I Can't Quit - Experiences of Black Women in STEM Professions
Dr. Margery Sendze23:092023
Stop asking why Black women leave STEM, ask why the 2 percent stay
Black women have had the highest female workforce participation rate in the US since 1996, yet they make up only 2 percent of the STEM workforce, and prior research on them reads like a list of harms: tokenism, isolation, double jeopardy. Dr. Margery Sendze, an industrial and organizational psychologist with more than 20 years building retention-focused teams, flipped the question and studied 13 Black women who stayed. What holds them, and what can organizations do to keep more?
See the seven themes that keep Black women in STEM and what leaders can change
Dr. Margery Sendze presents her peer-reviewed research on why Black women, who make up only 2 percent of the US STEM workforce, stay in their professions. Using intersectionality and job embeddedness theory to study the experiences of 13 Black women, she describes seven themes, from navigating race and gender to support anchors, growth, purpose, agency and financial security. She closes with recommendations for organizations and leaders who want to retain more Black women in STEM.
“So I decided that I needed to find out why the two percent that stay in STEM stay in STEM. What can we learn from them, and how can we recruit and retain more?”
“It just takes one person to see me and when they see me, they can take me to the next level.”
What you will learn
Recognize how race and gender intersect to shape Black women's experiences in STEM, from isolation and tokenism to being the only one in the room.
Apply job embeddedness theory (links, fit and sacrifice, on and off the job) to understand why employees choose to stay.
Identify the seven themes that keep Black women in STEM, including support anchors, welcoming workspaces, growth, purpose, agency and financial security.
Plan retention practices such as continuous learning, inclusive workspaces, consistent pay and promotion equity reviews and meaningful leader relationships.
Engage Black women who already act as STEM catalysts in their communities to help advocate for and recruit other underrepresented talent.
Key takeaways from the speaker
• Recognize and understand the differences in the experiences of Black women in STEM professions.
• Harness our understanding of these differences to address the unique barriers experienced by Black women in STEM.
• Implement policies and practices that will promote the wellbeing and retention of Black women in STEM.
Details
Level
All levels
Format
Talk
Technical depth
Non-technical
For
People manager, Executive
Length
23:09
Published
May 2023
Questions this talk answers
Why do Black women stay in STEM professions long term?
Their experience is an intricate tapestry of on-the-job and off-the-job forces at the intersection of race and gender. They rely on support anchors, welcoming workspaces, opportunities to innovate and grow, a heightened sense of purpose, a distinct level of agency and confidence, and the desire for financial security.
Why study Black women in STEM specifically?
As the speaker cited, Black women have had the highest female workforce participation rate in the US since 1996 and make up 14.1 percent of the female workforce but only 2 percent of the STEM profession. With STEM the fastest growing job sector, the industry needs to understand how to retain them.
What framework helps explain why employees stay in their jobs?
Job embeddedness theory, which looks at the links, fit and sacrifices on and off the job that influence a person's decision to stay. It stresses that employees bring their off-the-job experiences with them to work.
What can organizations do to retain Black women in STEM?
Provide intentional opportunities for continuous learning and growth, create inclusive workspaces that value diverse perspectives, and analyze pay and promotions for equity. HR should engage Black women already active as STEM catalysts in recruiting, and leaders should build meaningful relationships with them.
What training helps create a welcoming workspace?
There is no blanket solution; organizations should find leaders willing to take the organization through a journey of inclusion. Leaders must lead by example by getting to know their people, because it all starts with them.
About this talk
Understanding why women and people of color stay in STEM professions is critically important in attracting and retaining more of them. This is the level of understanding, knowledge, and insights unraveled in peer-reviewed research on Black women whose experiences on the axis of race and gender serve as a salient example. Furthermore, Black Women make up 13.9% of the female workforce, but only 2% of the U.S. STEM workforce, and their experiences regarding the factors that contribute to embedding and retaining this population were generally unknown until this research.
A Black female tech manager? That's different (85 s)
Why the 2% who stay in STEM stay (51 s)
It just takes one person to see me (68 s)
Marjorie Sendze: Good morning from Kansas City. I'm Marjorie Sendze, a technology leader, organizational psychologist, and an avid advocate for creating inclusive spaces in the STEM workforce so all can thrive. But before I continue, I'd like to tell you a little story about how I found myself here today presenting my research on the experiences of Black women who stay in STEM profession. Now, one day in 2013, I walked into an elevator at work and ran into this gentleman with the most welcoming presence. He immediately engaged in a conversation and he asked me about my role in the organization. I told him I was a technology manager and which to me was not a big deal, but it was his reaction and what he said that gave me pause. He smiled and with curiosity and then he
said, hmm, a Black female technology manager. Now, that's different. Don't get me wrong. I knew he meant no harm because of what I perceived as the welcoming presence and my belief that he was indeed happily surprised to see a Black female technology manager in the organization. But while I understood that he was coming from a place of positive intent, I suddenly became uneasy and I was reminded of the fact that I am an outlier. Now, to compound my heightened sense of uneasiness, I lost my father a few months after that encounter. You see, my father was my anchor, my champion in shape, and my ally. I still remember very vividly coming to work one day while I was still breathing and I just had this feeling like the world was going to
just double me up. Everything seemed very difficult and bleak. Then I looked around and again, I was accurately aware of the fact that there were not many women in technology and almost no one that looked like me. I knew about the absence of women in technology, especially Black women. But the heightened awareness around the absence of women in the profession became this powerful moment for me that would change my career focus and my purpose for good. And then a few months later, I attended a conference for women in technology. Now, that was a moment of epiphany listening to all these women in tech expressing their experiences, challenges, and obstacles in the profession finally made me realize that I was not alone. So I decided to be part of the solution and I made a commitment to myself that I will leave, I will
ensure that I work to leave the profession better than I found it. So I began focusing my career and personal outreach initiatives to understand actions and practices that can be implemented to grow the STEM pipeline and also to create a workforce environment where everyone, everyone, all STEM professionals can work together, value each other's contributions and thrive. And so that's how I found myself here today, applying meaningful insights into helping to close the gender and race gap in STEM, amplifying the voices and experiences of those marginalized and STEM pathways. So why Black women in STEM? Well, besides the fact that I am one, when I started looking at the underrepresentation of women and researching just general history of women in the workforce, I came to realize that Black women maintain the highest rate of
workforce or female workforce participation in the U.S. since 1996. They make up 13.6 percent of the U.S. female population, 14.1 percent of the female workforce, 8.2 percent of the STEM degrees conferred to women, 14.2 percent of the women, but only 2 percent in the STEM profession. And here's why that information is important. According to a 2021 report from the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, STEM is still the fastest growing job sector in the United States. Employment projections show that by 2029, STEM occupations are expected to grow by 8 percent compared to 3.7 percent for all other occupations.
Also STEM occupations may grow up to, it's projected that STEM occupations may grow up to 2.7 percent more than before the COVID-19 pandemic. But this high demand of STEM talent exceeds the capacity of the STEM industry to be able to fill the pipeline and create the persistent gap in the industry. But as researchers have noted, innovation needs the level and type of creativity often produced by diverse teams. Diverse teams create diverse teams create, excuse me, diverse teams create, realize higher level of performance, they create better innovative products, and they increase shareholder profit. Yet the STEM industry has been challenged in leveraging underrepresented populations and communities of difference in the U.S. STEM workforce to help bridge the gap. So it's on the heels of this data that I saw an opportunity to better understand the
experiences of Black women in STEM. But the research sounded very bleak when I was getting into it, and I started wondering why. Let me just give you an example of how the experience with being disbound was being described and supported by empirical data. What we know, they were described as a double bind, double jeopardy, cumulative disadvantage, emotionally taxing, visibly invisible, unheathen, and tokenism.
Just to name a few. Now, this all sounded very hopeless and powerless, and as a Black woman in the STEM profession who has lived these experiences, I needed to find a way to shift my energy toward a more positive and empowering state. So I decided that I needed to find out why the two percent that stay in STEM stay in STEM. What can we learn from them, and how can we recruit and retain more? And so I went back to the school to do a doctorate in organizational psychology to help me understand the experiences of people, and especially technology talent in the workforce, and people of color and women in the workforce, and really focus my research around Black women in STEM. So what do we know about the two percent
that stay in STEM? Well, not much. Up until this research, there was limited insights into why they stay. Research also underscored the point that their experiences are quite different from that of their non-Hispanic white counterparts, because their experiences intersect at the axis of two visible identities, gender and race. And as Kimberly Crenshaw describes it, the concept of intersectionality defines how an individual social, how an individual social world is constructed within the context of multiple identities, which informs their unique experiences. However, to understand their experiences, I needed a frame to focus on the intended outcome, which was to really understand why they stay.
So for me, I decided to choose the embeddedness theory, because the embeddedness theory provides a framework that helps you understand how individuals make meaning of the combination of material and psychological attachments both on the job and of the job that influences their decision to stay on the job. It also emphasizes the point that employees do not leave behind their of the job experiences when they come to work every day. They bring those experiences with them to work into the workplace.
And so based on this premise, it's very important to understand how an employee's on the job and of the job attachment influences their decision to stay on the job. Now, these attachments can come in the form of links to other people and activities. Also, their perceptions of how they believe their job fits with other aspects of their life and, quite frankly, the sacrifices that they would have to make if they leave the job.
So, what was the core question I was trying to understand? I was basically trying to understand, you know, through an objective lens, why Black women stay in STEM professions long term. So, based on this, I was able to explore the embeddedness experiences of 13 Black women in STEM professions. May I introduce to you, Aaliyah, Bella, Ebony, Destiny, Sophia, Chloe, Dee, Femi, Maria, Sovangel, Jen, Jasmine. These are the women behind the voices of this research.
This, um, the research, um, and through their voices, seven core themes revealed their on-the-job and of-the-job experiences and sacrifices that make them stay in the profession long term. So, let's examine these themes. The first theme that emerged was navigating their Blackness and womanhood. And in navigating their Blackness and womanhood, these three men shared that their identity presents disadvantages such as isolation, um, proving oneself, racial battle fatigue, seeing, being seen as a token, being the only one, and invisible.
For these women, they have visible identities as Black females, excuse me, as Black and female. They're raised, um, for these women, they're visible, excuse me, for these women, they have visible identities as Black and female who are very salient, especially in their race. Their race was more salient than their, um, gender. This intersectional experience is actually summarized by Jen, who stated that, "I have not really thought about my gender because my color has been so significant.
I am trying to get over the hurdle of being Black before becoming, before, uh, being a woman." However, though, despite the tension in navigating the race and gender, they have, um, often activated and often know how to activate a web of on-the-job and off-the-job links faith and sacrifices to keep them from quitting their job. For instance, they see the ability to bring their unique, unique perspectives to the job as a fit because they are often the only Black woman in their department.
As Sophia explained, "I bring in a different perspective because I am the only woman of color in that room." But there's another side of being the only Black woman. And as Jasmine explained, "My perception is that I have to represent everyone that looks like me, every Black woman, every Black man, every Black kid, or just people of color in general.
I am the representative of that race. And I am the only woman of color in that race. However, these women are able to sometimes navigate their experiences in STEM to their unique advantage by seeking opportunities to stand out for good and leveraging their visibility as the only one to positively assert themselves and affirm their role as contributing STEM professionals.
As Maria said, "Sometimes I like being the only woman there because it's like, wow, I must be smart if I'm sitting here with you all and you all are listening to me and listening to what I have to say." But again, I don't want to fight. I just want to come to work every day and be appreciated for the value I am.
Another theme that emerged as a key factor in making them stay was their links and their anchors. Now, at the center of these women's support system is their family, their churches, sister circles, and work relationships. As Chloe shared, "I have always had family support from day one, so I feel very, very supported in that respect." And as Destiny said, "My sisterhood makes me feel like I am never alone."
These women said that the ability to create networks and meaningful relationships at work also made them a good fit for their job. Their links, such as relationships with leaders and peers at work and investments made by their companies also make them link to their jobs. Now, in terms of relationships with leaders, Ebony surmised that although I feel invisible most of the time, there's always one person at work that sees me.
It just takes one person to see me and when they see me, they can take me to the next level. So when that person shows up, I am good. And Aliyah shared that having an awesome supervisor has definitely kept her in the field. Now, another theme that emerged was the fact that these women value welcoming workspaces. As they discussed, environment that is welcoming, flexible and shared diverse perspectives, make them embrace and make them feel embraced and comfortable and allows them to stay in the job long term.
And working in an environment that encourages innovation, supportive teams, growth and learning opportunities and promote diverse perspectives was also noted as a fit for these women. As Sophia summarized, what really helped me stay is the flexibility in my schedule. I don't have somebody micromanaging me. They treat me as an adult and as a professional. As the next theme that also emerged from this findings was the fact that these women thrive on opportunities to innovate and grow and engage in challenging assignments.
This actually influences their decision to stay in the job. And as Jasmine explained, innovation comes with STEM. So I am just not sure if another area will captivate me the way STEM does. And as Destiny summarized, I would like to have more opportunities to be able to grow, not just my technical skills, but my leadership and development opportunities.
If there were more opportunities for us to be promoted, there will be no stopping us. Now, another theme was the fact that these women do actualize a call to serve. They feel a sense of responsibility in making a difference in their communities and investing in others. They use their skills, their expertise and STEM professionals in giving back to their communities, which links them to their job.
As Southern Girl explained, it's just not in my heart to leave the profession. I feel like I would be letting down a whole bunch of people if I did leave. And I don't even know who these people are. I just know I would be letting a whole bunch of people down if I leave. And Femi summarized that.
Sometimes it's just not for personal reasons, but for the impact that as a black woman, you could have on your community. People are looking up to you. So you don't want to leave. You want to stay. Now, in terms of the themes around their agency, these women really demonstrated a very high level of agency. And they confidently explain how their skills, knowledge, agility and decision making and control and success made them a good fit for their job.
As Jen noted, I have a lot of knowledge in this area. I do my research. I learn and I spend a lot of time making sure that I understand the task in front of me and I execute it accordingly. As Maria noted, you have to have a little bit of self-preservation if you want to stay in the job.
And as a black woman, based on what Ebony said, you have to build that muscle to be able to take whatever's coming at you. You have to persist as much as you can. Now, above everything, these women also felt like financial security that comes with good salaries since then is also a key reason why they stay in the job.
However, these financial links also present some sacrifices if they leave the job. As Sophia said, I do enjoy the level of lifestyle that I'm able to have by staying in the STEM career. I know what poverty looks like. Growing up, I was told education is my only way out. So that has played a huge factor in selecting or helping me select my profession and staying in the profession long-term.
Now, at the end of the day, what is the experiences of black women who stay in STEM professions? And why do they stay? Well, the experiences can be surmised as an intricate tapestry of on-the-job and off-the-job forces, experience at the intersection of race and gender that relies on support anchors, welcoming workspaces, the opportunity to innovate and grow a heightened sense of purpose driven by a distinct level of agency and confidence and the desire for financial security.
So what did we learn from these women and what can we do about it? Well, the findings of the study suggest that STEM organizations should be more intentional about providing opportunities for continuous learning and growth to harness the black woman's desire to want to innovate solutions into STEM. Also, the need for organizations to create inclusive workspaces and actively promote and embrace the value of this diverse perspective was echoed in the study and supported by previous findings.
Also, HR practitioners should engage black women who are already active as STEM catalysts in their communities to help to advocate and recruit other underrepresented people in STEM. From a pay equity perspective, the study suggests that pay should actually be looked into and to understand and be consistent in analyzing how pay and promotions can be equitable. Also, leaders are encouraged to have a critical role in encouraging meaningful relationships with these women.
So again, why do black women stay in STEM professions long term? Why do they not want to quit? Well, it's complicated. Thank you. I know I have one minute for questions, but hopefully I've been able to give you a high level of my research. Marge, I'm not seeing any questions yet in the chat or the Q&A. Marge, I think I saw one question.
Oh, there's a question popped up. How do companies take advantage of your research? Well, as I shared earlier, there are some recommendations that came out of the research. And if you look at my screen there, there's some that, you know, are practical steps, really low hanging fruit. And there are some that will encourage psychological safety at the end of the day.
It's one of the key factors in enabling them to stay. And so companies can look at the recommendations out of the research and try to see what can be applied. It will be different for every company based on where they are. Oh, she did clarify. Tina did clarify. I mean, how are companies made aware of your research?
So how are you sharing this research out to companies? Okay. So first of all, the research is published in a peer review journal. And I have tried as much as I can to amplify through LinkedIn and other channels where I know I can reach individuals. So if you're interested in my research, go to my profile on LinkedIn and you'll be able to also see the research, a link to the, to the research article.
And Marge, there's one final question. What sort of training would be beneficial for promoting a welcoming workspace? Wow. Yeah. So I'm, I'm a, I'm a huge believer that we all move at the pace of our self-interest. There's no blanket solution. You need to be able to understand and look for those leaders who are willing to move in that journey.
And those leaders who are willing to move in the journey are the most critical actors in this, in creating those, those environments. They need to be able to understand and be at a place where they want to be able to take the organization through that journey of inclusion. Everyone in the organization is also responsible for creating that environment where people feel included, but then again, the, the, I mean, people, leaders need to lead by example because we are, we all look up to our leaders for that example.
And so if our leaders are inclusive and to, um, take the time to get to see people, know people and learn about them and everyone or at least everyone who is willing to go through that journey will do the same. It's all about the leaders. It starts with that. Thank you, Marge. That's all of the questions and all of the time that we have for today.
Thank you.
Transcribed automatically; names checked against the speaker record. Select a time to jump there.
Article based on this talk
Why Do Black Women Stay in STEM Careers?
Organizational psychologist Dr. Margery Sendze shares seven themes from her research on 13 Black women in STEM and what employers can do to keep them.
In short
Black women have held the highest female workforce participation rate in the United States since 1996, yet, as Dr. Margery Sendze cited, they make up only 2 percent of the STEM workforce. In her talk, the organizational psychologist and technology leader turns the usual question around: instead of asking why Black women leave STEM, she asks why the ones who stay, stay. Her research with 13 Black women points to seven themes and to concrete steps organizations can take to retain more of them.
Key takeaways
Recognize and understand the differences in the experiences of Black women in STEM professions.
Harness our understanding of these differences to address the unique barriers experienced by Black women in STEM.
Implement policies and practices that will promote the wellbeing and retention of Black women in STEM.
An elevator ride that changed her focus
Dr. Sendze opens with a moment from 2013. A friendly colleague in an elevator asked about her role, and when she said she was a technology manager, he remarked that a Black female technology manager was "different." She recognized his good intentions, yet the comment stayed with her.
"But while I understood that he was coming from a place of positive intent, I suddenly became uneasy and I was reminded of the fact that I am an outlier." (0:57)
A few months later she lost her father, whom she describes as her anchor, champion and ally. Walking into work and seeing almost no one who looked like her, she felt the absence of women, and especially Black women, more sharply than ever. A women in technology conference soon after showed her she was not alone. She committed to leaving the profession better than she found it, focusing her career on growing the STEM pipeline and creating workplaces where all STEM professionals can thrive.
Why the 2 percent matter
Dr. Sendze explains why she chose this group. As she cited, Black women make up 13.6 percent of the US female population and 14.1 percent of the female workforce, and earn 8.2 percent of the STEM degrees conferred to women, but hold only 2 percent of STEM roles. She also cited a 2021 report from the US Bureau of Labor Statistics showing STEM as the fastest growing job sector, with STEM occupations projected to grow 8 percent by 2029 compared to 3.7 percent for all other occupations. With demand outpacing supply, and research linking diverse teams to higher performance and more innovative products, the industry cannot afford to leave this talent untapped.
The existing literature, she notes, described Black women's experiences in bleak terms: double bind, double jeopardy, cumulative disadvantage, tokenism and being visibly invisible. Having lived those experiences herself, she wanted to shift toward a more positive and empowering view.
"So I decided that I needed to find out why the two percent that stay in STEM stay in STEM. What can we learn from them, and how can we recruit and retain more?" (5:52)
That question led her back to school for a doctorate in organizational psychology.
A lens for understanding why people stay
To frame the research, Dr. Sendze combines two ideas. Kimberlé Crenshaw's concept of intersectionality explains why Black women's experiences differ from those of their non-Hispanic white counterparts: they sit at the intersection of two visible identities, race and gender. Job embeddedness theory then offers a way to study retention by looking at the links people have to others and to activities, how well their job fits the rest of their life, and what they would sacrifice by leaving, both on and off the job.
"They bring those experiences with them to work into the workplace." (7:34)
Using this lens, she explored the experiences of 13 Black women in STEM professions.
Seven themes behind staying
The first theme, navigating Blackness and womanhood, captures isolation, the pressure to prove oneself, racial battle fatigue and being the only one in the room. For these women, race was often more salient than gender. Yet they also turned their visibility into an advantage, bringing a unique perspective to rooms where they were the only woman of color.
The second theme was links and anchors: family, churches, sister circles and work relationships. Relationships with leaders mattered greatly, and one participant, Ebony, described how a single person who notices her can change everything.
"It just takes one person to see me and when they see me, they can take me to the next level." (13:16)
The third and fourth themes were welcoming, flexible workspaces that value diverse perspectives, and opportunities to innovate, grow and take on challenging assignments. Participants wanted growth beyond technical skills, including leadership development.
"If there were more opportunities for us to be promoted, there will be no stopping us." (14:58)
The final themes were a call to serve their communities as people others look up to, a high level of agency and confidence in their own skills, and the financial security a STEM career brings. Dr. Sendze summarizes their experience as an intricate tapestry of on-the-job and off-the-job forces at the intersection of race and gender.
What organizations can do
From the findings, Dr. Sendze draws several recommendations. Organizations should be intentional about continuous learning and growth, create inclusive workspaces that actively value diverse perspectives, and analyze pay and promotions consistently so they are equitable. HR practitioners should engage Black women who are already STEM catalysts in their communities to help advocate for and recruit other underrepresented people, and leaders should build meaningful relationships with these women. In the Q&A she added that psychological safety is one of the key factors that keeps them in their roles.
Asked what training helps create a welcoming workspace, she said there is no blanket solution. Change starts with leaders who are willing to take the organization through a journey of inclusion and who lead by example by taking the time to see and know their people.
"It's all about the leaders. It starts with that." (22:29)
Her research is published in a peer-reviewed journal, and she shares a link to the article on her LinkedIn profile.
Watch the talk
I Can't Quit - Experiences of Black Women in STEM Professions by Dr. Margery Sendze (23 minutes): https://www.womentech.net/video/i-cant-quit-experiences-black-women-in-stem-professions
About the speaker
Dr. Margery Sendze is Sr. Technology Manager - Talent Enablement at the Federal Reserve Bank of Kansas City and an organizational culture influencer with more than 20 years of delivering business value by enabling high-performing teams. She holds a Ph.D. in industrial and organizational psychology, is a certified diversity professional coach and is active in various STEM initiatives in the Kansas City STEM community.
Questions this talk answers
Why do Black women stay in STEM professions long term?
Why study Black women in STEM specifically?
What framework helps explain why employees stay in their jobs?
What can organizations do to retain Black women in STEM?
What training helps create a welcoming workspace?
Drafted with AI from the talk transcript. Editor review pending.
Frameworks and ideas mentioned
Job embeddedness theory
Intersectionality
Resources mentioned
The speaker's peer-reviewed journal article on Black women in STEM (linked from her LinkedIn profile)
Cite this talk
Dr. Margery Sendze. "I Can't Quit - Experiences of Black Women in STEM Professions." WomenTech Network, 2023. https://www.womentech.net/video/i-cant-quit-experiences-black-women-in-stem-professions