Nobody hires a PM without PM experience, so she found a way in
Product management has a catch-22: no one hires you as a PM unless you already have PM experience. Mansi Mittal, a former Visa developer now headed to Microsoft as a PM II, gets past it by leaving her job for a startup PM internship. For anyone who builds products but wants to decide what gets built, the question is which concrete steps actually open the door.
Follow a step-by-step path from evaluating the PM role to walking into your dream-company interview
Mansi Mittal, a former Visa software developer headed to Microsoft as a PM II, breaks the move into product management into practical steps: evaluate the role, gain experience, practice, read, run mock interviews and interview strategically. She argues that internships secured through referrals and repeated case competitions are the way past the catch-22 of needing PM experience to get a PM job.
“The catch 22 of product management is the belief that no one will hire you as a PM unless you have product management experience.”
“Before my interview with Google and Microsoft, I used to have minimum two mocks every day for 45 minutes each.”
What you will learn
Evaluate whether product management fits you by talking to practising PMs, researching the career trajectory and choosing between B2B or B2C and startup or big firm.
Break the PM experience catch-22 through internships secured by referral and repeated case competitions.
Recognise the five PM interview question types and focus on design and analytical questions, which come up most.
Build a mock interview routine and schedule less critical interviews first so you reach your dream company in a state of flow.
Use referrals and cold outreach to people who post openings instead of applying into large anonymous candidate pools.
Key takeaways from the speaker
Developing skillset for Product Management
How to land a Product Management Role?
Journey from a Developer to Product Manager
Details
Level
Beginner
Format
Talk
Technical depth
Non-technical
For
Career changer, Early career, Mid-career
Length
20:24
Published
July 2022
Questions this talk answers
How do you get product management experience when no one hires PMs without it?
Mansi recommends internships, especially at startups, secured through referrals, plus repeated case competitions from PM communities. Both build product thinking and can lead to interviews or full-time roles.
What kinds of questions come up in PM interviews?
She lists product design, analytical, estimation, technical and product strategy questions, plus behavioural questions. Design and analytical questions are the most frequent, and in her experience no company asked her to code.
How should you prepare for PM interviews?
Practise each question type with resources such as Exponent and PM School, read tech news, and once you feel about 50% ready start mock interviews. She did at least two 45-minute mocks a day before her Google and Microsoft interviews.
How do you get a referral for an internship?
Find openings on LinkedIn, then ask someone in your network at that company, or a connection of theirs, for a referral instead of applying directly. She says about seven out of ten people she asked agreed, and she also cold emailed people who posted openings.
Do you need a domain specialization to move into product management?
For entry-level roles, no: she used the same preparation for Microsoft, Google, Swiggy, Nike, PhonePe and Paytm, adding only company research. Specialization may matter more for lateral or senior hires.
About this talk
In May '21, I left my job as a senior developer at Visa and took the risk to pursue a PM internship for a startup. Fast Forward to Jan '22 and I have bagged a full-time role as PM II at Microsoft.
Through the platform of the Women Tech Network Conference, I want to share the specific steps, the do's & don'ts of this journey that helped me cover the marathon's distance in a sprint.
This talk is for early PM career candidates and junior PMs looking to make the switch and lacking the required guidance.
Two mock interviews a day and the path to flow (57 s)
How to ask strangers for a referral (72 s)
Speaker: So hello everyone. Hope all of you are doing great. Thank you so much for tuning in. My name is Mansi Mittal and in today's session, I'll be sharing my journey to product management and how you can do it too. But before we dive into the agenda, let me start by giving a brief about myself to set the context.
I did my graduation from Indian Institute of Technology, one of the premium Institute in India. I then moved on to become a developer with Visa, where I worked for three years. As a developer, I understood one aspect of product as in how to build it, but I hope to gain a more holistic understanding of why to build it for, who to build it off and what exactly to build. This led me to a startup, Speaker 1: A London based startup as a PM intern and before the, and that too, before joining ISB or Indian school of business to pursue my MBA at the startup, I had a steep learning curve and had the opportunity to build and witness a product from zero to one.
This hands-on experience crystallized my vision. And after months of preparation and multiple interviews, I'm now headed to Microsoft as a product manager too. Speaker 1: This is a brief about me. I would encourage you all to introduce yourself in the chat, make meaningful connections. Further, let's keep the session very interactive so that every one of us can make the most of it.
Speaker 1: I will initially go with the slides and then open the floor for questions, given time permits. In today's session, I have tried to break down the journey of product management into actionable pieces. So without further ado, let's get started. Speaker 1: The number one step is to evaluate one of the initial and very important steps for anyone looking to move to product management is to evaluate and understand what the role entails.
Speaker 1: And if it is something that makes sense for you, some of the things which helped me in this evaluation process was first to talk to experienced product professionals and understand what are their daily duties. Speaker 1: And what are the traits that they have. Then to understand the career trajectory of product management. So this can be done through research, online courses, and different articles to gauge. If you enter product management, what will your trajectory look like and what will your exit options be?
Speaker 1: Number third to evaluate is to analyze the space. Do you want to be a product manager in a B2B place? Speaker 1: Or in a B2C place? Do you want to join a big firm or a growth startup for this network with product managers from different fields? I always find LinkedIn to be a great asset for such networking.
Speaker 1: There are a ton of PM communities on LinkedIn or Slack that can help you with the above. Some of them are mind the product, product school, women in product, etc. Also, there are conferences such as women tech conference, industry, etc. Speaker 1: which are amazing in this aspect. And with this kudos to all of you for already taking the steps in this direction by attending the women tech conference today.
Speaker 1: With the above information conclude and decide if the traits career trajectory and the space particularly interest you and is something you would like to dip your feet in. Speaker 1: Once the goal decision is taken, then we come to the next step, which is experience. Speaker 1: The catch 22 of product management is the belief that no one will hire you as a PM unless you have product management experience.
Speaker 1: So how to sail through this? Speaker 1: Some of the methods I have personally employed that open gates to new opportunities for me were first, Speaker 1: internship. A lot of companies, especially startups have now open internships opportunities. Speaker 1: These not only help you build your resume, but also give you the chance to try and test the work before.
Speaker 1: I personally like to go by the route of referrals rather than applying to a larger pool of candidates, and it has worked wonders for me. Speaker 1: The next method to gain experience would be case competitions. Numerous communities such as the PM school, the product folks, the product hood conduct weekly or monthly case competitions. Speaker 1: Repeatedly participating in them has helped me improve a lot because as soon as the results were announced, I would go through the winning entries and just try to figure out and reflect where and what I have done wrong.
Speaker 1: Also on the next slide, you can see some of the case prompts from some of the case competitions, just to give a brief on how case competitions are. Speaker 1: The experience will help you build product thinking and many times also lead to interviews or full-time opportunities. Speaker 1: So with your interviews scheduled or applications to interviews going on, we come to the third step, which is practice.
Speaker 1: So there are majorly five type of questions that are asked in a PM interview product design, analytic estimation, technical product strategy. Speaker 1: So let's go through one of like through each of them one by one. Speaker 1: First, we come to product design. Speaker 1: So these are the questions where you are asked to improve an existing product, design a new product or suggest improvement to your favorite product.
Speaker 1: It evaluates your creativity and customer empathy. Speaker 1: One of the examples would be improve YouTube. Speaker 1: Then we come to analytical questions. Speaker 1: These are more focused on metrics and are more quantitative in nature. Speaker 1: One of the examples here would be, how will you measure the success of Facebook reactions? Speaker 1: Then we come to estimation questions or popularly known as guesstimates.
Speaker 1: So here you have to break down the big problem into a smaller chunk and then try to guess what the number or what the answer might be. Speaker 1: One of the example would be, what is the weight of Mount Everest? Speaker 1: The fourth question are seldom asked given which company or which team you are interviewing for.
Speaker 1: Companies such as Google and Microsoft may tap into it. Speaker 1: Just to gauge your ability to communicate with the technical team. Speaker 1: But in my experience, none of the companies ask you to code specifically. Speaker 1: The fourth is product strategy. Speaker 1: This is something that is recently introduced in product questions. Speaker 1: These are very high level and might not even be asked in an entry level position.
Speaker 1: It is more about whether you can think on a macro scale. Speaker 1: Questions like should WhatsApp have a Spotify integration or not? Speaker 1: So this would form the product strategy question. Speaker 1: Out of these design and analytic questions are the most frequently asked questions. Speaker 1: For preparing for these, some of the good resources are just typed below which are exponent, the YouTube videos from them, PM school YouTube videos and many questions from PM exercises.
Speaker 1: Apart from the above five behavioral questions is what you can always expect in an interview. Speaker 1: So along with practicing the different type of questions, the next step is to read. Speaker 1: Read leading tech news and trends such as tech crunch and Ken to develop the awareness. Speaker 1: To this end, you can pick up new products, analyze and break them down on your own.
Speaker 1: And then check online for the product communities evaluation. Speaker 1: Additionally, you can find a ton of already solved cases on the internet. Speaker 1: So head over to growth.design or to PM school or the product folks for these routinely go through them and they have inspired me a lot. Speaker 1: So once you feel that you are 50% ready, start giving mock interviews.
Speaker 1: This is one of the crucial steps that has helped me a lot. Speaker 1: Answering something on the fly with time constraint and constantly trying to showcase your structural thinking is very difficult. Speaker 1: You need to simulate the final day multiple times with your friends, your peers or your mentors. Speaker 1: Before my interview with Google and Microsoft, I used to have minimum two mocks every day for 45 minutes each.
Speaker 1: So the final stage is then the interview. Speaker 1: One tip here is to start out initially by giving out interviews for smaller startups or any of the firm that you are particularly not that keen on joining. Speaker 1: And then slowly move on to your dream company. Speaker 1: So by the time you are giving interview for your dream company, you are already in that state of flow.
Speaker 1: On the D day, be relaxed. Speaker 1: Be curious about the company, the role and the interview and in the end, just have fun. Speaker 1: So this marks the end of the official presentation. Speaker 1: But now we can open the floor for any questions you might have. Speaker 1: Also, feel free to reach out to me on LinkedIn, where I've shared a lot of resources.
Speaker 1: So yes, let's open for questions. Speaker 1: Okay, I see a lot of people introducing. Speaker 1: Hi, Rama. Speaker 1: Hi, Savita. Speaker 1: Hi, Eleanor. Speaker 1: And then Ruchika is there. Speaker 1: Okay, so Eleanor has a question. Speaker 1: What do you find to be the hardest part of the PM role?
Speaker 1: So, uh, I would say because I'm not yet a practicing PM. Speaker 1: So I'll tell you what is the hardest part of actually cracking the PM role. Speaker 1: One thing is to actually give the interviews. Speaker 1: So basically, uh, you do a lot of research, you do a lot of reading, and you have gone through a lot of questions.
Speaker 1: But when you sit one on one with a person while sitting for giving the interviews, the whole scenario is very different. Speaker 1: You may come out to be very unstructured. Speaker 1: You may come out to be that you are all over the place. Speaker 1: So that practice of giving interviews and how to stay in a flow rather than just haphazardly Speaker 1: Saying whatever comes to your mind is something that took a lot of time for me.
Speaker 1: So my initial interviews with a couple of firms did not go that well. Speaker 1: And then eventually, uh, with all the other firms, I was able to make it through. Speaker 1: So hope this answers your question, Eleanor, uh, because I'm not a practicing PM. Speaker 1: So actually, what is the hardest part in going through the PM or like day to day, I might not be a good person to answer.
Speaker 1: Thank you so much. Speaker 1: Yeah. Speaker 1: Uh, okay. Speaker 1: Hi, Achillesh. Speaker 1: Would be great to have more questions and it could be anything as simple as like whatever you want to ask out. Speaker 1: Okay, this is a very good question. Eleanor. Thank you so much for asking it. Speaker 1: So what happened was that I was already a developer, uh, but I wanted to do internship.
Speaker 1: So how I approached was that I simply searched on LinkedIn that in case there were internship opportunities that were there. Speaker 1: But rather than applying directly through LinkedIn, because at that time, there is a very large pool of applicants as in 2000 3000 applicants. Speaker 1: And most of the time, what happens is that there is a third party who's going through the resumes and then shortlisting it to the company that you are applying for.
Speaker 1: So I just got to know the opportunities which were open and then reached out to my network in case there was someone working in this company in case it was not. Speaker 1: I directly contacted a person connected with them and like requested them to give me a referral. Speaker 1: So what happened was that in case I did not know that person, uh, some of them were very willing to help out because these days companies actually even compensate the other employee.
Speaker 1: In case your referral employee gets the job. Speaker 1: And there was some folks who did not agree to it, but out of 10, I would say seven people gave me referral. Speaker 1: So referral is the quickest way to get to the interview. Speaker 1: And once you have the interview, then it's the ball is in your court.
Speaker 1: So I would say find out from different resources, but then go through the referral approach. Speaker 1: The second method I also implemented was directly just searching about posts which were giving internship and then maybe cold emailing the people who had put out that posts. Speaker 1: So that was my approach. Speaker 1: Okay. Speaker 1: I hope that answers.
Speaker 1: And Akhilesh has a question. Speaker 1: Do you recommend any domain specialization for product management roles or do you advise courses on Udemy, Coursera might surface. Speaker 1: So Akhilesh, it depends on which phase of your journey you are in. Speaker 1: So for example, I am a person who's kind of starting out. Speaker 1: I just had a fintech industry experience, but in Microsoft, I might not be working on the fintech industry experience.
Speaker 1: So initially it could be, you know, just to understand, just to have that problem solving mindset, just to have that product thinking to get the initial level of jobs. Speaker 1: But in case you are someone higher on the ladder, then it might be good to actually see how product management in a growth startup might work out in an MNC, how does it work out and then develop those skills.
Speaker 1: But for an entry level position. Speaker 1: So I have given interviews for Microsoft or Swiggy, Nike, phone pay, Paytm. Speaker 1: These are all startups in India and Google. Speaker 1: So all of them, I did a common preparation. Speaker 1: There was nothing different that I did for them. Speaker 1: And most of them asked similar questions.
Speaker 1: It was just some of the company research that I did just before the job. Speaker 1: So nothing specific particularly, but in a lateral hiring, it might matter which position you are applying for. Speaker 1: Okay, hope that answers and Fatima has a question. Speaker 1: How did you know this was what you wanted? Speaker 1: Oh, nice.
Speaker 1: Sorry if it was already covered. Speaker 1: No problem Fatima. Speaker 1: So, so to be honest, I'll be very frank here. Speaker 1: I did computer science. Speaker 1: Then I was doing development. Speaker 1: One thing I knew that I did not want to do coding. Speaker 1: So that was one thing I was sure I did not want to do.
Speaker 1: And then, but I loved the tech industry and what the footprint of technology has. Speaker 1: So I wanted to be part of this industry. Speaker 1: The second thing I thought my, you know, what works for me or what my super skill is, is to maybe communicate with people is to handle different kind of stakeholders, which kind of aligned with what a product manager is supposed to do.
Speaker 1: So a couple of things. Speaker 1: So what was my trait kind of overlap with product management. Speaker 1: And secondly, because I wanted to be in the tech space. Speaker 1: Somehow product management made sense for me. Speaker 1: This was the initial thought process. Speaker 1: But when I did the internship for three months where I could actually go talk to the customers, try to find out what are the features that we want to do and then build that roadmap.
Speaker 1: I understood this was something naturally I was good at. Speaker 1: This was something I was easy to learn and not feel that I am not good at. So the experience mixed with a little hunch that I initially had kind of led me to product management. Speaker 1: So hi, hi Ronke. Thank you so much for joining in.
Speaker 1: So Ronke is also a great speaker and also a great advocate for women leadership and women in tech. Speaker 1: So do check out her channel as well. Speaker 1: Thank you so much. Speaker 1: We have three minutes more. Speaker 1: So if anyone has any more questions, we can definitely take it up. Speaker 1: Also, I would just put out my LinkedIn on the chat for everyone to connect.
Speaker 1: You can also scan the QR code. Speaker 1: Sure, sure Fatima, we can definitely chat on LinkedIn. Speaker 1: No worries in that. Speaker 1: So if there are no more questions. Speaker 1: Okay, so Molka has asked on Q and A, would it be possible to get the slides? Speaker 1: Is there anyone who can help out from the, would the slides be given?
Speaker 1: Otherwise, if you people want, I can just go through them and you can take screenshots in case the resources are something that you would want to see later. Speaker 1: Yeah. Speaker 1: It was a great experience. Speaker 1: Thank you so much for putting that out. Speaker 1: Yeah, no problem. Speaker 1: So I am hoping that this would be there on YouTube later, or you would get the recording later.
Speaker 1: Otherwise, just feel free to take some screenshots of some of the resources. Speaker 1: And then I think everyone is free to leave with this. Speaker 1: We have ended the session because it's already just one minute away. Speaker 1: Thank you so much for chiming in and it was great speaking to all of you.
Speaker 1: Okay, I think Linda has also messaged something. Speaker 1: I'm sorry if it was covered. Speaker 1: I did not get a chance. Speaker 1: I'm interested if your MBA helped you to become a better PM. Speaker 1: This is something Linda that I'll be finding out. Speaker 1: So I just graduated one week earlier, but I would say one thing that MBA did help me to find that peer network that had the similar mindset and that could kind of inspire me or lead me to different opportunities.
Speaker 1: But I'm still yet to find it out because my joining is next week in Microsoft. Speaker 1: But we can definitely connect offline Linda. Speaker 1: Sure. Speaker 1: Okay. Speaker 1: Thank you so much, everyone.
Transcribed automatically; names checked against the speaker record. Select a time to jump there.
Article based on this talk
How do you get a product management job without PM experience?
Former Visa developer Mansi Mittal shares the steps, from internships by referral to daily mock interviews, that took her to a PM II role at Microsoft.
In short
Mansi Mittal argues that the move from developer to product manager can be broken into actionable steps: evaluate the role, gain experience, practise, read, run mock interviews and approach interviews strategically. Her answer to the classic catch-22 of needing PM experience to get a PM job is to create that experience through internships secured by referral and through repeated case competitions.
Key takeaways
Developing a skill set for product management
How to land a product management role
The journey from developer to product manager
Deciding whether product management is right for you
Mittal spent three years as a developer at Visa after graduating from the Indian Institute of Technology. Building software taught her how a product is made, but she wanted to understand why to build it, who to build it for and what exactly to build. That curiosity took her to a London-based startup as a PM intern before her MBA at the Indian School of Business, and then to an offer from Microsoft.
Her first step for anyone considering the switch is evaluation. She suggests talking to experienced product professionals about their daily duties and traits, researching the PM career trajectory and exit options, and deciding which space appeals: B2B or B2C, a big firm or a growth startup. Networking makes this possible, and she points to communities such as Mind the Product, Product School and Women in Product.
"I always find LinkedIn to be a great asset for such networking." (2:41)
Breaking the experience catch-22
Once the decision is made, the hard part begins. Mittal names the obstacle plainly:
"The catch 22 of product management is the belief that no one will hire you as a PM unless you have product management experience." (3:37)
Her two methods for getting past it are internships and case competitions. Many companies, especially startups, now offer PM internships, which build a resume and let candidates test the work before committing. She prefers referrals over applying into large candidate pools. For case competitions, run weekly or monthly by communities such as The Product Folks, she would study the winning entries after each round and reflect on what she had done wrong.
"The experience will help you build product thinking and many times also lead to interviews or full-time opportunities." (5:12)
In the Q&A she explains the referral approach in detail. She found openings on LinkedIn, then rather than applying directly, where she says postings could draw two or three thousand applicants, she contacted people in her network at the company, or people connected to them, and asked for a referral. As the speaker cited, about seven out of ten agreed. She also cold emailed people who had posted openings.
"So referral is the quickest way to get to the interview." (13:39)
Practising for the five PM question types
Mittal groups PM interview questions into five types. Product design questions, such as improving YouTube, test creativity and customer empathy. Analytical questions, such as measuring the success of Facebook Reactions, focus on metrics. Estimation questions, or guesstimates, ask candidates to break a large problem into smaller chunks. Technical questions appear at some companies, including Google and Microsoft, to gauge how well a candidate can talk with engineers. Product strategy questions, such as whether WhatsApp should integrate Spotify, test macro-level thinking and may not come up at entry level. Behavioural questions are always expected.
"But in my experience, none of the companies ask you to code specifically." (6:56)
"Out of these design and analytic questions are the most frequently asked questions." (7:24)
For preparation she recommends Exponent and PM School videos on YouTube, PM Exercises, and already-solved cases on growth.design and The Product Folks. She also suggests reading tech news from TechCrunch and The Ken, picking up new products and breaking them down yourself before checking how product communities analysed them.
Mock interviews and interview day
When she felt about 50% ready, Mittal started mock interviews, which she calls one of the most crucial steps in her preparation.
"Answering something on the fly with time constraint and constantly trying to showcase your structural thinking is very difficult." (9:00)
"Before my interview with Google and Microsoft, I used to have minimum two mocks every day for 45 minutes each." (9:00)
She also recommends sequencing interviews: start with smaller startups or firms you are less keen on, then move toward your dream company. Asked about the hardest part of the process, she says it was staying structured once she was face to face with an interviewer; her first few interviews did not go well before the later ones succeeded.
"So by the time you are giving interview for your dream company, you are already in that state of flow." (9:30)
How she knew product management fit
Mittal is candid that she knew she did not want to keep coding but loved the tech industry. Her strength in communicating with people and handling different stakeholders matched what a PM does. A three-month internship, talking to customers and building a roadmap, confirmed it. For entry-level roles she did not specialise by domain: the same preparation served her interviews at Microsoft, Google, Swiggy, Nike, PhonePe and Paytm, with company research on top.
"So the experience mixed with a little hunch that I initially had kind of led me to product management." (17:12)
Watch the talk
"Road to Product Management" by Mansi Mittal, about 20 minutes: https://www.womentech.net/video/road-product-management-mansi-mittal
About the speaker
Mansi Mittal is an Incoming Product Manager who graduated from the Indian Institute of Technology, worked three years as a software developer on Visa's internal portal, and joined a London-based startup as a PM intern before her MBA at the Indian School of Business. She is headed to Microsoft as a PM II and mentors young students and professionals, especially girls, through NGOs to help them navigate the tech world.
Questions this talk answers
How do you get product management experience when no one hires PMs without it?
What kinds of questions come up in PM interviews?
How should you prepare for PM interviews?
How do you get a referral for an internship?
Do you need a domain specialization to move into product management?
Drafted with AI from the talk transcript. Editor review pending.
Resources mentioned
Mind the Product
Product School
Women in Product
Exponent (YouTube videos)
PM School (YouTube videos and case competitions)
PM Exercises
The Product Folks
growth.design
TechCrunch
The Ken
LinkedIn PM communities
Slack PM communities
Cite this talk
Mansi Mittal. "Road to Product Management." WomenTech Network, 2022. https://www.womentech.net/video/road-product-management-mansi-mittal