How to shatter the double-paned glass ceiling for Asian American women
Kelly C. Huang18:492023
Asian American women hold 1.8% of C-suite roles despite top education
Asians are far more likely than the general population to hold college degrees, yet Asian American women make up just 1.8% of the C-suite, as the speaker cited. Executive coach Kelly C. Huang, former co-chair of Women in Bio's Boardroom Ready program, argues this costs companies leaders who understand the world's fastest-growing consumer markets. Which biases keep the double-paned ceiling in place, and what can organizations change?
Learn the three biases behind the double-paned ceiling and three fixes organizations can make
Executive coach Kelly C. Huang argues that Asian American women face a double-paned glass ceiling made of gender and racial stereotypes, which leaves them badly underrepresented in the C-suite despite high educational attainment. She describes three biases (unfair assumptions, unwanted attention and unequal access) and proposes three organizational fixes: checking leadership biases, sponsoring ERGs and leveraging community involvement.
“But in corporate America today, does academic achievement translate into success in the C-suite? Well, unfortunately, the data does not support that.”
“But what's unfair about them is that they're painting these Asian American students and workers in one broad stroke.”
What you will learn
Explain the double-paned glass ceiling and why the racial effect compounds the gender effect for Asian American women.
Recognize three biases at work: unfair assumptions, unwanted attention and unequal access.
Challenge the habit of mistaking confidence for competence when judging who looks like a leader.
Value navigational, advocacy and linguistic or cultural capital in promotion and C-suite decisions.
Use employee resource groups and community involvement to build belonging and retention, not only recruiting.
Key takeaways from the speaker
Asian American women are under-represented at VP and above levels according to the 2022 McKinsey study.
The double paned glass ceiling puts these women at a disadvantage.
“The ‘Asian effect’ is 3.7X greater than the ‘gender effect’ as a glass ceiling factor," according to Ascend.
These women are constantly facing 1. Unfair Assumption 2. Unwanted Attention 3. Unequal Access
What can organizations do: Check Your Biases, Sponsor and Support Asian Women ERGs, and Leverage Community Involvement
Details
Level
All levels
Format
Talk
Technical depth
Non-technical
For
People manager, Executive, Mid-career
Length
18:49
Published
June 2023
Questions this talk answers
What is the double-paned glass ceiling?
It is a ceiling with two panes, one made of gender stereotypes and one of racial stereotypes. Huang cites an Ascend study finding the Asian effect almost four times as great as the gender effect.
Why does it matter for business that so few Asian American women reach the C-suite?
More than half of consumers live in Asian countries and their spending is expected to reach about half of world consumer spending by 2032, as the speaker cited. Asian American women leaders can act as cultural and language ambassadors to those markets.
Which biases hold Asian American women back at work?
Unfair assumptions such as the model minority myth, unwanted attention from media stereotypes and heritage culture expectations, and unequal access shown in low feelings of inclusion and belonging.
How should leaders rethink what a leader looks like?
They should stop substituting confidence for competence and recognize navigational capital, resistance advocacy capital and linguistic and cultural capital as leadership assets.
How can employee resource groups help?
ERGs should be sponsored and supported as places of belonging that retain AAPI employees long term, not only as recruiting tools. Connecting them to community involvement also gives members a way to show leadership.
About this talk
The glass ceiling for Asian American women is double-paned: One pane represents gender stereotypes and the other represents racial stereotypes. An Ascend study reported that while white women were also underrepresented at the highest levels, Asian women were the least likely to be executives, relative to their proportion of the workforce. Researchers wrote, “The ‘Asian effect’ is 3.7X greater than the ‘gender effect’ as a glass ceiling factor.”
To better understand how Asian American women encounter the double-paned ceiling, we can examine the stereotypes and biases they encounter. In particular, there are three types of biases to consider:
1. Unfair Assumption
2. Unwanted Attention
3. Unequal Access
When heritage culture adds unwanted attention (65 s)
Leadership capital immigrant families build (77 s)
Hi, everyone. This is Kelly Huang. I'm so glad to be here to shed a light on how to break through the double-pane glass ceiling as it relates to how to help Asian American women in the workplace reach the C-suite and the boardroom. And I became interested in this topic from my work as the former co-chair of Women in Bio's Boardroom Ready program, where we've onboarded 135 women out of 150 participants. Hence, the topic of board diversity is very relevant. However, in helping these high-potential women reach the C-suite as a coach, I'm seeing a consistent lack of representation at the highest level in corporate America. So, in trying to uncover what could be holding these high-achieving women back, I thought about whoever was voted the most likely to succeed, whether that was back in high school or in college. And usually,
that person was the one with the highest GPA or the best scholar. But in corporate America today, does academic achievement translate into success in the C-suite? Well, unfortunately, the data does not support that. And I'm going to share some of that with you. So, in my talk, I'm going to specifically discuss the three types of biases working against these women. But furthermore, in gaining a better understanding of these biases, I'm also hopeful that there are things that we can do to address them in the second half of my talk. So, first, let me get to the data.
So, I have four pie charts here. The two on the left talks about, basically, how higher education attainment is very high within the Asian population. So, out of the general population, 38% have college degrees. So, that's the one you see on the second chart from the left. But then the first one on the left demonstrates that 61% of Asians do all have college degrees, as compared to 38% of the general population.
And then on the right-hand side, you see that there are about 13% of the professional workforce that Asians are representing, according to KPMG's Board Learning Center analysis. But out of that statistic, they also only show 6% of the executives are Asians, and only 4% are holding Fortune 1000 board seats. And an even smaller sliver you see there, the 1.8% are represented at the C-suite level for Asian American women in the workplace. So, you may ask, why is it important to raise this dismal 1.8% figure, other than for diversity reasons? Well, there's a very good business reason, and let me tell you why.
So, from a global perspective, more than half the consumers live in Asian countries, and their spending is expected to grow to about half of the world's consumer spending by 2032. So, not too far from now. And with India and China predicted to have the greatest increase in their consumer classes. So, we do need these Asian American women to be representing in the C-suite and in the boardrooms, so that they can be the cultural and the language ambassadors to better capture these up-and-coming demographic of global consumers. So, let me get to the glass ceiling and what that means. So, what do I mean by the double pane glass ceiling? Well, there's two pains.
And maybe it's better that I call the pain P-A-I-N. So, one pain is the gender effect. So, typically, that shows up as the double-bind or the discrimination women face in the workplace. But the other pain is the racial effect. So, in fact, ASCEND, an Asian American advocacy group, they did a study of the Silicon Valley firms, the technology companies, that they found the Asian effect is actually four times, almost four times as great as the gender effect, and that the double-bind is even more acutely felt by these AAPI women in the workplace. So, I'm going to break down some of these, three of these biases, specifically, that are constantly challenging these women. And so, the first one is the unfair assumptions. The second one is the unwanted attention heaped upon these women. And then,
third is the unequal access faced by these women in the workplace. Let me get to the first one. And what are some of those unfair assumptions? So, what do we see here in this Time magazine cover? This is back in 1987, where they showcased the various whiz kids back in the day, the ones in the ponytails, the ones with their books. And so, the model minority myth is very much alive. But what's unfair about them is that they're painting these Asian American students and workers in one broad stroke.
And in fact, the Asian American community has about 20 plus different groups. And they're not all the same in terms of demographics and education attainment level and even cultural differences. So, that model minority can really be a problem when it comes to furthering some of these other stereotypes where, you know, the Asian American workers are the worker bees, they're quiet, they belong only in IT or engineering.
And furthermore, they're also the unfair Islamophobia stereotypes that came out of 9/11 too for the South Asians. And like I said, with the double bind, the women in the workplace are feeling that even more acutely, even though they already face the double bind gender effect. But the racial effect or the Asian effect, as I said, is almost four times greater. So, they're, you know, double doubly being held to this, you're too nice and or you're not aggressive enough, right? It's four times greater instead of two times greater. Um, and I just want to point out kind of just breaking this model minority myth. Um, the arrows pointing at Masioka. He's actually a famous actor in a TV show called, um, uh, Hiro, H-E-R-O, where he played
Hiro, H-I-R-O. And he also has been in Hawaiian 5-0. So, way to go for breaking through that stereotype. Next, I'm going to talk about the unwanted attention. So, in the picture here, I'm showing Anna Mae Wong. She's beautiful and actually was a very famous actress in the 20s. But she unfortunately got siloed into the perpetual foreigner role, where she was always the exotic Asian woman, or she was the geisha, or she was the assassin. And up to a point, even she couldn't take on those roles anymore. She left Hollywood. But I'm glad to say there's a nice ending to that. She is going to be on a U.S. postage stamp to celebrate her achievement. But, you know, you do see that the media portrayal is very much geared towards painting Asian women in this unwanted,
you know, in this, in this light. And even more recently, the Vietnam War movies also tend to paint these Asian women as the comfort women or in compromising positions. And you can only imagine that makes for very unpleasant comments or attention right from whether that's in the workplace or even just out on the street. And even with the recent, you know, stop Asian hate that I think kind of stereotype is not helping. And I also want to bring up the fact that our own heritage culture brings on at a level of unwanted attention. So I've been on the receiving end of this where I've heard from my own parents and relatives that say, women in our country don't do that. Or in the workplace, my Asian elders will remind
me that, hey, you're supposed to respect your elders. So all these heritage culture expectations can also be the unwanted attention. And lastly, let me get to the unequal access. So in this, I want to showcase this Bain and company survey. And of about 10,000 people surveyed, what they do show of all these marginalized groups, that in particular, Asian women and Asian men are at the bottom when it comes to feeling included. So with Asian women are feeling 20% included and Asian men at a very low 16%.
So we already know that lack of inclusion can rear its ugly head in terms of the bamboo ceiling effect, but also that lack of representation, you know, the 1.8% can really have some on one, you know, unfair effects, where if people don't see themselves, the entry level people don't see themselves represented at the highest level, the retention is going to be that much less. So again, having, you know, that active inclusion, having that sense of belonging is very important to the Asian Americans. And there is another recent research that shows that Asian Americans, in particular, are actively participating in ERGs because of this lack of belonging. So let me get to that, because that's going to be part of my recommendation going forward.
So I have three particular recommendations going forward, how, as to how organizations can do better. And my first one is to have C-suite leaders and hiring managers examine their biases as to what a leader should look like. And so a couple of the recent Harvard Business Review research, where I happen to have worked in the past, shows that definitely substituting confidence for competence is no longer valid.
Right? Because there is this bias that if somebody is really confident, they tend to be thought of as the leadership type. But in fact, that hasn't borne out to be true. And then another piece of research from Harvard Business Review on women of color, there are three particular types of leadership capital that we should look at more closely. The first one is navigational capital. So when you think about how immigrant communities where people come to this country with nothing, that somehow they're able to find an apartment, find a job, raise their kids, and get them to attain higher education, as you saw in my second slide about how Asians have high education attainment. So that navigational capital, that bootstrapping capability is definitely a huge leadership asset to have for any company. And then the second part of the
leadership capital that women in color bring to the table is that resistance advocacy capital. So when you think about advocacy, I can think of a few times where I've seen in these immigrant communities, the kids who are are fluent in English are the ones representing their parents at the immigration office, or at the school meetings. And that advocacy capital is also very good for leadership when you think about that. At such a young age, they're already being thrust into the front, and being able to negotiate for their families and negotiate for their communities. And that is also another strong leadership asset to bring to the table. And lastly, as I said earlier about the global consumer consumer with 50% being represented by the Asian countries, that linguistic and cultural capital
are also going to be very valuable in looking at these international markets. And little did you, I didn't know this, but little did we know that also being bilingual can really help us in decision making. So that linguistic cultural and decision making capability are another set of leadership capital to really consider as you're thinking about promotions and getting people into the C-suite.
Secondly, I want to talk about these ERG or employee resource groups. So as we saw in the Bain & Company survey, that the Asian men and Asian women are really low when it comes to feeling included or belonging. Because again, from what I said about the unwanted attention, the perpetual federal foreigner and unfair assumptions that they're only worker bees. So being able to have an ERG, not just a recruiting tool, but really as an asset to bring in these marginalized groups and, you know, hear them out and also sponsor them and support them in a way that the belonging can really truly occur is important.
And I know at this conference, there are many people talking about employee resource groups, so I hope you'll check those out and learn more about how to implement those in your company, because if you don't have one, hopefully there's a way to start one based on what you learn at this conference. And third, I want to discuss how to leverage the community involvement for these Asian American women and men.
So, as we support these Asian women and men in the company with ERGs, by having them reach out to their own communities, we're going to set them up for success. And why would that be the case? Well, definitely, as they get more involved in their community by collaborating with their own company, they're going to feel that sense of belonging.
And in addition, what better way to showcase their leadership capabilities than to have them active in their communities and really demonstrating what they can do. So these are my three recommendations. So in wrapping up, I want to make sure you can get some additional information if you would like to learn more. So first, I have written on this topic on Forbes. So if you search on Forbes Coaches Council and my name, you should be able to find this article.
And then secondly, let me quickly recap again that we went over the three biases right into the those into the three buckets. I mentioned the unfair assumptions, the unwanted attention when it comes to stereotypes and also the unequal access when it comes to belonging and networking. And next, in terms of solutions, I recommended first checking, checking your own biases, especially those C-suite leaders, checking your own biases as to what a leader should look like and make sure that they do bring the lead, the navigational capital, the advocacy capital and the cultural capital as much as they can for for these communities.
And then sponsor and deploy your ERG so that they're not just there for recruiting, but they're really there to help support and retain your AAPI employees for the long run. And then lastly, I want to make sure you know how to get in touch with me. So there is the my LinkedIn is there. I know I also posted it in the chat and also my landing page. So be sure to check out CoachKellieHuang.com/888.
And actually, 888 is a lucky number in Chinese. So on that note, I want to wish you prosperity and good fortune going forward. And I look forward to hearing from you. And I think we have a little bit of time. Does anybody have any questions or comments you'd like to share in the Q&A or in the chat box?
I'm happy to answer. I can definitely talk more about the debating company survey, too, because I do think that brings up a lot of questions about how the bamboo ceiling effect is really felt right at the company level. And when I look at this, as I said, this survey cover people from US, Canada, Australia, UK, France, Italy and Germany.
And it was about ninety nine thousand four hundred ninety four participants that responded. And you can see right like that all these marginalized groups and numbers are high. But that perpetual foreigner, I think that perpetual foreigner stereotype is is very insidious. As I said, that racial effect that is a sin has study is four times greater than the gender effect.
So I think if I can, you know, send you with one takeaway is to think about how to really challenge this. Right. How to really challenge the sense of belonging and this perpetual perpetual foreigner feeling that the API community are feeling deeply. And so that is where I'm going to wrap. And thank you very much. Yeah.
Transcribed automatically; names checked against the speaker record. Select a time to jump there.
Article based on this talk
Why highly educated Asian American women still miss the C-suite
Executive coach Kelly C. Huang names the three biases behind the double-paned glass ceiling and what organizations can do about them.
In short
Kelly C. Huang argues that Asian American women face a glass ceiling with two panes: gender stereotypes and racial stereotypes. Despite high educational attainment, they are the least represented group at the top, and Huang traces this to three biases: unfair assumptions, unwanted attention and unequal access. She asks organizations to respond by checking their ideas of leadership, sponsoring employee resource groups and leveraging community involvement.
Key takeaways
Asian American women are underrepresented at VP and above levels, according to the 2022 McKinsey study.
The double-paned glass ceiling puts these women at a disadvantage.
"The 'Asian effect' is 3.7X greater than the 'gender effect' as a glass ceiling factor," according to Ascend.
These women constantly face 1. unfair assumptions, 2. unwanted attention and 3. unequal access.
What organizations can do: check their biases, sponsor and support Asian women's ERGs, and leverage community involvement.
Education does not translate into the C-suite
Huang came to this topic through her work as former co-chair of Women in Bio's Boardroom Ready program and as a coach to high-potential women. She kept seeing a consistent lack of representation at the highest levels of corporate America, and she started with a simple question about the student voted most likely to succeed.
"But in corporate America today, does academic achievement translate into success in the C-suite? Well, unfortunately, the data does not support that." (1:03)
As the speaker cited, 61% of Asians hold college degrees compared with 38% of the general population. Asians make up about 13% of the professional workforce, according to a KPMG analysis she referenced, yet only 6% of executives and 4% of Fortune 1000 board seats. Asian American women hold just 1.8% of C-suite roles.
Huang is clear that this is not only a fairness issue. "So, you may ask, why is it important to raise this dismal 1.8% figure, other than for diversity reasons? Well, there's a very good business reason, and let me tell you why." (2:16) More than half of consumers live in Asian countries, and their spending is expected to reach about half of world consumer spending by 2032, she said. Asian American women in the C-suite and boardroom can be the cultural and language ambassadors companies need to reach those customers.
Two panes: gender and race
The first pane is the gender effect, which shows up as the double bind and discrimination women face at work. The second is the racial effect. Huang cited Ascend's study of Silicon Valley technology firms, which found the Asian effect almost four times as great as the gender effect, so the double bind is felt even more acutely by AAPI women. Being told you are too nice or not aggressive enough, she suggests, lands with multiplied force.
Unfair assumptions and unwanted attention
The first bias is the model minority myth, illustrated with a 1987 Time magazine cover of Asian American "whiz kids." "But what's unfair about them is that they're painting these Asian American students and workers in one broad stroke." (4:47) The Asian American community includes more than 20 groups that differ in demographics, education and culture, yet the myth feeds stereotypes of quiet worker bees who belong only in IT or engineering. Huang also noted the Islamophobic stereotypes South Asians faced after 9/11.
The second bias is unwanted attention. Huang pointed to actress Anna May Wong, who was confined to exotic, geisha or assassin roles until she left Hollywood, and to war films that cast Asian women in compromising positions. Such portrayals feed unpleasant comments at work and on the street. She added a less discussed source: her own heritage culture, from relatives saying "women in our country don't do that" to elders at work reminding her to respect her elders. "So all these heritage culture expectations can also be the unwanted attention." (8:43)
Unequal access and belonging
The third bias is unequal access. Huang shared a Bain & Company survey in which Asian women and Asian men ranked lowest of the marginalized groups on feeling included, at 20% and 16% respectively, as the speaker cited. Low inclusion and the lack of visible role models hurt retention: when entry-level employees do not see themselves at the top, they are less likely to stay. She also noted research showing Asian Americans actively join ERGs because of this lack of belonging.
Three things organizations can do
Huang's first recommendation targets C-suite leaders and hiring managers. "And my first one is to have C-suite leaders and hiring managers examine their biases as to what a leader should look like." (10:20) Drawing on Harvard Business Review research, she warned against substituting confidence for competence, and described three forms of leadership capital that women of color bring. Navigational capital comes from immigrant families who arrive with nothing and still find homes, jobs and education for their children. "So that navigational capital, that bootstrapping capability is definitely a huge leadership asset to have for any company." (10:53) Resistance advocacy capital comes from children who represent their parents at immigration offices and school meetings. Linguistic and cultural capital helps with international markets, and she noted that being bilingual can also aid decision making.
Second, she urged companies to treat ERGs as more than recruiting tools: sponsor them, listen to members and support them so belonging can truly occur and AAPI employees stay for the long run.
Third, she recommended connecting ERG members with their own communities. "And in addition, what better way to showcase their leadership capabilities than to have them active in their communities and really demonstrating what they can do." (14:40)
Closing, Huang left one takeaway: challenge the perpetual foreigner feeling that the AAPI community experiences so deeply.
Watch the talk
"How to shatter the double-paned glass ceiling for Asian American women" by Kelly C. Huang, 19 minutes: https://www.womentech.net/video/how-shatter-double-paned-glass-ceiling-asian-american-women
About the speaker
Kelly C. Huang is an Executive/Leadership Coach at CoachKellyHuang.com/888, bringing more than 20 years of Asian business development, entrepreneurial marketing and management training experience to her work as a board diversity advocate. She is the former co-chair of Women in Bio's Boardroom Ready program, which has added more than 135 board placements out of 150 female life-science executives.
Questions this talk answers
What is the double-paned glass ceiling?
Why does it matter for business that so few Asian American women reach the C-suite?
Which biases hold Asian American women back at work?
How should leaders rethink what a leader looks like?
How can employee resource groups help?
Drafted with AI from the talk transcript. Editor review pending.
Frameworks and ideas mentioned
Double-paned glass ceiling
Three biases: unfair assumption, unwanted attention, unequal access
Model minority myth
Bamboo ceiling
Leadership capital: navigational, resistance advocacy, linguistic and cultural
Resources mentioned
Kelly Huang's article on Forbes (Forbes Coaches Council)
CoachKellyHuang.com/888
Cite this talk
Kelly C. Huang. "How to shatter the double-paned glass ceiling for Asian American women." WomenTech Network, 2023. https://www.womentech.net/video/how-shatter-double-paned-glass-ceiling-asian-american-women