Tough Love for Meetings: How Top Leadership Teams Drive More Quickly to What Matters
Jo Ilfeld41:112023
Simple problems are stealing your leadership team's best hours
A biotech R&D head tells his coach his schedule is killing him: back-to-back meetings, debates stuck in the weeds and no time to prepare or think strategically. Executive coach Jo Ilfeld, CEO of Incite To Leadership, has worked with hundreds of leaders facing the same squeeze, and she counts the cost in strained families, stalled priorities and departing talent. So which problems truly deserve a leadership team's time together?
Learn to sort agenda items by problem type and untangle complex issues step by step
Executive coach Jo Ilfeld argues that leadership teams waste their meetings on problems that do not need them, and that leaders must show "tough love" by cutting agendas and saying no. Using a biotech client's story, she explains adult development stages, the Cynefin model for sorting simple, complicated, complex and chaotic problems, and a step-by-step blueprint for untangling complex problems together.
“But when I say tough love, I mean leaders who are willing to make the hard decisions and willing to take a stand, even when it means saying no. Because when you stay in the driver's seat, the big work gets done.”
“And it's not bad work, but it's not leadership work. As a leader, you have been hired to accomplish something great.”
What you will learn
Classify agenda items as simple, complicated, complex or chaotic using the Cynefin model.
Strike simple and complicated items from leadership agendas and hand them to people better placed to solve them.
Recognize four adult development stages in how leaders react to the same proposal.
Apply a step-back, start-at-the-edges blueprint to untangle complex problems with your team.
Assign accountable owners to post-mortem follow-up so lessons turn into the next iteration.
Key takeaways from the speaker
How to set an agenda that cuts out the fluff and is worth your team’s time
What you can learn from how the top 10% of leaders engage with conflicting priorities and personalities
“This could have been an email”: How to distinguish what needs to be talked about together -- and what doesn’t
Dr. Jo’s powerful blueprint for how to use meetings to innovate with your team and drive your organization’s top priorities forward
Details
Level
Intermediate
Format
Workshop
Technical depth
Non-technical
For
People manager, Executive
Length
41:11
Published
June 2023
Questions this talk answers
What does tough love mean for leadership meetings?
It means leaders who are willing to make hard decisions and take a stand, even when that means saying no, so they stay in the driver's seat and the big work gets done.
Which problems belong on a leadership team's agenda?
Complex problems, where A does not reliably lead to B, deserve the team's joint time. Simple and complicated problems can often be solved better by more junior employees or individual contributors.
How can a busy leader free up time from meetings?
Spend 15 minutes at the start or end of each workday reviewing upcoming meetings and decline those where you are not needed. For the rest, know the meeting's goals and the decisions it must make before you walk in.
How should a team tackle a complex problem?
Take a strategic step back to name every element of the problem, then tackle a tangle at the edge before the middle and run experiments. Afterwards, review what was learned and assign owners to act on it.
Why do leaders react so differently to the same proposal?
Adults move through developmental stages, from self-sovereign to socialized, self-authored and self-transforming, each with a wider frame of reference and greater comfort with complexity and paradox.
About this talk
When you find yourself bored in a meeting, it’s a sign. If you’re doing your “real work” at night because it’s the only time you don’t be interrupted, it’s a sign. If it’s the third time this week at a meeting with no agenda and no clear purpose, it’s definitely a sign. These are all signs that it’s time that your meetings need some tough love. And unfortunately, you’re in good company – according to a Harvard study, only 17% of senior executives report that their meetings are productive uses of group and individual time.
So what can you do? Drawing from more than a decade of work with leaders at companies including Genentech, eBay, and the SF Giants, as well as fast-growing start-ups, Dr. Jo walks you through what top leadership teams do differently in their meetings – and how that creates breakthrough results. Discover 3 proven meeting and leadership upgrades that will immediately refocus your team, increase its impact, and free up time for what matters most.
This talk is geared for executives, the C-Suite, and the HR leaders that support them.
Speaker 1: Welcome as you're coming in to the webinar. I'd love if you could put into chat. What words do you use to describe most of the meetings you attend? Or what words describe most of the meetings you attend? So we'd love to see that as you're joining. I know it's been a busy day. You're coming in from a lot of different things. Redundant. Thank you, Nicole. So just trying to get from you. What are the words that describe most of the meetings you attend?
Which is for some of you. It's just I'm too tired to even put into anything in chat. That's how many meetings I've attended today. So status updates. Yes. Thank you, Maya. That's a good one. Consensus building. Great, Elizabeth. So please keep coming. I'm going to get started. So we make sure we get through everything, but I'm excited to share with you some ideas to change up your meetings coming soon.
So as you can see, just from a few things on the list, meetings get mixed reviews and a decent percentage of the meetings we attend can actually feel like a complete waste of time. And this has a huge cost for us personally and as an organization. Maybe all those meetings that you're attending mean that you're getting your work done late at night after the kids are in bed.
Maybe it means that you're trying to fit in just one more meetings. You're constantly running late for family and friends after work. And maybe it's created the sense that you're falling behind and there's important issues that you know you and your team need to work on, but you just haven't had time to tackle them. And if we step back even further, think about what it's costing your organization.
Think about all those people sitting in meetings with strain on their loved ones because they can't show up how they want to show up. Think about all the people who aren't able to do the work that they know will have the biggest impact. And then think about the time that you don't have to grow and retain your best people.
And those are often the first to leave. And if we step back from all the business for a second, I want you to just pause and think about why do you do what you do? What inspires you about your work? Because this is why you should be going to meetings, ideally, because they get your work done and they help you get done the work that inspires you.
So let me introduce myself. I'm Joe Elfeld. I'm the CEO of insight to leadership. I'm actually located in Berkeley, California, so it's still middle of the day here. And one of my favorite places on Earth is Carmel Beach, and this is my family and I in Carmel Beach last summer. I also love to write about leadership topics on my blog.
This is a hole I fell into on Carmel Beach last summer because I'll admit it, I was looking at my cell phone. I'm also a huge connoisseur of dark chocolate, and I love reading. My favorite are leadership books and romantic comedies. I'm really passionate about helping you end meeting how and making the meetings that you are at more meaningful and productive so that you can get on with the work that matters.
The work that you were meant to do, and the work that makes an impact on this world. I believe to do that, we need teams with the capacity to drive to what matters. And to do that, we need leaders like you who are willing to give and receive tough love. Now, what do I mean by tough love?
No, it's not like some kind of intervention or something like that, and it's not military style tough love. But when I say tough love, I mean leaders who are willing to make the hard decisions and willing to take a stand, even when it means saying no. Because when you stay in the driver's seat, the big work gets done.
I've worked with hundreds of companies and leaders facing this need. And if you're listening and you're like, this sounds great, but I already have too much on my plate. You are not alone. Everyone I work with now has too many priorities, not enough resources, and a real question about how it will all get done. So it's one thing to talk about tough love, but it's really important to think about what it looks like in real life.
And so to do that throughout this workshop, I'm going to be talking about one of my clients. I'll call him Sam. I met Sam when he called on my company for help. Sam had just reorganized his R&D team for a global biotech. And the first time we talked, I could hear the frustration in his voice. He said, my schedule is killing me.
I feel like I'm in meetings with my team and they get so bogged down in the details that we never get to what's really important. So then we need to schedule another meeting to do a deep dive. Honestly, between executive team meetings, R&D strategy meetings, one on ones and running my whole org, my day is packed with back to back meetings.
If I'm honest, I barely know what meeting I'm heading into, let alone having any time to prepare. And then once I'm in the meetings, I often feel like people are just arguing for their own solutions and they're looking to meet a referee. I don't have the energy to do the work I need to do, make strategic new investments when I'm constantly being dragged down into the weeds.
And I know I need to develop my team so I can empower them and I can focus on the big picture. But there's just not enough time. Maybe Sam's story feels familiar to you. Maybe you've heard it from others in your organization. But in the months that followed, as I worked with Sam and his leadership team, we co-created the systems his team used to shift out of the small concerns and get their collective focus back on achieving the bigger results where it belongs.
So listening to this, you might start to feel skeptical and be like, we've talked about meetings before and they just never get better. And please don't tell me you're going to tell me about being more vulnerable with my team or even worse, improv games. Don't worry, I'm not. I'm not selling snake oil. I don't have a magic pill.
But I do want to share three questions that make a huge difference in making your everyday meetings more enjoyable, more meaningful and more effective. And these are three questions that really show you what I mean about tough love. What's the level? Is this problem worth our time together? And what's our process? So pause for a second. I want you to think about a meeting you attended where it wasn't a waste of time.
Maybe you nailed it. You got shit done. Whatever was going on, it felt like a really great use of your time. I'm just going to give you a moment to think. Okay. So thinking back on that meeting, whether you were the leader or someone else was the leader. Maybe you noticed that this leader was not just paying attention to the content of the meeting, but they were also tracking participation and engagement, right?
That leader was paying attention on multiple levels. This is essential for an effective meeting. So let's talk about how this happens. We have all been in a meeting where two people are going back and forth on an issue. They're in the weeds. Maybe this issue only matters to the two of them and not other people. And when it's me, I noticed immediately that I just start spacing out and often checking my phone to see, can I delete a few emails, get rid of a few things, make more time in my day.
I'm guessing you do that too. We all have these coping mechanisms. It's totally human. But be honest with yourself. What do you notice when you, when you see yourself checking out and you look around the room and you notice 3/4 of the people in the meeting are checked out or not participating? What do you use a leader do to address that?
To think more about what's really going on here. I'm going to turn to some of the science of leadership. Our brains actually stopped developing at 25 physically, but cognitively they keep developing our entire lives. And what that means is as our brain develops over time, we can handle more and more complexity. Researchers have found there are four different developmental stages commonly found in adults.
The first one is self-sovereign. These are people who see life as a battle. It's me versus the world. And their perspective is often pretty narrow. Well, how does this impact me? Next up, we have socialized leaders. These are leaders who are great team players, and they care about the objectives of the organization and looking for alignment between what they can provide and what the organization needs.
It's important to them that they be seen as results driven and contributing to the company's success. These leaders have a bit wider perspective. It's me and you. It's us. Then we move on to self-authored leaders. In this stage, leaders can look at multiple objectives. They have a larger frame of reference, and they can choose among them to decide which has the most merit and chance of success.
This leader can hold more complexity and options and is always choosing among them to create the biggest chance of success. This leader is also more independent. And finally, we have self-transforming leaders. In the self-transforming mind, this leader is, again, an independent problem solver. But instead of choosing among just the best options, this leader can hold on to conflicting agendas, both and, and is much more comfortable with paradox and uncertainty.
In a world that gets more and more complex, this leader doesn't need to pick a path, fully commit and see it through. They can be constantly weighing competing priorities and reassessing with the newest information possible. They have the widest frame of reference. To see how this might look in an actual team, let's turn back to Sam's team.
If we were listening to Sam's team, this is how we might hear these leadership types in action. Imagine Sam is in a meeting with his leaders, and someone has suggested that instead of giving each group a fixed budget, that they constantly reassess during the year to see which projects are doing better and then flexibly allocate their R&D spread to the projects that are doing the best.
Now let's listen to the conversation. Leader A, self-sovereign, immediately pipes in, "I don't think this is a good idea. I can't plan appropriately for my team if I don't know what my full budget is, and I don't want to have to spend my time defending my allocation resources to others." Leader B, socialized, says, "I'm hesitant to commit to any of this type of plan without talking it through with my leaders first and making sure they're on board."
"It's important that my group make decisions together." Leader C pulls the group in a different direction, says, "This is a really interesting idea, but it's really important to make sure that we have clear criteria for what is a successful project. For my team, I have well outlined success measures for the research criteria I would need to see to allocate more resources there."
And finally, we have a self-transforming leader. Leader D pauses before speaking, says, "It's great to hear everyone's perspectives. I think it's important we come up with a flexible model of funding that is responsive to the research results we're seeing on our team, but is also responsive to what's changing in the competitive landscape." Leader D pauses before speaking, says, "I think it's important that we're seeing on our team.
Leader D pauses when we're seeing on our team. Leader D pauses before hearing on our team. Leader D pauses before hearing on their team. Leader D pauses. Leader D. that's a great idea, Denia. I don't know if I said your name right, but you know, what's relevant to this topic and what's not? Like, let's set out what's relevant. Another thing I've seen people do is have like a parking lot, whether it's a Google Doc or a physical flip chart. And it's like when people come up with things, it's like, that's a really interesting point, but it's not really relevant right now. So we're going to write it on the parking lot so people know we haven't forgotten and we'll come back to it. So as a leader, your role is to be consistently helping
your people transition to the next level of their development by raising the level that your team can function at. And so one way is by challenging your team's thinking and enlarging their perspective taking skills. Another way is to make sure your team is focusing on the right problems together. Oftentimes people tell you that you should be solving problems and thinking with your team together. But what I want to tell you is that there are certain types of problems your team should not be wasting time on together. Let's talk about why. People often talk about how it's a VUCA world. If you haven't heard that term before, it's volatility, uncertainty, complexity, and ambiguity. It's a big mouthful, which is why people say VUCA.
And a lot of decision makings that might decisions that might have been simple in the past now involve a lot more of that and add a lot more complexity. You can take, I'm working right now with a team to schedule a leadership offsite retreat. And there is the complexity of everyone's different schedules, managing all those different vacations and different holidays, the ambiguity of how to kill no COVID, if at all. Then there's the uncertainty of like, what are we going to use our time together? How, how do we bridge the hybrid gaps? Or do we talk about our strategy? There's a lot that can go into even just something simple like a leadership offsite. One model that I love, what was formulated to classify problems. It's called the Kenevan model. And it was formulated by Dave Snowden when he was
working at IBM. At work, we're constantly making decisions. So it's important to know what type of decisions we're making. So we know what process to use. Let's look at Sam and his team again to think this through. The first is simple decisions. When I first started working with Sam, his team spent a lot of time talking about simple problems and complicated problems. Simple problems are problems where if you do A, you get B. It's their simple or obvious problems. And they're pretty straightforward to solve. Like if Sam wants to call a meeting for his team, he can tell his EA, they can send an evite, put the zoom room and barring any tech snafus, everyone ends up in the meeting at three. Or if Sam's team needs to create a budget, they know if
they just add up all the different subtotals, they get the total amount of money in the budget that they're requesting. Simple problems have best practices, how to solve them, you do that, you move forward. Next step, we have complicated, complicated decisions also have a right answer, but they're harder to figure out. They involve a lot more steps. With Sam's R&D group, some leaders need to think through clinical trials for prospective drugs. Clinical trials can be really complicated to think through how are we going to recruit people, how are we going to administer the medication, how will we measure treatment outcomes.
This is a complicated process. But if you want to get FDA approval, there's a lot of standards that you can follow. And in many companies, there's a program management office or project managers who help manage all these different types of complicated processes and systems so that the important pieces can come together at the right time. Then we start entering into the other side of the model. This is the complex world. And this is what most of us are honestly facing right now in our companies. That's when A doesn't always lead to B, and things don't happen the same way each time. So we can look for patterns, and we can find them. But there's no guarantees, like if you get a certain results in the lab, that it will
translate into human research, human subjects, or that a certain amount of advertising will always lead to the same amount of sales. In a complex world of problems, you're not just one answer, you can't just figure it out, like a simple solution or a complicated one. So you're looking at emerging practices and what works for where you are right now. As I worked with Sam and his team, one thing we shifted was taking out all the simple and complicated problems from their valuable team time together. Often these things can be solved better by more junior employees or individual contributors. And that way, Sam and his team have time for the most complex problems. I think Nicole mentioned smaller meetings, also a great idea. So imagine when
Sam calls his internal team together to discuss where should they invest their research dollars. There's drugs in early stage development, drugs, clinical trials, and there's companies that they can buy with promising results. This type of strategic planning is often what companies are doing where there is no one right answer. But when we think back to the first part of this workshop, we talked about perspective taking, the more perspectives you can get in the room, the more you can handle these unknown variables, and imagine many more different outcomes. As a result, once Sam and his team kicked out simple and complicated problems from their agenda, they had time to discuss the thorny issues that mattered most, and use their joint experiences as a brain trust. And for those of you who are like, wait, hold on, there was a
fourth box. What about chaos? That could easily describe what happened to a lot of companies when the pandemic started and everyone had to leave their workplace. When you have chaos, what you want to do is act quickly to find stability again. And then once things are more stable, you can start moving into what's next. For Sam and his team, when the pandemic hit, they they suddenly had to deal with a team that was all remote. And so they acted to make sure everyone had the technical equipment and the things that they needed to be able to work from home, then they could start looking at the complex issue of what did they want to do strategically? What were their new priorities, given this new state of work from home and this new reality?
So it's one thing to just hear about these things, but I wanted to give you a chance to actually play with it because identifying these problems is key. Otherwise, you won't know whether they should be on your agenda or not, right? So I'm going to give you a quiz. You can just put the answers in the chat and you know, you'll know if you're right or not. So how do we choose between our top three candidates for making a final offer? Is that a simple problem? A complicated problem?
A complex problem? A complex problem? A chaos? I see. Let me give you a moment to put something in the chat. You can just simplify if you want. For those of you who thought complex problem. Yes. There often isn't a right candidate to choose. And oftentimes, it depends what we're working on. Is this a job where we've seen other people do it successfully before? Is it brand new and we're creating a new position? So we need to see certain things.
is someone or some people internal versus external, there can be a lot of complexity in even just making a final offer. Should we reserve a booth at the XYZ conference again this year? Any thoughts from the audience? Simple. Okay, Elizabeth. I think in many companies, it is simple. Maybe it is. I sort of gave it as complicated that you could sort of look at how well your ROI was for your booth last year. You could look at your ROI of other things or sort of measuring these things. And then you're coming up with whether or not to reserve it. But yes, I agree. In some companies, it probably is just a super simple decision, depending on what the conference is. It's the biggest conference of the year. What's the best way
to pick which product upgrades we should invest in this cycle? Seeing if there's any answers. complicated. Okay. I went with complex because I think oftentimes you're having to weigh like, what is the cost and benefit of different product of different product benefits? Also what's happening competitively in the marketplace? What are your, what are other people doing? What is the, where's the market moving? So to me, there's a lot of complexity in that, but it depends on what product. And then finally, why am I so tired? And this one I thought could be all of the above. It could be as simple as I went to bed at 4 30 AM last night. That is not true for me. It could be complicated. Like, Oh, I'm taking some new medicines and I need to figure out like which one is affecting
my sleep. But there's a right answer there. It could be complex. Like I have a lot of stress at work. I'm taking some new medications. I also have a new puppy. That is true for me. And you know, so what are the, which of these things are contributing and then chaos. If you're in a war torn country and everything is chaotic around you, that might be a reason as well. So as you can see, lots of fun to just start thinking about which problems is your team spending time on. So the first thing that you and your team should be doing is to review your team meeting agendas beforehand, and you're looking for any things that are simple or complicated. And what you want to use is like
the red marker or the strikethrough function, and you want to get them off your agenda. And here's the tough love part. It's not going to be easy because this kind of stuff sucks our attention in the moment. It feels super important and we feel accomplished because we've solved a problem. And then sometimes other people don't like it when we remove their things from our agenda, because they want us to help solve their problems too. But if you really want to focus on the big stuff and have an impact, this is a truly necessary part of tough love. So here's what tough love can look like in action. First of all, as I said before, looking at your agendas, making sure there is time for what is truly complex.
What that often means is canceling meetings. I recommend to all my clients that they or their EA spend 15 minutes at the beginning or end of a workday and look at their meetings and decide, wait, which of these meetings do I really need to be at? Which of these meetings are pro forma, or they're just going to be sharing about things? And just send them an email and say, hey, I don't think I'm really needed in this meeting, but let me know if you have any questions and create some space on your calendar. Then, and I think I can't remember who said it, I think maybe Elizabeth, but know when you're going into the meeting, know your meeting goals. And what are the necessary decisions? Like understand what is a good outcome for this meeting? I worked
with a leader last summer, she was so busy going from meeting to meeting, she felt accomplished if she just showed up on time. But we ended up having conversations about the difference between showing up versus setting a purpose for a meeting, knowing what decisions need to be made and acting on that. And as a bonus, what I said to her is you can't have executive presence. If you're just showing up at the meeting with no clue about what needs to happen, then you're not leading that meeting from a place of strength. So I can't see you. So you're all a little bit saved. But I often will do this poll with people where I'll say, Okay, think about the meetings you had on last week. For those meetings,
like, did you show up to 100% of them like a rock star? Were you prepared and ready had reviewed the agenda knew what was important about that meeting? Or maybe for some of you 50% of the time, like half, half the time I just showed up and half the time I was prepped. And for some of you, it might just be 10% like there's one meeting a day that I know what needs to happen. And that's what I can do. So just apply some tough love to yourself and think about your own schedule. And think if there is any room for growth here for you and your team. Because in here's a key distinction here, meetings that focus on simple or complicated problems are largely procedural. Their purpose is about checking in,
reporting, giving updates, or problem solving with known variables. And it's not bad work, but it's not leadership work. As a leader, you have been hired to accomplish something great. And to achieve those goals, you need to have people working on the complex problems. And in the beginning, you're going to have to hold that agenda for your team, because they might not be used to it. And it might be a pattern interrupt for them.
But when you hold that vision, that meetings are a place to focus on complexity, and what our team can really do that makes an impact, I guarantee you, you won't feel like your meetings are a waste of time again. So let's say you've cleared your agendas of all those simple and complicated problems that have been eating away at your team's time. Now what? I'm glad you asked. You might know already that you can't forge ahead and just solve a complex problem head on. That's not how it works. But here's one way it does work.
I call this model the complex problem solving blueprint. I also joke it's the tangled necklace model. So many women, maybe you too, store their necklaces in ways where when you pick one up, suddenly you've gotten multiple necklaces and they're tangled together. I've heard this is similar to the Christmas light problem when you're taking them out for the new season. And most of us have learned by trial and error tackling tangled objects that if you go right to the tangle is and you sort of pull harder, it doesn't help. It makes things worse. Solving complex problems is the same thing. If you go right to the middle of it, you often end up with the tangle being tighter and you end up in more confusion.
It turns out you need a more systematized approach. The first step I talk about with my clients is executing a strategic step back. I talk a lot about strategic step backs with my clients. I find most of us are so busy going, going, going, going that we don't take the time to stop, breathe and look at the problem we're facing and understand what is, what is this problem involved?
What are all the elements of this problem? Especially once we're out of the domain of simple and complicated problem solving. So the first step is recognizing what are the, all the things involved in this complex tangle that you need to think through. And to do that, you take time by yourself or with your team to identify and name all the elements of going on, of what's going on. Otherwise, you might be missing the big picture. One of the things I find when people start noticing that they're in a real tangle is that they're having the same conversations over and over again. One of my clients nicknamed these zombie issues. And I love that means you think you've dealt with something you think you've made a decision and boom, it keeps popping up again. I often find that happens when we have a
complex problem and you haven't thought about all the pieces together. So you've made a decision and then people like, Oh, but what about this case out here? What about here? And so you haven't thought about all the elements of the problem. So once you've identified the edges of the problem, I find it's often wise to tangle tackle a tangle in the edge. First, before you go to the middle, this helps your team work on the smaller problem first, gain a little bit of traction, and even learn more about the complex tangle in the middle. So the next step for your teams and leaders is to notice where on the edges of this issue might you be successful and having an impact. Let's return to Sam and his team to see
how this works. Our first step was to initiate quarterly offsites for the global team. The leaders could come together and discuss where is the industry going? Where do we fit in this landscape? What's our vision for R&D within the company? And then following my model, these leaders picked one tangle to start. What they realized is that they didn't have strategic questions that they were always asking of new projects to figure out whether it fit well in their portfolio or not. So what they chose to focus on was creating 10 questions or guideposts that they could agree that helped them and the company decide which projects to take on and which to pass on. The first set of experiments that they did was holding focus group
like discussions with other groups in the organization to make sure did these seem like the right questions? Is there anything we're missing? What these leaders saw was how valuable it was to involve their stakeholders earlier in their thinking. They had a monthly meeting with the CEO and what they started doing was also setting up regular meetings with stakeholders like regional heads and the COO before this monthly meeting so they can improve their ideas before they presented them to the CEO. Complex problem solving doesn't doesn't just work for meetings though. It also works for company-wide problems and for teams that are different than Sam's too. I had one architecture firm that I worked with and their chief complaint wasn't time-wasting meetings. It was profitability. When they came to me, there were four partners and two were retiring
soon and the leadership dynamic was changing. And their big tangle, their big complexity is how would the firm survive? How would it stay profitable and become even more profitable? And what we saw is we did a step back together and started thinking about the issues that it made sense to start with the tangle of who were the next leaders coming up in the organization so they could develop them. So as these two leaders left, there were more leaders coming up through the pipeline. So we used a mix of individual and team coaching and we got these leaders together thinking not about architecture or project management, but thinking about business sustainability and building new relationships, what it meant to mentor their teams and work in a very different way. Then we worked with a third-party ROI firm who surveyed the
leaders and what they found is it does make a difference. These leaders all were much better at strategic execution and at anticipating and responding to what new opportunities in the market. That helps a lot with build profitability. The final return on their investment was 218% and this was the end of one year of work together. Since then, I've kept in touch and these partners who were once at a firm that was struggling with viability have grown 25% year over year and had some of their best years despite COVID.
The investment in leadership development pays for itself. This had been a firm really worried about viability and now they talk about the most important things as a group. So this is one version of what it can look like to work in complexity, but I find once you get your team better at conducting experiments, then it's important to build in time to think about what did we learn from this experiment?
What do we need to do differently going forward? I find a lot of teams do that okay, but then they skip the second part. Here's tough love where you actually need to create an action plan for what your next iteration is. It's not enough to just talk about it. You actually have to put it into action and to do that, you need to create accountable team members for that post-mortem follow-up. In Sam's team, that meant there was someone responsible after each focus group for taking the feedback and incorporating it into their 10 touchstones and guidelines. For other teams, this might mean creating new templates and checklists for onboarding so the same mistakes don't happen again and again. So I want to give you a moment to post-mortem
this workshop and we're not totally over yet, but we're getting the close. And so I'd love you to just think about what's one idea or insight that stood out to you at your workshop. And if you're willing, take the time to put it into chat. What is one takeaway from this workshop or something you want to do differently with your team when you go home?
As you're putting that in, I'll just keep moving on so that I make sure to get through everything and have some time for questions. But if you are like a lot of the people I work with, when you go to this conference, you hear great ideas and then you go back into the meeting madness. And it is hard to change and tough love need support. So if you think that you and your team could use some support, just drop me an email at [email protected] and we'll find a time to talk about the strength and growth areas of your team and what you can do next with your team that would be most effective. So whether your team feels like a disaster, whether your team is running to working together okay, but you know they need
to resolve some key issues, or whether your team is doing pretty well, but you're ready to take it to the next level, our conversation can help you identify where your team can easily improve and transform your company's results. Here's the thing, when we find ourselves going to meetings, meetings, meetings, this is another time to step back and ask ourselves, where am I having an impact?
What will my legacy be? I want to leave you with this story. My dad was a lawyer for a top research university, and I grew up listening to him tell my mom at the kitchen table about his day, his meetings, his vision, and he shaped much of how I first learned about leadership and teams. My dad was often focused on solving complex problems like community relations with a large research university, but he also made time for mentoring and life-changing conversations.
A few years ago, my dad, Art, passed away, and the first flowers that arrived to my parents' apartment were from then First Lady Michelle Obama, and the card read, "Art was a true mentor to me." My dad was able to impact many people through his dedication and care, including a First Lady of the United States. If my dad had settled for just getting through his need-to-dos, he never would have made time to meet, influence, and change the lives of the people he did. If my dad had settled for just getting through his daily meetings, he wouldn't have focused on the bigger picture and creating long-term change. And if my dad had settled for things being good enough, he wouldn't have left the lasting legacy that he did. Tough love is really about more than meetings. It's about paying attention to what
matters. So when you notice yourself consistently checking out in team meetings, it is a big signal that you and your team are not doing the impactful work you need to do. Because that is really why we're here, right? To do the work that inspires us and to make a difference. And I want that for all of you.
Thank you. And I know we're at the end, but I'm happy to stay and answer any questions if people have them. And if you have to jet off to other sessions, that's totally fine, too. I'll just wait for a minute or two and see if there's any questions in the chat. Okay. Thank you, everyone. I really enjoyed being here with you. And you drop me a line, Joe at Insight to Leadership, if you have any questions or I can be helpful to you and your team.
Thank you.
Transcribed automatically; names checked against the speaker record. Select a time to jump there.
Article based on this talk
Which problems deserve your leadership team's meeting time?
Executive coach Jo Ilfeld argues that leaders must cut simple problems from their agendas and reserve meetings for the complex work only a team can do.
In short
Most leadership meetings feel wasted because teams spend their shared time on problems that do not need them. Jo Ilfeld, executive coach and CEO of Incite To Leadership, says the fix is "tough love": leaders who strike simple and complicated items from agendas, cancel meetings they are not needed in, and reserve team time for complex problems, which they then untangle with a deliberate, step-by-step method.
Key takeaways
How to set an agenda that cuts out the fluff and is worth your team's time
What you can learn from how the top 10% of leaders engage with conflicting priorities and personalities
"This could have been an email": how to distinguish what needs to be talked about together, and what doesn't
Dr. Jo's blueprint for how to use meetings to innovate with your team and drive your organization's top priorities forward
Why meetings need tough love
Ilfeld opens by asking attendees to describe their meetings in chat. The answers ("redundant", "status updates", "consensus building") set the scene for the cost she describes next: real work pushed to late nights, people running late for family, important issues left untouched, and too little time to grow and retain the best people, who are often the first to leave.
Her answer is not vulnerability exercises or improv games. It is a leadership stance. "But when I say tough love, I mean leaders who are willing to make the hard decisions and willing to take a stand, even when it means saying no. Because when you stay in the driver's seat, the big work gets done." (4:04)
She grounds the talk in the story of a client she calls Sam, who had just reorganized the R&D team of a global biotech. His days were packed with back-to-back meetings, his team kept getting bogged down in details, and people argued for their own solutions while looking to him as a referee. Ilfeld frames her approach around three questions: what's the level, is this problem worth our time together, and what's our process.
Raising the level of the team
The first question draws on adult development research. Ilfeld explains that while our brains stop developing physically around 25, they keep developing cognitively, allowing us to handle more complexity over time. She describes four stages: self-sovereign leaders who see life as a battle, socialized leaders who are strong team players, self-authored leaders who weigh multiple objectives independently, and self-transforming leaders who are comfortable with paradox. Of the self-authored stage she says, "This leader can hold more complexity and options and is always choosing among them to create the biggest chance of success." (10:04)
She brings the stages to life with Sam's team reacting to a proposal for flexible R&D funding: one leader defends his budget, another wants to consult her group, a third asks for clear success criteria, and a fourth seeks a model responsive to both research results and the competitive landscape. A leader's role, she says, is to help people move to the next level by challenging their thinking and widening their perspective, and by tracking participation as well as content. Practical tips include agreeing what is relevant to the topic and keeping a "parking lot" for good points that belong elsewhere.
Is this problem worth our time together?
The second question uses the Cynefin model, which Ilfeld credits to Dave Snowden from his time at IBM. Simple problems have best practices: do A, get B. Complicated problems also have a right answer but involve many steps, like designing a clinical trial. Complex problems, which she says most companies now face, have no guaranteed cause and effect, only patterns and emerging practices. Chaos calls for fast action to restore stability.
With Sam's team, the shift was decisive: "As I worked with Sam and his team, one thing we shifted was taking out all the simple and complicated problems from their valuable team time together." (20:30) That freed the team to debate where to invest research dollars, using their joint experience as a brain trust. A quick audience quiz on hiring, conference booths and product upgrades shows how context changes a problem's category.
The tough love, she warns, is that procedural items feel urgent and satisfying, and colleagues may object when theirs are removed. She recommends a daily 15-minute calendar review to decline unneeded meetings, and knowing each meeting's goals and decisions in advance. "And it's not bad work, but it's not leadership work. As a leader, you have been hired to accomplish something great." (29:08)
Untangling complex problems
For the third question, Ilfeld offers her complex problem solving blueprint, which she nicknames the tangled necklace model. "Solving complex problems is the same thing. If you go right to the middle of it, you often end up with the tangle being tighter and you end up in more confusion." (30:09)
The method starts with a strategic step back to name every element of the problem, which also stops recurring "zombie issues". Teams then tackle a tangle at the edge first. Sam's team began quarterly offsites, agreed ten guiding questions for choosing projects, and tested them in focus groups with stakeholders before monthly CEO meetings. In a second case, an architecture firm facing partner retirements focused first on developing its next leaders; as the speaker cited, a third-party ROI firm measured a 218% return after one year. The final step is often skipped: "Here's tough love where you actually need to create an action plan for what your next iteration is. It's not enough to just talk about it." (36:18)
Paying attention to what matters
Ilfeld closes with her father, a university lawyer who made time for mentoring despite a demanding role, and whose legacy was recognized by former First Lady Michelle Obama. Her point is that checking out in meetings is a signal: "So when you notice yourself consistently checking out in team meetings, it is a big signal that you and your team are not doing the impactful work you need to do." (39:59)
Watch the talk
"Tough Love for Meetings: How Top Leadership Teams Drive More Quickly to What Matters" by Jo Ilfeld, 41 minutes: https://www.womentech.net/video/tough-love-meetings-how-top-leadership-teams-drive-more-quickly-what-matters
About the speaker
Jo Ilfeld, PhD, is CEO and founder of Incite To Leadership, a Bay Area leadership coaching and consulting company that has worked with eBay, the SF Giants, Genentech, Blue Shield of California and Gilead, as well as start-ups and non-profits. She is an executive leadership coach and Forbes.com author, a graduate of Yale College, and holds a PhD in Business from UC Berkeley.
Questions this talk answers
What does tough love mean for leadership meetings?
Which problems belong on a leadership team's agenda?
How can a busy leader free up time from meetings?
How should a team tackle a complex problem?
Why do leaders react so differently to the same proposal?
Drafted with AI from the talk transcript. Editor review pending.
Frameworks and ideas mentioned
Cynefin model
VUCA
Adult development stages (self-sovereign, socialized, self-authored, self-transforming)
Complex problem solving blueprint (tangled necklace model)
Strategic step back
Parking lot
Post-mortem
Cite this talk
Jo Ilfeld. "Tough Love for Meetings: How Top Leadership Teams Drive More Quickly to What Matters." WomenTech Network, 2023. https://www.womentech.net/video/tough-love-meetings-how-top-leadership-teams-drive-more-quickly-what-matters