Gamified virtual reality for physical and mental health
Katie Hoolahan19:252021
VR workouts felt easier than they were, and 90% of participants stuck with it
Over 18 weeks, 20 people played 36 off-the-shelf VR games, and their perceived exertion came in measurably lower than their actual heart-rate effort while 90% of them kept showing up. Katie Hoolahan, a biomedical engineering graduate who co-founded Virtually Healthy, argues that fun may be the missing ingredient in exercise for body and mind. So can a headset outlast the novelty that she says wore off for the Wii and Kinect?
See the study's numbers, the gamification model behind them and where VR fitness goes next
Katie Hoolahan, Managing Director and Research Manager at Virtually Healthy, argues that gamified virtual reality can tackle low engagement in exercise while supporting mental and physical health together. She explains the barriers to exercise, the gamification model behind VR fitness, and her company's 18-week study, in which participants perceived less exertion than they actually produced and 90% stuck with the program.
“A lot of people just don't enjoy exercise. If you don't enjoy it, then you're less likely to engage in it.”
“Mental and physical health go hand in hand, but they are very often dealt with separately within our healthcare systems.”
What you will learn
Identify the main barriers that keep people from exercising, from priorities and motivation to pain, body image and cost
Explain how VR absorbs attention and can reduce the perception of pain and anxiety during exercise
Apply gamification elements such as feedback, points, badges, levels, scoreboards, goals and challenges to motivate exercise
Interpret how a VR fitness study can measure intensity, perceived exertion and adherence with heart rate, motion capture and the Borg RPE scale
Weigh whether VR fitness engagement is driven by novelty or by lasting immersion
Key takeaways from the speaker
Low engagement in exercise is a major problem in the health & fitness industry
VR games reduce perception of exertion
VR games increase motivation to exercise
Virtually Healthy are doing the necessary research to use VR games for health & fitness
Details
Level
Intermediate
Format
Talk
Technical depth
Introductory technical
For
All career stages
Length
19:25
Published
June 2021
Questions this talk answers
Why do so many people fail to exercise regularly?
Lack of time is the biggest perceived barrier, which usually means exercise is a lower priority. Low motivation, body image concerns, pain, lack of enjoyment, limited access and cost also play a part.
How can virtual reality help people exercise?
VR absorbs attention and diverts it away from pain, reducing how pain and effort are perceived, and it can ease anxiety and depression. Combined with gamification it turns exercise into something fun and motivating.
What did Virtually Healthy's 18-week VR study find?
Most of the 36 games induced low to moderate intensity exercise, some high or very high, and perceived exertion was significantly lower than actual exertion. Adherence was 90% with a 10% dropout rate.
Did VR have mental health benefits for participants?
Twelve participants reported mental health benefits, including two diagnosed with depression, describing the sessions as a weekly highlight that helped them switch off and lifted their mood.
Is the high engagement just the novelty of VR?
Katie Hoolahan says novelty may play a part, but participants who had owned headsets for years also stayed, and she believes VR's level of immersion sets it apart from the Wii and Kinect.
About this talk
Low engagement in regular exercise is a major problem in the health and fitness industries. I will talk about gamification and how virtual reality is the perfect tool to apply it for increasing engagement in exercise as well as how it can improve mental and physical health holistically. I will also discuss the research that we are conducting to bring gamified VR into the health and fitness industries.
VR players felt less effort and kept coming back (62 s)
Is VR fitness just a novelty? (80 s)
Speaker: Hello, welcome to my presentation about the effect of VR games on perceived exertion, exercise adherence and health. My name is Katie Hoolahan and I'll start with a quick introduction about myself. So I have a background in applied sport and exercise science and I did my masters in biomedical engineering where I focused my dissertation on using VR games for helping with chronic pain. When I left university, I co-founded Virtually Healthy to be able to use VR games within health and fitness for both mental and physical health. So we all know that we need to exercise regularly to stay healthy and it's recommended for 30 minutes of exercise per day with 150 minutes of moderate exercise or 75 minutes of vigorous aerobic exercise per week and strengthening exercises two times per week. But unfortunately, only about 27%
of UK citizens and 23% of US citizens actually meet this recommendation. And we have a similar low adherence to exercise programs for managing health conditions and recovering from injuries, which is a major problem within the healthcare industry and costs healthcare around the world, billions of dollars and pounds because of this. So why, I guess you might ask, there are a lot of barriers that people perceive to exercise and the biggest one being lack of time. When somebody says that they don't have enough time to exercise, what they usually mean is that exercise is a lower priority on their list. For example, you might get home from a hard day at work and you'd rather sit on the sofa and watch some TV for half an hour
than get on the exercise bike or go for a run. Yeah, that just means that that relaxation after a long day is a higher priority to exercise. Or perhaps you've got kids that you need to cook dinner for and that's a higher priority than exercising for half an hour. A lot of people say they don't have the motivation to get started to exercise. And perhaps that might be because of a mental health condition or depression. A lot of people are very self-conscious about their body image. So they might not want to go to the gym and exercise in front of people. Or they might just not like looking at themselves exercising. Others might be in pain, whether that's for a chronic pain condition and you feel pain
because of that. Or if it's just because you don't like the feeling of your lungs burning after a hard run. Yeah, everybody's been there. A lot of people just don't enjoy exercise. If you don't enjoy it, then you're less likely to engage in it. And then we have the problem of lack of access to facilities and the cost of exercise, which can be quite expensive for some sports and some types of exercise.
So this is where virtual reality can come in. We have seen the research show VR has been able to distract from mental and physical pain, providing a reduction in pain whilst exercising and also helping with anxiety and depression. So it can help relieve that stress and that anxiety and depression when you're engaging with VR. So according to the gate theory of attention, VR absorbs and diverts attention away from pain, reducing perception of this pain. And it could even change the way that the brain physically registers that pain. And a lot of this research stresses the importance of gaming and play elements in VR interventions that are aimed at reducing pain. So this is how VR may actually help to overcome many of the barriers to exercise. And it provides a platform for fun and motivational exercise rather than just
the most standard exercise programs that you get given for health and fitness generally. We can use gamification along with VR. So gamification is basically game-like experiences which promote flow, mastery, achievement and intrinsic motivation. Encourages participation, positively influences attitude and behavior towards exercise, and it allows for easy goal setting and progression. So there are three main aspects of gamification for exercise. We have these motivational affordances, things like feedback that give context to progress and ability, points that measure achievement in relation to others, badges that visually reward achievements, levels that encourage progress to unlock new rewards, scoreboards which create competition between players, goal setting that provides motivation to reach a long-term goal, and challenges which engage players with specific tasks to complete.
And these motivational affordances lead to psychological outcomes such as increased self-efficacy, so your belief in your own ability to succeed. It can reduce perception of pain whilst exercise, and it can improve your attitude towards exercise. So these psychological outcomes then lead to this further behavioural outcome of increased participation in exercise, which overall leads to a better quality of life.
So if we can combine these two into gamified virtual reality, we can provide a much needed solution to low engagement in exercise for health, which can help holistically with both mental and physical health together. Mental and physical health go hand in hand, but they are very often dealt with separately within our healthcare systems. So that brings us to the research that we've been doing at Virtually Healthy.
We carried out an 18-week VR study to investigate the use of VR games for health and fitness. We used 36 different VR games that were already out there on the market with 20 participants. And we used heart rate monitoring, motion capture, Likert scale questionnaires, including using the rate of perceived exertion for each game. So we used a Borg scale of RPE scale, rate of perceived exertion scale, which goes from 6, which is basically no exertion, as if you're lying down or sitting down doing nothing, to a 20, which is maximal exertion, like the maximum you can give.
And finally, we recorded attendance. So what did we find? We found that VR was effective at inducing exercise. So obviously this was dependent on the game itself. On average, we found one game induced very low intensity exercise, so less than 50% of the maximum heart rate. But 14 games induced low intensity exercise, or 50 to 63% of maximum heart rate.
13 games induced moderate intensity of exercise, so 64 to 76% of maximum heart rate. So seven games induced a high intensity of exercise, so 77 to 93% of maximum heart rate. And one game induced a very high intensity exercise of 94 to 99% of maximum heart rate. We took people's RPE, rate of perceived exertion, and we converted it to heart rate to be able to compare the two.
So we compared perceived exertion to actual exertion, and we found that perceived exertion was actually lower than the actual exertion with a statistically significant result. Which may be one of the reasons why we had such great adherence rates. We had 90% adherence to our program, with only a 10% dropout rate, which is an amazing statistic, because for similar research with standard exercise programs, 67% adherence is considered successful, with general adherence of around 45 to 60%.
And dropout rates ranged from 25% to 80% in the majority of the literature that we were looking at beforehand. So here is some of the average questionnaire results for all the games. So this is all of the games put together and all the participants put together, just to give an overview of how our participants felt whilst playing these games.
So obviously it differed depending on the game again. Overall, we found that participants didn't find this boring. Yeah, they found it quite exciting and fun. And many of them weren't relaxing, because of course we're trying to induce exercise. Not many of them were uncomfortable to play. We had a couple of games that did induce some motion sickness, and these were the games that were moving the participant through the level, and that sort of game is known to cause motion sickness.
Many of the games were thought to be very comfortable to play though, and did not induce any sort of motion sickness. Many of the games challenged our participants to solve problems, and some were a little bit difficult, which is not necessarily a bad thing, just trying to engage people in this challenge, motivational affordance, as we were talking about before with gamification.
We had many of the games and people were mentally refreshed after playing it, and most of the games we had people would choose to play again and spend money on. And then the big ones is that we had a lot of our participants putting effort into these games, and they felt motivated to get a high score, and ultimately were very immersed in the game.
And overall we had a very satisfactory rating of the games. We also found in some cases that heart rate was actually observed to be lower than the initial heart rate, resting heart rate, sorry, whilst in virtual reality. This was usually whilst in the menus, not whilst playing the exercise type games. This can show how VR can lower people's anxiety and help with that mental health and have that relaxing element and distracting element from your mental pain in some ways.
We had two participants that had slight limitations to their upper limb movement, and without prompting, they noted how they felt that they could do things in VR that they couldn't do in real life. They had that extra movement, extra range of motion, which has been noted in some other research, and is being researched further by other people.
We had mental health benefits that were noted by 12 of our participants, including two who suffer from depression. They've been diagnosed with depression through their GP. And here are a couple of the quotes that they had in response to the question, did playing VR regularly have any effect on your mental health? So one said, I found it beneficial for my mental health.
It has been good for me to have the weekly activity just for myself, which I really enjoy. And I found the immersive nature of VR helps me to just switch off for a period of time, particularly when I'm feeling anxious. And the other said, definitely, it has been a highlight of my week and has always lifted my mood when I was feeling low otherwise.
So we currently have a journal paper that is being peer reviewed about this study to publish later this year. But in the meantime, you can read an overview of all of our research on our blog at virtuallyhealthy.co.uk/blog. And we are releasing detailed information about the specific games that were included through our blog as well. So we have currently released details about Racket NX, Synth Riders, Until You Fall, VR Regatta, and Creed Rise to Glory.
So Creed, we also did a small study that looked into the differences between their new endurance mode and their normal fighting mode, the boxing game. And we also have details on Spark, which are going to be released next week. And I'm excited to announce our new virtually healthy certification. Games that have proven to have benefits for health and fitness through our research can now be awarded a virtually healthy certification and be considered a virtually healthy game.
All virtually healthy games will be given a digital certificate detailing the categories in which they have proven to be beneficial. So we currently have two categories, cardiovascular exercise and range of motion. We have plans for more categories in the future as our research progresses and develops further. So keep an eye out for games with a certificate or logo on their Steam and Oculus pages.
And once we release our app and our VR programs later this year, which I'll talk about in a moment, you'll be able to access a list of all of the virtually healthy games and which categories they fall into. So what's next for us at Virtually Healthy? We are using all of this data to develop VR health and fitness programs.
We are beginning beta testing on our first programs later this month, and these are our first programs of many. So we are first releasing general health and fitness programs for keeping up exercise, regular exercise. And in the future, we want to develop more specific exercise programs for more specific health conditions, whether that's mental or physical health or a combination of the two.
We will be conducting more in-depth movement analysis to develop more specific programs for our fitness and rehabilitation. And we want to provide data allowing health and fitness professionals to be able to create custom programs. So you might have data about which muscles these games use, what type of range of motion, what forces and accelerations of the joints are being induced in each of these games.
We will be conducting research into the effectiveness of each of our VR programs to show that they are effective for our intended purposes. We will be releasing our VR programs on a website app to start with, and once we've released our first programs, we'll be beginning our first funding round to grow our app to be able to continue our research and progress further.
In the future, we are looking to organize a VR headset loaning system, which will be released both online and through private health and fitness services. So you might be able to go to your local physiotherapist or your local gym and be able to rent out a VR headset to be able to participate in our programs, which will have all of the games necessary to use on there.
We also have several partnerships planned with VR arcade companies, with private health and fitness professionals and organizations, and with game developers themselves, who have all seemed very enthusiastic about what we're doing at Virtually Healthy and want to help us in any way they can to push forward this use of virtual reality games within health and fitness. So here are some of the references that I've used throughout talking through this presentation, and thank you very much for listening, and I would be more than happy to take any questions or comments in the Q&A.
You can contact me at [email protected] or on LinkedIn or Facebook. You can sign up for updates on our website, virtuallyhealthy.co.uk. And please join our Facebook community, Virtually Healthy community, where we have regular discussions and content that gets shown there about VR and health and fitness. So, first question, how much do you think the low dropout rate was due to the novelty of VR, and do you think the results would be affected by VR becoming more common in society?
That may be part of it, but we also have participants that owned VR headsets themselves and have used VR for the past year, two years, three years. So the fact that they didn't drop out either does show something to the fact that it's not quite just a novelty. And if you look at the VR communities, so Facebook and things like that, we have people that have been using VR since the very beginning that it was released four or five years ago, and are still just as enthusiastic about using VR for health and fitness for games.
And personally, anecdotally, of course, I've been using VR for the last five years and I still use it very regularly for exercise and health. So there are worries about the novelty, but I feel like there is a lot of difference between this and, say, the Nintendo Wii and the Xbox Kinect, which definitely did stop being used so much because of the novelty of that.
And there is more to VR with the level of immersion that you get from the VR. Definitely, there is a novelty and the wow factor when you first go into VR. But I don't think that really wears off and has an impact on participation and engagement with it. Do we have any other questions? All right. Well, thank you very much for listening.
This has been lovely to present to you. Please get in touch if you have any questions or would like to talk more. I'm always open to having a conversation with anybody that is interested in this technology and its uses within mental and physical health. Have a great rest of the event. Thank you very much.
Transcribed automatically; names checked against the speaker record. Select a time to jump there.
Article based on this talk
Can VR games make people stick with exercise?
Katie Hoolahan shares an 18-week study in which VR players felt less effort than they produced and almost all of them kept coming back.
In short
Katie Hoolahan, Managing Director and Research Manager at Virtually Healthy, argues that gamified virtual reality can answer one of health and fitness's biggest problems: people simply don't keep exercising. In her company's 18-week study of 36 commercial VR games, participants perceived their effort as significantly lower than it really was, and 90% stayed with the program. She also reports mental health benefits, including for participants living with depression.
Key takeaways
Low engagement in exercise is a major problem in the health and fitness industry.
VR games reduce the perception of exertion.
VR games increase motivation to exercise.
Virtually Healthy is doing the necessary research to use VR games for health and fitness.
Why people don't exercise
Hoolahan opens with the gap between advice and behaviour. As the speaker cited, only about 27% of UK citizens and 23% of US citizens meet the recommended amount of weekly exercise, and adherence to exercise programs for health conditions and injury recovery is similarly low, costing healthcare systems billions.
She walks through the barriers people describe. The biggest is lack of time, which she reframes: "When somebody says that they don't have enough time to exercise, what they usually mean is that exercise is a lower priority on their list." (1:08) Others include low motivation, sometimes linked to depression, self-consciousness about body image, pain from chronic conditions or simply hard effort, limited access to facilities and cost. Underneath many of them sits a simpler problem: "A lot of people just don't enjoy exercise. If you don't enjoy it, then you're less likely to engage in it." (2:48)
How VR and gamification fit together
Hoolahan points to research showing that VR can distract from both mental and physical pain. Drawing on the gate theory of attention, she explains that VR absorbs and diverts attention away from pain, reducing how it is perceived, and that the research stresses the importance of play elements in VR interventions aimed at pain.
Gamification adds structure to that distraction. She describes three layers: motivational affordances (feedback, points, badges, levels, scoreboards, goal setting and challenges), psychological outcomes (higher self-efficacy, less perceived pain and a better attitude to exercise), and the behavioural outcome of more participation, leading to a better quality of life. Her case for combining the two is holistic: "Mental and physical health go hand in hand, but they are very often dealt with separately within our healthcare systems." (5:56)
What the 18-week study found
Virtually Healthy tested 36 VR games already on the market with 20 participants, using heart rate monitoring, motion capture, Likert scale questionnaires and the Borg rate of perceived exertion (RPE) scale, which runs from 6 (no exertion) to 20 (maximal exertion). Attendance was recorded too.
Intensity depended on the game. One game produced very low intensity exercise, 14 low, 13 moderate, seven high and one very high, measured against maximum heart rate. The headline result came from converting RPE to heart rate: "So we compared perceived exertion to actual exertion, and we found that perceived exertion was actually lower than the actual exertion with a statistically significant result." (8:05)
Hoolahan links that to adherence. The program achieved 90% adherence and a 10% dropout rate, which she contrasts with the literature the team reviewed, where 67% adherence is considered successful for standard programs and dropout ranges from 25% to 80%. Questionnaires showed participants found the games exciting and fun, put in effort, wanted high scores and felt immersed. A few games that moved the player through a level caused motion sickness.
Beyond the heart rate: mind and movement
Some findings went beyond fitness. In menus, heart rate sometimes dropped below resting levels, which she reads as a sign that VR can have a relaxing, distracting effect. Two participants with limited upper limb movement noticed something unprompted: "We had two participants that had slight limitations to their upper limb movement, and without prompting, they noted how they felt that they could do things in VR that they couldn't do in real life." (11:10)
Twelve participants reported mental health benefits, including two diagnosed with depression. One described the weekly sessions as time just for themselves; another said: "And the other said, definitely, it has been a highlight of my week and has always lifted my mood when I was feeling low otherwise." (11:56)
What comes next, and the novelty question
Hoolahan describes the company's plans at the time of the talk: a journal paper under peer review, game reviews on its blog, a certification for games proven to benefit cardiovascular exercise or range of motion, general fitness programs entering beta, and later condition-specific programs, a headset loan system through gyms and physiotherapists, and partnerships with VR arcades, health professionals and game developers.
In the Q&A she addresses whether the low dropout was just novelty. Participants who had owned headsets for years also stayed, and she separates VR from earlier motion gaming such as the Wii and Kinect because of its immersion: "Definitely, there is a novelty and the wow factor when you first go into VR. But I don't think that really wears off and has an impact on participation and engagement with it." (18:25)
Watch the talk
Gamified virtual reality for physical and mental health, Katie Hoolahan, 19 minutes: https://www.womentech.net/video/gamified-virtual-reality-physical-and-mental-health
About the speaker
Katie Hoolahan is Managing Director and Research Manager at Virtually Healthy, which she founded after an MSc in Biomedical Engineering focused on how gamification through virtual reality can increase engagement in exercise and reduce pain for chronic pain patients. She also holds a BSc in Applied Sport and Exercise Science and works to bring gamified VR into health and fitness to improve quality of life.
Questions this talk answers
Why do so many people fail to exercise regularly?
How can virtual reality help people exercise?
What did Virtually Healthy's 18-week VR study find?
Did VR have mental health benefits for participants?
Is the high engagement just the novelty of VR?
Drafted with AI from the talk transcript. Editor review pending.
Frameworks and ideas mentioned
Gate theory of attention
Borg rate of perceived exertion (RPE) scale
Likert scale
Gamification motivational affordances model
Resources mentioned
Virtually Healthy blog (virtuallyhealthy.co.uk/blog)