC, Data Protection and Cyber Security Manager at Avanade, where she helps organisations build robust information security governance structures and data protection practices that mitigate risk and meet regulatory requirements. She holds a technical engineering degree, an M.Sc and an LL.M in Information and Technology Law, has published a book on risk-based global approaches to data protection, and is an official speaker at ISACA Europe and ISACA Asia.
Questions this talk answers
What is cyber insurance?
Does cyber insurance improve cybersecurity?
Who needs cyber insurance?
Can cyber insurance pay GDPR fines?
Why does cyber loss go beyond digital assets?
Drafted with AI from the talk transcript. Editor review pending.
Frameworks and ideas mentioned
GDPR
Confidentiality, integrity and availability (CIA triad)
Cite this talk
Onur Korucu. "Digital Protectors of the New Era: Cyber Insurance." WomenTech Network, 2022. https://www.womentech.net/video/digital-protectors-new-era-cyber-insurance-onur-korucu