Pretending to be fine in a crisis hurts leaders and the teams they lead
A four-year-old falls a couple of times in front of hundreds of people and gets right back up; adults, the speaker argues, learn shame instead, and it holds them back as leaders. Rachana Kumar, VP of Engineering at Etsy, admitted openly that losing childcare in the pandemic affected her work. For anyone leading or being led through disruption, she asks what actually keeps a team steady when there is no playbook.
Learn two practical tools, resiliency and communication, for leading any team through a crisis
Rachana Kumar, VP of Engineering at Etsy, shares two tools for leading teams through a crisis: resiliency and communication. She argues that vulnerability and productive perseverance build resilience, and that transparency with context, honest acknowledgement of what people face and more frequent check-ins keep teams steady when there is no playbook.
“As my slide says, managing is just trying to cope. Leading is being more proactive about taking people along the journey.”
“Vulnerability is the key to resiliency.”
What you will learn
Distinguish managing, which copes reactively, from leading, which proactively takes people along through a crisis.
Use vulnerability, such as being open about personal struggles, to build resilience and give your team permission to ask for flexibility.
Practice productive perseverance by staying goal oriented while narrowing focus to a few vital priorities when energy is limited.
Share decisions with transparency and context, explaining how they were reached, and say you don't know when you don't.
Increase check-ins, stand-ups and open office hours to acknowledge stress and keep the team aligned as conditions change.
Details
Level
All levels
Format
Talk
Technical depth
Non-technical
For
People manager, Mid-career, Executive
Length
18:02
Published
August 2020
Questions this talk answers
How is vulnerability the base for resilience?
Resilience means staying focused on your goal while showing the chinks in your armor and admitting that things are hard. Pretending everything is normal in a crisis does not help, while honesty makes leaders relatable and authentic.
What is productive perseverance?
It means staying focused and goal oriented while being open to switching gears. When energy is limited, focus on the few things you need to do rather than trying to do everything.
How should leaders share difficult news with their teams?
Share as much as possible with transparency and context, including the decision framework behind it, because information without context can hurt teams. When you don't know something, say so.
How can a leader stay connected to a team during a crisis?
Acknowledge that this is not business as usual, provide safe spaces to talk, and check in more often, for example through smaller stand-ups with managers and weekly open office hours anyone can book.
What is the difference between managing and leading in a crisis?
Managing is just trying to cope and react. Leading is being proactive about taking people along the journey together.
About this talk
This talk is for anyone in tech looking for strategies to help their teams through crisis.
At the core of a leader's role is the responsibility to ensure the well-being of their teams. Companies may be taken over, recessions may take place, and even pandemics may occur - all of which can lead to disruptions in your colleagues’ personal and professional lives.
In this session, I will share important tools to lead teams through significant organizational change, enabling them to stay afloat and make a positive impact amidst chaos.
Speaker 1: Very exciting. So as we pivot, hey, Rachana, how are you? Speaker 1: Good. Speaker 1: Awesome. You know, this has been a great event today, a lot of good energy. We're coming off leaving a little bit better than we were just from listening to Helen's talk. And now I get to, I'm so excited to introduce you because you're the president of engineering at Etsy, one of my personal favorites. I'm sure a lot of opportunity to innovate. And today you're going to talk about the intersection of technology and social impact and success of teams. So I am now going to hand it over to you if you want to share your screen and everyone just to get, get, get connected on social. You could click on the bubble by any
person and you can get to their social channels and let's just use that hashtag. Thank you. Speaker 1: Thanks, Nicole. Intersection of social impact, technology, leading teams to success are, those are the topics I'm interested in general. Today, given the timing, I'll be specifically focusing on leading through a crisis, leading through unprecedented time sliders. Today we'll be talking about leading through crisis. Nicole mentioned this in the intro. I'm VP of engineering at Etsy. I oversee one of the larger groups within product engineering at Etsy. I'm based out of New York City. I'm also a mom to a four-year-old. I have been in tech for a long time now. I have seen many changes start starting from the financial crisis in 2008, 2009 to when I joined Etsy. It was a startup
startup to get, taking the company through an IPO, then establishing ourself as a successful publicly traded company. But I don't think anything could have prepared our generation for what we are seeing now. The crisis that, the pandemic and the crisis that we are seeing currently, which is not just localized somewhere. It's a global crisis. And there is absolutely no playbook in terms of how we can lead, larger companies, bigger teams, or even smaller startups, or even small businesses, any of that.
There's no playbook how to lead during these times. So based on my observations in the past few months, three, four months, and also my experience working in tech for a couple of decades, I've tried to come up with some high-level tools and skills that, you know, if you're a people leader or even if you're being led that you can use. What I mean by if you're being led is either if you're aspiring leader or even for that matter, I hope like you can take away something after this presentation today to even share it with your manager or your team leader or something like that. So this is generic and not just like very specific to engineering teams or anything like that. It can be used anywhere in tech or even broader
industry. So at a high level, I'll talk about two tools that you can lead during that you can kind of cultivate or use during massive changes. Then I will, after that, open up our questions for about five minutes in the end. As my slide says, managing is just trying to cope. Leading is being more proactive about taking people along the journey.
This is one of my management philosophies. What I mean by that is if you're a really good manager, sometimes you might be just reactive and thinking through how do I get through this. I just don't want to manage myself and my group through things. I want to proactively lead. And when there's a crisis like this, collectively, all of us take this journey together. And I'll talk about what are the tools that I've cultivated, as I said, two important tools to hopefully do that better. Each specific skill tools that I'm going to mention will have two categories within that. I will explain them as we go through it. The first one is resiliency. The kids are amazing at being resilient. This is my son in the picture here. Well, we were in Chicago last year and he was trying to push the V in there.
He really thought he couldn't move it. He might have fallen off a couple of times, but he got himself right back up in front of hundreds of people and he absolutely didn't care what people were thinking. If he was falling, he was just going at it till he got a little exhausted or bored. But as we grow up, something happens.
Something happens. We don't want to fall in front of a hundred people. We don't want to be vulnerable. We are worried what people will think of us. This is called shame bias. I learned it from another person called Terran. And the shame bias is something we cultivate as we become an adult. And it's actually a hindrance to being a successful leader. Vulnerability is the key to resiliency. As Brian Brown said, what makes you vulnerable makes you beautiful. Traditionally, you know, resiliency was more associated with like strong men who could pretend to get through a crisis without showing any signs of vulnerability. I think it hurts the leader and the team they're leading more than it helps to pretend because being vulnerable also means you're like authentic and you're real, you're relatable. One of the things I've tried to do in
the past three, four months at Etsy in general, we try to keep it real. But one of the things I have even been very open and honest about is like the struggle of being a working parent when both parents are working and there is no family around or all the support system you had built, which was childcare, like in paid support system, when that doesn't exist anymore. I didn't want to pretend like, oh, my day job was not affected. It was very much affected. And it was in the beginning, it was a struggle till we figured out a schedule and sorted it out. And I think the more I talk about it and be honest about it, my team also then feels like, you know, we are doing, they can be efficient at
their work. But also, if they want a mental health break, or if they wanted to stick, have very flexible, flexible schedule for childcare, that we are making it out, they can talk about it. And, you know, hopefully, me and the larger leadership at Etsy are making it available. The flexible schedule available to them. This is the first thing, vulnerability. And the second thing related to resiliency is practicing productive perseverance. What I mean by productive perseverance, it's like it's really important to be focused and goals oriented, irrespective of what their time is. But you should also be opening to switching gears, especially when there is so much change around us. And already, we all have limited energy with all that's going on. One of the things, you know, Etsy did say in 2017, when we got
a new management, our CEO decided that we only needed to focus on a few vital things. We had to stop working on a lot of things that was like very dear to our heart. But it was clearly critical for the business. And as someone who's been through that cycle and seen how the business turned around and how successful it is today, even though at that minute, it was very challenging to make those decisions. I think it really served us well. When the energy is limited, and there's so much going on in this pandemic, you know, companies have had to lay off people. I have been fortunate at Etsy that our business is doing well so far. But not, you know, all the businesses are doing well, especially during
these times, it's very important to reflect on what is really important. And if needed, either switch gears. Even if you switch gears, just focus on the few things that you need to do and not try to do everything. So then we'll move to the second tool. This is very basic, right? Like communication is almost a good communication is almost a requirement for any job. Even more so, if you're a leader, you have to be really good at communicating. I think there are so many aspects to communication, I would like for us to focus on two aspects of communication that is very important during a crisis like this. The first one is transparency with context. I can, I'm going to talk a little bit more about what I mean by that is share as much information as a leader, or if you're being led,
ask, you know, if you feel like you don't know how decisions are being made, ask your leadership. Why? No, I feel I hope most companies have the culture where it's open and transparent. But just sharing information without context, I think sometimes can hurt teams more than it can help teams. So as a leader, if you're providing a new piece of information that might kind of be a change to how people are currently functioning, always try to provide context. I'm an engineer. So I think of like both quantitative and qualitative ways and how, what was the decision framework and how we arrived at this decision. It might not be the always positive, good news, even if you're sharing not good news, sharing it with like full transparency and context as much
transparency as possible. I think it's really helpful. And most importantly, when you don't know something, say you don't know that there is no point pretending like as a leader, I always know everything. So just as an example, recently, a couple of managers within my group were asking me, what will the future of remote work at Etsy look like? And they wanted to answer them.
But Etsy is already to be clear, has always been a very remote friendly workplace over 20% of our engineering is already remote. And so we have a culture of always accommodating remote employees. But I honestly don't know what the pandemic will look like over the course of next year or what the future of work, not just in America, across the world will look like. So I was like, if I could predict all those things, I think I would have a different job than what I currently do. And it's okay.
It's okay to sometimes say, I don't know. And the next thing is acknowledge the situation and check in regularly as a leader. This is another form of communication. If you are not already doing, it's super, super important during a big change or a crisis like this, you do this regularly. What I mean by acknowledge what's happening is there's also the pandemic, there's also a racial tension right now. And there are so many things happening depending on who's on your team.
I'm very lucky to have a pretty diverse team. And depending on who's on your team, the stress and mental load of different people on the team is so different depending on who they are, where they are from. First of all, just acknowledging that this is not business as usual. Let's not put a fake face and bringing our whole self to work, authentic self to work means acknowledging that things are not okay right now and talking about it and providing safe spaces for employees to talking about it. And I also try to regularly check in with everyone on my team. I have family across the globe. My parents live in India, my sister lives in Singapore.
If I'm checking in with them regularly, because I think it's as important for me to check in with my team. A few things we have done at Etsy, which I think has been helpful as our CEO and the executive team have been addressing the company in a more open and in their town hall kind of way, more often than they have ever done. And that's, I think, been super helpful. Second thing that I'm doing regularly is when I have a group of 15, 16 engineering managers within my group managers and directors, I used to meet them weekly or biweekly before, whereas now I have, I do like smaller check-ins and stand-ups so that as things change, situations change, we all collectively know how to address it,
how to react to it, and we are all prepared the same way. I've also increased my open office hours that literally anyone in my organization can, on a weekly basis, book one-on-one time with me and chat with me. First of all, when we are all short of time, it might feel like, oh, it's more work, more meeting, but as a leader, during a time of crisis, being a good people manager and being available for your people is so critical. Okay. I think this is at a high level of all the things I discussed.
One of the things I want to say before we do a quick recap of everything I discussed is, I have been through different crises as a leader. As I said, like, you know, the financial crash, business term around, but I also think if you, either if you're a leader or an aspiring leader, even though currently it's so stressful, you can learn so much if you think of this opportunity for change and as also a chance to learn. Real life experiences always trump case studies.
I feel like whenever there has been a big change, either at my company or something like this globally, or even the financial crisis in 2008, I have always looked at them and reflected on them as all the things I've learned from it and try to document some of the things. That's how I'm sharing this with you now. And I hope you all can also, even though it's hard on all of us, can look at it that way. A quick recap of what we, the two tools we discussed, is our resiliency and communication. Within resiliency is vulnerability and perseverance.
Practicing both of them and within communication, transparency with context and acknowledgement and check in with your team members regularly. With that, I'm going to open it up for questions. And thank you. Great. Thanks, Roshana. Please put your questions in the box and I can help you if you're sharing your screen to get those over. Lots of obvious connections happening. Hopefully you're connecting to Roshana. Yes, I will also paste my LinkedIn below once.
I can get that up. I can get that up for you, Roshana. No problem. So let's get some good questions in, ladies and gentlemen. What do we have here? Lots of introductions. This is the question portion. Hi, Gabriella. Any questions will be great. Roshana, thank you very much for this super insightful and inspiring talk. Sure. I'm wishing you the great, the rest of the great conference. And thanks a lot for joining us.
Thank you. I see some questions I can answer. Oh, absolutely. Absolutely. Let's take, let's take, because there are so many questions and people say, love hearing you, Roshana. How vulnerability is the base for resilience? I didn't understand that part someone is asking. Sure. I think, as I said, traditionally, we've always thought of resiliency as someone who is strong, who puts like a face of like, come on, whatever, whatever we won't. But I actually think of resilience, yes, really staying focused and getting to your goal. But along the way, showing chunks in your armor and saying like, I know this is not easy. It's challenging for me as well. Because vulnerability helps keep other people. If you're in a crisis, there is no point pretending like everything's perfect and normal. Whereas it's important to focus,
but also be your authentic self and show who you are and the challenges that come with it. And I think that makes leaders really relatable and authentic. Yeah. Right. I totally agree. And being vulnerable is a strength, even though it's very often perceived as weakness. But that's how we build this, this empathy and how we say, Hey, I understand what you're feeling. And that's how great leaders are born.
Thanks a lot. Thanks a lot. Thanks a lot, Roshana. And enjoy the rest of the conference. How people can get in touch with you? They have more questions. What is the best way to get in touch with you? LinkedIn? Twitter? LinkedIn. LinkedIn is the best way. I'm most active on LinkedIn. I will paste my LinkedIn there. Absolutely. And I will also respond to a few questions there. Yeah.
Bye-bye. Thank you. Thanks.
Transcribed automatically; names checked against the speaker record. Select a time to jump there.
Article based on this talk
Why vulnerability, not toughness, keeps teams steady in a crisis
Etsy engineering leader Rachana Kumar offers two tools, resiliency and communication, for leading people through disruption when no playbook exists.
In short
Rachana Kumar, VP of Engineering at Etsy, argues that leaders get teams through a crisis with two tools: resiliency and communication. Resiliency rests on vulnerability and productive perseverance; communication rests on transparency with context and on regularly acknowledging what people are going through. Pretending to be strong and all-knowing, she says, hurts teams more than it helps.
Key takeaways
Distinguish managing, which copes reactively, from leading, which proactively takes people along through a crisis.
Use vulnerability, such as being open about personal struggles, to build resilience and give your team permission to ask for flexibility.
Practice productive perseverance by staying goal oriented while narrowing focus to a few vital priorities when energy is limited.
Share decisions with transparency and context, explaining how they were reached, and say you don't know when you don't.
Increase check-ins, stand-ups and open office hours to acknowledge stress and keep the team aligned as conditions change.
Managing copes, leading takes people along
Kumar has been in tech for a long time. She lived through the 2008 financial crisis and joined Etsy when it was a startup, then helped take it through an IPO and into life as a public company. Even so, she says nothing prepared her generation for a global pandemic, and there is no playbook for leading through it, whether in a large company, a startup or a small business. From her observations over the first months of the crisis and her years in tech, she distilled two tools that work for people leaders, aspiring leaders and anyone being led.
Her starting point is a management philosophy that separates reacting from leading:
"As my slide says, managing is just trying to cope. Leading is being more proactive about taking people along the journey." (3:06)
In a crisis, she explains, the whole group takes the journey together, and the leader's job is to bring people along rather than simply get through it.
Resiliency starts with vulnerability
The first tool is resiliency, and Kumar illustrates it with her son. On a trip to Chicago he fell a couple of times in front of hundreds of people and got right back up, not caring what anyone thought. Adults, she says, lose that. They develop what she calls shame bias: a fear of falling, or being seen as vulnerable, in front of others.
She challenges the traditional picture of resilience as strong men pretending to get through a crisis without showing any weakness. Pretending, in her view, hurts both the leader and the team, while vulnerability makes a leader authentic, real and relatable. She practised this herself, speaking openly about the struggle of two working parents with no family nearby and no paid childcare during the pandemic.
"I didn't want to pretend like, oh, my day job was not affected." (5:48)
Because she talked about it honestly, her team felt able to ask for mental health breaks or flexible schedules for childcare, which she and Etsy's wider leadership tried to make available.
Productive perseverance: focus on the vital few
The second part of resiliency is what Kumar calls productive perseverance: staying focused and goal oriented while being open to switching gears when so much is changing and everyone's energy is limited. She draws on Etsy's experience in 2017, when new management decided the company should focus only on a few vital things and stop work on many projects people cared about. The decisions were hard at the time, but she has seen how the business turned around since.
"Even if you switch gears, just focus on the few things that you need to do and not try to do everything." (8:11)
With companies laying off people and many businesses struggling, she urges leaders to reflect on what really matters before spreading thin.
Communicate with context, and admit what you don't know
The second tool is communication, which Kumar calls a basic requirement of any job and even more of a leader's. In a crisis she highlights two aspects. The first is transparency with context. Leaders should share as much as they can, and people being led should ask how decisions are made. But information alone is not enough.
"But just sharing information without context, I think sometimes can hurt teams more than it can help teams." (9:05)
As an engineer, she likes to explain both the quantitative and qualitative reasoning, the decision framework and how a decision was reached, even when the news is not good. Equally important is honesty about the limits of what a leader knows. When managers asked her about the future of remote work at Etsy, she pointed out that the company was already remote friendly, but admitted she could not predict how the pandemic or the future of work would unfold.
"It's okay to sometimes say, I don't know." (10:50)
Acknowledge, check in and learn
The second aspect of communication is acknowledging the situation and checking in regularly. Kumar notes that the pandemic and racial tension weigh differently on different people, depending on who they are and where they are from, and she values having a diverse team.
"First of all, just acknowledging that this is not business as usual." (11:22)
She describes concrete changes: Etsy's CEO and executive team holding open, town hall style sessions more often than ever; her own shift from weekly or biweekly meetings with her 15 or 16 managers and directors to smaller check-ins and stand-ups; and expanded open office hours that anyone in her organization can book. More meetings can feel like more work, she admits, but being available to people is critical in a crisis.
She closes by encouraging leaders and aspiring leaders to treat even a stressful period as a chance to learn, as she has done with each crisis by reflecting and documenting what she learned.
"Real life experiences always trump case studies." (13:28)
In the Q&A, she returns to vulnerability: resilience means staying focused on the goal while showing the chinks in your armor, which is what makes leaders relatable and authentic.
Watch the talk
"Leading Through Success" by Rachana Kumar, 18 minutes: https://www.womentech.net/video/rachana-kumar-leading-through-success
About the speaker
Rachana Kumar is VP of Engineering at Etsy, driven by the intersection of technology, social impact and leading diverse product and engineering teams to success. Her experience spans media and ecommerce in the US, the sociopolitical space in India and international development in Cambodia, and she has shepherded engineering organizations through explosive growth and change.
Questions this talk answers
How is vulnerability the base for resilience?
What is productive perseverance?
How should leaders share difficult news with their teams?
How can a leader stay connected to a team during a crisis?
What is the difference between managing and leading in a crisis?
Drafted with AI from the talk transcript. Editor review pending.
Frameworks and ideas mentioned
Shame bias
Productive perseverance
Transparency with context
Cite this talk
Rachana Kumar. "Leading Through Success." WomenTech Network, 2020. https://www.womentech.net/video/rachana-kumar-leading-through-success