Fintech at the Frontier: Empowering Financially Excluded Communities with Blockchain
Sofie Blakstad18:192021
Women farmers' savings groups run on trust that no lender can see
Anna cannot read, has no bank account and lives in a village 10 kilometers from the nearest road, yet she cannot borrow $50 to buy better seeds. Her savings group runs on deep trust, recorded only in cash and on paper. Sofie Blakstad, who built banking systems in 60 countries before founding hiveonline, asks what it would take to turn that invisible trust into credit and export markets.
See how a blockchain stable coin gives excluded farmers a reputation lenders and buyers can use
Sofie Blakstad, CEO of hiveonline, explains why women farmers in rural Africa are shut out of formal credit and markets despite the strong trust inside their savings groups. She shows how blockchain and stable coins can act as alternative financial infrastructure, and how hiveonline turns everyday commitments into a digital reputation that lenders and buyers can use. She closes by arguing that diverse teams are essential to building technology for diverse customers.
“Blockchain has been called the internet of trust. It runs on machines in the network, so it doesn't need central infrastructure.”
“These women aren't just giving back to their communities. They're raising the next generation.”
What you will learn
Explain why collateral rules, cash-only records and missing identity documents keep women farmers out of formal credit.
Describe how blockchain works as alternative infrastructure where central systems, power and connectivity are unreliable.
Distinguish cryptocurrencies, stable coins and central bank digital currencies, including the risk foreign currency stable coins pose to local money.
Design financial tools for low literacy, low data use, dropped signals and one shared device per community.
Build teams with lived experience of your customers' environment and co-design features with users.
Key takeaways from the speaker
Blockchain is an enabling technology to build the distributed economy
Women entrepreneurs, given the opportunity, build sustainable communities and intergenerational opportunities
Rural Africa is full of largely untapped opportunities and new technology opens out these markets
The world needs Africa to keep producing food more efficiently
Diverse teams are essential to building technology for diverse customers
Details
Level
Intermediate
Format
Talk
Technical depth
Introductory technical
For
All career stages
Length
18:19
Published
June 2021
Questions this talk answers
Why can't women farmers in rural Africa access formal credit?
Lenders want collateral and credit history, women are much less likely to own land or other assets, and savings group transactions are in cash recorded on paper, so they build no credit history.
Why use blockchain instead of relying on mobile money alone?
Telco-issued mobile money is expensive to use and its centralized infrastructure can be unreliable and hard to reach, while blockchain runs on machines in the network and needs no central infrastructure.
How does hiveonline turn community trust into access to finance?
It records facts about what businesses agree, deliver and transact, such as crop forecasts, measures whether they meet commitments and builds a digital reputation that lenders can use for credit assessment. It uses a stable coin on the Stellar blockchain so it behaves like money while keeping wealth in the community.
How do you design a financial app for people without phones or literacy?
Hiveonline built for low literacy and very low data use on any device with a browser, tolerant of dropped signal, and operating on a minimum of one device per community so members without phones still get an account and digital history.
Why are diverse teams essential when building for excluded communities?
Team members who are ex-refugees or grew up in poverty understand customers' environments, and testing features with customers in agile sprints means many popular features come from customers' own ideas.
About this talk
Most women entrepreneurs in Africa don't have access to formal finance. Many don't have access to grid electricity and are left behind by the digital revolution. It's got even worse with COVID, restricting movements further. Strong social groups form to manage collective savings and collaborative agriculture, but it's hard for them to use this trust to reach markets or formal financing, leaving them vulnerable to middle men and extortionate local lenders. I discuss how technology has built access to finance for women entrepreneurs, and the challenges and economic implications. Then I discuss how technology like blockchain is helping to create market access for these groups and entrepreneurs, helping them to grow better crops and reach export markets without needing to be dependent on banks. I present data from our work in Mozambique, Nigeria and elsewhere on the impact this can have on people's lives.
Anna can't borrow $50, and why that matters (68 s)
Blockchain explained as the internet of trust (51 s)
Building with customers who have never used a phone (79 s)
Speaker: So thanks everyone for coming. I'm Sophie Blaksta, CEO of hiveonline. We're building better economies for pharma with blockchain and other advanced technology. I'm also a writer and researcher. And if you're interested to know more, you can see my book, Fintech revolution, universal inclusion in the new financial ecosystem, which is a manifesto for what we do. Today I'll be telling you about the challenges faced by African farmers, especially women, and how technology can help to build alternative infrastructure and lift them out of poverty. I'll be sharing some of the learnings from our experiences over the last few years, working in some of the world's least developed countries. And if you'd like to ask questions, please feel free to put them in the chat. And I'll leave some time at the end to pick them up. So I won't
be able to actually see the chat while I'm talking. So if you put the questions in, I will pick them up again. So I can tell you this is probably the hardest thing I've ever done, including childbirth. But imagine how much harder it is for Anna. She didn't go to school, so she can't read and has never had a bank account. It's hard for her to save in cash because her husband takes it from her as soon as it's in the house. She doesn't have grid electricity and her village is 10 kilometers from the nearest road. But for her, running a business is a matter of survival. She needs better seeds and treatments to grow her farm, but can't borrow $50 without credit history. Fernando runs a successful microfinance business, but Anna's invisible to him,
and transporting cash to the villages is expensive. ...the fastest growing small business market, and Fernando's desperate to reach them. You know, I grew up with so many advantages. I can read, I have healthcare, and I take technology for granted. But when I ran my first business, I couldn't build up my reputation fast enough, and I ended up losing everything: my business, my husband, and my home. To be honest, I'm not so sad about the husband.
Then I had a career building technology and businesses for global banks in 60 countries, including the first online bank for UBS. At Citigroup, I was responsible for 13 African countries, first for infrastructure, and then business transformation. Monkeys were stealing the cables. Public infrastructure was unreliable. So I had to develop alternative infrastructure strategies, like putting satellite receivers on the roofs of branches.
I saw firsthand how difficult it is for banks to reach businesses in rural Africa, and how financial products don't meet their needs. I saw how today's economy is stacked against entrepreneurs, and especially women like Anna. 450 million small and family businesses make up over half the world's economy. They can't build trust and don't get the opportunities that big companies get to credit and markets.
They can't grow and contribute to the economy. Most of them fail. And that problem just got worse. With COVID-19 has come a credit crunch in declining markets that restricts their options even further. It's a universal problem, but trust is an even bigger problem in the least developed countries in the world. In the World Bank's Human Development Index, most of the least developed countries are in Africa, and that's where we're working to build better economies.
Agricultural cash flow is bumpy. If you grow multiple crops, a farmer may have several harvests a year, but they don't have cash available when you need to buy seeds or treat the crops in the early growing season. The farmers we work with in Mozambique can't sell to the export markets because the quality of their crops is too poor, and they can't afford the treatments to improve the quality.
Mozambique used to export 25% of the world's cashews, and now it's less than 3% because trees are aging and unproductive. But it's also expensive to plant new ones, and the new saplings take 10 years to become productive. Farmers in Africa have huge problems accessing credit, especially if they're women. Many lenders want collateral, which farmers don't have, and women are much less likely to own land or any other assets.
They also suffer from inefficient markets. Farmers can't show buyers what crops they're growing, and buyers can't keep the production plants operating efficiently because they can't predict where crops will be available. Middlemen buy from farmers at low prices and take most of the upside. And in a broader economic context, many African countries have dysfunctional financial infrastructure. Especially in mineral-rich economies, oligarchy and corruption has stripped the wealth out of countries, leaving them with inadequate physical infrastructure, healthcare, and education systems.
Capital markets are shallow, and moving money around is difficult. Most people don't have any formal identity or property deeds. Many don't have basic information like a date of birth, especially in rural areas. But outside the cities, it's mostly left up to communities to figure out how to survive. Social groups like cooperatives and saving groups help small producers collaborate and save to build financial stability.
But all their transactions are in cash, so they don't build credit history. This is a savings group that Anna joined five years ago. The members, who are mostly women, put a small amount in a pot every week and can borrow from the pot to start businesses. It's made a huge difference to Anna's economic resilience, but all their transactions are in cash recorded on paper.
So they don't build credit history. And she can't borrow as much as she needs to really kickstart her farm. There are strong social bonds and trust in the groups, but they can't use it to access capital. Digital payments with telco issued mobile money can help to take away some of the risk of cash and provide records that they can start to build a digital history.
M-Pesa has made a huge impact on the number of people who can access financial services, especially in Kenya. But telco issued money is expensive to use and their centralized infrastructure can be unreliable and difficult to reach. When M-Pesa, which is best known, has definitely helped micro businesses, it's also had negative impacts where communities haven't been able to support these businesses because of a lack of market development.
Co-operatives can also help farmers aggregate their crops and reach better market prices, but there's a lot of corruption and no transparency, so many farmers don't trust cooperatives. And as I learned all those years ago when I was working for Citigroup, these communities are often isolated from access to centralized services by poor connectivity, low device ownership and limited access to power.
Power and connectivity are further compromised in areas where there's conflict or corrupt governments fail to maintain infrastructure. Conflict also leads to the financial industry moving out, so there's even less access to capital for farmers. And that's where technology can help. Mobile money was a great start, but it needs infrastructure. Blockchain has been called the internet of trust. It runs on machines in the network, so it doesn't need central infrastructure.
And it's designed so that people who don't know each other or anything about each other can transact assets like money or other things without having to trust each other or any central authority. It's an alternative infrastructure with no central authority validating transaction. The network validates it instead. So say Alice wants to give Bill some money. She broadcasts that to the network, which all agree it's a good transaction before that transaction gets approved.
It's locked into a block of transactions, which is cryptographically locked to other blocks, making a chain, hence blockchain. And that means that the transaction is visible to everyone who's got access to that blockchain. Now we've all heard of Bitcoin and Ethereum, but cryptocurrency is just the basic type of digital asset that can use a blockchain. Other types of assets include stable coins, which are pegged to a national currency.
Stable coins have been around for a while, although there were some early scandals because there were no regulatory filter to prevent customers being exposed. But that's been changing and stable coins are now broadly accepted as a safe regulated asset in many countries. Stable coins have the advantage of behaving just like normal money in most respects, but can provide cheap digital currency for people without access to a bank account.
Now there is DiEM, which was formerly called Libra, and that's a stable coin, which will be distributed by Facebook. And even Amazon is joining the party along with Visa, giving stable coins, especially US dollar backed, huge distribution potential. The US dollar stable coin could be particularly useful in countries where currencies are volatile, although they can put the local monetary system at risk if everyone were to start using stable coins in foreign currencies instead of the national currency.
Stable coin backed by a local currency within the national current commercial banking system. That holds much less risk because it doesn't impact the money supply. And many countries are issuing or considering issuing central bank digital currencies or CVDCs, which are a type of digital currency, usually on the blockchain, which is backed directly by the central bank. China is the first major economy to run a large scale pilot running to hundreds of thousands of people.
And many think its announcement of the E1 was partly in response to Facebook's announcement of the Libra project now called DiEM. DiEM spooked the vast distribution of Facebook. They had 2.7 billion active customers. Even though DiEM is actually governed by a consortium of organizations, it's not technically a Facebook owned product. However, the big payments platforms pulled out of the project and some are now going their own way with stable coins.
So Facebook is the de facto leader. As you can see from this map, several countries are already using CBDCs in a wholesale context. But retail CBDCs are following fast. And that's partly because the technology is still maturing to the level where it can handle massive transaction volumes, but is getting there fast. If we look at the overall landscape, China is significantly ahead of most other major economies, although Japan has just started a pilot.
Interestingly, some of the first movers were countries, which recognize the importance of universally accessible digital payments, although some early projects have failed. So at the moment, the only actual live cases are the Bahamas and the East Caribbean. Although the Marshall Islands did issue one, but that was shut down by the IMF. And Senegal also ran a pilot some years ago, but that was not successful either.
But there are several other countries. I mean, Kenya, for example, is now pondering issue in one too. And Sweden is in pilots. So there's a lot there's a lot going on in this space. So we've built a model that's using a stable coin and preparing for the availability of CBDCs. Hive online builds the bridge between formal financial institutions and informal entrepreneurs with a distributed community finance solution that digitizes trust.
Businesses build trust by delivering what they've agreed based on relationships made through the trust we've helped them build. Trust is built on facts about what they do as they agree, deliver, and transact. Crop forecasts so buyers can pre-book their produce. Our analytics measure when they meet these commitments and others. And we build a digital reputation to show how reliable they are based on what they do.
Structured loans incentivize sustainable behaviors. And we aggregate risks so communities can leverage collective muscle. We take commission from lenders who -- I see and credit assessment thanks to the scoring. Governments and NGOs get cheap, reliable voucher distribution. NGOs alone spend $4.2 billion on vouchers annually, and a lot of that goes to administration. Our blockchain-based solution ensures they go to the right people, taking out cost and corruption.
Commercial and governmental organizations pay for access to the data and analytics that form the core of our platform. It's built on the Stella blockchain, so communities can build wealth without being tied to a bank or a financial institution, but they can access formal finance. As I said, we use a stable coin, so to our customers, it looks and behaves just like money, but with a token structure that keeps wealth in the community.
We built for low literacy, very low data use on any device with a browser. It's extremely tolerant to dropped signal and poor connectivity. It operates on a minimum of one device per community. So Anna's friends can have an account and identity and a digital history without needing a phone. And women are much less likely to own or have access to phones, as well as lacking digital and functional literacy.
We've also designed so it doesn't need a consistent signal to operate, and we're working to constantly improve it so we work better offline as well. And although it's a financial app, it does need to connect from time to time. So Anna gets the agricultural input she needs to increase her crops and makes enough money to send her girls to school.
She can prove that her peanuts were treated with organic controls against toxins and her peanuts can get a premium price on lucrative export markets. One of her girls wants to be a doctor with increased investment in the community should be able to access the education she needs to develop a professional career. The statistics are astonishing by giving farmers access to better inputs.
Agricultural productivity can increase three times, giving much better revenue given 70% of arable land in Africa is unused. There's also the opportunity for expansion and more food production as farmers become more secure. We're all going to need Africa to produce more food in the future. And at the moment, it's responsible for only 3% of the world's food exports.
Africa today is a net importer of food, which is crazy when you consider how much land there is. So agriculture is a sector with a massive upside potential. And by keeping wealth in the communities, more jobs are created. So for the youth, they have options that look more attractive than going to the city or picking up a rifle.
Market efficiencies increase farmer income and help buyers to be more prosperous. While women and entrepreneurs give back to the community, each of these ladies at the heart of a family or her community. And in some countries, they're responsible for between 5 and 15 people each. They buy solar panels, plant trees and invest in irrigation, making their environments more sustainable.
Trust builds business relationships and Hive Online builds trust as we're proving in some of the least developed countries in the world. And the results are amazing. Background experiences are really key to what we do. As well as my experience in Africa and building global banking systems, I've written books on organisations, fintech and economics. I've built a strong, inclusive team with over a century of experience in finance, technology and research from commercial banking, the World Bank and NGOs and elite developers from Kigali's Carnegie Mellon University.
When I set up the development team for Africa, I recognise that it's important for all of us to understand the needs of the farmers and especially the women we support, which is why I decided to put the development team in Kigali in Rwanda. Both JP and Kasai are ex-refugees, so they understand the environments and challenges our customers face.
Latif, our product owner, grew up in poverty in Dar es Salaam in Tanzania, and his mother's still the treasurer of the savings group. While Simone's from Mozambique, and she's our Portuguese speaker, we have over 10 languages between us. We work in agile sprints, constantly testing new features with our customers and learning more about their needs. This has been really important when we're working, we have very little exposure to technology or digital systems.
And many of our most popular features are the result of their ideas. It's super important when working with customers who've never used technology to talk to them and learn what's meaningful from them. Some of these ladies have never used a phone before, and some are worried about touching devices. When I asked the group on the left what this symbol meant, they didn't understand it.
But when I asked what would be more meaningful, they couldn't tell me. They've never seen send. But they agreed that they would learn to understand whatever symbol we use, though, because they're so keen to engage and get the benefits of technology. We work with partners in the NGO, government, excuse me, and private system to help reach the ecosystem.
And these partners are really important to our customers, too. We combine our technology with the work they're doing already to improve farming ecosystems in both rural and urban settings. Each country is different with different challenges. And we're learning now with each new release. Our research is also an important component. I think it's fair to say without the research, we'd not be able to understand our customer needs and their opportunity nearly so well.
A byproduct of this is that there are a lot of organizations who are interested in what we're learning. So we support them with insights into how blockchain can help humanitarian causes and improve sustainability. It's a rapidly emerging field and the technology is evolving really fast. So practitioners like us are really well positioned to feed back to these groups when they're designing policy and regulation.
And if you're interested to read more, you can read our research for free on our website. Or I mentioned my book, Fintech Revolution, which is a manifesto for how the global financial system needs to change and how technology can enable it. So to summarize, there are some key takeaways which I find useful. Blockchain isn't enabling technology to build a distributed economy.
It's not something that's happening in the future. It's already here and being used by commercial banks, central banks and fintechs like us. Women entrepreneurs give the opportunity, build sustainable communities and intergenerational opportunities. These women aren't just giving back to their communities. They're raising the next generation. They are the community. And rural Africa is full of largely untapped opportunities and new technology opens out these markets.
The upside potential is huge and the world should be able to turn that FINDEX map of Africa mostly green with greater rural development. And the world needs Africa to keep producing food more efficiently. And space and opportunity is there. All that's needed is more opportunities. And lastly, diverse teams are essential to building technology for diverse customers. They're not a nice to have.
They're critical to understanding the needs of customers. Thanks.
Transcribed automatically; names checked against the speaker record. Select a time to jump there.
Article based on this talk
How blockchain can turn savings group trust into credit for African women farmers
Sofie Blakstad explains why women farmers stay invisible to lenders and how a digital reputation built on blockchain can change that.
In short
Sofie Blakstad argues that women farmers in rural Africa are not short of trust, only of a way to prove it. Drawing on nearly three decades building banking systems for global banks and on hiveonline's work in Mozambique, Nigeria and elsewhere, she shows how a blockchain stable coin, designed for low literacy and poor connectivity, can turn the trust inside savings groups into a digital reputation that lenders and buyers can see. Her closing point is that this only works when the team building it understands the people it serves.
Key takeaways
Blockchain is an enabling technology to build the distributed economy.
Women entrepreneurs, given the opportunity, build sustainable communities and intergenerational opportunities.
Rural Africa is full of largely untapped opportunities, and new technology opens up these markets.
The world needs Africa to keep producing food more efficiently.
Diverse teams are essential to building technology for diverse customers.
A farmer the banks cannot see
Blakstad opens with Anna, a farmer who never went to school, cannot read and has never had a bank account. Her husband takes cash as soon as it is in the house, she has no grid electricity and her village is 10 kilometers from the nearest road. She needs better seeds and treatments but cannot borrow $50 without a credit history. Meanwhile Fernando, who runs a microfinance business, wants to reach customers like her, but she is invisible to him and carrying cash to villages is expensive.
Blakstad connects this to her own experience of how reputation shapes opportunity: "But when I ran my first business, I couldn't build up my reputation fast enough, and I ended up losing everything: my business, my husband, and my home." (1:43)
She went on to build technology and businesses for global banks in 60 countries, including the first online bank for UBS, and was responsible for 13 African countries at Citigroup. There she learned how fragile central infrastructure can be: "Monkeys were stealing the cables. Public infrastructure was unreliable." (2:11) Her answer then was alternative infrastructure, such as satellite receivers on branch roofs.
Why trust stays trapped in cash
Blakstad lays out the barriers farmers face. Agricultural cash flow is bumpy, so money is not there when seeds and treatments must be bought. Lenders want collateral, and women are much less likely to own land or other assets. Middlemen buy at low prices and take most of the upside. As the speaker cited, Mozambique once exported 25% of the world's cashews and now exports less than 3%, because trees are aging and new saplings take 10 years to become productive.
Communities have built their own answers. Savings groups and cooperatives help small producers save and collaborate, and Anna's group has changed her life. But, Blakstad notes, "It's made a huge difference to Anna's economic resilience, but all their transactions are in cash recorded on paper." (5:15) Without records, the trust never becomes credit history. Mobile money such as M-Pesa helped many people, especially in Kenya, but she describes telco-issued money as expensive and dependent on centralized infrastructure that can be unreliable.
Blockchain as alternative infrastructure
This is where Blakstad sees blockchain fitting in. "Blockchain has been called the internet of trust. It runs on machines in the network, so it doesn't need central infrastructure." (6:44) She explains that the network, not a central authority, validates each transaction, which is then cryptographically locked into a chain of blocks.
She stresses that cryptocurrency is only one kind of digital asset. Stable coins, pegged to a national currency, behave like ordinary money and can provide cheap digital currency for people without bank accounts. She discusses Diem (formerly Libra), the growth of central bank digital currencies and the risk that widespread use of foreign currency stable coins could pose to local monetary systems, while a stable coin backed by a local currency carries much less risk.
Digitizing trust with hiveonline
Hiveonline, Blakstad explains, bridges formal financial institutions and informal entrepreneurs. Businesses build a digital reputation based on what they agree, deliver and transact, such as crop forecasts that let buyers pre-book produce. Structured loans incentivize sustainable behaviors, and risk is aggregated so communities can use their collective strength. The platform runs on the Stellar blockchain with a stable coin, so to customers it looks and behaves like money.
Design choices follow the realities of rural users: "We built for low literacy, very low data use on any device with a browser. It's extremely tolerant to dropped signal and poor connectivity." (12:19) It needs only one device per community, which matters because women are less likely to own or have access to phones.
The outcomes she describes are concrete. Anna can prove her peanuts were treated with organic controls and earn a premium on export markets, and she can send her girls to school. As the speaker cited, better inputs can triple agricultural productivity, 70% of arable land in Africa is unused, and Africa accounts for only 3% of world food exports. Women, she adds, reinvest in solar panels, trees and irrigation.
Diverse teams are not a nice to have
Blakstad placed hiveonline's development team in Kigali, Rwanda, so the people building the product would understand its users. Two developers are former refugees, the product owner grew up in poverty in Dar es Salaam and his mother is still treasurer of a savings group, and the team speaks over 10 languages. They test features with customers in agile sprints, and many popular features come from customers' ideas. "It's super important when working with customers who've never used technology to talk to them and learn what's meaningful from them." (15:43)
She ends with a firm conclusion: "And lastly, diverse teams are essential to building technology for diverse customers. They're not a nice to have." (17:49)
Watch the talk
Fintech at the Frontier: Empowering Financially Excluded Communities with Blockchain, by Sofie Blakstad, 18 minutes: https://www.womentech.net/video/sofie-blakstad-fintech-frontier-empowering-financially-excluded-communities-blockchainapply
About the speaker
Sofie Blakstad is CEO of hiveonline, which is building better economies for communities of financially excluded African entrepreneurs. She built global banking systems and businesses for eight major international banks in 60 countries over nearly 30 years, advises NGOs, central banks and the UN's Digital Finance Task Force, and co-wrote Fintech Revolution with Rob Allen.
Questions this talk answers
Why can't women farmers in rural Africa access formal credit?
Why use blockchain instead of relying on mobile money alone?
How does hiveonline turn community trust into access to finance?
How do you design a financial app for people without phones or literacy?
Why are diverse teams essential when building for excluded communities?
Drafted with AI from the talk transcript. Editor review pending.
Frameworks and ideas mentioned
Human Development Index
Global Findex
Agile sprints
Resources mentioned
Fintech Revolution: Universal Inclusion in the New Financial Ecosystem (book by Sofie Blakstad)
hiveonline research, free on the hiveonline website
Cite this talk
Sofie Blakstad. "Fintech at the Frontier: Empowering Financially Excluded Communities with Blockchain." WomenTech Network, 2021. https://www.womentech.net/video/sofie-blakstad-fintech-frontier-empowering-financially-excluded-communities-blockchainapply