Powering Up and Powering Down: How to think about Leadership Levers for women
Kelly Huang19:142021
Women leaders need a dimmer switch for power, not an on-off switch
Power up and you risk being seen as cold and competitive; power down and you can look aloof or unsure, the double bind that trips up many women stepping into leadership. Leadership coach and UCSD Extension educator Kelly Huang, drawing on Stanford professor Deborah Gruenfeld's power matrix, shows why the answer is not picking one side. So how do you dial authority, advocacy, demands and distance up or down without losing trust?
Learn four leadership levers plus concrete tactics for feedback, negotiation and new-manager trust
Leadership coach Kelly Huang argues that women leaders need to power down as skillfully as they power up, drawing on Stanford professor Deborah Gruenfeld's power matrix. She presents four leadership levers (authoritative yet participative, self-advocating yet serving, demanding yet caring, distant yet approachable) and practical tactics such as building trust before making demands and using situation-behavior-impact feedback to escape the double bind.
“So powering up and powering down shouldn't be this on and off switch.”
“And so this is where I really want us to think about powering up means owning our superpower.”
What you will learn
Recognize the double bind: how powering up or down is perceived depends on whether it serves you or others.
Use four leadership levers as dimmer switches to balance authority, advocacy, demands and distance.
Sequence a new leadership role by building trust and rapport before raising demands and accountability.
Negotiate beyond salary by packaging flexible work, coaching or resources into a win-win deal.
Deliver tough feedback with situation, behavior, impact: hard on the behavior, soft on the person.
Key takeaways from the speaker
You can "Power Up" successfully by negotiating not just for yourself, but for your team, your organization and your community.
You will need to know the dynamics of the 4 leadership paradoxes/levers in order to Power Up effectively.
The double bind gets in the way of female leaders gathering their power: choose to be nice or choose to be powerful and decisive.
WHY IS ALL OF THIS IMPORTANT? We need to elevate women everywhere – not just for our own selfish purposes, but to empower all those around us who do not have a voice.
Details
Level
All levels
Format
Talk
Technical depth
Non-technical
For
Mid-career, People manager
Length
19:14
Published
June 2021
Questions this talk answers
What does it mean for a leader to power down?
Powering down means dialing back displays of power to be more approachable, collaborative and to recharge. When it is done to share power, it is perceived as warm and trusting.
What is the double bind women leaders face?
Powering up for selfish purposes can make a woman look competitive and cold, while powering down can make her look aloof or unassured. Huang says many women run into this trap.
What are the four leadership levers?
Being authoritative yet participative, advocating for yourself yet serving others, being demanding yet caring, and maintaining distance yet being approachable. Each should be adjusted like a dimmer, not switched on or off.
How should a newly promoted manager balance being demanding and caring?
Go in order: project niceness and build trust and rapport first, then use that goodwill to introduce tougher demands. Acknowledge the hurt feelings of peers who were passed over.
How can you give tough feedback without attacking someone's character?
Use situation, behavior, impact: describe where it happened, the specific behavior, and its effect on the team. Be hard on the behavior and soft on the person's feelings.
About this talk
While there are many TedTalks and books advising women to "Power Up" or to "Lean In," but did you know that it is also important to "Power Down"? In my talk, "Powering Up and Powering Down: Dial Up and/or Dial Down with These Four Leadership Levers" I will cover the 4 leadership paradoxes/levers that allow female leaders to effectively Power Up as well as Power Down:
Lever 1: Authoritative yet participative
Lever 2: Advocating for themselves yet serving others
Lever 3: Demanding yet caring
Lever 4: Maintaining distance yet being approachable
Situation, behavior, impact feedback example (49 s)
Why women in power lift everyone (87 s)
Yeah, so basically this concept came from actually Professor Deborah Gruenfeldt, the powering up and powering down mechanism. And as you said in a TED Talks, I think inherently we understand what powering up looks like, but this powering down mechanism allows us to be more approachable and accessible. And that's what I'm going to talk to you today about those four levers that allow us to dial up our power or dial down our power. So starting with looking at this screen, there are three women in these various power poses, starting with some of you that are overseas, this is Wonder Woman, who's about to take on a super villain, I'm sure in her power pose. And in front of her is Professor Amy Cuddy, who's known for her power posing advice
for us to own our own confidence. And to also use this expansive body gesture for us to power up. And lastly, you have Christine Lagarde, who is the head of the European Central Bank, who's basically staring down a shorter man in front of her, who's probably cowering in her presence. So like I said, intuitively, most of us understand what powering up looks like. The powering down will be something we also need to do in order to recharge ourselves. And like I said, to be more collaborative and more approachable. So next, let me be the first one to tell you guys that even though there's many advice about faking it till you make it, I'll be the first person to tell you that you don't need to do that
because of this recent research that came out of Zenger-Folkman out of Harvard Business Review. And this is where you have the superpower to already take on those leadership roles because looking at each of these leadership traits, such as taking initiative, learning agility, being able to inspire and motivate others, women statistically score better than men. But even in those categories where maybe we're just dead even, such as technical expertise or innovation, I would argue that we're just as good, right? And so this is where I really want us to think about powering up means owning our superpower. So let's take a look at some specific advice about what to do about powering up. So here are the three ways that, again, the Stanford professor, Deborah Grunfeld, has advised for us to do. So I'm making use of Christine Lagarde
here again where she is, along with Angela Merkel, taking advantage of the spotlight on them, right, where Europe is in this depth of the COVID crisis and both of them have rose to the occasion to really take on the spotlight and to leave. And in addition to these two European women, you also see Jacinda Ardern, who is the New New Zealand Prime Minister, who's been effectively shutting down, well, who's been very effective in fighting the COVID crisis by shutting down New Zealand at the right time and taking those tough measures in order to take on the crisis. And then third, you see Christine Lagarde basically getting her elbow room, right? This is against Timothy Gartner on one hand. I'm not even sure who the gentleman is
in the wheelchair, but no doubt she owns her space and she is willing to fight for it. And so again, powering up is something we inherently understand, but let's take a look at those mechanisms that allow us to better own our power as well as empower others. So this additional dimension that Professor Grunfeld has laid out in this two-by-two matrix is to look at how we might actually consider when we're powering down for our own purposes, and that's on this left-hand side, and then also the right-hand side of the matrix is to empower others. And so when we are seen as powering up to help others, to empower our team, we're perceived positively as assured, we're able to exhibit that power, and we're also very sociable. However, if we are seen as powering up in a way that's greedy or doing it
for selfish purposes, we might come across as competitive and also cool or cold. And so this is the power-up mechanism that I wanted to consider, again, this additional dimension of how we might want to help the perception of we're powering up in order to help others. Now next, let's take a look at some of the resistant forces that we might come across if we have this negative perception against us, right? And so this is actually a character using those super hero characters. I'm using one from Disney Plus, and this is Wanda the Scarlet Witch. And so initially in the TV series, she's seen as a very likable character, a suburban mom who's a wife taking care of her family. But then, lo and behold, when she now has the superpower to take over an entire
town or maybe even destroy the world, she's then to be feared and vanquished. And so I think I want us to think about how has that affected you when you've tried to power up in the past? Was it always received in a positive light? Or have you encountered some of these negative resistant forces? And unfortunately, given the 20 minutes, I won't be able to capture all the comments, but I'm sure some of you have some good story to share about what has happened to you when you try to seize the power or own the power, but found some negative reactions. And so next, I want to talk about powering down, which is this lower half of the quadrant where Professor Grunfeld again is advising us to look at when we are powering down for the purpose of sharing power and being collaborative,
then we are again perceived positively as being warm and trusting and even deferential. However, when we're powering down such that people see us as doing it selfishly or maybe not assured, then we might be seen as aloof or maybe even inhibited. So what are we to do, right? When we power up, we get the resistant forces. When we power down, we could be seen as aloof and even unassured, right? So this is the double bind many women have come across. So let's take a look at what we can do. And so I have some advice when it comes to what I call these four levers, right? So basically, the lever one is having to be authoritative and still helping others participate. And the second lever is to advocate for ourselves
as well as advocate for others. And the third lever is to be demanding and hold people accountable, but still show that we care. And then the four lever is to maintain some professional distance, but still having to be approachable. And I want to tell people, you know, again, in terms of powering up and powering down, the analogy I would use, and this is the dimmer switch that you see here versus the on and off switch. So powering up and powering down shouldn't be this on and off switch. Powering up and powering down should look like these dimmer switches, which allow us to dial up the authoritative, but still allow people to participate, or dial down the demanding and allow us to show some caring, or maybe even maintain a little bit of distance, but still allow people to approach us.
So let's talk about specific tips on how you can do that and navigate the double bind. So first strategy that I have for you would be to be adaptable. Because in times, you do have to be tough, right? In a negotiation, or in a client setting, you want to show up as the authoritarian figure. But there are also times like happy hours, or at some company gathering, you'll want to have some niceness projected, but also you want to dress a bit more formally. Because the tough negotiation that I've seen from my coaches is that when they're everybody's best friend, it's hard then to become the demanding, holding people accountable manager, right? So you want to create a little bit of distance, and then adapt to the situation, whether that is, like I said, at a company outing, or in front of some
very important clients. And definitely, you should own your decision power, just like what we saw in the three power up suggestion to take the spotlight and own those tough decisions and create space for yourself by sitting at the table when a key decision needs to be made. And the next strategy I have for you is to look at different negotiation opportunities. So whether that's a negotiation for resources, or negotiating for your salary, you want to create opportunities where you can have everybody walk out as winners, right? So normally, you look at salary negotiation as just on the salary piece, or your wage. But in fact, you might be able to package, you know, the flexible work, or additional coaching you want to have. So think bigger picture as to what you want out of your work environment, besides just
the salary number. And then the other suggestion I have is also to acknowledge the hurt feelings. And I know this happens a lot in terms of promotions, where you might have been picked as the person promoted, but then some other peers of yours actually was in the comp was in the running, but did not get the job, right? So acknowledge the elephant in the room and let people know that yes, you know, you did get the promotion, and you're now the manager for the team. But you also know that somebody might have been disappointed, or some of your other team members thought that that person should have gotten the job. So you want to acknowledge those hurt feelings, so that you can create those win win strategies for people
moving ahead. And the next strategy I have for you is to perhaps go in order. So again, in terms of being demanding and yet caring, it might be worthwhile for all of us to to project that niceness and collaborative first, right? Especially when you're newly promoted in your role. Being nice and caring is going to build trust, right? Build those key relationships and rapport that you need in order to use it later on as the political goodwill to make those tough changes. So build the relationship, then follow on with the tougher demanding piece that you'll want the team to behave or some higher accountability you want them to follow. And again, people want to follow leaders that they trust, right? So make sure you have the trusting relationships built before you ask for really demanding
objectives and priorities that your team needs to achieve. And the next strategy I have for you is to think about how to basically say the tough message, but also frame it in a way that lets people know you still care. So Kim Malone Scott wrote this book about radical candor, which many of you I'm sure in the Silicon Valley may have heard of. So she, she is able to talk about radical candor as a way to help people improve, right? So people may not always want to hear the negative feedback, but they do want to hear feedback about how they can improve. So being able to reframe your tough message as a way to show radical candor is one way, but also to let people know you may not have all the answers, but you're very action oriented
and you're going to find out and get right back to them. Okay. And then the next strategy I have for you is this whole idea of what I call situation behavior impact. And maybe the key takeaway here is that you'll want to be tough on people's or your demands on the tasks, but what you want to be soft on are people's feelings as I said earlier, right? You don't want people to walk out as enemies at the end of a negotiation, but you want to walk out as friends, but you also want to frame your approach instead of saying, well, that's a stupid idea, but actually question the underlying assumption of something that was said. And then the third one is to make use of, like I said, the situation behavior impact, whereby
you can describe the situation where you saw some negative behavior pop up. So let's say somebody was talking over you or somebody was talking over another colleague. The way that I would do it as somebody trying to recommend a behavior change is to say, "Hey, I observed that you talked over Sally at our last meeting." And so that behavior affected all of us and that's the impact, right? That behavior affected all of us in that, number one, I couldn't hear what Sally had to say. And number two, the rest of the team kind of were so shocked that they weren't able to contribute either. And so we lost out on a productive brainstorming meeting because of that behavior that you exhibited. So be hard on the behavior, but
maybe go softer and not criticize the character flaw or what I call personality issues. And so you're tough on the situation, you're tough on the behavior, and then you'll describe the impact that that behavior has on the rest of the team and help the person understand that when they talked over somebody else or when they were shouting down another person in the meeting, that they had a really negative impact, right, on the rest of the team. Okay, so from there, I want to get to why we're all here, right? Why have a women's conference? And I have heard this from some of my business school colleagues too. Like, why can't the men have their own men's conference? Well, the difference is when women all get together and when we are in position of power, we actually help influence and
lift everybody around us. So let me give you the examples. So when women are in charge of families, we help our children have better education and we help the entire family get better health. When women participate in business, we improve the overall profitability. When women are active in our society, we see an overall increase of our GDP. And then when our congresswomen are effectively advocating for the rest of us, they actually get 10% more funding for their communities.
And the two examples I want to share here in particular are someone who is my own personal hero, Malala, who says it doesn't make sense to keep one half of the population be silent or even not educated, right? So she says that she raises her voice so that she can help those voiceless, uneducated girls that she knows get an education and get an advocate on their side, such as Malala. And then I myself am very active in the women in bios board and ready program. And so through the SB 826 law in California, we're able to increase the board seats up to 665 this year. And again, when we have these women at these key decision making positions, we're going to see a lot more fantastic medicine, like the vaccines we've
seen, and life-saving cure for cancer. So on that, I want to start wrapping up and let you know. So I know I only have 20 minutes, but I did summarize the tips into this tip sheet. So if you want to email me at [email protected], I'd be happy to send that to you and feel free to connect with me via LinkedIn. And at this point, can I take out any questions?
Hey, Kelly. Great job. Thank you so much. Hi. Hi. We do have like one more minute together or so. Yeah. You know, I know you're saying like you had to go through this really fast, right? And you've got these tips and you can share them. Is there any extra anecdote that you'd love to give us while we do have another minute, like a tip that you get stands out the most to you? Yeah. Well, I have to say the powering up, the power posing, now that I've been giving this talks a few times, when I do this, it really does calm me down. It's amazing. And I know Professor Amy Cuddy has said this very many times that you don't have to do it in front of your audience. Go to the bathroom,
do the widest X that you can do and then come out. And it really does. It opens up my chest. I breathe better. I feel a lot more confident. It really is. Like I said, it's the superwoman pose. Yeah, absolutely. I know. I feel energized just doing it with you right now. I mean, I know you're silly. We're in front of everybody. We don't, like you say, you don't have to do it that way. Yeah. You can do it kind of hidden behind the scenes and it's totally really, really well.
And then when you step out, you're feeling really good. And I think that's a difference often too, between men and women and how we stand naturally, right? Yeah. So kind of like this kind of stuff, when you're sitting down, arm over the chair, kind of feel right. It's less common for women, but those are all things that do make you innately more confident, right? Yes. Go for the X.
Go for it. Okay. Thanks so much, Kelly, for joining us today.
Transcribed automatically; names checked against the speaker record. Select a time to jump there.
Article based on this talk
Why women leaders need to power down as well as power up
Kelly Huang shares four leadership levers that help women escape the double bind between seeming too tough and too soft.
In short
Leadership coach Kelly Huang argues that strong women leaders need to know how to power down as well as power up. Building on Stanford professor Deborah Gruenfeld's work on power, she presents four leadership levers that work like dimmer switches rather than on-off switches, and pairs them with practical tactics for negotiation, trust-building and feedback that help women navigate the double bind.
Key takeaways
You can "power up" successfully by negotiating not just for yourself, but for your team, your organization and your community.
You need to know the dynamics of the four leadership paradoxes, or levers, in order to power up effectively.
The double bind gets in the way of female leaders gathering their power: choose to be nice, or choose to be powerful and decisive.
Why is all of this important? We need to elevate women everywhere, not just for our own selfish purposes, but to empower all those around us who do not have a voice.
Powering up starts with owning strengths women already have
Huang opens with three images of power posing: Wonder Woman, social psychologist Amy Cuddy, known for her advice on expansive body language, and Christine Lagarde, head of the European Central Bank. Most people, she says, intuitively understand what powering up looks like. What they understand less well is powering down, which lets leaders recharge and become more collaborative and approachable.
She also pushes back on the familiar advice to "fake it till you make it." As the speaker cited, research from Zenger Folkman published in Harvard Business Review found that women score better than men on leadership traits such as taking initiative, learning agility and inspiring and motivating others, and are level on others such as technical expertise and innovation. Her conclusion: "And so this is where I really want us to think about powering up means owning our superpower." (1:47)
Drawing on Gruenfeld's advice, she points to leaders who took the spotlight during the COVID crisis, including Lagarde, Angela Merkel and Jacinda Ardern, and to Lagarde visibly claiming her elbow room among male peers.
The power matrix and the double bind
Huang then walks through Gruenfeld's two-by-two matrix, which adds a second dimension: whether you use power for your own purposes or to empower others. Powering up to help a team is perceived as assured and sociable. Powering up in a way that looks greedy or selfish can come across as competitive and cold.
To illustrate the backlash, she uses Wanda, the Scarlet Witch from Disney+: likable as a suburban wife and mother, then feared and vanquished once her power grows. She invites viewers to reflect on whether their own attempts to claim power were always received positively.
Powering down carries its own risks. Done to share power, it reads as warm, trusting and even deferential. Done in a way that looks selfish or unassured, it reads as aloof or inhibited. "So this is the double bind many women have come across." (6:37)
Four levers, set like dimmer switches
Huang's answer is four leadership levers, each a paradox to balance:
Authoritative, yet helping others participate
Advocating for yourself, yet advocating for others
Demanding and holding people accountable, yet showing care
Maintaining professional distance, yet staying approachable
The key is how they are adjusted. "So powering up and powering down shouldn't be this on and off switch." (7:32) Instead, a leader can dial up authority while still inviting participation, or dial down demands to show care.
Tactics for navigating the double bind
Huang offers a set of practical strategies:
Be adaptable. Show up as the authoritative figure in negotiations or with important clients, and project more warmth at company gatherings, while keeping some distance. She notes that managers who are everybody's best friend struggle to hold people accountable later.
Own your decision power. Take the spotlight on tough decisions and sit at the table when key decisions are made.
Negotiate bigger. "So whether that's a negotiation for resources, or negotiating for your salary, you want to create opportunities where you can have everybody walk out as winners, right?" (9:29) A salary talk, for example, can include flexible work or coaching.
Acknowledge hurt feelings. After a promotion, name the elephant in the room if a peer was passed over.
Go in order. Especially when newly promoted, build trust and rapport first, then use that goodwill for tougher demands. "And again, people want to follow leaders that they trust, right?" (11:11)
Frame tough messages with care. She references Kim Malone Scott's book on radical candor: people may not want negative feedback, but they do want to know how to improve.
Her final tool is situation, behavior, impact. Using the example of a colleague who talks over someone in a meeting, she describes naming the situation, the behavior and its effect on the team, such as losing a productive brainstorm. The principle is to be tough on the task and the behavior while being soft on people's feelings and avoiding criticism of personality.
Why elevating women lifts everyone
Huang closes by answering a question she hears from business school colleagues: why hold a women's conference at all? Her case is that women in power lift those around them. As the speaker cited, women in charge of families improve their children's education and family health, women in business improve profitability, women active in society raise GDP, and congresswomen secure 10% more funding for their communities. "When women participate in business, we improve the overall profitability." (15:39)
She cites Malala as a personal hero who raises her voice for girls without one, and describes her own work in Executive Women in Bio's Boardroom Ready program, noting that California's SB 826 law helped increase board seats for women to 665 that year, as she reported. In the brief Q&A, she returns to the power pose, recommending doing it privately before speaking: "It opens up my chest. I breathe better." (18:15)
Watch the talk
"Powering Up and Powering Down: How to think about Leadership Levers for women" by Kelly Huang, 19 minutes: https://www.womentech.net/video/kelly-huang-powering-and-powering-down-how-think-about-leadership-levers-women
About the speaker
Kelly Huang is a Leadership Coach and Digital Marketing Adjunct at UCSD Extension, a marketing educator and community builder who began her career in sales at IBM before moving into international business development at Monsanto. She has developed curriculum for STEM professionals becoming leaders and entrepreneurs, and co-chairs Executive Women in Bio's Boardroom Ready program to increase board representation for female life science executives.
Questions this talk answers
What does it mean for a leader to power down?
What is the double bind women leaders face?
What are the four leadership levers?
How should a newly promoted manager balance being demanding and caring?
How can you give tough feedback without attacking someone's character?
Drafted with AI from the talk transcript. Editor review pending.
Frameworks and ideas mentioned
Powering up and powering down (Deborah Gruenfeld)
Gruenfeld's two-by-two power matrix
Four leadership levers
Double bind
Situation-Behavior-Impact (SBI)
Radical Candor
Power posing
Resources mentioned
Radical Candor by Kim Malone Scott
Kelly Huang's leadership tip sheet (available by email)
Cite this talk
Kelly Huang. "Powering Up and Powering Down: How to think about Leadership Levers for women." WomenTech Network, 2021. https://www.womentech.net/video/kelly-huang-powering-and-powering-down-how-think-about-leadership-levers-women