Even well-intentioned leaders don't automatically trust each other
Her first move with an inherited leadership team is a shock: no politics, no passive whispers, and any disagreement goes to the colleague first, then to her together. Suba Vasudevan, a Vice President in Meta's Global Operations, has built multiple global functions and seen diverse leadership groups fail and succeed. What turns capable people from different backgrounds into a team that genuinely trusts itself?
Get a simple trust-scoring framework and five first-team practices for diverse leaders
Suba Vasudevan, a Vice President at Meta, argues that diverse leadership teams do not build trust automatically, even when every member is capable and well-intentioned. She shares a simple framework for scoring trust, five practices drawn from Patrick Lencioni's first-team concept, and team exercises that help leaders move groups away from active distrust.
“Building trust is important. But moving away from active distrust is critical.”
“But even the best intentioned people don't automatically trust each other.”
What you will learn
Set explicit operating norms at a new leadership team's very first meeting.
Score trust in a group with a simple values, respect and openness framework.
Apply five practices: accountability, care, elevating diversity, transparency and role clarity.
Recognize when your own centrality blocks your leaders from building peer relationships.
Run team exercises on vulnerability, strengths and failure stories to deepen trust.
Key takeaways from the speaker
Build high performing leadership/senior/management teams
Details
Level
Intermediate
Format
Talk
Technical depth
Non-technical
For
People manager, Executive
Length
19:56
Published
June 2023
Questions this talk answers
How should a leader set the tone with a new leadership team?
State expectations at the first meeting: no politics, talk to a colleague directly first and escalate together, have each other's backs, and focus on the work rather than ownership edge cases.
How can a team measure trust among its members?
Share each leader's top three values and behaviors alongside always-on respect and openness, score them, and assign a trust level that serves as an anchor to revisit over time.
What is the first-team concept?
An idea articulated by Patrick Lencioni that true leaders prioritize supporting their fellow leaders over their direct reports.
Why do capable, diverse leaders struggle to trust one another?
Competitiveness, stylistic differences, unexpected situations and a lack of role clarity can all erode trust even among well-intentioned people.
What practical exercises help build trust in a team?
Ask people what makes them tick while the leader role models vulnerability, share and understand each other's strengths, and hold failure stories and postmortems.
About this talk
Bringing together diverse groups to form leadership teams can come at a high cost. Driving trust upfront requires intention, focus, and an appetite for failure. In this talk we will discuss a few examples, pitfalls and strategies for putting together high performing leadership/management/senior cross functional groups while addressing trust deficit challenges upfront.
Three rules for a brand new leadership team (73 s)
Trust is not a straight line (75 s)
When pop culture references leave you out (73 s)
Suba Vasudevan: All right. Hi, everybody. Thanks for joining me today. My name is Suba Vasudevan, and I'm a Vice President within Global Operations at Meta. Over the years, I've had the pleasure and honor of working on, as well as building out multiple global functions, and as a result, hiring and bringing together diverse leadership groups. But along the way, I've experienced and observed failures, as well as successes, which is what I'm working on.
I would love to share today. So today we'll talk a little bit about how to implement and build trust amongst diverse leadership groups. Let's start with an example. I once inherited a brand new leadership team. Some of them knew each other's, others didn't. Some had never connected with each other before, and yet others had told themselves stories about each other over time. Some great stories and some not so much. I knew all this because I had spent sufficient time one-on-one with them to understand this to understand this, and in some cases intuit this info. In our very first leadership offsite together, I decided to make some shocking statements. And I say the word shocking because I think it did surprise some people, but mainly it set the tone.
So I basically kicked it off. I basically kicked it off. I basically kicked it off, welcomed everyone and said, this is how this new leadership group, we are going to operate. We're going to have an in it together mindset. First point. And I use these words. I said, no politics. If you have an issue with someone, talk to them first about it. If you cannot see eye to eye, come to me together.
We're not going to have an in it together. We're not going to have passive whispers on the side. Be honest, be direct. Two, I expect you to up-level and really help each other. Have each other's backs. That's table stakes expectation. And three, focus on the work at hand, less on the edge cases of what we own, what we don't own, etc. Because that can just lead to inefficient use of time.
I'm telling you that surprised people because that's not what they expected in our first ever leadership coming together of the group, but it really helped me as a leader set the tone. Because after all, things like these can start with subconscious biases from unexpected places. For example, I once hired a former journalist. This person's entire career had been spent in journalism and not in big tech.
They came to me in week one and said, the team seems confused because I'm asking all these questions. The questions seem basic to me. Why is the team so confused? I dug in and realized it's not because they were asking questions. It's not because of the types of questions. We were a very helpful culture after all. In fact, it was about the taxonomy, the language being used.
So basically, I had them reframe their original request for help to say, help me ask the questions in a language that resonates. Over time, of course, we reached a middle ground of taxonomies, language, so we could learn from the amazing people that we were hiring and just didn't stick to our methods of doing things. But all of this took time, and this helped us to build trust.
This person went on to be one of our most successful people managers. But I realized me as the hiring manager alone couldn't help them. You can never help a newly hired leader on your own. And this applies to anyone you hire on the team. I quickly realized the team needed to understand the differences in backgrounds, the diversity of experiences people were bringing to the table, and so did partner departments or cross-functional functions, so to speak.
And I realized I needed to find this person mentors, a village, a village of allies. Another example is during the fall of 2020, I remember that year, I hired a phenomenal leader, tenured, coming from an industry that none of the rest of us were from, very different background, i.e. diversity. But they were completely remote, did not have the benefit of in-person interactions and culture building that everybody else had had as a baseline in my group.
So they felt like they were on shaky ground for a while. It's only when they spent time with each other, almost 18 months later, that they felt like they had real trust and connection because of that in-person meetup. By the way, I've also had the joy of working on cross-department leadership teams, where you come together on a cadence, set strategy, roadmaps, vision, mission, etc., towards a common business goal.
So this isn't just about your own leadership team or your immediate team. It could be about a cross-functional or cross-department team. So you really do need to think about this and apply these concepts that I'll share today across any group. I once had a leader in Asia-Pacific. They were adept at building relationships themselves. But often I felt like I was their go-to point for things, and I simply kept redirecting them to their peers.
That got me thinking about the concept of trust and how to build trust amongst the diverse individuals I had hired globally as well. So for many of you who've heard of the first team concept, it's a concept articulated by Patrick Lencioni way back when. I'm going to explain that a little bit later in my presentation, as I've used that as one of the tools in my toolkit to set expectations for my teams.
But first, let's examine two important aspects. Trust in the context of a workplace team and diversity in leadership teams. And then we'll talk about how we put all of that together. So when it comes to trust, several years ago, I was asked to build out the operating model for a cross-functional or cross-departmental group. A group of smart, well-intentioned, highly accountable leaders who did not know how to operate as a group coming together for the first time.
I know this reminded me of my fifth graders getting put on a new basketball team for the first time and really figuring out their position on the team or how to play with each other. It really felt like that. We were feeling each other out for a while and really trying. So I decided to have a little exercise.
Questions I asked them to work on together. This included me was, one, why are we coming together? It's shocking to ask a basic question like that because you'll realize everybody's notion of the why can be different. And that's important. I then asked the question, how much do we value each of us coming together as this group? Everybody said, oh, yeah, it's important.
Of course we want to come together. But then I said, why? What is our vision for each other? That stumped several people. It truly got us as a group thinking. Often at companies, we operate in a positional model or functional or matrix model. Give it any name you like. But if we don't come together as a core group of leaders who serve the same common purpose, goals, and business outcomes, with intention, we're not going to achieve the same speed and success.
Final question that I asked the group, how much trust does exist? Now, that was interesting. Let's talk about that in a second. One thing I'll say before I'm going to project something here is trust is not a straight line. It can take a long time to build. It's highly dependent on the humans as well as the circumstances involved.
Building trust is important. But moving away from active distrust is critical. And that can be a real challenge. What shocks me often as I talk to different leaders across companies is how few of them are trying, are trying to call these out when they see them around themselves, moving away from active distrust. As you think about that, I'm going to quickly project one thing here for everybody to look at.
All right. So what I'm projecting right now is a framework for evaluating and scoring trust levels. We've talked about, you know, you have frameworks for risk evaluation at companies and whatnot. This is literally for trust amongst people. So I have a very simple thing, a very simple framework that you can use and apply the way you like.
What are your top three values and behaviors? That's something leaders should share about themselves openly when bringing together any group and set these as expectations for their groups. And then, on the other hand, you have something that's always on, respect and openness. This is something everybody will immediately seek from a group that they are a part of.
How you use this framework is really simple and it's up to you. You use that table to fill in your top three, assign a score against it, use whatever rating level you like. That's the beauty of it. Once you finish scoring, assign levels of trust. I have a few, a little bit of taxonomy here. You can use that.
You can use something else. It's up to you. But the idea of assigning a taxonomy and having a score or having a common framework is to have an anchor, is to be able to come back to the anchor from time to time and be able to dig into how much trust does exist or does not exist. Trust, which is the only reason why I even recommend having something like a framework.
I've used this before. Frameworks like these leave open wide room for interpretation, but at least you can move on with low-hanging fruit and solving for those problems. By the way, this can go forwards or backwards, right? Trust can start to move forward in the right direction and then move backwards because of situations or people coming in and out.
The second important concept in all of this is diversity. Diversity matters. You all know this. We all know this. Especially in today's day and age. It matters in how we hire, who we hire, how we train, retain, invest, sponsor, et cetera. Sometimes you're handed a team of individuals and organizations to fix. Sometimes you hire intentionally. Either way is everyone has a unique viewpoint and different stylistic approaches.
Everyone brings diversity of thought and leadership to the table. The sum of our lived experiences, who we are as humans, our values and how we think equates us to the uniqueness we bring to any group or any setting. But even the best intentioned people don't automatically trust each other. It could be competitiveness. It could be a complete stylistic difference.
So people just don't resonate with each other. It could be that something situational was thrown at two people, otherwise completely well-intentioned. It's completely unexpected as well at times. But it's our jobs as leaders to recognize and elevate those differences in a way that it leads to truly beautiful music in the end. With that, I want to refer everyone to a book that really resonated with me called Say Yes to the Mess by Frank Barrett.
It focuses a lot on how leaders today need to improvise based on principles jazz musicians use. But one paragraph stood out to me from the book, and I'm going to read this out. It says, and I'm paraphrasing, jazz players don't innovate by isolating or breaking off from others. They don't wait for inspiration. And then the book goes on to say how they innovate by being tightly coupled to a diverse group of specialists, noticing the potential in people, ideas, etc.
That is powerful. Let that sink in for a second when you think about the diversity of any group. I'll repeat that. The book is called Say Yes to the Mess by Frank Barrett. It's a wonderful book. A lot can be said about listening intentionally, learning, building awareness, and then acting as allies in a diverse setting. A lot can also be said about our diversity journeys as individuals.
We're at various stages. It requires incredibly nuanced thinking and leadership, and most of all, deep, deep care and investment. So now that I've talked a little bit about the trust framework and a few different ideas around diversity, let's put all of this together to see how we bring together a successful, diverse leadership team, or any group for that matter.
As I said, first, let's understand where a leadership group is at. Functional, dysfunctional, somewhere along the way. But we also need to look at ourselves in the mirrors as leaders and acknowledge where we are at with investing and making any group way more functional. Don't get me wrong. This isn't about rah-rah, we're family. This is about work.
I get it. But it's also about humans, capable, competent individuals who are at a workplace and do need care. So we all need tools to drive success in such a setting. One thing I realized is, as I matured as a leader, one of the biggest things I did is I had to take myself out of the equation.
It could no longer be about me. It had to be about them, the leadership group that surrounded me or that I had hired that reported into me. It had to be about them for each other and for the rest of the organization. And no, this doesn't come out of some sense of false humility or fake back-end approach.
It actually is truly about building a culture of that team first for itself. It's that existing concept I referred to as first team earlier. We're going to come to it in a second. Look it up. First team, articulated by Patrick Lencioni, is the idea that true leaders prioritize supporting their fellow leaders over their direct reports. I know, shocking.
But there's a version of it that every company, every group can adopt or adapt for itself, so to speak. For me, there are five or six things here. One, accountability. You could be a unifier, a connector, a vision setter, but at the end of the day, you are accountable as a leader. It's your job. Role modeling. Role modeling high accountability drives that amongst the groups that you represent or work with.
Two is a no-brainer. Show care. As a manager, custom approaches to showing care are required. I'll give you a super simple example. When I first started working in the U.S., this is 20 plus years ago at this point, a lot of pop culture references from growing up here in the 70s and 80s fell flat for me. I felt excluded from social conversations with co-workers as a result because I just had not grown up here.
I had grown up in a different country with different pop culture references growing up. So what did that do to me? I'm an extrovert, or at least consider myself one. It eroded my confidence. I felt like I had to throw myself extra hard at work to prove myself to co-workers. That's just crazy, right? Eventually, as I matured, I realized I had to name it and call it out.
So I started telling people that a particular reference or a phrase just didn't land for me. Over time, I've started coaching those around me to be very careful with all of these little areas and aspects. Three, elevate the diversity of your team. Make a point about it. That's great. Celebrate it. But also elevate it. Backgrounds, introverts, extroverts, different perspectives.
It could be anything. Watch for when someone sucks up space or steamrolls over others. And be careful not to get that in your decision-making as well. Be very careful. I know it sounds basic. We move fast as leaders in our day-to-day and can forget these little things. Next, be transparent. You have to be a leader who communicates decisions transparently, does not back-channel them with person one or person two.
That's the fastest way to erode success in your group. I remember a relatively dysfunctional leadership team I was once a part of. Once that manager left and I took over the team, someone came to me and said, no pair-wise conversations, please. No back-channeling. That eroded trust for me. That was an aha moment for me. I didn't realize that that had caused so much grief for this individual who was my peer.
Finally, provide role clarity. I have found that often trust amongst the most well-intentioned and diverse groups is low because of lack of role clarity. People are running into each other, stepping on each other's toes. Sometimes it's our jobs as leaders to acknowledge that and create tools to prevent such misunderstandings. The second big part of what I want to talk about today is the first-team mindset and approach.
Go check out what Patrick Lencioni has to say. The whole concept may not be for everyone, but you have to be very clear. If you put yourself at the center of things, that group that you're trying to invest in and make functional is never going to really become functional. Think about it this way. If a peer of yours calls you with feedback from someone on your direct leadership team, what's your immediate instinct?
Are you going to protect the team member or listen to the peer? Do you like being at the center of things? Or are you able to take a step back and let your team build their own relationships? You could always have a cadence where if something needs to be escalated to you, it comes to you together and not on the side from one person.
There's a lot more that I can say about first-team, and I see a few questions coming in, so I want to acknowledge that. But I want to finish one or two other thoughts here. Building trust takes time and effort. It requires ongoing commitment from everyone on the team. And those benefits of a trusting and inclusive team are well worth the investment.
There are some tactical things you can do. Team exercises. Ask your team what makes you tick as a human. By the way, you need to role model vulnerability as a leader. Strengths understanding. Understand the strengths of your team. It's an aha moment for people to know, Oh, this person is high on a learner dimension and therefore asks a lot of questions.
They mean well. Finally, have failure stories and postmortems. The more you talk about your appetite for failure, the better. We have just a few seconds left. I'm going to conclude by saying this all matters a lot because you want to be that leader that invested in a legacy of scaling an organization and a group well. You cared deeply, coached others, elevated them.
There's a lot more that can be said here. I see questions coming in and apologize for not taking them because we're at time. Feel free to reach out to me on LinkedIn if you'd like me to answer your questions. Thank you very much to the Women in Tech Conference and everybody and anybody who's watching this webinar. Bye.
Thank you. We'll see you next time.
Transcribed automatically; names checked against the speaker record. Select a time to jump there.
Article based on this talk
Why diverse leadership teams don't trust each other by default, and how to fix it
Meta VP Suba Vasudevan explains how leaders can set expectations, measure trust and step out of the center so their teams rely on one another.
In short
Suba Vasudevan, a Vice President in Meta's Global Operations, argues that bringing capable, diverse people together does not create trust on its own. Leaders have to set expectations early, measure trust deliberately and take themselves out of the center so their leaders can rely on each other. She offers a simple trust-scoring framework, five practices inspired by Patrick Lencioni's first-team concept, and a handful of team exercises.
Key takeaways
Build high-performing leadership, senior and management teams.
Set the tone from the very first meeting
Vasudevan opens with a story about inheriting a brand new leadership team. Some members knew each other, some had never connected, and some had told themselves stories about each other over time. At their first offsite she made what she calls shocking statements, laying out how the group would operate with an "in it together" mindset. Her first rule was simple: "If you have an issue with someone, talk to them first about it. If you cannot see eye to eye, come to me together." (1:17) She also asked her leaders to have each other's backs and to spend less time on the edge cases of who owns what.
She then shows how trust can be undermined by subconscious biases from unexpected places. A former journalist she hired found the team confused by questions that seemed basic, and Vasudevan realized the problem was the language being used, not the questions. The lesson went beyond one hire: "You can never help a newly hired leader on your own." (3:19) The team, partner departments and a village of allies all had to understand the different backgrounds people brought. A remote leader hired in fall 2020 had a similar experience, feeling on shaky ground until an in-person meetup roughly 18 months later.
Trust is not a straight line
When she was asked to build an operating model for a cross-departmental group of smart, accountable leaders who had never worked together, Vasudevan ran an exercise around a few basic questions: why are we coming together, how much do we value this group, what is our vision for each other, and how much trust exists today. Asking "why" stumped several people, which was exactly the point.
She stresses that trust takes time and depends on people and circumstances. "Building trust is important. But moving away from active distrust is critical." (7:44) To make that work concrete, she shares a framework: leaders openly share their top three values and behaviors, alongside the always-on expectations of respect and openness. The group scores each one with any rating scale it likes, then assigns a level of trust. The value is less in precision than in having an anchor the team can return to, because trust can move forward and backward as situations and people change.
Diversity needs deliberate leadership
Diversity matters in how organizations hire, train, retain, invest and sponsor, Vasudevan says, and everyone brings a unique viewpoint shaped by their lived experiences. Yet she warns: "But even the best intentioned people don't automatically trust each other." (10:36) Competitiveness, stylistic differences or an unexpected situation can all get in the way, and it is the leader's job to recognize and elevate those differences.
She recommends the book Say Yes to the Mess by Frank Barrett, which draws leadership lessons from jazz improvisation. She highlights its point that jazz players innovate by being tightly coupled to a diverse group of specialists and noticing the potential in people and ideas.
Take yourself out of the equation
As she matured as a leader, Vasudevan realized the work could no longer center on her. "It could no longer be about me." (13:43) She connects this to Lencioni's first-team concept, the idea that true leaders prioritize supporting their fellow leaders over their direct reports, and outlines five practices:
Accountability: role model it, because high accountability spreads through the groups you lead.
Show care: tailor it to individuals. She recalls how, when she first worked in the U.S., unfamiliar pop culture references left her feeling excluded and eroded her confidence until she learned to name it.
Elevate diversity: celebrate different backgrounds and perspectives, and watch for anyone who steamrolls others.
Be transparent: communicate decisions openly and never back-channel them. A peer once told her that pair-wise conversations had eroded trust for them.
Provide role clarity: "I have found that often trust amongst the most well-intentioned and diverse groups is low because of lack of role clarity." (17:05)
Practising the first-team mindset
Vasudevan acknowledges the first-team concept may not suit everyone, but she is firm on one point: "If you put yourself at the center of things, that group that you're trying to invest in and make functional is never going to really become functional." (17:31) She invites leaders to ask how they react when a peer brings feedback about someone on their team, and whether they can step back and let their leaders build their own relationships, with escalations arriving together rather than from one person on the side.
She closes with tactical exercises: asking team members what makes them tick while the leader models vulnerability, understanding each other's strengths, and openly sharing failures. "The more you talk about your appetite for failure, the better." (19:01) The aim, she says, is to be the leader who invested in a legacy of scaling an organization well, cared deeply and elevated others.
Watch the talk
"Building trust among diverse leaders and groups" by Suba Vasudevan (20 minutes): https://www.womentech.net/video/building-trust-among-diverse-leaders-and-groups
About the speaker
Suba Vasudevan is a Vice President at Meta, where she leads analytics, tooling, operational and strategy functions within Global Operations, and previously led Facebook's Business Integrity and Platform Operations org. She has spent over two decades leading teams in strategy, operations, analytics, customer support and trust and safety, after earlier roles at KPMG's Advisory Services practice and as a journalist.
Questions this talk answers
How should a leader set the tone with a new leadership team?
How can a team measure trust among its members?
What is the first-team concept?
Why do capable, diverse leaders struggle to trust one another?
What practical exercises help build trust in a team?
Drafted with AI from the talk transcript. Editor review pending.
Frameworks and ideas mentioned
First team (Patrick Lencioni)
Trust scoring framework (values, behaviors, respect and openness)
Resources mentioned
Say Yes to the Mess by Frank Barrett
Patrick Lencioni's first team concept
Cite this talk
Suba Vasudevan. "Building trust among diverse leaders and groups." WomenTech Network, 2023. https://www.womentech.net/video/building-trust-among-diverse-leaders-and-groups