Why making silence harder than speaking up builds high-performing teams
When her students disengaged, the fix was never stricter authority but more engagement, and former elementary teacher Anna Gulstine, now an engineering manager and Professional Scrum Master at ed-tech company Otus, applies that lesson to software teams. Silence, unfinished work kept out of sight and waiting for permission all quietly slow a team down. Which foundation must come first before a team can truly manage itself?
Learn concrete habits for psychological safety, belonging, self-management and transparency
Anna Gulstine, an engineering manager at Otus and former elementary school teacher, argues that high-performing teams are built on purpose rather than by chance. She walks through four connected values (psychological safety, belonging, team self-management and transparency) and gives concrete practices leaders and teammates can use to support each one.
“We want to make it more difficult for people to remain silent than to share any concerns.”
“And the way to dissipate these issues wasn't to enforce stricter authority on them or to manage the students even more.”
What you will learn
Define psychological safety and recognise why it underpins belonging, accomplishment and fulfilment on a team
Promote psychological safety by welcoming bad news, modelling dumb questions and asking open, non-threatening questions continually
Build belonging by checking in personally and professionally, acting as an ally and making room for quieter voices in meetings
Enable team self-management by sharing the why behind goals and letting the team define its own processes
Strengthen transparency by making work visible at every stage and raising risks before they become problems
Key takeaways from the speaker
An understanding of what team self-management means and some of its benefits
How creating a sense of psychological safety promotes a high-performing team
The importance of transparency and how it builds trust amongst team members
Details
Level
Beginner
Format
Talk
Technical depth
Non-technical
For
People manager, Mid-career, Early career
Length
14:45
Published
June 2022
Questions this talk answers
What is psychological safety at work?
It is a shared belief that the team is safe for interpersonal risk taking, so people can share ideas, question things and try new approaches without fear of retaliation, judgment or harm to their career.
How can a leader promote psychological safety?
Appreciate bad news as well as good news, treat failure without learning as the only failure, model asking for help and admitting errors, and keep asking teammates open questions about their concerns.
What does team self-management mean?
As defined in the Scrum Guide, team members internally decide who does what, when and how, working together toward a common goal that everyone understands.
Why should teams care about belonging?
No business case should be required, but the speaker notes that people with a strong sense of belonging perform better, are less likely to leave and put more effort into team goals.
How can a team become more transparent?
Strengthen psychological safety, voice concerns before they become issues, make work visible at all stages rather than only when polished, and spend as much time with the team as possible.
About this talk
Throughout my transition from a classroom teacher to an engineering manager at an ed-tech company, I’ve discovered how many parallels can be drawn between qualities of an effective teacher and qualities of any effective leader. Even though I’m still on the path of lifelong learning, I’m excited about the opportunity to share some of the lessons I’ve learned along the way. These include some of the values and practices that support high performing teams.
What a classroom teaches about self-managing teams (47 s)
Show unfinished work and feel the room's temperature (65 s)
Speaker 1: Speaker is a former classroom teacher who made a career transition into tech in 2016. She's currently holding a role of an engineering manager at Otus, an ad tech company. And she is a professional scrum master passionate about building healthy, high-performing teams by supporting people over processes. She will take you on the 20-minute journey. Speaker 1: The journey where you will get an understanding of what team self-management means and some of its benefits, the importance of transparency and how it builds trust amongst team members and how created a sense of psychological safety promotes a high-performing team. Welcome on this stage, Anna. Welcome on this stage, Anna Gulstine, values to promote that build high-performing teams. Hi, Anna. Super excited to have you with us today.
Speaker 1: Good morning. Thank you again for having me. I'm excited to be here. Speaker 1: Absolutely. Our pleasure. Let's say hi in the chat to Anna. And you are ready to go. The stage is all yours. Speaker 1: Perfect. Yeah. So like Anna said, my name is Anna Gulstine. I'm an engineering manager at Otus, which is an educational technology company. Looking forward to talking a little bit more about Otus at the end of this presentation. I'm coming to you from Nashville, Tennessee.
Speaker 1: I made a career transition from teaching in elementary schools to software engineering in 2016. And I've since become extremely interested in learning how to promote high-performing teams, higher productivity, workplace fulfillment in teams. So thank you for joining this session and allowing me to share some of what I have learned with you. Now, high-performing teams don't form by chance. There are principles that we can understand that support the foundations of life.
Speaker 1: I'm going to share some of these teams. And my goal for the next 18 or so minutes is for everyone to just come away with one thing that maybe you learned or you're thinking about a little bit differently, or one thing that you want to apply right away in your work supporting your team. Speaker 1: So I'd like to talk about three areas. We have psychological safety and belonging. We have promoting team self-management and creating a culture of transparency. All of them build on top of each other. And let's just go right ahead and jump into the first one psychological safety and belonging.
Speaker 1: You've probably seen this before. Maslow's hierarchy of needs. Any textbook that talks about organizational behavior or psychology will probably present this. The idea that if your most basic needs aren't met, if you don't have food, water, warmth, rest, you won't be able to do anything else because you will be busy attempting to improve your circumstances. To get those needs met will be what motivates your behavior.
Speaker 1: So we have our basic physiological needs. And also in basic needs, we have our need for safety and psychological safety is included in this doesn't only refer to the physical safety of our bodies. It refers to feeling secure in our place in the various groups of people we are part of. Speaker 1: Psychological safety at work is just something we don't want to leave hanging and we want to pay special attention to it, especially because it's really foundational to Speaker 1: Sorry about that. I didn't navigate it. It's like it's foundational to some of these other needs. We have belonging, friendship, feeling accomplished and fulfillment.
Speaker 1: Psychological safety is defined as a shared belief that the team is safe for interpersonal risk taking. Speaker 1: In the workplace, psychologically looks like team members feeling safe to express their ideas, question things, try different approaches to solving problems and to take risks without fear of negative consequences like retaliation or judgment, harm done to their self image or harm done to their career.
Speaker 1: Some benefits of psychological safety, the organization will benefit from hearing a diversity of ideas being expressed. Team members will feel safer to experiment with new ideas to solve complex problems and employees will be more engaged. Speaker 1: Of course, there's many other benefits. These are just a few of them. Speaker 1: Ways that we can promote psychological safety. We can create a culture of being appreciative of bad news as well as good news. We can personally adopt this mindset of there's no failure except failure without learning.
Speaker 1: We can model asking for help. We can model asking dumb questions, which this has really helped me to try to sort of get over this hurdle of being afraid to do that. And now I just sort of unapologetically will do that and just kind of get over that hurdle of not wanting to ask stupid questions, admitting errors.
Speaker 1: We can proactively ask questions of team members or teammates. What's on your mind? What are you seeing? What concerns do you have? Open ended, non threatening questions. Speaker 1: And we don't want to just assume that teammates know that we're available to talk if they ever have a concern. Speaker 1: We want to make sure that we are asking these questions, not just one time, but continually. We want to make it more difficult for people to remain silent than to share any concerns.
Speaker 1: So psychological safety focuses on feeling safe to speak up and vocalize ideas without fear. And now I would like to talk about belonging. Speaker 1: So belonging is about feeling connected to others as well as accepted for who you are. Speaker 1: There's some words associated with a high sense of belonging. In addition to feeling safe to express ourselves in a group, humans need to feel included and accepted, feeling like we matter to the group and that we are supported and worthwhile.
Speaker 1: And then there's some words that are associated with a low sense of belonging. A person may feel isolated, they may be withdrawn, indifferent, disconnected. Speaker 1: There was a great session earlier today by Rachel Shield that talked about some of the impacts COVID has had on women, especially their sense of belonging. Speaker 1: So I would highly recommend going back and watching her talk if you haven't already.
Speaker 1: Just move on. Speaker 1: So why should we care about belonging? We shouldn't require there to be a business case for promoting a high level of belonging on our teams. Speaker 1: But there are many benefits that our teams and organization will experience if employees have a strong sense of belonging. Speaker 1: Team members show increased job performance and are less likely to leave their jobs.
Speaker 1: Employees are more likely to recommend their company to others, promoting their organization as a desirable place to work. Speaker 1: Team members are also more likely to give more effort to accomplishing team goals instead of only towards individual goals. Speaker 1: There's some links, some resources in my slides as well that I'm going to share my slides at the end of this presentation in the chat.
Speaker 1: So some ways that we can promote belonging. Speaker 1: Again, check in with team members on both a professional level and a personal level. Speaker 1: Going along with the word supported, being in that list, being associated with belonging. Speaker 1: We want to support team members and their daily work as well as their growth as humans and in their career.
Speaker 1: Be an ally, celebrate people being themselves. Speaker 1: This is something we really give a lot of attention to at Otis. Speaker 1: Team members should always feel like they have an ally in us and that we treat everyone fairly. Speaker 1: Notice if someone is having a difficult time getting a word in and a meeting and make sure to call on them.
Speaker 1: And then finally, we have grow as a leader. Speaker 1: Work to gather a diverse range of perspectives from lots of different kinds of people and use those perspectives to help us grow as leaders or as team members. Speaker 1: And just being open to talking about our experiences in that growth. Speaker 1: So I think we can really work to sort of build a bridge towards greater inclusion for everyone.
Speaker 1: So now we've talked about psychological safety and belonging and the final topic I would like to go over. Speaker 1: Actually, it's not the final topic. Speaker 1: The second topic I would like to go over the second to last is self-management of teams. Speaker 1: Agile development has popularized this idea of self-managing teams. Speaker 1: It's defined in the scrum guide as team members internally decide who does what, when and how.
Speaker 1: It looks like a group of people working together towards a common goal. Speaker 1: As a former teacher, I learned that when experiencing classroom management challenges, I first needed to ask myself why the students were not engaged. Speaker 1: And often this may have been because they didn't understand the purpose behind what they were learning or they didn't feel invested in the goals.
Speaker 1: And the way to dissipate these issues wasn't to enforce stricter authority on them or to manage the students even more. Speaker 1: It was to increase the students level of engagement. Speaker 1: So in the workplace, if we have clear goals that are shared and everyone understands what we're working towards, then everyone can be involved in deciding the how, how to get there.
Speaker 1: Continue talking about team self-management. Speaker 1: Some things that we can do to promote team self-management. Speaker 1: Facilitate conversations that ensure goals are understood by everyone. Speaker 1: Everyone underneath, everyone needs to understand the vision and the why behind the goals. Speaker 1: You can also have team members be part of defining the vision.
Speaker 1: We can allow team members to define their own processes and how they want to organize their work. Speaker 1: This can look like once a project kicks off, team members are collectively responsible for some management activities such as assigning daily work. Speaker 1: And the team will be able to continually improve in their ability to manage themselves and organize their own work if they're continually reflecting on how they're doing, learning from mistakes.
Speaker 1: So you can see why this is a big reason why psychological safety needs to be strong in order to have a team that is able to self-manage and reflect on how things are truly going. Speaker 1: Benefits of team self-management. Speaker 1: Team members are able to adapt quickly when needed. Speaker 1: They're not needing to wait for permission to be able to do something or wait for a manager to tell them how to do it.
Speaker 1: They're able to just adapt quickly based on their learnings. Speaker 1: Promoting self-management and employees has the effect of promoting engagements. Speaker 1: Self-management also promotes a culture of accountability. Speaker 1: I know that when I've been involved in making a decision, I feel more invested in the outcome of the decision, and I feel like I have assumed more control over how it goes.
Speaker 1: And also, you'll see team members be interested in the outcome of the work. Speaker 1: And a little less interested in sort of who gets credit, etc. Speaker 1: Okay. Speaker 1: I'm going to talk about creating a culture of transparency. Speaker 1: So this is the last topic that I would like to talk about is transparency.
Speaker 1: One definition of the word transparent is characterized by visibility or accessibility of information. Speaker 2: Everyone has the same facts. Speaker 1: If we're looking at something, if we're inspecting it, we want to make sure that we are inspecting the right thing, that we're inspecting the true state of something. Speaker 1: I'll continue talking about transparency.
Speaker 1: I'll continue to see some ways to promote. Speaker 1: So as we get ready to wrap up, we can promote transparency by promoting psychological safety. Speaker 1: If you have a low level of transparency, you might see team members keeping information sort of internal and not sharing opinions openly, maybe just with one other person who they do feel safe with.
Speaker 1: We should focus on creating an environment where making changes is valued and failing and learning is accepted. Speaker 1: Also, that concerns are voiced before things become an issue. Speaker 1: So going back to checking in with team members and just making sure that even the potential risk for an issue is identified. Speaker 1: Something doesn't need to be a really big problem before we can voice it.
Speaker 1: Also, making work visible is really important for transparency. Speaker 1: One sign that transparency could be better is if team members are afraid to show their work in its current state before they feel like it's finished and polished. Speaker 1: We don't want that. Speaker 1: We want work to be visible at all stages so that we can know how things are going and adapt if we need to.
Speaker 1: So that's something that we can support team members to that end and we can model that for them and encourage them to just make their work visible throughout all stages of a process. Speaker 1: And then finally, we have spend time with teammates, which sounds self-evident. Speaker 1: I always think of if people are in a room together, everyone is able to tell how hot or cold the room is.
Speaker 1: Everyone is able to feel the temperature of the room and because they are in the room together. Speaker 1: And so as a leader, as a teammate, if you want transparency, you will want to spend as much time in a room with your team as you can. Speaker 1: Just spend as much time with your team so that you have the same facts as everyone else.
Speaker 1: You know the temperature in the room just like everyone else. Speaker 1: Yeah, so I just wanted to say thank you again for joining this session. Speaker 1: I hope it's helped you to grow in your understanding of these principles. Speaker 1: And I would like to encourage you to think of one area that you would like to come away with one concrete way.
Speaker 1: You would like to promote one of these values in your team. Speaker 1: Keeping in mind that psychological safety and belonging are the foundations for everything else. Speaker 1: Thanks for everything else.
Transcribed automatically; names checked against the speaker record. Select a time to jump there.
Article based on this talk
What really makes a team high-performing? Safety, belonging, autonomy and transparency
A former classroom teacher turned engineering manager explains why great teams are built on purpose, and which foundation has to come first.
In short
High-performing teams don't form by chance, argues Anna Gulstine, an engineering manager at ed-tech company Otus. She shows how four connected values (psychological safety, belonging, team self-management and transparency) build on each other, with safety and belonging as the foundation for everything else. Drawing on her years as an elementary school teacher, she offers simple practices any leader or teammate can start using right away.
Key takeaways
An understanding of what team self-management means and some of its benefits
How creating a sense of psychological safety promotes a high-performing team
The importance of transparency and how it builds trust amongst team members
Psychological safety: a basic need, not a perk
Gulstine made a career transition from teaching in elementary schools to software engineering in 2016, and has since focused on what helps teams become productive and fulfilled. Her starting point is a familiar model: Maslow's hierarchy of needs. If basic needs are not met, people spend their energy trying to meet them. She places psychological safety among those basic needs, because it is about feeling secure in our place in the groups we belong to, not only about physical safety.
She uses a clear definition: "Psychological safety is defined as a shared belief that the team is safe for interpersonal risk taking." (3:50) In practice, that means people feel free to express ideas, question things and try new approaches without fear of retaliation, judgment or damage to their career. The benefits she lists include hearing a wider diversity of ideas, more willingness to experiment on complex problems and more engaged employees.
Her practical advice is concrete. Be appreciative of bad news as well as good news. Adopt the mindset that "there's no failure except failure without learning" (4:17). Model asking for help, admitting errors and asking so-called dumb questions, something she says helped her get over her own fear of looking foolish. Above all, do not assume people know you are available. Ask open, non-threatening questions such as "What's on your mind?" and keep asking them: "We want to make it more difficult for people to remain silent than to share any concerns." (5:18)
Belonging: feeling connected and accepted
Where psychological safety is about speaking up without fear, belonging is about feeling connected to others and accepted for who you are. Gulstine contrasts words linked to high belonging (included, accepted, supported, worthwhile) with those linked to low belonging (isolated, withdrawn, indifferent, disconnected).
She is clear that belonging should not need a justification: "We shouldn't require there to be a business case for promoting a high level of belonging on our teams." (6:46) Even so, she notes that team members with a strong sense of belonging show better job performance, are less likely to leave, are more likely to recommend their company and put more effort into team goals rather than only individual ones.
To build it, she recommends checking in with people on both a professional and a personal level, supporting their daily work as well as their growth, and acting as an ally who celebrates people being themselves. One small habit stands out: notice when someone is struggling to get a word in during a meeting, and call on them. Leaders can also seek out a diverse range of perspectives and talk openly about their own growth.
Team self-management: share the why, let the team decide the how
Agile development popularised self-managing teams, which the Scrum Guide describes as team members internally deciding who does what, when and how. Here Gulstine's classroom experience is especially useful. When students were disengaged, she learned to ask why, and the answer was often that they did not understand the purpose of their learning or felt no investment in the goals. "And the way to dissipate these issues wasn't to enforce stricter authority on them or to manage the students even more." (9:28)
The same applies at work. Facilitate conversations so everyone understands the vision and the reasons behind goals, and involve team members in defining that vision. Then let the team define its own processes, for example by collectively assigning daily work once a project starts. Continuous reflection and learning from mistakes help teams get better at managing themselves, which is why psychological safety must already be strong.
The benefits are speed, engagement and accountability. Teams adapt quickly because they do not wait for permission. Gulstine speaks from experience: "I know that when I've been involved in making a decision, I feel more invested in the outcome of the decision, and I feel like I have assumed more control over how it goes." (11:14) She also observes that people become more interested in outcomes and less interested in who gets credit.
Transparency: everyone has the same facts
The final value is transparency, which she defines as visibility or accessibility of information, so that a team inspects the true state of its work. Low transparency often shows up as people keeping opinions to themselves or sharing them only with one trusted colleague, which again points back to psychological safety.
She encourages teams to voice concerns early, even when they are only potential risks, and to make work visible throughout every stage rather than only when it feels finished and polished. "We want work to be visible at all stages so that we can know how things are going and adapt if we need to." (13:03)
Her last practice sounds obvious but carries a memorable image: people in the same room can all feel its temperature. "Just spend as much time with your team so that you have the same facts as everyone else." (13:49) She closes by inviting viewers to choose one concrete way to promote one of these values, remembering that safety and belonging come first.
Watch the talk
"High-Performing Teams: How to Support Them" by Anna Gulstine, about 15 minutes: https://www.womentech.net/video/high-performing-teams-how-support-them-anna-gulstine
About the speaker
Anna Gulstine is an Engineering Manager at Otus, LLC, an ed-tech company, and a former classroom teacher who made a career transition into tech in 2016. A Professional Scrum Master, she is passionate about building healthy, high-performing teams by supporting people over processes.
Questions this talk answers
What is psychological safety at work?
How can a leader promote psychological safety?
What does team self-management mean?
Why should teams care about belonging?
How can a team become more transparent?
Drafted with AI from the talk transcript. Editor review pending.
Frameworks and ideas mentioned
Maslow's hierarchy of needs
Psychological safety
Scrum
Agile
Self-managing teams
Resources mentioned
Scrum Guide
Earlier conference session by Rachel Shield on COVID's impact on women's sense of belonging (speaker name as transcribed)
Cite this talk
Anna Gulstine. "High-Performing Teams: How to Support Them." WomenTech Network, 2022. https://www.womentech.net/video/high-performing-teams-how-support-them-anna-gulstine