Your referral program may be quietly keeping your team homogeneous
A state of diversity recruiting report found 98% of companies focused on diversity recruiting, yet only half had tangible goals and processes behind it, as the speaker cited. For hiring managers, that gap means good intentions leaking out through legacy habits. Daniela Herrera, Director of Recruitment Operations and EDI at R/GA with 15+ years in recruitment, asks which everyday interview practices are quietly undoing the work.
Get concrete fixes for degrees, referrals, interview formats and accommodations you can apply today
Daniela Herrera, Director of Recruitment Operations and EDI at R/GA, argues that diversity recruiting is unsustainable unless inclusion is intentionally built into every step of hiring. She gives hiring managers and recruiters practical ways to audit their interview processes, minimize bias and challenge legacy practices such as degree requirements and referral programs.
“But being intentionally inclusive means to purposely and consciously make the choice to challenge inequities and embed inclusive practices in every single step of every single process that you have in place.”
“Because if your current company is not diverse, it is extremely likely that the referrals that they bring are not diverse either, right?”
What you will learn
Define what intentional inclusion means and apply it to every step of your hiring process.
Assess your team's current representation honestly and share the gaps with your recruiting team.
Audit your interview process through candidate surveys, accessibility checks and flexible interview formats.
Question legacy practices such as mandatory college degrees, referral programs and accommodation processes.
Attract more diverse applicants by reviewing job description language and where you post roles.
Key takeaways from the speaker
Identify inherent biases in your interview and hiring process
Identify Inclusion and Equity improvement opportunities in your processes
Identify inherent un-inclusive and un-intentional practices in your current processes
Details
Level
Intermediate
Format
Talk
Technical depth
Non-technical
For
People manager, Executive
Length
19:40
Published
July 2022
Questions this talk answers
What does it mean to be intentionally inclusive in hiring?
It means purposely and consciously choosing to challenge inequities and embed inclusive practices in every step of every process you have in place. Herrera stresses there is no one-size-fits-all solution and it takes time.
Where should a hiring manager start when making hiring more inclusive?
Be open, honest and vulnerable about what your team looks like today, identify which representation is missing, and communicate those findings to your recruiting team so you can choose intentional recruiting efforts together.
How can you tell whether your interview process is really inclusive?
Slow down and review it often, for example by running a candidate survey or working with an external consultant. Check whether your website and application process are accessible and whether candidates get choices of interview format and time between conversations.
Should companies drop degree requirements or referral programs?
If a college degree is not truly mandatory for a role such as software engineer or tech lead, remove it from the job description. If your company is not yet diverse, consider pausing referrals, since referrals from a non-diverse workforce are likely to be non-diverse too.
How can you increase applications from more diverse candidates?
Pay attention to the language in your job descriptions and be intentional about where you post roles. If you are not getting applications from a group, such as Black women, partner with organizations that focus on that community.
About this talk
Hiring a diverse team is imperative and needed –– but how do you, as a Leader, make sure that your hiring processes are intentionally inclusive? In this talk, we'll uncover how to identify inherent biases in your interview process, break down your talent attraction and hiring process to identify inclusivity opportunities, and discuss methods for expanding your talent pool.
Accessible applications and flexible interview formats (66 s)
Rethink degrees, referrals and accommodations (70 s)
Speaker 1: Hi, everyone. I'm Daniela Herrera. My pronouns are she and her in English and Isha in Spanish. And I'm the Director of Recruiting Operations and Diversity, Equity and Inclusion at R/GA. I'm joining you today from New York, the original and traditional land of the Lenape people. Speaker 1: And I want to thank you all for coming in this morning or this afternoon, really depending on where you're joining in from me today. And I want to thank you as well for showing up for more inclusive interview processes. I'm so, so happy to be here with you today.
So as we settle and as we get ready for our conversation and excuse the New York noise outside the window, I would love for all of you, if you can and if you have a minute, to visit native-land.ca and tell me in the chat what you've learned about the land you live in today and who were the original and traditional people.
And the location that you're in today. So go ahead and get some coffee, some tea, some water, your lunch, your breakfast, really depending on where you are. And let's get started. We actually have a lot of cover today. So, yeah, I think I'm not breaking any news here, but 2020 was a reckoning year for everybody, right? And companies were no exception.
Organizations started to openly talk about racism, diversity, equity, and inclusion as they've never done before, at least here in the United States, right? And we kind of saw that happening in real time. Like diversity data was being openly shared on companies' websites, diversity recruiting efforts were prioritized for many companies, pledges were being signed all over the place.
And more importantly, working from home was suddenly acceptable and available for a lot of people, even though this is something that the disability community and the parent community have been asking for and advocating for so, so many years. And yet, this is what our industry's diversity recruiting efforts looked like in 2020. Not great, right? Now, 2021 came and went and some progress was made, especially on the diversity front.
But, you know, like earlier this year, a state of diversity recruiting report showed that at least 98% of companies had a specific focus on diversity recruiting, but only 50% of those companies had outlined tangible goals and processes for diversity recruiting efforts. So, if hiring a diverse workforce is so, so important, but processes and practices are not in place, are we really making any progress?
So, if you've been following me on social media for a while, you've probably heard me say before that diversity recruiting efforts cannot be done in isolation, and it cannot be the only one thing that you do. So, and if you haven't been following me on social media, I don't know what you're doing, you can go ahead and find me everywhere.
More importantly, on LinkedIn, I'm every day there. But let's be honest, right? I think that if you are part of a recruiting team, or if you've ever participated of a recruiting process, I'm pretty sure that you know that recruiting, interviewing, and hiring, they have been unintentional, they have been unintentional, and uninclusive by design for way too long.
And obviously, while hiring and retaining a diverse workforce is the goal, or at least should be everyone's goal, I believe that these efforts are not sustainable, unless we focus on equity, belonging, and inclusion first, and along the way. Now, don't get me wrong, many companies have been driving inclusive and interviewing and inclusive hiring practices for a while, right?
Like, we know that organizations now more than ever are boosting their recruiting efforts by partnering with community organizations to meet and interview diverse talent between a million or quotes. Many companies may have diversity goals and may even have fully dedicated diversity recruiting teams as well. And to be fair, many companies are also training their interview teams on how to be more mindful and more inclusive during their interviews.
And they might be hosting unconscious bias trainings, and even reconsidering what their company culture looks like as a whole, and honestly, about DM time. Now, all of those practices are needed, they're important. But if there is one thing that I've learned working on diversity and inclusion is that sometimes it's actually okay to focus on progress over perfection.
But in order to make that progress sustainable, impactful, and meaningful, we need to be intentionally inclusive about those efforts. Now, I'm sure you're wondering, like, what does that even mean? I'm just, like, throwing a lot of data your way, right? But being intentionally inclusive means to purposely and consciously make the choice to challenge inequities and embed inclusive practices in every single step of every single process that you have in place.
Being intentionally inclusive is not easy, and honestly, there is no one-size-fits solution. And honestly, it's going to take some time, right? But at the end of the day, it is truly about disrupting some of the practices and some of the processes and the policies that you have in place today that probably worked for you maybe a couple of years ago, many years ago, or even last year.
Or that probably are working for you today from a regular recruiting point of view, but are not necessarily inclusive, right? So it is my hope that today you can take away a few examples and a few ideas that you can later adapt and start using right after this conversation with your recruiting teams. So how do we get started with everything, right?
So the very first step might sound obvious, but if you're a hiring manager, a decision maker, someone from the recruiting team or the HR team or anyone that has, like, any proximity to power in terms of recruiting itself, my recommendation would be to be open, honest, and vulnerable with yourself and with your recruiting team. And what I mean by that is you could probably start by considering what your current team looks like from a representation point of view and where you would like to take that team in the future.
So take a moment or as many as you need to identify what representation is missing from your team today and how your new hires could add value to your mission and vice versa. And once you figure that out, obviously, that's going to take you some time. Just make sure that you communicate those findings to your recruiting team so together you can better identify, like, those organizations, those events, like, those intentional recruiting efforts that you would like to invest in.
Now, even if your current recruiting or interview process is or feels inclusive, biases and uninclusive practices, they have a tendency to sneak back in all the time. So it is truly, truly important to make an active and conscious decision to slow down. I know that's not easy, especially if you're part of our recruiting team, we're all working on a million different things at the same time.
But to pause and review your processes often, it is important to understand what is and what is not working from your candidate's point of view and what's not working for your teams as well, right? So there are multiple ways to go about it. Probably the easiest way to start is maybe running a candidate survey to assess what they really thought about meeting with you and with your team, like, learning a little bit more about what they thought about your interview process, the questions that they were asked, like, how long the process was and the entire thing, right?
But if you do have the budget and the means, I would always recommend to work with an external consultant to help identify opportunity areas, like, improvement opportunity areas on your recruiting process. So a few ideas that come to mind, especially when looking into your processes and trying to identify, like, whether your processes are inclusive or not, maybe try to understand if your current website is accessible or if your application process is accessible, right?
Or even when you are, I don't know, like, scheduling interviews with your candidates, like, are you offering, like, multiple options for your candidates to choose from? Like, a phone call or a video call or maybe a video call with the camera off or maybe an in-person meeting if that's an opportunity for you. And even if you're doing that, like, are you making sure that you are giving your candidates time in between those conversations so they can actually gather their thoughts and get ready for the next conversation, right?
So I know I've said this before, but minimizing biases and uninclusive practices, unfortunately, is not a one and done deal. So you will need to stay, like, super vigilant and call things out as you move forward so you can improve things as you move forward as well, right? And for that, you, your processes, and your team, they will need to be as flexible as possible.
Now, as we know, biases are part of our human nature, so we cannot remove them completely. But there are still a couple of ways or a couple of things that we can do to minimize those biases, right? Of course, every company, every team, and every single person is a completely different stage of their diversity and inclusion effort.
But again, I brought a couple of ideas that I'm hoping that you can start using after our call today. So get your screenshots ready. So this is obviously not a comprehensive list. But here are a couple of things that you could, like, consider and maybe start thinking about, like, maybe pay attention to your process. Are you making sure that it's a structured interview process?
And even if it is, are you reviewing your behavioral questions? Because they actually can become very biased very quickly. Something else that comes to mind whenever you are interviewing a candidate or whenever you are running an interview process is make sure that you are using on both ends, like, from your end as an interviewer and from the candidate's point of view, that you are using a neutral Zoom background.
And, you know, as we just talked about, like, biases and uninclusive practices will pop up literally everywhere once you start reviewing your processes, especially when you're dealing with legacy systems and policies, meaning, like, practices that were put in place, like, many years ago or a couple of years ago. And they probably weren't built without, like, inclusion in mind, right?
And I know that challenging and deconstructing practices that have been useful in the past or maybe are useful today might not actually be easy, especially if you're dealing with leadership or with executives. So, you might also need to learn how to challenge inequities and how to pivot your processes along the way. So, again, I brought a couple of ideas that you can probably screenshot or that you can start using later in the day or assume forward with your interview processes, right?
So, a couple of things that you could potentially start doing is say that you are interviewing or that you are trying to hire for a software engineer or a tech lead. Like, do you, like, do you really absolutely 100% need that person to have a college degree or is that a nice to have from your point of view?
So, if it's not mandatory, just go ahead and remove it from job description or something else that you could potentially do. And this actually requires, like, a full talk on its own. But if your company as of today doesn't have, like, a very diverse representation, maybe you should start, like, pausing or eliminating your referral program, at least for a little bit, right?
Because if your current company is not diverse, it is extremely likely that the referrals that they bring are not diverse either, right? Something else, again, that may need a full talk on its own, but maybe you would need to review your reasonable accommodation processes just to make sure that you believe your candidates and that you are trusting your candidates, right?
So, again, not a comprehensive list, but I'm really hoping that you can take a few ideas from here today. So, committing to intentionality and our recruiting practices, it honestly takes time, it takes effort, and sometimes, I'm not going to lie, it can be emotionally taxing. But I can assure you that if your processes are inclusive and feel inclusive, you will have a positive impact on your candidate experience, your employee experience, your interviewing and hiring goals, your attrition numbers, and, of course, your overall diversity and inclusion efforts.
And, of course, being intentionally inclusive doesn't and honestly shouldn't end with recruiting, but it's definitely a start. And as I mentioned before, sometimes, it is truly about progress over perfection. All right, I think that we do have maybe four minutes for questions and maybe for comments on the chat, but in the meantime, that's my personal information. Please feel free to go ahead and search me online and send me a note on LinkedIn or email if you would like to.
All right, so I think that we have a comment. Thank you all for joining, but let me see. Rachel is saying, like, one idea to make interviews more inclusive is to use equal time. A tool track speaking time interruptions and monologues, as well as gender participation. Available on Google Meet for free. Rachel, that's actually great to know.
I mean, it is a fantastic tool. I would definitely want to give it a try. My only recommendation would also be, and again, because I don't necessarily know how this tool works and how you would use it for, but the only caveat that actually comes to mind is it might not necessarily be super inclusive for everyone, right?
Like, say that you are meeting with a candidate that has, like, someone that has a disability, right? And someone that may need a little bit more time to think about their answer before, like, answering your question or someone that might need a little bit more time to gather their thoughts before, like, answering your question. That's probably, like, the only caveat that comes to mind.
But overall, from the information that you share there, it seems to be, like, a great tool. All right. So any other questions? I would love to answer any questions that you may have. Is there a way you would educate sourcing teams to gather more diverse teams? Yes, absolutely, 100%. We only have two more minutes. But, yes, your sourcing team should be fully trained on how to source diverse talent between a millionaire quotes.
There are a lot of trainings out there. There is even a certification that they could take. But, yes, I would highly recommend at least training them on awareness, right? Because I know that sourcing is just about, like, finding and sourcing as many candidates as you can. And, of course, like, in certain industries that might not be as diverse.
Sana, is there a way to increase job application for more diverse people? Yes. Again, I only have one more minute, but I would pay special attention to the language that you're using on your job descriptions. And also, I would be, like, super, super mindful and super intentional about where you're posting those jobs, right? Because if you are not getting applications from Black women, for instance, right?
Like, you might need to partner with an organization that focuses on Black women in tech, right? As a minority woman trying to get into tech, I'm always concerned about bias. Are you seeing my eager needs to join? Will you give me the chance? I have only one more minute. I'm so sorry, Erily, that I won't be able to answer your question in full.
Unfortunately, there is no one-size-fits-all answer to your question. Because at the end of the day, I think every company and every interviewer is at a completely different stage of their, like, unbiased training and unbiased process. So my answer might be completely different to somebody else. And that's very unfortunate. But at the end of the day, I wouldn't let that deter you from applying to the roles that you actually want.
All right. I think that we're out of time. It was fantastic meeting you all. Just go ahead and connect with me on LinkedIn, and we can keep the conversation going. Thank you again. Have a great rest of the day, and enjoy the rest of the conference. See ya. Bye.
Transcribed automatically; names checked against the speaker record. Select a time to jump there.
Article based on this talk
Why diversity recruiting fails without intentionally inclusive interview processes
Daniela Herrera of R/GA shows hiring teams how to find and fix the bias built into everyday recruiting practices.
In short
Daniela Herrera argues that diversity recruiting only lasts when inclusion is deliberately designed into every step of the hiring process, not added on top of it. Drawing on her work leading recruitment operations and EDI at R/GA, she shows hiring managers and recruiters how to audit their processes, minimize bias in interviews and challenge legacy practices such as degree requirements and referral programs, while accepting that progress matters more than perfection.
Key takeaways
Identify inherent biases in your interview and hiring process.
Identify inclusion and equity improvement opportunities in your processes.
Identify inherently uninclusive and unintentional practices in your current processes.
Why pledges were not enough
Herrera opens by describing 2020 as a reckoning year. Organizations began talking openly about racism and diversity, equity and inclusion, sharing diversity data on their websites, prioritizing diversity recruiting and signing pledges. Remote work also suddenly became acceptable, something she notes the disability and parent communities had been requesting for years.
Yet the results lagged. As the speaker cited, a state of diversity recruiting report found that at least 98% of companies had a specific focus on diversity recruiting, but only 50% of those had outlined tangible goals and processes. Her question to the audience is direct:
"So, if hiring a diverse workforce is so, so important, but processes and practices are not in place, are we really making any progress?" (2:44)
Herrera's core position is that diversity recruiting cannot be done in isolation. Partnering with community organizations, setting diversity goals, running unconscious bias training and building dedicated diversity recruiting teams are all needed. But she believes these efforts are not sustainable unless equity, belonging and inclusion come first and stay present throughout.
What intentional inclusion means
The concept at the heart of the talk is intentional inclusion. Herrera defines it clearly:
"But being intentionally inclusive means to purposely and consciously make the choice to challenge inequities and embed inclusive practices in every single step of every single process that you have in place." (5:40)
She is candid that this is not easy, has no one-size-fits-all solution and takes time. It often means disrupting processes and policies that worked a few years ago, or that still work from a standard recruiting point of view, but were never built with inclusion in mind.
Start with honesty, then slow down
Herrera's first step may sound obvious, but she directs it at anyone with proximity to power in hiring: be open, honest and vulnerable with yourself and your recruiting team. Look at what your team looks like today from a representation point of view, identify what is missing, and consider how new hires could add value to your mission and vice versa. Then share those findings with recruiters so you can choose the right organizations, events and intentional recruiting efforts together.
The second step is to slow down. Even a process that feels inclusive can drift:
"Now, even if your current recruiting or interview process is or feels inclusive, biases and uninclusive practices, they have a tendency to sneak back in all the time." (8:20)
She suggests several ways to review processes from the candidate's point of view:
Run a candidate survey about the interview experience, the questions asked and the length of the process.
Work with an external consultant if budget allows.
Check whether your careers website and application process are accessible.
Offer candidates a choice of interview format: phone, video, video with camera off, or in person where possible.
Leave candidates time between conversations so they can gather their thoughts.
Minimizing bias and challenging legacy practices
Because bias is part of human nature, Herrera does not promise to remove it, only to minimize it. Her practical checks include using a structured interview process and scrutinizing the questions within it:
"And even if it is, are you reviewing your behavioral questions? Because they actually can become very biased very quickly." (11:49)
She also recommends neutral video backgrounds on both sides of the interview. Legacy systems and policies are where she expects the most resistance, particularly from leadership and executives. Her examples are pointed. When hiring a software engineer or tech lead, ask whether a college degree is truly mandatory; if not, remove it from the job description. If your company lacks diverse representation, consider pausing your referral program for a while:
"Because if your current company is not diverse, it is extremely likely that the referrals that they bring are not diverse either, right?" (14:14)
She adds that reasonable accommodation processes deserve review so that candidates are believed and trusted.
Progress over perfection, and questions from the audience
Herrera acknowledges that committing to intentionality takes time and effort and can be emotionally taxing. She argues the payoff shows up in candidate experience, employee experience, hiring goals, attrition and overall diversity and inclusion efforts, and that inclusion should not stop at recruiting.
In the Q&A, an attendee suggested Equal Time, a tool for Google Meet that tracks speaking time and interruptions. Herrera welcomed it but raised a caveat: candidates with a disability, or anyone who needs more time to gather their thoughts, might not be well served by speaking-time metrics. She also urged training sourcing teams on awareness, reviewing job description language, and being intentional about where roles are posted, for example partnering with organizations focused on Black women in tech when those applications are missing. To a candidate worried about bias, she advised not to let it deter them from applying to the roles they want.
Watch the talk
"Is your Interview Process (Really) Inclusive?" by Daniela Herrera, 20 minutes: https://www.womentech.net/video/your-interview-process-really-inclusive-daniela-herrera
About the speaker
Daniela Herrera is Director, Recruitment Operations and EDI at R/GA in New York, and an ED&I, recruitment and people leader passionate about building cultures that attract and retain historically and systematically excluded talent. Originally from Buenos Aires, she co-chairs R/GA's Latine Heritage ERG, is the Awareness & Advocacy Founding Partner at Allies in Recruiting, and has 15+ years of recruitment expertise, including 10+ years in technology recruitment.
Questions this talk answers
What does it mean to be intentionally inclusive in hiring?
Where should a hiring manager start when making hiring more inclusive?
How can you tell whether your interview process is really inclusive?
Should companies drop degree requirements or referral programs?
How can you increase applications from more diverse candidates?
Drafted with AI from the talk transcript. Editor review pending.
Frameworks and ideas mentioned
Intentional inclusion
Structured interviews
Progress over perfection
Resources mentioned
native-land.ca
Equal Time (Google Meet tool, suggested by an attendee)
Cite this talk
Daniela Herrera. "Is your Interview Process (Really) Inclusive?." WomenTech Network, 2022. https://www.womentech.net/video/your-interview-process-really-inclusive-daniela-herrera