Her interviewer wanted to check if her HBCU was even accredited
Ten years into her career, an interviewer told her he would need to verify that her university, a historically Black college, was accredited because he had never heard of it. Retired US Naval Officer and former programmer Trina Martin uses moments like this to show why companies that claim they cannot find qualified women of color in tech keep missing and losing them. What would it take to stop overlooking them?
Learn the biases women of color in tech face and how to hire, promote and retain them
Trina Martin, founder and CEO of Trina L. Martin International, argues that companies cannot find qualified women of color in tech because they recruit with blinders on, not because the talent is missing. Drawing on her own career, she describes biased hiring, withheld mentorship, unequal pay and the "concrete ceiling", then sets out what employers and colleagues can do to hire, promote and retain women of color.
“The truth of the matter is, companies are looking with blinders on.”
“Now, imagine climbing the career ladder and hitting a point that you can't see through. You can't push and you can't shatter.”
What you will learn
Recognize the hiring, mentorship and pay biases that women of color in tech face because of both race and gender.
Distinguish the concrete ceiling that women of color hit from the more familiar glass ceiling.
Widen recruiting to HBCUs, Hispanic-serving institutions and other overlooked schools instead of the same elite campuses.
Plan retention through diverse mentors and sponsors, training, leadership career paths and pay equality.
Document hostile incidents with dates, times, witnesses and what was said so you have proof if you go to HR.
Key takeaways from the speaker
You will understand the biases that WOC in tech face
You will be inspired to hire WOC in tech
You will learn how to retain and promote WOC in tech
Details
Level
All levels
Format
Talk
Technical depth
Non-technical
For
All career stages
Length
25:47
Published
July 2022
Questions this talk answers
Why do companies say they can't find qualified women of color in tech?
Martin says they are looking with blinders on, recruiting the same demographic at elite schools and dismissing candidates who don't fit their box of standards.
What is the concrete ceiling?
It is the barrier women of color hit on the career ladder that, unlike the glass ceiling, they cannot see through, push or shatter, because they are denied the tools, training and opportunities their white counterparts get.
How can companies retain and promote women of color in tech?
Invest in her growth, provide diverse mentors, sponsors and role models, offer training and networking, create a leadership career path and, most importantly, create pay equality.
How can a white woman be a better ally to women of color in tech?
Recommend and mentor qualified women of color, speak up on their behalf for open roles, and help dedicated colleagues who are not getting the recognition they deserve.
How should you handle hostility at work?
Keep a journal documenting dates, times, who was present and what was said, so you have proof if you need to take it to HR.
About this talk
Companies say they can't find qualified women of color in tech. Why is that? It's not the lack of skill. Women of color face barriers and obstacles related to race and gender in the technology industry. This talk will detail the inequality of women of color in tech being underrepresented, underpaid, and discriminated against in the white male-dominated industry. I will explain the biases women of color in tech face and the impact on these women. This talk will leave you ready to take action in order to close the racial and gender wage gap that women of color in tech endure.
Document everything when work turns hostile (54 s)
Speaker 1: Qualified women of color in tech are hard to find. That is a common statement and major issue. Why is that? Do qualified women of color in tech exist? I'm a former computer programmer, consultant, and CCE. I've programmed multi-million dollar systems for major corporations. I'm also a woman of color, if you hadn't noticed. As I progressed in my tech career, my two-decade tech career, I was often the only woman of color in rooms, on projects, and in the tech department. In 1989, I attended the university to study computer science. At that time, there was a small number of universities that actually offered a degree in computer science. Now, that's not to be confused with computer information systems. According to computerscience.org, in 1984, women who earned computer science degrees
peaked at 37%, but has been on the decline ever since. At that time, black women who held computer science degrees was less than 8%. I didn't know any women in tech, especially not women of color. I wanted to be part of the elite few. I soon realized that women of color. I soon realized that women of color in tech worked elite, because they were overlooked and causing many of them to leave the technology profession. In my career, I've been underpaid, overlooked for promotions, and experienced racism.
I never imagined nearly 30 years later, women of color in tech will be experiencing these same obstacles. Now, I can in no way speak in depth on all the obstacles that women of color in tech face, but it's my hope that by the end of my talk, you will, one, understand the biases that women of color in tech face.
Two, commit to hiring women of color in tech. And three, learn how to hire, promote, and retain women of color in tech. Today, the world is focusing on becoming diverse and inclusive. It's troubling that in a day and age of artificial intelligence, augmented reality, and other technical advances, that women of color are a small percentage of the profession.
According to Statista.com, in 2020, women of color who earned, who accounted for approximately 12% of the computing and mathematical workforce in the United States. Of the women that are in tech. Of the women that are in tech, they're often overlooked. So who are considered the women of color in the tech industry? Women of color are the underrepresented minorities.
Now, underrepresentation varies across the computing context. For this talk, I'm focusing on Black or African American, Hispanic or Latinx, Native American, or Alaskan Native women as the underrepresented across the tech pipeline. Companies say, "We can't find a qualified woman of color in tech." Or they say, "We're trying." The truth of the matter is, companies are looking with blinders on.
They go to elite schools to recruit the same demographic of candidates who they always have. Or they overlook women of color who had entered the interview process because she failed to exceed the stated requirements for the job. It was January of 2000. I interviewed for a computer analyst position with one of the United States largest utility companies.
At that time, I had about 10 years of experience. The interview was going well as I confidently answered the questions being thrown at me by the two white gentlemen in the room. I was able to showcase my technical knowledge and I felt really good. But at the conclusion of that interview, one of the gentlemen, who would become my manager, stated that he would have to verify that the university that I attended was accredited.
Because he hadn't heard of it. That shocked me and gave me pause. I never had anyone before or after him say such a thing to me, at least not to my face. I immediately began to wonder, why would he think the school that I attended wasn't accredited? Did this man know of every university that existed? Did he question the degree accreditation of every applicant or mine because I was a woman of color who hadn't attended an elite university, but instead an HBCU?
And for those of you who don't know, HBCU stands for historically black college and university. What gave me pause was thinking about not being hired for a position because the interviewing person hadn't heard of my university, therefore deeming me unqualified for the position. I then began to wonder, had that happened to me before? Have you or someone you know dismissed a woman of color candidate because she didn't fit inside your box of standards?
Unfair hiring practices are one form of bias that women of color in tech face. According to builtin.com, black and Hispanic women who majored in computer science or engineering are less likely to be hired than their white counterparts. Three percent of the computer related jobs are held by African American women. Two percent are held by Latino women. And after some exhaustive research, I found that point one percent are held by Native American women.
Interesting enough, I couldn't find any statistics on Alaskan Native women in tech. That truly emphasized how women of color are overlooked because there are Alaskan Native women in tech. Women of color in tech are intimidating to their male counterparts, which results in being ignored. We attend meetings and are made to feel like we don't belong. Our input isn't valued and we aren't given assistance when we seek out help.
If you are a woman of color in tech, can you recall a time when you were overlooked? When I began working with the utility company, the second gentleman in the interview ended up being my coworker. We were both to support one of the major systems in the company. He was supposed to mentor and train me. Despite me sitting right next to him, he refused to mentor or train me.
He barely answered any of my questions. And he always gave me that. You are an idiot look of irritation. He made it very clear that he would not train me so that I could take the job that he had coveted for years. It was very frustrating working with someone who didn't want me around. I felt like I was being set up for failure.
I remember going into my manager's office crying, telling him how I wanted to do a good job. But it was very difficult when the person that was supposed to be my trainer didn't want to train me. My manager told me to suck it up because that's how my coworker was. I was dismissed. That is an example of the lack of support and mentorship that women of color in tech face within the white male dominated tech profession.
During my career, I taught myself everything I needed to know to be successful. I bought books to keep my coding skills up. I financially invested in new technology courses so that I may enhance my career. In my position with the utility company, I would receive 1 a.m. phone calls when the system had issues. I would work to resolve those issues at home or by going into the office in the early morning hours if I needed to.
I would ensure that all systems would run on schedule. Women of color in tech put their all in what they do, but they feel like I did, not valued. We often ask ourselves, do I really belong here? When you are a woman of color in tech, you are well aware that you have to be smarter and work harder.
Not only will you face gender bias, but also racial bias. You work hard because you're ambitious and you want to enhance your career. As you continue to show up and work hard, you realize that you're underpaid. When asking for a raise, you're given every excuse in the book why you will not receive one. Even being told your performance is lacking and to work harder.
Then you're given a false sense of hope and told that maybe next year a raise will be considered. Unfair pay practices for women of color in tech are blatant. According to a report from the tech job platform Hired, for every dollar a white man in tech earned in 2020, a black and latino woman in the same role made 90 cents.
We are all familiar with the term glass ceiling. Now, the glass ceiling is a barrier to your success, to career success. You can, it's the barrier that you encounter as you're climbing the career ladder. You can look through it and you can see what's possible. But did you know there's also a concrete ceiling? And similar to the glass ceiling, the concrete ceiling exists, but for women of color.
It's the women of color's barrier. Now, imagine climbing the career ladder and hitting a point that you can't see through. You can't push and you can't shatter. You soon realize that there is no possibility for your advancement. This type of discrimination is what women of color in tech face when they aren't given the necessary tools, training, and opportunities that will allow them to advance and be as competitive as their white counterparts.
The concrete ceiling in the workplace, along with lack of role models, mentors, and lack of representation is what women of color have to endure on a daily basis. We start to doubt ourselves, and then we start to doubt ourselves, and then we start to believe that the heartache just isn't worth it. So we end up taking our skills and expertise to friendlier industries like accounting and marketing.
Women of color in tech are tired of the microaggressions, the unconscious bias, and the lack of representation. So how can this all change? Start with the recruiting process. In addition to the usual places that employers go to recruit, employers must also look at HBCUs, Hispanic-serving institutions, and other institutions that they normally would not have even considered. Then they have to actually be sincere and look for people who don't fit inside that box that they're used to.
Qualified women of color in tech do exist. So don't just say, you're trying. Actually do. Hire a woman of color in tech and invest in her so that you can not only fulfill a quota, but that you can retain her. Make her growth and success a priority. Seek to create diverse mentors, sponsors, and role models who want to be part of a solution.
Provide training opportunities that will allow her to network, develop, and advance her career. Create a career path for women of color in tech who want to be in leadership so that they can grow and thrive. Most importantly, create pay equality. If you are currently a woman of color in tech, or even if you are a non-woman of color in tech, look around your work environment.
Don't just be glad that you have your position. Mentor and support women of color in tech. Let your company know of qualified women of color in tech that will be a good fit. Companies that are diverse perform better and have engaged employees. Develop leaders in a workplace that have zero tolerance for implicit or explicit bias and racism.
You will find that when you hire and invest in a woman of color in tech, you will have an employee who is loyal and who performs her best. She will also seek out other qualified women of color in tech that can add value to your organization. Women of color add a diverse perspective that will not only add value to your organization, but also foster innovation.
Our life experiences and unique worldviews allow us to solve problems. If you truly want to see a diverse and inclusive workforce in tech, allow women of color to show up as their full, authentic selves. Open your mind to see the benefits that women of color in tech can bring when they're not overlooked. I challenge you to take the blinders off and release the negative stereotypes that you have about women of color in tech.
I assure you that if she isn't overlooked, her skills, her intellect, and her presence will let you know that she's capable and qualified to do the job. I'm Trina L. Martin. I am the queen of equality of tech and the CEO of Trina L. Martin International. I hope you enjoyed this talk. I'm glad to connect with you on LinkedIn or you can scan the QR code.
If you are a company looking to hire, promote, and retain a woman of color in tech, I look forward to speaking with you. I would like to thank the Women Tech Network for allowing me this opportunity. I welcome your questions. Great. I'm glad you guys liked it. Please connect with me. Please do. Feel free to connect with me.
I would like to connect with everyone here. And definitely go out and support a woman in color in tech. This is my passion. This is something that I speak about because I actually lived. And I really want... If you go to LinkedIn and you look for Trina L. Martin, it's a Trina L. Martin MBA. That's me. Please feel free to connect with me.
Reach out to me. If you have companies that you guys want to learn how to be more diverse and inclusive, please reach out to me. I'm happy to speak with you. Okay. So, there's a question. Katie, how do I stay motivated when I run up against a wall? You know, that's a very good question. Sometimes it's hard to do.
I'm going to be honest with you. But I have to remember the bigger purpose. And that is for me to do my job. I look back now and I realize that I was in those positions, not for me, but to bring me here to where I am today to actually advocate for women of color in tech. So, I try to keep myself motivated.
I try to pray. And I try to stay resilient and be strong because I think about the little girls out there who may not have seen or had modeled for them the possibilities that they have. And I want to be that person that they see, that looks like them, that gives them that hope. Who do we bridge the gap in?
Who do we bridge this gap in your corporation? If you're talking about my business personally, Monique, you can reach out directly to me and I can help you or speak with you or do training if that's what you're referring to. What else? Any other questions? I'm really glad you guys showed up. I love speaking about this topic because it's necessary.
Like I said, I never realized that 30 years later we would be stating these same obstacles in the same small percentages. But I think it's possible that for our daughters and for those coming after us, I think we can make the tech space more diverse for them. As a white woman, how can you be a better ally?
Well, Katie, support. If you know if there's a qualified woman of color in tech that you know and recommend her, even if she doesn't work at your company, recommend her in a position or mentor, train her. If you have positions open and you know she's qualified and she's looking, go forward. Be that person who opened the door for her.
And I'm not saying that you're giving her a job, but go before her and just speak good on her behalf and say, I know this person. If you just want to be an ally, seek out those people in your company that you see that are hard charging, that are really dedicated and want to work, but may not be getting the recognition or being heard like they should.
And then step in and help them. Yeah, I agree, Lisa. There is no reason that in 2022, Black women, Latino women should be a small percentage in the tech industry or not getting paid equal pay. I mean, no woman should be getting less than what the male counterparts are, but it's really troubling that women of color have those statistics that I talked about.
Yes, microaggressions are real. Yeah. Yeah, I'm seeing some. I see that this resonated with a lot of people. I see people saying that, you know, women of color. Yeah, we're unique. That's true. We're not unicorns. There's someone out there who also said they're the only African-American woman of color in their company. Definitely. Yeah. And, you know, that's why I'm here, because it is.
It's such a necessary conversation. And no one had been talking about it. And this is, I call it my call, my duty, my destiny for me to do this, because it's something that I'm very passionate about. I see some HBCU graduates in the house. Yes. Thank you. So, Elisa, also, your professional goal is to build a pipeline of biopic women as well as the pipeline for trained allies.
And please connect with me on LinkedIn. I definitely would love to be part of what you're doing. Let's see. Anyone else? I'm going to make sure I didn't miss anything. How do you handle hostility at your job? Okay, that's from Katie. Again, that is something that is very difficult. And what I've learned, especially because I retired from the Navy, I was a naval officer.
So, I did 30 years in the Navy. What I do is I keep a journal. Whenever I would encounter things, that's kind of your best defense is to just document everything. Dates, time, who was present, what was said. Because eventually, if you have to take it to HR, you have documentation. It's very difficult to fight City Hall without proof.
So, always just have your proof together. Of course, you don't want to exacerbate the situation. But you also don't want people to think that you're weak and that they can walk all over you. So, I'm not that person. I'm not the weak person. I always have spoken up for myself, even as a child. And I know that's frowned upon, especially in an industry like tech, because, one, women are, you know, they don't want us there anyway.
But then being a woman and a woman of color on top of it, a lot of times, that's not received well. And I've been on the end of saying, oh, she's angry. She's aggressive. No, I'm not angry. No, I'm not aggressive. But I am going to let you know my thoughts. I'm going to let you know my opinions.
And if you don't like that, then I hate that you think that I'm angry or aggression. Aggressive. Anything else? I know, let's see, I think I'm a little bit over time. But if you guys still have more questions, I'm here to answer them. Any more? Such a great turnout. I really want to thank you for listening to my talk and your great questions and your great feedback.
It's very important and it's very important to me that you guys have responded with your feedback because that lets me know that I am on the right journey in my life and advocating for what I advocate for. So I want to thank you for attending. And, Katie, I'm also a Chicagoan. I was born and raised in Chicago.
So just to let you know. Okay. Well, again, thank you guys for attending. And please connect with me on LinkedIn. And I'll see you around at the rest of the conference.
Transcribed automatically; names checked against the speaker record. Select a time to jump there.
Article based on this talk
Why companies can't find qualified women of color in tech, and how to fix it
Trina Martin argues the talent exists, and that hiring blinders, withheld mentorship and unequal pay are what drive it away.
In short
Qualified women of color in tech do exist, Trina Martin argues; companies simply look for them with blinders on. Drawing on a two-decade career as a programmer and the experiences of women like her, she shows how biased hiring, refused mentorship, unequal pay and a "concrete ceiling" push women of color out of tech. She then lays out what employers, colleagues and allies can do to hire, promote and retain them.
Key takeaways
You will understand the biases that WOC in tech face.
You will be inspired to hire WOC in tech.
You will learn how to retain and promote WOC in tech.
Hiring with blinders on
Martin opens with the statement she has heard for years: qualified women of color in tech are hard to find. She started studying computer science in 1989, when few universities offered the degree, and spent much of her career as the only woman of color in the room. As the speaker cited from Statista, women of color accounted for approximately 12% of the US computing and mathematical workforce in 2020.
Her diagnosis is blunt. "The truth of the matter is, companies are looking with blinders on." (3:50) Recruiters return to the same elite schools for the same demographic, or reject women of color who do not exceed every stated requirement.
She illustrates this with a 2000 interview for a computer analyst role at a large US utility. She had about ten years of experience and the interview went well, until her future manager said he would need to verify that her university was accredited because he had never heard of it. She still asks herself: "Did he question the degree accreditation of every applicant or mine because I was a woman of color who hadn't attended an elite university, but instead an HBCU?" (5:29) As the speaker cited from Built In, Black and Hispanic women who majored in computer science or engineering are less likely to be hired than their white counterparts, and she notes she could find no statistics at all on Alaskan Native women in tech.
Left without support
Once hired, Martin was paired with the second interviewer, a coworker who was supposed to train her. He sat next to her and refused. When she went to her manager in tears, the response was dismissive: "My manager told me to suck it up because that's how my coworker was. I was dismissed." (9:16)
She taught herself what she needed, bought books, paid for her own courses and took 1 a.m. calls to keep systems running. Yet the feeling of not being valued persisted. "When you are a woman of color in tech, you are well aware that you have to be smarter and work harder." (10:22) Women of color, she explains, face gender bias and racial bias at the same time.
Underpaid, and stopped by a concrete ceiling
Hard work, Martin says, often brings excuses rather than raises: claims of lacking performance and vague promises about next year. As the speaker cited from a report by the tech job platform Hired, for every dollar a white man in tech earned in 2020, a Black or Latina woman in the same role made 90 cents.
She then contrasts the glass ceiling with what women of color face. "Now, imagine climbing the career ladder and hitting a point that you can't see through. You can't push and you can't shatter." (12:36) Combined with few role models, mentors and representation, this concrete ceiling leads women to doubt themselves and take their skills to friendlier fields such as accounting and marketing.
What companies and colleagues can do
Martin's prescription starts with recruiting: look beyond the usual campuses to HBCUs, Hispanic-serving institutions and others employers would not normally consider, and sincerely look for people outside the usual box. "So don't just say, you're trying. Actually do." (14:18)
Retention matters as much as hiring. "Make her growth and success a priority." (14:45) That means diverse mentors, sponsors and role models, training that lets her network and advance, a career path into leadership, and above all pay equality. She asks colleagues of every background to mentor women of color and to tell their companies about qualified candidates, and leaders to hold zero tolerance for implicit or explicit bias. Women of color who are invested in, she says, become loyal, high performing employees who bring in other qualified women and add perspectives that foster innovation.
Advice from the Q&A
Asked how a white woman can be a better ally, Martin urges recommending and mentoring qualified women of color, even at other companies, and speaking up for them when roles open. "Be that person who opened the door for her." (20:42)
On handling hostility, she draws on her Navy years: keep a journal of dates, times, who was present and what was said. "It's very difficult to fight City Hall without proof." (23:26) She also names the stereotype of being labelled angry or aggressive for voicing opinions, and says she continues to speak up anyway. When the wall feels too high, she stays motivated by thinking of the girls who need to see someone who looks like them succeed.
Watch the talk
Women of Color in Tech: Qualified but Overlooked, Trina Martin, 26 minutes: https://www.womentech.net/video/women-color-in-tech-qualified-overlooked-trina-martin
About the speaker
Trina Martin is the Founder & CEO of Trina L. Martin International, a technologist, international speaker, best-selling author and podcaster, and a retired US Naval Officer and former computer programmer with over two decades of programming, digital forensics and intelligence experience. Calling herself "The Queen of Equality in Tech", she is on a mission to close the racial and gender wage gap in tech for women, especially women of color, and help them move into leadership.
Questions this talk answers
Why do companies say they can't find qualified women of color in tech?
What is the concrete ceiling?
How can companies retain and promote women of color in tech?
How can a white woman be a better ally to women of color in tech?
How should you handle hostility at work?
Drafted with AI from the talk transcript. Editor review pending.
Frameworks and ideas mentioned
Glass ceiling
Concrete ceiling
Cite this talk
Trina Martin. "Women of Color in Tech: Qualified but Overlooked." WomenTech Network, 2022. https://www.womentech.net/video/women-color-in-tech-qualified-overlooked-trina-martin