In short
Naimeesha Murthy argues that the pandemic-era exodus of women from the workforce is tied directly to a lack of primary care benefits. Working caregivers, especially mothers, carry a double load that leads to burnout, and she says employers are still falling short. Her answer is a minimum set of benefits, from work from anywhere to daycare support, and a rethink of benefit packages that were designed for a pre-pandemic world.
Key takeaways
- Impact of COVID on women in the workforce
- How organizations can support
- How we can create more opportunities and help
A personal starting point
Murthy opens with her own story. In late 2017 she had her son, Ari, at about the same time she was offered a move from product marketing into product management. She took the opportunity, but returning from maternity leave after only three months made balancing a new role with everything else in life very hard. Mentorship, she explains, simply was not available to her.
Rather than wait, she built her own support system: a meetup first called New York Women in Product Management, which became Products by Women. As she told attendees, "And now we have expanded our community to over 120 countries for women in tech and beyond." (2:53)
That experience frames the rest of the talk. The problem she describes is not abstract to her; it is one she lived through as a new mother stepping into a bigger role.
The numbers behind the exodus
Murthy then turns to data. As the speaker cited, another 275,000 women dropped out of the US labor force in January 2021, bringing the total to 2.3 million women and leaving participation at 57%, the lowest level since 1988. In her words, women's place in the labor force has been set back 33 years.
She is direct about the cause: "One of the main reasons for this primary exodus is primary care benefits. It's shocking, but it's the truth." (4:32)
She adds further figures as evidence: job losses cost women worldwide about $800 billion in earnings, mothers have been three times more responsible for housework and childcare, and roughly one in four women say they have considered downshifting their careers or leaving the workplace entirely. One in ten women, she notes, have quit their jobs for pandemic-related reasons, which means whole families lose disposable income.
Work-life balance was never real
A central idea in the talk is that the pandemic exposed a long-standing illusion. "Just the concept of work life balance has always been a lie." (5:52) Work and life, Murthy argues, are interrelated: a change in one always affects the other.
She describes the pandemic routine many viewers will recognize: waking early, eating 15-minute lunches and working late to finish. Employees who kept working reported a decline in mental health, and she links that decline to the lack of healthcare and care benefit packages. Caregivers worry about their children's needs while also trying to meet employer expectations during the day, and she warns that this squeeze leads to burnout. She speaks from experience, telling the audience that burnout is real and that she can vouch for it.
What employers must offer at minimum
Murthy then sets out a must-have list for employers who want to lean in.
- Work from anywhere, not just work from home. Not every organization offers childcare benefits, so parents often depend on family support to raise their children, and that may mean working from somewhere else.
- Flexible hours with trained managers. Offering flexibility is not enough if bias persists between people who go into the office and those who work remotely. "Managers should be trained on managing distributed workforces, and this should not impact the performance evaluation or opportunities that present themselves at large." (9:19)
- Upskilling budgets for those who need them most, especially mothers being re-engaged in the workforce, along with skill-based peer mentorship on the job.
- Standard daycare benefits.
Benefits built for how people live now
Murthy also challenges the shape of benefit packages themselves. She asks whether employees could swap commuter benefits for alternatives such as dog walking, kid enrichment classes, mental health support, entertainment or delivery services. "Shouldn't we have a choice in the benefits that we want?" (10:12)
Her broader point is that the old package no longer fits: "The benefit package that you received in 2019 is not relevant anymore, in my opinion." (10:34) She is hopeful, noting that many employers and leaders have taken notice, and she closes with her view of what work should become: "Future of work should be flexible. Future of work should entail mental health benefits." (11:14) She adds that it should also be inclusive and fair.
In a short Q&A, an attendee asked how employees can drive the change. Murthy admitted she did not have every answer but suggested listing these questions, taking them to employers and asking managers directly whether they check in on mental health, send care packages and talk about workload.
Watch the talk
The Correlation Between Primary Care Benefits and Women in the Workforce, by Naimeesha Murthy (14 minutes): https://www.womentech.net/video/naimeesha-murthy-correlation-between-primary-care-benefits-and-women-in-workforce
About the speaker
Naimeesha Murthy is a Founder/Product Leader at Products by Women/HUGE, and founded Products by Women, a diverse global community offering skill-based mentorship and professional development for women in tech and beyond. She is also a start-up advisor and mentor specializing in product and go-to-market, an advisory board member at Pace University in New York, and a Forbes Council Member.
Questions this talk answers
- Why have so many women left the workforce during the pandemic?
- What should employers offer working caregivers at a minimum?
- Is work-life balance a realistic goal?
- How should benefit packages change after the pandemic?
- How can employees drive change on care benefits?
Drafted with AI from the talk transcript. Editor review pending.