Cushioning criticism between compliments can leave it unnoticed
In her trainings, 12 or 13 people out of 20 admit they find improvement feedback hard to give, and habits make it worse: blaming, vague judgments, or tucking criticism between compliments where it may go unnoticed. Navneetha Lokanathan, a leadership and communication trainer who spent eight years as a software developer and team lead, tackles a scenario with a teammate who keeps breaking commitments. What changes when feedback starts from your feelings and needs?
Learn the four NVC steps for framing tough feedback colleagues can hear without getting defensive
Navneetha Lokanathan, a leadership and communication trainer, teaches how to give difficult feedback using Nonviolent Communication (NVC). She covers common feedback mistakes, then the four NVC steps of observation, feelings, needs and requests, and has participants rewrite feedback for a team member who misses commitments.
“So anything that makes the other person feel fearful, shameful, or guilt is considered as violent, right?”
“So the needs are the underlying factors of feelings.”
What you will learn
Spot common feedback mistakes such as blaming, vague judgments and the feedback sandwich that hides the message.
Separate factual observations from evaluations when describing a problem.
Express feelings with I statements and connect them to the unmet needs behind them.
Frame requests as one clear, positive, concrete action the other person can take.
Rewrite a real piece of difficult feedback using the four-step NVC template.
Key takeaways from the speaker
Common mistakes in giving feedback when we are emotional
Understanding principles of NVC
Practical & effective ways of framing the feedback
Details
Level
Intermediate
Format
Talk
Technical depth
Non-technical
For
Early career, Mid-career, People manager
Length
18:40
Published
June 2023
Questions this talk answers
What are the most common mistakes people make when giving feedback?
Blaming, saying too much, giving the wrong type of feedback for the person's experience, failing to make it actionable, phrasing it as judgment, being too general and targeting the person instead of the behavior. She also flags the 'pillow issue', where criticism cushioned between positives may go unnoticed.
What counts as violent communication in NVC?
Anything that makes the other person feel fearful, shameful or guilty. NVC instead speaks from your own feelings and needs, so the other person is less likely to become defensive.
What are the four steps of Nonviolent Communication?
Observe the facts, identify your feelings, identify the associated unmet needs, and make a request for a specific action.
How do you observe without evaluating?
State what actually happened rather than your opinion. Instead of saying someone is always late to meetings, say they have come late to the last three meetings.
Why do requests need to be specific and positive?
A string of 'don'ts' leaves people unsure what to do, and vague asks backfire. In her example, a wife asked her husband to spend less time at work and he signed up for golf, when she wanted time with him.
About this talk
Communication is everything. Especially as we grow in our career ladder, our ability to give difficult feedback, have those difficult conversation with our peers and supervisors with ease make us stand out from others. To get our difficult conversations right, this session uses techniques from Non-Violent Communication(NVC). The session is focuses on common mistakes made in giving feedback when we are emotional, core components of NVC, implementation of the principles with hands on activities in giving difficult feedback.
The golf course story: vague requests backfire (55 s)
So yes, I welcome you all to this session, becoming an expert in giving feedback. Good morning. Good afternoon. Good evening from wherever you are connecting. So tell me how many of you find it difficult to give feedback, especially when it comes to giving feedback that needs some improvement in others performance or some change in their behavior. How many of you find it difficult to give such sort of feedback? Can you see it in the chat? Yeah.
In the trainings that I conduct, you know what, when I ask this question, people say out of like 20 people, almost 12 to 13 people say that I find it difficult to give feedback. And that is almost more than 50 percentage, right? So let's get practical now. And let me give you a situation. And can you write a feedback? Let's see how it turns out. Are you in for that?
Yeah, Elaine, I hear you. Okay, so let me give you a situation. So the situation is, let's assume you are the team lead. You are the team lead and one of your team members doesn't, you know, doesn't hold on to the commitments he had made. Okay. And this is affecting you and the team. Let's see how will you give feedback for this particular person for this particular scenario.
All right. So let's take a couple of minutes to write the feedback. Once you're done, you can put your feedback in the chat box. Let's see. Giving feedback can be worse. Sarah, yes. But with right techniques, it can, it need not be worse. Okay, your time starts now to write the feedback. So if you want to know the situation again, for people who have joined just now, you are the team lead, and one of your team members doesn't stick to the commitments he has made when it comes to group work.
And it is affecting you and it is affecting you and the team. And how will you give the feedback in this scenario? Write down your feedback and paste it in the chat. Uh-huh. I got it, Selena. Come on, keep it going. Could you prioritized? Try to prioritize. Okay. Anybody else? Like, what feedback have you returned? Please put it in the chat box so that all of us can learn together.
Yeah. I hope we have. Yes. Yes, yes, yes. Keep it coming in. And you're all right, you know, when we say it is difficult to give feedback. Why? Because feedback can make or break a relationship with a team member or a colleague, right? When managed effectively, feedback can bring that high talent, bring that high potential into the workplace.
It can lead to high collaboration. So what are some of the mistakes we make when giving feedback? Let me share my screen with you now. What do you think are some of the mistakes we make in giving feedback? Can I see some of your answers in the chat box? Blaming people exactly what? What else? What are the common mistakes we make in giving feedback?
Yes, absolutely, Sarah. And telling people they are responsible for our feelings, right? Not giving enough praise. Yes. If you have any questions, you can put it in the Q&A box available and we will take it up at the end of this session. So I see some hands raised. you can put it in the Q&A box. Being either too bland or too soft.
Yes, yes, yes. You're all there. So these are some of the common mistakes we make. There are plenty, plentiful mistakes. But to cut short, like, you know, if we have to rate the mistakes that we make in feedback, these are some of the things that stand out. Blaming, right? You did this. Because of you, it got worse, right?
And saying too much. Wrong type of feedback. Sometimes, you know, the fresher, for the fresher, you have just joined in. If you gave him continuously improvements, he would go frustrated, right? So you would have to give some praise over there for a fresher. But for an experienced person, they might be looking for points to improve. So if we are giving a wrong type of feedback, then it is not going to serve the purpose of giving feedback.
And failure to give actionable feedback. What does the other person has to do? Right? And pausing it as judgments, lack of specificity, being too generalized. Feedback on someone instead of their behavior, right? And the pillow issue. What is this pillow issue? Sometimes, we know, right? Like, when we give feedback, we give a positive and negative and a positive, Like a sandwich.
And they say it is a pillow issue because it is like cushioned. The negative, whatever area of improvement is cushioned between the positives. And the thing here is sometimes that may, that may not get noticed by the recipient, right? So these are some of the common mistakes in giving feedback. Okay. I have come across many different ways of giving feedback and most of them are like transactional, There is no human involved in it.
So when it is transactional, what happens is we don't consider how the other person feels when we give this feedback, right? And we don't even consider our own feelings, how we feel when something happens, But to eliminate all these mistakes where in giving feedback, there comes this nonviolent communication, which is what we are going to see in this session.
So anything that makes the other person feel fearful, shameful, or guilt is considered as violent, right? It is considered as violent communication. This nonviolent communication was introduced by Dr. Marshall and he says like, we should not make the other person fearful, shameful, or guiltful when we communicate, right? So nonviolent communication is like, do you know, it is inclusive with empathy, inclusive of our feelings as well our needs, along with considering the other person's needs and wants.
Okay. And NVC is about you and not the other person because we have some unmet needs and that, that is what we expect from the other person. So in NVC method of giving feedback, we are not going to say to the other person that you have done this. Yeah. You have made me feel, you have made me feel bad and you have to change your behavior.
We are not going to blame the other person, but rather we are going to come from our side. So it is not at all about the other person. It is about us, our feelings and our emotions. And when we express in that way, what happens is we, the other person will not become defensive, rather he will listen to what we are saying.
All right. So NVC has four particular steps. Observe, identify your feelings, identify associated needs and request. Okay. Observe is, you will state that factual observations that is affecting you. What is the actual factual situation that is happening? That is what is observed. And what are the feelings associated with yourself? What are the needs, unmet needs? And what is the request?
What do you want the other person to do? All right. So four components in NVC, which are observe and feelings, identifying your feelings, identifying the needs and request. So when it comes to observe, often we confuse it with our evaluation and judgment. Okay. So observe without evaluation, right? How can we do that? How can we observe without evaluating?
Say, for example, saying that my father is a good man is evaluating, right? It is your opinion that he is a good man. But what is the actual thing that has happened? My father has donated $1 million to charity. That is the actual thing that has happened. So this is what observation is. Instead of saying you are always late to meeting, that is your opinion.
But that is not the fact, right? The fact is last three times, the person has come late to the meeting. All right. So when you are giving feedback in any situation, observe and factual statements. Okay. And withdrawing from your evaluations and from giving your own opinions. All right. And the next is feelings. Feelings give us a lot of information about ourselves, right?
Why we feel a certain way. And it is very important to have an emotional audit. What we feel at any particular time, correct? Because feeling tells us like what we like, what we don't like, what we like to have, all that we come to know about feelings. And once you have an emotional audit of what you're feeling, what is that that is affecting you?
Yeah. And what feel it is, what, what is that it is making you feel when you say that? Express it. Correct? It is, feeling is one of the most important components of nonviolent communication. Let us see. See, you irritate me when you leave company documents on the conference room floor. Here, it is wrong because you irritate me.
I'm blaming the other person. Correct? But when you say I am irritated when you leave company documents on the conference room floor, the other person don't have anything to take it down in a defensive way. Rather, they will listen to you. Correct? So one tip when you are expressing your feelings is using the I statements. You see, I am irritated instead of telling you irritate me.
And needs. How are these feelings and needs are connected? Because feelings are the mirror, that says that are there any unmet needs? Okay? If your needs are, all of your needs are met, you will be happy. Correct? If your, some of your needs are not met, you will be, you will be angry, frustrated. Correct? So the needs are the underlying factors of feelings.
So identify what are your underlying needs and express it. Because when you express your needs, most often we have a better chance of getting them met. Okay? See, in this example of leaving company documents on the conference room floor, when we add our needs to it, the other person understands why we say so. Right? because I want our documents to be safely stored and accessible.
Okay? So we saw observe without evaluation, feeling and needs. Be clear about your needs. And finally, request. Identify one actionable item that the other person wants to do, that you want the other person to do. Okay? And request it in clear, positive, concrete action language. When you say, don't do this, people will not, that is not a positive language.
Don't spread company documents on the conference room floor. Like, they don't know why this lady is always like, don't, Yeah? But when you say, could you place the company documents in the locker room? It is very specific. Tell them specifically what action item you want the other person to do. Right? So, nonviolent communication is observe, state the factual observations that is affecting you.
Do not evaluate. Again, I'm using here, but that is a wrong. You have to give it a positive statement as we saw in the request space. And identify your feelings. What are the, what are your feelings associated with it? And identifying what are the needs underlying with it? And what is the request? What is that you want the other person to do?
So with this template, now I invite you to go back and change your feedback for the situation we saw early, earlier. How would you change it? Can I see it in the chat box? If you have to say your observation, your feelings, associated needs and requests. When you say it in this template, what happens is the other person is not blamed.
The other person is not judged. Rather, it invites for understanding, which is what we need in today's working environment. Right? So if you have to change it, how would you change your feedback? Exactly, Sarah, needs are often related to your core values. Thank you. So I'm looking for the changed feedback. Meanwhile, we have four more minutes for this session to get over.
If you have any questions, you can type it in the Q&A box. The floor is open for questions. Thank you, Hamida. So when we are making requests, we need to be clear. What is it we really want? Yeah, there was an, you know, there was a story, a husband and wife were there and that his husband was spending too much of time at his workplace.
So the wife went and told him like, don't spend too much work, too much time at your workplace. Yeah. So what happened? This husband, after two, three weeks, he come and told me, see, I have signed up for the golf course, but actually the wife wanted him to spend the time with her. Right? Since she did not mention what is that she wants specifically, this is what will happen.
Yes. I noticed that we are in getting everything done on time as the team. Could you make sure? Your part in the project is done by end of the week. we are getting there. Yes. Well, I feel stressed when the team deadlines are not met. Please share your timelines with your team so that we could address the workload.
Do you have any questions or any thoughts to say about what we have just discussed? You can type it in the chat box as well. So here, the challenges could be two things. Right? When we have our feelings, we may forget to be in touch with our feelings anytime. So that is one challenge. And another challenge is we may not know, clearly know what we need.
So if we can work on this, it would be much, much better when we give our feedback to our colleagues rather than blaming them. Yes. So thank you everyone for the wonderful participation in, through the chat box. And how do you feel where for your first feedback and this feedback when you have changed it? Yeah. Love it.
We all would want to receive such a feedback where nobody blames us, right? But just points what has to be correct. Isn't it? So thank you. Thank you for your participation. And yes, love it. I don't feel defensive at all. That is the beauty of NVC. And thanks a lot for your participation in this session. Thank you.
Maya, wish you good luck in delivering that difficult feedback. The session will be ending now. Thanks a lot for your participation.
Transcribed automatically; names checked against the speaker record. Select a time to jump there.
Article based on this talk
How do you give difficult feedback without making people defensive?
Navneetha Lokanathan shows how Nonviolent Communication turns blame into a clear, factual request that colleagues can actually hear.
In short
Difficult feedback goes wrong when it blames, judges or hides the real message, argues leadership and communication trainer Navneetha Lokanathan. Her answer is Nonviolent Communication (NVC): state a factual observation, name your own feeling, connect it to an unmet need and make one clear, positive request. Framed this way, feedback invites understanding instead of defensiveness.
Key takeaways
Common mistakes in giving feedback when we are emotional
Understanding the principles of NVC
Practical and effective ways of framing feedback
Why feedback so often misfires
Lokanathan opens with a simple question: who finds it hard to give feedback that asks for better performance or a change in behavior? In her own trainings, she says, roughly 12 or 13 people out of 20 admit they do. She then sets a practical exercise. Participants imagine they are a team lead whose team member does not keep the commitments he makes on group work, and they write the feedback they would give.
The stakes, she explains, are high: "Because feedback can make or break a relationship with a team member or a colleague, right?" (3:15). Handled well, feedback can bring out high potential and lead to strong collaboration.
With the audience, she builds a list of common mistakes: blaming ("because of you, it got worse"), saying too much, giving the wrong type of feedback (a newcomer needs some praise, while an experienced person may want points to improve), failing to make feedback actionable, phrasing it as judgment, being too general, and commenting on the person rather than the behavior. She also names the "pillow issue", better known as the feedback sandwich, where an area for improvement is cushioned between two positives and may never be noticed by the recipient. Underneath many of these errors, she says, is feedback that is purely transactional, with no attention to how either person feels.
What makes communication "violent"
To remove those mistakes, Lokanathan turns to Nonviolent Communication, which she credits, as the speaker cited, to Dr. Marshall. Her definition is direct: "So anything that makes the other person feel fearful, shameful, or guilt is considered as violent, right?" (7:15).
NVC, she explains, is inclusive of empathy, of our own feelings and needs, and of the other person's needs and wants. Crucially, it starts from the speaker's side. Instead of telling someone what they did wrong and how they made you feel, you describe your own experience. When feedback is expressed that way, she says, the other person does not become defensive and is more likely to listen.
Observe the facts, then own your feelings
The four steps are observe, identify your feelings, identify the associated needs, and request. The first step is harder than it sounds because people confuse observation with evaluation. Saying "my father is a good man" is an opinion; saying he donated money to charity is an observation. The workplace version: "But that is not the fact, right? The fact is last three times, the person has come late to the meeting." (10:19).
Next come feelings. Lokanathan recommends an "emotional audit" to notice what you are feeling and what is causing it, because feelings reveal what we like and what we do not. She contrasts "you irritate me when you leave company documents on the conference room floor" with "I am irritated when you leave company documents on the conference room floor". Her tip: "So one tip when you are expressing your feelings is using the I statements. You see, I am irritated instead of telling you irritate me." (11:38).
Name the need, then make a clear request
Feelings, she says, are a mirror for needs. When needs are met we feel content; when they are not, we feel angry or frustrated. "So the needs are the underlying factors of feelings." (12:03). Expressing the need helps the other person understand why you are raising the issue, as in wanting company documents to be safely stored and accessible.
The final step is a request for one actionable item, in clear, positive, concrete language. A stream of "don't do this" leaves people confused about what is wanted. "Could you place the company documents in the locker room?" works better because it is specific. As she puts it: "Tell them specifically what action item you want the other person to do." (13:28). She illustrates the cost of vague requests with a story of a wife who asked her husband not to spend so much time at work; weeks later he announced he had signed up for golf, when what she wanted was time with him.
Rewriting the feedback with the template
Lokanathan then asks participants to rewrite their original feedback using the four steps. One rewrite she reads from the chat expresses stress when team deadlines are not met and asks: "Please share your timelines with your team so that we could address the workload." (16:13). The point of the template, she says, is that "The other person is not judged. Rather, it invites for understanding, which is what we need in today's working environment." (14:51).
She closes with two challenges to watch for: losing touch with your own feelings in the moment, and not knowing clearly what you need. Working on both, she argues, makes feedback far more effective than blame. One participant's reaction to the reworked feedback sums up the result: they did not feel defensive at all.
Watch the talk
"Become an expert in giving difficult feedback" by Navneetha Lokanathan, about 19 minutes: https://www.womentech.net/video/become-expert-in-giving-difficult-feedback
About the speaker
Navneetha Lokanathan is a Leadership & Communication Trainer & Assertiveness Coach based in London, certified as a life coach and NLP practitioner, who has trained more than 800 people in four years. Before moving into training and coaching, she worked in IT for eight years as a software developer and team lead in multinational companies across India, the US and Dubai.
Questions this talk answers
What are the most common mistakes people make when giving feedback?
What counts as violent communication in NVC?
What are the four steps of Nonviolent Communication?
How do you observe without evaluating?
Why do requests need to be specific and positive?
Drafted with AI from the talk transcript. Editor review pending.
Frameworks and ideas mentioned
Nonviolent Communication (NVC)
Feedback sandwich
I statements
Cite this talk
Navneetha Lokanathan. "Become an expert in giving difficult feedback." WomenTech Network, 2023. https://www.womentech.net/video/become-expert-in-giving-difficult-feedback