Opportunities to Support Mental Health with Virtual Reality Nature Videos
Katherine Mimnaugh23:222020
Virtual nature did not lift mood, but it stopped it from falling
Six minutes in a forest lifted people's mood, while six minutes watching that same forest in a VR headset did not, yet it stopped the drop seen in people facing a blank wall. Katherine Mimnaugh, a doctoral researcher in virtual reality at the University of Oulu with a background in clinical psychology and neuroscience, ran that comparison for her master's thesis. So when real nature is out of reach, what can a headset give back?
Learn the theory, the study results and practical ways to bring nature indoors
Katherine Mimnaugh, a doctoral researcher in virtual reality at the University of Oulu, explains the theories linking nature to human health and presents her master's study comparing real nature, a 360-degree VR video of the same forest and a blank-wall control. She argues that real nature is best, but that VR nature can preserve mood for people who cannot get outdoors, and shares practical ways to try it.
“And so even though it was a grainy video that wasn't that realistic, my body had just responded as if I was actually there. And I thought about how powerful that is.”
“So sometimes just maintaining it or buffering against that decrease is helpful.”
What you will learn
Explain how biophilia, attention restoration theory and stress reduction theory link nature to health.
Distinguish what VR nature can and cannot replicate, such as phytoncides and vitamin D from sunlight.
Interpret a three-condition study comparing real nature, VR nature and a blank-wall control.
Choose practical ways to bring nature indoors, from VR headsets and 360 videos to virtual windows.
Assess where VR nature fits alongside therapy for post-traumatic stress, anxiety and attention difficulties.
Details
Level
Beginner
Format
Talk
Technical depth
Introductory technical
For
All career stages
Length
23:22
Published
July 2020
Questions this talk answers
Why does spending time in nature help mental and physical health?
Biophilia holds that humans evolved in natural environments and have an innate connection to nature. Attention restoration theory says nature refreshes indirect attention, and stress reduction theory says it triggers a parasympathetic calming response that helps people recover from stress.
Does VR nature work as well as real nature?
Not fully: in her study real nature increased positive mood, while VR nature kept it steady and the blank-wall control group's positive mood dropped. Real and VR nature produced a similar increase in physiological arousal measured by skin conductance.
Should virtual nature replace going outside?
No. VR cannot deliver phytoncides from trees or vitamin D from sunlight, so real nature is best, but virtual nature is a good option for people in hospital or facing barriers such as a pandemic.
Can VR nature videos help with post-traumatic stress or anxiety?
For post-traumatic stress she sees nature as powerful in combination with psychotherapy, for example as a relaxing setting while veterans talk through what was stressful. For general stress and anxiety she thinks nature by itself can be effective.
How can someone start using VR nature videos?
She suggests headsets in various price ranges with nature apps from the Oculus Store or Steam, VR arcades, or panoramic videos on YouTube. A TV screen showing nature videos works as a simple virtual window in an office.
About this talk
This talk will present scientific research exploring the mental and physical effects of being immersed in a panoramic nature video in virtual reality. I will explain the theories relating nature to human health, discuss the findings from research that was part of my master’s program and offer suggestions about opportunities for you to engage with this exciting new technology.
Thanks everybody for coming. I'm really excited to have you here. My name is Katherine Mimna and I'm a doctoral student in the Perception Engineering Group at the Center for Ubiquitous Computing at the University of Oulu in Finland. So today I'm going to talk to you about the power of nature in virtual reality. If you have questions, you can put them in the chat and I will answer those at the end. I also created a slack channel called virtual dash nature. So if you have questions, you can put them in the chat and I will answer those at the end. I also created a Slack channel called virtual dash nature.
So if I don't get your question here, you can send it to me there as well. If you have trouble hearing me, please let me know and I can speak a little louder. Alrighty. So I studied psychology and neuroscience at the University of Illinois in Urbana-Champaign. And I'm currently studying computer science and engineering at the University of Oulu in Finland. My website is vrdevcat.com.
And you can connect with me on Twitter if you have any questions. Although I'm locked out of my account right now, so I might be a little slow to respond. So I just want to start off by saying that if you're struggling with mental health concerns, that you're not alone. It was a really difficult time with COVID-19 and worldwide protests against racism and police brutality and to affirm that black and indigenous lives matter.
So you have to know that there are resources online and understanding people you can talk to. So I've listed some resources here. And if you want to download the slides, you can see them at vrdevcat.com. So today I want to talk to you about the healing power of nature and how virtual reality technology can harness that power and bring it to people who cannot get out into natural areas.
Here I have a list of benefits from being out in real nature that have been proven in many different research studies over the past few decades. Instead of listing all the individual studies, I have a review paper there that discusses this body of literature. I particularly want to particularly want particularly want to point out the research on Shinoyoku, which is out of Japan.
That means a forest bathing and it's been found to have a really strong effect on your immune system. So I have a paper and a link there to a YouTube video that will give you more information. So you might be wondering, how does nature help people? And I have some theories here for you. Biophilia is a theory by E.O. Wilson, who theorized that humans as a species evolved over thousands of years living in natural environments.
And because of this, we have an innate, excuse me, connection to nature. And it's really been only since the beginning of the nineteen hundreds that humans have spent most of their lives indoors. And studies show that as people have been inside more than there have been more health problems. So what does our connection with nature mean? So there's two big theories about how it affects us, the attention restoration theory and the stress reduction theory.
So the first basically says that you have two types of attention, direct and indirect. And direct is when you're focusing and indirect is when you're kind of zoning out. And so being out in nature helps you refresh indirect attention. The stress reduction theory says that we have this physiological calming response, parasympathetic activation when we are out in nature and that helps us recover from stress.
So a lot of the studies that were done on stress reduction theory were just using images of nature. So people have studied just photographs or you can use virtual windows, so to speak, which is a TV screen or a monitor that shows pictures or videos of nature. And those have also found to have a positive effect on people.
So in my lab in Finland, I have put up a big TV screen and shown some nature videos there. And it's actually really nice. We have a great nature forest out here, but sometimes the beach is nice as well. So you might wonder how nature can affect us. This image is from paper by Dr. Kuo, and I have a citation at the bottom there.
Again, you can get these slides off my website. One of the things that's really powerful are phytoncides, which are organic compounds that trees and plants release that fight off fungus and other intruders. You might think of the smell of pine trees, for example. So going back to the shiny Yoku that I mentioned earlier, Dr. Lee found a powerful influence of phytoncides on the immune system.
There's also other aspects like vitamin D from sunlight, which is why nature simulations can't exactly replicate the effects of nature. But some people have been studying adding things to simulated nature like phytoncide essential oils, sun lamps and so on. So now talking about virtual nature, as I mentioned, there have been studies with pictures, TV screens, computer screens and various types of virtual reality technology.
I work with the current generation of VR. So you might heard of Oculus or PlayStation VR. The work that I'll be presenting in a little bit was based on personal experience and inspired by the work of Bob Stone and colleagues at the University of Birmingham and the human interfaces technology team. So one of the first times I tried virtual reality myself back in 2015, I was watching the short low resolution 360 video on the Oculus DK2.
And in the video, I was standing on a balcony overlooking an expansive area below me. And as I looked over the edge of the balcony, I could see a giant drop to the ground. And my stomach had this really uncomfortable feeling that you get when you're scared of heights. I realized in that moment that I just had a bodily response to what I was seeing.
And so even though it was a grainy video that wasn't that realistic, my body had just responded as if I was actually there. And I thought about how powerful that is. So since we know that nature can affect your body in great ways and it can improve your health and well-being in real life, then we wondered if your body would respond in the same way in virtual reality.
So the teams at Birmingham had explored using restorative environments or ones that restore positive states to your body from military veterans in the UK and found some really positive results. So now I'll present to you a little bit about a study that I did with my advisor, Dr. Browning, during my master's thesis that's been published this year in Frontiers in Psychology.
When we started working on the project in 2016, new and more affordable panoramic cameras and lightweight standalone virtual reality headsets had just come on the market. So we wanted to try a novel approach that wasn't available previously. And so we were carrying the same natural environment and virtual reality with the environment, the same environment outdoors. And so we wanted to ask this question.
Well, if you have the spectrum of mental and physical and physiological benefits that you get, where along the spectrum from no nature to real nature does virtual nature fall? So we used this equipment right here. This is a little 360 camera or panoramic camera that records in 360 that we use to make the film. And I have a link where you can actually see the film online.
And then this was the headset that we used, the Samsung Gear VR. So this was 2016 when we had the equipment. So we had this phone here and that would show the video. We popped it in the little headset and then people could see it with these noise canceling headphones. We also measured people's physiological response. So you can see the skin conductance measurement device right here, GSR.
So here on the left, you can see the camera out on a tripod in the forest for recording. And on the right, you can see that with one of the nice things about this technology is that you can record. You can see what it's recording as you're recording it. So you look on the phone, make sure everything is set up nicely, and then you can go ahead and record that way.
And so I say panoramic, but 360 is also interchangeable. So we had three conditions in our study. One group went out into real nature. And then one group saw that same environment where we recorded it in the headset. So you can see is the headset and he's sitting inside here. And then we also had a control group that was inside and they were looking at a blank wall.
So that was the no nature condition. And basically we recorded positive affect and negative affect. You can think of that as like mood. So we recorded state affect, meaning at this specific moment in time, how are you feeling? And people answered that question both before and after they had these whichever nature group they were in. So we found that positive affect or good mood increased for the subjects that went out into real nature.
But for subjects in VR nature, we do not observe an increase in positive mood, but also didn't decrease like it did for the control group. So we thought of this as sort of preservation of good mood. I'm sure that we can all appreciate these days how seeing something for a few seconds on social media can really cut down your good mood.
So sometimes just maintaining it or buffering against that decrease is helpful. Surprisingly, we found a decrease in bad mood, so to speak, for all three groups. But we wonder if this is related to the control group just relaxing indoors with time away from their cell phones. We saw a similar increase in physiological arousal arousal, excuse me, for real and VR nature, which would support the changes in affect that we saw.
So we concluded that real nature is best as we expected. But however, if real nature is not possible to go out into, virtual nature can also be a good option if you're in the hospital or you have barriers to getting out into natural areas, say, for example, a pandemic. So if you're interested in how to use this technology, I've listed some VR headsets here in various price ranges.
There are great applications in the Oculus Store or on Steam to watch nature videos and try out some of the other nature relaxation applications. If you'd like to know what I recommend virtual reality nature videos. I haven't seen anything better than spheres VR and I have the link here. Eric Fassbender, who started the company, lent us some of his videos, which we use to introduce the VR headset in our pilot study.
So I'm really grateful to him for that. But regardless, the quality of his videos are really amazing. And he has some that are just nature and some that have meditation and some other things. So location based gaming is also pretty popular. There might be VR arcades in your area. But you can also just watch panoramic videos on YouTube and scroll around to see the full video, although they aren't as immersive as a headset.
But for non panoramic nature videos, I use films from Johnny Lawson on YouTube. So I just wanted to add a thank you to the people that we thanked from our research study. This is in the paper as well. We had many research assistants and helpers. And I also want to thank Anna for inviting me to give this talk for you.
So I have some more mental health resources here again. And I'm going to end on the slide and encourage you to take care of your mental health because it's really important. So hopefully you learned something new today about how to support your mental health with nature. All righty. So let's see. Let me turn my camera back on here.
And yeah, let's see. So questions. Yes, it was in Urbana-Champaign. That's where I did my master's specific nature environment. So we went to the Anita Purves Nature Center. We are really grateful to them for letting us use their environment or their nature center. So it was a forested area and it was near the university and we had access to the basement.
So we took everybody there and either they walked outside to that little forested area or they stayed indoors. And we're looking for something that matched some of the theories that I mentioned before. So prospect and refuge having being open, not too enclosed, but still having some protection. And yeah, so let's see. There's a question here from Julia.
Let's see. A question about placing exercise in VR nature. There's actually some research on exercise in nature and there is a benefit when you add nature to exercise. I know that there are bicycles, these like exercise bikes that they have in gyms that people use with a VR headset. There's like a company creating these things. And so those are good options.
Yeah. So if it's possible to exercise outdoors, that's the best because of Phi Tinsides and some of those other things that I mentioned before. But if not, yeah, then as long as you are in something stationary, then exercising indoors or even some treadmills have like a screen that like shows like a nature video on there. Let's see.
So there's a question that says, is there negativity on using VR for such reasons? Some of the feedback or some of the concerns that people have had is like, will people start using this instead of going out into nature? And there are all these things like sunlight gives you vitamin D, phytoncides are which are the organic compounds that trees release.
These are that fight off pesticides and other things. Those you get from being out in nature and are really beneficial. So you can't get that from VR nature. So I wouldn't tell anyone if you can go outside to just sit indoors and do nothing. But if you don't have access to outdoors, then, yeah, there's a good option.
Let's see. There's a question that says, how do I integrate the potential of this approach to integrate into VR applications for the office of the future? So as I said before, I have like a TV screen that I keep in my office and I show just regular nature videos. And they had a study. I have a link to it, I think, in my slides.
You can look in that Berto study, but they used a virtual window. So there were some people that were in an office basement and they put a camera on the roof of the building and then they put a TV screen and they had this video feed outside. So the people in the office that didn't have an actual window had this like sort of virtual window and they found that it helped people's creativity and people said that they enjoyed being in the office more and were able to focus better.
So, yeah, that would be amazing. I've also seen the Vario headset. It's a new VR headset on the high end and they have this sort of pass through. And what they're trying to work on is like a virtual environment that you can a work virtual work environment. So it's sort of overlays in, let's say, your office. And then instead of having one screen, you can have 10 screens or you can be working with 3D models and doing other sorts of things like that.
So I know a lot of VR companies like and well, XR companies like Magic Leap even have been moving towards enterprise. So specifically building headsets for business. That's where the Microsoft HoloLens is. So it is something that people are really thinking about. And it seems like there's a big appetite for it. I know a lot of big companies like, is it Volvo or Volkswagen?
Maybe Mercedes Benz actually have you can go in VR and like look at a car that you want to order with different paint and different options and like see what it actually looks like before you order it, which is really cool. So that's not exactly office, but I wouldn't be surprised to see other sorts of applications in the business areas like that.
There's a question about VR being used in psychology for post-traumatic stress and irregular stress and anxiety. Yeah. So and the question says, do I think nature videos could serve as a first approach before therapy? So there's there was a great talk by Skip Rizzo actually yesterday on YouTube. It's part of this virtual reality series from frontiers in psychology VR.
And so he does research on PTSD with VR and I can put a link to that on my website as well. It's a really great series if you're interested in academic virtual reality. But so. One of the big benefits of having virtual reality is that the researcher or the therapist has control over that environment, so you can use it for PTSD, for example, to expose people to things that are traumatic to them.
And then the therapist can be there with them and help them work through it. I think part of the problem with post-traumatic stress is that you're trying to avoid something that's stressful to you. So if you were to just go into nature by itself, that might be relaxing, but you're not actually doing the. The work of addressing what the underlying problem is.
So Bob Stone, one of the things that he was thinking about was having people instead of going into for these military veterans, instead of going into like a virtual Iraq or virtual Afghanistan while they're doing this, like you sort of talk about what happened and why it was stressful instead of going into that exact environment, going into nature instead as a relaxing thing.
But then still doing this process of talking about what was stressful to them and addressing these problems that they've had. And so that can be really powerful. I was trying to see if I could find a study that's out there, but I have the links to his website. So I think in combination with specifically for post-traumatic stress, in combination with psychotherapy, that I think nature could be very powerful.
But for stress, other sorts of anxiety and things like that, then I think nature by itself can be effective. So let's see. There's a question. Did you understand correctly that VR just makes sense that you stay at a baseline and not a drop in mood? OK, so we showed people these the nature or the VR nature of the control groups were each a six minute exposure.
So that's a very short amount of time. And so we saw in just that couple of minutes that people in nature had this improvement in their positive affect. And people in VR stayed the same and the control group had a decrease in positive affect. And so we didn't see an increase in positive affect from virtual nature, but we did see the same physiological response.
So they had this increase in skin conductance. And that was the same between VR nature and real nature. And so in this first study of what will hopefully be a long line of studies, we didn't see exactly the same response. And I wouldn't think that you would get the response. But since there was a decrease in positive affect for the control, then we thought that it might have been some sort of buffering or an affect preserving effect that we saw from the virtual nature.
So the next question, do I think there's a way to adapt this to help people for whom sitting still without distractions may be difficult or unhelpful for their mental health? Yeah. So there's a lot of research on how virtual how nature sees me can help with attention deficit disorder, ADHD. And there are theories like I presented at the beginning about how nature can replenish people's attentional resources.
So I don't know that there has been a study about VR nature specifically to look at attention yet. But I would not be surprised if there is one coming up in the future, because that is a really a piece that makes sense. We know that nature helps with attention. We are can bring something that could help with attention into a place where people are having trouble concentrating and you might see those effects.
So I wouldn't be surprised. I don't know. Like I said, off the top of my head. Yeah. Oh, yeah. Someone posted this frontiers and virtual reality thing in the comments there. Thank you. Thank you so much for putting that there for me. And see, do we have any other questions? Again, my website is VR dev cat dot com and you can connect with me there or on Slack.
And I really appreciate you for attending. Thank you so much, everybody. And thanks for your nice questions as well. Feel free to connect with me on LinkedIn or anywhere else.
Transcribed automatically; names checked against the speaker record. Select a time to jump there.
Article based on this talk
Can a VR nature video do what a walk in the forest does?
Katherine Mimnaugh's research shows virtual nature falls short of the real thing but can still protect mood when people cannot get outside.
In short
Not entirely, but it can help. Katherine Mimnaugh, a doctoral researcher in virtual reality and robotics at the University of Oulu, compared people who walked into a real forest, people who watched a 360-degree video of that same forest in a VR headset, and people who looked at a blank wall. Real nature lifted mood, virtual nature kept mood from dropping, and both produced a similar physiological response, which makes VR nature a useful option for anyone who cannot get outdoors.
Key takeaways
Explain how biophilia, attention restoration theory and stress reduction theory link nature to health.
Distinguish what VR nature can and cannot replicate, such as phytoncides and vitamin D from sunlight.
Interpret a three-condition study comparing real nature, VR nature and a blank-wall control.
Choose practical ways to bring nature indoors, from VR headsets and 360 videos to virtual windows.
Assess where VR nature fits alongside therapy for post-traumatic stress, anxiety and attention difficulties.
Why nature is good for us
Mimnaugh opens with care: she acknowledges how hard the period of COVID-19 and worldwide protests against racism has been, and points listeners to mental health resources. She then turns to the evidence that time in real nature benefits people, a body of research built up over decades. She highlights shinrin-yoku, or forest bathing, from Japan, which she says has been found to have a strong effect on the immune system.
To explain why, she walks through three ideas. E.O. Wilson's biophilia theory holds that humans evolved over thousands of years in natural environments and so carry an innate connection to nature; she notes that only since the early 1900s have people spent most of their lives indoors. Attention restoration theory separates focused attention from the more relaxed, "zoning out" kind, and says nature refreshes the latter. Stress reduction theory focuses on the body: "The stress reduction theory says that we have this physiological calming response, parasympathetic activation when we are out in nature and that helps us recover from stress." (3:06)
Many stress reduction studies used only photographs or "virtual windows", screens showing nature, and still found positive effects. Mimnaugh has set up a large TV screen with nature videos in her own lab in Finland.
What a simulation cannot copy
She is clear about the limits. Trees and plants release phytoncides, organic compounds that fight off fungus and other intruders (think of the smell of pine), and researchers have linked them to immune effects. Sunlight provides vitamin D. "There's also other aspects like vitamin D from sunlight, which is why nature simulations can't exactly replicate the effects of nature." (4:44) Some researchers are experimenting with adding essential oils and sun lamps to simulated nature to close part of that gap.
A grainy video and a racing stomach
The research question came from her own body. In 2015, watching a short, low-resolution 360 video on an Oculus DK2, she stood on a virtual balcony, looked over the edge and felt the stomach drop of a fear of heights. "I realized in that moment that I just had a bodily response to what I was seeing." (5:41) If a grainy video could do that, she reasoned, perhaps restorative nature could also reach the body through a headset. She was further inspired by Bob Stone and colleagues at the University of Birmingham, who explored restorative virtual environments with military veterans in the UK.
With her advisor, Dr. Browning, she designed a study published in Frontiers in Psychology. Using a 360 camera on a tripod in a forest near the Anita Purves Nature Center in Urbana-Champaign, the team recorded an environment chosen to match prospect and refuge theory: open, but with some protection. Participants either walked out into that forest, watched the recording on a Samsung Gear VR headset with noise-cancelling headphones, or sat indoors facing a blank wall. Each exposure lasted six minutes, and the team measured mood before and after, plus skin conductance.
What the study found
Positive mood rose for people in real nature. In VR nature it did not rise, but it also did not fall the way it did for the control group. "So we thought of this as sort of preservation of good mood." (9:27) Mimnaugh connects that to everyday life, noting how a few seconds on social media can cut a good mood short: "So sometimes just maintaining it or buffering against that decrease is helpful." (9:44)
Negative mood fell in all three groups, which she suspects may reflect the control group simply relaxing away from their phones. Physiological arousal increased in a similar way for real and VR nature. Her conclusion is measured: "So we concluded that real nature is best as we expected." (10:08) Virtual nature, though, is a good option for people in hospital or facing barriers to getting outdoors, such as a pandemic.
Bringing nature indoors
For viewers who want to try it, she lists headsets across price ranges, nature and relaxation apps in the Oculus Store and on Steam, VR arcades, and panoramic videos on YouTube, while noting these are less immersive without a headset. She praises the videos made by Eric Fassbender, who lent footage for the pilot study, and uses non-panoramic nature films on YouTube herself.
The Q&A widens the picture. Exercise outdoors is best, but VR exercise bikes or treadmills with nature screens are alternatives. For offices, she describes a study where a rooftop camera fed a live view to a screen in a windowless basement office, and people reported better creativity, focus and enjoyment. On therapy, she argues that for post-traumatic stress, nature works best combined with psychotherapy, where a calming virtual setting can support talking through what happened. "But for stress, other sorts of anxiety and things like that, then I think nature by itself can be effective." (19:55) She also sees promise for attention difficulties such as ADHD, though she does not know of a VR nature study on attention yet.
She closes where she began: "And I'm going to end on the slide and encourage you to take care of your mental health because it's really important." (11:45)
Watch the talk
"Opportunities to Support Mental Health with Virtual Reality Nature Videos" by Katherine Mimnaugh, 23 minutes: https://www.womentech.net/video/katherine-mimnaugh-opportunities-support-mental-health-virtual-reality-nature-videos
About the speaker
Katherine Mimnaugh is a Doctoral Researcher in Virtual Reality and Robotics at the University of Oulu, Finland, a 2018 Oculus LaunchPad Fellow and a 2020 recipient of the Google Students with Disabilities Scholarship. Her academic background is in clinical psychology and cognitive neuroscience, and her master's thesis research investigated the restorative effects of natural environments in virtual reality.
Questions this talk answers
Why does spending time in nature help mental and physical health?
Does VR nature work as well as real nature?
Should virtual nature replace going outside?
Can VR nature videos help with post-traumatic stress or anxiety?
How can someone start using VR nature videos?
Drafted with AI from the talk transcript. Editor review pending.
Frameworks and ideas mentioned
Biophilia theory
Attention restoration theory
Stress reduction theory
Prospect and refuge theory
Shinrin-yoku (forest bathing)
Resources mentioned
vrdevcat.com (speaker's website with slides and links)
virtual-nature Slack channel
Spheres VR nature videos by Eric Fassbender
Oculus Store
Steam
Johnny Lawson nature films on YouTube
Frontiers in Psychology virtual reality talk series (Skip Rizzo talk)
Mimnaugh and Browning study in Frontiers in Psychology
Cite this talk
Katherine Mimnaugh. "Opportunities to Support Mental Health with Virtual Reality Nature Videos." WomenTech Network, 2020. https://www.womentech.net/video/katherine-mimnaugh-opportunities-support-mental-health-virtual-reality-nature-videos