Treating your career as zero-sum keeps everyone stuck at a local maximum
Samsung sold its industry-leading OLED screen to Apple, its direct smartphone rival, and both gained from the deal. Yet in Sreeja Nair's own first team, a single performance review turned friendly colleagues into rivals who stopped sharing. Nair, Director of Product Management at Qualcomm and a Qualcomm Global D&I Champion, asks what it would take to compete and cooperate at once without giving up your edge.
Get three concrete habits that turn peer rivalry into shared growth for you and your team
Sreeja Nair, Director of Product Management at Qualcomm, argues that careers should not be treated as a zero-sum, finite game. Using game theory, the prisoner's dilemma and business examples from Samsung, Apple and Amazon, she explains co-opetition and offers three practical actions for individuals and managers to combine competition with cooperation.
“She believes that she can learn from both of them and constantly works on becoming the best version of herself.”
“It's a little difficult to appreciate people who are junior, but hardest to appreciate peers.”
What you will learn
Explain co-opetition and why rivals such as Samsung, Apple and Amazon gain by cooperating.
Recognise how zero-sum thinking, modelled by the prisoner's dilemma, leads to worse outcomes for everyone.
Spot moments such as performance reviews when a team stops sharing, and counter them with initiatives like expert talks.
Practise co-opetition by sharing work for feedback and complimenting peers whose skills you want to learn.
Set win-win goals that measure each person by the success of their peers and stakeholders.
Key takeaways from the speaker
Learn about the concept of co-opetition in the business world
Understand how co-opetition is critical to developing one's career
How to apply co-opetition to your career and personal growth
Details
Level
All levels
Format
Talk
Technical depth
Non-technical
For
Early career, Mid-career, People manager
Length
22:43
Published
August 2022
Questions this talk answers
What is co-opetition?
It is a business strategy in which competitors cooperate on something with the expectation of mutual benefit, combining competition and cooperation. The speaker says it was introduced in business by professors Adam Brandenburger and Barry Nalebuff in the early 1990s.
Why would Samsung supply its best screen to Apple?
If Samsung had not supplied it, another screen maker would have, strengthening Samsung's competitors, and Apple helps its suppliers improve quality. Samsung had the best screen and Apple had a loyal customer base, so both gained.
How does the prisoner's dilemma relate to careers?
Individual incentives push each party to act against the other even though cooperating would serve both better. Nair argues that the same win-lose mindset at work keeps individuals and society stuck at a local maximum.
How can an individual start practising co-opetition?
Share your work to get feedback and give feedback to others, and acknowledge, appreciate and elevate peers. Nair challenges viewers to identify three peers with skills they admire, compliment them and ask them to teach.Set up meetings to learn from them.
How can managers build co-opetition into a team?
Make win-win a KPI by giving each team member a goal measured by the success of their direct stakeholders and peers. In the example Nair shares, this made people listen more, acknowledge each other's work and collaborate.
About this talk
We typically view our careers as a zero sum or finite game. In this talk I will use concepts from game theory and business, to demonstrate why our careers should not be viewed as a finite game. I will use examples from my career, personal life, other individuals and business to explain the concept of co-opetition and how you can use it to bring out the best version of yourself. The session will include actionable tips to imbibe co-opetition in your career planning and strategy
The idea today is to talk about co-opetition and it comes from this idea that I'd like to introduce to you. Before that, I'll go into a story. Alex, Beth, and Kathy are three high schoolers in Freemont High School, Bay Area. Okay. The three have been in the same schools throughout their academic journeys. All three are extremely talented straight A students and work really hard to excel at everything they do. Now off this, Beth is an eloquent speaker and has won every debate and oratory competition. Alex, while being good, has always ended up coming second in these oratory competitions.
Now throughout her school life, she's competed closely with Beth, but has never managed to secure the first place. What this has done is it has created an unwanted animosity and jealousy in Alex's, um, in, in her mind and, uh, against Alex, which spills over into other fields. Where she is late looking to outsmart beat or put down Alex.
Now Kathy, on the other hand, isn't as good as Alex or Beth at oratory skills and at best ends up winning a second runner up or a consolation prize or a rising star in most competitions. However, Kathy has a different approach to these competitions. She talks to both Alex and Beth to learn how they prepare their tricks and feedback for her.
She believes that she can learn from both of them and constantly works on becoming the best version of herself. Now all three of them end up graduating with honors and going to different undergrad schools. They now find themselves in a different world with a completely different set of people. Alex now loses her top oratory spot to someone else in the class and tries to deal with a whole new reality.
Beth now finds more competitors and sinks into depression at losing her only mode. You know what she believed in that. Hey, I'm good. I'm just, you know, next to Alex. Kathy also finds new folks who are better than her, but she continues to be happy and thrives by collaborating with people better than her and constantly improving her skills.
So what happened here? Alex and Beth were both better than Kathy at school. But when faced with a different challenge, the skills they learned did not suffice. Beth was so focused on, you know, competing with Alex that she forgot to learn and enjoy. Alex, on the other hand, was so focused on winning that she did not focus on improving her strengths.
And learning, learning additional skill sets from others. After three, Kathy was focused on continuous improvement, which served her well in both the worlds in school and in undergrad school. And in the above example, we focused on a single dimension of oratory skills. What would happen if each of the, each of them embodied Kathy's philosophy and cooperated to learn while competing in arts, sports, music, dance and all other facets that, you know, they do in school.
Each one of them would strive to learn from each other from others and become the best version of themselves and raise the bar for the class and for themselves. Hello, I am Sreeja Nayar and I work as the director of product management at Qualcomm, where I work with enterprise providers to align their connectivity needs with Qualcomm's prolific wireless portfolio.
Today, I'm really excited to talk about this idea of cooperation with all of you. The idea of cooperation comes from two words, cooperation and competition. Cooperation and competition together combined to form competition. Now, competition is a strategy in business in which competition and cooperation are combined in a way that harnesses the benefits of each. In a way, it is a, it is when two businesses in the same industry work together on something that is not their core competency or where they can, you know, collaborate to get better.
Specifically, competition is when two companies that are known to be competitors collaborate with each other with the expectation of mutual benefits. The idea of competition is not new. It's been, it's been there for a long time. In the business world, it was introduced by two professors, Adam Brandenberger and Barry Nalbuff in the early nineties. Now in business, competition is a model that draws insight from game theory in which competitors in a game form an alliance to achieve the same purpose.
Competition models involve the use of statistics that map out shares and losses involved in an alliance. Now, business really historically has been viewed as a zero sum game where, you know, one loses, one wins between competitors. So one had to lose for the other to win. Competition strategies have paved a new way for businesses to work together to deliver the highest value to create a win-win game.
So here are a couple of famous examples. You may not even have thought about them. You think of them as rivals, but here is how they have co-opitate. Okay. So first example, Samsung and Apple. Can you imagine? Now Samsung had a decision to make whether they wanted to sell Apple their newest super retina edge to edge OLED screen for the iPhone X.
They could temporarily have hurt Apple in the high-end smartphone market because, you know, that's where Samsung Galaxy and iPhone compete by not supplying its industry leading screen. But Apple isn't the only rival Samsung has to worry about. In addition to being one of the largest phone manufacturers, Samsung also is one of the largest suppliers to phone manufacturers, including Apple.
If it hadn't provided the super retina display, someone else would have, strengthening Samsung's competitors in that way. And Apple is very well known for helping its suppliers to improve their quality. So cooperating with Apple meant that Samsung would get this benefit and share that its screen technology competitors would not. So it takes two to cooperate, remember. Now let's look at the deal from Apple's perspective.
Would it make Samsung a more formidable rival? It probably would. In the year prior to the iPhone X launch, revenue from Apple almost accounted for 30% of the Samsung display business. But for Apple, getting the best screen in the business was well worth it. The underlying economic reason that working together was advantageous to both was that Samsung had the best screen and Apple had a loyal customer base.
Without cooperating, neither company could get the extra value from getting the best to the customers and putting the superior screen on the iPhone. Another example is that of Amazon. Now Amazon, as you know, invites third party sellers to its marketplace. Amazon gives rival sellers on Amazon marketplace access to its customers and warehouse. Why? They could have just, you know, kept it to themselves.
Right? For starters, while it loses some direct business and the associated markup, it makes a commission on marketplace sales. The net effect on profit depends on the commission compared with the markup and whether Amazon marketplace leads to an increase in total volume. More important, though, Amazon shares its platform. When Amazon shares its platform, it becomes a hub, the starting place for any search.
Look, think of the amount of data Amazon has when you go to a search on Amazon. When a person, you know, like you and I looking for a computer, a book or anything else, you know, home goods. Whatever we go and purchase, the more we purchase, the more high margin purchases we do, the more of consumer behavior it gets.
So it just works. It's a win-win for Amazon. And finally, opening up Amazon marketplace allows Amazon to operate more warehouses and increase shipping volume, thereby reducing shipping times and lowering overall costs for its customers. Okay. So you may be wondering by now, you understand competition and how it applies to business and life really, but how does it correlate with our careers?
Well, here is the problem. If you see these pictures, whether it's academics, sports, arts, business, or any other field, we are ingrained with this belief since our childhood that life is a zero sum game. You win and others lose or others win and you lose. In game theory, this can be best modeled by prisoner's dilemma. And this is how prisoner's dilemma works.
In case, you know, some of you are not familiar. For those who are familiar, let's just go ahead and revise the concept. So imagine we have two, you know, people, person A and person B. So person A is arrested by a police for robbing a bank. Now they also arrest another person B for the same crime. Each of them is integrated in interrogated independently in different rooms and unable to communicate with one another.
In the interrogation room, the police say, we've caught your accomplice. You guys are in trouble. You should confess now to make your sentence easier. And then they explain the positive possible sentences as you can see here. Okay. So if both of you and the other person, so if both you and the other person confess, you each get three years in prison, which is this box here.
Both A confesses, B confesses. If neither of you confesses, you each get one year in prison. Which is here. If you confess and the other person doesn't, you go free and the other spends five years in prison. You know, one of these two boxes. Now, here's what happens, you know. So here's what you have to consider. Suppose you are A.
If the other person confesses, you will get three years. If, so you will get, if the other person confesses, you, if you confess and five years, if you don't. So you can think of it this way. Now, you know, what will be A's, what is A's best strategy? Okay. What is A's best strategy? If, if B confesses, what's best for A?
If, if B confesses, this is the most optimal strategy. And if B stays silent, which is what works best for A? Right. So that is what you need to consider. And similarly, you do the same for B. So it makes sense. And you look at this game. It makes sense for both to confess. But assume that the other person doesn't confess.
Then you will get one year. If you don't confess. And go free if you confess. Again, here it makes sense to confess. It seems that no matter what the other person does, you're better off confessing. Okay. So what, you know, irrespective of the other person's behavior, you see that in this, you know, we result in a, we result in a suboptimal outcome where it says both are better off confessing.
And the same logic is better for the other person. The rational outcome to this game is always for both parties to confess. Now, as we can see, this is a suboptimal solution considering, you know, you can clearly see the best outcome, you know, out of these is of course this one, right? As you can see for both.
Then you look at it both together. But when you look, when you look at both confessions, you're talking about both serving three years. So here's the, here's the dilemma. If both parties confess, each spends three years in prison. If neither confesses, each gets only one year in prison. Although they're better off cooperating with each other, individual incentives encourage them to confess.
And this will lead them, this will lead to a five year imprisonment for each of them, which as you can see, is the worst possible outcome. You can go read up about this. I know this can be complex if you've not seen this, but you know, you can go read up about this. And that's why what it leads to, we are all trained to think like this.
That, you know, you win, I lose. And you will see as a result of this, we are all stuck here at our local maximus, as I call it. Which means we could have been here together as a society, as individuals. But because we work on the suboptimal outcomes, as we showed, you know, in that two dimensional game.
We are, we are a society that's stuck at our global, at our local maxima, oblivious to what a global maxima could look like. Now, throughout our formative years, we are taught to be competitive, be a winner. And we bring that same mindset to our workplace, to our careers. In our workplaces, promotions, bonuses, or lucrative projects seem finite in number, and to bring out our competitive side.
Now, I personally witnessed this when I first joined the workforce. Our team was a newly formed team, where most folks had joined around the same time. When we started out, there was, you know, a lot of camaraderie and bonhomie in the team, where everyone helped one another. They, you know, we kind of demonstrated things as a team, worked together, and we all grew in our work together.
Then came along the first performance review. And suddenly, there was a shift in attitudes. People started becoming keen on demonstrating their individual brilliances, stop sharing information, and conflicts and, you know, cutting each other kind of grew. I'm sure many of you may have seen this playing out in your teams, you know, at different points in time, or at some point in time.
This slowly sets a culture of walls and a lack of sharing. Everyone creates their boundaries and focuses on growing their skills, their work, and their teams as leads without partnering with others. Now, imagine this world where we focused on competition instead of simply competing. Just imagine, where could we be? While work, project, and life goes on, you know, with a certain desired result, what we miss out on as individuals, teams, and businesses, or as a society, is the massive opportunity where a fixed pie could have grown to a larger pie, with revolutionary ideas stemming from an exchange of expertise, resulting in exponential growth for individuals, team, and the business.
Now, on my team, I broke this cycle by initiating a series of expert talks, where I invited individuals with expertise to come and share their ideas with the entire team. Well, it was not easy, and I definitely had to rally and influence leaders to get this initiative going. But once I did this, you know, the benefits were multifold.
Individuals, when elevated and highlighted as speakers, wanted to give and share their best. They offered themselves as points of contact if folks had any questions in the respective areas. Now, this helped folks who were previously hesitant to exchange information now brainstorm ideas. The result, numerous patents, new projects, and high visibility for the larger team within the organization, and individual growth at the same time.
I realized this concept of co-opetition much later while studying game theory in the business world. And like most other concepts in business, it directly applies to how you can make the best of your careers. Here are some direct actions you can take to co-opet and help bring out the best in you and your teams. Share your work and wisdom.
I know many entrepreneurs, coders, and late creators who believe, you know, that feedback helps them become the best version of themselves and deliver the best. In my case, I started doing with my presentations, you know, I work on the product management side of you to make a lot of presentations. So I run it by a small audience of peers and get feedback before I go and make an eventual presentation.
It's hard, it doesn't, it's not easy, you know, when you're hearing feedback and hyperating. But it has definitely helped me improve the quality of my work. So get feedback, share your work, you know, give others feedback. And, you know, that's how you can co-op it together with your peers. The second one, acknowledge, appreciate, and elevate. Now, remember, it's easier to appreciate people that are higher than you, like, you know, senior.
It's a little difficult to appreciate people who are junior, but hardest to appreciate peers. Now, one, you know, takeaway, one, let me give you one challenge. Identify three peers who you believe have skills you can learn and compliment them and ask them if they can teach you. Set up meetings. It's okay to set up boundaries initially or practice if, you know, sharing does not come naturally to you.
And you'll get better at it. See how you can share your learnings and create something bigger to grow the pie. Okay? And finally, make win-win a KPI. I learned this pretty recently. For managers leading teams, how do you inculcate core petitions successfully in your teams? A recent, a friend of mine recently shared his experience of how he helped, you know, kind of initiate in a very large organization.
When he initiated, when he initially took on a nascent team, he realized that everyone was working to highlight their individual brilliances. At the cost of, you know, interrupting or putting others down or just, you know, stalling work at times. All techniques, including 360 feedback, did not work. Eventually, each member of the team had a direct goal listed down.
Their success would be measured by the success of their direct stakeholders and peers. This brought about a stark change in the entire team. Because this now became a goal for the team. People started listening more to their stakeholders, peers, and in fact, acknowledging their work more openly. The team dynamics changed and collaboration peaked. Hopefully, these three actionables and you can add to them, help you start incorporating co-opetition into your daily lives.
Trust me, it's not easy. I think we've all been there. You know, we have a natural tendency to compete. It's, you know, in green. But that's why a mix of competition and cooperation, which is co-opetition helps bring out the best in us. Now, remember, we typically view our careers as a zero-sum or finite game. It's time we look beyond and start looking at it as a non-finite game with co-opetition to achieve our global maximus.
This is the way forward. This is the only way that can lead us to the best version of ourselves, but lead the whole society to a collective global maximus. I hope that competition helps you achieve your global maximus. Thank you.
Transcribed automatically; names checked against the speaker record. Select a time to jump there.
Article based on this talk
Why your career is not a zero-sum game, and what co-opetition offers instead
Sreeja Nair uses game theory and real business deals to show how competing and cooperating at once brings out the best in people and teams.
In short
Sreeja Nair argues that most professionals carry a childhood belief into work: that a career is a zero-sum game in which someone must lose for us to win. Drawing on game theory and business strategy, she shows how co-opetition, a deliberate mix of competition and cooperation, lets individuals and teams grow the pie instead of fighting over a fixed one. She closes with three practical habits, from sharing work for feedback to making win-win a formal team goal.
Key takeaways
Learn about the concept of co-opetition in the business world.
Understand how co-opetition is critical to developing one's career.
Learn how to apply co-opetition to your career and personal growth.
Three students, three ways to compete
Nair opens with a story about three talented straight-A students at a high school in Fremont, in the Bay Area. Two of them are locked in a long rivalry over oratory competitions, and the student who keeps finishing second develops a jealousy that spills into other parts of school life. The third, Kathy, is the weakest speaker of the three, yet she takes a different approach: she asks both rivals how they prepare and invites their feedback.
"She believes that she can learn from both of them and constantly works on becoming the best version of herself." (1:54)
When all three move on to university, the rivals discover a much larger pool of talent. One loses her top spot and the other struggles to cope. Kathy, meanwhile, keeps thriving by collaborating with people better than her. Nair's point is that the skills the rivals built through pure competition did not travel well, while a habit of continuous learning did. She then asks the audience to imagine a whole class that competed and cooperated across arts, sports and music, raising the bar for everyone.
Rivals that cooperate: Samsung, Apple and Amazon
Nair defines co-opetition as a business strategy in which known competitors work together with the expectation of mutual benefit, often on something that is not their core competency. She notes that the idea was introduced in business by professors Adam Brandenburger and Barry Nalebuff in the early 1990s and draws on game theory.
Her first example is Samsung's decision to supply its newest OLED display for the iPhone X. Withholding it might have hurt Apple in the high-end smartphone market, but another supplier would simply have stepped in, strengthening Samsung's screen competitors. As the speaker cited, revenue from Apple accounted for almost 30 percent of Samsung's display business in the year before the iPhone X launch.
"The underlying economic reason that working together was advantageous to both was that Samsung had the best screen and Apple had a loyal customer base." (8:18)
Her second example is Amazon inviting rival third-party sellers onto its marketplace. Amazon gives up some direct sales but earns commission, becomes the starting point for shoppers' searches, gathers more data on consumer behavior and gains the volume to run more warehouses, shortening delivery times and lowering costs.
The prisoner's dilemma and the local maximum
So how does this apply to careers? Nair argues that from academics to sports to business, people are taught early that life is a zero-sum game.
"You win and others lose or others win and you lose." (10:44)
She models this mindset with the prisoner's dilemma: two suspects questioned separately are each better off confessing, whatever the other does, even though both would be better off if neither confessed. Individual incentives push them toward a worse shared result. Nair suggests the same logic leaves individuals and society stuck at what she calls a local maximum, unaware of the global maximum that cooperation could reach. Promotions, bonuses and lucrative projects seem finite at work, so the competitive habits of childhood follow people into their careers.
When the first performance review arrives
Nair saw this happen in her first job. Her newly formed team began with plenty of camaraderie and shared learning.
"Then came along the first performance review. And suddenly, there was a shift in attitudes." (16:10)
People started showcasing individual brilliance, stopped sharing information, and walls went up. Nair responded by rallying leaders to support a new initiative.
"Now, on my team, I broke this cycle by initiating a series of expert talks, where I invited individuals with expertise to come and share their ideas with the entire team." (17:33)
Speakers who were elevated wanted to share their best and offered themselves as points of contact. People who had hesitated to exchange information began brainstorming together. She reports that the result included numerous patents, new projects, high visibility for the larger team and individual growth.
Three ways to practise co-opetition
Nair offers three actions. First, share your work and wisdom. She runs her own product management presentations past a small group of peers before delivering them, and admits that hearing feedback is not easy but has improved the quality of her work.
Second, acknowledge, appreciate and elevate others.
"It's a little difficult to appreciate people who are junior, but hardest to appreciate peers." (19:48)
Her challenge to viewers: identify three peers whose skills you want to learn, compliment them, ask them to teach you and set up meetings. Setting boundaries at first is fine if sharing does not come naturally.
Third, for managers, make win-win a KPI. She describes a friend who took over a team where people competed at each other's expense and where even 360 feedback did not help. What worked was giving each person a goal tied to others' success.
"Their success would be measured by the success of their direct stakeholders and peers." (21:10)
People began listening to stakeholders, acknowledging colleagues' work openly, and collaboration peaked. Nair closes by urging viewers to stop seeing their careers as a finite game and to use co-opetition to reach a global maximum, for themselves and for society.
Watch the talk
Co-opetition - Helping bring out the best in you, by Sreeja Nair, 23 minutes: https://www.womentech.net/video/co-opetition-helping-bring-out-best-in-you
About the speaker
Sreeja Nair is Director, Product Management at Qualcomm, where she leads outbound product management for the Wireless Infrastructure and Networking Enterprise segment, defining the product roadmap, go-to-market strategy and customer engagements. She holds a master's degree in Electrical Engineering from Virginia Tech, has two patents in wireless and display technologies, and was a 2020 YWCA Silicon Valley Tribute to Women Honoree.
Questions this talk answers
What is co-opetition?
Why would Samsung supply its best screen to Apple?
How does the prisoner's dilemma relate to careers?
How can an individual start practising co-opetition?
How can managers build co-opetition into a team?
Drafted with AI from the talk transcript. Editor review pending.
Frameworks and ideas mentioned
Co-opetition
Game theory
Prisoner's dilemma
Zero-sum game
Finite and non-finite games
Local and global maximum
360 feedback
Win-win as a KPI
Cite this talk
Sreeja Nair. "Co-opetition - Helping bring out the best in you." WomenTech Network, 2022. https://www.womentech.net/video/co-opetition-helping-bring-out-best-in-you