Lessons learned from Mars and Moon Exploration: diversity, inclusion and gender balance
Maria-Paz Zorzano18:202023
A Mars rover run from home shows what flat, flexible teams do for women
The Curiosity rover takes instructions from Earth every day, decided within hours by scientists spread across the world and working in shifts. When its Participating Scientists program picked people purely on competitive merit, many brilliant women joined. Planetary physicist Maria-Paz Zorzano, who works on NASA and ESA Mars missions, asks why women still thin out at the top of science, and what any organization can copy from this team.
Get three levers and a mission-tested team structure for keeping women rising in STEM
Planetary physicist Maria-Paz Zorzano uses the NASA Mars Science Laboratory mission as a case study for gender balance in STEM. She argues that visibility, objective selection and flexible, flat working structures let women rise, and recommends other scientific and technical institutions adopt them.
“So what I suggest is that we try to promote visibility, objectivity and flexibility as three fundamental areas of work to break this gap.”
“And because it's so competitive and you really want the best, it turns out that at the end, naturally, we ended up having many brilliant women in the program.”
What you will learn
Trace where women drop out of STEM, from early schooling through PhD, postdoc and professorship.
Apply visibility, objectivity and flexibility as three levers for closing gender gaps.
Make selection and promotion decisions objective enough to explain openly to outsiders.
Design shared, shift-based responsibilities and online collaboration so careers fit around family, teaching and supervision.
Replace hidden, top-down decision making with flat, competitive structures that reward merit.
Key takeaways from the speaker
gender balance
digital nomad
excellence, diversity and inclusion
STEM
space exploration
Details
Level
All levels
Format
Talk
Technical depth
Non-technical
For
People manager, Executive, Senior individual contributor
Length
18:20
Published
June 2023
Questions this talk answers
Why do gender gaps in STEM appear so early?
Citing UNESCO's Cracking the Code, the speaker says the gaps come not from different aptitudes but from different stereotypes and expectations of what girls can do.
Where in a research career does the gender gap widen?
In the European Union, women are near 50% at the start of science studies, but the gap opens through PhD, postdoc and teaching until only one in four or five top positions go to women.
What can organizations do to change these trends?
She proposes three levers: visibility for women and diverse role models, objectivity to counter unconscious bias in decisions, and flexibility for work-life balance.
Why did the Mars Science Laboratory team end up with many women?
Participating Scientists were selected competitively and objectively, and responsibilities were shared in shifts online, so people could keep other commitments while gaining recognition for their work.
What structure does she recommend for other technical institutions?
A flat, competitive and flexible structure where decisions are discussed openly and people are promoted on merit rather than gender, race or age.
About this talk
The number of female students enrolled STEM have been decreasing in the last twenty years, while the number of women resigning from technological job positions remains unacceptably high. New multi-factor approaches are being suggested to fight this trend, such as promoting interaction with professional women working in STEM environments and increasing the visibility of female role models. The NASA Mars Science Laboratory rover mission operation, with its flat and rotating working structure, is a practical case where some of these factors are already in place. Given the popularity of space exploration an adequate representation of female scientists and engineers in this field at all levels,
from initial educational and training programs to managing decisions, this field could be used to illustrate to the public how gender balance is achievable even in this very specialized, competitive, subject. Furthermore, by setting role models, this can awake the interest of girls in STEM disciplines from childhood and, therefore, contribute positively to the fourth (quality education) 2030 sustainable development goals.
From MSL operation we have learned that when a challenging task requires the added effort of multiple, top-quality talents, these need to be selected without biases, as any discrimination would imply a loss of potential talents. This selection approach, based exclusively on excellence, contributes to promoting gender diversity. Another key factor is flexibility of the working process, for instance space mission operations, are nowadays implemented online, allowing for the cooperation of people in multiple time zones, with varying schedules and roles. The main lesson learned from MSL operation is that flat competitive, flexible, structures give opportunities for women to rise to the level where this system is implemented, but this should be reinforced to allow women to get through the next ranks. This may be applicable in other fields now that blended work (a combination of remote and physically present work) is becoming a universal need.
Visibility, objectivity and flexibility: three levers (54 s)
How competitive selection brought women onto a Mars rover team (46 s)
Shared shifts so nobody has to be irreplaceable (43 s)
Speaker: Good afternoon, everyone. Thank you for joining us today here. I want to share with you some of my experience in promoting gender balance and what kind of experiences I've seen in science and technology that happen to work efficiently. I'm focusing here today on one particular example, the one that I'm more familiarized with. It comes from the area of space space.
I'm a planetary physicist and a scientist by training. What I do for a living is that I explore Mars using robotic missions like those that are developed by NASA or the European Space Agency. This is basically an area of research where we work together physicists, engineers, chemists, biologists, mathematicians, informaticians. You can think of all the fields that are traditionally described as STEM, that means science, technology, engineering, and mathematics. What I think is very important for us is to be aware that we have responsibilities to contribute somehow to a better world in whatever position we have, in particular when we are researchers. There is, of course, an expectation that we give something back to society. There are two topics where I think we can contribute positively. One of them is
regarding the United Nations, regarding the United Nations Sustainable Development Goal Number 4, which is education. And the other one is gender equality. And I'm going to give here a few examples of how we can promote that. You may be aware that according to the UNESCO, Cracking the Code, girls and women's education in science, technology, engineering, and mathematics. It has been demonstrated that gender differences in STEM education already start at the very early years. And the reason why this happens is not because female girls, girls have different qualities or aptitudes. It's because they are different.
There are different stereotypes and there are different expectations of what they can do. So in order to bring this talent, female talent to STEM disciplines, we need to give visibility to give examples and to make it more accessible and more appealing in the early years of their education. But this problem also continues all the way through the professional track. And statistics in this case from the US show us that whereas you can find almost 50% of females in topics of biology, when you talk about chemists or mathematics or engineering or physics, then this percentage is very rapidly reduced. In spite of the examples that we have had of female researchers in the past who have had spectacular contributions, and it turns out. It turns out that we are not aware of professionals, how they contributed and therefore these role models don't exist in our minds.
The fact is that only 35% of STEM students in higher education globally are women. And when I say globally, this is an average. So it means that there are many countries where the situation for women and their access to university is even harder. We can only change things by setting examples in those institutions and countries that can afford to make this effort.
When it comes to research, only 30% of the world's average population are females. And then the reason behind this is always attributed to be the stereotypes, the stereotypes that are portrayed in the media, in the movies, in journalism, and these are assimilated by adults also. And they're perpetrated through every decision that we make. So not only we need to attract the female talent to science and technology, but also we need to make sure that they are retained, that they are safe conditions for female workers to continue their full path.
So, I want to bring to your attention here some of the analysis done in this research program. It's a study that is regularly maintained at the European Union. The European Union. It's called the SHE figures, and it's updated regularly. And here we can see, for instance, that even though about 48% of women in research are of researchers are females, when you look at technical paths of research and academia, only 24% are covered by females. And when you look at the higher rank positions in research and the decision making positions, they're only covered by maybe one every four or one every five by females. And in return, this is going to perpetuate the situation for many years. So we have to change that.
I like this kind of graphs where you see the evolution from the early stages of studies in the university. When we have access to science studies, we are almost represented at 50%. This is again for the European Union. However, as you continue your training. However, as you continue your training and you go through PhD and postdoc, and then the early stages of teaching or international collaborations, then this gap is opening up until the moment where you get to the moment where you get to the highest position, which could be a professorship in the university, where generally you tend to have only one every five or every four given to females.
So how can we change these trends? If you compare consecutive periods of years, as the ones that are shown here, there is a slight tendency for things to change. Some activities that are being implemented, apparently they are effective. There are three major blocks where I think we can act. In my opinion, as I mentioned, the first one is breaking the stereotypes, providing visibility to females that are working in every kind of level of the spectrum, but also breaking stereotypes about any other thing like age stereotypes. Do you have an expectation of what is the age of a professor?
Or do you have an expectation of what is the age where you should start doing the PhD? And the same for race and economical level and country of origin and so on. Then we have to be very active breaking the unconscious biases that we all have. Whenever we are making a decision, who are we giving funding to? Who are we promoting for this position? Who are we giving the responsibility to supervise somebody else?
We tend to have biases that come from many years of working the same way. We expect to have a kind of candidate there. So we have to be always fair when we take the decision. We're ready to be ready to be extremely objective to share the ideas that made us take the decision openly. And that way we're going to break this this sick trend.
And finally, of course, even if you promote females and you give visibility to them, there is a possibility that females decide not to continue in this career because there is it's very difficult to maintain balance between work and life. And this affects not only women, but also obviously men and not even people that have family. You may be single and you may want to have a healthy balance between your work and life.
And nowadays, there are ways of using computers and teleworking and networking to promote this. So what I suggest is that we try to promote visibility, objectivity and flexibility as three fundamental areas of work to break this gap. I'm going to give a few examples. I'm going to give a few examples. Here we have the Artemis crew that has been selected for the next NASA mission to the moon.
And you already see how we are breaking a stereotype. We're giving examples to the society of different people that are clearly heroes to our mind. They're brilliant, they're successful, and they represent a different spectrum of society. And this has been done already in the International Space Station. This is an international cooperation program between NASA, the European Space Agency, Canadian Space Agency, Japanese and Russian Space Agency.
And regularly, we see astronauts here, and some of them also have covered leading positions like Samantha Cusoforetti, who has been the commander of the International Space Station. And then here I'm giving another example of how to break stereotypes. So now we have the Chinese experimental space station. And again, we have a female astronaut, and she's communicating from orbit with Earth.
She's sharing videos of science. And this is something that we are well aware of now that astronauts, besides being super clever, intelligent, having many studies and languages, and we physically fit. They are also extremely good at communicating. They are ambassadors for science and technology, and they have a lot of responsibility in breaking these kind of stereotypes, and also in promoting interest in society.
So we can, by no doubt, we think of an astronaut, we think that it's a hero that is well prepared, is extremely brilliant, and obviously they must have been selected objectively. So we think that in this case, visibility and objectivity manage to give a team where there is a balance. So maybe this is not the most common example for a job career, because there are very few profiles, and because it's not the best one to have in parallel with a personal life on Earth.
But I want to give a few other examples of the way we're doing this in space exploration. So not only you can explore when you're an astronaut, but you can also do it from your home using your computer when you're using robots. So if the rover is exploring the surface of Mars, this rover is communicating with Earth on a daily basis.
And here I'm giving examples from the Mars Science Laboratory, the Curiosity rover, but it works the same for the Perseverance rover that is also working right now on Mars. These platforms have to communicate on a daily basis with Earth, sending data back to Earth and receiving instructions from Earth. And when these decisions are made on Earth, they have to be done with themes that are distributed all over the world.
And they have to decide this within a few hours and in a cohesive way, arguing, why do I recommend to do this or that? Now, in the case of Curiosity, I know for a fact that this has been working successfully for already 11 years. It has been in operation on Mars. And when you put together brilliant people with a good attitude, with a good spirit, and you're using this kind of teleconferences, networking infrastructures, then things can run very smoothly.
And finally, the goal of this community is to make sure that you get the best out of the rover and you produce the best science, and you document this in scientific articles. I'm sharing here some statistics, some analysis that I've done on the population and the gender distribution of the community of the Mars Science Laboratory. And if you start from top and go down, as you can see at the beginning of the mission, when the mission was proposed prior to being designed and built and launched, most of the critical roles were covered by mail.
And this is what happens always in science, that leadership positions are generally covered by mail, and they are the ones that are getting the funding and the support from their institutions. Now, as the mission was built and more investigators were joining the team, and especially once it landed, there was a program called Participate in Scientists that allows for scientists to apply to be part of the team for a couple of years.
And this is a competitive program, and you have to say, I'm going to do this science, if you allow me to join the team, I'm going to use this data and I'm going to produce these papers. And because it's so competitive and you really want the best, it turns out that at the end, naturally, we ended up having many brilliant women in the program.
And this is a graph that I'm not going to explain in detail unless you have questions about it, but it shows the evolution over the years of the percentage of female participation in planetary exploration and in particular in the case of the Mars Science Laboratory. And I'm comparing the blue line, which is based on the data that we have and where we are right now with the red line that it's what it tells you how many PhD students at the academic level have the training that could allow them to join the mission.
So there is always a shift between the people that are actually ready to join and the ones that really join. There's always this trend to have less women that we should, but the gap is going to be broken. So in summary, what I've seen that I think to me were the keys of success of this mission is that a participating sorry participating scientists are always competitively selected and this decision was done in a organic way by the network and the reasons why you choose somebody.
There might be that must be objective and you have to be able to present them to other people external to the program. The people that join the team have responsibilities that are shared so you don't have to commit to be like five years leading this and you're the only one I cannot get sick and I cannot have a leave to take care of my kids.
You're going to be doing this in shifts, you're going to distribute or have a share of responsibility, but I'm always going to be accountable for my own ideas. I'm going to have visibility if I perform well, I'm going to be recognized for that. And what this means is that at the end, this is going to allow me independent of my gender to build my CV and to apply for other things beyond this, this mission.
So these are my recommendations for other institutions, basically for scientific, technical institutions and technical programs. I think we have learned that if you really have to do something that is extremely challenging, you want to have the best people in the team. You cannot afford to lose talent and you're going to focus. Your decision is just going to be focused on the qualities of the people, not on their gender or the race or the age.
And if you have the selection approach based exclusively on excellence, then at the end, what you're going to end up doing is that you're going to give an example of diversity and inclusion and you're going to promote people through the career path, allowing them to have more chances. So a key factor, at least to me, was the flexibility in the group, because if you're going to commit to 10 years program, I want to make sure that this is not going to be observant, that I can keep some of the things in parallel.
Maybe I have to teach, maybe I have to supervise my other student, or as I said, maybe I have to, I may need some time to dedicate to my family. And also it's very important, this networking idea that things are discussed openly and there is a flat structure. We have this pyramid structure where things are decided at the top in a hidden way.
You don't have to be accountable for the decisions. Then we're going to perpetuate these mistakes of the past. So my recommendations make a flat, competitive and flexible structure so that you give rise to the best, not only women, but to the best candidates to promote based on their merits and their work. If you take these advices and you implement it in other fields, then I think we're going to feel this is a contagious, positive effect on other areas.
And again, we have this responsibility in the case of research, because we are the avant garde of knowledge, we are the ones that we have to change the trends. But in general, if we are working in countries that have a well established educational system, a safe working environment, I think that we also can hope that we can give example to other countries where these things are not guaranteed.
And by that I would like to stress once again, this is my take home message for you. I would like you to encourage to provide visibility to all kinds of roles. Okay. Not only female roles to be objective in your decisions and make sure that you can share them openly, that you would be ready to go to confront the scrutiny of people from outside and to implement working policies that are flexible.
And that way I can guarantee that you're going to get the best of your team. So thank you very much. And if you have any questions, I'm happy to answer them. Thank you. Thank you all. And have a nice afternoon or nice day. wherever you are. Take care. Bye.
Transcribed automatically; names checked against the speaker record. Select a time to jump there.
Article based on this talk
What Mars rover teams teach about keeping women in STEM
Planetary physicist Maria-Paz Zorzano shows how objective selection and flexible, flat teams on the Curiosity mission let women rise, and why other institutions should copy them.
In short
Women are close to parity when they start science studies, yet they thin out at every step toward senior research roles. Maria-Paz Zorzano, a planetary physicist at Spain's National Institute of Aerospace Technology, argues that three levers (visibility, objectivity and flexibility) can reverse that trend. Her evidence is the NASA Mars Science Laboratory mission, where competitive, open selection and shift-based online work brought many brilliant women into the team.
Key takeaways
Gender balance
Digital nomad
Excellence, diversity and inclusion
STEM
Space exploration
Where the numbers break down
Zorzano opens by framing research as a responsibility to society, tied to two United Nations goals: quality education and gender equality. As the speaker cited, UNESCO's report Cracking the Code shows that gender differences in STEM education start in the very early years, driven not by different aptitudes but by stereotypes and expectations of what girls can do.
The gap follows women into their careers. She notes, as the speaker cited, that only 35% of STEM students in higher education globally are women and that only about 30% of the world's researchers are female. Attracting talent is only half the job:
"So not only we need to attract the female talent to science and technology, but also we need to make sure that they are retained, that they are safe conditions for female workers to continue their full path." (3:33)
Using the European Union's She Figures, she shows a pattern many viewers will recognise. Women are represented at almost 50% at the start of university science, but the gap opens through PhD, postdoc and early teaching, until only one in four or one in five professorships goes to a woman. She warns that this imbalance at the top keeps itself going for years.
Three levers: visibility, objectivity and flexibility
Zorzano's answer is a short framework. The first lever is breaking stereotypes by making women visible at every level, and by questioning other assumptions too, such as the expected age of a professor or a PhD student. The second is tackling the unconscious biases behind decisions about funding, promotion and supervision:
"So we have to be always fair when we take the decision." (6:52)
For her, fairness means being ready to share openly the reasons behind a decision. The third lever is flexibility, because even well-supported women may leave if work and life cannot be balanced, a need she says applies equally to men and to people without families.
"So what I suggest is that we try to promote visibility, objectivity and flexibility as three fundamental areas of work to break this gap." (7:45)
Role models in orbit
Astronauts show visibility and objectivity at work. Zorzano points to the crew selected for NASA's Artemis mission to the Moon, to Samantha Cristoforetti's command of the International Space Station, and to a female astronaut sharing science videos from the Chinese space station.
"They're brilliant, they're successful, and they represent a different spectrum of society." (8:12)
Because the public assumes astronauts are chosen objectively, a balanced crew sends a strong signal. She admits, though, that astronaut careers are rare and hard to combine with personal life on Earth, so she turns to a more ordinary model of space work.
Exploring Mars from a laptop
The Curiosity and Perseverance rovers exchange data and instructions with Earth every day. Teams spread around the world must agree within a few hours on what the rover does next, arguing their recommendations over teleconferences and networked tools.
"Now, in the case of Curiosity, I know for a fact that this has been working successfully for already 11 years." (10:47)
Zorzano's own analysis of the mission's gender distribution shows that when the mission was proposed, most critical roles were held by men, as is typical in science. That changed once the Participating Scientists program opened competitive places for researchers to join for a few years:
"And because it's so competitive and you really want the best, it turns out that at the end, naturally, we ended up having many brilliant women in the program." (12:18)
She still sees a lag between the share of women qualified to join and the share who actually do, but she expects that gap to close.
Flat, competitive and flexible
Zorzano lists what made the mission work. Selection was competitive, and the reasons for choosing someone had to be objective enough to present to outsiders. Responsibilities were shared in shifts, so nobody had to be the only person who could never be sick or take leave to care for children. Each person stayed accountable for their own ideas and got credit for good work:
"I'm going to have visibility if I perform well, I'm going to be recognized for that." (14:01)
That recognition, she says, lets people build their CVs regardless of gender. Her recommendation for scientific and technical institutions is to drop hidden, pyramid-style decision making, which repeats the mistakes of the past, and adopt the mission's model instead:
"So my recommendations make a flat, competitive and flexible structure so that you give rise to the best, not only women, but to the best candidates to promote based on their merits and their work." (15:43)
She closes by urging viewers to give visibility to all kinds of roles, to make decisions that can withstand outside scrutiny and to adopt flexible working policies, which she believes will spread to other fields now that blended work is becoming common.
Watch the talk
Lessons learned from Mars and Moon Exploration: diversity, inclusion and gender balance, by Maria-Paz Zorzano (18 minutes): https://www.womentech.net/video/lessons-learned-mars-and-moon-exploration-diversity-inclusion-and-gender-balance
About the speaker
Dr. Maria-Paz Zorzano is a Scientist and Civil Servant at the National Institute of Aerospace Technology (INTA) in Spain, working at the Center for Astrobiology, and a planetary physicist who has taken part in several NASA and ESA Mars missions, including the Curiosity and Perseverance rovers. She is the author of more than 150 peer-reviewed publications and of a research paper on gender balance in Mars exploration drawn from the Mars Science Laboratory.
Questions this talk answers
Why do gender gaps in STEM appear so early?
Where in a research career does the gender gap widen?
What can organizations do to change these trends?
Why did the Mars Science Laboratory team end up with many women?
What structure does she recommend for other technical institutions?
Drafted with AI from the talk transcript. Editor review pending.
Frameworks and ideas mentioned
Visibility, objectivity and flexibility
UN Sustainable Development Goals
Participating Scientists program
Resources mentioned
UNESCO, Cracking the Code: girls' and women's education in STEM
She Figures (European Union)
Cite this talk
Maria-Paz Zorzano. "Lessons learned from Mars and Moon Exploration: diversity, inclusion and gender balance." WomenTech Network, 2023. https://www.womentech.net/video/lessons-learned-mars-and-moon-exploration-diversity-inclusion-and-gender-balance