Building Resilience in a Changing Environment by Jennifer Bryan
16:042022
People don't resist change, they resist being changed
Two weeks before moving into a bright new office, staff learned they would have no assigned desks, and they complained for three years despite the cafes and collaboration zones. Jennifer Bryan, who has spent over 20 years leading change across nearly 40 organizations, argues that such failures come from managing tasks instead of people. So what does it take to bring people along before resistance sets in?
Get three factors for leading change people adopt, and a simple fix for technology phobia
Jennifer Bryan argues that organizations struggle with change because they focus on tasks, plans and training rather than on the people affected. Drawing on more than 20 years of change work, she offers three factors for building resilience: a ten-year vision, a holistic approach combined with an A/B change model, and designing for the person furthest from the decision-making room.
“And as a result, there's a lot of leaders that think people don't like change. But I would say it's that people don't like being changed.”
“And I use the word share very specifically, because change is not a one man band activity.”
What you will learn
Answer the "so what?" question for every person affected before asking them to adopt new tools or processes.
Build a change vision that looks ten years ahead and covers how staff and clients should think, feel and perceive the organization.
Assess political, economic, social and internal factors from both an inside-out and outside-in perspective before planning change.
Design the first moment of change for the person furthest from the decision-making room.
Give people with a fear or phobia of new technology gradual, low-pressure exposure before formal rollout.
Details
Level
All levels
Format
Talk
Technical depth
Non-technical
For
People manager, Executive
Length
16:04
Published
June 2022
Questions this talk answers
Why do employees resist organizational change?
According to Bryan, people don't dislike change itself; they dislike being changed without being brought along. When decisions are simply announced, resistance can last for years.
What are the three factors for building resilience during change?
A vision that looks ten years ahead, a holistic approach to change combined with the A/B change model for flexibility, and keeping the end person in mind.
What does keeping the "end person in mind" mean?
It means thinking about the person furthest from the project and the decision-making room and how they will first hear about and feel about the change. If that first moment is positive, everyone in between is likely to have a positive first moment too.
How can leaders help staff who are afraid of new technology?
Bryan placed new equipment with a dummy profile on desks in high-traffic areas so people could see, ask about and eventually try it over time. By the formal rollout the equipment no longer felt alien and adoption improved.
Why is a directive management style less effective today?
Directive leadership suited the industrial age, but in the digital information age, and especially after the pandemic, people have very different expectations about what, how and where they work.
The office move that caused three years of complaints (78 s)
Design change for the person furthest away (54 s)
A simple fix for technology phobia (84 s)
Speaker 1: Good afternoon, or good morning, or good evening, wherever you may be in the world, silence is loud. Have you guys ever asked someone a question and they've not answered you? Not because they haven't heard you or because they haven't seen the question. The response they are giving you speaks volumes when you are leading change. And if it's one thing I've learned working in over 20 years in the leading change space and helping nearly 40 different organizations is that change is about people, not rocket science. Now, that's a little bit of a double-edged sword. It's not to say that change is simple. It's just that sometimes we make it a bit more complicated than it needs to be. It's also not to say that
people are simple because we all know that A plus B does not necessarily equal C when it comes to people. Businesses tend to focus on the tasks, the project plans, the communication, training plans, the things that need to get done, rather than on actual leading the people and the impact it's going to have on people. I was working for an organization and I was brought in for a digital transformation program and to help them with that. And this program had, at that point, been operating for nine months. And I'm sitting in their strategy session and they're talking about the things of what went well, what didn't go so well, what they do, what they're going to do next year, that kind of thing. I said, you know, this all sounds great guys, but why should I care?
And they stopped and they looked at me and they said, well, because of efficiencies and effectiveness and blah, blah, blah, basically giving me what I would call the management spiel. And I said, that all, again, sounds great, but so what? And that's when the penny really dropped for them. They realized they hadn't communicated that so what to the person, what's going on for them, and hence why they should be adapting these new processes and tools and systems that they were actually putting in place. Now, back in the industrial age, it used to be that it was really imperative to use a more directive style of management and leadership, and it was actually expected.
But in today's digital informational age, expectations are enormously different, especially now post-pandemic. A load of people are looking at what do they want? How do they want it? Where do they want to work? How do they want to work? And that's hence the great resignation. And that's just the tip of the iceberg. There's a McKinsey report that states that back in 1958, there was the lifespan of a typical organization on the SNP was 60 years. Now, that's 12 years. It also states that in 2027, 75% of the organizations that are currently listed on the SNP will no longer exist. Now, that's a startling statistic in my book, because that means organizations need to adapt and change, or they're are going to die. So it can feel really quite bewildering to be leading change in this time of great uncertainty and
complexity. It can also feel really daunting to have to feel you've got to support and help people along the journey of change and have the confidence to lead them in that change. And as a result, there's a lot of leaders that think people don't like change. But I would say it's that people don't like being changed. Now, I was working for a different organization, and I was actually an employee of this organization. And we were in a grungy, dirty, very old, not very nice building.
And we were moving to this brand new, shiny, gorgeous building, new furnishings, loads of light everywhere, really, really lovely space. And as we're packing up our stuff, and putting in the boxes for the move, literally two weeks before we moved, we suddenly get the notification that we will not have a assigned desk in this new space. And not only that, there won't be enough desks for everybody in the team. Now, I can tell you, because people weren't brought along that change, we're just suddenly told this is what's going to happen, literally two weeks before we're going to actually make the change.
For three years, people were complaining. Even though we were in a beautiful new building, we had cafeterias, cafes, lots of collaboration, and informal meeting zones, all the gizmos that you would expect really in a modern office now. But because people weren't brought along, they continued to complain most of us have heard the analogy that change is a story or a journey.
The question I would pose is, what story do you want to share? And how do you want to travel? And I use the word share very specifically, because change is not a one man band activity. Also, how do you want to travel? Do you want to travel with everyone next to you and as you all go down the path together?
Or do you want to be about 20 yards ahead and using your energy to keep everybody moving along with you and trying to give them that impetus to keep along on the journey? There are three factors you need to take into consideration when it comes to delivering resilience and building that resilience and delivering the change and leading the change.
The first one is about vision. And it's not just about the here and now. I would argue that it's very important to really look at 10 years down the line. And when you're thinking of the vision, you need to think about what is it that we want and how do we want it? What do we want our clients to think about, feel about, perceive us as?
What do we want our staff to think, feel and perceive us as? How do they want to think about us as an organization? Secondly, it's about utilizing the holistic approach to change. That gives us an outside in and an inside out perspective on what it is that we are trying to achieve. Because we need to take into consideration the different political dynamics internally and externally.
We also need to look at the economic fluctuations, the different social norms that are going on. Do we have the right systems, processes, teams in place? All of these different elements. And what is it about those elements that may help or hinder us in the change? Because that will help us build out the change and understand the impacts that that will have on the people.
And with that, followed by the AB change model will give us the flexibility in our leadership styles to actually make it work during this level of uncertainty. And finally, it's about the in person, in mind. And what I mean by that, it's about thinking of the person who's the furthest away from the project and the decision making room.
What are they thinking? What are they feeling? How are they perceiving potentially the change when they first hear about, when they first think about it, when they first discover it, learn? It gets announced to them, they get told, it's in the gossip, whatever that may be. If you can make that moment for them positive, then there is a high probability that everybody in between will have a positive initial moment with that change.
And that helps you with the first hurdle of change. Now, all of these three different areas really gives leaders the flexibility to deal with the uncertainty and the complexity and which is indicative of today. And it allows us to not just focus on the actual plan of change, those things that need to get done, but it allows us to plan in a way in which we are able to thrive as an organization rather than just survive.
Well, when I was working for another organization, it was another digital transformation. It was quite a large organization. And long story short, they were doing several pilots and where people got completely new equipment and new software and all the gizmos that people really expect if they were to go into a technology store and get that today. And put it into their homes.
But what they discovered is that when they had those pilot sessions, a load of people actually were scared to turn the machine on, to touch the machine in its entirety. Now, they knew people had a fear of technology. There was a lot of that in the organization. But when we were observing that, and I was observing this in these pilot sessions and started to realize it's not just a fear of technology people had, but a phobia of technology.
And that's a completely different kettle of fish. So I had to think, okay, so what would that mean? What does that? What does that feel like? And then I thought, ah, I have a phobia. I won't go into all the nooks and crannies, but I have a phobia of rats. And so I started to think, all right, the client had this beautiful building.
It was about literally a block long. And where I worked with the team was down at one end and there was a meeting room and all the meeting rooms and the quiet rooms and the small meeting rooms all were glass walls and so forth. And I started to think, if there was a rat in that meeting room, there is no way I'd be in that building, much less down there working with the team.
And so I started to think, what would it take for me to finally get comfortable to go and sit in the area that I normally do within my client base? Long story short, a lot of time. And that's what I started to realize these individuals needed when it came to the technology phobia. They needed time to get used to the actual technology.
So I started to think, okay, how could we make that work? And I realized when I was working with the client that they have actually an IT help desk at all the offices. And even if they aren't, there isn't someone there every day of the week, because there's some that were really quite small satellite offices. There was at least some one there part time the week for two of the days or three of the days and so on and so forth.
And I thought, right, great. Could let's get the equipment, all the brand new equipment with a dummy system video, you know, profile set up onto it and have that at each of their desks. And if their desk isn't in a high traffic zone area, move them to a high traffic zone area. And so that way, when people were coming in and out and getting their cups of tea or whatever it may be, they would see the new equipment over there and they'd be like, oh, what is that?
I don't know, I'm going to just go this way. But eventually they might even say, hey, Joe, what's that thing on your desk? Oh, it's the new equipment. You want to see it? No, no, that's okay. That's all right. I'm just going to, just wanted to know. Thank you very much. Anyway, long story short, over time, they would start to get a little bit more curious, a little bit closer to the equipment, to the point they might want to start to try and test it, have a play with it, watch people do with it.
But by the time the equipment was then delivered for them and they had to start using this new device and learning how to use it properly in the actual pilot and release sessions, it was an alien to them. And as a result, they are able to take it on board and adopt the new ways of working, which was a real issue prior to that.
So, to recap, the three things you need to really take into consideration when it comes to building resilience and change is, first of all, having a vision. A vision that is very much in 10 years' time. Thinking about how do you want people to feel? How do you want people to think? How do you want people to perceive you?
Your staff? Your clients? Yourself? Your friends? What is it that you want? Then utilize the holistic approach to change that gives you that inside-out, outside-in perspective, followed by the A/B change model that then builds that flexibility into your plans and into your approach and delivery mechanisms for the change. And then finally, having that end-person, end-mind approach so you understand where are they coming from, what's going on for them, and what is happening for them.
Because after all, change is about people, not rocket science. So, thank you very much, guys. I really appreciate you coming along and listening. I'm going to take a look at some questions here. I have a dual screen going on. These are all my contacts, though. So, if you want to reach out to me after the event, or please feel free to do so.
No worries. Also, I'll be hanging around in the event, so you can come and meet me in the networking sessions or just send me a little message, no problems at all. So, thank you very much. Also, if you want to purchase my book, you can do so at all, depending on where you are in the world, at all of these different retail outlets online.
So, I'm just going to see if there's any questions. Thank you very much, guys. Really appreciate it. So, Ronnie, I see that you weren't able to hear, so I hope that got rectified. But it looks like others could. So, I hope that all got sorted. Any other questions? No, it doesn't look like it. Well, thank you very much, guys.
Really appreciate it. And I look forward to chatting with you sometime soon. Thank you very much. All right. Bye-bye.
Transcribed automatically; names checked against the speaker record. Select a time to jump there.
Article based on this talk
Why do people resist change, and how can leaders bring them along?
Jennifer Bryan argues that change fails when leaders manage tasks instead of people, and offers three factors for building resilience.
In short
Jennifer Bryan argues that most change efforts stumble not because change is hard but because organizations focus on project plans, communications and training rather than on the people living through the change. Drawing on more than 20 years in the change space and work with nearly 40 organizations, she offers three factors for building resilience: a long-range vision, a holistic approach to change, and designing for the person furthest from the decision-making room.
Key takeaways
Answer the "so what?" question for every person affected before asking them to adopt new tools or processes.
Build a change vision that looks ten years ahead and covers how staff and clients should think, feel and perceive the organization.
Assess political, economic, social and internal factors from both an inside-out and outside-in perspective before planning change.
Design the first moment of change for the person furthest from the decision-making room.
Give people with a fear or phobia of new technology gradual, low-pressure exposure before formal rollout.
Change is about people, not rocket science
Bryan opens with a provocation: silence is loud. When people do not respond to a change, that non-response tells leaders a great deal. Her core lesson from two decades of work is simple to state and harder to practise.
"Because after all, change is about people, not rocket science." (14:36)
She is careful to note that this does not make change simple. People are not predictable, and businesses tend to retreat into what they can control: tasks, plans and checklists. She illustrates this with a digital transformation program she joined nine months in. Sitting in a strategy session, she asked the team a blunt question.
"I said, you know, this all sounds great guys, but why should I care?" (1:00)
The team answered with efficiencies and effectiveness, what Bryan calls "the management spiel". Only when she pushed again with "so what?" did they realize they had never explained to staff what the change meant for them, and therefore why they should adopt the new processes, tools and systems.
Why the pressure to change keeps rising
Bryan contrasts the industrial age, when directive leadership was expected, with today's digital information age, where expectations about how and where people work have shifted sharply, especially after the pandemic. She points to the Great Resignation as one sign of this.
She also cites a McKinsey report, as she described it, stating that the lifespan of a typical company on the S&P was 60 years in 1958 and is now 12 years, and that by 2027, 75% of companies currently listed will no longer exist. Her conclusion: organizations must adapt and change or they will die. That leaves many leaders feeling daunted, and some decide that people simply dislike change. Bryan disagrees.
"And as a result, there's a lot of leaders that think people don't like change. But I would say it's that people don't like being changed." (3:50)
She tells the story of moving from a grungy old building into a bright new one with cafes and collaboration zones. Two weeks before the move, staff learned they would have no assigned desks, and there would not be enough desks for everyone. Because nobody had been brought along, people complained for three years despite the beautiful new space.
Change as a shared journey
Bryan reframes the familiar idea that change is a story or journey by asking what story leaders want to share and how they want to travel: side by side with everyone, or 20 yards ahead, spending energy dragging people along.
"And I use the word share very specifically, because change is not a one man band activity." (5:49)
Three factors for building resilience
Bryan sets out three factors leaders need to consider. The first is vision, looking about ten years ahead and asking what the organization wants clients and staff to think, feel and perceive. The second is a holistic approach to change that gives an outside-in and inside-out perspective: internal and external politics, economic fluctuations, social norms, and whether the right systems, processes and teams are in place. Combined with what she calls the A/B change model, this builds flexibility into leadership styles during uncertainty.
The third is keeping the end person in mind: the person furthest from the project and the decision-making room, and how they first hear about the change, whether by announcement or gossip.
"If you can make that moment for them positive, then there is a high probability that everybody in between will have a positive initial moment with that change." (8:19)
Together, she says, these factors let organizations thrive rather than just survive.
From technology phobia to adoption
Bryan's most practical story comes from a large digital transformation where pilot participants were afraid even to switch on new machines. Watching the sessions, she realized this was not just fear but a phobia of technology. Drawing on her own phobia of rats, she reasoned that what such people need most is time.
Her solution used the organization's existing IT help desks. New equipment with a dummy profile was placed on desks, moved into high-traffic areas if needed, so that people passing by on their way to make tea would see it, ask about it, and gradually grow curious enough to try it. By the time the formal pilot and release sessions arrived, the equipment no longer felt alien, and people were able to adopt the new ways of working, something that had been a real problem before.
Watch the talk
Building Resilience in a Changing Environment by Jennifer Bryan, 16 minutes: https://www.womentech.net/video/building-resilience-in-changing-environment-jennifer-bryan-0
About the speaker
Jennifer Bryan says in the talk that she has spent over 20 years working in the leading change space and has helped nearly 40 organizations. She is also the author of a book, which she mentions at the close of the session.
Questions this talk answers
Why do employees resist organizational change?
What are the three factors for building resilience during change?
What does keeping the "end person in mind" mean?
How can leaders help staff who are afraid of new technology?
Why is a directive management style less effective today?
Drafted with AI from the talk transcript. Editor review pending.
Frameworks and ideas mentioned
Holistic approach to change
A/B change model
End person in mind
Resources mentioned
The speaker's book (title not named in the transcript)
McKinsey report on company lifespans on the S&P
Cite this talk
WomenTech Network. "Building Resilience in a Changing Environment by Jennifer Bryan." WomenTech Network, 2022. https://www.womentech.net/video/building-resilience-in-changing-environment-jennifer-bryan-0