Why a boss she disliked counts as one of her two formative mentors
As a young girl in her banker father's office in South Africa, she saw only men in suits and wondered where all the women were. Estelle Roux-Stevens, a career development strategist nominated for a 2017 Woman in Tech award, argues that the people you meet shape success more than money does. So which kind of mentor do you actually need, and what can the wrong role model teach you?
Learn to tell mentors from coaches and pick the peer, career or life mentor you need now
Estelle Roux-Stevens, career development strategist and mentor at Eva Connections, argues that mentoring is the most powerful professional development tool and that success comes from the people you meet. She separates mentoring from coaching, outlines three types of mentors (peer, career and life), and shares two women who shaped her own career, including a "de-mentor" who showed her who not to become.
“And you cannot be where you cannot see.”
“But I'm really successful because of the type of people that I have met along my way. And to me, success is achieving what I value.”
What you will learn
Distinguish mentoring from coaching and choose a coach for direction and a mentor for a specific skill set.
Identify whether a peer, career or life mentor fits your current career need.
Use your core values as a compass for career decisions and for choosing mentors.
Learn from negative role models by treating them as "de-mentors" who show you who not to become.
Design mentoring programs that pair people by specific skills and include reverse, maternity and diverse mentoring.
Details
Level
All levels
Format
Talk
Technical depth
Non-technical
For
All career stages
Length
17:08
Published
July 2020
Questions this talk answers
What is the difference between mentoring and coaching?
Coaching is a structured partnership for clarifying your direction, where the coach asks questions and does not share personal stories. Mentoring focuses on a specific skill set and is a trusted two-way relationship where experience, mistakes and lessons are shared.
What types of mentors are there?
She describes three clear types: the peer mentor (a buddy for early days or basic learning), the career mentor (a trusted advisor on career choices and company politics) and the life mentor (an aspirational figure whose core values align with yours).
Does a life mentor have to be someone you know personally?
No. She says a life mentor might be someone you have never met, naming Oprah Winfrey and Richard Branson as examples whose values align with hers.
Can a bad boss teach you something about your career?
Yes. Her first HR manager was a "de-mentor" who showed her exactly the type of businesswoman she did not want to be.
How should organizations build mentoring programs?
They should think about the specific skill sets a mentee wants to learn so they can pair them with the right mentor. She also recommends reverse mentoring, maternity mentoring and diverse mentoring programs.
About this talk
There is no greater professional development tool than that of Mentoring. For centuries the power of mentoring has enabled successful leaders to transform their careers, break through innovation barriers and perfect their leadership styles.
Are you considering being a Mentor, or wondering if working with a Mentor will help you reach your career goals? In this session I'll learn about the true Power of Mentoring and how by being either a Mentor or Mentee can help you shape your career and reach your goals.
Mentoring vs coaching: what is the difference? (85 s)
The de-mentor who showed her who not to be (72 s)
So today I would love to speak to you about mentoring and really the power of mentoring and what that has, you know, how mentoring has really made a difference in my life and I hope there are a few things that you can also take from this session. It's only 20 minutes. It's not very long. So if you have any questions, do also feel free to connect with me afterwards.
So I'm a woman and I'm successful. It's not something that you hear very often, not from a woman. And I'm not successful because of the house I have or the amount of money I have in my bank account or the size of my box bike. I live in Amsterdam, so we have box bikes here, but it's comparable to a big car, for instance, in any other country.
But I'm really successful because of the type of people that I have met along my way. And to me, success is achieving what I value. So I value growth, recognition, freedom and meaningful work. So over the years, my core values have not changed. In actual fact, quite the opposite. I've really helped me stay focused on what it is that I wanted from my life and from my career.
And if I'm in a crossroads, then, you know, staying true to my values has really helped me focus and helping make decisions as well. So I grew up in South Africa. My dad was a banker, forex trader and later also finance director. So super, super serious man. My mom, she was a stay home mom. I called her a domestic engineer, but she was also an artist and creative.
So as you can see, you know, I grew up with no real female business role models around me. And you cannot be where you cannot see. So I spent a lot of Saturday mornings with my dad at the office. This is a nice indication of what the office would have looked like back in back in the later 80s, I guess.
This is a typical dealing room, you know, big gray office, lots of men in suits doing very, very important things, looking very serious, staring at screens with green digits on. And here was a young girl, always dressed in a dress. My mom loved to dress me up. I wasn't a jeans, a jeans girl at all, but very brightly colored, sitting around watching all these men going about their serious jobs.
And I remember thinking to myself, but where are all these women? Where are the women? Why are there no women here on a Saturday morning? What's all these men doing? And, but of course, they were at home looking after their kids. So my dad wants me to be a doctor or dentist or something medical. Most of my family are in the medical profession.
So he knew I had the smarts for it, but, and it was super, super clear that he did not want me to work in business because there was no space for women in business, as you can see. But being a curious learner, I was always still looking for growth, recognition, freedom and meaningful work. So I wasn't going to settle for that as a concept.
And I wanted to do something different, but I also knew I wanted to work in business. So we're going to talk about mentoring a little bit today, but following the rule of how to deliver an awesome presentation and no presentation is perfect without some powerful stats. I'm showing a couple of numbers with you today. I love the Harvard Business Review.
It's a great source of research and learning. And there's some pretty awesome articles on mentoring, for instance, within the Harvard Business Review. So the first one is 80%. So 80% of learning takes place between mentors and mentees. So that's a really, really big number right there. And then 75% of private sector executives describe mentoring as critical to their own career development.
That's 75%. That is, again, a really, really large number. Then the final one, 71% of Fortune 500 companies offer some sort of mentoring program. So if these numbers don't convince you that mentoring is important, then nothing else will unless you experience it for yourself. So there are often some really big questions that people overlook when they think about mentoring.
And that is, what type of mentor should I be looking for? Now, today I'm going to tell you about two key mentors that played a really big part in my career. But before that, I also want to just talk a little bit about the difference between mentoring and coaching, because that's often confused. A lot of people mention mentoring and coaching kind of in the same sentence.
But there are some really key differences which I like to point out. And I also want to tell you just a little bit about the three types of mentors that you would potentially come across. So when you think about coaching, so coaching is when you really need clarification on your path or direction. So you're not really sure in terms of where you need to go, what do you want to do, your direction, your goals, et cetera, et cetera.
You would really partner with a coach. So this is a very structured decision. They help you ask, they ask you, right, kind of clarifying questions. They help you find your own answers. They help you gain clarity on a specific direction or specific problem or something. And they will really work out with you what it will take to get to reach your particular goals.
So together, you will brainstorm a very tactical action plan around goals that you want to achieve and also who else you need to involve along the way. So like I said, they follow a pretty structured approach. And the other really great, interesting thing about joining with a coach is that they will not really share anything personal. So they won't share personal stories, personal experiences and their learnings and kind of the mistakes that they've made.
Whereas mentoring on the other side, you know, you'd partner with a mentor on a very particular piece, on a very specific skill set. So if you know that you want to develop a very particular skill set or you want to reach a very particular, you know, set of skills, then you would partner with a mentor. So this is much more of a kind of a trusted, a respected relationship in terms of that both parties, the mentor and the mentee are in a learning situation.
So very often the mentor also takes something from the mentee in that mentoring relationship. And a great thing about a mentor-mentor relationship is that there's a lot of knowledge share. There's a lot of experience share, skill share, like mistakes made, for instance, or lessons learned, et cetera. So you can see the learning between or the difference between the two is quite clear even just on that aspect.
So it's really important for a company when they build a mentoring program to really think about the specific skill sets that someone, a mentor, would want to learn so they can pair them with the right mentor. There's also sponsoring and teaching, but that's another topic and it's quite big, so we don't have enough time for that. But if you want to learn more about how those four then come together, do let me know.
So the type of mentors, you know, mentors, they're, they're, when you Google type of mentors, there's a ton of stuff that come up and there's loads and loads of varieties of mentors that you can come across. But they're actually just three, three clear types of mentors. There's the peer mentor, the career mentor, and the life mentor. There's a ton of information on these.
So if you want to learn more, do, do let me know. But just some high level, for the peer mentor, for instance, this is a really nice one. And sometimes overlooked when in an organization, this is where you would pair someone with more of a buddy. So this is where the act of mentoring is more around the act of learning.
So you would be partnered with somebody who could really help you with those very early days of starting a new job or learning something kind of like a basic level, a new level. Then there's the classic and the, the, the classic or the career mentor. So this is the one that you typically think of when you think about mentoring.
And this is the, the, you know, there's loads of different varieties of career mentors that you would, that you would come across. They would be more of kind of like a trusted advisor or someone who would really help you think about things in the long run and help you with career choices, potentially also with navigating some company politics, anything like that.
Some really, and they might also point out some really valuable opportunities on the horizon, for instance, or something that you might not have considered or thought about. And they would also help you think about your space in the, in, in, so for instance, if it's within the organization, kind of your career path or your place within the organization.
Then the last one is my favorite, and that's the, the life mentor, more of an aspirational mentor. So this is a really interesting one. This person, and you might only ever need one or two of these in your, in your life. So this is someone whose core values really align with yours. And someone who you would, if you think about your career, your community and your relationships and your personal goals and values, and you put these three kind of circles together.
Someone who kind of sits in the middle of those three very powerful communities. And it really brings that together for you. Sometimes it might not even be someone that you have met personally. So for me, for instance, a really great life mentor is someone like Oprah Winfrey, or for instance, Richard Branson. These are people that I really, there's some core bits of their skill set or their values that really align with mine.
So yeah, so that's a really interesting one to, to explore. So those are the three kind of key mentors that I wanted to mention. So I said that I'd love to give you a couple of examples of mentors in, that have played a role in my life. The first one is my fluffy version of one of the three categories I've mentioned earlier.
And that's a de-mentor. In actual fact, this is an interesting one. And I'm going to take you back to the late 90s when I was still living in South Africa. And I was studying and doing lots and lots of different part-time jobs. And one of the jobs I had was a few days a week. I was working in the HR department in the bank that my dad was the finance director.
And I was reporting to the head of HR, awful woman, really, really awful. She was mean. She was pretty angry. And she was a really great example of a businesswoman that I did not want to be, the type of businesswoman I did not want to be. And I remember thinking to myself, well, if HR people and businesswoman are like that, I do not want to have anything to do with that at all.
However, she was also really good at playing politics. Great with the senior staff and really kind of knew how to pull the pull strings to get what she wanted. And it was just something that I just could not align with. So I really, very clearly remember, you know, thinking that that was just not the kind of woman I wanted to be in business.
You know, I grew up with the idea of it being a man's world. Yes, I was really frustrated with this concept of us living in a man's world, but, you know, half of it are women. And this was a really great example for me of, you know, why it just concept is just completely just wrong. And she used to call me Mr. Rue's daughter.
As if I had, did not have my own name or my own identity. It's terrible. So, yeah. So I had this idea of something that I just absolutely did not want to do in a career I just don't want to be in. So then I'm going to take you to the next type of mentor, which is the next woman who made a real impact in my life.
And now I've left South Africa. I've moved to the UK and, you know, I'm working in a big corporate company. And after a few years, the company had closed down and we all lost our jobs. And I was in this real weird space where I wasn't entirely sure what I wanted to do with my career. I was now in business and I was working and, you know, I was enjoying kind of what I'm doing.
But I needed to take the next step in what I wanted to do. So then along the way, I met this woman. I mean, we worked for the same organization and she really took me under her wing. And she got really got to know my strengths and my weaknesses, my skill set, and also my potential. So she knew what she knew me pretty well.
So she could then help me rethink and reposition the concept and the term of HR, which in actual fact is something that I feel truly passionate about. If you think about my values around growth and recognition and meaningful work, you know, these are things that, you know, I would love to be able to give to somebody else.
So she really helped me kind of re rework that concept in my mind to then move back into the world of HR, which is then where I was able to really build a very interesting and very successful career. So I know I'm probably running out of time, but I want to leave you with a quote from Steven Spielberg on mentoring.
So it's a delicate balance of mentoring. Someone is not creating them in your own image, but giving them the opportunity to create themselves. So if you want to be a mentor or you're looking for a mentor, do contact me via LinkedIn or Eva Connections, which is my email at [email protected]. I'm going to try and get back the screen and see if I can get some questions in the small amount of time that I've got left.
Any questions from anybody? If you want to connect, I'd love to hear from you. I see there's quite a few people on the session, which is great. Thank you so much. And yes, reverse mentoring. Reverse mentoring is fantastic. It's quite a new concept or concept in organizations, and they're really using reverse mentoring now, especially with millennials coming into the order and all the other wonderful gems coming into work and with technology moving at the speed of it does, you know, bringing in reverse mentoring into an organization and into a mentoring program is fantastic.
There's also maternity mentoring, which is a great one for organizations to really use and think about, you know, women going on maternity leave and how they reintegrate back into the working world once they've had their baby. You know, diverse mentoring is another great one for organizations to think about. So there's tons of different programs that you could join as a woman or you can think about as an organization.
And I think I'm going to be kicked out of this room any second now, but lovely to see you all and hope to connect with as many of you as possible. Thank you.
Transcribed automatically; names checked against the speaker record. Select a time to jump there.
Article based on this talk
Which mentor do you need, and what can a bad boss teach you?
Estelle Roux-Stevens separates mentoring from coaching, maps three types of mentors and shows how two very different women shaped her career.
In short
Estelle Roux-Stevens, career development strategist and mentor at Eva Connections, argues that mentoring is the strongest professional development tool there is, and that success depends on the people you meet along the way. She explains how mentoring differs from coaching, describes three types of mentors (peer, career and life), and tells the story of two women who shaped her path: one who showed her what not to become, and one who saw her potential.
Key takeaways
Distinguish mentoring from coaching and choose a coach for direction and a mentor for a specific skill set.
Identify whether a peer, career or life mentor fits your current career need.
Use your core values as a compass for career decisions and for choosing mentors.
Learn from negative role models by treating them as "de-mentors" who show you who not to become.
Design mentoring programs that pair people by specific skills and include reverse, maternity and diverse mentoring.
Success measured by values, not possessions
Roux-Stevens opens with a deliberately bold statement: she is a woman, and she is successful. Living in Amsterdam, she jokes that she does not measure this by the size of her box bike. Instead she defines success through four values that have stayed constant throughout her career: growth, recognition, freedom and meaningful work.
"But I'm really successful because of the type of people that I have met along my way. And to me, success is achieving what I value." (1:05)
Those values, she explains, have helped her stay focused and make decisions whenever she reached a crossroads.
Growing up without women to look up to
She grew up in South Africa. Her father was a banker, forex trader and later a finance director; her mother stayed at home and was an artist. She spent many Saturday mornings at her father's office, a young girl in a brightly coloured dress among men in suits staring at screens, wondering where all the women were. Her father wanted her to go into medicine, because he saw no space for women in business.
She still wanted to work in business, and that search for role models frames the rest of the talk. To underline why mentoring matters, she shares figures she attributes to the Harvard Business Review: 80% of learning takes place between mentors and mentees, 75% of private sector executives describe mentoring as critical to their career development, and 71% of Fortune 500 companies offer some form of mentoring program (as the speaker cited).
Mentoring is not coaching
Roux-Stevens notes that people often mention mentoring and coaching in the same sentence, but the two serve different needs. Coaching is for when you need clarity on your path or direction. A coach follows a structured approach, asks clarifying questions, helps you find your own answers and builds a tactical action plan with you. Coaches typically do not share personal stories or mistakes.
Mentoring, by contrast, is about developing a particular skill set. It is a trusted, respected relationship in which knowledge, experience, mistakes and lessons are shared, and both sides learn.
"So very often the mentor also takes something from the mentee in that mentoring relationship." (7:33)
For companies, the practical consequence is clear: a good mentoring program starts by identifying the specific skills a mentee wants to learn, so they can be paired with the right mentor.
Peer, career and life mentors
Search online and you will find endless varieties of mentors, she says, but there are really three. The peer mentor is a buddy, often overlooked, who helps in the early days of a new job or with learning something at a basic level. The career mentor is the classic trusted advisor who helps with long-term choices, company politics and spotting opportunities you had not considered. The life mentor, her favourite, is aspirational, and you may only need one or two in a lifetime.
"So this is someone whose core values really align with yours." (10:16)
A life mentor sits at the intersection of your career, your community and relationships, and your personal goals and values. They need not be someone you have met: she names Oprah Winfrey and Richard Branson as examples.
The de-mentor and the mentor who reframed HR
Her first story comes from the late 1990s, when she worked part-time in the HR department of the bank where her father was finance director. Her manager was mean and angry, skilled at politics with senior staff, and called her "Mr. Roux's daughter" as if she had no identity of her own. Roux-Stevens calls her a "de-mentor".
"And she was a really great example of a businesswoman that I did not want to be, the type of businesswoman I did not want to be." (11:55)
Years later, after moving to the UK and losing her job when her corporate employer closed, she met a woman at her new organisation who took her under her wing.
"And she got really got to know my strengths and my weaknesses, my skill set, and also my potential." (13:55)
That mentor helped her rethink HR as a field that matched her values of growth, recognition and meaningful work, and she returned to it to build a successful career. She closes with a line from Steven Spielberg: "So it's a delicate balance of mentoring. Someone is not creating them in your own image, but giving them the opportunity to create themselves." (15:01)
In the brief Q&A she welcomes reverse mentoring as technology moves fast and younger generations enter the workforce, and recommends maternity mentoring to help women reintegrate after leave, along with diverse mentoring programs.
Watch the talk
"The Power of Mentoring" by Estelle Roux-Stevens, 17 minutes: https://www.womentech.net/video/estelle-roux-stevens-power-mentoring
About the speaker
Estelle Roux-Stevens is a Career Development Strategist and Mentor at Eva Connections who has helped start-ups and scale-ups grow, build strong female workforces and create graduate programs aimed at female students. In 2017 she was nominated for a Woman in Tech award in the Diversity category, and she describes herself as a proud mother of two and an advocate for women in business.
Questions this talk answers
What is the difference between mentoring and coaching?
What types of mentors are there?
Does a life mentor have to be someone you know personally?
Can a bad boss teach you something about your career?
How should organizations build mentoring programs?
Drafted with AI from the talk transcript. Editor review pending.
Frameworks and ideas mentioned
Mentoring vs coaching
Peer, career and life mentor types
De-mentor
Reverse mentoring
Maternity mentoring
Diverse mentoring
Resources mentioned
Harvard Business Review articles on mentoring
Cite this talk
Estelle Roux-Stevens. "The Power of Mentoring." WomenTech Network, 2020. https://www.womentech.net/video/estelle-roux-stevens-power-mentoring