The Woman's Workforce: Integrating Flexible Practices for a More Equitable Workplace
Rachel Peterson17:262023
No set hours can quietly create a nine-to-nine workforce
Telling employees there are no set hours sounds generous, yet it often breeds a nine-to-nine workforce where nobody knows when it is okay to leave. For women, who are more likely to be primary caregivers even when working full time, that confusion makes it harder to stay and get ahead. Rachel Peterson, VP of Marketing at Fountain, says workplaces still run on 1950s assumptions. Which management myths have to go before flexibility really works?
Learn three management myths to drop and a low-risk way to pilot flex hours with your team
Rachel Peterson, VP of Marketing at Fountain, argues that workplaces still follow norms designed for a 1950s single-earner household and that this blocks flexibility for women and caregivers. She takes apart three management myths (empathy versus productivity, hours as a measure of quality, and bringing your whole self to work) and offers one principle in their place: the why is fixed and the how is flexible. She also shows how leaders can test flex hours with their own teams.
“And so instead, you know, I always suggest managing teams knowing that empathy and productivity are two sides of the same coin.”
“And so the focus here really needs to be that quality counts, but when and how it happens is far less important.”
What you will learn
Challenge the belief that empathy and productivity work against each other when managing teams.
Judge work by its quality rather than by hours at a desk or time shown online.
Spell out clear expectations when removing set hours so that flexibility does not turn into a nine-to-nine workday.
Model healthy boundaries as a leader so teams bring themselves to work without losing themselves.
Run a small flex-hours experiment with your own team and use the results to argue for wider change.
Key takeaways from the speaker
A better understanding of how to accommodate and account for greater flexibility in the workplace, and how companies can thrive in doing so
Charting a path to attract more women/diversity into the workplace through flexible programs, with steps on how to retain that talent
Why prioritizing well-being and adopting new working practices can lead to longer-term success for the company
Details
Level
Intermediate
Format
Talk
Technical depth
Non-technical
For
People manager, Executive
Length
17:26
Published
June 2023
Questions this talk answers
Why do so many workplaces resist flexible practices?
Peterson says the status quo was designed for the homogenous post World War II workforce, when one person worked and usually a woman stayed home. Workplaces have changed little even though the workforce has changed a great deal.
Are empathy and productivity at odds?
No. She calls them two sides of the same coin: teams that feel heard and valued as individuals do their best work.
Why can a policy of no set working hours backfire?
Like unlimited PTO, it can breed a nine-to-nine workforce where people do not know when it is okay to leave. Leaders need to state what they expect in a working day and make clear that people are free to step away.
What is wrong with telling people to bring their whole self to work?
Women are already expected to give 100% at work, at home and in their communities, so the idea erodes healthy boundaries and leads to burnout. Peterson suggests people bring themselves to work without losing themselves.
How can a manager introduce flexibility without company-wide buy-in?
Test it at a small scale by letting your own team choose when and how they work best, then take the findings back to leadership. Keep repeating the case for flexibility loudly.
About this talk
Addressing workplace flexibility will be one of the biggest issues facing every company in 2023. From hourly roles to corporate settings, flexibility is mission critical for job applicants and employees - women, especially - who often have to juggle their careers with their position as caretakers for children, elderly family members, or others. And this showed no signs of slowing during the pandemic. How can employers address this while attracting and retaining more women in the workplace? Many women are turning to hourly jobs and gig work, which often provides an added layer of flexibility and income. Rachel will discuss how corporate leadership teams can rethink recruitment approaches to attract more women to the workplace, focusing on updated expectations that accommodate for the many roles women play inside and out of the household while making room for the flexibility that comes with the rise in women taking on independent freelance work and/or multiple jobs.
How no set hours creates a nine-to-nine workforce (75 s)
The day she realized she had no hobbies (76 s)
Pilot flex hours with your own team (64 s)
Speaker 1: Well, hello, everyone. Thank you so much for joining us today. My name is Rachel Peterson. I'm the VP of Marketing at Fountain. We are a high volume hourly hiring platform. And I'm going to be talking today about the woman's workforce, how to integrate flexible and equitable practices within your workplace. And I'm going to go ahead and share my screen to get us started.
All righty. And so one of the things that I want to start off with in this conversation is really the fact that a more equitable workplace starts with myth busting management. And what I mean by that is that the status quo of the modern working world, particularly for knowledge workers, you know, it was largely designed for the post World War II homogenous working population of, you know, 50s, 60s, 70s, going beyond that. And yet the modern workplace has changed very little, despite the fact that our working population has changed a great deal. And many of the practices that were put in place that seemingly made sense when a traditional working household had one person working and generally a woman might be staying home. She might be looking after the children. She might be, you know, taking care of the home.
The practices that were designed for the practices that were designed for that type of society are not the practices that are really going to get us to a more equitable workplace today. And it's interesting and it's interesting and it's interesting and it's interesting and important to consider that when we're talking about what a modern workplace needs, oftentimes the ideas of what is status quo are rooted right in decades past.
And so what I'm going to do is talk about a couple of the most common myths that exist that prevent us from integrating these flexible practices and then how we can overcome them specifically from a management level. So myth number one, empathy and productivity are opposing behaviors. And so I think this is one that especially as women, we often struggle with is this idea that you cannot be both empathetic and also encourage productivity on your team or encourage productivity within your organization, you know, and we can even see this in sort of the quote unquote hustle culture that took hold in Silicon Valley.
Took hold in Silicon Valley through both, you know, the first tech bubble and then through 2008 2010 and now beyond to where we are today. There's this idea that like you've got a hustle. And if you're not giving that 110% and if you're not doing it in a way that is very black and white very focused sort of devoid of emotion.
That's not productive enough. And so I think when we talk about integrating different types of practices, whether it's optional meetings or no set working hours, whether it's, you know, what a track to leadership looks like. Is that managing people, is that not managing people, all of that needs to come and can come only after we've successfully gotten over this idea that empathy is a barrier to success for ourselves and for our teams rather than empathy being at the root of success.
And so instead, you know, I always suggest managing teams knowing that empathy and productivity are two sides of the same coin. So when our teams feel as though we hear them, we're listening to them and we are invested in them as people, that's when we really start to get the type of work that we're looking for out of our teams.
And so that is both because they want to do their best work for themselves, but also because they understand that they're being seen as individuals and respected as individuals, not just as workers when they come into the workplace. Myth number two, hours of work equal quality of work. And this, I think, is one of the biggest status quo ideas that gets in the way of implementing flexible practices, because we are still very much conditioned to believe that the person who is sitting at their desk the longest or in the days of remote work, you know, the person whose slack bubble is green for the longest period of time.
And that is the person who is working the hardest. And that is also the person who is creating the highest quality work. And that is not necessarily the case. And where that really starts to damage us, not only in terms of thinking about, you know, women who may be in positions of caregiving where the hours of work might be different, but the quality is the same.
It also ends up damaging us when we think about the neurodiverse workforce and how the expectations that we place on people might not necessarily be aligned to their best way of working. And so this is where we have the opportunity, again, going back to empathy, to speaking with our teams, to speaking within the leadership team, specifically of our organization, and understanding, driving home this idea that, look, the quality of the work matters.
The hours that it takes to get there may vary widely from person to person. And I mean that both in terms of a project that might take one person five hours could take another person 10, but also in terms of the actual working hours that we expect from our employees. And I think we fall into a trap similar to that of unlimited PTO, which we know statistically means that people take less PTO.
But when organizations start off simply by saying, oh, we don't have any set hours. What that tends to breed is a nine to nine workforce, right? People are at their desk at 9:00 AM. They're sitting there until 9:00 PM. They don't know when to leave. Is it okay to leave? And so we have to be really thoughtful.
Even when we look at a practice like, oh, we won't have set working hours. Think about what that actually means for our employee populations and go a step beyond that to say, hey, Here is what we expect from you within a working day. You know that your projects are in good shape, that you're providing the updates you need to to your manager, but also that you have the freedom to step away when you need to, to handle the types of things that we know most often come up for women who are more likely to be the primary caregivers in their households, even when they are working full time.
And understanding that if we judge a woman's career by her ability to be available, you know, nine to nine, so to speak, that's not necessarily an indicator of how good she is at her job, nor how successful she is going to be in the future. And so the focus here really needs to be that quality counts, but when and how it happens is far less important.
And this is where remote work has presented us with some interesting opportunities, but also challenges. I think we have all at this point heard a lot about productivity paranoia and this idea that because workers are now remote organizations trust less that they are doing the work that needs to be done. And what that leads leading to is sort of an influx of unnecessary meetings and check-ins and too much kind of oversight, if you will, that implies that organizations do not trust the folks that they have brought in to work with them.
And so that has been one of the negative side effects of remote work, whereas on the positive side, it has allowed us more freedom. You know, so for example, if you need to step out for a doctor's appointment, you need to step out to handle childcare or to take a relative to a doctor's appointment, these types of things are now easier to do if you're within a remote work situation.
But they also haven't necessarily been served up on a silver platter that has fixed everything. So when we think about our role from a leadership perspective and what we need to do within our organizations to encourage this type of thinking that the quality counts, the when and how does not. We really need to exemplify that A, ourselves and in how we manage our teams, and then allow that to move down into how our direct reports are managing their direct reports and so on.
Because this is something that really starts, as with all things, from the example that we set in the workplace. And that too can be incredibly challenging. You know, so for example, going back to empathy, we might demonstrate a great amount of empathy when we are speaking to the folks on our team. But we don't have that same empathy when we consider our own situations, we are harder on ourselves, we are more likely to beat ourselves down.
And so again, from the place of empathy, the ability to focus on quality work then comes forward and you're able to divorce that from this idea that it has to be based on the number of hours someone is physically sitting in a chair. Myth number three, bring your whole self to work. So this is an interesting one that I think, again, tends to bring specific challenges for women, because when we think about where we are expected to be present in our lives, it is 100% everywhere.
It is 100% at work, it is 100% at home, it is 100% with your children, with your family, with your friends, with your community, with volunteer opportunities. And we don't have three, four, 500% of ourselves to go around and this is another idea that while it started off in a positive realm, this idea that you should bring your whole self.
What it actually translates into is really an inability to give ourselves permission to create healthy boundaries and an inability to allow our teams to create healthy boundaries when we think about how they show up every day. And so while the unique characteristics that every individual brings to the workplace are highly valuable and are something that we should be focused on, something that we should celebrate, we should actually focus on bringing ourselves, telling our teams to bring themselves, but not lose themselves.
And that's really what can end up leading to burnout, both for ourselves as well as our teams, when we don't allow for the space to set healthy boundaries or when we expect that someone brings every aspect and every ounce of themselves to work every day. Not only is that unrealistic and setting ourselves and the other folks we work with up for failure, but it's also damaging in leading to burnout in that long-term way because no one can sustain that pace ad nauseum, infinity forever.
Um, and so, you know, one of the examples that I give of the ways that this can be damaging many moons ago, I was let go from a place where I was working and it was the first time I had ever been let go. And I was so distressed and I left this job and you know, I was talking with my husband and he said, Oh, this is good.
Maybe this gives you some time to focus on hobbies. And I realized that I did not have a single hobby. I couldn't tell you what my interests were outside of, well, I led marketing at the startup. And before that I led marketing at another startup. And before that, another startup. Um, and so there was this realization there for me that while I had built a very successful career, it had been focused on giving my whole self to my work.
And that is particularly something within the tech space, as I'm sure many of you come from young or hyper growth organizations, you know, that is encouraged, right? Even the perks that are offered are all about bringing your whole self to work, sticking around, becoming best friends with your coworkers, spending your time with them outside of work. And that on the one hand can create a very strong community within your workspace, but it can also lead to a lack of identity outside of work.
And this is once again, an idea where we are setting the example. And so if the example that you are setting is I'm always here, 100%, I'm always on, there are no boundaries. That is the example that we're setting for our teams as well. Uh, and that is really the most damaging thing. Even if we're telling them one thing, if what they're seeing from us as leaders at an organization is another, they're going to follow what they see, not necessarily what we tell them because we're not living up to those values.
Um, and then, you know, finally, the most important key to an equitable organization is operating with the understanding that the why is fixed and the how is flexible. And that why is why we do what we do, what drives us in the mission, what gets us up every day and takes us to work, why the company exists, what our goals are, how we reach those goals, especially if we want to build flexible workplaces that work for everyone moving forward in the future has to be flexible.
And that means letting go of the idea that quality equates to the number of hours worked or the set hours that are worked. It means giving up the idea that you cannot be both empathetic and encourage the highest level of productivity on your team. And that, of course, bringing your whole self to work is the only way to be successful when, in fact, what we see is that more often than not, that can be very damaging.
So I'm going to go ahead and stop share there. And I think, you know, when we talk about some of the most important aspects of bringing these practices to life, a couple of things that I've seen work well that I think are very important. One of them is we need to be loud and we need to be repetitive when we talk to our organizations about why flexible practices matter.
And we know that they matter for the bottom line. We know, for example, that organizations with more diverse leadership teams perform better. Their revenues are higher. We have sort of a library of statistics from research that has been done in the past five, 10 years. But that isn't worth as much if we are not, when we have a seat at the table, banging our fists about it and making sure that there is an understanding that, look, we know that if we want to attract diverse talent, if we want to maintain diverse talent and we want to increase the level of women in leadership, We need to design a workplace, not of 1950 when women were more likely to be staying home, caring for the children and men were out there working, but rather a workplace that is designed for what will ultimately benefit everyone in the workplace.
And that is flexibility and that is recognizing that there is a vital importance in ensuring that those who are responsible for childcare, that those who are responsible for family members, for other aspects of their homes, their lives, their communities, as we all are. They are deserving of a workplace that fits those needs, and that is what is going to get the highest quality and highest level of work out of them.
So, you know, again, I think that idea of the why is fixed and the how is flexible is incredibly important. And I think even if you are within a large organization, you know, even if it's thousands or tens of thousands of people, and this isn't necessarily something that can come to life in the day to day immediately, or maybe it has to go, you know, 20 folks up the chain to even get a conversation started.
So, there are ways to enact these principles within your own teams and even within how you show up, how you bring yourself to work and really model those behaviors for the other leaders on your team and ensure that you have the empathy and the understanding when someone is working flex hours or that you offer flex hours and that you are aware, all right, how someone works best, when they work best, it might be from 9 p.m. at night to 1 a.m.
And that's how they work and their work is always done by the next day and that's okay if that is what works best for them. And I think as long as we have team members who are passionate about the mission of a company, who are excited about why they're there, who are good at their work, you know, really at the bedrock of all of this is the ability to trust, to trust our teams, to trust the women we work with to manage their time as best they can to do their best work.
And I think every one of us would probably say that we are some of the best multitaskers we know, there is not a woman I don't know who isn't doing seven things at once. And I think when we bring that level of trust into the workplace and allow room for flexibility and allow room to talk to our management teams about this, to provide them with examples to say, look, I'm going to try and experiment with my team.
And I am going to let them work these flex hours. I am going to let them decide when and how they're most productive and let's see how that goes. That experiment is probably going to go really well and that's something that you can do regardless of whether you have, you know, full 100% team support or full company buy-in.
There are ways to test this out on micro levels and then bring your findings back and keep banging your fists on that table because the only path forward for us is if we're able to test things to prove what we already know to be true, which is that adding these flexible practices into the working environment is the best way to a more equitable future.
And I do see that we're coming up toward the end of our time here. But I do want to thank you all so much for joining again. My name is Rachel Peterson, and if you would like to chat more feel free to reach out to me on my email is pretty simple. It is just [email protected] look forward to hearing from all of our other amazing speakers today and again just want to thank you all so much for joining us.
Thank you.
Transcribed automatically; names checked against the speaker record. Select a time to jump there.
Article based on this talk
Why flexible work fails women until managers drop three myths
Rachel Peterson explains how empathy, judging output over hours and healthy boundaries turn flexibility into equity.
In short
Rachel Peterson argues that most workplaces still run on rules written for the post World War II workforce, when one person went out to work and another, usually a woman, stayed home. Before flexibility can be fair, she says, managers have to let go of three myths: that empathy and productivity are opposites, that hours of work equal quality of work, and that people should bring their whole selves to work. In their place she offers one principle: the why is fixed and the how is flexible.
Key takeaways
A better understanding of how to accommodate and account for greater flexibility in the workplace, and how companies can thrive in doing so.
A path to attract more women and more diversity into the workplace through flexible programs, with steps on how to retain that talent.
Why prioritizing well-being and adopting new working practices can lead to longer-term success for the company.
A workplace designed for decades past
Peterson, VP of Marketing at the hourly hiring platform Fountain, begins with a diagnosis. The modern working world, especially for knowledge workers, was designed for the fairly uniform workforce of the 1950s, 60s and 70s. The workforce has changed a great deal since then, but the workplace has changed very little. Practices that made sense when one adult stayed home to look after the children and the house are not the ones that will produce an equitable workplace today.
"All righty. And so one of the things that I want to start off with in this conversation is really the fact that a more equitable workplace starts with myth busting management." (0:29)
Myth one: empathy and productivity are opposites
The first myth, Peterson says, is one women often struggle with: the belief that you cannot be empathetic and still drive productivity. She links it to the hustle culture that took hold in Silicon Valley, where giving 110% in a black-and-white, unemotional way was treated as the only way to be productive enough. Until leaders get past this belief, she argues, practices such as optional meetings, no set working hours or new routes into leadership will not take hold.
"And so instead, you know, I always suggest managing teams knowing that empathy and productivity are two sides of the same coin." (3:08)
When people feel heard and feel that their manager is invested in them as people, she says, they do their best work, both for themselves and because they are respected as individuals and not only as workers.
Myth two: hours of work equal quality of work
Peterson calls this one of the biggest obstacles to flexible practice. People are still trained to see the person who sits at the desk longest, or whose Slack status stays green longest, as the hardest and best worker. That view penalizes women in caregiving roles, whose hours may differ while the quality of their work stays the same. It also penalizes neurodivergent employees, whose best way of working may not fit standard expectations.
She warns that simply dropping set hours is not enough. As the speaker cited, unlimited PTO statistically leads people to take less time off, and the same thing can happen with hours. "What that tends to breed is a nine to nine workforce, right?" (5:15) Leaders need to say clearly what they expect in a working day and also make clear that people are free to step away for the things that most often fall to women as primary caregivers.
"And so the focus here really needs to be that quality counts, but when and how it happens is far less important." (6:05)
Remote work, she adds, has brought both sides of this. It makes it easier to step out for a doctor's appointment or childcare, but it has also fed productivity paranoia, with unnecessary meetings and check-ins that signal distrust.
Myth three: bring your whole self to work
The third myth started out as a positive idea but lands hard on women, who are expected to give 100% at work, at home, with family, with friends and in their communities. Nobody has 300 or 400 percent of themselves to give. In practice, Peterson says, the idea leaves people unable to set healthy boundaries, and it leads to burnout.
She shares a personal story. The first time she was let go from a job, her husband suggested she use the time for her hobbies. "And I realized that I did not have a single hobby." (10:22) Her whole identity had been leading marketing at one startup after another, and tech perks that encourage people to stay late and make work their social life can deepen that.
Her advice is to bring yourself to work without losing yourself, and to remember that teams copy what leaders do. "Even if we're telling them one thing, if what they're seeing from us as leaders at an organization is another, they're going to follow what they see, not necessarily what we tell them because we're not living up to those values." (11:26)
The why is fixed, the how is flexible
Peterson's main principle ties the three myths together. The mission, the reason the company exists and its goals stay constant, while the way people reach them has to stay open if workplaces are going to work for everyone.
"Um, and then, you know, finally, the most important key to an equitable organization is operating with the understanding that the why is fixed and the how is flexible." (11:51)
Start small and keep making the case
To put this into practice, Peterson asks leaders to keep making the case, loudly and often. "One of them is we need to be loud and we need to be repetitive when we talk to our organizations about why flexible practices matter." (12:47) As the speaker cited, research from the past five to ten years shows that organizations with more diverse leadership teams perform better and earn higher revenues. But that evidence only matters if people with a seat at the table push for it.
In large organizations, where change may need approval from far up the chain, she suggests starting with your own team. Let people choose when and how they are most productive, even if that means 9 p.m. to 1 a.m., and trust them to manage their time. "That experiment is probably going to go really well and that's something that you can do regardless of whether you have, you know, full 100% team support or full company buy-in." (16:08) Then take the findings back to leadership and keep pushing.
Watch the talk
"The Woman's Workforce: Integrating Flexible Practices for a More Equitable Workplace" by Rachel Peterson, 17 minutes: https://www.womentech.net/video/womans-workforce-integrating-flexible-practices-more-equitable-workplace
About the speaker
Rachel Peterson is Vice President, Marketing at Fountain and a B2B marketing leader with over a decade of experience driving revenues and building collaborative commercial teams at rapidly scaling technology companies. She is an active advocate for gender parity and diverse representation in tech and volunteers with initiatives focused on global gender equality.
Questions this talk answers
Why do so many workplaces resist flexible practices?
Are empathy and productivity at odds?
Why can a policy of no set working hours backfire?
What is wrong with telling people to bring their whole self to work?
How can a manager introduce flexibility without company-wide buy-in?
Drafted with AI from the talk transcript. Editor review pending.
Frameworks and ideas mentioned
The why is fixed, the how is flexible
Cite this talk
Rachel Peterson. "The Woman's Workforce: Integrating Flexible Practices for a More Equitable Workplace." WomenTech Network, 2023. https://www.womentech.net/video/womans-workforce-integrating-flexible-practices-more-equitable-workplace