In short
Yes, if you own it. Katie Schuele, co-founder and Chief Customer Officer of Boostr, tells the story of the day a conference line broadcast her muttered complaint to a room of senior colleagues, and how admitting it unlocked a stalled problem. From that moment she draws a simple leadership formula: address everything head on, make space for emotion, and take responsibility.
Key takeaways
- How honesty and emotion, once shunned as "female characteristics", can actually be good tools to improve collaboration in business.
- Practical methods to lead colleagues who might be older, more experienced and unwilling to be led.
- How to find shared objectives among groups with competing agendas by changing the nature of a bad conversation.
A young account executive in a room of older men
Schuele opens with a promise: "And I am going to tell you the exact moment I learned how to be a leader, like the actual formula." (0:00) She aims it at anyone who is questioning themselves, feeling scared or feeling like an imposter.
Twenty years earlier she was, in her words, ambitious and driven but deeply insecure. She held a degree in art history and primatology, had landed a big job at IBM as an account executive, and carried a large case of imposter syndrome. Her colleagues were engineers or founders whose companies IBM had acquired, and most were twice her age. "I was surrounded by almost entirely men." (1:08) Her job was to tell them what to do to grow revenue.
At one client, the situation was tangled. One IBM group wanted to sell software, another wanted to sell services that would remove the need for that software, and hardware already sold to the client had stopped working. The client refused to do anything until it was fixed. That triggered a "crit sit", a critical situation procedure with a daily 2:30 call for about eight people. The calls were full of competing agendas and made no progress, and Schuele dreaded every one.
The moment the whole call heard her
On roughly day ten, slumped in her chair and dialling in late, she muttered under her breath that she did not want to join the call, using a word she would not normally say to clients. The conference system, which played a recording of each caller's name, played her words instead. "And it was dead silent on the line." (3:56) As the only woman on the call, she could not pretend it was someone else.
She describes time slowing down while she considered her options: walking calmly out of the building and starting a new life, hanging up and never mentioning it, or pretending she had heard nothing. Every option meant paying a price later. So she spoke up, introduced herself and said she really hated the call. The problem was not fixed in five minutes, she admits, but breaking that block let the group find a solution. That painful moment, she says, taught her the lessons she still uses as a founder who runs product and customer success.
Principle one: address everything head on
"The first is address everything head on." (7:12) Schuele is clear that she does not mean being rude or blunt the way she was. She means assessing the situation, the problem, the objective and the constraints, then laying them out honestly and completely. "No tap dancing." (7:37)
She offers phrases that do this work: here are the problems we are solving, here is what we are up against, this is not working, a piece of the data does not fit the model, we have a dilemma. Looking back, she says she could have told the team which path she believed was best for the client, admitted she was hesitating because everyone had more experience, and asked what they thought. That one honest statement would have addressed every block without humiliating herself, a practical model for anyone leading older or more experienced colleagues.
Principle two: make space for emotion
This is the principle Schuele stresses most. "If you feel a certain way, you aren't alone." (8:20) She notes that imposter syndrome is widely documented and that most people wonder whether they belong, even while insisting that business is just business.
"And I think the assumption there is that emotions have to be bad, but they can also be good." (9:07) Passion and excitement shape outcomes as much as fear and frustration, so she treats emotions as an input to any project. Her practical advice is to ask everyone, at the daily stand-up or the weekly status meeting, how they are feeling about the project. It is not therapy; asking is a good enough start. Had she shared her frustration on day two, she believes the team would have discovered what they had in common: none of them wanted to be there. Instead she focused on everything she was not, from technical enough to older to a man, and missed that shared ground.
Principle three: take responsibility
The final principle is to own your mistakes and your results, good or bad, and to recognise that you probably own more than you think. On that account, Schuele was waiting for the experts to solve the problem even though it was her account and her problem. "I wasted so much time hiding from my responsibility." (11:09)
She closes with a promise of her own: apply these three principles in any situation and you will find common ground with the people you work with. "And I truly believe that if you can do that, you will emerge as a leader." (11:09)
Watch the talk
"Did I Say That Out Loud?: How My Foot in Mouth Stepped Into Common Ground" by Katie Schuele, about 12 minutes: https://www.womentech.net/video/did-i-say-out-loud-how-my-foot-in-mouth-stepped-common-ground
About the speaker
Katie Schuele is Co-Founder and Chief Customer Officer of Boostr, an enterprise ad sales CRM platform built for advertising and media sales teams, which she launched in 2016 after a career at IBM, Yahoo and Time Inc. She has built Boostr around an intense focus on customer success and currently runs both Customer Success and Product.
Questions this talk answers
- What did Katie Schuele do after her colleagues heard her curse on the call?
- What is her three-part formula for becoming a leader?
- How can a junior person lead colleagues who are older and more experienced?
- How do you make space for emotion at work without turning meetings into therapy?
- Why does taking responsibility matter so much?
Drafted with AI from the talk transcript. Editor review pending.