0:0019:14

Powering Up and Powering Down: How to think about Leadership Levers for women

Kelly Huang 19:14 2021

Women leaders need a dimmer switch for power, not an on-off switch

Power up and you risk being seen as cold and competitive; power down and you can look aloof or unsure, the double bind that trips up many women stepping into leadership. Leadership coach and UCSD Extension educator Kelly Huang, drawing on Stanford professor Deborah Gruenfeld's power matrix, shows why the answer is not picking one side. So how do you dial authority, advocacy, demands and distance up or down without losing trust?

Learn four leadership levers plus concrete tactics for feedback, negotiation and new-manager trust

Watch on YouTube

In short

Leadership coach Kelly Huang argues that women leaders need to power down as skillfully as they power up, drawing on Stanford professor Deborah Gruenfeld's power matrix. She presents four leadership levers (authoritative yet participative, self-advocating yet serving, demanding yet caring, distant yet approachable) and practical tactics such as building trust before making demands and using situation-behavior-impact feedback to escape the double bind.

“So powering up and powering down shouldn't be this on and off switch.”
“And so this is where I really want us to think about powering up means owning our superpower.”

What you will learn

  • Recognize the double bind: how powering up or down is perceived depends on whether it serves you or others.
  • Use four leadership levers as dimmer switches to balance authority, advocacy, demands and distance.
  • Sequence a new leadership role by building trust and rapport before raising demands and accountability.
  • Negotiate beyond salary by packaging flexible work, coaching or resources into a win-win deal.
  • Deliver tough feedback with situation, behavior, impact: hard on the behavior, soft on the person.

Key takeaways from the speaker

  • You can "Power Up" successfully by negotiating not just for yourself, but for your team, your organization and your community.
  • You will need to know the dynamics of the 4 leadership paradoxes/levers in order to Power Up effectively.
  • The double bind gets in the way of female leaders gathering their power: choose to be nice or choose to be powerful and decisive.
  • WHY IS ALL OF THIS IMPORTANT? We need to elevate women everywhere – not just for our own selfish purposes, but to empower all those around us who do not have a voice.

Details

Level
All levels
Format
Talk
Technical depth
Non-technical
For
Mid-career, People manager
Length
19:14
Published
June 2021

Questions this talk answers

What does it mean for a leader to power down?

Powering down means dialing back displays of power to be more approachable, collaborative and to recharge. When it is done to share power, it is perceived as warm and trusting.

What is the double bind women leaders face?

Powering up for selfish purposes can make a woman look competitive and cold, while powering down can make her look aloof or unassured. Huang says many women run into this trap.

What are the four leadership levers?

Being authoritative yet participative, advocating for yourself yet serving others, being demanding yet caring, and maintaining distance yet being approachable. Each should be adjusted like a dimmer, not switched on or off.

How should a newly promoted manager balance being demanding and caring?

Go in order: project niceness and build trust and rapport first, then use that goodwill to introduce tougher demands. Acknowledge the hurt feelings of peers who were passed over.

How can you give tough feedback without attacking someone's character?

Use situation, behavior, impact: describe where it happened, the specific behavior, and its effect on the team. Be hard on the behavior and soft on the person's feelings.

About this talk

While there are many TedTalks and books advising women to "Power Up" or to "Lean In," but did you know that it is also important to "Power Down"? In my talk, "Powering Up and Powering Down: Dial Up and/or Dial Down with These Four Leadership Levers" I will cover the 4 leadership paradoxes/levers that allow female leaders to effectively Power Up as well as Power Down:

Lever 1: Authoritative yet participative Lever 2: Advocating for themselves yet serving others Lever 3: Demanding yet caring  Lever 4: Maintaining distance yet being approachable

Topics

Related talks

Browse the library